Environmental Monitoring Report Quarterly Report October - December 2012
VIE: Greater Mekong Subregion Kunming–Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai– Lao Cai Highway Project Prepared by Getinsa for the Vietnam Expressway Corporation, the Ministry of Transport, the Government of Viet Nam, and the Asian Development Bank.
CURRENCY EQUIVALENTS (as of 1 January 2013)
Currency unit
–
Viet Nam dong (VND)
VND1.00 = $0.000048 $1.00 = VND20,825
NOTE
In this report, "$" refers to US dollars unless otherwise stated.
This environmental monitoring report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
Hanoi office : 12th floor, Ocean Park Building, Dao Duy Anh Street, Dong Da District Vinh Phuc office: Huu Thu Hamlet, Kim Long Ward, Tam Duong Dist, Vinh Phuc Province Madrid Spain head office: C/ Ramón de Aguinaga No 8, 28028 Madrid, Spain/ Web Page: www.getinsa.com
ENVIRONMENTAL, HEALTH AND SAFETYQUARTERLY REPORT
OCTOBER – DECEMBER 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
INDEX
0 SUMMARY ........................................................................................................................... 3
1 INTRODUCTION. FRAMEWORK OF THE REPORT ......................................................... 7
1.1 FRAMEWORK OF THE REPORT ...................................................................................... 7
1.2 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT. DIVISION IN PACKAGES ........................................ 7
2 CONSTRUCTION WORKS PROGRESS DURING THE PERIOD .................................... 11
2.1 PACKAGE A1 ................................................................................................................... 11
2.2 PACKAGE A2 ................................................................................................................... 13
2.3 PACKAGE A3 ................................................................................................................... 15
2.4 PACKAGE A4 ................................................................................................................... 18
2.5 PACKAGE A5 ................................................................................................................... 19
2.6 PACKAGE A6 ................................................................................................................... 21
2.7 PACKAGE A7 ................................................................................................................... 23
2.8 PACKAGE A8 ................................................................................................................... 25
3 CARRIED OUT TASKS DURING THE PERIOD ............................................................... 29
4 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING RESULTS. COMPLEMENTARY MEASURES TO
BE APPLIED ...................................................................................................................... 31
4.1 IMPACT ON AIR QUALITY .............................................................................................. 31
4.2 IMPACT ON WATER RESOURCES ................................................................................ 47
4.3 IMPACT ON SOILS QUALITY .......................................................................................... 64
4.4 NOISE AND VIBRATION LEVELS ................................................................................... 89
4.5 STREAMS AND RIVERSIDES MAINTENANCE .............................................................. 92
4.6 EROSION RISKS AND STABILITY IN SLOPES ............................................................ 109
4.7 HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES MANAGEMENT ............................................................. 133
4.8 UNSUITABLE MATERIAL DISPOSALS AND BORROW PITS ..................................... 152
4.9 WASTE AND CLEANLINESS ON SITE ......................................................................... 163
4.10 BIODIVERSITY PRESERVATION ................................................................................. 183
4.11 WORKERS’ CAMPS CONDITIONS ............................................................................... 185
4.12 LABOUR SAFETY EQUIPMENT ................................................................................... 213
4.13 TRAFFIC CONDITIONS AND SIGNPOSTING IN ROADS ............................................ 239
4.14 SIGNPOSTING IN DANGEROUS SURFACES ............................................................. 264
4.15 ACCIDENTS DUE TO THE LACK OF SAFETY MEASURES. RESPONSIBLES .......... 278
4.16 CONTRACTORS’ ENVIRONMENTAL AND SAFETY SPECIALISTS MOBILIZATION . 279
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
5 REFERENCE DOCUMENTS RELATIVE TO ENVIRONMENT, HEALTH AND SAFETY
ISSUES ........................................................................................................................... 283
5.1 PACKAGE A1 ................................................................................................................ 283
5.2 PACKAGE A2 ................................................................................................................ 284
5.3 PACKAGE A3 ................................................................................................................ 285
5.4 PACKAGE A4 ................................................................................................................ 285
5.5 PACKAGE A5 ................................................................................................................ 286
5.6 PACKAGE A6 ................................................................................................................ 288
5.7 PACKAGE A7 ................................................................................................................ 289
5.8 PACKAGE A8 ................................................................................................................ 290
6 GRIEVANCE INTAKES. PUBLIC CONSULTATION ....................................................... 291
ANNEX 1: GRIEVANCE INTAKES. PUBLIC CONSULTATION ............................................. 293
ANNEX 2: DATA OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY PARAMETERS ANALYSIS ................... 339
ANNEX 2.1: AIR QUALITY PARAMETERS ............................................................................. 341
ANNEX 2.2: WATER QUALITY PARAMETERS ...................................................................... 355
ANNEX 2.3: NOISE LEVELS ................................................................................................... 379
ANNEX 3: DOCUMENTATION RECEIVED FROM CONTRACTORS DURING THE PERIOD393
ANNEX 4: STATUS OF THE DOCUMENTATION RELATED TO BORROW PITS,
QUARRIES, SOIL DISPOSALS AND CONCRETE BATCHING PLANTS ...................... 399
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
1
ABBREVIATIONS
ADB Asian Development Bank
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
EPMU Expressway Project Management Unit
EHSMR Environmental, Health and Safety Monthly Report
EHSQR Environmental, Health and Safety Quarterly Report
EHSWIR Environmental, Health and Safety Weekly Inspection Report
MONRE Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment
MOT Ministry of Transport
NB-LC Noi Bai - Lao Cai
NS National Specialist (environmental)
PPE Personal Protection Equipment
PSC Project Supervision Consultant
SMR Safety Monitoring Report
TOR Terms Of Reference
VEC Vietnam Expressway Corporation
KPH Not detected
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
2
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
3
0 SUMMARY
Environmental, Health and Safety Control and Protection: Environmental, Health
and Safety inspections continued being regularly carried out in weekly basis to monitor
impacts due to works and the implementation of mitigation measures. Specific monthly
reports, which are submitted to EPMU, and a quarterly report, which is submitted to the
Client and to ADB, were prepared for all packages concerning the supervision and
control of the above mentioned issues, as regular reporting procedure established by
the PSC, increasing the duties specified in our Contract in order to improve the
monitoring and control processes. Also, short weekly check lists are prepared after
each inspection on site in order to maintain the information constantly updated.
The general main problems and impacts on site along the entire Project this forth
quarter 2012 have been very similar to the previous periods, and may be summarized
as below:
Cleanliness, healthy conditions
Lack of cleanliness at some construction sites. Waste materials are generally
not properly stored. Anyway, in the last three months it could be seen some kind
of improvement about it.
This quarter, most of worker camps were improving, little by little, the
cleanliness and the sanitary conditions. In any case, they must continue in this
line. Package A5 must clearly improve this issue.
Noise & Air Pollution
A lot of dust is generated on site in dry days. The causes are: not enough water
spraying activities and trucks for earthworks operating without being covered.
Mitigation measures to alleviate the increase of noise level were introduced in
some locations, avoiding noisy night works near houses.
