Date post: | 08-Dec-2023 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | landaverde |
View: | 0 times |
Download: | 0 times |
International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application 2013, Vol. 03, Issue 01(Special Issue), pp. 05-15
INTERNATIONAL
JOURNAL OF
COMPUTER SCIENCE
RESEARCH AND
APPLICATION
ISSN 2012-9564 (Print)
ISSN 2012-9572 (Online)
© Author Names. Authors retain all rights.
IJCSRA has been granted the right to publish and share, Creative Commons 3.0 www.ijcsra.org
Serious Games for Serious Learning-
Using SG for Business, Management and Defence Education
Maria Magdalena Popescu
1, Margarida Romero
2, Mireia Usart
2
1Carol I National Defence University, 68-72 Panduri st, Bucharest, ROMANIA
Email : [email protected] 2 ESADE Law & Business School, 60-62 Avenue Pedralbes, Barcelona, SPAIN
Email: [email protected]; [email protected]
Abstract
Moto: "I want to talk about […] games—[…] --and say some positive things about them." (J.P.Gee, 2007)
With the 21st century dynamics in one's thinking and being, education and -along with it- curriculum features have
witnessed an upsurge in skills to be trained. Paraphrasing UNESCO's Task Force vision, we now teach students to know,
to do, to live together and to be. In this respect, the "digital immigrants " now have to keep up with the ever changing
quality of information and reconsider Bloom's taxonomy from the upper levels onward, looking for better ways to integrate
interdisciplinary and trans-discipinary activities into the curriculum to prepare the "new millenials" for ever-challenging
environments. In this context, inordinate books have been written and countless lectures have been given in conferences, as
“games for educational purposes” and “gamification” as alternative and effective learning tools are nowadays "hash tags"
in education. Everybody knows a little of it and nothing seems intricate enough not to be achieved. While games are still
being designed for educational purposes and for a raised interest in instructors, the academic technologists and other staff
who wish to learn by playing and reflect on this experience still have no clear, measurable understanding of what games
really do in a real-teaching environment. After state-of-art has been presented in what Serious Games feature now both in
education and corporate training, case studies are still to feed researchers via practitioners into revealing new facets of
using games, in adapting and personalizing them to every context of use; all this aims at better meeting the requirements
of the users, enhancing knowledge transfer in its various forms, bridging gaps between researchers, game designers,
trainers, trainees and labour market stakeholders eventually. In this light, we here showcase a study undertaken
asynchronously by ESADE Business School in Barcelona, Spain, and Carol I National Defence University (NDU),
Bucharest, Romania, to identify the possibilities of integrating serious games into curriculum for an ESP (English for
Specific Purposes) module, in an adult education-context, given the specificities of time, age, background and cultural –
embedding features.
Keywords: Game Based Learning, Serious Games, User’s experience, Personalization, Adult Education,
English for Specific Purposes.
1. Introduction: The rationale for the MetaVals case study in Spain and Romania
Games Based Learning (GBL) is one of the active learning methodologies that have benefitted from the
evolution of the Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) lately. Moreover, computer-based games
have allowed educators to reconsider the dynamics of face-to-face interactions and allowed to facilitate the use
of digital games in asynchronous and distant context. The use of games with learning purposes has also
benefitted from the use of educational technologies, allowing to redesign face-to-face GBL activies into
computer-based Serious Games (Padrós, Romero, & Usart, 2011). Following Zyda (2005), GBL activities are
designed to help achieving a balance between fun and educational value. The pedagogical use of computer-based
games could enhance problem solving competences, decision making, knowledge transfer and meta-analytic
skills (Kirriemuir & McFarlane, 2004). In particular, GBL involving collaborative actions could allow for
6 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
placing learning into an authentic and realist context, thus allowing students to practice in safe environments,
providing realism and motivation to players through a good pedagogical design (Leemkuil, de Jong, de Hoog &
Christoph, 2003). From the students’ point of view and according to Foreman (2003), active discovery required
in this learning process enhances skills such as analysis, interpretation, problem solving, memory and physical
activity. Nevertheless, these scenarios may show a lack of effectiveness when no instructional or support
measures are added in order to guide this process. In this respect, de Freitas and colleagues (2010) affirm that
negative learning transfer may occur with some game players in GBL, where the players’ expectation for high
fidelity environments may be related to negative learning processes. Nonetheless, in looking for instruments and
educational alternatives one can relentlessly consider Serious Games as they seem to have more answers in
providing the context for problem-based learning, inquiry learning, constructionism and connectionism as SG
"have more than just story, art and software...they involve pedagogy, activities that educate or instruct, thereby
imparting knowledge or skill"(Zyda, 2005). Moreover, games have the power to shift attitudes (Holland and
Jenkins and Squire, 2003) even though not all subjects in a curriculum can lend themselves to teaching with SG.
