luNutr MUNtISABATTAR
Ushbu sonda
oT u H ooP MAUUOHH'TX TEX HODO rU UK nH OOPM AUU OH H Oh 3KOH OMU K E :KOHKYPEHTHAfl CTPATETUq NHAUUB XXI e.
M A-b H A B 14 14 X A BOC IBN'4 K :TYUYHI]A BA MOXUqT
+ OOPM6I COBEPUEHCTBOBAHNflM DKny H AP OAH O rO C OT PyA H n q ECT B AB EOPbEE C TEPPOPU3MOM
S IYO SAT
r0ils00HUl|Ul|
200i)
j'lg2
REITATIO]NS
E:=
I
EII]
EùrF
l-er,litll-l
ilrrF
rIl_EùÈ
rF
Ê[vAttt=
,/AHON IQTISOD IYOTI VA DIPINMATryAUNIVERSITETI
XATQARO MUNOSABATTARsIrosAT, IQTTSODIyOT, HUQUQ
ILMrY-NAZARTyJURNAT
2/2008G:Wz)
SIYOSAT
3. Caunoe,cotrcraTe,aÉ YME,4
OCEOBTThIE CTPATEruTTECITfiEno,4xo,4br BAmuErTorrA B EoPbEEC PEJIU.TZOSHâIM ?ITCTPEMJTSMOMB UCJIAMCIîOM MUPE*
1 Mai 2003 r. Hâ 6opry ocMhHqa.A..IlrH(onbH, npærAeHrC .lA Ax. 6yur-Mn, o6r''Bnqn o 6narononyltHoM 3asepLue,r.r4u 6oeBb,x onepaquù s 14pa(e Ha eo8erpoMa,qHoro nnaKâ1â (Mrccl49 B6tnojrHe-HaD.r He3aÂonro ao ol0ro n3 oKpyxeHurlâMepxKaHcKoi aaMrH14cTpaqr4 BbtaBl4-ra.nhcb npeAnonoxeH[q, tro BoùcKa CUJAB 14pa(e 6yA),T npxsercr8oBarbca 6yKe-raMr4 qaeroB B Ka'lecrBe oceo6oAureneù.,OAHarc nocneAyoqxe orpoMHbre qenoBe-qec(l,1e u KonoccanbHHe Malepuanbh6tenorepfi c o6el4x cropoH, ocKanaqug ceK-TaHTCKOù pO3Ht4 l,1 HenpeKpaùlaDqxùcapocr aHTxaMept4KâHcKr4x HacrpoeH!ù,oco6eHHo B apa6o-MycynbMancKoM Mhpe,BblH)Di(qâor Baa!hHfi oH oKcrpeH!o nepe-cMoTpeTb cBo14 clpaTerhtecKuê noÂxo,qhl
pâ3pa6orarb Hoabre,CTparerhc onpeÂenqercç KaK ( cKyc-
oTBO '1 HayKa no QopMynl4poBaHl,o, Koop-
' Bce nepeBoAu c aH.fuùcK
I lvlello Mbhael F. Otni|liîg a Bis-War Mililarywilh Small-War Capabitilies//Prlrnête.s, Autumn2006. P 26
, Kopstein Jetfrcy. the IÂnsaiantic D vide overDènoù acv P. omotion / / f he washingtan euaûeny,Spring 2006. 2912. P.85-98i Bacevich Aîdrcw.Coilq lo( Btokê//fhe Americdn Consetuatirc,Jânuary 29, 2007 lssuei Câkewa kers go AWOL//The Washington Tlnes, June 15,20A4,
al4Hailrx ,4 nptMeHèHl4o acex rHcTpyMeH-TOB HaqilOHanhHOù MOqh CTpaHbt - 6ya6TO AXnnoMaîû9eCKtat, TOpTOBO-SKOHOMrr-'lecKut, BoeilHo-nonoTrqecKIù, ncfi xoto-rh,recKrù, HHOopMau4oHHo-rlaeorof tgec-Khù Ânl Aoct4xeHhl qeneù, o6ecne,luBa-roul4x HaqroHanËHyo 6egonacHocTbD.3 143oTofo gcHo! 'rTo cTpaterx'lecK[e nopxoablTpe6yoT yMerug npxBJlegh MaKo,lMalJl6ioeKO]I|4ITOCTBO UêHToOB Ct4tbt Ha CBOIO CTO-pol.ty x oTropaDK48arÈ npoThaHhKâ oT Ma(-cxMarbHo 6onbuero g[cnâ ueHTDoB cunblB MO(AyHapOAHbtx OTHOtlleHUFX,
Crrycrq ceM6 ner nocne coobrkri 11oeHrtops, a oro nAonblle, .teM gosreqe-nue CLIIA Bo Brcpyo MrrpoByo BoùHy,a,TeaTp BoeHHbrx AeùclBr.4 ù CLllA B Mycyrh-MaHCKOM MUpe 3aMelHO pacLul,lphnc9, axx BbrSoabryBeJ|url,4nncb B pa3H, tl3aec-THhrù Tepponor PoxaH fy8aparHa orMeqa-er, rro B 2008 r, ,4, Bo3MoxHo, B o6o3pl4-MoM byAyuleM "rnâsHhte rÀeonorliqecxl4ex onepaqxoHHbre yrpæht 6yÂyr r,tcxoÂarb
lcercni Jaseph, Hotconb Janas Jt. leds.l.SùâtegK Siudres nstrrùle U.S Army War ColegeGuide To SlrEteoy, F€bruar! 2001, P.1-?82
. Hofihan B.uce Combating Al ea€da and theMiiitanl lstâm c Threat/Â$timony prssenled to th€flouse Armed Services Cômmitt€e, Subcomntneeon ler.orism, Unconvenlionat Threâts and Capâ-bllities on Febtuary 16,2006. P.5
N
ôiz
rl
IA
Z
Eo
-t
x
q,l
oogt
o
xqJEaoz
Jt!
