Date post: | 04-Dec-2023 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | independent |
View: | 0 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Mechanical inhomogeneity of myocardium studied in paralleland serial cardiac muscle duplexes: experiments and models
Olga Solovyova *, Leonid Katsnelson, Slava Guriev, Larissa Nikitina,Yury Protsenko, Sergei Routkevitch, Vladimir Markhasin
Department of Molecular and Cellular Biomechanics, Ekaterinburg Branch of the Institute of Ecology and
Genetics of Microorganisms, Ural Division of Russian Academy of Sciences, 620219 Ekaterinburg, Russia
Abstract
We investigate, both experimentally and theoretically, contribution of the myocardium mechanical inhomogeneity
to the contractile function. We developed three approaches, named as Muscle Duplex Methods, to study the specific
effects and mechanisms of interaction in the simplest myocardial system consisting of two muscular units connected
either in parallel or in series. Our experimental approach is designed to study the interaction between two isolated
mechanically inhomogeneous cardiac muscles. The virtual duplex approach is based on a mathematical model of the
myocardium contraction. The hybrid duplex approach has been designed to support, in real time, interaction between a
natural muscle and its virtual counterpart. Using these approaches we showed the existence of a fine alignment between
mechanical characteristics of interacting inhomogeneous myocardial elements. Contractile properties of the elements
together with particular sequences and time delays in their stimulation specifically determine this alignment. We term as
‘‘tuning effects’’ all the phenomena concerning the interaction between inhomogeneous system’s elements. Within the
framework of the mathematical model we showed that the key mechanism underlying tuning effects is a feedback
between mechanical conditions and cooperative Ca2þ binding by troponin C. Thanks to the model analysis, we also
hypothesize that mechanical inhomogeneity of myocardium is apt to produce its electrical inhomogeneity. � 2002
Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The term ‘mechanical inhomogeneity of myocardium’ (MIM) is used to address the differences between basic me-
chanical characteristics of adjacent or distant interacting contractile elements (CEs) in a cardiac muscle. These elements
may be small (e.g. separate sarcomeres) or large (strands of tissue), up to whole segments of the heart chambers. MIM
has been observed by many investigators. In particular, systolic and diastolic deformations of cardiac muscle are more
pronounced in sub-endocardium vs. sub-epicardium, as well as in the heart’s apex vs. its base [1]. Regional variations in
the left ventricular wall thickness and/or curvature [2], and of transmural pressure gradients [3] were found. It has been
shown that cardiomyocites in various regions within different heart chambers differ in their biochemical, metabolic,
electrophysiological and mechanical properties [1,4]. MIM is specifically prominent in pathological conditions like
myocardial ischaemia, which dramatically changes both the local and global kinetics of the ventricular walls [5]. MIM is
also widely expressed on the level of sarcomeres. For example, it was shown that sarcomere lengths differ in various
myocardial layers as a function of the ventricular volume [6]. Also, the onset and time courses of sarcomere activation
during a single beat vary in different layers of the ventricle [7]. Furthermore, MIM reveals itself on the molecular level
via variations in the ratio of myosin isoforms in cardiomyocytes lying in different myocardium layers [8,9]. Each
Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711www.elsevier.com/locate/chaos
*Corresponding author. Tel.: 7-3432-741316; fax: 7-3432-740070.
E-mail address: [email protected] (O. Solovyova).
0960-0779/02/$ - see front matter � 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S0960-0779 (01 )00175-8
particular ratio corresponds to specific mechanic and energetic properties of a cardiomyocyte [10]. Besides, this ratio
may change due to variations in load or as a result of hormonal effects [11].
While MIM is a firmly established phenomenon, the basic properties of the interaction between elements of inho-
mogeneous myocardial structure have not been studied in detail yet. The identification of these properties would widen
the paradigm of cardiac biomechanics [10,12] and help to understand the contribution of MIM to cardiac regulation in
both norm and pathology.
Owing to the extremely complicated character of MIM in the whole heart, it is beneficial to use specific, simplified
approaches for an experimental and theoretical study of this phenomenon. We assume that inhomogeneous system may
be represented on any level (from the cell to the whole organ) as a composition of groups of basic inhomogeneous sub-
systems, each of which may be represented by a duplex, i.e. by two elements connected either in parallel or in series.
When creating the duplex method, we hypothesized that mechanical interaction between contractile structures should
produce, by itself, some new specific effects. This hypothesis follows from two points: (1) evidence that partners of an
inhomogeneous duplex continuously produce specific changes in mechanical conditions for each other, and (2) the
existence of a feedback between mechanical conditions during muscle contraction and the process of thin filament Ca2þ
activation being reported by many authors [13].
We have developed three approaches based on the concept of a duplex of cardiac muscles. We have studied duplexes
of the following three different types:
• Muscle duplex composed of two natural heart muscles connected in parallel.
• Parallel and serial virtual duplexes composed of two virtual muscles, each of which is represented by a mathematical
model of homogeneous myocardium.
• Hybrid duplex composed of a natural and a virtual muscle, which interact in real time simulating contraction of a
duplex of natural muscles connected in parallel.
All these approaches complement each other but we pay special attention to the method of mathematical modelling
because based on this method we can explain the mechanisms underlying inhomogeneity phenomena.
2. Mathematical model of homogeneous myocardium contraction (virtual muscle)
2.1. Brief description
First of all we will demonstrate the simulation capability of a mathematical model of homogeneous myocardium
contraction embodying virtual elements in both virtual and hybrid duplexes in our studies.
The full list of the model equations is given in Appendix A. In part we published this model of homogeneous
myocardium elsewhere [14–17]. Here we reproduce a brief description of the main model postulates and specific features.
Mechanical block of the model. A classical three-element rheological scheme is used to represent the homogeneous
muscle (see Fig. 1(A) for the scheme). It consists of a CE (sarcomere), plus series and parallel elastic elements (SE and
PE). We consider tensions of the two latter elements as exponential functions of their deformations (see Eqs. (A.3) and
(A.4)).
We assume that force generated by the sarcomere is determined as follows:
FCEðtÞ ¼ k � f ðvðtÞÞ � NðtÞ; ð1Þ
where t is the time, k is a scaling factor, f ðvÞ is an explicit parametrical function describing dependence of the averageforce f of one cross-bridge (XB) on the velocity v of sarcomere shortening or lengthening and N is a number of force-
generating XBs in the overlap zone of thin and thick filaments.
The fraction N of force-generating XBs depends on the number Nact of active sites on thin filaments available forinteraction with XBs and on the probability n for XBs to be attached to the actin:
N ¼ Nact � n: ð2Þ
The probability n ¼ n1 � n2 is determined as a product of the probability n1 for an XB to find an active site on thethin filament and the conditional probability n2 to interact with the bound site. We consider that the probability n1depends on the lattice spacing and increases with sarcomere length (Eq. (A.12)). This consideration takes its stand on a
number of experimental data [18,19]. The probability n2 depends on the velocity of sarcomere shortening or lengtheningand it is determined by the velocity dependent kinetics of XBs attachment–detachment (Eq. (A.11)).
Thus, force generated by the sarcomere nonlinearly depends on the sarcomere length, velocity of sarcomere
shortening or lengthening and Ca2þ activation of thin filament.
1686 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
Cooperative mechanisms of Ca2þ activation. Kinetics of Ca2þ complexes with specific troponin C (TnC) is one of thecentral points regulating the process of Ca2þ activation of thin filament and CE force development during contraction/
relaxation. In particular, we guess and prove by means of the model that peculiarities of this kinetics are responsible for
the experimentally observed phenomena of myocardium inactivation [13,20–23].
In general, Ca2þ binding with TnC is described by the following scheme:
Ca2þ þ TnC $aonaoff ðNA ;AÞ
A;
where aon; aoff are the on/off rate constants of Ca–Tnc association/dissociation; A denotes the concentration of Ca–TnCcomplexes and NA is defined below.
We took into account three types of cooperativity being relevant to Ca–TnC kinetics. All of them have been founded
experimentally and reported elsewhere [24–29].
Type 1. Affinity of TnC for Ca2þ increases with the average number of strongly bound XBs around each Ca–TnC
complex (this number is denoted as NA). We consider the Ca–TnC off-rate to be decreasing with increase in NA
(Eqs. (A.21) and (A.32)). Because of the NA depends implicitly on the sarcomere length (Eqs. (A.6), (A.7) and (A.31)),
off-rate for Ca–TnC is length-dependent as well. The latter circumstance produces, in turn, the length dependence of
myocardium Ca2þ activation.
Type 2. Affinity of TnC for Ca2þ increases with the Ca–TnC concentration resulting from conformation of the
troponin–tropomyosin complex due to Ca2þ binding to TnC. Adjusting, we consider the Ca–TnC off-rate to be de-
creasing with increase in A (Eq. (A.21)).
Type 3. Fraction Nact of active sites on the thin filament in the overlap zone increases cooperatively with Ca–TnCconcentration as a result of an end-to-end interaction between adjacent tropomyosins:
Nact ¼Al
Al þ KlA
� Loz; ð3Þ
where Loz is the length of the overlap zone; KA is the concentration of Ca–TnC for the half-maximum fraction of active
sites and l is the coefficient of cooperativity.
