8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
1/24
Why Ethics in Business?
Dr. Raghavendra Rao
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
2/24
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
3/24
Thus, none of the arguments for keeping ethicsout ofbusiness seems forceful.
In contrast, there are fairly strong arguments
for bringing ethics into business.
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
4/24
Arguments for ethics
One argument points out that since ethics shouldgovern all human activity, there is no reason to exemptbusiness activity from ethical scrutiny.
Another more developed argument points out that noactivity, business included, could be carried out in anethical vacuum.
One interesting argument actually claims that ethicalconsiderations are consistent with business activitiessuch as the pursuit of profit. Indeed, the argumentclaims that ethical companies are more profitable thanother companies.
Most interesting is the Prisoners Dilemma
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
5/24
Prisoners Dilemma
Is a situation in which two parties are each faced with achoice between two options: Either cooperate with theother party or do not cooperate.
Ifboth parties cooperate, they will both gain somebenefit.
Ifboth choose not to cooperate, neither gets thebenefit.
If one cooperates while the other chooses not to
cooperate, the one who cooperates suffers a loss whilethe one who chooses not to cooperate gains a benefit.
The prisoner's dilemma demonstrates that cooperationis more advantageous
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
6/24
Unethical practices (Internal)
Managers lying to employees Nepotism and favoritism Taking credit for others work Receiving or offering kick backs Stealing from the company Firing an employee for whistle blowing Padding expense accounts Divulging confidential information/trade secrets
Terminating employment without giving sufficientnotice Using companys property and material for personal
use
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
7/24
Unethical practices (External)
No transparency in dealings
No accountability to stakeholders
Not honoring the contracts Supplying faulty/outdated technology and
services at a very high cost
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
8/24
Unethical practices (Environmental)
Buying natural resources and goods fromdeveloping economies at a cheaper price
Exploiting services and labour of developingcountries.
Exploit natural resources of developingcountries (hamburgerization ofAmazonian
forests)
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
9/24
Ethics means money!
Acting legally and ethically means saving billions of
dollars each year from law suits, settlements and
theft
Work place theft in US costs 40 billion $ each year
Costs to business also include:
Deterioration of relationships
Declining productivity, creativity, loyalty, absenteeism Difficulty recruiting and retaining valued professionals
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
10/24
Morality and Ethics in international
context
how they are to be applied in foreign
countries is more complex.
Petty bribery, which is considered unethical inthe U.S., is a standard practice in Mexico and
other countries
Nepotism and sexism occur as a matter of
course in some Arabic business environments.
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
11/24
Ethical Dilemmas
Should multinationals follow the laws of theless developed countries in which theyoperate?
Should they try to introduce their ownstandards?
How do they treat their own employees doing
the same job in two very different countries? Do they pay them the same wage?
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
12/24
Issues
1. What does the action really mean in the localculture's context?
2. Does the action produce consequences that
are ethically acceptable from the point of view ofat least one of the four ethical theories?
3. Does the local government truly representthe will of all its people?
4. If the morally questionable action is acommon local practice, is it possible to conductbusiness there without engaging in it?
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
13/24
Systemic issues
Systemic issuesquestions raised about theeconomic, political, legal, or other socialsystems within which businesses operate.
These include questions about the moralityof capitalism or of the laws, regulations,industrial structures, and social practiceswithin which businesses operate.
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
14/24
Corporate issues
Corporate issuesquestions raised about aparticular company.
These include questions about the morality ofthe activities,
policies,
practices, or organizational structure of an individual company
taken as a whole
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
15/24
Individual issues
Individual issuesquestions about aparticular individual within an organizationand their behaviors and decisions.
These include questions about the moralityof the
decisions,
actions, or character of an individual
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
16/24
Globalization and Business Ethics
Virtually all of the 500 largest U.S. industrial corporations today aremultinationals.
Operating in more than one country at once produces a new set ofethical dilemmas.
Multinationals can escape environmental regulations and labor lawsby shifting to another country, for example.
They can shift raw materials, goods, and capital so that they escapetaxes.
In addition, because they have new technologies and products thatless developed countries do not, multinationals must decide when a
particular country is ready to assimilate these new things. They are also faced with the different moral codes and laws of
different countries. Even if a particular norm is not unethical, theymust still decide between competing standards in their manyoperations.
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
17/24
Ethical relativism
Ethical relativism is the theory that, because
different societies have different ethical
beliefs, there is no rational way of determining
whether an action is morally right or wrong
other than by asking whether the people of
this or that society believe it to be right or
wrong
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
18/24
Finally, new technologies developed in the closing decades of the 20th century and
the opening years of the 21st century are again transforming society and business
and creating the potential for new ethical problems.
They bring with them questions of risks, which may be unpredictable and/or
irreversible.
Who should decide whether the benefits of a particular technology are worth the
risks?
How will victims ofbad technology be compensated for their loss?
How will risk be distributed?
How will privacy be maintained?
How will property rights be protected?
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
19/24
Moral blame
A person is NOT morally responsible for aninjury or a wrong if:
1. The person did not cause and could notprevent the injury or wrong;
2. The person did not know he was inflicting
the injury or the wrong; 3. The person did not inflict the injury or the
wrong of his own free will
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
20/24
Some theorists maintain that moral notions apply only to individuals, not to
corporations themselves.
Others counter that corporations do act like individuals, having objectives
and actions, which can be moral or immoral just as an individual's action
might be.
In 2002, for example, the Justice Department charged the accounting firm of
Arthur Andersen for obstruction ofjustice.
Arthur Andersen was caught shredding documents showing how they
helped Enron hide its debt through the use of several accounting tricks.
Critics afterward claimed that the Justice Department should have chargedthe individual employees ofArthur Andersen, not the company, because
"Companies don't commit crimes, people do."
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
21/24
Perhaps neither extreme view is correct.
Corporate actions do depend on human
individuals who should be held accountable
for their actions.
However, they also have policies and culture
that direct individuals, and should therefore
be held accountable for the effects of thesecorporate artifacts.
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
22/24
Mitigating factors
there are also three mitigating factors thatdiminish moral responsibility. They are:
1. Circumstances that leave a person uncertain(but not unsure) about what he or she is doing;
2. Circumstances that make it difficult (but notimpossible) for the person to avoid doing it;
3. Circumstances that minimize (but do notremove) a person's involvement in an act.
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
23/24
KFC in IndiaExxon valdez,
Coca cola in India,
Boeings unethical practices
The Tata Tea/ULFA story
The Bhopal gas tragedy
The T-Series storyThe McDonald's 'Beef Fries' Controversy
The Recall of Vioxx
Johnson & Johnson Tylenol controversy
Childhood Obesity: Should Junk Food be
Regulated?
Rio Tinto: The Mining Giant PollutesIndonesia's Environment
Fall ofArthur Andersen, the accounting firm
8/7/2019 2 Why Ethics in Business
24/24
Reebok - Managing Human Rights Issues 'Ethically?'
Kmart - Forced Towards Bankruptcy?Nestles infant formula controversy
Microsoft playing monopoly
GlaxoSmithKline, Bristol-Myers Squibb and AIDS in Africa
Ford/Firestone controversy
Ethical issues in BPOs in India
The bribery scandal in Siemens AG
De-nocils bribery case
BT cotton controversy
Foreign patenting of domestic products
Retail chains in fruits and vegetables
Child labour in the sandstone industry
Harshad Mehta and Indian financial scam
Marketing of Fairness Creams and the Question of Ethics