1.1 Serious games in the context of management education
In the context of management education, simulations and games have been adopted during the last decades as an
active learning methodology that allows learners’ to participate in an engaging and authentic situation, avoiding
the risk that real life could engender in the fields of finance or security management (Kirriemuir, & McFarlane,
2004). In the recent years, Serious Games (SG) have become one of the trends of learning innovation in Business
Schools, moving the traditional lecture methodology and the classroom developed study cases forward. In this
sense, reference schools such as Harvard Business School have meant to make a progress, from the evolution of
paper based study cases into simulations and interactive case studies where the learners’ could play a realistic
situation, to learning by doing (Srikant, Garvin, & Cullen, 2010). In the context of management education, SG
are focused on achieving the particular objectives of given educational content through game play. Students’
attempts to solve problems are maintained throughout the learning session. SGs can be used by teachers as
instructional tools used to apprehend an experience system behaviour that will provide experiential insights
through learning by doing methodologies. For instance, GBL allows management competences training by
failing without the consequences of the real world (Prensky, 2001). Game design is based on the deep human
inclination to play games as a source for highly motivated learning (Gee, 2003), where the learner can achieve a
state of flow, considered by Csikszentmihalyi (1991) as the complete engagement or absorption in an activity. In
the state of flow “the sense of duration of time is altered; hours pass by in minutes, and minutes can stretch out to
seem like hours” (p. 49). Csikszentmihalyi identifies the playing activity as one of the activities that helps
players’ “achieve an ordered state of mind that is highly enjoyable” (p. 72).
Moreover, the action of gaming is visibly becoming a new form of interactive (mobile, multiplatform)
content, worthy of exploration for learning purposes. While motivation in the use of the games fosters student’s
effort without resentment, relaxation enables learners to understand things more easily. Since an additional goal
for management students are the new methods of learning under pressure, which could enable the combination of
theory and practice to construct new concepts that are learned from course content in the classroom, SGs are
used to construct educational situations so as to enhance the learning motivation of the students, especially
instructors in production management, logistics management, and other decision sciences courses that adopt
game-assisted teaching tools to simulate real enterprise situations so as to let students prepare for their
professional careers (Tao, 2009). In addition to that, collaborative games allow individuals who are
geographically and temporarily dispersed to participate in the same game. Collaborative SGs can provide
experiences across various situated contexts that enable learners to understand complex situations found in
management. Group members can build on each others’ knowledge and provide feedback on each others’
activities and metacognitive activities (Kim, Park, & Baek, 2009). Advantageous peer interactions such as
providing and receiving explanations, co-constructing ideas, reproving disputes and negotiation meaning can be
found in collaborative gaming scenarios and this adds to the reasons why SGs are a learning and teaching
method more frequently used in management education.
1.2 SG in defence education
It was not only the management education, but also corporate training and military universities which have
adopted this methodology where Serious Games have seen an important development, especially since it has
been considered well appropriated in the context of risk-management situations. The specific field of military
education has promoted the use of games both for risk-avoidance reasons, for leadersip, decision-making and
for cognitive skills as well, in addition to the pedagogical advantages of SG in terms of engagement, playfulness
and knowledge transferability.
7 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
As far as Serious Games’ deployment in the military context is concerned, the topic is closely connected to
the inception of using the video game America’s Army, released in 2002 , while the same year the Woodrow
Wilson Centre for International Scholar in Washington, D.C. founded the Serious Games Initiative; this way the
term “serious games” has triggered a large uptake process. Moreover, recent literature reviews have presented
serious games as providing innovative solutions to issues in the military that would be still valid now as well as
in the future. Simulations in particular have been used for different learning goals to train the military: medical,
combat, leadership, logistics, strategic planning, military history, communications, engineering, and business
management, linguistic and cultural issues. It was not only once that military education has utterly stressed on
the benefits of using games in training, especially stressing on boosting learner’s motivation. Things became
more prominent when Return on Investment is brought to the limelight and issues such as reduced training costs,
training time and increased learner’s engagement translate themselves into the effectiveness of using Game-
based-learning, irrespective of the cultural and structural existent barriers ( fear of failure, generation gap in
awareness and skills, command and control, hierarchical culture).While much has been done on military topics
with respect to SG education and training- Command and Conquer, Call of Duty, Haze, etc ( Caspian Learning,
SG in Defence Education, 2008), there still are things to be explored with respect to language and culture
training for the military. Tactical Iraqi along with the Tactical Language and Culture Training System are but
few examples of the efforts done in this direction as well, where not only tactics and strategy are in focus with
serious game-based training, but linguistics and culture as well. For this last use we will hereto present some
conclusions we have drawn, subsequent to using the MetaVals game produced by ESADE, in an applied
linguistics module- English for special Purposes; the target group consisted of military students from a Financial
Leadership Post-graduate course within the Carol I National Defence University, Bucharest, Romania.