.l
zF
ztI]Fz
SIYOSAT
r13 AByX MeXAyHapOÀfrbrx 3nIqêHrpoaTeppop!43Mâ - llpaKa Ha SndxHeM Boc-lOKe r Qeaepan6Ho-aÂMIH14cTprpyeMbrxnneMeHHbrx 3oH (OAnS) naKxcTaHa",rrpaH,4'raû1ux c aoraH4cTaHoM. flo npu-3HaHUO EOpO nO nOAOT9eTHOCTII npaaM-renbcrBa CLIIA B anpene 2008 r. , .C|IAHeaoclaer Bceo6ùeMnloulero nraHa nonxKBxaâquh Teppop14cTl4'rec(où yrp03blu 3aKpb|rrlo y6exrul a nakuclaHckr4xoan3'.,
no cnosâM npe3xAeHTâ CoBera nofi HOCTpaHHbTM OTBOLl]eHUgM Ph'rapAa Xâ-acca, (CoeAl4HeHHbre lllTaTH !1 aMepuKaH-cKhi Hapo nnaTtT cyulecrseHHyo qeHy3a peueHUe HanâcTb Ha 14paK,4 3a noc'leayDqhe peueH119, npxB9T6re nocleocso6oxAeH|4r l4paxa,,3 TaK, no cocloe-Huo Ha I aBrycrâ 2008 r.4162 aMep[-KaHCK,IX BOeHB6tX 66|nO y6ù1O '1 6Onee30642 eeno8eK paHeHo so BpeMe ùpâKc-Koù onepaquh,4 He MoxeT He sorHosaTbx ToToaKr', 91O q XCIeHHOCIb ybXTbtX Cpe-ar4 MxpHoro HaceneHhi l4paKa, no npea-noIoxrTenSHUM noactelaM pâ3n149HbtxHenpaB|,TeIbcIBeHH6rx opraHxSaquù, Ko-ne6nercr or 83 221 Ao 793 663 ,ren.s BcBoro o'repeÂ6, KoHrpecc CIIJA câHKr.txo-Hl.4poBan cyMMy 3 pa3Mepe (nprMepHo857,3 MnpA Aorrn. CIIIA s nepuoA Aot4ons 2009 r, Ha noKp6rÎr4e pacxoÂoB cne-ayoÙ1hx lpex L!14poKoMacLUTa6Hbx aoeh-
H6rX Onepaq,4ù, IHXr.t l4xpoBâHHhlx noc/1eco6brrqù 2001r,6:
. onepaq,49 "14paKc(ar cao60.qa",HâqaTaî oceHbrc 2002 r, c oopMripoBa-8r4C BOùCK Anq ATOpXeHrlg a l,4paK, npo-Ào4xaou.lâ9c9 no HacTotqee BpeM9;
. onepaul49 (HecoKpyu]IMa9 cBo-60Aâ" B AO.aHhcraBe ,4 Àpyrhe onepa-qr414 no (rnooanÈHoù BoiHe npoTr,4B Tep-popa', pacTgBystùyecA o1 Qt ̂ nunf lhHAo Axrr6yTx, Ha'raB|.j]fieca cpa3y nocneaÏa( 11 ceHrg6pq l, npoÂor'txaoqi4ecqno ceù aeHb;
. onepauhg (EnaropoaHbrù open,,o6ecnegqBaÉqaq yny!ureHHyo 6ego-nacHocT6 Ânr Boet l6tx 6a3 x 6e3onac-HOCTb CIIIA,
CornacHo gerbrpexnerBoMy o6æpe-Hho N,4,4HhcrepcTBa 060poH6| ClllA or 6ôe8parF 2006 r.. râK Ha3brBaeMaq (Aor-raq aoùHa' He 6yAeT 3aKaHquBarbcg hpa-KOM X AOfaH4CTaHOM, OÉa (pâCnpOCTpa-Hr,4TC9 AaneKO 3a UX npeAenaMU, MOXeT6brrh, B ÂecarKax Apyfl,4x crpâH oAHoBpe-MeHHO x ftâ aonrue rpgÂyqhe roabr,An6-KâxAa x cBqgaHHbte c Heù Asrxe-HUe OnepxpyoT B 6onee eeM 80 cTpaHaxMuPa,. /
n o y r B e p x A e B u D n p o o e c c o p âAxopDKrayHcKoro yHhBepcxiera AsH14e-na 5aùMeHa, (crpaTor4g CLJA B 6opb6ec Anb-KâxAoù 14 poÂcrBeHHbtMr4 c Hêùr p y n n x p o B K a M M n e p e M e H r x B a xr e o n p e a e l e H H a ' , 3 T e M H e M ê H e e ,Har6onee x3BecTHbrM14 ocHoBHbrMr,t cTpa-T e r q e c K n M 1 4 n o a x o a a M x c l l l a ,np,4HflTbrM14 BO BpeM9 nepBOrO CpOKAaAMuH14crpaqrr Ax.6yura"Mn. (2000-2 0 0 4 r r . ) , c { r l r a r c r c q ( A o K r p r l H aynpexaa|oirlero yaapa, u (crparerxe
I Gunaratna Rohan. Tenorsm Th.ear in 2008//The Jebsen Cenler lor CounteÈTerorsm Studies.The Fletcher School, Tulls Unilersily Bes€archBneiing Series. Vo!. 3, No 2, Febtrary 20OB P.1-2
z Thê United States Lacks Comprehonsve Panio Destroy lhe Tenorist Threal and C ose the SatoHaven in Pakislan s F€d€rally Adminislered
-friba
Areas, Combat ing Teûor ism, Uni ted Sta lesGovernmert Accountabiliry Otfice, GAO-08-622,Apr12008.P.1.37.
3 Haass Bichad. Pteparcdlestimony beiore theSenate Committee on Foreign Relatiôns, Jânuary23, 2007, ww.crr.orq
1U.S. Departme.t oi DeJense Press tjnks CasuallyUpdare (Seprembêr 17, 2008) aw.delenselink.miy
s Fischer Hannah. lraqi Civilian CâsualtiesEstimates Congressiona Besearch Seryice Repon8522537, May r6, 2008. P.3
6
3 Belasco Any, The Cost or kaq, Arghanistar,and Olher Global Wêr on Teiror Operations Sinc69/l l//Congressio.âr Fesearch Seruice RêportR133110, Juns 23,2008. P. CRS-1.? 2006 Ouadrennial Dèiense Feviêw Rêport,
Pe.tagon, Washinglon D,C,, February6, 2006, P,213 Bynan Daniel. B€making Aliances lor the Wâr
o letrct sm//rhe Journal ol Strateglc Srird''es, Vol.?9 No. 5, October 2006. P.775
npoaB4xeHxg ÂeMoKpaT ,. o6a noÂxo-Âa 3arparrBaoT cTpaHhl r,lcnaMc(oroMrpa ,1 npu3BaHbt cTa16 cpeÂcTBaM nor r,4 KBr,1Àât_1, h npoqsreHqn Teppopt43Ma.
