8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
1/56
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
2/56
Every sermon preached by Christiansin the NT centres on the resurrection.
Kreeft says, The Gospel or goodnews means essentially the news ofChrists resurrection. he goes on tosay that the news that set the ancient
world on fire was not that of loveyour neighbour but of theresurrection of Jesus Christ, whoclaimed to be the Son of God andSaviour of the world.The resurrection is of crucialimportance because it completes our
salvation - Rom 6:23
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
3/56
Abraham, Buddha,
Muhammed, Confucius and
Lao Tzu all still lie dead in theirgraves - the tomb of Jesus is
empty.
In life changing terms we see
the difference in the disciples
before and after the
resurrection - before hidden
behind closed doors, afterconfident world changing
missionaries and ready to face
martyrdom if necessary.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
4/56
It is important to see that the
resurrection is not in the past,
Christ rose, - but in thepresent, Christ is risen
He is living - Lk 24:5
Do you keep Christ mummifiedin words like apologetics and
history - or do you allow him to
live and set lives alight now ashe did millennia ago?
For that is what the
resurrection did - and still does.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
5/56
The strategy of the argument forthe resurrection - 5 theories
The resurrection can beproved and believed with as
much historical credibility asany other well documentedevent in ancient history. The
two basic assumptions forsuch a belief are simple andare based on empirical data
which is no disputed:
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
6/56
The strategy of the argument forthe resurrection - 5 theories
The existence of the NT
texts as we have them,and the existence (but notnecessarily the truth) of
the Christian religion aswe find it today.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
7/56
The question to ask is this:Which theory about whathappened in Jerusalemon that first EasterSunday can account forthe data?The following five
diagrams represent thepossible theories.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
8/56
Jesus Died Jesus Rose 1. Christianity
5 Theories about the resurrection
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
9/56
Jesus Died Jesus Rose 1. Christianity
2. HallucinationJesus
didnt rise
The apostleswere deceived
5 Theories about the resurrection
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
10/56
Jesus Died Jesus Rose 1. Christianity
2. Hallucination
3. Myth
Jesusdidnt rise
The apostleswere deceived
The apostles weremyth-makers
5 Theories about the resurrection
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
11/56
Jesus Died Jesus Rose 1. Christianity
4. Conspiracy
2. Hallucination
3. Myth
Jesusdidnt rise
The apostleswere deceived
The apostles weremyth-makers
The apostleswere deceivers
5 Theories about the resurrection
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
12/56
Jesus Died
Jesusdidnt die
Jesus Rose 1. Christianity
5. Swoon
4. Conspiracy
2. Hallucination
3. Myth
Jesusdidnt rise
The apostleswere deceived
The apostles weremyth-makers
The apostleswere deceivers
5 Theories about the resurrection
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
13/56
Could it be that Christ in factsurvived the crucifixion, he didnot die but just swooned?Here are 9 arguments inresponse to the swoon theory:1. Jesus could not have
survived crucifixion. Romanprocedures were very careful toeliminate that possibility. Romanlaw even laid the death penaltyon any soldier who let a capital
prisoner escape in any way,including bungling a crucifixion.
It was never done.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
14/56
2. The fact thatthe Romansoldier did not break Jesus'legs, as he did to the other twocrucified criminals (Jn
19:31-33), means that thesoldier was sure Jesus wasdead. Breaking the legshastened the death so that thecorpse could be taken downbefore the sabbath.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
15/56
3. John, an eyewitness,certified that he saw blood
and water come fromJesus' pierced heart (Jn19:34-35). This shows thatJesus' lungs had collapsedand he had died ofasphyxiation. Any medicalexpert can vouch for this.
4. The body was totallyencased in winding sheetsand entombed (Jn19:38-42).
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
16/56
5. The post-resurrectionappearances convinced the
disciples, even doubting Thomas,that Jesus was alive (Jn20:19-29). It is psychologicallyimpossible for the disciples to have
been so transformed and confidentif Jesus had merely struggled outof a swoon, badly in need of adoctor. A half-dead, staggeringsick man who has just had anarrow escape is not worshipedfearlessly as divine lord and
conquerer of death.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
17/56
6. How were the Roman guards at thetomb overpowered by a swooningcorpse? Or by unarmed disciples? And
if the disciples did it, they knowinglylied when they wrote the Gospels, and
we are into the conspiracy theory.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
18/56
7. How could a swooning half-dead man have moved the great
stone at the door of the tomb?Who moved the stone if not anangel? No one has everanswered that question. Neither
the Jews nor the Romans wouldmove it, for it was in both theirinterests to keep the tomb sealed,
the Jews had the stone put therein the first place, and the Romanguards would be killed if they let
the body "escape."