2. MetaVals as a decision making game with individual and collaborative phases
In the context of SGs for management education, MetaVals was first designed as a classification game for
practicing basic finance concepts. The computer-based Serious Game was developed in the context of the FP7
Network of Excellence Games and Learning Alliance (GaLA). MetaVals was adapted from an existing class
activity that the professor used for helping students practice finance concepts such as assets and liabilities in an
active manner (Massons et al., 2011). This SG was designed through a process that involved a paper-based
release at first and two computer-based versions of the game that were tested in different environments (Padrós,
Romero, & Usart, 2011). Now MetaVals is a computer-based, sorting game where students play in dyads with a
virtual or a real peer, against the rest of the class. A welcome screen asks players to introduce their age and
previous knowledge on finance. This leads to a second screen with peers’ information. After general instructions
are given by a virtual lecturer, the student starts playing individually by classifying 6 items as assets or liabilities
(e.g. “Computer software”, “Bank Loan”); after this first phase, 6 different items appear, but now the player has
access to his virtual peer’s answers in the correction phase. This phase allows students to see their peers’ answers
and level of confidence before they give their own answers. The objective of the correction phase is to propose
each of the student to reflect on their team-mates’ answers and evaluate their correctness, building self-
confidence and self-esteem, meta-cognitive skills. After the correction phase, a final discussion phase starts; the
player has to decide if the 12 previously classified items were correctly classified. If the peer is another real
student, there is a discussion using a chat tool (e.g. Moodle chat) where dyads should reach consensus over the
12 items’ final answer; in case of virtual peers, the discussion phase is not supported by a computer mediated
communication. Finally, the dyad with a higher number of correct answers classified in less time, wins the game.
The results of all the dyads playing in the same cohort are displayed according to the scores, in order to provide a
feedback to the students’ based on their results in respect to the other dyads participating in the game.
2.1 Internationalisation and personalisation of MetaVals in the context of the FP7 NoE GALA
The MetaVals Serious Game has been designed as a classification game that could be adapted to different
contexts, to different knowledge domains, different languages and different graphic customisations according to
the specific needs of each of the context. The personalisation capabilities of the MetaVals are achieved by a
software design based on a modular structure of the database and an independent graphic interface that could be
replaced by changing the images. For adapting the game for a new context, the MetaVals administrative users
define a new context in the database, assigning an ID for the context, defining the pre-test and post-test surveys
to be completed by the students, the language, the availability of a forum or chat for supporting the synchronous
discussions between the dyads, and the creation of dyads composed by two real learners, or one real learner and
a virtual teammate.
In order to facilitate the implementation of MetaVals game in different contexts, a management interface was
developed to allow an easier management of the different contexts, groups, users and domain-specific
knowledge settings. The interface has been designed to allow teachers and non-experts to manage the
8 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
personalization. This interface has been conceived to include other languages in case the MetaVals should be
managed in other linguistic contexts. MetaVals is designed in six different stages to allow the personalization of
each game play. First, students can access two previous tests; these are totally adaptable and aim to help students
being aware of their initial level of knowledge. Then, MetaVals allows students to personalize their avatar for the
game and also explicit their age, knowledge and experience in the field of the concrete gameplay. After the
initial settings, the students play the individual and collaborative phases, and finally, there is another
personalized post-test that can also be used to evaluate knowledge acquisition after the game play. The MetaVals
game also aims to address the concrete demands of each learning context where the SG may be implemented.
This goal is reached by adapting both the graphical design and the language displayed in the game. Through the
use of personalization, the SG sense of credibility could be enhanced, especially when using a tailored graphic
design; then, students can identify themselves with the learning activity in an easier manner (Shapiro et al.,
2006)
2.2 Metavals and applied linguistics, cognitive and soft skill- enhancement for ESP classes
Used in the Carol I National Defence University environment, the ESADE MetaVals game was applied within
the module of English for Special Purposes, with the intention to determine the impact of a game on learning
effectiveness and the chances that such an activity could be embedded within the educational process with
military post-graduate students, for syllabus other than tactics and special operations; all this is given the benefit
of doubt, as our subjects are postgraduate students aged 35-45, both males and females, with a career in the
military and financial background, all in leading positions at their place of work. The MetaVals game was used
in the context of bank and accounting topics, subsequent to understanding and learning the English equivalents
of the specific terminology. Cognitive skills like remembering, understanding, applying and evaluating, along
with inter- and intra-personal skills like self-confidence, collaboration, decision-making, negotiation, have been
activated during this activity.
2.3 Alternative teaching in the context of GEL Theme team Stellar NoE
The purpose of using this game was encompassed by the Game-Enhanced-Learning (GEL) Theme Team, a
small-scale European project financed under the umbrella of Stellar NoE and TEL.eu, in order to add up to the
best practice section, with insight from a military Higher Education environment; we aimed at contributing to
guidelines for effective Serious Games deployment, looked at from an instructor’s perspective. We performed
the case study to underline the alternative to traditional teaching methods and materials, even if the system under
lens presumes some more strict rules of use with respect to the learning context. Instead of using the paper and
pencil test or the obsolete debate or already classical role-play to apply the previously taught financial
terminology, we engaged the postgraduate students in collaborative and individual activities that tested their
previous knowledge as well as the extent to which the knowledge transfer has been performed prior to the game.
In addition, the pre-test section of the game shed light over students’ self-confidence on the concepts in relation
to their experience and background, enhancing motivation and engagement for the rest of the game. Therefore,
the use of MetaVals in this case was set as a self-evaluation activity from the students’ perspective and as a
formative assessment from the teacher’s point of view.