t oKtpttÈa vr pexÀa F,llre ro vaa DalPteemptive Strike), ftr.xe h3BecTHae noAha3aaHheM (aoKrpr-1Ha Eyua", BflepBbre6brna 03BygeHa npe3l,AeHToM nepe Bbr-nycKrMKaMu BoeHHoù aKAlqeM u cLllA Byscr flohHle s hrcHe 2002 r.,1 u ooriqu-an6Ho 3aKpenneHa s cTpaTefurl Haqho-HanbHoù 6e3onacHoc .4 CllJA, npùHeToù17 ceHrA6pA2002 r., AoKrpl,lHa paccex-Taf ia Hâ npeo6pa3oBaHue KoHqenq|4xnpeBeHrrBHoro yaapa /Preventive stike),npeanonararcqero HaHecrl4 yaap nepg6tMnpoIr4B HeMxByeMOù, Cnequof i gecKoù,npr16n|4xaouericc yrpo3u, Ha 6oneeur4poKyo KoHuenql4o aTaKoBaT6 nepabtMaaxe no coMHfiTerrbHstM qe,rnM ao roro,KaK npoT14BH14K yCnen coopMt4poBaTbcg,
AMephkaHcKMe Bracrra Morl4srlpoBa-rr,1 3TO peuteH,le TeM, lTo nocne 1 1 ceH-rq6pr CLLIA cTanKr4BaDTcq c ac/MMeT-pl4r'rlrstMh yfpo3aMh B nuue Herocyaap-cTBeHHhrx a(ÎopoB, noBeaeH'le KoTopbtx lieno[qaeTcg npeacKaSaHho, h npexHlecTpaTer![ neproaa (xonoaHoù BoùHbt, -cAepxnaaHhe lcontainmentl 6 ycrpauJe-Hhe ldeteîencel ' 6onee HeoOOeKrl4BHhr.no rûIv,Kà Wrpawe4 16 npeAnonaraja, qronoTeHqranbH6rt Bpar 6bn patl!4oHaj6HhtMrocyaapcTBoM, koropoe He HâghHano alaKynepBbrM, oco3HaBag 60,16!JyO BepOqT-HOCTb OTBeTHOTO yÀapa, 'llo rexato B Kori-uenqxl. BSarMHo rapaHItpoBaHHoroyHt4troxeHqg, 6naroÂapq (oropoù coxpâ-Hence xpynKL,rù Mr.4p Mexay ctljA 14 Co-BeTCKr,lM cOO30M B TegeH!4e 60nee geM40 ner nocne Bropoù Ml1poBoù BoùHH.ÂoKTp14Hâ npeÀnonaraer, 9To spâra, He
rWhte Nouse, President Bush Detvers craduationSpeech at W€sl Point , Uôi ted Srares Mi t i taryAcademy, West Point, New York, June 1. 2002www. white ho use. gov/n ews teteases /2002/06/20020601-3.hrhr
? The National Securily Strateoy of the UnitodStales 01 America, Washinston, 0.C,, The Whitel-louse, September 17, 2002
S'YOSAT
uMeloqero KoHKpeTHoTo fpar(aaHclBa,roToBoro noKoH9ll'l' XX3Hb CaMOybUù-craoMj Henb3r ycTpaLlurb Hx nreM Bo3-Me3AX9, Hu n).reM HaBrcbrBaHrg oTKa3a oT3Tr.4X ÀÊy( oOpM CTparefva ycTpauJeHt4q,
npoOeccop tienbcKoro yHl.4BepcùÎe-ra AxoH Jlbor,tc fapA c xapaKrep 3oBaIgry AorrprHy KaK qpeacTaBnFpu.lyto BaI-6onee paâtKarbHyro cMeHy E rno6an6ùoùcÎparerh CtlJA c neploAa Harana (xo-noÂHoù BoùHbr',3 CornacHo MHeHfi|o pgAanonxronoroB, aoKTpuHa oTnx'laeTcq c,le-ÂytoulxMr acne(ÎaMx,
(1) CùA BnpeÂb ocÎasnqoT 3a co-60ù npaBo AeùcrBoBar6 s nrc6où ToqKe3eMn'1 B OAHOCTOpOHHeM noprÀke, KOc-BeHHO AOKa3HBa9 CyqeClByrOqre Te3fi -c6r o cTpeMneBot BauJ[HrToHa ( (rno-6anbHoMy AoMxHhpoBaBho,,4 (reTeMo-Hr,44,5 h.nu cTpor-re,tbcTsy (aMep14kâHc-Koù Mnep[ti",ô no oToMy âMdMqxo3Ho-My pa3Maxy oHa MoxeT ynoao6t41bct aoK-TpûHe MoHpo 1823 r,, npoBogrnauâBLleùcTpaHU 3ânaaHoro nonyuapt.9 coepâMxkcKn|o9rTell6Horo BnhgHf g ctlJA, CBO60A-HhrMtl oT KOnOHU3aqhU eApOnêiCKl4MtaepxaBaMh.T
(2)AoKrpt-1Ha Âer Bpa3pêo c hop-MaM4 MeXÀyHapOAHOrO npA8a, COrnaCtO
3 Gaddts John lew/s, A crand Sùategy olftanst ot .narion / /Fore ign Poticy, Naleûbet/December 2002.'Th€ Perils oJ Empire, Statemenl of Prnciples by
the Coalilion lof a Featistic Fore gn Polcy, 2OO?ww.realisticlorei0npollcy,org
5 Yordan Cêrlas. Amerca s Ouesl for c obalHegemony, Oflensive Fealism, Bush Doctrine andllie ltaq\1\at //Ihearia: A Jounal ot Sôciai & PoiiticalIheory Augusr, 2006. P,125-157.6 Bacevich andtev american Empirei Ihe
Bealities and Cons€quences 01U.S. Diptomacy -Harvard Universily Press, 2002 302 p. lkenberryJohr. Americâ's lmpenar Ambiriaî | / Foreisn Aîa ].s,September/October 2002. P,44-6Ot Tùcket Foben,Hendrickson Dêid The mperial Templâtion: TheNew World Order aod Americaig Purpose, Colnciton Foreian Be al ons Press, 1992, 228 p.
' Monroe Doclrinei December 2, 1823/fihe AratonPrcject at Yale Lâw School, ww.yaleedulaweb/a\aton/mo oe.hrm. zakaia FârËed. From w€a[hto Power: The UnusualOrigins ol Americâ s WondFole, Princeton lJniversily Press, 1998, 199 pp.
oN
Nz
5F
th
zE
J
X
ql
ts
t!
f;EaaZ
F
JI!
'J
E
F
zg,lFz
SIY OAAT
KOrOpbrM pa3peLUaercç ucnonb3oBaHMecunbr B Kâ'recrBe caMoo60poH6r ,hrùrrnpoTfiB aeùcTafiTenbHoù, a He noreHqrl-an6Hoù yrpo3br. flo MHeHxo peÂaKropoB
"AMepu(aHcKoro xypHâna Me)(AyHapoa-Horo npaBa, J l .o .ÂaN4por! '1 5.oKcMaH,(BOeHHOe AeùCTShe npoi,lB 14pAXâ BeC-Hoù 2003 f. sBnflerca o.qHrM r43 HeMHo-rûx cnygaea ycrasa ooH, cnoco6HoeÔyH-aaMeHTan6Ho TpaHcoopMfipoBaTb un ,BOSMOXHO, AaXe pa3pyll4Tb Cr,4CTeM6lHOpMj peryn14poBaBUxx BonpocH xcnonÈ-3OBaHrg ChtH, pA3pa6orafih6rx B TeqeH[eXX aeKa, , , , 14Nf iqf iupoBaHf ie BoopyxeH-r-roÉ cfirbr nponrB l4paKa ecrb nepBoenpfi MeHeHhe HoBoù aoKJpt 49at yn perçla -
toLlero yaapa>il B qenoM ÂoKrprHa 6po-caer Bbr3oB aRroprrely ooH M apyrhxMexayrapoaHbtx opraHu3aqk14, np,4aeaeTK non3yveMy aroÂpbrBy ee BceM!4pHoro Bnl,l-cHr49, pacuaT6|BaHho cr,4creMbr Mexay-Hapoarofo npaBa, npûHq4n0B yaaxeHrlqrocyaâp0TBeHHoro cyaepesxTeTa rl Tep-prlTop!lal,lbHou uenocTlrocTx.
