1
Advisory Statement
Professor Lim’s PowerPoint presentations are optimized for the Mac (OS X).
Windows-based PC users may find some or all of the slides unviewable due to formatting incompatibilities. These
slides have not been tested on Vista.
This presentation is the intellectual property of Professor Timothy C. Lim • Most images, pictures and charts are from third
party sources
POLS 459 Politics of POLS 459 Politics of East AsiaEast Asia
China’s Economic RiseChina’s Economic Rise
Regional and Global Regional and Global ImplicationsImplications
Professor Timothy C. LimProfessor Timothy C. Lim
California State University, Los AngelesCalifornia State University, Los Angeles
[email protected]@calstatela.edu
Last slide
3
“The rise of China as a major player in the capitalist world economy is likely to become one of the most significant developments in the first half of the 21st century”
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
There probably would be little or no debate from anyone about this statement,
but there would be a great deal of debate about implications of China’s economic rise, both regional and
globally …
There probably would be little or no debate from anyone about this statement,
but there would be a great deal of debate about implications of China’s economic rise, both regional and
globally …
4
The Rise of China: ImplicationsSome scholars, such as Nanto and Chanlett-Avery focus primarily on the military-strategic, diplomatic and (narrow) economic implications. They ask questions such as …
How will China’s growth reoriented international trade patterns?
Will Chinese development lead to greater interdependence and regional cooperation?
Will a richer China try to dominate the region and theworld?
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
5
The Rise of China: ImplicationsOther scholars, such as Minqi Li, focus on the deeper, structural implications of China’s rapid development. They ask such questions as …
How is China’s internal structure likely to evolve as China
assumes different positions in the existing world system?
Will China’s rise “save” or “destabilize” the global system?
Can China replace the United States as global hegemonic
power?
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
Let’s focus on this set of questions
Let’s focus on this set of questions
6
The Rise of China: Larger ContextTo properly assess the implications of China’s rise, according to Li, we must understand the larger context within which China’s ascendance is taking place
This “larger context” is a concept about which we are already familiar …
Neoliberalism
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
7
The Rise of China: Larger ContextUnder neoliberalism, contradictory processes take place in the system of global capitalism
Neoliberal policies put downward pressure on wages in
order to maximize profit
Global capitalism requires constantly increasing consumption
in order to maintain system equilibrium
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
Resolving this contradiction is not easy, but one way the global economy has been able to avoid a full-scale downward spiral is through the actions of a hegemonic power: for most the postwar period, the US has played this role by pumping demand into the global economy through huge and rising deficits
…
Resolving this contradiction is not easy, but one way the global economy has been able to avoid a full-scale downward spiral is through the actions of a hegemonic power: for most the postwar period, the US has played this role by pumping demand into the global economy through huge and rising deficits
…
8
The Rise of China: Larger Context
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
This chart illustrates the increasing level
and scale of deficit spending
in the United States. Starting
off at about $500 million in
1940, the accumulated
national debt is now (in 2007) more than $9
trillion in in real terms,
about $30,000 for every man, woman and child
in the U.S.
9
The Rise of China: Larger Context
Deficit spending by the global hegemon, however, is inherently unsustainable: for
the world economy to resume sustained, long-term expansion, global effective demand must
have a more stable base
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
geographicHistorically, the key
base has been _________________
expansion, which allows access to new reserves
of cheap labor and natural resources, and
new markets for consumption
10
The Rise of China: Larger ContextIn one respect, then, China represent the last major geographic source of expansion for global capitalism
China’s economic rise, therefore, raises China’s economic rise, therefore, raises the question: the question: Can the existing world Can the existing world system (and humanity) survive without the system (and humanity) survive without the rise of China?rise of China?
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
How does Li answer this question?How does Li answer this question?
11
The Rise of China: Different ScenariosBasic answer: It depends.
Li gives us 4 different scenariosLi gives us 4 different scenarios
Significantly, though, underlying Significantly, though, underlying his scenarios is another question, his scenarios is another question, namely …namely …
“Can the existing world system survive with the rise of China?”
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
12
The Rise of China: Different ScenariosThe Four Scenarios
China may fail (to rise)……………………………..
China rises, but in so doing “peripheralizes” the
rest of the semiperiphery ………………………….
China rises, but in so doing it catches up with other semiperipheral states in terms of wages …..
China rises, which has an uneven impact on between-country inequality ………………………
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
1.1.2.2.
3.3.
4.4.
What are the implications of each scenario?What are the implications of each scenario?
13
The Rise of China: ConvergenceKey points from the four scenarios
None of the four scenarios is particularly promising
The basic reason: China’s rise will have a necessary impact on the internal dynamics of the system--this is largely a product of the sheer economic size of China, which has a labor force larger than the total labor force of all core states combined or of the entire semiperiphery
China’s huge size, therefore, will necessarily bring a process of convergence, either upward or downward: Neither is good
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
14
The Rise of China: ConvergenceQuestion: So, what’s the problem with convergence?
Downward convergence: Puts downward pressure on wage levels in the rest of the semiperiphery, which could deprive the capitalist world-economy of major source of effective demand; the “peripheralization” of the semiperiphery also threatenspolitical stability
Upward convergence (of Chinese wages): Reducesthe total surplus available for the rest of world; profitrates are reduced, competition increases, growthin many economies will come to a grinding halt
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
15
The Rise of China: Other ImplicationsEven if the problem
convergence is overcome, another problem remains …
The “rise of China” in the sense of China increasingly becoming the center of world capitalist industrialization, is likely to place increasingly greater pressure on the ________________________.
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
global environment
16
The Rise of China: Other Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
This short segment from CNN provides a general, but telling overview of the environmental threat China’s development poses, both to China and the rest of the worldFrom YouTube
Video intentionally removedClick on YouTube link to view
video online
17
The Rise of China: Summing Up
China’s economic rise has serious, but paradoxical implications
Paradoxically, the world-capitalist system “needs” China as the last major outpost of global expansion, but China’s rise could also threaten the stability and ultimately the survivability of the system as a whole
Still others see China’s rise as a potential strategic and politico-economy threat, and, in particular, as a threat to American dominance
Not everyone agrees, of course. Mainstream economists and other liberal scholars generally applaud China’s economic rise: it represents the triumph of capitalism and last big step towards the “end of history”
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications
China’s Economic RiseRegional and Global Implications