Fig. 1. Schemes of the mechanical and Ca blocks of the model. (A) Rheological scheme. Shown are the contractile element (CE), series
(SE) and parallel (PE) elastic elements. l1; l2 are the CE and PE lengthening over the rest length Lr; muscle length L is proportional toLPE. FPE; FSE – PE and SE tensions (see also Eqs. (A.3) and (A.4));muscle force F is proportional to FSE þ FPE. L¼ const under isometricconditions; F ¼ const under isotonic conditions. (B) Ca2þ handling scheme. The scheme demonstrates Ca2þ recirculation in cardio-myocyte during a beat. CaC – free Ca
2þ concentration in cytosol; Fin is the trans-sarcolemmal Ca2þ influx; FSRrel – flux of Ca
2þ released
from terminal cisterns (TC) of the SR; A – concentration of calcium associated with specific TnC; B1 and B2 – concentrations ofcalcium bound to fast and slow buffer ligands as a total; FSRpump – flux of Ca
2þ-uptake by SR-pumps; Fout – total flow of Ca2þ removed
out of the cell; FSRflow is a flow of Ca2þ between longitudinal SR (LR) and the TC; C – concentration of Ca–calsequestrin complexes;
CaLR;CaTC – free Ca2þ concentration in the LR and in the TC.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1687
All these types of cooperativity were firmly established in particular biochemical experiments and were discussed in
detail in our previous works [15,16].
Ca2þ handling modelling. We used a typical scheme of Ca2þ handling (Fig. 1(B)) including a simplified description of
the Ca2þ exchange between cytosol and external space, Ca2þ binding by TnC and other cytosolic ligands. Cytosolic
Ca2þ buffering was described in the model as Ca2þ binding by a generalized Ca2þ-buffer [30]. Ca2þ exchange with
sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) includes: Ca2þ release from SR, Ca2þ pumping from cytosol to SR, Ca2þ flow between SR’
compartments and Ca2þ binding by calsequestrin within SR’s release compartment. All Ca-block equations of the
model are listed in Appendix A as (A.18)–(A.30). Particularly, we considered the mechanism of back-inhibition of the
SR-pump in our model (see right multiplier expð�kinh CaLRÞ in Eq. (A.28)) [16]. Owing to this mechanism velocity of SRCa2þ-pumping decreases with an increase in SR lumenal Ca2þ [31,32]. This effect may be important in the regulation of
muscle relaxation.
2.2. Simulation of myocardium mechanical behaviour by means of a homogeneous virtual muscle
Further on we demonstrate the main results of modelling obtained within the framework of the model presented
here. Some of them were earlier simulated by means of simpler versions of the model and were partially published
elsewhere [14–17].
Steady-state Ca2þ–force relationships at different lengths of a virtual muscle. We have adequately simulated Ca2þ–force relationships and the typical change in Ca2þ sensitivity with muscle length decrease.
First, we modelled pure isometric conditions for a virtual muscle implemented when considering an absolutely stiff
series elastic element (SE) (see Fig. 1(A) for the rheological scheme of a contractile unit). In this case there is no internal
sarcomere shortening, which means that sarcomere length is permanently equal to its initial length. When the muscle
length is fixed, force generated by the muscle at pure isometric conditions is determined only by the Ca2þ concentration.
Fig. 2. Model simulation of the effect of muscle length on Ca2þ–force relationships. Different pCa–force curves ðpCa ¼ � lgð½Ca2þÞÞcorrespond to three initial sarcomere lengths of 1.9, 2.0 and 2.2 lm (these lengths are indicated in the panels). Top: A virtual musclewith absolutely stiff SE (pure isometric conditions). Bottom: The same but with compliant SE (see Eqs. (A.3)). (A), (C) The unit of force
corresponds to the maximum force plateau obtained at an initial sarcomere length of 2.2 lm. Values of pCa1=2 of Ca2þ concentration
for half-maximum force are marked on the curves. The lower pCa1=2 values correspond to the higher Ca2þ concentrations and the
lower Ca2þ sensitivity of force response. (B), (D) Force is normalized by the maximum force corresponding to the given muscle length.
Hill coefficients of Ca2þ–force dependences are given in the panels (see Eq. (A.36)).
1688 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
The following changes in ‘pCa–force’ ðpCa ¼ � lgð½Ca2þÞÞ dependence due to muscle length decrease were observed innumerical experiments (Fig. 2(A)):
• decrease in the magnitude of the force plateau;
• decrease in pCa1=2 (pCa1=2 ¼ pCa for the half �maximum force). Corresponding pCa1=2 values are indicated on the
curves in Fig. 2(A);
• decrease in the slope of pCa–force curve where force is plotted in fractions of the maximum force plateau corre-
sponding to the largest muscle length.
At the same time we found out that the slope of the ‘pCa–normalized force’ curve, where force was normalized by the
maximum force corresponding to the given muscle length (Fig. 2(B)), did not depend on virtual muscle’s length. As a
result, Hill coefficients of ‘Ca2þ–force’ dependences (see Eqs. (A.35) and (A.36)), were also the same at different muscle
lengths (values of Hill coefficients are shown in Fig. 2(B)).
We also showed the influence of SE compliance on Ca2þ–force dependencies. Unlike the pure isometric conditions,
the compliance of SE resulted in a different internal sarcomere shortening depending on the Ca2þ level: the higher the
Ca2þ concentration the deeper the sarcomere shortening, and thus the more intense the inactivation of contractile
proteins. This inactivation revealed itself in the following effects (Fig. 2(C)): force plateau, pCa1=2, and the slope of pCa–
force curves decreased due to SE compliance. The main qualitative difference of the results obtained with accounting for
SE compliance as compared to pure isometric simulation is as follows. The Hill coefficient of Ca2þ–force relationship
increased with muscle length decrease (Fig. 2(D)). All the above results, the latter included, are in good concordance
with experimental data [33–35].
Isometric contraction–relaxation cycles. We have simulated the length dependence of isometric twitches and have
reproduced the following effects caused by a decrease in the muscle length (Fig. 3):
• peak force decrease (Figs. 3(A) and (C));
• insignificant decrease in time-to-peak force (TPF);
• essential decrease in relaxation time (T50) to 50% of peak force (TPF and T50 are marked on the curves in Figs. 3(B)and (D)).
These results of the numerical experiments are in good conformity with physiological data [15].
Fig. 3. Model simulation of the effect of muscle length on the isometric contraction–relaxation cycle. Time courses of isometric force
correspond to different initial sarcomere lengths which ranged from 1.9 up to 2.2 lm (boundary lengths are indicated in the panels).Top: A virtual muscle with absolutely stiff SE (pure isometric conditions). Bottom: The same but with compliant SE. In panels (A), (C)
force is normalized by the peak force obtained at muscle length Lmax when initial sarcomere length being equal to 2.2 lm. In panels (B),(D) force is normalized by the peak force corresponding to the given muscle length. Values of the time to peak force and relaxation
time to 50% of peak force at the shortest and the largest muscle lengths are marked on the corresponding curves.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1689
All the listed simulations proved to be qualitatively similar in both cases of pure isometric conditions for the virtual
muscle (Figs. 3(A) and (B)) and when SE compliance was taken into account (Figs. 3(C) and (D)). In the latter case time
to peak forces at all muscle lengths exceeded those observed during pure isometric conditions, but relaxation times
turned out to be much shorter. In other words, muscle’s capability for force generation decreased as a result of the
inactivation due to internal sarcomere shortening produced by the series element compliance.
Afterloaded contractions. Afterloaded muscle contractions at different constant afterloads are adequately simulated
in the model as well (Fig. 4). The modelling of sarcomere shortening–lengthening during afterloaded twitches
(Fig. 4(C)), in particular, two phases of sarcomere lengthening – fast and slow is also very similar to experimental data
obtained by laser diffraction [36]. Based on a set of afterloaded contractions we obtained the basic mechanical
Fig. 4. Afterloaded twitches of a virtual muscle. Shown are time courses of the below-listed model variables during afterloaded twitches
at constant afterloads (from 0 to 1 in step of 0.1 of the peak isometric force Fmax at muscle length Lmax). Thick lines are isometric twitchcurves. (A) Muscle force F is expressed in fractions of Fmax. (B) Muscle length is expressed in fractions of Lmax. (C) Sarcomere length.(D) Concentration of Ca–TnC complexes. (E) Concentration CaC of cytosolic Ca
2þ. (F) Upper traces represent the concentrations
CaLR of Ca2þ within longitudinal reticulum, lower traces represent the concentrations CaTC of Ca
2þ within terminal cisterns of the SR.
Time courses of all the variables depend essentially on the load applied. The lower the afterload the bigger the shortening and the
higher the shortening–lengthening velocity of both muscle and sarcomere and the lower the peak and the faster the decay of Ca–TnC.
Length dependent decrease in Ca–TnC leads to an increase in and prolongation of Ca2þ-transient corresponding to lower afterloads.
Increase in CaC is followed by an increase in peak CaLR as compared with that during isometric twitch.
