Antoinette Butler Wilks
Supervisors:Prof Trang Thomas Dr Sophie Xenos
RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Women & Psychology 17th Annual Conference1-3 December 2006, VU, Sunbury Victoria Australia
Brides and caregiving: Cultural, social and psychological resources of older Filipinos in Australia
RMIT University 2
Presentation
• Introduction• Theoretical Framework• Research Method• Results• Summary and ImplicationsNOTE: (Most figures/graphs/photos were removed
for website copy of presentation.)
RMIT University 3
Introduction: Definitions Bride = refers to a woman born overseas who migrated to
Australia as a result of mixed marriage
Mixed marriage = refers to marriages between people from different birthplace groups
Intermarriage = refers to marriage outside own ethnic background
Intramarriage = refers to marriage within the same ethnic background
Caregiver = refers to a primary carer of a sick or elderly husband/spouse/parent or child/grandchildren in the family
Urban = comprises capital city; Non-urban refers to the remainder
RMIT University 4
CALD communities and ageing
Table 1: Birthplaces of persons aged 65 and over from CALD backgrounds ranked in order of size, Australia 1996-2026 (Gibson, et. al., 2001, p82) Birthplace 1996
2001
2006
2011
2016
2021
2026
Italy 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Poland 2 5 6 11 13 14 16 Germany 3 3 3 3 3 3 5 Greece 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 Netherlands 5 4 4 4 4 4 7 China 6 6 5 5 5 6 4 India 7 7 10 9 8 9 8 Vietnam 13 11 11 10 6 5 3 Philippines 21 20 19 15 11 7 6 Lebanon 17 14 14 12 12 10 9 Malaysia 25 24 20 18 14 12 10
RMIT University 5
Mixed marriages & Overseas-born brides
Slide 9 Mixed marriages in Australia
Literature indicate that disparity has been influenced by mixed marriage between overseas born marrying Australian men. Initially- UK, Ireland & NZ. Recently- Italy, Vietnam, China, Phils.
Slide 10 Overseas-born brides
This slide highlights the big proportion of Philippines-born brides marrying long-time Australians compared to other recent overseas-born brides. Nearly 32% of Filipino brides marry long-term Australians in contrast to only 9% groom born in the Philippines married long-term Australians.
RMIT University 6
Filipinos and caregiving challenges
Ageing CALD communities Filipinos - 6th largest ethnic group by 2026 Labour shortage and Family Reunion Programs Scholars and Skilled Trade Migration in 1960s-1980s Intermarriages/Intramarriages and grandmothers
1980s-1990s Gender ratio and Geographical dispersion
Paucity of empirical research Psychological well-being, long term-care needs Caregivers personal resources and well-being
RMIT University 7
Aims of the project:
Investigate the relationship between: migration circumstances acculturation experiences coping strategies general and mental health use of health services services by Filipino migrants who migrated to Australia under different circumstances (young brides/spouses, grandmothers, and skilled male
migrants).
Develop a model for positive ageing for this dominantly female community who live in both rural and urban areas.
RMIT University 8
Theoretical Framework: Resource-Congruence Model of Adaptation
Proactive Reactive Relaxation
Develop → Assess → Utilize →Conserve resources
Stress: an interactive, dynamic process that takes place in a cultural context.
Potential stressors for Asian elderly: cultural & language barriers, identity, social roles, discrimination.
RMIT University 9
MethodsParticipants: Philippines-born migrants (40+)
Brides/intermarried (1964-2005) Intramarried women Grandmothers Men
Procedure: Stage 1 Qualitative Interview (N=170)
Semi-structured Interview and Thematic Analysis Stage 2 Survey (N=300) in progress
Demographics, Ageing, Caregiving Acculturation scale Depression, Anxiety, Stress Coping Social Support AppraisalSPSS – ANOVA, MANOVA, GLM, Regression, SEM
Stage 3 Qualitative Interview
RMIT University 10
Results: Preliminary findings
Australian Filipinos Brides Spouse Age 35.6 Aus-
35.9 Asian- 38.2 yrs (22.2 Phils)
52 yrs (40-88)
63 yrs (36-94)
Age difference 45% 2yrs 10% 10+ yrs
51% 10+yrs
Sex ratio 98.6M : 100F 52.6M : 100F 86%F (N=216) Urban Non-Urban
75% 25%
80 % 20%
34% 66% (82% born Non-Urban)
Qualifications Higher quals
46.2% 58.5% 38%
70% 64%
51% 31%
Primary carer 20% 38%
Caree 40% Partner 25% Children 21% Parent
60% Partner 23% Child/etc 6% Parent/S/G
60%Illness 20%Help fam 13%Gratitude
RMIT University 11
Results: (Graphs removed for website version.)
A one-sample T-test was conducted to compare sample means against population means in the Depression, Anxiety and Stress scales. The output indicates that there are significant differences in all three scales. The sample means in the three scales are significantly lower than the normative value for women.
RMIT University 12
Summary: Brides and caregiving
“Caring for husband makes me busy to find the right food – organic which makes it more expensive.”
“Satisfaction to care for a loved one. My love does not falter because he is sick. I give spiritual support.”
“…go around shops, budget well…”
“Pray, talk to friends, join clubs, Filipino and church organizations that help me. I do volunteer work.”
RMIT University 13
Summary: Resources
Psychological Resources: • Traditional Filipino values and beliefs: filial love, respect
and duty, in debt gratitude, religiosity, family centredness,
• Positive attitude, continuous adjustment of values and expectations
• Language, education, health status
Social Resources: • Family, friends, Filipino assoc & services, Church • Health and social support services
RMIT University 14
Summary: Variables contributing to positive well being
1. Religion2. Humour3. Acceptance4. Level of interest to migrate5. Migration expectation met6. Social network7. Living arrangements
RMIT University 15
Implications
Challenges in cross-cultural research• access to ethnic women in intermarriage• ethnic women in rural and remote • aged migrants from CALD backgrounds
Evidence based data • Impact of caregiving in comparison with stressors in
non-caregivers • Research design on caregiving studies by: recruiting sample from non-caregiver programs using standardized measures on stress and coping
RMIT University 16
Filipino brides …
Wife killer's payout refused
August 04, 2006 03:00am, Article from: The Daily Telegraph
THE man dubbed Sydney's "most evil husband" yesterday lost a $750,000 legal claim over his treatment by police after the murder of his second wife. Thomas Andrew Keir was convicted at three trials of killing his first wife Jean Keir but was acquitted of the 1991 murder of his second wife, Rosalina Canonisado.
RMIT University 17
Global Migration of brides …
Anastasia King, in this undated photo at the UW, was found strangled and dumped in a shallow grave Dec. 28 near Marysville. She was only 20 years old. / Family Photo