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
19/56
The story the Jewishauthorities spread, that the
guards fell asleep and thedisciples stole the body (Mt28:11-15), is unbelievable.Roman guards would not
fall asleep on a job like that;if they did, they would lose
their lives. If they did fallasleep, the crowd and theeffort and the noise it wouldhave taken to move anenormous boulder would
have wakened them.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
20/56
8. If Jesus awoke from aswoon, where did he go?
Think this through: you havea living body to deal withnow, not a dead one. Why didit disappear? There is
absolutely no data, not evenany false, fantastic, imagineddata, about Jesus' life afterhis crucifixion, in anysources, friend or foe, at any
time, early or late. A man likethat, with a past like that,
would have left traces.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
21/56
9. Most simply, theswoon theory necessarilyturns into the conspiracytheory or the
hallucination theory, forthe disciples testified thatJesus did not swoon butreally died and reallyrose.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
22/56
Refutation of the ConspiracyTheory: Seven Arguments
Why couldn't the discipleshave made up the wholestory?
1. Blaise Pascal gives a simple,psychologically sound prooffor why this is unthinkable:
"The apostles were eitherdeceived or deceivers. Eithersupposition is difficult, for it isnot possible to imagine that a
man has risen from the dead...
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
23/56
Refutation of the ConspiracyTheory: Seven Arguments
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
24/56
The hypothesis that the Apostles were dishonestis quite absurd. Follow it out to the end, andimagine these twelve men meeting after Jesus'death and conspiring to say that he has risenfrom the dead. This means attacking all the
powers that be. The human heart is susceptibleto fickleness, to change, to promises, to bribery.One of them had only to deny his story under
these inducements, or still more because of
possible imprisonment, tortures and death, andthey would all have been lost. Follow that out."Pascal, Pensees 322, 310
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
25/56
The "cruncher" in this argument is the historicalfact that no one, weak or strong, saint or sinner,
Christian or heretic, ever confessed, freely orunder pressure, bribe or even torture, that the
whole story of the resurrection was a fake a lie,a deliberate deception. Even when people brokeunder torture, denied Christ and worshipedCaesar, they never let that cat out of the bag,never revealed that the resurrection was their
conspiracy. For that cat was never in that bag.No Christians believed the resurrection was aconspiracy; if they had, they wouldn't havebecome Christians.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
26/56
2. If they made up the
story, they were the mostcreative, clever, intelligentfantasists in history, farsurpassing Shakespeare,or Dante or Tolkien.Fisherman's "fish stories"are never that elaborate,
that convincing, that life-changing, and thatenduring.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
27/56
3. The disciples' characterargues strongly against such aconspiracy on the part of all of
them, with no dissenters. Theywere simple, honest, commonpeasants, not cunning,
conniving liars. Their sincerityis proved by their words anddeeds. They preached aresurrected Christ and they
lived a resurrected Christ.They willingly died for their"conspiracy." Nothing proves
sincerity like martyrdom.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
28/56
They change in their livesfrom fear to faith, despair toconfidence, confusion tocertitude, runaway cowardice
to steadfast boldness underthreat and persecution, not
only proves their sincerity buttestifies to some powerfulcause of it. Can a lie causesuch a transformation? Are
truth and goodness suchenemies that the greatest goodin history -- sanctity -- has
come from the greatest lie?
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
29/56
4. There could be nopossible motive for such a
lie. Lies are always told forsome selfish advantage. Whatadvantage did the"conspirators" derive from
their "lie" ? They were hated,scorned, persecuted,excommunicated, imprisoned,
tortured, exiled, crucified,boiled alive, roasted,beheaded, disemboweled andfed to lions - hardly a catalog
of perks!