1690 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
characteristics of active muscle such as length–force, force–velocity relationships, and load-dependent power and work
(Fig. 5). We also showed that a particular shape of all the above relationships, force–velocity included, depended on the
elastic properties of series and parallel elements (Fig. 5(B)).
We have simulated the principally important phenomenon of load dependence of relaxation (LDR) [4,15–17,23,37].
The essence of this phenomenon is as follows (see Fig. 6, left panels, for the model simulation):
• the lower the afterload the higher the velocity of muscle lengthening during the isotonic phase of relaxation
(Figs. 6(B) and (C));
• the lower the afterload the lesser the ratio T1=T2, where T1 indicates the duration of isotonic phase of the twitch underthe given afterload and T2 denotes the duration of such part of the isometric twitch where the force remains to behigher than this afterload (T1; T2 are shown schematically in Fig. 6(A)).We presume that the main factor underlying the load dependence of relaxation is the length-dependent inactivation
due to the length-dependent cooperativity of the first type (see the above item ‘cooperative mechanisms of Ca2þ ac-
tivation’). Within the framework of our model we obtained a faster Ca–TnC decay due to deeper sarcomere shortening
during afterloaded twitch (Fig. 4(D)). Feedback influence of mechanical conditions of contraction–relaxation on the
time course of Ca–TnC kinetics resulted, in turn, in a load-dependent difference between Ca2þ-transients during the
isometric cycle and lower-loaded twitches (Fig. 4(E)). The last result is also in good concordance with experiments [38].
By the way, this essential distinction in Ca2þ-transients led to a difference in the time courses of both free Ca2þ within
SR compartments (Fig. 4(F)), and calcium bound with cytosolic Ca2þ-buffers and with calsequestrin.
Fig. 5. Basic mechanical characteristics of active muscle. All dependencies presented are obtained using a set of afterloaded contrac-
tions at constant afterloads (from 0 to 1 in step of 0.1 of the peak isometric force Fmax at muscle length Lmax). (A) Length (right scale)–force curve is a plot of end-systolic muscle length L normalized by Lmax vs. normalized afterload value F =Fmax;Work (left scale)–forcecurve represents the relationship between load and muscle work calculated as the product of end-systolic force on end-systolic
shortening and normalized by the maximum value; Power (left scale)–force curve represents dependence between load and muscle
power calculated as the product of end-systolic force on maximum velocity of afterloaded shortening and normalized by the maximum
value. (B) Force–velocity curve represents the maximum velocity of afterloaded shortening plotted vs. the afterload value. Influence of
stiffness of series (SE) and parallel (PE) elastic elements on F–V dependence is shown. Control curve corresponds to the model with the
basic set of parameters (see table in Appendix A), and other curves were obtained at changed parameters of FSE and FPE functions (seeEqs. A.3 and A.4: more compliant SE was modelled by setting a1 ¼ 10 vs. 14.6 and b1 ¼ 0:1 vs 0.56 in the control); stiffer PE wasmodelled by setting a2 ¼ 18 vs. 14.6 in the control.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1691
Attenuation of load dependence of relaxation. Fig. 6 demonstrates the attenuation of LDR simulated by means of the
model. This effect was experimentally observed in different cases such as in severely hypertrophied myocardium, in the
myocardium of new-born animals, at high temperature, low ½Ca2þ0 level, etc. [39–43]. Mechanisms underlying the LDRattenuation were specific in each case. Using the model we classified the possible mechanisms, and in particular showed
that amplification of back-inhibition of SR-pump affected LDR in the model.
Perturbations in muscle load or length. Virtual muscle’s responses to load perturbation during the isotonic cycle are
shown in Figs. 7(A) and (B). They are in good concordance with experimental data [4,23]. For example, if a muscle
contracted with a load higher than a control one and then this load was abruptly reduced down to the baseline,
subsequent relaxation continued longer than that in control twitch (Fig. 7(A), curve 3).
Fig. 6.Modelling of load dependence of relaxation (LDR) of normal myocardium and LDR attenuation. Time courses of muscle force F
(normalized by the peak isometric force Fmax at muscle length Lmax), length L (normalized by Lmax) and velocity of muscle’s shortening(negative values) – lengthening (positive values) during afterloaded twitches are shown. (A)–(C) Simulation of the load-dependent
myocardium (see table in Appendix A for the basic values of the model parameters). (D)–(F) Particular example of simulation of
myocardium with attenuated LDR (the fraction of the SR in cell volume was decreased 1.5 times and maximum velocity kpump of SR-pumping was decreased 1.2 times vs. baselines). T1; T2 shown in panel (A) denote, respectively, duration of the isotonic phase at thegiven afterload and duration of that part of isometric cycle where force exceeds the afterload value. Index T1=T2 is used to quantify loaddependence of relaxation. This index is about 0.5–0.7 at middle afterloads in normal myocardium and it is close to 1 in myocardium
with attenuated LDR (hypertrophied, embryonic, new-born myocardium, etc).
1692 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
Figs. 7(C) and (D) demonstrate the effects of cyclic short-time deformations on isometric twitch. In concordance
with experimental data [15] we obtained that a short length change during the isometric cycle was followed by the
muscle’s force inactivation.
Fig. 7. Effects of load or length perturbations on a virtual muscle. (A), (B) Influence of load perturbations applied during muscle
shortening (panel A) or lengthening (panel B) on muscle relaxation. Time course of muscle force (upper plots) and length (lower plots)
during the twitch under the control afterload (curves 1, thick lines) are compared with test cycles (thin lines) after switching from/to
lower (curves 2) or higher (curves 3) afterloads. Time course of muscle relaxation depends essentially on the mode of muscle loading.
Shortening at lower-than-control afterload and following an abrupt increase in the afterload level (curve 2 in panel A) lead to ad-
ditional inactivation and earlier relaxation. Increase in the afterload level during lengthening phase (curve 3 in panel B) is also followed
by muscle inactivation and earlier relaxation. (C), (D) Influence of short-time cyclic deformations on isometric twitches. Thick lines
show time courses of isometric force (lower traces) at muscle length Lmax (upper traces). Thin lines show change in the muscle force dueto 5% muscle shortening/lengthening at different time moments during isometric cycle. Abrupt change in muscle length is followed by
force inactivation. First two deformations shown in panels C and D were applied at the same level of the muscle force, but first
deformation was applied earlier than peak force was reached and second one after that. Deformation applied in the latter case resulted
in more prominent inactivation because of decreased instantaneous level of Ca2þ activation reached during relaxation at the moment
when deformation was applied, as compared to the first case.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1693
Summarizing this part of the article, we should stress that our model of homogeneous muscle contraction reproduces
a very wide range of experimental data. They are as follows:
• steady-state Ca2þ–force relationships at different initial sarcomere lengths;
• time courses of force, muscle length and sarcomere length changes during isometric and afterloaded twitches at dif-
ferent initial muscle lengths;
• basic mechanical characteristics: length–force, force–velocity, force–work, force–power relationships;
• different aspects of load dependence of relaxation;
• effects of length or load perturbations on time courses of isometric or isotonic muscle twitches;
• Ca2þ-transients in the cytosol during muscle twitches.
Moreover, the model allows us to analyse mechanisms underlying the above-listed phenomena. We think that the
key factor is a feedback influence of mechanical conditions on cooperative activation–inactivation processes.
Based on the results obtained we think that our model is fit to serve as a virtual muscle in our experiments dealing
with the inhomogeneous system.
3. Muscle duplexes
We have been considering the muscle duplex as an elementary inhomogeneous system [44–46]. We composed du-
plexes of two elements mechanically connected either in parallel or in series (Fig. 8). In parallel connection duplex
shortening is equal to each element’s shortening and duplex force is equal to the sum of the element’s forces. In series
connection duplex shortening is equal to the sum of the element’s shortenings and the duplex force is equal to each
element’s force.
We developed three kinds of duplex methods: Natural Duplex, Virtual Duplex, and Hybrid Duplex. Below in this
chapter we briefly describe the methodological approaches specific for experiments with both natural duplex and
hybrid ones. Therein we also present the results of these experiments. As for the Virtual Duplex, it is performed as a
mathematical model of the muscle duplex composed either in series or in parallel. The latter model, in turn, was
created on the basis of the above-presented homogeneous virtual muscle. Particular mathematical formulas used to
combine the equations of two virtual muscles in the virtual duplex are given in Eqs. (B.1)–(B.4). The results of the
numerical experiments with both parallel and serial virtual duplexes are described below in the respective sections of
this chapter.
Fig. 8.Muscle duplexes. Scheme of contractile units’ connection within a duplex. (A) Parallel connection. Duplex shortening DL is equalto each element’s shortening DL1;2; duplex force F is equal to the sum of the element’s forces F1 þ F2. (B) Connection in series. Duplexshortening DL is equal to the sum of the element’s shortenings DL1 þ DL2 and the duplex force F is equal to each element’s force F1;2.Either a natural muscle or a virtual muscle can represent each contractile unit within a duplex. We consider a natural muscle duplex,
which consists of two natural muscles connected in parallel, a hybrid duplex composed of a natural and a virtual muscle connected in
parallel and parallel and serial virtual duplexes composed of two virtual muscles.