Soil pollution and erosive processes. Hazardous substances management
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
4
Soil landslide continued happening in some slopes and several riverbanks, due
to the heavy rains in this season and the lack of protection for the new surfaces
in most of locations. Specially, in package A3, soil landslide happened in all
sections. Now, Contractor almost solved this problem in accordance with local
people and authorities. In some sections of package A1, the planting works are
not in good maintenance, grass got dry. In package A6, planting works are
almost finished, but without any inspection, so PSC has to wait for the real
results. In package A7, the planting works are in good maintenance, Contractor
planted grass in more than 65% of planting areas.
Oil, fuel and waste oil and other hazardous substances as well as bentonite,
continue overflowing on the ground and in the rivers and streams in many
locations, affecting again to water quality and the earth around sites. No
substantial improvement was detected in this issue.
Rivers protection, water quality
According to the results of the water quality monitoring activities, it can be
considered, in general, not significantly affected by the project.
Some riversides, especially in packages A1 (2 rivers) and A2 (2 rivers), are
seriously eroded and even destroyed because of changes in the direction and
speed of waters, due to riverbeds invasion and bad done temporary cross
accesses or invaded by spoils and earths beyond the needs for the works.
Cement Batching Plants
CBPs were improved in this Quarter, installing or improving settling ponds and
other protective measures. In the third quarter of 2012, settling pond of Cement
Batching Plant which installed near Lo river was not in good maintenance.
However, in the last quarter of 2012, the improvement was clearly shown. The
Engineer paid special attention to CBPs installed near Lo and Red rivers.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
5
Safety conditions
In the most dangerous locations, such as structures, workers are mostly
provided with safety equipment (PPE), although in other locations
(embankments…) workers can be seen even without boots. In Lo and Red
rivers bridges, proper scaffoldings were installed some months ago and are now
in good maintenance. In Red river, all workers used enough PPEs when
working in site. In the area of Ngoi Vien bridge (A5), the safety conditions in the
construction process are very poor: no safety scaffoldings, no safety access stairs.
Some fences were installed in sites when the working surfaces are beside local
roads. But most of these locations are still not signposted.
Engineer (International Environmental Specialist in core team) has successfully
completed the training plan activities for contractors and subcontractors about
safety, health and environmental matters in construction site, with the staff for all
packages. A report was submitted to the Client.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
6
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
7
1 INTRODUCTION. FRAMEWORK OF THE REPORT
1.1 FRAMEWORK OF THE REPORT
Within the framework of the Environmental Control Plans proposed by the contractors and the
duties of the Consultant (PSC) in this matter contained in the Consulting Services Contract, the
environmental team of national specialists (NS) in charge of inspecting the environmental
conditions of the works for the new highway, have done weekly inspections along the sites and
surroundings of all the Packages which nowadays are all with construction activities, checking
the environmental measures applied by the constructors and detecting any impacts that could
be generated by the building works during the period of reference of this quarterly report, that
means, October, November and December 2012.
The results were already included in the environmental, health and safety weekly inspection
reports (EHSWIR) and the corresponding monthly reports for each package (EHSMR). The
Weekly Reports have been included in the corresponding Monthly Reports. So, it’s considered
not necessary or useful to include again that information in this document.
As the environmental team, therefore under its responsibility, is also in charge of monitoring
the healthy and safety conditions in site, specialists in site offices also have made weekly
inspections in all packages. Their results have been being included in the mentioned monthly
reports, as nowadays all these issues have been joined in only one report. Therefore these
issues are also included in this quarterly report.
So, this document is defined as Environmental, Health and Safety Monitoring Quarterly Report
(hereinafter called EHSQR). It will be submitted to the Client, Vietnam Expressway Corporation
(VEC), through the Expressway Project Management Unit (EPMU) and following the Terms of
Reference (ToR) of the Consultant’s Contract, also to Asian Development Bank (ADB).
1.2 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT. DIVISION IN PACKAGES
Noi Bai - Lao Cai (NB-LC) Highway is a part of Kunming - Hai Phong Transport Corridor, which
has been studied with a total length of 865 km passing Yunnan province of China and Lao Cai,
Yen Bai, Phu Tho, Vinh Phuc, Ha Noi, Bac Ninh, Hai Duong, Quang Ninh and Hai Phong
provinces of Vietnam.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
8
Vietnam Expressway Corporation, which is a state owner company, is the proposer of this
project. Its executing agency is the Ministry of Transport (MOT), and it’s being financed by
Asian Development Bank (ADB) and the Government of Vietnam.
According to original design, NB - LC Highway has a total length of about 262.4 km, passing
through 72 communes and 18 districts of provinces and cities as Ha Noi, Vinh Phuc, Phu Tho,
Yen Bai and Lao Cai.
The construction of project is divided into two phases, in which the first phase will construct
244 km with 4 lanes from Ha Noi to Yen Bai and 2 lanes from Yen Bai to Lao Cai. The second
phase will be the widen section of the former with 6 lanes from Ha Noi to Yen Bai and 4 lanes
from Yen Bai to Lao Cai (Chinese border, 262 km).
Construction of the whole project, first phase, is divided into 8 packages including A1, A2, A3,
A4, A5, A6, A7 and A8. All of them have already begun their construction activities. The length,
location and the status of works in each package at the end of the period are described in the
following paragraphs and tables.
- Package A1 is about 26.630 km of length with start point at station Km 0+070 and
finishes at station Km 26+700. Package A1 goes through the Soc Son district of
Hanoi City and Vinh Phuc province.
- Package A2 is about 22.120 km of length and goes through the Vinh Phuc province
and a little of Phu Tho province. Package A2 has start point at station Km 26+700
and finishes at station Km 48+820. It must cross over Lo River, with a long bridge.
- Package A3 is about 32.240 km of length with start point at station Km48+360 and
ending point at station Km 80+00. Package A3 goes through the Phu Tho province.
The most significant structure is the bridge to cross over Red River.
- Package A4 has start point at Km 80+000 in Cam Khe district, Phu Tho province
and ending point at Km109+750 in Tran Yen district, Yen Bai province. Its total
length is 29.750 km.
- Package A5 has start point at Km109+750 in Tran Yen district, Yen Bai province
and ending point at Km150+900 in Van Yen district, Yen Bai province. Its total
length is 41.150 km.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
9
- Package A6 lengthens from start point Km150+900 of Van Yen district, Yen Bai
province to Km190+420 in Van Ban district, Lao Cai province. Its total length is
39.520 km. Almost alignment goes through high mountains in Yen Bai and Lao Cai
province and crosses over natural streams by 18 bridges. This section also
includes 1 tunnel under range of mountain at Km186+500.
- Package A7 lengthens from start point Km190+420 in Van Ban district to Km
218+040 in Bao Thang district, Lao Cai province. Almost alignment also goes
through high mountains and 18 bridges are needed. Its total length is 27,620 m.
Khe Sang bridge with a length of 287m is the biggest one.
- Package A8 begins at station Km 218+040 in Bao Thang district and finishes at Km
244+155 in Bao Thang district, Lao Cai province. Its total length is 26,115 m. Suoi
Trat bridge with a length of 374.8 m is the biggest one.