(3)Ao(rphHa co3Âacr {xnh yxe co-3AAna) O6CTaHOBKy nepMaHeHfi OfO XâO-ca, MexÂyHapoÀHoù !ecla6 rbftocTr4 rlyBell I9MT 914CrîO (npOaajl!4BLlJ11XC9, CTpaH,.CaMo no| lrTa4e.BoùHa c reppopoM" 98-nrercg (aMnâHreù c H!lKoraa He Kanl,ry-nxpyrou]uM npoThBHr4KoM j T,e, oTcyrcTBy-eT (oHKpeTHaq cropoHa, npx3HaoulaccBoe nopaxeHhe, KoTopoÉ noÂnrchrBaer'c9 nepeMupMe ht, abtnnagtBaHr4e pena-
(4) OHa epeBara nocneacÏBrreMu He-q36exHoro x aBroMaTuqecKoro x3MeHe-Hrlt clpâTer,4ù x yBen,4rei 9 94cna noc-neaoaaTe.fleù B BhÂe pgÂa Ma.rlbx x 6onb-ur4x cTpaH Mrpa, onpaBAHBarcq|4x co6-cTBeHHbre aeùc r Bxc npoTxa csor,4x Heapy-roB, 9TO CnOCO6CrByer X3MeHeH4|o soei
Mer(qyHapoaHoù cxcreMbr x pexhMa Mex-ayHapoÂHoù 6e30nacHocTr,1.
no3ÂBee, B 2006 r,, B AoKnaAe PsH-Âa, HuBenhpyc aoKTprlHy Eyua, oTMeqe-HO byKBanbHO CreAyol4ee; "CTparerhtHauMoHanbHoi 6e3onacHocTr He npeano-narana, 9To CLIIA BcerAa 6yA].r HaHocr4Tbyaap nepB!'Mx, Ho 3ârBnrna, 9To cLIJA Heo6e3aren6Ho 6yAF )(Aaru, noKa Hacryn-,leH e npoTMBHl,4Ka cTaHoB|4TC9 HeMfi Hye-MhrM ang HaHeceHri yÀapa nepBbrM,.3Aanee a AoKnaAe KoHKper|4314pyorcF Tpl4cqeHapl.9 npuMeHeHùi 3Toù aoKTpr4HblClllA B KparKo" r cpeÂHecpoqHbrx cpoKax:ynpex4eHh9 a cxTyaqrlgx (MexrpaH149-HOr,1 arpeccxM, npoTxB TeppopxcToa xnpoTxB rocy,qapcTB Bo fi36exâHrle pac-nPoclpaHeHrs OIMY'.4
Cro a re n't I n DoÀ B tt xe H u I ae M o x -pAtt!. B flo\6pe 2003 T. rraÊa EenoroAoMa o6HapoÀoaM (crparerfio CtllA nonpoÀsuxeHro aeMo(paT r,15 0603HaqxB, 'rTo (ygpexÂeHhe cBo6oaHoao tlpa-(a B cepaqe 6IrlxHero BocToKa cTaHeTaoÀopaSaenbHbrM co66rTueM B rnooanb-Hoù AeMoKparl4eecKoù pesonoql4h".6Ta(oe peùeH e CUIA raKxe 6brno 86rA-ahHyro Bo BpeMq BTopoù r.4HâyrypârlxoH-Hoù peefi Ax.Syua (cHBapb 2005 r.). OH,6brnl4 BKnoqeHd B reKcrlr HaU4oBanbHoicrpâTeruq no 6op66e c reppopr43MoM(ce8rr6pb 2006 r.)7 u HauuoHaibHoùcTpaTer,4rl no oe3onacHocTM cTpaHH (oK-re6ph 2007 r.) ,3 npx groM noAqepKxBâ-noc6, qro ctIA (npoaB|4raor 3ÔoeKrha-Hyo ÂeMoKparqo B KateclBe npoTrlBo-
' Danrosch Loti Fisler, Axnan Bernad. EdlaÊIntoduclion, Agora:Future lmplical ons ol the lraqWat//Anèrican Jounal of lntenational Law. Vol.97 No.3 July 2003. P.553-554.
, Shépirc /an, Fealurêd Speak€r, Containins G obâÎeftor, Governing ldeas Seres. - The BrookingsInstit!lion, Washington, D C., Apri 13 2007. P L
I
3 Muenet Katt let al) srfiking Filsr: Preernptiveand Pr€venuv€ Attack in U S. Nâtiônâl SecurlyPolcy, BAND, 2006. P xi.
5 Fact Sheeti President Bùsh Callsfora "FoMardSlrategy oi Freedom" to Promote O€mocracy nthe Middle East, November 6, 2003.
6 President Bùsh Discusses Ff€edom in laq andMiddle Easl NMmbû 6, 2003, ww.{niteho!s.9ov/news/eleases/2003/1 1/æ031 106-2.hlml
r Nâtionâl Strategy lor Combaling Terrorism, ThêWhite House, September 5, 200ô, p.1
3 Nat ional Si rategy Ior Homeland Securty ,Home and securlry Council, october 5, 2007 p. 1 5
çÀr,4c uae0norr14 rcppopr.1c.rr'rec(qx npo-'rrBHl4KOB t AOnTOCpO9HOTO peLUeHr49 AnqoaoreHur BoùHbr c TeppopoM>, TaK Bon'poc aeMoKpaTr3awx cTajr oaHrrM h3MeioaoB KoHTpTeppop14cTl,4gecl(oli cTpa-Tefr{. B ao&laae oTMegeHH geTb|pe oc-HOsHbrX0aKTOpa, nOpOXAa|l]U.l14XTeppO-p143M: (nonHTxrecKoeoTrp<aeHue; 06h-aH r npeanonaraeMbre HecnpaaeAnrBo-cTt4, KOTOpbte MOXHO CBanrlh HaApyrrxicy6KynbTypbr KoHcnupaqrh rAe3rHOop-Mau!1Ù, a TaKxe uaeonorr4g, onpâBAbrBâ-ouac cMeplb,,' cTpaTer/g claarl ne-peA co6où AocTxxeHre KoMnneKca pa3-hoo6pa3Hbrx qeneÉ: .pacnpocÎpaHr4lbcBo6oay B ly'paKe 14 ts Mripe, noroxrrrbKOrieq TrpaHxh, coaeùcTBoBarb cTa6M.r ,-Hoc s 6ecnoKoùH6rx perr4oHax h noBbr-cl4Tb npoqBeTaHxe B 6eaHbrx cTpaHax','
PaccMorp14M HeKoropHe peaKufi xaxaaeMItecKoto coo6ulecTBa, HecMoÏpgHâ TO, 9TO B paonOpgXeHI11 AMeprlKaHC-Koù ÀhnnoMath! no npoÂBl,xeHl4o cBo-hx HauhoHarbHbrx xHrepecoa, B lrâcTfio-cru B paMKax 6opr,66r c reppopr43MoM,l,lMeercg urrlpo(4ù Ha6op csoero poaa((Hyl.oa u npgHt4(oB', McnonS3yeMÉrx angoKasafiIt Btl4cHtq h onpeaereHHoro aâB-neHur Hâ r,4HocTpaHHbre rocyaapcTBa, o8aoKaSÈrBaeTcA no9tl4 oeccunbÉoi nepeaHaTrcKoM paÂrKanbHoro tcnaMxSMâ,