1694 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
3.1. Natural muscle duplex
Experimental method. We have created and used an experimental device for studying parallel inhomogeneous du-
plexes, composed of two muscles [44,45] (see Fig. 8(A) for the scheme of muscles’ parallel connection). In short, two
papillary muscles (£ < 0:7 mm) or trabeculae are excised from rat or rabbit right ventricles and placed in isolated
perfusion chambers with separate stimulating electrodes, preparation survival control, pre- and afterloading, force
recording. One end of each muscle is attached to the common lever of a linear servomotor and the other to an individual
force transducer. The servomotor is able to supply a range of velocities up to 200 lm/ms (while real velocities ofmyocardium shortening are 6 5 lm/ms). Experiments are controlled by a computer that also serves for both datagathering and processing.
At the beginning of every experiment basic mechanical characteristics (such as ‘force–velocity’, ‘length–force’, etc.)
are obtained separately for each of the two muscles. Subsequently, these muscles are mechanically connected in parallel
and the above characteristics are obtained for each of the interacting muscles and the whole duplex. Differences between
the characteristics of isolated and duplexed muscles allow one to assess the effects of interaction, both in control
conditions and during varying mechanical, chemical, pharmacological interventions, and/or during changes in bath
temperature, and/or during variations in time delay between the muscles’ stimulation (asynchronism).
Afterloaded contractions of a duplex. Fig. 9 demonstrates afterloaded twitches of a parallel duplex composed of two
thin papillary muscles excised from a right ventricle of rabbit. One of these muscles was cooled from 30 to 28 �C, sothat it contracted more slowly. In this way we obtained an inhomogeneous duplex consisting of a fast and a slow
element. Both elements of the parallel duplex contracted auxotonically under varying loads while the duplex contracted
isotonically. In this case, force decay in one muscle is compensated by the force increase in the second muscle so that
the sum of the forces keeps a constant value equal to the afterload applied to the duplex. In some cases complex
oscillations of the elements’ force were observed (Fig. 9). At the bottom part in Fig. 9 we show the results of the
corresponding numerical experiment with a virtual duplex. Virtual duplexes are considered in detail in the following
section.
Fig. 9. Afterloaded contractions of a parallel duplex. (A)–(D) Experimental record of contractions of a natural muscle duplex composed
of two thin papillary muscles excised from a rabbit right ventricle. (E)–(H) Results of a corresponding numerical experiment with a
parallel virtual duplex. Time courses of duplex shortening (panels A, E), duplex force (panels B, F) and force of each muscle interacting
within the duplex (panels C–D, G–H) during twitches at different afterloads applied to the duplex are shown. Muscles within the
duplexes contract auxotonically under varying loads and their forces reveal complex oscillations during the shown experiments. Force
decay in one of the elements is compensated by the force increase in the second element so that the sum of the forces is a constant value
equal to an afterload applied to the duplex.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1695
Length–force (L–F) relationships. Fig. 10 demonstrates L–F relationships between end-systolic shortening and end-
systolic force in a sequence of afterloaded contractions for duplex elements being separate or interacting, and L–F
relationships for the whole duplex as well. We also considered the ‘‘formal sum’’ of L–F curves in isolation obtained by
plotting given end-systolic shortening vs. sum of the two forces, where each force corresponds to the shortening of the
respective muscle in isolation.
When the muscles interacted their L–F dependencies slightly shifted in opposite directions as compared to their L–F
curves in isolation (Fig. 10(A)) it means that one muscle was additionally activated and the other was inactivated due to
their interaction within the duplex. Moreover, the ‘‘formal sum’’ did not coincide with the duplex length–force curve.
Thus, interaction revealed itself in the non-additive influence on the muscles’ L–F characteristics.
There was an influence of asynchronous stimulation of duplex elements on their length–force dependencies
(Fig. 10(B)). Delay in one muscle stimulation led to an increase in the above-mentioned shift of the L–F curve of each
interacting muscle as compared to such a curve in isolation. The mismatch between the ‘‘formal sum’’ and the duplex’s
L–F curve became more prominent as well.
At the bottom part of Fig. 10 we demonstrate corresponding data of numerical experiments with a virtual duplex.
Force–velocity (F–V) relationships. In Fig. 11 we show experimental F–V dependencies obtained for a fast and a slow
papillary muscle either being separate or interacting with each other within the duplex. In the same panels we plot F–V
curves for the duplex as a whole. For each muscle in isolation and for the whole duplex we use a common procedure,
when plotting F–V curves, i.e. we plot maximum velocity of the afterloaded shortening vs. corresponding value of the
afterload. F–V curves for each interacting duplex muscle are obtained by plotting the maximum velocity of the muscle’s
shortening (under every afterload applied to the duplex) vs. force developed by the muscle, when this velocities being
reached.
Investigating F–V relationships for duplex elements we found that in some cases their F–V curves became closer to
each other, thanks to the interaction between the muscles (Fig. 11(A)). It means that at each given load the fast muscle
Fig. 10. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in parallel duplexes (both natural and virtual ones) on length–force (L–F) rela-
tionships. Relationships between end-systolic shortening and end-systolic force obtained in series of afterloaded contractions are
shown. Different curves represent L–F dependencies for duplex elements in both isolation (solid lines) and interaction (dashed lines), as
well as for the whole duplex (top dashed lines). ‘‘Formal sum’’ (top solid lines) of L–F curves in isolation is obtained by plotting the
given muscle shortening vs. sum of two forces, where each force corresponds to this end-systolic shortening for the respective muscle in
isolation. Experimental results (panels A–B) are compared with modelling (panels C–D). (A), (C) Muscle duplex with simultaneous
stimulation of the elements. (B) Parallel natural duplex with 80 ms delay in one element stimulation. (D) Parallel virtual duplex with 55
ms delay in one element stimulation.
1696 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
within the duplex shortened slower than in isolation, and the slow muscle contracted faster. Furthermore, we found in
some cases such a delay in stimulation of one duplex element where F–V relationships of both elements became very
close (almost coincided – see Fig. 11(B)).
3.2. Parallel virtual duplex
In order to analyse more precisely the effects found we used a virtual duplex which consisted of a fast and a slow
virtual element connected in parallel (see Fig. 8(A) for the scheme of parallel connection of duplex muscles). Time
courses of force and length of the duplex and its elements during afterloaded contractions are shown in Fig. 12.
Fig. 11. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in a natural parallel duplex on force–velocity relationships (F–V). Shown are the
experimental F–V dependencies obtained for a fast and a slow papillary muscle either in isolation (solid lines) or when interacting
within the duplex (dashed lines) and for the duplex as a whole (thick lines). F–V curves are obtained by plotting the maximum velocity
of shortening vs. the force developed at the time when this velocity is reached. The duplex’s force is normalized by its maximum (i.e.
isometric peak force) value, whereas the muscle’s forces are normalized by their own isometric peak values. (A) Duplex with simul-
taneous stimulation of the elements. (B) Duplex with 30 ms delay in one element stimulation.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1697
Force–velocity dependencies. Fig. 13 demonstrates the effect of delayed stimulation of one duplex element on F–V
dependencies of both interacting muscles and their duplex. First we delayed stimulation of the fast muscle (by 30 and 50
ms). We observed F–V curves of both muscles drawing close to each other – up to their coincidence at 50 ms stimulation
Fig. 13. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in the parallel virtual duplex on force–velocity relationships. F–V dependencies,
obtained as described above (see Fig. 10), for the fast and the slow virtual muscles (thin lines), interacting within the parallel virtual
duplex, and for the duplex as a whole (thick lines) are shown. The duplex’s force is normalized by its maximum (i.e. isometric peak
force) value, whereas the muscle’s forces are normalized by their own isometric peak forces at one and the same muscle length Lmax. (A)The duplex with simultaneous stimulation of the elements. (B), (C) The duplex with 30 or 50 ms delay in the fast muscle stimulation.
(D) The duplex with 50 ms delay in the slow muscle stimulation.
Fig. 12. Afterloaded contractions of a parallel virtual duplex composed of a ‘‘fast’’ and a ‘‘slow’’ muscle. Shown are time courses of
duplex force (panel A), duplex length (panel B) and force of each muscle interacting within the duplex (panels C–D) during twitches at
different afterloads applied to the duplex. Duplex elements are stimulated simultaneously. Isometric peak forces are almost equal in
both duplex elements. Time to peak force and relaxation time of the ‘‘fast’’ muscle (panel C) are shorter than those of ‘‘slow’’ muscle
(panel D). The lengths of the muscles are equal both to each other and to the duplex length. Forces are normalized by the maximum
force of the duplex Fmax reached during the duplex isometric contraction at length Lmax. Respectively, lengths are normalized by Lmax.
1698 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
delay applied to the fast muscle (Figs. 13(B) and (C)). After this we delayed the stimulation of the slow muscle. As a
result, two F–V curves of the interacting muscles proved to be even more distant than they were in isolation
(Fig. 13(D)).
Length–force dependencies. In Fig. 14 we show the influence of the above stimulation delays on L–F dependencies.