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
30/56
5. If the resurrection was a lie, theJews would have produced thecorpse. All they had to do was go
to the tomb and get it. TheRoman soldiers and their leaders
were on their side. If the Jews
couldn't get the body because thedisciples stole it, how did they do
that? The arguments against theswoon theory hold here too:
unarmed peasants could not haveoverpowered Roman soldiers orrolled away a great stone while
they slept on duty.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
31/56
6. The disciples could not havegotten away with proclaiming the
resurrection in Jerusalem - sametime, same place, full ofeyewitnesses - if it had been a lie.
William Lane Craig says,
"The fact that the disciples were able toroclaim the resurrection in Jerusalemin the face of their enemies a few weeks
after the crucifixion shows that whatthey proclaimed was true, for they could
never have proclaimed the resurrection(and been believed) under such
circumstances had it not occurred.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
32/56
Refutation of the HallucinationTheory: Thirteen Arguments
If you thought you saw a
dead man walking andtalking, wouldn't you think itmore likely that you werehallucinating than that you
were seeing correctly? Whythen not think the same thingabout Christ's resurrection?
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
33/56
Refutation of the HallucinationTheory: Thirteen Arguments
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
34/56
1. There were too manywitnesses. Hallucinations areprivate, individual, subjective.Christ appeared to MaryMagdalene, to the disciples minusThomas, to the disciples including
Thomas, to the two disciples atEmmaus, to the fisherman on theshore, to James (his "brother" orcousin), and even to five hundred
people at once (1 Cor 15:3-8).Even three different witnesses areenough for a kind of psychological
trigonometry;
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
35/56
...over five hundred is about as public as you canwish. And Paul says in this passage (v. 6) thatmost of the five hundred are still alive, inviting
any reader to check the truth of the story byquestioning the eyewitnesses -- he could neverhave done this and gotten away with it, given
the power, resources and numbers of hisenemies, if it were not true.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
36/56
2. The witnesses were qualified.They were simple, honest, moral
people who had firsthandknowledge of the facts.
3. The five hundred saw Christtogether, at the same time andplace.
4. Hallucinations usually last afew seconds or minutes; rarelyhours. This one hung around forforty days (Acts 1:3).
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
37/56
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
38/56
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
39/56
10. They also spoke withhim, and he spoke back.
Figments of yourimagination do not hold
profound, extendedconversations with you,unless you have the kind ofmental disorder thatisolates you. But this
"hallucination" conversedwith at least eleven peopleat once, for forty days(Acts 1:3).
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
40/56
11. The apostles could not have believed in the"hallucination" if Jesus' corpse had still been in
the tomb. This is very simple and telling point;for if it was a hallucination, where was thecorpse? They would have checked for it; if it
was there, they could not have believed.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
41/56
12. If the apostles hadhallucinated and thenspread their hallucinogenicstory, the Jews would have
stopped it by producing thebody -- unless the discipleshad stolen it, in which case
we are back with the
conspiracy theory and allits difficulties.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
42/56
13. A hallucination would
explain only the post-resurrection appearances;it would not explain theempty tomb, the rolled-away stone, or theinability to produce thecorpse. No theory can
explain all these dataexcept a realresurrection.
C S Le is sa s
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
43/56
C.S. Lewis says,
"Any theory of hallucination breaks down on the fact(and if it is invention [rather than fact], it is the oddest
invention that ever entered the mind of man) that onthree separate occasions this hallucination was notimmediately recognized as Jesus (Lk 24:13-31; Jn20:15; 21:4). Even granting that God sent a holyhallucination to teach truths already widely believedwithout it, and far more easily taught by other methods,and certain to be completely obscured by this, might we
not at least hope that he would get the face of thehallucination right? Is he who made all faces such abungler that he cannot even work up a recognizablelikeness of the Man who was himself?" (Miracles,
chapter 16)
R f i f h M h Th
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
44/56
Refutation of the Myth Theory:Six Arguments
1. The style of the Gospels isradically and clearly differentfrom the style of all the myths.
Any literary scholar who knowsand appreciates myths can verify
this. There are no overblown,spectacular, childishlyexaggerated events. Nothing isarbitrary. Everything fits in.Everything is meaningful. The
hand of a master is at work here.