Table 1.1: Current status of the works at the end of the quarter
A1 A2 A3 A4Site clearing 92.06 61.14 69.26 81.32 Earthworks 87.15 75.90 63.91 38.41 Drainage 47.83 18.03 30.48 38.50 Structures (1) 75.91 80.55 65.97 64.88 Overall progress 56.54 49.37 41.18 28.28
A5 A6 A7 A8Site clearing 93.35 91.08 99.86 91.68 Earthworks 29.32 52.29 81.99 73.85 Drainage 23.23 39.77 70.92 60.85 Structures 21.00 57.58 61.13 71.17 Overall progress 13.78 34.91 59.18 43.02
(1) Concrete works
(data expressed in percentage of the total planned in the project, related to the contract quantities)
The environmental monitoring program is carried out in compliance with regulations of Vietnam
Government and ADB safeguard policy in order to control environmental impacts and to
ensure that the environment in the surroundings of the project area is well preserved. The VEC
proponent should perform environmental protection measures stated in the EIA report as well
as requirements written in the approval decision made by MONRE. In accordance with article
23 of the Environmental Protection Law and article 15 of Decree 80/2006/ND-CP, MONRE will
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
10
organize, direct, and monitor the environmental protection measures performed by VEC as
stated in the EIA report approved.
At present, this environmental monitoring program is being undertaken by Environmental
specialists of Getinsa hired by Vietnam Expressway Corporation. EPMU, the Project Manager,
with the Consultant’s support, monitors the environmental protection measures applied by the
contractors during the development of their works, incompliance with the environmental control
and protection plans proposed by contractors and already approved by the PSC. Consultant
reports to EPMU-VEC as the main involved authority in the project.
In addition to that, during the monitoring process, the environmental specialists and contractors
will try to find out and mitigate unanticipated environmental impacts arising from the project
construction process.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
11
2 CONSTRUCTION WORKS PROGRESS DURING THE PERIOD
In this chapter, they are included all the works already done or in process during the period, in
each package and detailing the section where the works are developed.
2.1 PACKAGE A1
OctoberSec 1: Km 0+900 ~ Km 4+350 Embankment work Sec 2: Km 0+080 ~ Km 1+000 & Km 4+350 ~ Km 7+661 Embankment work
Sec 3: Km 7+661 ~ Km 10+771 Embankment work Sec 4: Km 10+771 ~ Km15+030 Embankment work Sec 5: Km 15+030 ~ Km 18+400 Embankment work Sec 6: Km 18+400 ~ Km 21+900 Embankment work Sec 7: Km 21+900 ~ Km 23+900 Embankment work Sec 8: Km 23+900 ~ Km 26+700 Embankment work Underpass NH2 Structure work Kim Anh bridge (Km 1+901.05) No activity TL402 bridge (Km 3+053.55) No activity
Trung Kien bridge (Km 4+491.00) Structure work
Dai Duong bridge (Km 7+392.65) Structure work
Xuan Phuong bridge (Km 7+660.05) Structure work NTT bridge (Km 7 + 854.7) No activity Tan Loi bridge (Km 10+695.00) Structure work Ba Thien bridge (Km 14+026.00) Structure work I.C 3 bridge (Km 14+590.00) No activity Bon bridge (Km 15+107.00) No activity TL302B bridge (Km 15+825.00) No activity TL-TK bridge (Km 19+120.05) Structure work TL302CI bridge (Km 19+740.05) No activity Cam I bridge (Km 21+910.05) Structure work Cam II bridge (Km 21+910.05) No activityTL302CII bridge (Km 22+480.05) No activity Army I bridge (Km 23+855.45) No activity NH2B bridge (Km 24+946.00) No activity
NovemberSec 1: Km 0+900 ~ Km 4+350 Embankment work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
12
Sec 2: Km 0+080 ~ Km 1+000 & Km 4+350 ~ Km 7+661 Embankment work
Sec 3: Km 7+661 ~ Km 10+771 Embankment work Sec 4: Km 10+771 ~ Km15+030 Embankment work Sec 5: Km 15+030 ~ Km 18+400 Embankment work Sec 6: Km 18+400 ~ Km 21+900 Embankment work Sec 7: Km 21+900 ~ Km 23+900 Embankment work Sec 8: Km 23+900 ~ Km 26+700 Embankment work Underpass NH2 Structure work Kim Anh bridge (Km 1+901.05) No activity TL402 bridge (Km 3+053.55) No activity Trung Kien bridge (Km 4+491.00) Structure work Dai Duong bridge (Km 7+392.65) Structure work Xuan Phuong bridge (Km 7+660.05) Structure work NTT bridge (Km 7 + 854.7) Structure work Tan Loi bridge (Km 10+695.00) Structure work Ba Thien bridge (Km 14+026.00) Structure work I.C 3 bridge (Km 14+590.00) No activity Bon bridge (Km 15+107.00) Structure work TL302B bridge (Km 15+825.00) No activity TL-TK bridge (Km 19+120.05) Structure work TL302CI bridge (Km 19+740.05) No activity Cam I bridge (Km 21+910.05) Structure work Cam II bridge (Km 21+910.05) No activity TL302CII bridge (Km 22+480.05) No activity Army I bridge (Km 23+855.45) No activity NH2B bridge (Km 24+946.00) No activity
DecemberSec 1: Km 0+900 ~ Km 4+350 Embankment work Sec 2: Km 0+080 ~ Km 1+000 & Km 4+350 ~ Km 7+661 Embankment work
Sec 3: Km 7+661 ~ Km 10+771 Embankment work Sec 4: Km 10+771 ~ Km15+030 Embankment work Sec 5: Km 15+030 ~ Km 18+400 Embankment work Sec 6: Km 18+400 ~ Km 21+900 Embankment work Sec 7: Km 21+900 ~ Km 23+900 Embankment work Sec 8: Km 23+900 ~ Km 26+700 Embankment work Underpass NH2 Structure work Kim Anh bridge (Km 1+901.05) No activity
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
13
TL402 bridge (Km 3+053.55) No activity Trung Kien bridge (Km 4+491.00) Structure work Dai Duong bridge (Km 7+392.65) Structure work Xuan Phuong bridge (Km 7+660.05) Structure work NTT bridge (Km 7 + 854.7) Structure work Tan Loi bridge (Km 10+695.00) Structure work Ba Thien bridge (Km 14+026.00) Structure work I.C 3 bridge (Km 14+590.00) No activity Bon bridge (Km 15+107.00) Structure work TL302B bridge (Km 15+825.00) No activity TL-TK bridge (Km 19+120.05) No activity TL302CI bridge (Km 19+740.05) No activity Cam I bridge (Km 21+910.05) Structure work Cam II bridge (Km 21+910.05) No activity TL302CII bridge (Km 22+480.05) No activity Army I bridge (Km 23+855.45) No activity NH2B bridge (Km 24+946.00) No activity
2.2 PACKAGE A2