In the case of the 50 ms delay in the fast muscle stimulation F–L curves of interacting muscles became markedly
closer to each other (Fig. 14(B)), just as the corresponding F–V curves did (Fig. 13(C)). Contrariwise, when the slow
muscle stimulation was delayed by 50 ms, the L–F curves were even more diverged than without delay (Fig. 14(C)).
Summarizing, we can say that, for 50 ms delay in stimulation of the fast muscle, the basic mechanical character-
istics (L–F, F–V dependencies) of interacting inhomogeneous muscles became almost identical. In other words, the
muscles interacting within the inhomogeneous and asynchronous system behaved as functionally homogeneous
ones.
Ca2þ activation of duplex elements. In order to analyse factors determining this effect of functional tuning of in-teracting inhomogeneous muscles, we studied how Ca2þ activation of each element within the virtual duplex changed
due to the asynchronous stimulation. Fig. 15 demonstrates time courses of Ca–TnC concentration of both the fast and
slow muscles at different stimulation delays: simultaneous stimulation; stimulation of the fast muscle delayed for 50 ms;
and stimulation of the slow muscle delayed for 50 ms. When the fast muscle stimulation was delayed by 50 ms, the peak
of Ca–TnC concentration became lower in the fast muscle and higher in the slow muscle as compared to their si-
multaneous stimulation in the duplex. This means that the fast muscle was inactivated whereas the slow muscle was
additionally activated due to their asynchronous stimulation. When we changed the sequence of excitation and delayed
the slow muscle stimulation, Ca–TnC concentration slightly increased in the fast muscle as it essentially fell down in the
slow muscle, unlike the previous case.
We found some premises of equalization or, vice versa, divergence of the F–V curves for interacting muscles. Fig.
16 presents dependencies between normalized afterloads applied to the duplex and time to peak Ca–TnC concen-
trations of both interacting muscles. The curves are plotted for different stimulation delays of one element of the
duplex. As we noted above F–V curves of interacting muscles coincided in the case of 50 ms delayed stimulation of
the fast muscle. Exactly this delay induced close convergence of time to peak Ca–TnC concentrations in both in-
teracting muscles (Fig. 16(B)). In contrast, when stimulation of the slow muscle was delayed by 50 ms, time to peak
Ca–TnC concentrations diverged even more strongly than in the case of simultaneous stimulation of duplex muscles
(Fig. 16(C)).
Fig. 14. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in the parallel virtual duplex on length–force relationships. Relationships between
end-systolic length and end-systolic force of the fast and the slow virtual muscle interacting within the duplex during afterloaded
contractions are shown. The muscle forces are normalized by their own isometric peak forces Fmax at one and the same muscle lengthLmax. Length is normalized by Lmax. (A) The duplex with simultaneous stimulation of the elements. (B) The duplex with 50 ms delay inthe fast muscle stimulation. (C) The duplex with 50 ms delay in the slow muscle stimulation.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1699
Fig. 17 demonstrates that during afterloaded twitches, Ca2þ-transients of interacting muscles in the virtual duplex
changed depending on stimulation delays, and these changes occurred in opposite directions as compared to Ca–TnC
concentration. In particular, the upsurge of Ca2þ concentration corresponded with the fall of Ca–TnC concentration.
Fig. 16. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in a parallel virtual duplex on the Time to Peak Ca–TnC concentration in interacting
virtual muscles. Shown are dependencies between times to peak Ca–TnC concentration in the fast and the slow virtual muscles during
afterloaded twitches of the virtual duplex and the afterload values (normalized by isometric peak force of the duplex, Fmax). (A) Duplexwith simultaneous stimulation of the elements. (B) Duplex with 50 ms delay in the fast muscle stimulation. (C) The duplex with 50 ms
delay in the slow muscle stimulation.
Fig. 15. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in the parallel virtual duplex on Ca–TnC kinetics in interacting virtual muscles. Time
courses of Ca–TnC concentration in the fast (left) and the slow (right) muscle during afterloaded twitches of the virtual duplex are
shown. (A) The duplex with 50 ms delay in the slow muscle stimulation. (B) The duplex with simultaneous stimulation of the elements.
(C) The duplex with 50 ms delay in the fast muscle stimulation.
1700 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
3.3. Parallel hybrid duplex
As we mentioned above, one of the methods we used to study the inhomogeneity phenomena is that of Hybrid
Duplex. We used the above-described virtual muscle as a counterpart for a natural muscle within a hybrid duplex (see
Fig. 8 for the scheme of a parallel duplex).
In more detail, the concept of the hybrid duplex method is as follows. A natural papillary muscle (or trabecula)
interacts mechanically – in real time – with a virtual one. In-parallel or in-series connection between natural and virtual
muscles is implemented by means of computer-controlled A/D & D/A input/output functions. These transform the
digital signal from the virtual muscle (tension calculated in the model at each current step – i.e. once per 100 ls; themodel calculation at every step takes about 50 ls) to an analogue output (instant load, applied to the natural muscle viaa servomotor). Vice versa, the program transforms the analogue signal from the natural muscle (its real instant
shortening/lengthening) to a digital reading to set the current length of the virtual counterpart. From this input, the
model calculates the next instant force of the virtual counterpart, which is applied to affect the next instant load on the
natural one, etc.
The Hybrid Duplex concept allows us:
• to create groups of standard virtual counterparts for interactions with natural muscles including representations of
normal, hypertrophied, and hypoxic muscles (parameter identification [47,48] of the above-described mathematical
model of homogeneous myocardium allows us to create these groups);
• to study the response of one and the same natural muscle to the interaction with either normal, hypertrophied or
hypoxic virtual muscle;
• to use the virtual muscle of any hybrid duplex as a transparent one, i.e. to observe in it a sequence of intracellular
events resulting from the interaction with the natural counterpart in the duplex;
• to change properties of virtual counterparts via parameters’ variation and to study how both the natural muscle and
the hybrid duplex (as a whole) respond (i.e. to study the sensitivity of an inhomogeneous system to changes in
intracellular mechanisms of its part).
We studied the afterloaded twitches of parallel hybrid duplexes composed of one and the same natural muscle with
two different virtual counterparts, one with strong load dependence of relaxation, and the other without load depen-
dence at all. The latter takes place, for instance, in severely hypertrophied myocardium. Fig. 18 shows afterloaded
twitches of a rabbit trabecula (natural muscle) and two virtual muscles both normal and ‘hypertrophied’ ones.
Fig. 17. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in the parallel virtual duplex on Ca2þ-transients in the interacting virtual muscles.Time courses of cytosolic Ca2þ concentration in the fast (left) and the slow (right) muscle during afterloaded twitches of the virtual
duplex are shown. (A) The duplex with simultaneous stimulation of the elements. (B) Duplex with 50 ms delay in the fast muscle
stimulation. (C) Duplex with 50 ms delay in the slow muscle stimulation.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1701
Afterloaded twitches of the corresponding hybrid duplexes are also presented in the same figure. Hybrid duplex
properties, as well as the response of one and the same natural muscle to interaction with different virtual counterparts
within the duplex (Fig. 19), differed strongly, depending on particular properties of these counterparts.
We also studied the influence of asynchronous stimulation of hybrid duplex elements on their force–velocity rela-
tionships and found such delays in stimulation where F–V curves approached together closely (Fig. 20). We noted that
this closeness was achieved mostly by shifting the F–V curve of the natural muscle, and this peculiarity of the hybrid
duplex has not yet been clear for us.
3.4. Serial virtual duplex
At the present time we have almost finished creating a physiological setup for carrying out experiments with du-
plexes composed of two natural muscles connected in series. Meantime we have already developed a mathematical
model of such a virtual duplex (see Fig. 8(B) for the scheme of muscle connection within a serial duplex) and carried out
some numerical experiments as follows.
Isometric twitches of serial duplexes. In comparison with parallel connection elements of a serial duplex actually
interact during isometric mode of the whole duplex contraction, where the lengths of the elements redistribute whilst the
duplex length remains constant. Fig. 21(A) shows isometric twitches of a serial duplex composed of mechanically
homogeneous elements, both when they were stimulated without delay and when stimulation of one element was de-
layed by 50 ms. Peak force of the duplex with asynchronous elements decreased but the characteristic time of relaxation
did not change. Isometric twitches of the duplex composed of a fast and a slow muscle are shown in Figs. 21(B) and (C).
When stimulation of the fast muscle was delayed the duplex peak force was over that of the synchronous duplex and
relaxation became faster (Fig. 21(B)). On the contrary, if stimulation of the slow muscle was delayed the peak of the
duplex force decreased and relaxation time increased as compared to the synchronous duplex (Fig. 21(C)).
These results show that interaction between asynchronous inhomogeneous elements can affect duplex force quan-
titatively in different ways.
