Download - 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

3-Dimensional Modeling to 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Support the

Short North Design GuidelinesShort North Design GuidelinesMidterm PresentationMidterm Presentation

Duane Hoskins| Scott Ulrich| Krystina SchaeferDuane Hoskins| Scott Ulrich| Krystina SchaeferThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional PlanningThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional Planning

April 29, 2010April 29, 2010

Objective

• Develop a 3-D computerized model of the study area using Google Sketch-Up– analyze existing building massing and height transitions

• Use the model as an analysis tool– Understand and visualize potential impacts of future

development patterns

Model Development

• Use existing City of Columbus (GIS and AutoCAD data) of building footprints combined with data obtained from the Franklin County Auditor to create simple massing of existing buildings

• Add façade details and ornamentation to the masses • Put the completed model into Google Earth to understand

the the study area given the context of the surroundings

Current Conditions | Overview

Current Conditions | Overview

• Some long, complete historic blocks• Also a few smaller historic clusters• Isolated extremes, big & small• Suburban-style, strip-style retail• Bulky newer development

Long, complete historic blocks

Smaller historic clusters

Isolated extremes – big & small

Suburban-style, strip-style retail

Bulkier newer development

Next Steps

• Compare building heights to identify inconsistencies and buildings which are incompatible with the Short North design aesthetic

• Visualize development potential for selected sites

Short North Arts DistrictShort North Arts District

SketchUp Group - Final PresentationSketchUp Group - Final Presentation

Duane Hoskins| Krystina Schaefer| Scott UlrichDuane Hoskins| Krystina Schaefer| Scott UlrichThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional PlanningThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional Planning

May 25, 2010May 25, 2010

The Process

• 5 sites selected based on:– Low FAR– Surface Parking Lots– Large Setbacks

• Design considerations:– Parking Requirements– No Setbacks– Limit High Street Ingress

1

23

45

Redevelopment SitesRedevelopment Sites

Proposed Redevelopment Sites

1

23

45

1. United Dairy Farmers2. Shopping Center

High & PriceExisting

Site: 6 Parcels - Approx 70,000 ft2

1 Building – 11,570 ft2

FAR = 0.17

High & PriceRedevelopment Site

Redevelopment Plans:

Mixed Use – 6 Stories – 138,000 ft2

Residential – 2nd & 3rd Stories – 15,450 ft2

Public Plaza – 3,700 ft2

Parking Garage – 3 Stories – 66,760 ft2

Parking Required - 158 SpacesParking Provided - 204 Spaces

FAR=2.20 (not including parking garage)FAR=3.15 (including parking garage)



IBIZA - Existing

IBIZA – Proposed

11-story mixed use

Residential over retail

Buried parking garage

Looking North on High from Hubbard

Before & After

DiscussionDiscussion

Questions | Thank YouQuestions | Thank You