OctoberSec 1: Km 26+700~Km 32+700 Embankment work Sec 2: Km 32+700~Km 35+300 No activity Sec 3: Km 35+300~Km36+910 No activity Sec 4: Km 36+910~Km 39+850 No activity Sec 5: Km 39+580~Km 40+690 Embankment work Sec 6: Km 40+690~Km 43+400 Embankment work Sec 7: Km 43+400~Km 45+300 Embankment work Sec 8: Km 45+300~Km 47+660 Embankment work Army II Bridge (Km 27+015.00) Structure work Army III Bridge (Km 28+010.00) No activity TL310 Bridge (Km 29+201.00) Structure work Ben Tre Bridge (Km 31+068.00) Structure work Tan Dung Bridge (Km 31+245.05) Structure work Muong Noi Bridge (Km 31+504.50) Bored pile work TL306I Bridge (Km 33+181.55) Structure work Muong Dao Bridge (Km 33+295.00) Structure work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
14
Ben Gao Bridge (Km 35+211.05) No activity TL305 Bridge (Km 37+951.55) No activity Song Dao Bridge (Km 38+450.05) No activity Phung Nguyen Bridge (Km 39+188.00) No activity Xuan Quang Bridge (Km 41+480.00) Structure work TL306II Bridge (Km 45+834.05) No activity Lo river Bridge (Km 48+181.30) Structure work
NovemberSec 1: Km 26+700~Km 32+700 Embankment work Sec 2: Km 32+700~Km 35+300 Embankment work Sec 3: Km 35+300~Km36+910 Embankment work Sec 4: Km 36+910~Km 39+850 Embankment work Sec 5: Km 39+580~Km 40+690 Embankment work Sec 6: Km 40+690~Km 43+400 Embankment work Sec 7: Km 43+400~Km 45+300 Embankment work Sec 8: Km 45+300~Km 47+660 Embankment work Army II Bridge (Km 27+015.00) Structure work Army III Bridge (Km 28+010.00) No activity TL310 Bridge (Km 29+201.00) Structure work Ben Tre Bridge (Km 31+068.00) Structure work Tan Dung Bridge (Km 31+245.05) Structure work Muong Noi Bridge (Km 31+504.50) Structure work TL306I Bridge (Km 33+181.55) Structure work Muong Dao Bridge (Km 33+295.00) Structure work Ben Gao Bridge (Km 35+211.05) Structure work TL305 Bridge (Km 37+951.55) No activity Song Dao Bridge (Km 38+450.05) No activity Phung Nguyen Bridge (Km 39+188.00) No activity Xuan Quang Bridge (Km 41+480.00) Structure work TL306II Bridge (Km 45+834.05) Structure work Lo river Bridge (Km 48+181.30) Structure work
DecemberSec 1: Km 26+700~Km 32+700 Embankment work Sec 2: Km 32+700~Km 35+300 Embankment work Sec 3: Km 35+300~Km36+910 Embankment work Sec 4: Km 36+910~Km 39+850 Embankment work Sec 5: Km 39+580~Km 40+690 Embankment work Sec 6: Km 40+690~Km 43+400 Embankment work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
15
Sec 7: Km 43+400~Km 45+300 Embankment work Sec 8: Km 45+300~Km 47+660 Embankment work Army II Bridge (Km 27+015.00) Structure work Army III Bridge (Km 28+010.00) No activity TL310 Bridge (Km 29+201.00) Structure work Ben Tre Bridge (Km 31+068.00) Structure work Tan Dung Bridge (Km 31+245.05) Structure work Muong Noi Bridge (Km 31+504.50) Structure work TL306I Bridge (Km 33+181.55) Structure work Muong Dao Bridge (Km 33+295.00) Structure work Ben Gao Bridge (Km 35+211.05) Structure work TL305 Bridge (Km 37+951.55) No activity Song Dao Bridge (Km 38+450.05) No activity Phung Nguyen Bridge (Km 39+188.00) No activity Xuan Quang Bridge (Km 41+480.00) Structure work TL306II Bridge (Km 45+834.05) Structure work Lo river Bridge (Km 48+181.30) Structure work
2.3 PACKAGE A3
OctoberTL 323 B Finished
TL 325 B Permission from local authority has not been issued yet.
Bai Bang The contractor stopped work Cam Phu Casting girder Lung Thuong The contractor stopped work TL 320 B Casting Abutment HCM IC The contractor stopped work
XuanThanh Pile work and PCI girder work are completed, Casting stem of A1
TL 315 B Casting precast slab Phai Din Finished TL 320C Prepare concrete A2
RW Flyover Casting pier column; Casting girder in Noi Bai side.
Red River Completed launch girder in Noi Bai side. 29 PCI girders casted.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
16
IC8 Casting girder. Casting Pier and abutment
IC10 Casting girder and Pier, drilling bored piles at P6
CV QL2 Prepare girder bed Phong Chau Casting curb and desk slab Section 1: Km48+360-Km54+000 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km54+000-Km59+600 Earth work and Implement box culvert
Section 3: Km59+600-Km65+390 Embankment work and Implement box and pipe culvert
Section 4: Km65+390-Km69+070 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km69+070-Km73+070 Suspense
Section 6: Km73+070-Km77+620 Excavation & filling work and Implement pipe and box culvert
Section 7: Km77+620-Km80+000 Embankment work and Implement box and pipe culvert
NovemberTL 323 B Finished
TL 325 B Permission from local authority has not been issued yet.
Bai Bang The contractor stopped work Cam Phu Casting girder Lung Thuong The contractor stopped work TL 320 B Casting Abutment HCM IC The contractor stopped work
XuanThanh Pile work and PCI girder work are completed, Casting stem of A1
TL 315 B Casting precast slab Phai Din Finished TL 320C Prepare concrete A2
RW Flyover Casting pier column, Casting girder in Noi Bai side
Red River Completed launch girder in Noi Bai side. 29 PCI girders casted.
IC8 Casting girder. Casting pier and abutment
IC10 Casting girder and pier, drilling bored piles at P6
CV QL2 Prepare girder bed Phong Chau Casting curb and desk slab Section 1: Km48+360-Km54+000 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km54+000-Km59+600 Earth work and Implement box culvert
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
17
Section 3: Km59+600-Km65+390 Embankment work and Implement box and pipe culvert
Section 4: Km65+390-Km69+070 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km69+070-Km73+070 Suspense
Section 6: Km73+070-Km77+620 Excavation & filling work and Implement pipe and box culvert
Section 7: Km77+620-Km80+000 Embankment work and Implement box and pipe culvert
DecemberTL 323 B Finished
TL 325 B Permission from local authority has not been issued yet.
Bai Bang The contractor stopped work Cam Phu Casting girder Lung Thuong The contractor stopped work TL 320 B Casting Abutment HCM IC The contractor stopped work
XuanThanh Pile work and PCI girder work are completed, Casting stem of A1
TL 315 B Casting precast slab Phai Din Finished TL 320C Prepare concrete A2
RW Flyover Casting pier column, Casting girder in NoiBai side
Red River
Completed launch girder in NoiBai side. P3: K0 is completed; P4: K0 segment; P5: cantilever work is completed; P6: casted K13; P7: casted K12 segment; P8: Load test for scaffolding is completed; P9 to A2: casting concrete; 29 PCI Girders casted.