Characteristics of serial duplex relaxation. Fig. 22(A) shows that interaction between inhomogeneous fast and slow
muscles affected sensitivity of the relaxationof a serial duplex to its length.The slope of the normalized length–T30 curve (T30
Fig. 18. Afterloaded twitches of hybrid duplexes. Shown are time courses of force (upper traces) and length (lower traces) during af-
terloaded contractions of (A) a rabbit trabecula in isolation; (B) ‘‘normal’’ virtual muscle in isolation; (C) A+B hybrid duplex; (D)
‘‘hypertrophied’’ virtual muscle in isolation; (E) A+D hybrid duplex. Presented virtual muscles differ, in particular, in their load
dependence of relaxation (LDR). ‘‘Normal’’ virtual muscle simulates a natural muscle with strong LDR and ‘‘hypertrophied’’ virtual
muscle is characterized mechanically by attenuation of LDR. Mechanical behaviour of the hybrid duplexes composed of one and the
same natural muscle with different virtual counterparts appears to depend strongly on mechanical properties of these counterparts.
1702 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
is relaxation time to 30% of peak force) for the inhomogeneous duplex was much steeper as compared to those for ho-
mogeneous duplexes, each one being composed of two identical copies of either the fast or the slow element of the in-
homogeneous duplex. The slope of the duplex length–T30 curve was almost twofold steeper in the inhomogeneous duplex.Fig. 22(B) shows the effect of delayed stimulation of one duplex element on relaxation time T30 of a serial duplex. A
few such duplexes composed of different virtual pairs are represented. An increase in the delay in the fast muscle
stimulation in inhomogeneous duplex caused a decrease in the duplex relaxation time, but an increase in the delay in the
slow muscle stimulation vice versa resulted in an increase in the duplex relaxation time.
Thus, mechanical inhomogeneity as such essentially affected the mechanical behaviour of the contractile system.
Moreover, different order of asynchronous stimulation of inhomogeneous contractile elements significantly modulated
the mechanical response of the system.
4. Discussion
Conclusions. Summarizing all the above results we conclude that the methods of muscle duplexes allowed us to
describe and analyse a new class of biomechanical phenomena caused by myocardium element interaction. We showed
that owing to mechanical interaction between inhomogeneous duplex elements their basic mechanical characteristics
Fig. 19. Auxotonic twitches of a rabbit trabecula interacting with different virtual muscles during afterloaded contractions of hybrid
duplexes. (A), (D) Isometric twitches of a rabbit trabecula (see ‘‘N-muscle’’ curve in the panel), its virtual counterpart (‘‘V-muscle’’
curve) and the corresponding hybrid duplex (‘‘Duplex’’ curve). (B), (E) Force of the natural muscle contracting within the corre-
sponding hybrid duplex. (C), (F) Force of the virtual muscle interacting with the above natural one within the hybrid duplex. Virtual
muscles differ by both their time to peak force and relaxation time (left virtual muscle is faster than right one) as well as by their load
dependence of relaxation (right virtual muscle is not load dependent).
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1703
changed, adapting to each other. This was observed for force–length, force–velocity dependencies. We found out that
the approaching of mechanical characteristics of both duplex elements closer to each other crucially depended on
stimulation asynchronism and the sequence of stimulations of these elements. In particular, there appeared to be such a
delay in stimulation of the faster element in the inhomogeneous duplex where length–force and force–velocity de-
pendencies of the interacting elements became practically identical. In other words, there were such conditions of
contraction for originally inhomogeneous systems where their elements became functionally homogeneous. We found
out that this functional tuning of the duplex elements was closely connected with and probably controlled by opposite
changes in Ca2þ activation of thin filaments of interacting contractile units so as to reach the closing of time to peak Ca–
TnC concentrations in these units.
Analyzing Ca2þ kinetics in interacting contractile units by means of the mathematical model, we found out, in
particular, that Ca2þ-transients of interacting elements changed also in opposite directions depending on the sequence
of asynchronous stimulations of the elements. This result, being compared with electrophysiological experimental data,
suggests the following hypothesis: mechanical inhomogeneity can induce or modulate electrical inhomogeneity of
myocardium. Following experimental data justify the validity of this hypothesis. It has been shown that in case of
isotonic shortening of the cardiac muscle the action potential duration (APD) increases [49]. The increase seems to be
induced by the length-dependent increase in the calcium transient which is also revealed in experiments [38]. Conversely,
the muscle lengthening results in both a decrease in the calcium transient and a reduction of the AP duration [49]. These
data point out that mechanical inhomogeneity of excitable environs may breed by itself electrical inhomogeneity and
cause perturbations during electrical wave propagation. This problem has not been properly studied yet.
In summary we can conclude that mechanical inhomogeneity proves to be an important factor regulating or modu-
lating heart muscle function. Interaction between inhomogeneous elements can affect myocardium biomechanical
properties not only quantitatively but also qualitatively. From the physiological point of view it seems important that
Fig. 20. Effect of delayed stimulation of one element in a hybrid duplex on force–velocity relationships. Shown are F–V dependencies,
obtained as described above (see Fig. 10), for a rabbit trabecula (N-muscle) and its virtual counterpart (V-muscle) interacting within
the hybrid duplex and for their duplex also. The duplex’s force is normalized by its maximum value (i.e. isometric peak force), whereas
the muscle’s forces are normalized by their own isometric peak forces at one and the same muscle length Lmax. (A) The duplex withsimultaneous stimulation of the elements. (B), (C) The duplex with 30 or 50 ms delay in the natural (slower) muscle stimulation.
(D), (E) The duplex with 30 or 50 ms delay in the virtual (faster) muscle stimulation.
1704 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
interaction between probably a great number of inhomogeneous cardiomyocytes should arrange specifically their be-
haviour within the whole system. It means that inhomogeneous cardiomyocytes have to be in tune with each other ac-
cording to their ownmechanical properties and time-space arrangement within myocardium.Wemean that depending on
the specific spatial arrangement of mechanical properties in an inhomogeneous cardiac tissue, there should exist a cor-
responding time arrangement of excitation that leads to an in-tune interaction between these tissue’s contractile elements.
Thus, the investigated biomechanical effects of interaction between inhomogeneous myocardial elements should be
considered as a new separate class of biomechanical phenomena, for which we propose the term ‘‘tuning effects’’.
Perspectives. We consider several directions for studying further inhomogeneity phenomena based on duplex ap-
proaches. They are as follows:
• to complete elaboration of an experimental device and computer software for both natural duplex and hybrid duplex
composed of muscles connected in series;
• to assess the effects of mechanical inhomogeneity of myocardium on the contractile function in pathology (local
hypoxia or hypertrophy);
• to verify the effects of mechanical inhomogeneity on cardiac pharmacological reactivity;
• to create mathematical models for complex mechanically inhomogeneous contractile systems:
1-D models of muscle chains composed of a number of virtual elements connected either in parallel or in series,
2-D and 3-D models of mechanically inhomogeneous tissue composed of several virtual muscles (quartet, octet,
etc.) connected partially in parallel and partially in series;
Fig. 21. Influence of delayed stimulation of one element in a serial virtual duplex on the duplex isometric twitch. Compared are time
courses of a virtual muscle forces and lengths during duplex isometric twitch in case of simultaneous stimulation of duplex elements
and of 50 ms delayed stimulation of one duplex element. Force is normalized by the peak force of synchronous duplex, length is
normalized by the same initial length in both muscles. (A) The duplex composed of two identical virtual muscles. (B) The duplex
composed of a fast and a slow muscle where stimulation of the fast muscle is delayed. (C) The duplex composed of the above muscles
where stimulation of the slow muscle is delayed.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1705
• to study the inhomogeneity phenomena on the molecular level by means of a mathematical model describing slow
and fast isomyosins presented in various ratios within the cardiomyocyte;
• to elucidate the interrelation between mechanical and electrical inhomogeneities in myocardium by means of an im-
proved mathematical model of homogeneous muscle contraction including simulation of mechano-electrical feed-
back influence on excitation–contraction coupling processes.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Dr. Peter Kohl from the University Laboratory of Physiology, Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PT,
UK, for his helpful comments during the discussion of the manuscript. This is also our pleasure to acknowledge the role
of the Wellcome Trust Foundation supporting our study of inhomogeneous duplexes (grant # 061115/Z/00/Z), and
both RFBR (grant # 00-04-48323) and NATO Cooperative Linkage Grant (#LST.CLG. 975785) supporting our
mathematical modelling of homogeneous cardiac muscle.
Appendix A. Mathematical model of homogeneous myocardium contractions
Justification of all the model equations and choice of the basic parameter values are given elsewhere [14–17,45].
A.1. Mechanical block of the model (see 1(A) for the scheme)
t (ms) – time;
LCE ðlmÞ – length of the CE;LSE ðlmÞ – length of the SE;LPE ðlmÞ – length of the PE;Lr ¼ 1:78 ðlmÞ – the length of CE and PE in absolutely relaxed and non-stretched states.
Fig. 22. Influence of mechanical inhomogeneity on characteristic time of relaxation ðT30Þ in a virtual serial duplex during isometric twitch.T30 is relaxation time to 30% of isometric peak force. (A) Relationships between T30 in duplex isometric twitches and correspondingduplex length in serial duplexes composed of either homogeneous or inhomogeneous elements. Duplex length L is normalized by
duplex length Lmax at which initial sarcomere lengths of both duplex elements are equal to 2.23 lm. (B) Effect of delayed stimulation ofone element on T30 in isometric twitches of duplex composed of either homogeneous or inhomogeneous elements.