R f i f h M h Th
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
45/56
Refutation of the Myth Theory:Six Arguments
h l l d h
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
46/56
Psychological depth is at a maximum. Inmyth it is at a minimum. In myth, suchspectacular external events happen that it
would be distracting to add much internaldepth of character. That is why it isordinary people like Alice who are the
protagonists of extra-ordinary adventureslike Wonderland. That character depthand development of everyone in theGospels -- especially, of course, Jesus
himself -- is remarkable.It is also done with an incredible economyof words. Myths are verbose; the Gospels
are laconic (concise).
h l ll l k f
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
47/56
There are also telltale marks of eyewitnessdescription, like the little detail of Jesus
writing in the sand when asked whetherto stone the adulteress or not (Jn 8:6). Noone knows why this is put in; nothingcomes of it. The only explanation is that
the writer saw it. If this detail and otherslike it throughout all four Gospels wereinvented, then a first-century tax collector(Matthew), a "young man" (Mark), a
doctor (Luke), and a fisherman (John) allindependently invented the new genre ofrealistic fantasy nineteen centuries before
it was reinvented in the twentieth.
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
48/56
2. A second problem is thatthere was not enough time for
myth to develop. The originaldemythologizers pinned theircase onto a late second-centurydate for the writing of the
Gospels; several generationshave to pass before the addedmythological elements can be
mistakenly believed to be facts.Eyewitnesses would be aroundbefore that to discredit the new,mythic versions.
I h h h d
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
49/56
In other cases where myths andlegends of miracles developed arounda religious founder, e.g. Buddha, Lao-
tzu and Muhammad. In each case,many generations passed before themyth surfaced.
Julius Muller challenged hisnineteenth-century contemporaries to
produce a single example anywherein history of a great myth or legend
arising around a historical figure andbeing generally believed within thirty
years after that figure's death. No one
has ever answered him.
3 Th h h h l Th
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
50/56
3. The myth theory has two layers. Thefirst layer is the historical Jesus, who wasnot divine, did not claim divinity,
performed no miracles, and did not risefrom the dead. The second, later,mythologized layer is the Gospels as we
have them, with a Jesus who claimed to bedivine, performed miracles and rose from
the dead. The problem with this theory issimply that there is not the slightest bit of
any real evidence whatever for theexistence of any such first layer. The two-layer cake theory has the first layer made
entirely of air -- and hot air at that.
4 A li l d il ld i d i
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
51/56
4. A little detail, seldom noticed, issignificant in distinguishing the Gospelsfrom myth: the first witnesses of theresurrection were women. In first-centuryJudaism, women had low social statusand no legal right to serve as witnesses. If
the empty tomb were an invented legend,its inventors surely wouldnot have had itdiscovered by women, whose testimony
was considered worthless. If, on the other
hand, the writers were simply reportingwhat they saw, they would have to tell thetruth, however socially and legally
inconvenient.
5 Th NT ld b h
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
52/56
5. The NT could not be mythmisinterpreted and confused
with fact because itspecifically distinguishes the
two and repudiates the mythicinterpretation (2 Peter 1:16).
Since it explicitly says it is notmyth, if it is myth it is adeliberate lie rather thanmyth. The dilemma still
stands. It is either truth or lie,whether deliberate(conspiracy) or non-
deliberate (hallucination).
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
53/56
There is no escape from
the horns of this dilemma.Once a child asks whetherSanta Claus is real, your
yes becomes a lie, not
myth, if he is not literallyreal. Once the NewTestament distinguishes
myth from fact, itbecomes a lie if theresurrection is not fact.
Ri h d P till i th
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
54/56
Richard Purtill summarizes thetextual case:"Many events which are regardedas firmly established historicallyhave (1) far less documentaryevidence than many biblical events;
(2) and the documents on whichhistorians rely for much secularhistory are written much longerafter the event than many records
of biblical events; (3) furthermore,we have many more copies ofbiblical narratives than of secular
histories;
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
55/56
(4) the surviving copies aremuch earlier than those on whichour evidence for secular historyis based. If the biblical narrativesdid not contain accounts of
miraculous events, biblicalhistory would probably beregarded as much more firmlyestablished than most of the
history of, say, classical Greeceand Rome."Thinking About Religion, p. 84-85
8/3/2019 Apologetics, Kreeft Chapter 9: The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
56/56
If the evidence provided istrue then we have to face adecision: will we followChrist?
Such a decision can be basedon the evidence providedbeing intellectually acceptable
- and the moral integrity toaccept and act upon it.