3 Universities as learning context for our case study
3.1 Carol I National Defence University
Carol I National Defence University is a higher education institution, offering degree programs at different
levels-bachelor, master and doctoral programs, along with mixed training on short term postgraduate career
courses. The educational process in our university comes to support the methods and scientific tools that enhance
the formation of outstanding officers and leaders for tomorrow, at operational and strategic levels, both at peace
and war times. Modern teaching devices along with technology have boosted the educational process in Carol I
NDU lately, ensuring knowledge transfer along with meta-cognitive necessary skills. Serious Games have been
used in training our military at tactical and operational level, more in the form of simulations, while games
embedded in syllabuses other than these are still incipient. The reasons why this is so can be related to
educational policies, to security issues restrictions, to mentalities and instructors' reluctance to new pedagogies,
to educational staff's fears of loosing ground. We do hope, yet, that the MetaVals case unfolded in April 2012 is
just the promising beginning, while other initiatives will soon emerge.
9 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
3.2 ESADE Business & Law School
ESADE is an international academic institution with more than fifty years of history. Its key mission is to
develop individuals unto becoming highly-competent professionals with a high capacity of reflection, dialogue
and initiative. ESADE promotes quality education and research through its Law and Business Schools, both for
undergraduate and post-graduate students. There is also the Executive Education (ExEd) department, with
participants ranging from 20 to 80 years old. The use of Serious Games (SG) in ESADE is not generalized,
although it has grown during the last decade. Business simulations and investment games are used in face-to-face
classes both for undergraduate students and master courses. In the context of the first e-learning module designed
by the Direction of Educational Innovation and Academic Quality (DIPQA), the first release of MetaVals was
designed and implemented in 2011.
4 Learning objectives for the use of Metavals in Spain and Romania.
The MetaVals game was firstly designed as an adaptation of a learning activity used in a face to face course. Its
objective as a class activity was to help students in the practice and sharing of the knowledge acquired in the
previous lecture-based lessons. This way, MetaVals first release was defined as a classification game. Its first
objective aimed to overcome the difficulties of the lecture-based activity. When implementing this activity in
class, not all the participants could explain their knowledge in an equal way, neither could they get feedback
from the teacher and from other students. As shown in Figure 1, the relationship between the teacher and
participants was asymmetric and only allowed a small number of participants to get involved and receive
feedback. The second scheme presented in Figure 1 shows the change in the interactions that MetaVals
introduction in the classroom could provide. The game design consciously intends to help each and every one of
the participants to explain and share their knowledge, first individually and then collaboratively, in dyads. The
design of MetaVals therefore aims to allow students and teachers overcome the limits of the traditional activity.
Figure 1. Interaction scheme in a lecture-based activity compared to a collaborative, game-based activity.
A second learning objective is to help students practice theoretical contents. MetaVals was first implemented
as a part of a finance course. In particular, this SG aimed to help students practice two financial concepts: assets
and liabilities. With this aim, game designers together with an expert professor in finance designed a list of items
that could be classified into assets or liabilities. This list was divided into easy, medium and high difficulty
items, and then concepts were mixed and distributed in two panels or screens in order to make the gaming
experience challenging enough for students. Each panel presented six different items that had to be classified. In
its current version, the MetaVals game allows teachers to introduce and select different items for each different
game play; therefore, this can be used in different areas of knowledge.
Thirdly, with the aim of facilitating knowledge sharing, each item in the SG presents a certainty level gadget.
This tool allows students to rate and share their level of certainty when classifying each item from 0 (not sure at
all) to 10 (completely sure). This tool could help students in their metacognitive processes, both individual and
collaborative ones (Romero, Usart, & Almirall, 2001; Usart, Romero & Esteve, 2011).
Within the Carol I National Defence University we intended to use the MetaVals game with the aim to
establish the impact games have on knowledge transfer considering the context and particularities of adult
education with specifities of age, background , generation gap in awareness and skills; in addition to that, the
possibility of curriculum integration has been explored with a view to using Serious Games embedded into
curricular activities as altenative instruments for assessment, simultaneously measuring the effectiveness of
games on students' learning attitude. Of paramount importance among these objectives was teacher's role to be
played in this new learning context.
10 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
Figure 2. Level of certainty elicitation
Should we consider though the learning objectives we pursued in our endeavour to use the MetaVals game
within the Finance and Business Leadership Postgraduate course, it is imporant to state that the game was used
as post-teaching activity, in the controlled practice stage of the lesson , targeting skills like remembering,
applying, analyzing, evaluating. Needless to say that there were not only cognitive skills that were involved in
our activity as learning objectives but also the affective ones, such as: receiving and responding to phenomena as
well as internalizing values in the process of selecting the best answer for assets or liabilities and then compare
students’ answer to their colleagues, to then self-evaluate their certainty level and be able to negotiate over the
best answer in the ranked terms.
Another important element set as learning objective in the MetaVals case study was the improvement of soft
skills like team-building or decision making to be developed by means of this activity, given the specificity of
andragogy and adults in the defence education field, adding to the fact that the targeted students range between
35-45 years old and all fill leading positions in their place of work, elements conducive to sensitive situations
when assessment is involved.
Last but not least was the objective of creating situational context that are very close to real life environment
for the sake of immediate applicability of a learning activity with a view to practicing some functional language
context for formal language and decision making for reaching consensus dialogues.