1706 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
l1 ¼ LCE � Lr; ðA:1Þ
l2 ¼ LPE � Lr: ðA:2Þ
From equality LSE þ LCE ¼ LPE follows that LSE ¼ l2 � l1.FCE (mN) – force of CE;FSE (mN) – force of SE;FPE (mN) – force of PE.
FSE ¼ b1 ðexpða1 ðl2 � l1ÞÞ � 1Þ; ðA:3Þ
FPE ¼ b2 ðexpða2 l2Þ � 1Þ; ðA:4Þ
FCE ¼ kfdl1dt
� �N ; ðA:5Þ
N ¼ Nact n; ðA:6Þ
n ¼ n1ðl1Þn2; ðA:7Þ
Nact ¼Al
Al þ KlA
Lozðl1Þ: ðA:8Þ
Mechanical block of the model equations contains ordinary differential equations for l1; l2 and n2. They are asfollows.
The following equation results from the identity FCE�tFSE and Eqs. (A.3) and (A.5).
fdl1dt
� �¼ b1 ½expða1 ðl2 � l1ÞÞ � 1
k ðAl=ðAl þ KlAÞÞn2 n1ðl1ÞLozðl1Þ
: ðA:9Þ
Required dl1=dt was obtained by calculating the inverse function v ¼ gðf Þ which was described in the explicit form.The following equation results from the identity l02 � 0 during isometric mode or from the identity ðFSE þ FPEÞ
during isotonic mode of muscle contraction.
dl2dt
¼0; isometric mode;
a1 b1 ðdl1=dtÞ expða1 ðl2�l1ÞÞa2 b2 expða2 l2Þþa1 b1 expða1 ðl2�l1ÞÞ
; isotonic mode;
�ðA:10Þ
dn2dt
¼ qndl1dt
� �G
dl1dt
� �0:9
�� n2
�: ðA:11Þ
Functions used in the above equations are listed below:
n1ðl1Þ ¼ 0:6 l1 þ 0:5; ðA:12Þ
Lozðl1Þ ¼ l1 þ 1:14; ðA:13Þ
f ðvÞ ¼ P ðvÞGðvÞ ; ðA:14Þ
GðvÞ ¼0:6v=vmax þ 1; �vmax6 v6 v1;
ð0:6v1=vmax þ 1Þ v0�vv0�v1
h i0:1; v16 v6 v0;
(ðA:15Þ
PðvÞ ¼a ð1þv=vmaxÞa�v=vmax
; �vmax6 v6 0;ðs1 v
vmaxþ 1ÞGðvÞ; 06 v6 v1;
d; v16 v6 v0:
8<: ðA:16Þ
Coefficient s1 in Eq. (A.16) is determined providing continuity of P ðvÞ.
qnðvÞ ¼0:02� 0:26 v
vmax
�; �vmax6 v6 0;
0:02� 0:005 v0:99v0
�; 06 v6 0:99v0;
0:015
1þ5000 ðv�0:99v0Þ½ 10 ; 0:99v06 v6 v0:
8>>><>>>:
ðA:17Þ
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1707
A.2. Ca2þ handling block of the model (see Fig. 1(B) for the scheme)
Ca2þ handling block of the model equations contains ordinary differential equations for following variables:
CaC ðlMÞ – cytosolic [Ca2þ ];CaTC ðlMÞ – [ Ca2þ] within terminal cisterns (TC) of SR;CaLR ðlMÞ – ½Ca2þ within longitudinal reticulum (LR) of SR;
A (lM) – concentration of Ca–TnC;B1 ðlMÞ – concentration of Ca2þ bound with ‘‘fast’’ Ca2þ binding ligands;B2 ðlMÞ – concentration of Ca2þ bound with ‘‘slow’’ Ca2þ binding ligands;C (lM) – concentration of Ca–calsequestrin complexes.
These equations are as follows:
dCaC
dt¼ Fin � Fout þ kTC=C FSRrel � FSRpump �
dAdt
� dB1dt
� dB2dt
; ðA:18Þ
dCaTC
dt¼ �FSRrel þ kLR=TC FSRflow �
dCdt
; ðA:19Þ
dCaLR
dt¼ kC=LR FSRpump � FSRflow; ðA:20Þ
dAdt
¼ aon ðAtot � AÞCaC � aaoff expð�kA AÞpðNAÞA; ðA:21Þ
dB1dt
¼ b1on ðB1tot � B1ÞCaC � b1off B1; ðA:22Þ
dB2dt
¼ b2on ðB2tot � B2ÞCaC � b2off B2; ðA:23Þ
dCdt
¼ con ðCtot � CÞCaTC � coff C; ðA:24Þ
Fin ¼JðtÞ
zF 0:5VC; ðA:25Þ
Fout ¼ koutCaC
CaC þ Kout; ðA:26Þ
FSRrel ¼ krelQðtÞ ðCaTC � CaCÞ; ðA:27Þ
FSRpump ¼ kpumpCaC
Kpump þ CaCexpð�kinh CaLRÞ; ðA:28Þ
FSRflow ¼ kflow CaLRð � CaTCÞ; ðA:29Þ
kTC=C ¼ VTCVC
; kC=LR ¼ VCVLR
; kLR=TC ¼ VLRVTC
; ðA:30Þ
NA ¼ NðA=AtotÞLoz
: ðA:31Þ
Functions used in the above equations are listed below:
pðNAÞ ¼1; 06NA < 0:25;0:022NA�0:5; 0:256NA < 0:75;0:02; 0:756NA 6 1;
8<: ðA:32Þ
JðtÞ ¼ kin0:8� 0:008 ðt � 10Þ2; 06 t < 10;0:5 expf10�t
10g þ 0:3 expf10�t
55g; 106 t6 30;
8<: ðA:33Þ
QðtÞ ¼ t=t1; 06 t < t1;t2�tt2�t1
; t16 t6 t2:
�ðA:34Þ
1708 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
Differential equations (A.9)–(A.11), (A.18)–(A.24) present a complete system for the phase variables of the model.
Hill curve for Ca2þ–force relationship
F ¼ FpðCa2þÞnH
ðCa2þÞnH þ ðCa2þ1=2ÞnH
; ðA:35Þ
where F is a force, Fp is the force maximum plateau, nH is the Hill coefficient, and Ca1=2 is the Ca2þ concentration for
the half-maximum force.
Hill coefficient for Ca2þ–force relationship
nH ¼�4� F 0ðpCa1=2Þ
Fp � lnð10Þ; ðA:36Þ
where pCa ¼ lgðCa2þÞ; F 0ðpCa1=2Þ is derivative of function F ðpCaÞ calculated at the point pCa1=2.
Appendix B. Additional equations used for combining two virtual muscles in a duplex
DL – duplex shortening;DL1;2 – muscle shortening;F – duplex force;
F1;2 – muscle force.Connection in parallel (see Fig. 8(A) for the scheme)
DL ¼ DL1 ¼ DL2; ðB:1Þ
F ¼ F1 þ F2: ðB:2Þ
Connection in series (see Fig. 8(B) for the scheme)
DL ¼ DL1 þ DL2; ðB:3Þ
F ¼ F1 ¼ F2: ðB:4Þ
Eqs. (B.1)–(B.4) were rewritten using phase variables ðl1Þi; ðl2Þi; i ¼ 1; 2;, where i denotes a virtual muscle number.From these relations implicit equations for dðl2Þi=dt are obtained which substitute corresponding equation (A.10) foreach duplex’s muscle. Other equations A.9,A.11, (A.18)–(A.24) are duplicated for each virtual muscle in the duplex
system.
Basic values of the model parameters
a1 14:6 lm�1 B2tot 100 lMb1 0.56 mN b2on 0:001 lM�1 ms�1
a2 14.6 lm�1 b2off 0.003 ms�1
b2 0.0012 mN Ctot 40,000 lMk 20 mN lm�1 con 0.05 lM�1 ms�1
KA 35 lM coff 50 ms�1
l 2.5 krel 2.13 ms�1
vmax 0.0055 lm ms�1 kpump 1.5 lM ms�1
v0 0:5vmax lm ms�1 Kpump 1 lMv1 0:1vmax lm ms�1 kinh 400 lM�1
A 0.25 kflow 0.0039 ms�1
D 0.6 kin 5 C ms�1
Atot 70 lM kout 0 lM ms�1
aon 0.02285 lM�1 ms�1 Kout 0 lMaaoff 0.6 ms�1 VC 20; 000� 10�15 lkA 0.4 lM�1 VTC 120� 10�15 lB1tot 80 lM VLR 1200� 10�15 lb1on 0.1 lM�1 ms�1 z 2
B1off 0.182 ms�1 F 9:648� 1010 C lM�1
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1709
References
[1] Lew WYW. Functional consequences of regional heterogeneity in the left ventricle. In: Theory of heart. New York: Springer;
1991. p. 209–37.
[2] Role L, Bogen D, McMahon TA, Abelmann WH. Regional variations in calculated diastolic wall stress in rat left ventricle. Am J
Physiol 1978;235:247–50.