MHoru4e aHantrû(! cran!t 6r'rb rpe-BOry B CB93t4 C reM, qro.6opb6a C Teppo-prl3MOM MOXeT npOAOlXATbCt B reqeH[eHeonpeAeIeHHoro BpeMe{u 4 t4cnaM,ÀcÎ -cK14ù SKcrpeMr4SM Tpe6yeT coaepueHHol,HOrO CTpaTen49eCKOf O nIIaHUpOBaHIg',!9To (CLUA ace eqe B nol4cKe nyTeù pe-
SITOAAT
ueH14ù B sOnpoce noBcTaHqecTaa, Bceeue He noKa3biBaoqero npfi3HaKoB oc-na1neHvts", A HaeàAtA nposo.q[Tb napân-fienx c (,qxneMMoù BberHaMcKoù Boù-HH,.4 HaqrHae c 2005 r. MHorue Hl4l4Hara, u paspa6orKy HoB!,rx aoKrpl4H t, xoH "qenql4ù, B yge6HHe nporpaMMH BoeHHbrxB\,9O8 ABen|4 pg KypCOA nO OCHOBaM lep-pophsMa, apa6crcro 93btKa, hcnaMcKoMynpaBy h Kyn6rype. npe,qMeîi no napTr-3aHCKOù BOùHe Ha'tArl4 nO9BrqTÈCt B npo-rpâMMâx npooeccuoHarbx6rx BoeHh6txL!(O,i, KnaccxgecK e Tpyabr o (oHon ffaxBo BberHaMe Arxhpe clal, o6''3aren6"HbtM14 KHIraM A,II9 BOeHH btX ' UAepOS.5
Âpyryo rpynny flonxTonoroa cfi,rbHo6ecnoKor4T Bonpoc raK Ha36rBaeMoro (rlM-nepcKoro nepeHanpgxeHxg, j3 o6ocHo-saHHo BBeaeNHofo s saytHËrù o6opol no-toM KeHHe,U|4 B ero (Hl4re (BgreT l. naÂe-HfiE BCNI4KXXAEPXAB,. N KEHÈCA' OTMC.gar,9TO BenrKXe AepxâBH CKnOHH6| nOA-Beprarb pa3pyueHho 14 r4cToqeHurc l4c-IOKOB CBOeTO oUHâHCOBO-SKOHOMlrqeCKO-fo Be'lxrrhg, yaeng9 cnxLJKoM MHofo cBo-xx orpaHI'letHbtx pecypcoS Ât9 3arpa-Hr4'rHbx aaaHlop h,]t4 BoaIegeHkù,7
Âxeôopx PeKopA r.4s rlHcrqrfraclpaTeruæcKlrx r4ccneaoBaH[ù oaHt4M 143nepebrx apryMeHrhpoBan,s vro rax raasr-
' Pel Baphael Nationa Stralegy lor CornbalingTe(orism: Background and lssLres lor Aongress//Congressional Feseârch Seftice Beport F134230,November 1, 2007. P 6-8
'z Epstein Sùsaû, Serclino Ni,ta, Miko Ftêucis.Democracy Promoiion: Cornerstone ot U.S. For€iOnPolicy?//Congressional Fesearch Seruice ReportF134296, December 26, 2007.P.1.
3 Lovelace Douglas Jt. FotMord in Sh€riia Zuhur,A Hundred Osâmas: lslâmisr Threats And The FutureOf Counterinsurqe.cy, Stfalegic Siudies Inslitute,U S. Army War ColleQe, December 2005. P.iii,
4 Andâdê @le, Wlbanks Jânes, COBDS/PhoenixlÇounterinsurqency Lessons from Vietnam lor lheFrtorc/ lMilitary Baeievr', March-April 2006. P.9.
5 Merz slêeer, New Chal€nges and Old ConceptsU n d e r s l â n d i n O 2 1 s t C e n l u r y I n s ' r r € e r c y / /Pa.anêters, wlrret 2047.08. P.21,
r Cordesnan Anthony, Fesôurces versus Sfialegyand Force Transforrnât on: râq and the charrenoesoi Americân Oversrretch ,//Cenrer ior Sr.alêgicand lnrernatiofal Studies, Aptil 12,2AOS FogetsPrul. Ihe US Miltâry and the 'Wâr on Teûoahternalional Security Monlhly Brieting OxlordFssearch Group, Seplember 2005; Korb laly,Kraig M,bhael. Sùateaies lor LJ.S. Nal onâl SecurityWinnlng thê Peace in lhe 21sl Cent!ry, The SianleyFoundation, odober 2003,
1 Kennedy Paul. fîe eise and Fall oi lhe GreatPowe.s: Economic and Milirary Conl ict trom 1500to 2000. - New York, 1987.
3 Fecard Je.frcy. Bounding the Global War oîTerrorism. - Slrâteo c Studies Insttute//U.S. ArrnyWar College, Oecember, 2003, 62 p.
oN
z
r1F
an
zE
,l
X
9
AIYOSAT
EI
F
!J
!JEathZ
F
r,lgJ
J
zF
tq,lFz.
BaeMori (aoùt]e c reppop,'13MoM" Heao-cTaeT crpalefngecKoù gcHocTr'1 oHa cra-Bl4r oropBaHHble oT AeùcTBrlenbHocrl4qenfi, 'rpeBaTa ucToqeHxeM BOoHHOII Cunbl4 Apyrrlx pecypcos clLlA B HeCKOHTIâeMoM11 6e3HaAexBoM Ilol4c(e a6conorfloù 6e'3onacHocr,1, clllA MOI!.T 6b|1b B cocrou-HrI pa3rpoMl4rb, aaxe yHxgToxMlb Anb-Kafiay, Ho He h36aBsr Ml,4p or reppopr43-Ma. CornacHo Ax.PeKopay, aÂMfl Hrcrpa-rlr,49 nocryntlpoBana MHoroo6paS/e Bpa-roBj B(nto'ra9 (noporoable> cTpaHH, pac-
npocTpaH!4rcneù oMy, reppopMcrhrrecK4xopraH!æaq ù rnooarÎbHoro, perfioHanbHo-fo r MecrHofo MacMa6oe, cnnasngl ,xBOeAUITO B MOHOTXTHyO yrpo3y.