5. Teacher’s approach in Spanish and Romanian contexts
Prior to using the game in Carol I NDU in Romania for the ESP learning context, a familiarization with the
activities and elements of the game has been performed by the teacher, following the game developer’s
instructions. A simulated play and game interaction was performed by one representative of the staff in ESADE
with the teaching representative in Carol I NDU, so that the instructor would become familiar with all the stages
of the game herself and see the learning stages from the student's perspective as well; this way all the questions
can be anticipated and the game-based teaching sequence can thus be performed smoothly and
consistently.Once this stage was performed and the teacher can control all the unexpected situations by being
familiar with the context, the game-based teaching / assessment activity/ application can begin. The case study in
question unfolded in the computer lab, wher the students were invited subsequent to paper –based and debate
activities that introduced the topic and ensured the knowledge transfer. At the stage of starting the game per se,
students were provided with personalized welcoming messages via mail from the game developer, informing
them on steps to be taken; consequently, teacher’s role has been seriously diminished at this later stage.
However, this fact has shown its minor drawbacks as well, as a side effect.
Teacher’s role in this very case has been limited to guiding them through the beginning of the game and the
game pre-testing phase, where they stated their level of knowledge in the field, based on their own self-
assessment; therefore, when the game started, students just used the information in the customized mailed
messages, received from the game designers. What is worth being mentioned about students yet, is that being
pursued by time-factor in the desire to complete the game in the shortest time possible, students paid no attention
to in-game real teacher’s instruction. At the end they required a more interactive virtual tutor to guide them
along. This shows the complete dichotomy between the real versus the in-game instructor’s role and the impact
they both have over student’s activity effectiveness.
In the context of ESADE in Spain, the game has been used in three modalities. A firt release of the game has
been used in a paper-based approach reproducing the screens of the computer-based environment. After this
successful experience, the second modality of use was the use of the MetaVals games in a computer-based
11 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
environment accessible through the laptops of the students collocated in a face-to-face class. In this context, the
teacher’s role was reduced to a reduced level of external guidance aiming to provide help to the students’
demands during the game. This game modality has been deployed during three months in different classes of the
Introduction to Finance course. After these successful experiences, it was decided, along with the Finance
professor, to do a step further and propose the students to play to MetaVals as an autonomous activity available
in the Moodle website, in a distance asynchronous modality. This last stage has beed completed successfully by
the students’ playing the game. Nevertheless, in this distant asynchrounous modality a small part of the students’
were not playing the game because of their reduced engagement out of the classroom academic time. The use of
the MetaVals has currently involved more than 200 students and allowed to analyse the ease-of-use, utility and
acceptability of the game , in addition to its possibilities for adaption and personalisation (Romero, Usart,
Popescu, & Boyle, 2012).
6. Students’ approach with MetaVals game in Spain and Romania
At the outset of this study case, students of the Carol I NDU were very enthusiastic with the proposal of using
the game as an alternate means to apply and evaluate the knowledge gained and the concepts refreshed during
the course. They created themselves avatars using their own basic data unreluctantly, to feel themselves better
engaged in the game. They were anxious to go through the game in the shortest time possible as the word
“competition” had become a buzz word for them. Due to this fact they even ignored teacher’s extra instructions,
being eager to be the first to finish and win, to the detriment of final results. As they were told their peers in the
game- the dyads- were virtual and less knowledgeable, they changed the initial level of confidence, and they
were even disappointed, as a real and stronger opponent would have challenged those more- according to their
feedback. They yet got involved, immersed (as the information in the game had immediate relevance to the real
world) and felt both serious and entertained during this activity. They expressed their desire for more such
classes.
At the end of this one-hour experiment with the Finance and Accounting Post-graduate students on using the
MetaVals game in Carol I NDU, we can state the objectives of our experiment have been met. Consequently, we
concluded that:
-games do have positive effects on learning even in adult training, in that they boost students’ interest and
engagement towards the knowledge in focus. Even if by using the MetaVals students didn’t actually acquire new
concepts, their soft skills were improved, their metacognitive skills were developed and the teacher took this
opportunity to have the students self-assessed. In adult teaching sometimes evaluation is a sensitive issue due to
age and career leading positions, affecting self-esteem and public image, therefore softer methods that would
allow for a teaching process to be completed with evaluating the cognitive gain without affecting one’s self are
better received by mature students.
-as far as the integration within the learning process is concerned, the MetaVals game has been used in the
Postgraduate Financial English course in the reinforcement and application phase, subsequent to teaching and
learning. We both used the game for cognitive and soft skills development, among which we mention
remembering, understanding, applying, evaluating, along with inter- and intra-personal skills like self-
confidence, collaboration, decision-making, negotiation, self-efficacy skills.
-It turned out that the group needed more preparation for the game sequences -due to the novelty of the
activity- than for the cognitive component of the game content which comes as a strong factor in support of
spreading more information on the game-based –learning activities with a view to a larger uptake. Reluctance
comes from ignorance and once the method is well spread, more and more teachers and students will take to it.