IC8 Casting girder. Casting Pier and abutment
IC10 Casting girder and Pier, drilling bored piles at P6
CV QL2 Prepare girder bed PhongChau Casting curb and desk slab Section 1: Km48+360-Km54+000 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km54+000-Km59+600 Earth work and Implement box culvert
Section 3: Km59+600-Km65+390 Embankment work and Implement box and pipe culvert
Section 4: Km65+390-Km69+070 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km69+070-Km73+070 Suspense
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
18
Section 6: Km73+070-Km77+620 Excavation & filling work and Implement pipe and box culvert
Section 7: Km77+620-Km80+000 Embankment work and Implement box and pipe culvert
2.4 PACKAGE A4
October
Ngoi Lao bridge - Km97+100 Drilling pile of A2 and P3, PCI girder work is now completed
QL32C bypass bridge - Km107+533 Casting girder, Drilling piles of abutment A2 Ngoi Van bridge - Km108+960 Casting girders. Pier column of P1 Dam Nang bridge –Km108+287 Drilling piles of A1 and A2. Prepare girderbed TL321C bridge – Km84+400 Drilling piles for A1 and A2. 1st girder casted
NgoiGianh bridge – Km88+760 Drilling pile for A2, P4. Casting girder, casting pier, blindingstone and sonic test of A1
Section 1: Km80+000-Km85+000 Earth work Section 2: Km85+000-Km89+600 Embankment and filling work Section 3: Km89+600-Km96+200 Earth work Section 4: Km96+200-Km100+000 Embankment and filling work Section 5: Km100+000-Km105+000 Embankment and filling work Section 6: Km105+000-Km109+750 Embankment and filling work
November
Ngoi Lao bridge - Km97+100 Drilling pile of A2 and P3, PCI girder work is now completed
QL32C bypass bridge - Km107+533 Casting girder, Drilling piles of abutment A2 Ngoi Van bridge - Km108+960 Casting girders. Pier column of P1
Dam Nang bridge –Km108+287 Drilling piles of A1 and A2. Prepare girder bed
TL321C bridge – Km84+400 Drilling piles for A1 and A2. 1st girder was casted
Ngoi Gianh bridge – Km88+760 Drilling pile for A2, P4. Casting girder, casting pier, blinding stone and sonic test of A1
Section 1: Km80+000 - Km85+000 Earth work Section 2: Km85+000 - Km89+600 Embankment and filling work Section 3: Km89+600 - Km96+200 Earth workSection 4: Km96+200 - Km100+000 Embankment and filling work Section 5: Km100+000 - Km105+000 Embankment and filling work Section 6: Km105+000 - Km109+750 Embankment and filling work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
19
December
Ngoi Lao bridge - Km97+100 Drilling pile of A2 and P3, PCI girder work is now completed
QL32C bypass bridge - Km107+533 Casting girder, Drilling piles of abutment A2 Ngoi Van bridge - Km108+960 Casting girders. Pier column of P1
Dam Nang bridge –Km108+287 Drilling piles of A1 and A2. Prepare girder bed
TL321C bridge – Km84+400 Drilling piles for A1 and A2. 1st girder was casted
Ngoi Gianh bridge – Km88+760 Drilling pile for A2, P4. Casting girder, casting pier, blinding stone and sonic test of A1
Section 1: Km80+000 - Km85+000 Earth work Section 2: Km85+000 - Km89+600 Embankment and filling work Section 3: Km89+600 - Km96+200 Earth workSection 4: Km96+200 - Km100+000 Embankment and filling work Section 5: Km100+000 - Km105+000 Embankment and filling work Section 6: Km105+000 - Km109+750 Embankment and filling work
2.5 PACKAGE A5
OctoberVan Phu bridge – Km114+100.05 Structure work Hop Minh My bridge – Km118+920.05 Structure work Ngoi Lau bridge – Km120+615.85 No activity QL 37 bridge – Km121+433.05 Structure work Ngoi Gua bridge – Km128+665.46 Structure work Ngoi Rao bridge – Km130+916.30 No activity Ngoi Thu bridge – Km136+108.35 No activity Ngoi Thap bridge – Km138+447.15 No activity Ngoi Vien bridge – Km140+788.50 Structure work Xuan Thu bridge – Km141+483.55 No activity Ngoi Thia bridge – Km145+434.05 Structure work Ngoi Buc bridge – Km 150+704.65 No activity Section 1: Km109+750 - Km115+800 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km115+800 - Km120+000 Excavation & filling work Section 3: Km120+000 - Km125+000 Excavation & filling work Section 4: Km125+000 - Km130+000 Excavation & filling work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
20
Section 5: Km130+000 - Km136+400 Excavation & filling work Section 6: Km136+400 - Km142+000 Excavation & filling work Section 7: Km142+000 - Km148+000 Excavation & filling work Section 8: Km148+000 - Km150+900 Excavation & filling work
NovemberVan Phu bridge – Km114+100.05 No activity Hop Minh My bridge – Km118+920.05 Structure work Ngoi Lau bridge – Km120+615.85 No activity QL 37 bridge – Km121+433.05 Structure work Ngoi Gua bridge – Km128+665.46 Structure work Ngoi Rao bridge – Km130+916.30 No activity Ngoi Thu bridge – Km136+108.35 No activity Ngoi Thap bridge – Km138+447.15 No activity Ngoi Vien bridge – Km140+788.50 Structure work Xuan Thu bridge – Km141+483.55 No activity Ngoi Thia bridge – Km145+434.05 Structure work Ngoi Buc bridge – Km 150+704.65 No activity Section 1: Km109+750 - Km115+800 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km115+800 - Km120+000 Excavation & filling work Section 3: Km120+000 - Km125+000 Excavation & filling work Section 4: Km125+000 - Km130+000 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km130+000 - Km136+400 Excavation & filling work Section 6: Km136+400 - Km142+000 Excavation & filling work Section 7: Km142+000 - Km148+000 Excavation & filling work Section 8: Km148+000 - Km150+900 Excavation & filling work
DecemberVan Phu bridge – Km114+100.05 Structure work Hop Minh My bridge – Km118+920.05 Structure work Ngoi Lau bridge – Km120+615.85 No activity QL 37 bridge – Km121+433.05 Structure work Ngoi Gua bridge – Km128+665.46 Structure work Ngoi Rao bridge – Km130+916.30 No activity Ngoi Thu bridge – Km136+108.35 No activity Ngoi Thap bridge – Km138+447.15 No activity Ngoi Vien bridge – Km140+788.50 Structure work Xuan Thu bridge – Km141+483.55 No activity Ngoi Thia bridge – Km145+434.05 Structure work
Ngoi Buc bridge – Km 150+704.65 Structure work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
21
Section 1: Km109+750 - Km115+800 Excavation & filling work
Section 2: Km115+800 - Km120+000 Excavation & filling work
Section 3: Km120+000 - Km125+000 Excavation & filling work Section 4: Km125+000 - Km130+000 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km130+000 - Km136+400 Excavation & filling work Section 6: Km136+400 - Km142+000 Excavation & filling work Section 7: Km142+000 - Km148+000 Excavation & filling work Section 8: Km148+000 - Km150+900 Excavation & filling work
2.6 PACKAGE A6
OctoberKhe Chuong bridge – Km153+355.05 Structure work Ngoi That bridge – Km155+971.55 Structure work Ngoi Rom bridge- Km157+517.05 No activity Ngoi Cong bridge – Km159+207.85 Structure work Ngoi Giam I bridge – Km162+896.35 Structure work Ngoi Giam II bridge – Km163+126.00 Structure work Ngoi Hut bridge – Km165+110.50 No activity Ngoi Chac bridge – Km169+412.00 Structure work Ngoi Pha bridge – Km170+312.50 Structure work Suoi Quan bridge – Km173+434.00 Structure work Ngoi Nhuoc bridge – Km176+661.85 No activity Lang Nhay bridge – Km182+164.00 Structure work Lang Lau bridge – Km184+057.95 Structure work Ngoi Don bridge – Km185+077.75 Structure work Dai Viet bridge – Km186+902.05 Structure work Van Xuan bridge – Km187+141.55 Structure work Suoi Nau bridge – Km188+766.00 Structure work Lang Nheo flyover – Km173+929 Structure work Section 1: Km150+900 - Km156+000 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km156+000 - Km162+000 Excavation & filling work Section 3: Km162+000 - Km165+000 Excavation & filling work Section 4: Km165+000 - Km168+000 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km168+000 - Km172+000 Excavation & filling work Section 6: Km172+000 - Km176+713 Excavation & filling work Section 7: Km176+713 - Km182+214 Excavation & filling work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
