2
OutlineOutline
Introduction: To what extent is religion a basis for morality?
The Divine Command Theory
The Natural Law Theory
Conclusion: Religion and Morality
3
OutlineOutline
Introduction: To what extent is religion a basis for morality?
Introduction: To what extent is religion a basis for morality?
The Divine Command Theory
The Natural Law Theory
Conclusion: Religion and Morality
4
IntroductionIntroductionReligion as a foundation of moralityReligion as a foundation of morality
Our problem: Moral truths
1. Are there such things as moral truths?
2. How do we know them and what is their content?
One answer: Religion
1. Yes: God’s law
- As God’s creation, the world is in order – God’s law.
- Human beings and their acts are part of such order.
- Humans beings ought to follow the moral law in their actions.
2. We must find out God’s law.
5
IntroductionIntroductionMorality and ReligionMorality and Religion
The problem:
- Not all religious people act morally – religion not sufficient for moral behavior
- Not all non-religious people act immorally – religion not necessary
The relationships between morality and religion are more complex than expected
The relationships between morality and religion are more complex than expected
Our question: to what extent can religion be a foundation for morality?
Our question: to what extent can religion be a foundation for morality?
6
OutlineOutline
Introduction
The Divine Command TheoryThe Divine Command Theory
The Natural Law Theory
Conclusion: Religion and Morality
7
The Divine Command Theory The Divine Command Theory
The Divine Command Theory (DCT):
The Divine Command Theory is the view on morality that what is right is whatever God commands.
This gives answers to our questions:
1. Are there such things as moral truths?
Yes, God’s law
2. How do we know them and what is their content?
We know them through religion, and their content are whatever our religion says it is.
8
The Problem with the DCT: The Problem with the DCT: Socrates’ questionSocrates’ question
Socrates’ question about the definition of “what is holy”:
Euthyphro: what is holy is whatever is loved by the gods
Socrates: is it holy because it is loved by the gods or is it loved by the gods because it is holy?
Socrates’ answer: it is loved by the gods because it is holy – not the other way.
Socrates’ answer: it is loved by the gods because it is holy – not the other way.
9
The Problem with the DCT: The Problem with the DCT: Understanding Socrates’ questionUnderstanding Socrates’ question
Socrates’ question about the definition of “what is a great hike”:
Euthyphro: what is a great hike is whatever is loved by the Montanans.
Socrates: is it a great hike because it is loved by the Montanans or is it loved by the Montanans because it is a great hike?
Socrates’ answer: it is loved by the Montanans because it is a great hike– not the other way
around.
Socrates’ answer: it is loved by the Montanans because it is a great hike– not the other way
around.
10
The Problem with the DCT: The Problem with the DCT: Socrates’ question applied to the DCTSocrates’ question applied to the DCT
Socrates’ question about the definition of “what is right”:
Euthyphro: what is right is whatever is whatever God commands
Socrates: is it right because God commands it or does God command it because it is right?
Socrates’ answer: it is commanded by God because it is right – not the other way
around.
Socrates’ answer: it is commanded by God because it is right – not the other way
around.
11
The Problem with the DCT: The Problem with the DCT: One last exampleOne last example
Socrates’ question about the definition of “what is good for your education”:
Euthyphro: what is good for your education is whatever is whatever your parents command
Socrates: is it good for your education because your parents command it or do your parents command it because it is good for your education ?
Socrates’ answer: it is commanded by your parents because it is good for your
education – not the other way around.
Socrates’ answer: it is commanded by your parents because it is good for your
education – not the other way around.
12
The Divine Command Theory:The Divine Command Theory:Two interpretationsTwo interpretations
Interpretation 1:
Something is right because God commands it
Interpretation 2:
God commands something because it is right
Interpretation 1:
Good for your education because your parents
command it
Interpretation 2:
Commanded by your parents because good for your
education
Mere AuthorityMere Authority Knowledgeable guideKnowledgeable guide
13
The Divine Command Theory:The Divine Command Theory:Interpretation 1 – Pros and ConsInterpretation 1 – Pros and Cons
Interpretation 1:
Something is right because God commands it
PROS:
- There are moral truths
- These truths are easy to find: Follow the Scriptures as an absolute authority
CONS:
- Moral truths are arbitrary
- How to understand the Scriptures when ambiguous or outdated?