In the context of ESADE, the participants of the Introduction to finance course playing the Metavals have
been invited to answer a feedback questionnaire related to their learning and playing experience, based on the
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM, Davis, 1986). The TAM model suggests that the users’ perceived ease of
use (PEOU), perceived enjoyment (PE), perceived usefulness (PU) and Utility (U) influence the use of the
computer-based system. The TAM has been largely used in the analysis of the Human Computer Interaction
(HCI) capabilities of SG in the last years (Yusoff, Crowder, Gilbert, 2010; Kong et al. 2009). GBL can thus be
defined as a computer-based learning Environment that provides a host of new opportunities for instructional
designers, based on traditional lecture-based methodologies (Anderson, 2008), and also supporting more active
forms of student-content interaction. For teachers and practitioners, one aspect that should be analyzed in the use
and effects of GBL, is the students’ acceptance of the activity. Following the TAM, we considered PU, as a key
characteristic or factor of students’ acceptance to be considered in the MetaVals activity analysis. In Davis’s
TAM, PU is defined as the degree to which users consider that the IT system will improve their performance. PU
in GBL could be considered as the learners’ perceived learning opportunities, “the extent to which a person
believes that using an online educational game can offer him or her opportunities for learning” (Bourgonjon et
12 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
al., 2010, p. 1147). Preliminary results in ESADE experiences (Padrós, Romero & Usart, 2011) show that the
relation between PE and PU was significant. A possible explanation for this result is that games in general and
GBL in particular, are environments supposed to motivate and engage players (Prensky, 2001); therefore,
enjoyment and usefulness are supposed to be enhanced in games.The TAM can also be used as a post-test in
GBL activities such as MetaVals for helping teachers have a clearer picture of students’ future uses and intention
of use with the game.
7. Teacher’s post-training approach over a prospective game-based-curriculum in Spain
and Romania
A very important conclusion is that customization plays an important role in students’ engagement with the
game, and MetaVals gives some customization options. However, a more interactive interface would be more
efficient in giving the students’ the reality factor at a better quota. An interactive tutor once the game starts was
asked for, as it is more difficult to „go in and out of the game” for different instructions provided by the
classroom tutor.
Moreover, students would have liked to „feel and see” the opponent in the dyad, his lack or representation as
a real character- being presented only with an on-screen column with values- gave the feeling of little
interactivity. It is well known that one of the adult-learning compliance factors is the reality factor and
immediate use of whatever it is presented as training. Not being compliant with their real-life post-training cases,
an activity ends in being lacked of interest. Avatars have their importance as well as the other characters in the
game, especially with adults, for a raised reality-factor challenge as well as for a better engagement triggered by
this.
As far as the syllabus is concerned this game has been well embedded thematically, answering both the
objectives of the case study and the objectives of the lesson per se, objectives which had been previously
required in the general curriculum. However, at this stage games can only be embedded into syllabus provided
educators identify elements conducive to the learning contexts and learning objectives. More time and financial
resources, more open-mindedness is all required from the higher education staff. Nevertheless, since the first
steps from both the students’ and the tutor’s perspective have been taken successfully, more will surely follow.
In the context of the use of MetaVals in ESADE, the professor is not playing an important role in the process.
He supports the student when they require to answer content related questions in the face-to-face uses of the
game. In the context of asynchronic and distant use of the MetaVals, the professor is not required in the process
of integration of the game in the Virtual Learning Environment (VLE) Moodle. The students’ plays
autonomously to the game and has not yet used the forum to ask for additional information or share doubts on
the content of the game. MetaVals shows the results of the classification activity to the students just after
playing. For this reason, is not required for the professor to analyse the students’ answer and provide them with
feedback.
8. Students’ post-training vision over the effectiveness of a game-based –curriculum in
Spain and Romania
Students’ answers in the post-game feedback session on the use of MetaVals game for ESP purposes in Romania
have presented us with some interesting insights. The questionnaire submitted at the end of the game-training
session elicited both qualitative and quantitative indicators and used Likert scale.
Hence:
- Motivation was given by the fact that the game was experience based, that the difficulty level was well
balanced with respect to completing the challenges inside the game
- As far as relevance for the job was concerned the answers for all the students were 3 on a Likert scale, while
the correspondence between their job description and skills employed in training had a different feedback
from user to user, given their different positions in the work-place.
When they were asked to give comments on the game, they stated that they liked the idea of gamifying the
learning activity, they liked competition and the combination between cognitive and soft skills employed in
solving the task. 90% of them would rather attend this kind of blended training, where some of the activities are
gamified, due to the novelty factor, due to the possibility of self-assessment and challenge, due to the idea of
entertainment within an otherwise strict learning context.
13 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
8.1 Using games for self assessing knowledge
Serious Games, as an active learning methodology, aims to place the learner in a central role (Oblinger, 2004).
These educational activities can be used for improving students’ self-assesment. In particular, MetaVals is a SG
that allows students to practice previously acquired knowledge on their own. This is achieved through three
different factors; first, the possibility of playing the collaborative phases with a virtual peer. This characteristic
allows players to access and play the SG both online and asynchronously. Secondly, MetaVals was designed
with a virtual teacher character that aims to pedagogically scaffold the players’ advance screen by screen. With
this virtual role, the students need little guidance from the teacher during the game play activity. Finally, the fact
that pre-test and post-tests are also implemented and are easily accessible from the game application could help
students in self-assessing their process before, during, and after the game play. Nevertheless, a debriefing session
is recommended when playing MetaVals, as it could help students reflect on the process, and share doubts on the
game results.