.4nc BbrxoAa l13 cnoxtaBuJefoca noro-xeBuq Ax,Pe(opA npeÂJrarat l gblnonHe-
Hhe cneayoull,4x ocHoBH6lx peKoMeHAa-qr4ù, hcxoag u3 Heo6xoar,4Mocrr4 onpeae"neHug npiopurerttblx flanpaBneH ù B co-ol3eTCTB14r,4 C KOH(peTHblMl.4 14H repecaM,',16e3onâcrocrLr CLIIA r npeÂenaMx aMe-phKaHcKoa4 Mou.Ir: (l ) pa3ùeAtlHxrb yr-po3y no pa3n,4qHblM OneMeHTaM; (2) 3a_MeHUTb XHCTpyMeHT npe BeHf k BH où aoù't5, ha uHcrpyMeHT ycrpaueHuq B Kale-crse rnaÊHoro MexaH14sMa peryn poBa_Hrc orHourert,4fr o (noporoBblM14' crpâHa-Mr,1, crpeMeu-1{4Mucc o6nâaarL ON4y; (3)nepeOoKycl4poBarb "rno6anbHyro Bo!1Hy cTeppopr43MoM, B nepByro o9epeab HaAnb Ka,4Ay, ee coo3Ht4Ko6, a raKxe Ha6e3onacBocr! caMtlx CLIIA (4) HânpaBrirbycMnfis I t4paKe Ha cra6hnu3aul4o, a raK-xe aonycrtlTb pa3ÂeneH,4e o6g3aHHocreùCLIIA n!.reM pacurupeHl49 MHorocropoH-Hero coTpyaHr,{qecTBa,
(DpoHcr,4c Oy<yqMa Bbrcryfl r1 nporhBcaMoro Ha3BaHfic 3roli KaMnaH[x. f]o eroMneHhlo, (Teppop143M' x "BoùHa" !enpa-Bl,1rlbHbre TepMtlH6l ant on,4câHu9 npo-6neM, c KoropblMl4 cranK Bâorca CLIIAuTeppopr43M - gro raKThKa, !lcnonb3ye-Mâe cna6HMt; ClllA xe cpaxalorci He cTaKTTKOù, a c rpynnoù 9phrx r4craMtlcroB,1 noBcraHueB. 6oph6a 60rbue noxoÂ1,47Ha npor14BonoBcraH'iecKyo KaMnaHu10 B
rno6ânbHoM MacûTa6e,. j 6o,1ee roro,BCe eqe Her MexayHapoaHofo KoHceHcy-ca o6 yHuOuUtlpoBaHHoM onpeAeneH14fiTepML-iHa <reppopr43M,, Ane oAHhx clpaHoH noapa3yMeaaeT flpecrynHtiKa, a angapyrrax - 6opua-oceo6oatarene "B Hacro-9!uee BpeMc cyqecrByeT 6onee 100 on-peaenexMù reppoP143Mâ".'z
B Âpyrori cBoeù crarbe (D.(pYKYqMa
orMe,laer, Llro.Heo6xoÂllMo noHqrb, 9TonpoaBL4xeHue aeMo(paTxu 14 MoaepHrl'3âr.lr,4t SnxxHero BocroKa Be 9angerccpeueHBeM npo6rleMU axuxa,qr{crcKofoTeppopM3Mâ. PaÂxKatlbBhlù t,|cnaMu3Myxe 9Bnge1c9 no6o'IHHM npoÂyKToM ca-Moù MoAepH 3aqhu, npo creKaoqer4 u3-3a norep,4 câMoco3HaHvg B npouecce ne-pexoaa B MoaepHr314pyroqeecg !1 nno-panqcr[gecKoe 06qecrBo. Sonhue Âe_MOKparhI o3Ha'.]aeT 6onbuJe or'1yx'4eH149,paÀMKanu3aqtl14 |4 TePPoPr4SMan 3
HecMorpc Ha pa3Hoo6pa3ue crpare'rl4qecKxx no!,xoaoB, clllA cornacHo Maii_Kny illoùepy, .nporrpbrBaor 6opb6y creppoprr3MoMD.a lM l l loùep, 6HBtl l14ùoO qep UPY co 22-nerHhM craxeM Pa'6orH no sonpocaM 8aq,4oHaJlb|loù 6e3o-nacHocTli, fiMeel creneHb ao(Topa noBonpocaM SprraHc(où xMnepl.h x orHo'ueHueM Ct]jA, KaHaAH u BenxKo6purâ-Hr.4r.4 l-43 yH sepculera lvlaHrro6a (KaHa-
Aa), OH cran ,13secreH B KagecrBe âaio'
fJa rpex 6ecrcentepos, ony6nv(oBaHHblxaHoHMMHo: uCKBo3s B30p6| haulrx npor,l8_
@vRvnMa AFBckc, Aeqnh èeqet, KoropbrMMd râyqrrrcb nocne 11 ceHrF6pe 2001 roAâ11.09.2006 r ww.lh€-amer can inleresl,com. Laqueù W the New leiro.ism: Fânalicism
â.d lhe Arns ôl Mass Deslruction _ New York:oxJord university Press, 1999/l Recatd Jeftèv.Boundinq TheGlobalWar OnTerrorism _ Slrâteglcsru. l iês lnst tu le U.S, Armv War ColLeqe
. Fukùyana Frâncis. Attet Neoco.servalism//IheNew Yorl< Îimes, Fêbruarv 19, 2006
a Kellv tlary Louise. Senior CIA Otii.6r Saysu.S. Losino Teûor War/ /Mornrnq Ediuon, NPFÊadro ,lùi; 24, 2oo4i CIA aniiwar Râdio wrthscoll Horton ând charles Govettte InterviewMichael Scheuer, Antiwâr.com, April 17, 2008,http://w!ûv.antiwar.com/radio/calesorv/c,a
HxKoB, 12003), .LlMnepcKaq cnec6" (2004)h "floxoÀ B npercnoÂHroo" (2008), s Ko-Topbrx oH noaBepfaer pes(ot (pxr4Ke no-nxTtgecKuù rypc Ax.6,J,11la fo oTHoueH rcK MycynbMaHc(oMy Mr,4py,' KHLafa uly'Mnep-cKas cnecbD eu.le 60,1bLue npoclaB naas-rcpa nocne ee (oao6peHug' caM'4M Oca-Moù 6eH tlaÂeHoM B ero B,lAeoo6paqe-Hr414 3 CeHreope 2007 r,, a KoTopoM roBo-pr4Tcg, 9TO (eCrM BÈii XOTrlre y3HArb HeKO-TOpb,e nph914Hbr aaL!efo nponrpbtBaHh9 aBoùHe nporqB Hac, To \r4raùre KH ryNraù-Kra Llloùepa B gToM orHoujeHr4l,t,,,
Nr.Ljloùep ca,araer, ero Anb-KafiÂaBr.4Ar1 Mr,1p 9c|jee HaC ll Ax.6ytu BeAeT CIUAUMeHHO nO HanpaBreHy@, no KoTopoMyxenaer 6eH .IlaAeB, - ( TorânbHoù (oHO-poÈTa|lrl14 c tlcrlaMoM noa3HaMeHeM npo-aBuxeHhr aeMoKpalxu, (DyliaaMeHla,rtbHbtùnopoK a npeÂcTaBneHxl, o 6eH tlaaeHe 3aK-nroqaeTc9 B ToM, 9To MycynbMaHe HeHaBu-491t4 HanaaaloT Ha Hac rc-3aToro, Kro MblecT6, a He 3a ro, 9ro MbtÂenaeM. B cpocrbOcaMy npnBoAt r BHeuH9r nonhr|,lKa AMe-poKh, a He aMepl4KaHcKaF Kynsrypa L1 06-qecrao. flonr4IhKa l, AeùcruûÊ CllJA, oco,6eHHo Ha SnrxHeM BocroKe, a Be qeHHoc-Tl,4 9B.nqrcTcg MOTTIBaM|. COnpOTt4BteHrtxcnaM4croB. BofiHa s |4pâKe npeBpaTruacbB (poxÂecTBeHcKtlù noaâpoK> an9 6eHJlaAeHa, TaK KaK oHa npeAocraBûna penr-rhoSHhrM 3(cTpeMrlcTaM npoBânxBLllylocgcTpaHy, r,1s KoTopori Moxt-ro BecTr4 onepâ-r.I4o 6o,1ee draronpr.rerHyo, leM AôraHu-cTâH, BropxeHqe B l4paK noAT6ep)(AâeTMHeH[e 6eH 'lAAeHa, 9rO hCnaMUCTbr Be-ayr o6opoHr,4TerbHyro BoùHy npoTl/lB l,4Hoc-TpaHHbrx oKKynaHToB, HaqeneHHyo Ha yHxg-IOXeltue '4CIaMa.