22
Section 8: Km182+214 - Km186+200 Excavation & filling work Section 9: Km186+730 - Km190+420 Excavation & filling work Tunnel (Km 186+200 – Km 186+730) Excavation
NovemberKhe Chuong bridge – Km153+355.05 Structure work Ngoi That bridge – Km155+971.55 Structure work Ngoi Rom bridge- Km157+517.05 No activity Ngoi Cong bridge – Km159+207.85 Structure work Ngoi Giam I bridge – Km162+896.35 Structure work Ngoi Giam II bridge – Km163+126.00 Structure work Ngoi Hut bridge – Km165+110.50 Structure work Ngoi Chac bridge – Km169+412.00 Structure work Ngoi Pha bridge – Km170+312.50 Structure work Suoi Quan bridge – Km173+434.00 Structure work Ngoi Nhuoc bridge – Km176+661.85 No activity Lang Nhay bridge – Km182+164.00 Structure work Lang Lau bridge – Km184+057.95 Structure work Ngoi Don bridge – Km185+077.75 Structure work Dai Viet bridge – Km186+902.05 Structure work Van Xuan bridge – Km187+141.55 Structure work Suoi Nau bridge – Km188+766.00 Structure work Lang Nheo flyover – Km173+929 Structure work Section 1: Km150+900 - Km156+000 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km156+000 - Km162+000 Excavation & filling work Section 3: Km162+000 - Km165+000 Excavation & filling work Section 4: Km165+000 - Km168+000 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km168+000 - Km172+000 Excavation & filling work Section 6: Km172+000 - Km176+713 Excavation & filling work Section 7: Km176+713 - Km182+214 Excavation & filling work Section 8: Km182+214 - Km186+200 Excavation & filling work Section 9: Km186+730 - Km190+420 Excavation & filling work Tunnel (Km 186+200 – Km 186+730) Excavation & filling work
DecemberKhe Chuong bridge – Km153+355.05 Structure work Ngoi That bridge – Km155+971.55 Structure work Ngoi Rom bridge- Km157+517.05 No activity Ngoi Cong bridge – Km159+207.85 Structure work Ngoi Giam I bridge – Km162+896.35 Structure work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
23
Ngoi Giam II bridge – Km163+126.00 Structure work Ngoi Hut bridge – Km165+110.50 Structure work Ngoi Chac bridge – Km169+412.00 Structure work Ngoi Pha bridge – Km170+312.50 Structure work Suoi Quan bridge – Km173+434.00 Structure work Ngoi Nhuoc bridge – Km176+661.85 No activity
Lang Nhay bridge – Km182+164.00 Structure work
Lang Lau bridge – Km184+057.95 Structure work Ngoi Don bridge – Km185+077.75 Structure work Dai Viet bridge – Km186+902.05 Structure work Van Xuan bridge – Km187+141.55 Structure work Suoi Nau bridge – Km188+766.00 Structure work Lang Nheo flyover – Km173+929 Structure work Section 1: Km150+900 - Km156+000 Excavation & filling work Section 2: Km156+000 - Km162+000 Excavation & filling work Section 3: Km162+000 - Km165+000 Excavation & filling work Section 4: Km165+000 - Km168+000 Excavation & filling work Section 5: Km168+000 - Km172+000 Excavation & filling work Section 6: Km172+000 - Km176+713 Excavation & filling work Section 7: Km176+713 - Km182+214 Excavation & filling work Section 8: Km182+214 - Km186+200 Excavation & filling work Section 9: Km186+730 - Km190+420 Excavation & filling work Tunnel (Km 186+200 – Km 186+730) Excavation & filling work
2.7 PACKAGE A7
OctoberKhe Sang Brdge No activated Khe Can Bridge No activated Tan Tien Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each;
PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each ; A2 Structure concrete class C2: 76m3
Thin Thung II Bridge P1 (right); P1 (left): Structure concrete class C2: 200m3, 31.9m3
Tan An Bridge No activated Xom Danh Bridge Structure concrete class C2: 100.0m3
Ram AII Bridge No activated Xom Cam Bridge Cast-in-place concrete pile (A1, A2): 12m
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
24
Ngoi Bong Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each Tan Thuong Bridge No activated Khe Hong Bridge P4: Structure concrete class C2: 30m3
Cam Con Bridge Structure excavation without cofferdam: 200m3
Chau Que Rhuong Bridge A2, P1: Structure concrete class C2: 56.9m3;24m3
Ram B Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each Section 1: Km190+420-Km201+000 No activated Section 2: Km201+000-Km207+000 No activated Section 3: Km207+000-Km218+040 Common excavation and Unsuitable material
NovemberKhe Sang Brdge No activated Khe Can Bridge No activated Tan Tien Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each;
PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each ; A2 Structure concrete class C2: 76m3
Thin Thung II Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each; A2 Structure concrete class C2
Tan An Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each Xom Danh Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each Ram AII Bridge PC voided slab, length 18m: 2 each Xom Cam Bridge Structure concrete at A1, A2 Ngoi Bong Bridge No activated Tan Thuong Bridge Structure concrete at A1, A2 Khe Hong Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each;
casting bore pile: 24m Cam Con Bridge Structure concrete at P1 Chau Que Rhuong Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each Ram B Bridge Launching girder Section 1: Km190+420-Km201+000 Granular back fill; Common excavation:
3000m3; Aggregate subbase: 2000m3;Aggregate base: 3000 m3
Section 2: Km201+000-Km207+000 Granular back fill; Subbase preparation: 1000m2; Aggregate subbase: 2000 m3
Section 3: Km207+000-Km218+040 Common excavation and Unsuitable material December
Khe Sang Bridge No activate Khe Can Bridge Finished top slab Tan Tien Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each;
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
25
PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each ; A2 Structure concrete class C2: 76m3
Thin Thung II Bridge PC-I girder long: 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each; A2 Structure concrete class C2
Tan An Bridge Launching girder Xom Danh Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each Ram AII Bridge PC voided slab, length 18m: 2 each Xom Cam Bridge Structure concrete at A1, A2 Ngoi Bong Bridge No activate Tan Thuong Bridge Structure concrete at A1, A2
Khe Hong Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each; casting bore pile: 24m
Cam Con Bridge Structure concrete at P1 Chau Que Rhuong Bridge PC-I girder long: 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each Ram B Bridge Launching girder
Section1: Km190+420-Km201+000 Granular back fill; Common excavation: 3000m3; Aggregate subbase: 2000m3; Aggregate base: 3000m3
Section2: Km201+000-Km207+000 Granular back fill; Subbase preparation: 1000m2; Aggregate subbase: 2000m3
Section3: Km207+000-Km218+040 Common excavation and Unsuitable material
2.8 PACKAGE A8