[3] Heineman FW, Grauson J. Transmural distribution of intramyocardial pressure measured by micropipette technique. Am J
Physiol 1985;249:1216–23.
[4] Brutsaert DL, Sys SU, De Clerck NM. Control of relaxation of mammalian cardiac muscle. In: Sideman S, Beyar R, editors.
Simulation and control of the cardiac system, vol. 1. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 1987. p. 139–60.
[5] Tennant LR, Wiggers CJ. The effect of coronary occlusion on myocardial contraction. Am J Physiol 1935;112:351–61.
[6] Grimm AF, Lin HL, Grimm BR. Left ventricular free wall and intraventricular pressure-sarcomere length distribution. Am J
Physiol 1980;239:101–7.
[7] Arisi G, Macchi E, Baruffi S, Spaggiari S, Taccardi B. Potential fields on the ventricular surface of the exposed dog heart during
normal excitation. Circ Res 1983;52:706–15.
[8] Winegrad S. Mechanism of contraction in cardiac muscle. Int Rev Physiol 1982;26:87–100.
[9] Litten RZ, Buchtal RH, Nagai R, Low RR, Alpert N. Heterogenetity of myosin isozyme content in the rabbit heart. Circ Res
1985;57:406–14.
[10] Katz AM. Molecular biology on cardiology: a paradigmatic shift. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1988;20:355–66.
[11] Alpert NR, Mulieri LA, Hasenfuss G, Holubarsch Ch. Optimization of myocardial function. In: Myocardial optimization and
efficiency, evolutionary aspects and philosophy of science consideration. New York: Steinkopff Verlag Darmstadt; 1994. p. 30–40.
[12] Katz AM, Katz PB. Homogeneity out heterogeneity. Circulation 1989;79(3):712–7.
[13] Allen DG, Kentish JC. The effects of length changes on the myoplastic calcium concentration in skinned ferret ventricular muscle.
J Physiol 1995;366:67.
[14] Katsnelson LB, Izakov VYa, Markhasin VS. Heart muscle: mathematical modeling of the mechanical activity and modeling of
mechanochemical uncoupling. Gen Physiol Biophys 1990;9:218–44.
[15] Izakov VYa, Katsnelson LB, Blyakhman FA, Markhasin VS, Shklyar TF. Cooperative effects due to calcium binding by troponin
and their consequences for contraction and relaxation of cardiac muscle under various conditions of mechanical loading. Circ Res
1991;69:1171–84.
[16] Katsnelson LB, Markhasin VS. Mathematical modeling of relations between the kinetics of free intracellular calcium and
mechanical function of myocardium. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1996;28(3):475–86.
[17] Katsnelson LB, Markhasin VS, Khazieva NS. Mathematical modeling of the effect of the sarcoplasmic reticulum calcium pump
function on the load dependent relaxation of myocardium. Gen Physiol Biophys 1999;19:137–70.
[18] McDonald KS, Moss RL. Osmotic compression of single cardiac myocytes eliminates the reduction in Ca2þ sensitivity of tension
at short length. Circ Res 1995;77:115–9.
[19] Wang Y-P, Fuchs F. Osmotic compression of skinned cardiac and skeletal bundles: effects on force generation, Ca2þ sensitivity
and Ca2þ binding. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1995;27:1235–44.
[20] Bodem R, Sonnenblick EH. Deactivation of contraction by quick release in the isolated papillary muscle of the cat: effects of lever
damping, caffeine, and tetanization. Circ Res 1974;47:637–53.
[21] Allen DG, Cannel MB, Lab MJ, Orchard CH. Shortening during contractions slows the calcium transients in cat papillary muscle.
J Physiol London 1983;334:108–9.
[22] Allen DG, Kentish JC. The cellular basis of the length – tension in cardiac muscle. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1985;17:821–40.
[23] Brutsaert DL, Sys SU. Relaxation and diastole of the heart. Physiol Rev 1989;69:1228–315.
[24] Bremel RD, Weber A. Cooperation within filaments in vertebrate skeletal muscle. Nature 1972;238:97–101.
[25] Murray JM, Weber A. Cooperation of the calcium switch of regulated rabbit actomyosin system. Mol Cell Biochem 1980;35:11–5.
[26] Brandt PW, Diamond MS, Schachat FH. The thin filament of vertebrate skeletal muscle cooperatively activates as a unit. J Mol
Biol 1984;180:379–84.
[27] Grabarek Z, Gergely J. Appendix on the application of the Hill analysis to fluorescence data. JBC 1983;258(23):14102–3.
[28] Moss RL, Giulian GG, Greaser ML. The effects of partial extraction of TnC upon the tension–pCa relationship in rabbit skinned
skeletal muscle fibres. J Gen Physiol 1985;86:585–600.
[29] Gulati J, Stordilis SC, Babu A. Efects of troponin C on the cooperativity in Ca2þ activation of cardiac muscle. FEBS Left
1988;236:441–4.
[30] Solovyova OE, Markhasin VS, Romanchenko TYu, Katsnelson LB. Mathematical model of the generalised calcium buffer in
cardiac muscle cells. Biophizika (Biophysics) 1999;44(1):91–101.
[31] Haynes DH, Mandveno A. Computer modeling of Ca2þ pump function of Ca2þ–Mg2þ ATPase of sarcoplasmic reticulum. PhysiolRev 1987;67:244–8.
[32] Inesi G, Meis L. Regulation of steady state filling in sarcoplasmic reticulum. Role of back-inhibition, leakage, and slippage of the
calcium pump. J Biol Chem 1989;264:5929–36.
[33] Bers DM. Excitation–contraction coupling and cardiac contractile force. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 1991.
[34] Akella AB, Su H, Sonnenblick EH, Rao VG, Gulati J. The cardiac troponin C isoform and the length dependence of Ca2þ
sensitivity of tension in myocardium. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1997;29:381–9.
1710 O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711
[35] Ishikava T, Kajiwara H, Kurihara S. Modulation of Ca2þ transient decay by tension and Ca2þ removal in hyperthyroid
myocardium. Am J Physiol 1999;276:289–99.
[36] Lecarpentier YC, Martin JL, Claes V, Chambaret JP, Migus A, Antonetti A, Hatt PY. Real time kinetics of sarcomere relaxation
by laser diffraction. Circ Res 1985;56:331–9.
[37] Lecarpentier Y, Chuck LHS, Housmans PR, DeClerck NM, Brutsaert DL. Nature of load dependence of relaxation in cardiac
muscle. Am J Physiol 1979;237:455–60.
[38] Lab MJ, Allen DG, Orchard CH. The effect of shortening on myoplasmic calcium concentration and on the action potential in
mammalian ventricular muscle. Circ Res 1984;55:825–9.
[39] Hoerter JA, Lecarpentier Y. Load sensitivity of relaxation in the fetal and newborn rabbit heart. Cardiovasc Res 1984;18:523–7.
[40] Lecarpentier YC, Bugaisky LB, Chemla D, Mercadier JJ, Schwartz K, Whalen RG, Martin JL. Coordinated changes in
contractility, energetics, and isomyosins after aortic stenosis. Am J Physiol 1987;252:275–82.
[41] Lecarpentier YC, Waldenstorm A, Clergue M, Chemla D, Oliviero P, Martin JL, Swynghedauw B. Major alterations in relaxation
during cardiac hypertrophy induced by aortic stenosis in guinea pig. Circ Res 1987;61:107–16.
[42] Antony I, Chemla D, Lecarpentier YC. Myocardial contractility, lusitropy and calcium responsiveness in young (50 days) and
hypertrophied (180 days) cardiomyopathic hamsters. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1992;24:1089–100.
[43] Dobrunz LE, Berman MR. Effect of temperature on Ca2þ-dependent and mechanical modulators of relaxation in mammalian
myocardium. J Mol Cell Cardiol 1994;26:243–50.
[44] Routkevich SM, Markhasin VS, Nikitina LV, Protsenko YuL. Experimental model of mechanically non-homogeneous
myocardium (the duplex method). Russian J Physiol 1997;83(4):131–4 [in Russian].
[45] Markhasin VS, Katsnelson LB, Nikitina LV, Protsenko YuL, Routkevich SM, Solovyeva OE, Yasnikov GP. In: Biomechanics of
the inhomogeneous myocardium. Ekaterinburg: RAS Ural Division; 1999. p. 253 [in Russian].
[46] Markhasin VS, Katsnelson LB, Nikitina LV, Protsenko YuL. Mathematical modelling of contribution of myocardium mechanical
inhomogeneity in its contractile function. Gen Physiol Biophys 1997;16(2):101–37.
[47] Milstein GN, Solovyova OE. Recurrent estimation and parameters identification in non-linear deterministic systems. PMM (Appl
Math Mech) 1991;55(1):39–47 [in Russian].
[48] Milstein GN, Solovyova OE. Filters construction in non-linear deterministic systems. PMM (Appl Math Mech) 1994;58(6):30–41
[in Russian].
[49] Lab MJ. Mechanosensitivity as an integrative system in heart: an audit. Prog Biophys Mol Biol 1999;71:7–27.
O. Solovyova et al. / Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 13 (2002) 1685–1711 1711