, norymoûs. Ihrouqh Or Enem es Eyes:OsamabinLaden Fâdical rs lam,â.dtheFl tureotAmer ica2003t Anônynaus. lmpe|al Hubrts: Why ihê Westls Los ng lhe War on Terror, 2004i Marchinq TowafdHel: America and tsiam Àiter kaq 2008.? The Solulion - A Video Speech trom Usama
bin Laden Addressinq th€ Amefican peopo on theOccâsion ol the Sixth Anniversâry or 9/r 1 - 9/2007, SITE Intellioence Group, Berhesda, f|40,September 7, 2007. P 6.
AIYOSAT
C|'oâfernu noa,a BteÈng M grexeù(COIN - countetinsurgency) ç'Br,sercs aa-Moù nocneAHeù kHHoBaqqeù Ht,|HeuÉeùaalvr4HrcrpaqfiM c[l]A B 6opb6e c pen -fl4o3H5rM OKCtpeMU3MOM B ICnaMCKOMMrpe. oHa ooHapoaoBâHâ 3 aeKa6pe2006 r. B ôopMe EoeBoro ycraBa BCBN,IC CUIA;3 oroMy npeAuecrBoBanoaByMeTHee o6cyxleHrle cpeÂt MxH14-cTepcrB, Be,qoMcTs u aKaaeMfillecKofocoo6utefisa CIIJA no pyKoBoAcrBoM .e-Hepanâ A.nerpeyca, KoMaHAyoUero MHo-roHa44oHarbHl,rMl4 cunaMx B ly'paKe. eTolHOAHù nOÂXOA COBnan C nepl,1OÀOM non"HOrO nepeocMbtcneHl4g caMoro oopMâTaBeaeH,4f, aHThreppophcTM'{ecKol1 (aMnâ-Hl4x ai,4epl4KaHCXr4Mr,4 Hây'rHbrMû k OOl4q -anhHbrMx KpyraMh, B npeal4cnoBhl4 cKa-Saro: (ÀocaÂrio, Ho KorÀa Halancn MgTexneroM 2003 r. s ly'paKe, BoicKa CulA He6brtrfi K oroMy roroB6r,,a
aBTOpOMT|oBOTOCTpaTeMqeCKOTO nOÂ-xo.qa B 6opb6e c Teppopl3MoM rBncerctAgBxA KrnKanneH, fl orqnorKoBH!rK aBcrpa-n{ùcKoù apMrl4 B orcTaBke, "pa3pa6oTaB-luruù paMot|lyo nor rr4Ky, perynxpyrou.lylo6C1O KOHTpTeppOpXCûqeCK\,lO,lll4tUoMaÏhloClll no BceMy Mrpy,.s B 2000 r. A.Kff-xaJUreH 3auxr4n aoKropcKyto ar4cceplaqhoB y8r.iBepcrrere HoB6rù loxBhrù ysnbc (AB-crpanhÉ) no TeMe (flontfr4tecKxe noc,lea-cTBr,4C BOeHHbTX Onepaqfiù B LllraoHe3xrl1945- 1 999 rr.: aHaM3 noreBbx r4ccreAosa-Hhù nonutùrccK,rxB@AeùcrB|4' pa36pocaH-HOCTIT nâp143âHCKOTO koHonriKra",6 nO OÂ-
t Nagl John, Anos Janes, Petraeus David(Forcwod), Sewal sêrah lhto.l. The U.S Anny/Marine Corps Coûnterinsurqency Fietd Manuat. ,Universly oi Chicago Press, 2007
I Evenl .Co!nt€Êlnsurgency i . Pr incple andPracticê", Hoùse ofCornrnons Comminee, UK, 1gthMarch 2008, ww.firsldetence.org
6 Kilcùllen David, Patiticat Corsequences of M tirâryOperâlions n Indonesla 1945-99 A tieldwork Anatys sol the Political PowelDiflusion Efiects oi GueritlâConliclr PhDdissenaton SchoololPoitics, Uni€BilyCollaqe The Unive.siry ot Now South Wates 2000ww. ibrary.uos.edu aul'lhesis/ad1-ADFÀy'uptoads/approved/adt-ADFA20060323. 1 21 1 24/ptht c /
Nô|z
rl
oZ
E
X
1 1
El
tolu
rEaUIz
5tI]
J
7.
F
Zt!Fz
SIYOSAT
HOù Bepchr,4, OH Ta(Xe .py(oBoa[n Boirc_KaM!i TxMop-I leMe,.r C 2005 r. pa6o'Ta,n TraBH6rM CIpATeTOM nO Teppopl,l3MyB TocÂene, neHtaroHe h gBrFercq coBel'HhKoM A.nerpeyca B l,4pa(e. A.Khn(anneHa cBoeM HaygHoM aoKnaÂe, nocBguleHHoMKoHqenqfih noaaBneH g MRTexeù, nl4uerc/1eayou.lee:
"Hacroeuaq BoùHa BahnyeuuM o6pa3oM6y4er noHerâ B Kâqecrae rno6atÉHoro Me-fe)(a, uHt4uurlpoBaqqofo paSdpoca1Haù'zrpynnupoBKoù t4ctaMhcfcKl4x .qauxeHut4,naTabult4xcs npeo6pâ3oBaft' ponb cna'MA B MU7OBOM nOpgAXe. oHt4 h.notbSy'tor leppopulM B kagecfae rtaÊHati, Ho HeeAhHcfBeHHoù cgoeù faKfuKu. nosToMy,cKopee Bcero Ko4\en\hq noaaEteHhqMgfexeù, geM fpaaulluotl4htù KoH\)rep'popu3M, MoxeT npeanafafb Haûtyt1at4t4noAxÔA 4n, Haqeceqhq nopaxeshq rto-6anbHoMy AxkxâAy",3
gApoM 3Toù crpareruh cnyxlr flo-relve pa3LeA41eque (disêggregation),BOT KaK O6È9o!l9er cBoo crparertbA.Kl,lnKarrreHl
nnoAo5Ho Ko4ueûuut4 cAepxugaHu,so speMe (xonoaqoù ÈoùtlhtD yMecrqoùclpalerheû an, npofuaocloe4rq rno-6anbHoMy ucnaMucrckoMy Mqrer<y craqerKOtlUenUUg pA3beAhHeNrlA. oHa O3BA9A'eT pA3HI'|e Beulu, E pâ3tuqHbù fearpaxL1n' B pâ3HOe ÈpeMq, HO O6eCne9hT fox'AecTBe H H Où Cf paf e ruq ecKoù KoH qemue ù
At19 tlpOAOnXUfetbHOù rto6arbHoù KoH'