OctoberIC18 Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 15m
Suoi Trat Bridge Structural concrete G: 9.7m3; Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 30m
Ngoi Bo Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 31m Suoi Nhu Bridge PC-I girder, length 33m, height 1.65m: 1each
Lang Tra Bridge PC-I girder length 33m, height 1.65m: 1 each; Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 42m
IC17 Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 28m
Son Ha Bridge PC-I girder length 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each; Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 16m
Son Hai Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 7m C u Xuân Giao Structure concrete class C: 124.75m3
Section 1: Km218+080-Km223+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material and common excavation
Section 2: Km223+000-Km225+000 Unsuitable material
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
26
Section 3: Km225+000-Km229+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material Section 4: Km229+000-Km232+000 Common excavation Section 5: Km232+000-Km235+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation Section 6: Km235+000-Km238+000 Common excavation
Section 7: Km238+000-Km241+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material and common excavation
Section 8: Km241+000-Km243+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation Section 9: Km243+000-Km244+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation RAM IC18: Km244+000-Km244+570 No activity
November
IC18 Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 46m; PC-I girder length 24m, height 1.45m: 1 each
Suoi Trat Bridge Structural concrete pier 203.23m3; Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 12m; PC-I girder, length 33m, height 1.65m: 1each
Ngoi Bo Bridge PC-I girder, length 33m, height 1.65m: 1each; Structural concrete pier
Suoi Nhu Bridge Structural concrete pier. abutment Lang Tra Bridge Structural concrete pier. abutment IC17 Bridge Structural concrete pier. abutment Son Ha Bridge Structural concrete pier. abutment Son Hai Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 7m
C u Xuân Giao Structure concrete class C: 124.75m3; PC-I girder, length 33m, height 1.65m
Section 1: Km218+080-Km223+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material and common excavation
Section 2: Km223+000-Km225+000 Unsuitable material Section 3: Km225+000-Km229+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material Section 4: Km229+000-Km232+000 Common excavation Section 5: Km232+000-Km235+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation Section 6: Km235+000-Km238+000 Common excavation
Section 7: Km238+000-Km241+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material and common excavation
Section 8: Km241+000-Km243+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation Section 9: Km243+000-Km244+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation RAM IC18: Km244+000-Km244+570 No activity
December
IC18 Bridge Cast-in-place concrete A1 of RAM Aii, IC18 Bridge
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
27
Suoi Trat Bridge Structural concrete pier 203.23m3; Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 12m; PC-I girder, length 33m, height 1.65m: 1each
Ngoi Bo Bridge PC-I girder, length 33m, height 1.65m: 1each; Structural concrete pier
Suoi Nhu Bridge Structural concrete pier. abutment Lang Tra Bridge Launching girder IC17 Bridge Structural concrete pier. abutment Son Ha Bridge Launching girder Son Hai Bridge Cast-in-place concrete Pile D=1000mm: 7m Xuan Giao Bridge Launching girder
Section1: Km218+080-Km223+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material and common excavation
Section2: Km223+000-Km225+000 Unsuitable material Section3: Km225+000-Km229+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material Section4: Km229+000-Km232+000 Common excavation Section5: Km232+000-Km235+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation Section6: Km235+000-Km238+000 Common excavation
Section7: Km238+000-Km241+000 Back to fill and Unsuitable material and common excavation
Section8: Km241+000-Km243+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation Section9: Km243+000-Km244+000 Unsuitable material and common excavation RAM IC18: Km244+000-Km244+570 No activity
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
28
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
29
3 CARRIED OUT TASKS DURING THE PERIOD
During the period of reference for this quarterly report, the environmental tasks carried out by the specialists in their site offices and for each
package were the following (see table below).
In some cases, weather conditions difficulted so much the movement along the alignment, therefore may be any week it was not possible the
access to site. In other cases, the progress and distribution of the works in the packages, have conditioned especialists to carry out punctual
inspections instead of general ones.
PackageGeneral Inspection1 Punctual Inspection2 Weekly Report
SubmissionLetter/Notification
SubmissionWeekly, Monthly and
Specific Meeting Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
A15, 9,
16, 23, 30
6, 15, 20, 27,
3011, 25 2 21, 29 18
7, 14, 21, 28,
31
3, 10, 17, 24
1, 8, 15, 22,
29
3, 11, 18, 27,
31
6, 8, 22, 23,
293, 14 11, 12 8, 22,
29 -
A23, 10,
17, 24, 31
13, 15, 21, 28 14 15, 16,
30 20
5, 7, 10, 13, 19, 26,
27
7, 14, 21, 28
3, 10, 17, 24
1, 8, 15, 22,
29
3, 8, 11, 19, 27,
31
2, 8, 13, 22, 23, 28, 29
3, 6, 7, 20, 28 11, 12 8, 22,
29 -
A3 01, 08, 22, 25
1, 8, 21, 29
4, 11, 18, 25
5, 11, 18 - 6, 7 8, 15,
22, 295, 12, 19, 26
3, 10, 17, 24,
31
4, 23, 29 16 12, 15,
16, 25 10, 31 22, 28 20, 27
A4 5, 11, 18, 25
02, 12, 17, 30
06, 12, 19, 31 - - - 8, 15,
22, 295, 12, 19, 26
10, 17, 24, 31
15, 23, 25 16 12 11, 25 21, 29 13, 24
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
30
PackageGeneral Inspection1 Punctual Inspection2 Weekly Report
SubmissionLetter/Notification
SubmissionWeekly, Monthly and
Specific Meeting Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
A5 3, 10, 16, 25
2, 10, 20, 26
10, 18, 27
11, 26, 30
16,27,30
4, 17, 21, 28
7, 14, 21, 28
3, 10, 17, 24
1, 8, 15,22, 29
9, 10, 15, 23, 24, 27
9, 13, 21, 28
13, 14, 17, 18, 19, 28
1, 22 5, 19, 26 3, 24
A6 3, 10, 23, 30
5, 13, 21, 27 11, 19 5, 16,
26 6, 8, 24 3, 5, 24, 31
6, 13, 20, 27
3, 10, 17, 24
1, 8, 15, 22,
29
15, 16, 24, 25,
31
7, 8, 9, 13, 21,
28
7, 16, 27 8, 22 5, 19,
26 3, 24
A7 15, 16, 24
13, 15, 20 3, 17 1, 8, 22 6. 27 11, 25 6, 13,
203, 10, 17, 24
8, 15, 22, 29 5 2, 5, 19 26 22, 24 8, 22 6, 20
A8 3, 19 13, 14, 28 14, 28 10, 30 2, 9, 22 7, 18 6, 13,
203, 10, 17, 24
8, 15, 22, 29 2 12 4, 13 26 8, 22 6, 20
1: Inspections along the whole package or, at least, most of its main stations 2: Inspections in one or few locations, generally because of any specific matter or problem
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
31
4 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING RESULTS. COMPLEMENTARY MEASURES TO BE APPLIED
4.1 IMPACT ON AIR QUALITY
As Annex 2.1 there are included the results of the air quality monitoring carried out during the
period of this quarterly report.
