8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
1/28
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
2/28
Article 1
Restricted scope
OECD & UN MC identical, while US MC different
Heading changed to Persons Covered fromPersonal Scope
Earlier treaties applied to Citizens or taxpayers
ExceptionsNon discrimination, Exchange ofInformation
2-Nov-13 2
This Convention shall apply topersonswho areresidentsof one or both of the Contracting States.
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
3/28
Article 3(1)(a)Person
OECD Model: The term person includes anindividual, a company and any other body ofpersons.
Indian Judicial Precedents on person
2-Nov-13 3
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
4/28
Abdul Razak Meman* Issue
o Whether NRI residing in UAE entitled to Treaty in respect ofdividends, interest and capital gains
Assesseescontentionso Residence certificates of UAE authorities proof of residence
under Treaty
Rulingo Individual not a taxable unit under the UAE Decreeo expressions "resident of the other contracting State" not definedo Means a person residing, dwelling or having an abode in UAE or a
person staying regularly in UAEo For dividends/interest lower rate, residential status of the recipient
not relevanto For capital gains, assessee not a Treaty Subject, not entitled to
Treaty
*[2005] 146 TAXMAN 115 (AAR - NEW DELHI)
2-Nov-13 4
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
5/28
UAE Treaty
Article 3(1)Person (e) the term "person" includes an individual, a company, and any
other entity which is treated as a taxable unit under the taxation lawsin force in the respective Contracting States
Article 10 - Dividends1. Dividends paid by a company which is a resident of a
Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting Statemaybe taxed in that other State.
2.However, such dividends may also be taxed in the ContractingState of which the company paying the dividends is a resident andaccording to the laws of that State, butif the recipient is thebeneficial ownerof the dividends, the tax so charged shall not
exceed.. Article 13Capital Gains
3. Gains from the alienation of any property other than thatmentioned in paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be taxable only in theContracting State of which the alienator is a resident.
2-Nov-13 5
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
6/28
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
7/28
Person as per different DTAAs
India USA :the term person includes an individual, an estate,a trust, a partnership, a company, any other body of persons,or other taxable entity
India UK:the term person includes an individual, a
company and any other entity which is treated as a taxableunit under the taxation laws in force in the respectiveContracting States, but, subject to paragraph 2 of this Article,does not include a partnership;
2-Nov-13 7
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
8/28
Article 3(1)(a)
Which States law to apply?
Taxable Unit under the taxation laws of respectiveContracting States
Klaus Vogel on Persono Source State to classify a foreign entity as per its own tax laws regardless
of classification in its Home State.
o Source State will force foreign entity into one or the other category of
taxpayers based on
the foreign laws legal characteristics of the entity in order
the similarity of civil and commercial laws of the states concerned
2-Nov-13 8
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
9/28
Person - Case Study A Singapore Company establishes a branch in Philippines as a
Regional Headquarters (RHQ)to serve its Group in APAC regionunder the Omnibus Investment Code of 1987.
A RHQ can be established under the Code by a foreign company ora group of foreign companies. The RHQ is allowed to derive income
in the Philippines by performing some qualifying services for itsaffiliates, subsidiaries or branches in the Philippines, the Asia Pacificregion and other foreign markets.
The RHQ is treated as a Resident Foreign Corporation in Philippinesand is taxed @ 10% on its income.
RHQ derives income in the nature of fees for technical services fromIndia. Is the RHQ entitled to protection under India-Philippines Treaty?
2-Nov-13 9
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
10/28
Schellenberg Wittmer* (1/2)
Factso Switzerland based law firm, all partners Swiss residents.
o Under Swiss law, partnership not separate entity
o Partnership income assessed in the hands of the partners
Taxpayers argumentso A partnership a 'company' or 'body of persons'.o Actual taxation in Switzerland is not necessary; Switzerland has
the right to tax partnership.
