1111
CEQA ScopingCEQA Scoping
Naomi FegerNaomi Feger
Planning TMDL Section LeaderPlanning TMDL Section LeaderRegion 2Region 2
2222
Today’s PresentationToday’s Presentation
Purpose of CEQA ScopingPurpose of CEQA Scoping Benefits of ScopingBenefits of Scoping When to scope?When to scope? Public Notice of scoping sessionPublic Notice of scoping session Conducting the scoping meetingConducting the scoping meeting Meeting management Meeting management
3333
Purpose of ScopingPurpose of Scoping
Scoping is required for projects of Scoping is required for projects of “statewide, regional or area-wide “statewide, regional or area-wide significance.” significance.” (CEQA (CEQA §§21083)21083)
Invite public input Invite public input earlyearly in the process – in the process – head off future problems head off future problems
Solicit comments on the scope of our Solicit comments on the scope of our environmental analysisenvironmental analysis
4444
Benefits of ScopingBenefits of Scoping
Opportunity to inform the stakeholders Opportunity to inform the stakeholders about Project about Project
Helps to identify range of actions, Helps to identify range of actions, alternatives, mitigation measures, alternatives, mitigation measures, and significant effects to be analyzed and significant effects to be analyzed
Incorporate modifications early to Incorporate modifications early to resolve potential problemsresolve potential problems
5555
When to Scope?When to Scope? ““As early as possible” As early as possible” (Guidelines §15083)(Guidelines §15083) When you can present and discussWhen you can present and discuss
Project objectivesProject objectives Draft Project description Draft Project description Reasonably foreseeable compliance measures Reasonably foreseeable compliance measures
i.e., potential implementation requirements – i.e., potential implementation requirements – specific actions or measures specific actions or measures
Reasonable alternatives Reasonable alternatives For TMDLs, generally at Project Report stageFor TMDLs, generally at Project Report stage
6666
Noticing the Scoping MeetingNoticing the Scoping Meeting
Notify as broadly as feasibleNotify as broadly as feasible At least 30 days notice suggestedAt least 30 days notice suggested Publish notice for one day in an Publish notice for one day in an
“appropriate newspaper”“appropriate newspaper” Notice by mail and email Notice by mail and email Post on websitePost on website
7777
And the Notice Goes To…And the Notice Goes To…
All interested partiesAll interested parties Organizations or individuals who filed Organizations or individuals who filed
written requests for noticewritten requests for notice
AND AND Everyone elseEveryone else
Any responsible agencyAny responsible agency Any public agency with legal jurisdiction Any public agency with legal jurisdiction
related to the projectrelated to the project
8888
Conducting the Scoping Conducting the Scoping MeetingMeeting
9999
Conducting the Scoping Conducting the Scoping MeetingMeeting
Take advantage of the meeting to combine it Take advantage of the meeting to combine it with a public workshop with a public workshop
Make clear distinction between public workshop Make clear distinction between public workshop and CEQA scoping and CEQA scoping
Options for meeting recordOptions for meeting record Audio recordingAudio recording Meeting notes or summaryMeeting notes or summary Court reporter and transcriptCourt reporter and transcript
10101010
Conducting the Scoping Conducting the Scoping Meeting Meeting
Manage expectations by clarifying the Manage expectations by clarifying the purpose of the meeting:purpose of the meeting: Explain the project and the steps in the Explain the project and the steps in the
process process Explain our obligation under CEQA Explain our obligation under CEQA Hear stakeholders’ comments, concerns, and Hear stakeholders’ comments, concerns, and
ideas – not debate issues or make decisionsideas – not debate issues or make decisions Review agenda and meeting ground rulesReview agenda and meeting ground rules
11111111
Prompting DiscussionPrompting Discussion The more concrete information you provide, the The more concrete information you provide, the
better the discussion will bebetter the discussion will be Take time to explain CEQA requirements and Take time to explain CEQA requirements and
process, including terminology e.g.,process, including terminology e.g., Significant and potentially significant impactsSignificant and potentially significant impacts mitigation mitigation cumulative impactscumulative impacts
Ask for inputAsk for input““Do you foresee any significant or potentially significant Do you foresee any significant or potentially significant
adverse environmental impacts?”adverse environmental impacts?”
12121212
Meeting ManagementMeeting Management
Be clear about how staff will use/honor Be clear about how staff will use/honor commentscomments Explain that we’re not required to respond in Explain that we’re not required to respond in
writing, but staff will consider comments as we writing, but staff will consider comments as we develop the environmental analysis develop the environmental analysis
Identify time frame for submission of Identify time frame for submission of comments, provide staff contact info comments, provide staff contact info
Note comments on flip chart; ALSO take Note comments on flip chart; ALSO take notes on a laptop, or bring a note-takernotes on a laptop, or bring a note-taker
13131313
Depending on Your Stakeholders…Depending on Your Stakeholders…
Depending on the stage of your project, level of controversy, Depending on the stage of your project, level of controversy, time/resource constraints and public interest…time/resource constraints and public interest…
You may choose to You may choose to Develop a stakeholder involvement planDevelop a stakeholder involvement plan Consider using a facilitator (neutral moderator/ WB staff)Consider using a facilitator (neutral moderator/ WB staff) Format your official notice formally or informally Format your official notice formally or informally Present a blank or a draft checklistPresent a blank or a draft checklist Present draft alternativesPresent draft alternatives
14141414
Potential Meeting HandoutsPotential Meeting Handouts
Basin Planning/TMDL flowchart or other Basin Planning/TMDL flowchart or other simple, helpful handoutsimple, helpful handout
Preliminary project report or description Preliminary project report or description of proposed activityof proposed activity
Blank or draft checklistBlank or draft checklist List of alternatives identified to date List of alternatives identified to date
(optional)(optional) List of references relied on for research to List of references relied on for research to
date; websites, staff contactsdate; websites, staff contacts
15151515
Take Home MessageTake Home Message
Emphasize and re-emphasize that Board Emphasize and re-emphasize that Board decisions have not been made, and public decisions have not been made, and public input will be input will be consideredconsidered Prominently mark all materials “DRAFT”Prominently mark all materials “DRAFT” Note CEQA’s requirement to evaluate an actual Note CEQA’s requirement to evaluate an actual
project, not just an idea…project, not just an idea…
No requirement to respond to all comments No requirement to respond to all comments
16161616
Scoping SummaryScoping Summary
Scoping provides valuable input Scoping provides valuable input Local conditionsLocal conditions Stakeholder concerns - early in processStakeholder concerns - early in process
First formal step in CEQA – opportunity to First formal step in CEQA – opportunity to get project on good footingget project on good footing
Manage expectations – communicate Manage expectations – communicate meeting objectives clearlymeeting objectives clearly
17171717
Questions?Questions?