In the context of adult learning this method has an added value in itelf as assessment with adults poses some
sensitive issues with respect to leading postions back at work place, ranks - for the defence education-
hierarchical culture, fear of failure. By performing an in-game assessment the results are communicated in a low
profile and by collaborative learning the burden of being held responsible for one's answers is shared, while
team-work values are promoted and strengthened.
8.2 Using serious games out of the classroom
Nowadays, teachers claim for IT resources readily available; if SGs are used as technologies for learning and
teaching, teachers need resources to be accessible in order to simplify their implementation, and to help possible
overcome class limitations (Becker, 2007). When thinking of using SGs out of the classroom, there are some key
aspects that need to be studied. A SG used by the learner must be accessible online. MetaVals is web-based, and
it can be played online, with the only requirement that the teacher has to previously release the users into the
game engine. This step is also important as a security issue: only students engaged in a class can access the
game. As out of class activities, as homework, it needs clear instructions from the teacher. In the case of a SG,
these instructions can be given by the game, and students can follow the activity on their own. MetaVals, as seen
in the previous section, allows a high personalization of each game-play, and, if needed, it can present a virtual
teacher that guides the student throughout all the screens of the game to make this SG able to be played out of
the classroom too. On the other hand, in class, this role can be played by the teacher or tutor who explains the
game phases step by step to the students. These personalization choices allow practitioners to use the game in
different learning situations (Romero, Usart, Popescu & Boyle, 2012), and therefore help students engage in
active learning activities both in and out of the classroom.
9. Conclusions and steps ahead
The use of the Serious Game MetaVals in the context of the case study perofrmed within Carol I NDU- Romania
and the regular use of MetaVals in ESADE has achieved the learning objectives for each of the contexts, not
only in terms of the balances in finance but also in the English for Special Purpose, developed through playing
the game. In terms of the learning experience, there is room for improvement in the management of the prior
knowledge asymmetries between the dyads.
Also, the deployment of serious games in defence education, into areas that involve more than tactics and
strict military operations, such as trans-disciplinary and interdisciplinary contexts in the applied linguistics
modules, strategy, communication and leadership and even teacher trainer are optimistically seen as viable and
with many chances of successful uptake, provided the methodology is made well-known and teachers get
familiarized with the fruits such an approach bear on the learning effectiveness, while pedagogical approaches
will make formal education more engaging and boost its effectiveness (Arnab S.et al.- 2012), provided both
teachers and students drop the barrier of reluctance and embrace the road successfully lying ahead for most of
us-Technology-Enhanced-Learning.
References: Arnab,S., Berta R. , Earp J., de Freitas S., Popescu M., Romero M., Stanescu I., Usart I. (2012). Framing the Adoption of
Serious Games in Formal Education. Electronic Journal of e-Learning, Academic Publishing Limited, pp159‑171
Becker, K. (2007). Digital game-based learning once removed: teaching teachers. British Journal of Educational Technology,
38 (3), 478-488.Davis, F. D. (1986) A Technology Acceptance Model for Empirically Testing New End-User Information
Systems: Theory and Results, Unpublished Doctoral dissertation, Sloan School of Management, Massachusetts Institute
of Technology.
14 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1991). Flow: The psychology of optimal experience. New York: Harper Collins.
de Freitas, S., Rebolledo-Mendez, G., Liarokapis, F. Magoulas, G. & Poulovassilis A. (2010). Learning as immersive
experiences: using the four dimensional framework for designing and evaluating immersive learning experiences in a
virtual world. British Journal of Educational Technology, 41(1), 69-85.
Foreman, J. (2003). Next-Generation Educational Technology versus the Lecture. Educause Review, 38(4), 12.
Kim, B., Park, H. & Baek, Y. (2009). Not just fun, but serious strategies: Using meta-cognitive strategies in game-based
learning. Computers and Education, 52(4), 800 810.
Kirriemuir, J., & McFarlane, A. (2004). Report 8: Literature review in games and learning. Futurelab Series.
Kong, S.C., Ogata, H., Arnseth, H.C., Chan, C.K.K., Hirashima, T., Klett, F., Lee, J.H.M., Liu, C.C., Looi, C.K., Milrad, M.,
Mitrovic, A., Nakabayashi, K., Wong, S.L., Yang, S.J.H. (eds.) (2009). Proceedings of the 17th International
Conference on Computers in Education. Hong Kong: Asia-Pacific Society for Computers in Education.
Leemkuil, H., de Jong, T., de Hoog, R. & Christoph, N. (2003). KM Quest: A Collaborative Internet-Based Simulation
Game. Simulation & Gaming, 34(1), 89–111.
Massons, J., Romero, M., Usart, M., Mas, S., Padrós, A. & Almirall, E. (2011). Uso del aprendizaje basado en juegos en la
formación de finanzas para no financieros. Actas de las Jornadas Interuniversitarias de Innovación Docente. Universitat
Ramon Llull, DEUSTO, ICADE, 16-17 June, Barcelona.
Oblinger, D. (2004). The next generation of educational engagement. Journal of Interactive Media in Education, 8.
Padrós, A. Romero, M. & Usart, M. (2011). Developing serious Games: Form Face-to-Face to a Computer-based Modality.
E-learning papers, 25, 15-07-2011.