o All partners resident in Switzerland, entire income taxed inSwitzerland
o
Fiscal domicile of the partnership lay in Switzerland .o OECD Comm Art 4 para 8.7 relied upon
Where partnership denied treaty, partners to be entitled
*[2012] 24 taxmann.com 299 (AAR - New Delhi)
2-Nov-13 10
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
11/28
Schellenberg Wittmer (2/2)
Art. 3(1)(d) Person in India-Swiss Treatyincludes an individual, a company, a body of persons, or anyother entity which is a taxable unitunder the laws in force ineitherContracting State
Rulingo receiver of income & person taxed not the same
o no definition of person in Swiss law
o If a body of individuals or any other entity is not a taxableentity in the concerned state, it will not be a person.
o India not accepted OECD Commentary that partnerships will
be considered as persons either as company or body ofpersons.
o Necessary that body of individuals is taxable in Switzerland
2-Nov-13 11
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
12/28
Linklaters LLP
Partnership Example: UK LLP established in UK. A & B, partners of
UK LLP, are residents of UK. UK LLP earns royalties from India. CanUK LLP access the India-UK Tax Treaty?
2-Nov-13 12
UKLLP
A B
UK India
FTS
Held Fact of taxation in the UK rather than its modality, relevant The entire income is liable to tax in the UK
Hence the recipient of income is treaty resident
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
13/28
Chiron Behring GmbH & Co.* (1/2)
Factso Assessee a limited partnership in Germany
o Partners taxed on income in Germany
o Assessee liable for trade tax
Revenues argumentso Trade tax a turnover tax not tax on income
o Assessee not liable to tax in Germany
o Assessee not entitled to Treaty
Assesseescontentionso Assessee liable to trade tax in Germany
o Trade tax covered under Art. 2
o Assessee entitled to Treaty
*[2008] 24 SOT 278 (MUM.)
2-Nov-13 13
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
14/28
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
15/28
2-Nov-13 15
Norsk,Bahamas
Crown Forest Industries*
CanadianIncome
US Branch
Ruling The basis of Norsksliability for taxation
in the United States emanates fromthefact that it conducts a trade or businesswhich is effectively connected with the USand has income arising from that
business. Although the fact thatits "place of
management"is located in the UnitedStates is one factor contributing to the
finding that its trade or business is
connected with the United States, it doesnot constitute the basis for Norskstaxliabilityin the first place.
A factual proposition which merelyinforms domestic tax liability cannotconstitute a residency criterion.
Norsk s claimed to be entitledto Canada- US Treaty forconcessional tax
*(1995) 2 SCR 802
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
16/28
Art. 4(1)Resident1stSentence
Literal meaningo Non-source taxationo by reason of connecting factors
OECD MC Comm.o Comprehensive (full-tax) liability to tax [Para 8 , Comm on Art. 4]
2-Nov-13 16
For the purposes of this Convention, the term resident of aContracting State means any person who, under the laws
of that State, is liable to taxtherein by reason ofhisdomicile, residence, place of management or any other
criterion of a similar nature, and also includes that Stateand any political subdivision or local authority thereof.
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
17/28
Article 4(1)First Sentence
Liable to tax - Indian judicial precedents
2-Nov-13 17
M A Rafik
NR paid tax in India, andhence he is an IndianResident
TVM Ltd.
Mauritian Co. Entitled toDTAA if it has paid tax inMauritius
Cyril Pereira
As no income-tax law onIndividuals in UAE, theycannot access DTAA
ABA
Liability to tax is legalsituation, Payment of taxis fiscal situation
Abdul Razak Memon
UAE individual cannotaccess the DTAA, but areentitled to lower tax fordividends/interest
Green Emirates
UAE Residents can availDTAA as there is apotential liability to tax
Linklaters LLP
Income of the firm istaxed in UK. Firm hasfiscal domicile in UK -thus resident
Meera Bhatia
UAE Individuals canaccess the DTAA as thereis a potential liability totax
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
18/28
Article 4(1)Liable to tax
Can the following access their States tax treaty?
2-Nov-13 18
An Indian Resident, earning onlyagricultural income.
Exempt Income
An Indian Charitable Organisation,paying no tax on its income.
Exempt Entity
An NRI, not liable to tax within India.Potentially
taxable
A RNOR, taxed only on sources withinIndia.