14
The Divine Command Theory:The Divine Command Theory:Interpretation 2 – Pros and ConsInterpretation 2 – Pros and Cons
Interpretation 2:
God commands something because it is right
PROS:
- There are moral truths
- These truths are not arbitrary
CONS:
Moral truths exist independently of religion / God
We need another foundation!
15
The Divine Command Theory The Divine Command Theory ConclusionConclusion
The Divine Command Theory:The Divine Command Theory is the view on
morality that what is right is whatever God commands.
Socrates’ question: Is it right because God’s commands it or does
God command it because it is rightTwo interpretations: 1. Right because God commands itProblem: Arbitrariness of moral truths2. Commanded by God because it is rightProblem: need for another foundation
The Divine Command Theory:The Divine Command Theory is the view on
morality that what is right is whatever God commands.
Socrates’ question: Is it right because God’s commands it or does
God command it because it is rightTwo interpretations: 1. Right because God commands itProblem: Arbitrariness of moral truths2. Commanded by God because it is rightProblem: need for another foundation
16
OutlineOutline
Introduction
The Divine Command Theory
The Natural Law TheoryThe Natural Law Theory
Conclusion: Religion and Morality
17
The Natural Law TheoryThe Natural Law TheoryThe Natural Law and the CosmosThe Natural Law and the Cosmos
The idea of the cosmos:
- Cosmos: the world in rational order – natural law
- Humans: gifted with reason to understand the law
- Morality: understand and follow the natural law
Aquinas: Reason = “the imprint of divine light” on us
Aquinas: Reason = “the imprint of divine light” on us
The Natural Law Theory
The Natural Law Theory is the view that what is right is governed by the natural law, which reflects the rational order of the world.
18
The Natural Law TheoryThe Natural Law TheoryMorality and UsMorality and Us
Humans vs. Animals
- Only humans can follow the law voluntarily – will
- Only humans can understand the law – reason
Believers vs Non-believers
All humans can understand and follow the law, believers or not, because all humans possess reason and will
To what extend is religion a foundation of moral truths?
- The rational order is the ultimate foundation
- But Religion gives us the assurance that the world is in a rational order
19
The Natural Law TheoryThe Natural Law TheoryMoral TruthsMoral Truths
How can we understand the law?
- Same as mathematics (Euclid)
- Rational intuition + logical reasoning
What does the law provide us?
- General guiding principles for our motives/intentions
- NOT specific acts for particular circumstances
- Ex: “good entrusted to another should be restored to their owner”
20
The Natural Law Theory The Natural Law Theory ConclusionConclusion
The Natural Law Theory: what is right is governed by the natural law, which reflects the rational order of the world.Common aspects between the NLT and the DCT - There are moral truths- We can know themDifference between the NLT and the DCT:- Use of reason necessary - All humans - Only guidelines – not particular casesThe NLT: what does religion give us? Rational order of the world
The Natural Law Theory: what is right is governed by the natural law, which reflects the rational order of the world.Common aspects between the NLT and the DCT - There are moral truths- We can know themDifference between the NLT and the DCT:- Use of reason necessary - All humans - Only guidelines – not particular casesThe NLT: what does religion give us? Rational order of the world
21
OutlineOutline
Introduction: Is religion a necessary basis for morality?
The Divine Command Theory: 2 interpretations
The Natural Law Theory
Conclusion: Religion and MoralityConclusion: Religion and Morality
22
Morality and ReligionMorality and Religion
Our problem: Moral truths1. Are there such things as moral truths? 2. How do we know them and what is their
content? An answer: Religion But how?1. Divine Command Theory: - Socrates’ question: two interpretations- Interpretation 1: moral truths arbitrary- Interpretation 2: need for another foundation2. Natural Law Theory- Reason as the ultimate foundation of moral
truths- Religion as the guarantee of the rational order
of the world
Our problem: Moral truths1. Are there such things as moral truths? 2. How do we know them and what is their
content? An answer: Religion But how?1. Divine Command Theory: - Socrates’ question: two interpretations- Interpretation 1: moral truths arbitrary- Interpretation 2: need for another foundation2. Natural Law Theory- Reason as the ultimate foundation of moral
truths- Religion as the guarantee of the rational order
of the world