Prensky, M. (2002). The motivation of gameplay: The real twenty-first century learning revolution. On the Horizon, 10,(1),
5-11.
Romero, M., Usart, M., Almirall, E. (2011). Serious games in a finance course promoting the knowledge group awareness.
EDULEARN11 Proceedings, pp. 3490-3492.
Romero, M., Usart, M., Popescu, M., & Boyle, E. (2012). Interdisciplinary an international adaption and personalization of
the MetaVals Serious Games. The Third International Conference on Serious Games Development and Applications
SGDA 2012, 26-29 Sep, University of Bremen, Germany.
Shapiro, M. A. Pena-Herborn, J., Hancock, J. T.: Realism, imagination and narrative video games. In: Playing Video Games:
Motives, Responses, and Consequences. Eds: Vorderer, P., & Bryant, J. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
(2006).
Srikant D., Garvin, D., & Cullen, P. (2010). Rethinking the MBA, Business Education at a Crossroads. Boston: Harvard
Business Press,
Tao, Y.-H., Cheng, C.-J. & Sun, S.-Y. (2009). What influences college students to continue using business simulation games?
The Taiwan experience. Computers and Education, 53(3), 929-939.
Usart, M., Romero, M. & Almirall, E. (2011). Impact of the Feeling of Knowledge explicitation in the learners’ participation
and performance in a collaborative Game Based Learning activity. International Conference on Serious Games
Development and Applications Springer LNCS proceedings, Lisbon.
Yusoff, A., Crowder, R., Gilbert, L. (2010). Validation of serious games attributes using the technology acceptance model.
Proceedings of 2010 second international conference on games and virtual worlds for serious applications (45-51).
Braga, Portugal.
Zyda, M. 2005. From visual simulation to virtual reality to games. IEEE computer, 38(9), 30–34.
A Brief Author Biography
Dr. Maria Magdalena Popescu- is an associate professor within the Foreign Languages Department at the Carol I National
Defence University in Bucharest, Romania. With an ESL major and a Master of Arts in British Cultural Studies, she obtained
her Ph.D. in Humanities with a trans-disciplinary approach – psychoanalytical criticism of the British Novel. She currently
focuses on English for Specific Purposes in the field of security, crisis management, geopolitics, strategy and tactics, as well
as financial, communication and military terminology for adult education. One of the initiators of the military English
blended learning courses in the Romanian military, she has lately turned to research in the technology-enhanced-learning
realm. She has authored more than 40 articles in national and international journals. She has attended conferences both as a
moderator and a reviewer, acted in scientific committees on topics covering both foreign languages, culture and civilization,
but also eLearning and Serious Games. She has authored 7 books, and co-edited 1 to be published in IGI Global in 2013, she
participated in two European funded projects and three national ones on eLearning, mobile learning and serious games. As a
linguist she has also developed standardized tests for NATO linguistic evaluation and assessed speaking competency for the
deployable military, based on NATO standardized agreement profile.
Dr. Margarida Romero- holds an European Ph.D. in Psychology by UMR CNRS (France) and Universitat Autonoma de
Barcelona (Extraordinary Ph.D. Award in Psychology). She is an Associate Director of E-learning in ESADE Law &
Business School and associate professor of psychology in UAB and e-learning in UOC. Awarded with the 3rd price on
Technology Transfer from the EU NoE Kaleidoscope in 2007, and the 1st price of the Artificial Intelligence French
Association Award in 2006. Her research aims to advance the understanding of the time factor in Computer Supported
Collaborative Learning in the contexts of online learning and Serious Games. In particular, she is interested in how students,
in long-term collective learning tasks, perceive, allocate and regulate their learning times at the individual and group level.
Her dissertation research focused on the study of collective time management difficulties expressed by adult freshmen in
online Computer-Supported Collaborative e-Learning (CSCL) and Project-Oriented Learning (POL) situations. As a
15 International Journal of Computer Science Research and Application, 3(1): 05-15
consultant, she worked during the last 10 years on counseling international academic and professional organizations in
educational projects (ITIN University in Paris, IUFM French Guyana, Educational Ministry of Algeria, IQPC Brazil…) and
she is also leading the Euro-CAT-CSCL research project within the FP7 Marie Curie IAPP actions
PhDC- Mireia Usart- a junior researcher, she has a degree in physical sciences, a Master of Science in education and ICT,
and is currently a first year PhD student at the Open University of Catalonia (UOC). Post‐graduate course “Pedagogical
aptitude program”. Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (UPC). Simultaneously, she is collaborating with ESADE in
Barcelona, where she works with Dr. Margarida Romero at the Direction of Educational Innovation and Academic Quality
(DIPQA). She has worked as a freelance trainer in high education workshops “2.0 Educational tools and Skills” and as a
mathematics teacher in different institutions: Institut Joan Maragall (Barcelona), Acadèmia Carme Benet (Molins de Rei),
Acadèmia ‘The Castle” (Hospitalet de Llobregat), and her area of interest spins around ICT skills training,Web 2.0,
eLearning.
Copyright for articles published in this journal is retained by the authors, with first publication rights granted to the journal. By the
appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use with the required attribution. Users must contact the corresponding authors
for any potential use of the article or its content that affects the authors’ copyright.