QpoHrauuu. Pa3Éea,uHeHne cQoKycupy'ercq Ha npenrlcfBoaâHun coeauHehunMex4y feaTpaMn; nrueHhu Bo3MoxHoc'feù peruoqarbHbtx 4 fno6art'Ht x axTopoBnptlMKHtTb u ?KCntyATUpOBAtu MeCTHEtxaKfopos; noAphtB cBo5oaÉt aeùcfBuù cpeau u MeMy feafpaMtà ,qxuxztaa; Heaony'
qeHku paùoHo9-y6exuu; haonupoBaHutlùcnaMhcToB of MecfHoro HacereHqq; afaKxe noApaae BaaaoB u Bnoxe4hû t43
hcfouHnKoB ucnâMh3Ma B EotbaoMSruxHeM BocroKe. CTpafefun pasbeau'
H9HUq nph3AAHâ npeaorBpâfkfb paccpe'
4OTO9eHHge U HeCOhSMeprMÉle SneMeH'fH AXnXAAUCfCKOTO ABUxeHue 01 ÔWK'tlko|kpoBaHhg B KasecfBe rno6athHoù
B nprlHirr4r, oloË AoKTpt4Hbl, 6onee
Spenoù, 9eM paHHhe - HâclynaTerlbHblÉynpexaaoqit y.4ap x nopoù uaeânuc_T trecKoe npoaBixeHre aeMo(paTr[, _
He nocneÂHrc|o po/tb cbltpanâ Âxrxaal4_crcKa9 nr4leparypa, HaùaeHHât B aora-HhcraHe, B oaHoM 1,,!3 TaKlx [cnaMrcrc_KUX yge6HhKOB paCC(â3UBaercg (O Xe_narensHocTr o6ocrpeHu9 (oHQpoHTaqhxCIIJA c l4paHoM a Kagecrse Knolesoùcrparefru Anb-Kâxabt. B crytae Hana'aeHrg BâLlhHrroHâ Ha lerepaH l4paHMOXer np46efHyrb ( HaHeceHrlo yÂapoano HeOTgHHM obbe(IaM I nepcuÀcKoMsanrBe, seayul4M K napanû3aqhx 6070Mr,rpoBsrx HeoTnHbrx nocTaaoK|4 ÂecTa_641/'3a\tÀr g(oHoMr4K crparl 3afl aAa.Moqh ClllA Moxei noùTx Hâ ybbrnb ny-TeM nocrogHrloli 9KcnaHct4r,4 Kpyra !xcTbr'qeK'5 h3-3a (nepeHânpcxeHri' l,l r,1cro-ueHr19 cBorrx cMn. Ha orcÉ ocHoBe (op_pecnoHAeHr .Hbo lzopKep, I loypeHcypatTAerlâer 3aKno.leHre, tlro (Anq re'operr(oB axl,lxaaa Anb'KauÀâ ,ll,4lllb Ha-gâno scex Hâ'ran,.a
AHân,l3 crpâTerû.]ecKxx noAXoAoBBauuHrroHa K perurl4o3Hoù aKT!€143a'qr414 B MCIaMCKOM Ml4pe noKa3blaaeTno-cTeneHFyo oBonpq lo apabo-MycynbMâH_cKoù nonfi ThKu CtllA, nepeocMËDneHHoùc y'ieroM cyqeorayoulxx yrpoS l,1 ao3Mox-I Mc2ani Chris. Counterinsutqency Expett
Advises Soldiers in lraq, 11 June 2007, w!,ry.mnf_
z TepMsH, npearoxeH|uù a.Kr.lrxarneHoM3 Klculen David, Cornle ns GLobal Inslrgency/
/Jounal ol Strategic Studies, Vol, 28, No.4 August2005. P.597-617,
t 2
É wtisht Lâwrcnae.Ihè Master Plân//te Nêwyorre., sepr€mber 11, 2006. P.48'59.
HOCTeù CaMIX aMephKaHqeB, IcnaMrcT-cK4X paÀMKAnOB { nOCTeneHH0 l4X COO3-Hr4koB, flpeAaapllTenbHbtù aHanfi s TaxxesbrnBn9eï np9Mylo SaxHTepecoBaHHooThHbrHeurHeù aaM14Hl,4cmaqur B hcnorb3o-BaHl4l4 (hcnaMcKofo (baKTopa' ',| co6Ètn4ùI I ceHrrbp9 B npoAB xeHr4r4 cBot4xÂoJt-rocpoqHbx BoeHHo-non,4fligecKyx, Topro-BO-OKOHOMU9eCKqX U rAeonOrtl9OCKXXtrllepecoB Hâ SnhxHeM r CpeAHeM Boc-TOKe, CO3ÂaHhl4 14 COXpaHeHût dnaronph-,|THOTO UM MypOAOTO nOpnAXa. HecMoT-pt Ha ace nJrocbr !r Mt4ttvc6t HoBoi croa-Terl4r, noc4eÂHtâ ÂoKTpuHa |4Âeo.norh-qecKot 6op66H c noBcTaHgec(hM llshxe-H'ieM BCe eq€ 9B,lqelcg oaHoi ,3 Haytr-Èbrx rrnoTê3 06 rcnaMcKoM conpoTxsne-Ht4t4, cnoco6HoM K nocToqHHoli MyrAquuI rpaHcQopMaqhrl, ero lpeoyeT np6Hr-Tl.{i HoaËx aae(BaTHbtx cTpaler,4'.r6cK|,lxfloaxoÂoB I TaKlx(,
CaMbrM heMaroBâxHbtM ôaKToooM Bpa9B93l,tsaBtr,4 gTl/|x BoùH I nphHgTh14
SIYOSAT
peaa crparerrl'recKnx nopxoaoBr He no-nyYhBLil4x ulhpoKoTo M14poBoro oao6pe-Hh9, Xrpano caMo Bocnovqlve ûcJ|aM-c(oro M14pa HeoKoHcepBaTiBHbtM oKpy-xeHxeM a,qMIH14cTpaqhû ax,Syura-Mn,,oco6eHHo so BpeMq nepBoro cpo(a eronpa84eH!19, npuHilbte cTpaTerhgecKûennaHd CtllA no npoTt4ÊoctoqBrro ,tAgo-norxx no'|aM14cTc(ofo gkcTpeMh3Ma no-leHqranbHo Haqe,leH6| Ha Hace'|eHuecTpaH MycyrbMaHoKoro MIpa, npoôTx-pabuerocr oT DxHoù CaxapH ao ocT-poBoB l4HAoHesq!4, a TaKxe Ha pacry-qu€ o6uraHbr B crpaHax 3anaAa u ca-Mxx ClllA. ?qânbHoùutee fl phcÏanbHoeh3y9eHIe HOB6TX CTpaTefl49eCkXX nOAXO-ÀoB 14 xHcrpyMeHroa 6op66u CLUA cTeppopl43MoM MoxeT aHîal.T6 Âonon-HUTenbHbte rcToqHt4t(l4 Bfl eulHênonIT0-qeckoro noaeÂeHh9 BaurHrToHa HaMr4posoù apeHe, B qacftocTx B o6urp-HOM. flO ACe eLUe ManO nOHCTOM r4ctaM-cKoM Mroe,
ao
N
ôiz
st-
û
Z
E
.J
X