Limited taxation
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
19/28
Article 4(1)Liable to tax
non-taxability through-o loss adjustments
o personal allowances deduction/exemption
o specific item of income exempted
o certain types of activity exempted
o certain types of person exempted
o complete exclusion of a persono Absence of tax legislation
Non-taxability through which method depends ondomestic law but determines treaty entitlement
At which point the liable to tax not satisfied?
2-Nov-13 19
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
20/28
Article 4(1)2nd Sentence
Absent in MC 63, introduced in MC 77
Aimed at diplomats and consular officialso To prevent diplomats from treaty benefits from both Home and Host State
Extended to conduit companieso [Para 8.2 (1st sent.) MC Comm. through 1992 Update]
Extended to apply for effect of other treatieso [Para 8.2 (2nd sent.) MC Comm 2008 Update]
2-Nov-13 20
This term, however, does not include any person who isliable to tax in that State in respect only of incomefrom
sources in that Stateor capital situated therein
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
21/28
2-Nov-13 21
A A
State R1 State R2
Cumulative effect of treaties
State S
Income
State S to limit its taxation as per bothR1-S and R2-S treaties.
Income
A
Income
State S1 State S2
State R to limit its taxation/grant reliefas per both R-S1and R-S2treaties.
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
22/28
2-Nov-13 22
State R2
Income
Effect of other treaties
Can R2-S Treaty apply?
A ceases to be fully liable to tax inState R2by application of R1-R2Treaty
A may continue to be residentunder State R2s domestic law(exceptions e.g. UK, Canada)
Under R2-S Treaty, A not liable tocomprehensive taxation in State R2
(effect of application of R1-R2Treaty)
State S
A A
State R1
Winner Loser
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
23/28
Article 4(1), Second Sentence
A mere clarifying statement? [Klaus Vogel m.no. 31,Art.4]o Treaty residence does not apply to non-residents with limited-tax liability
o Aimed at diplomats & consular officials [para 8.2 MC Comm.(1977)
Who are considered residents of Receiving State though they do not
live there permanently
2-Nov-13 23
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
24/28
Art. 4(1), Second Sentence
As an exception to 1st sent.o Diplomats
exemption from all taxes, except taxes on private income having its
source in the receiving State [Art 34(d) Vienna Convention on
Diplomatic Relations]
Under the laws of that Stateo laws vs. law
o Monist/Dualist States - different results?
2-Nov-13 24
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
25/28
Art. 4(1), Second Sentence
Sources in that State - Undefinedo Ordinary meaning
Point of origin
o Treaty meaning
Income arising in the other State according to distributive ruleshas its source in that state
o Domestic meaning
Domestic source (for taxation of non-residents)
Foreign source (for providing relief to residents)
Para 8.1 Comm. uses Treaty meaning
2-Nov-13 25
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
26/28
2-Nov-13 26
State R2
Income
Meaning of SourceA is resident of R1after tiebreaker under
R1-R2Treaty
Income sourced in State Sbuttaxed in State R2.
For example, shipping profits
earned by enterprise of R2(havingits POEM in R1) may be sourcedfrom outside State R2.
State R2taxes A (say, since A isincorporated there) on incomesourced in State S
Application of R2-S Treaty?
State S
AA
State R1
Winner Loser
PE
d E l
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
27/28
2-Nov-13 27
Swiss
Federation
Concertperformance
Fragmented Treaty EntitlementAznavour case*- Source State taxation inFrance
UK Co earns income from As performance inFrance and is taxed in the UK. A is not taxedin Switzerland on performance income as itaccrues to UK Co. France taxes performance
income in the hands of A and not UKCo.Both UKCo and A are tax residents of UKand Switzerland respectively.*Conseil dEtat, 28thMar, 2008, No. 271366, IBFD
France
UKCoA
UK
Held: A taxed on income under domestic law Swiss-France Treaty examined, Art. 17(1) allowed France to tax the income
UK Co.s entitlement to access Treaty considered irrelevant Whether Switzerland taxed A also not found relevant
Where one persons owns the income and liability to tax is imposed on anotherperson; a potential claim for treaty entitlement is fragmented between twopersons
8/14/2019 4.9.2013 - CA Ganesh Rajgopalan - Treaty Entitlement- CTC 4Sep13- Final.pptx
28/28
Thank you!
2-Nov-13 28