Related with the measurement of the parameter PM10, it’s necessary to clarify that there were
taken 3 samples along the day, for a period of 40 minutes each one. Although the standard
value is expressed for a period of 24 hours, the National Technical Regulation on Ambient Air
Quality allows, in point 1.2.3, to consider the “average value” to compare with the standard.
Also, it must be mentioned that as the maximum value measured is lower than the standard for
24 hours, it may be consider that the results of this parameter are under the standards.
So, even the comparation between a punctual measurement and a continous 24 hours
measurement is not available to get exact data for this parameter (PM10), it was considered
that, since it is monitored by the specialists, it could be a good approximation to the real value
and, specially, to the real impact or effect.
It must be also mentioned that there is not a homogeneous methodology between packages,
as the companies which carry out the monitoring of these parameters are different ones in
some of them.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
32
4.1.1 Package A1
Oct 02, 2012
Oct 02, 2012
Location: Package A1
Site visit: 2, 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct
Description: The Contractor has mobilized the water wagon to water affected areas to minimize the spread of airborne dust. In the site inspections, we also didn’t detected the serious problem on site and recommended the Contractor to maintain this status during construction work.
Nov 21, 2012
Location: Km 3+000 ~ Km 7+000
Site visit: 6, 15, 20, 21, 27, 29 Nov
Date first observed: 21-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: The spread of airborne dust was high due to the Contractor didn’t spray water on surface of embankment in regular basis.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer has requested the Contractor to mobilize more water truck to intensify the watering activity in order to mitigate the spread of airborn dust onsite. Refer to the minutes of meeting REF-A1-
Loa
N
D
D
n 2391/2392
Nov 21, 2012
Dec 25, 2012
Dec 25, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
33
GET
Res
Dea
Curmoreissucond
Loc
Site
Desspra
– Hai Phongghway Proje
T1-MOM-67,
sponsible Pa
adline: 21-No
rent status:e equipmente was also mdition
ation: Emba
e visit: 11, 25
scription: Suay water to m
g Transport ect
68
arty: Contrac
ov-2012 (imm
The Contract for each secmitigated due
ankment sect
5
urface of embminimize the s
Corridor
ctor
mediate)
ctor has mobction. Besidee to the wet w
tions
bankment sespread of air
bilized one es, this weather
ections are rborne dust
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
34
4.1.2 Package A2
Oct 17, 2012
Oct 24, 2012
Location: Package A2
Site visit: 3, 10, 15, 16, 17, 24, 30, 31 Oct,
Description: The Contractor has mobilized the water wagon to water affected areas to minimize the spread of airborne dust. In the site inspections, we also didn’t detected the serious problem on site and recommended the Contractor to maintain this status during construction work.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
35
Nov 13, 2012
Oct 21, 2012
Nov 21, 2012
Location: Package A2
Site visit: 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov
Date first observed: 13-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: The spread of airborne dust was high due to the Contractor didn’t spray water on surface of embankment in regular basis.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:The Engineer has requested the Contractor to mobilize more water truck to intensify the watering activity in order to mitigate the spread of airborn dust onsite. Refer to the minutes of meeting:
REF-A2-GET1-MOM-51, 52
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 13-Nov-2012 (immediate)
Current status: The Contractor has mobilized one more equipment for each section. Besides, this issue was also mitigated due to the wet weather condition
Loan 23
Nov 1
Oct 2
Nov 2
91/2392 – VNo
3, 2012
1, 2012
21, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
36
Location
Site visi
Descriptinspectiohas beenarrangedembankmweather
ai Phong Traay Project
n: Embankm
t: 15, 7, 10,
tion: By obsons, we percen mitigated dd the water trment during was wet as w
ansport Corr
ment section
14, 19, 26, 2
servations dueived that th
due to the Coruck to watertransporting well.
rridor
27 Dec
uring the site e spread of d
ontractor hasr the surfacematerial and
dusts of d the
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
37
4.1.3 Package A3
Results of air quality monitoring (carried out by Green Environment Engineering Joint Stock
Company in the forth quarter 2012) showed that construction works did not affect to ambient
air quality. Results of air quality analysis are compared with QCVN 05:2009 / BTNMT: National
Technical Regulation on ambient air quality and QCVN 06:2009 / BTNMT: The national
standards on a number of toxic substances in ambient air measured as Annex 2.1. Results
obtained showed that air quality is acceptable in package A3.
4.1.4 Package A4
Results of air quality monitoring (carried out by Green Environment Engineering Joint Stock
Company in the forth quarter 2012) showed that construction works did not affect to ambient
air quality. Results obtained are compared with QCVN 05:2009 / BTNMT: National Technical
Regulation on ambient air quality and QCVN 06:2009 / BTNMT: The national standards on a
number of toxic substances in ambient air measured as Annex 2.1.
3rd October, 2012
Location: Km114
Site visit: October, 3 and 16
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s truck was not covered with canvas during material transportation.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The whole contractor’s trucks must be covered with canvas during material transportation, at the same time, the Contractor must apply suitable measures in order to minimize dust during material transportation
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 13, 2012
Current status:
No improvement seen
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
38
16th October, 2012
02-November 2012
Location: TL321C Bridge
Site visit: 02, 12, 17, 30– November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 02 – November 2012
Problems description and cause: Local road is full of mud, so, when dry and windy days, this mud flies in the atmosphere causing a big amount of dust, that impacts on local people and is deposited on the fields
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to frequently clean local road and water it
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 30/12/2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
39
17-November 2012
06-December 2012
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
40
4.1.5 Package A5
Through the site inspection in this quarter, the Consultant found that the construction activities
and transportation of raw materials by the Contractor have not caused serious impact on the
regional air quality. In addition, October had many rainy days, so the amount of dust generated
during the execution of the project has been decreased due to this natural factor.
However, there are still some outstanding issues have not yet been addressed by the
Contractor:
October
- The Contractor has not watered to minimize dust generated in the transportation process of
raw materials as at a number of stations such as: Km112 – Km113, Km114 – Km115, Km116
– Km117, Km148, Km123... This has generated dust, especially in the hot and windy days.
- At Km111 – Km112, Km116 - Km117, Km128 – Km130, Km138... the Contractor's trucks
were still not fully equipped with canvas during transportation process.
2nd November, 2012
Location: Km148
Site visit: November, 2 and 27
Date first observed: 2-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s truck was not covered with canvas during material transportation.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The whole contractor’s trucks must be covered with canvas during material transportation, at the same time, the Contractor must apply suitable measures in order to minimize dust during material transportation
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: November 15, 2012
Current status: Some trucks of the Contractor were covered with canvas during material
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
41
27th November, 2012
transportation.
November
- At stations Km111 - Km112, Km116 - Km117, Km128, Km136 - Km138 ... the Contractor's
trucks did still not fully use canvases during transporting materials.
- At stations Km112 - Km113, Km114 - Km115, Km116 - Km117, Km126... the Contractor has
not applied adequate measures to minimize dust generated, such as: watering on the access
roads and construction locations; this was the cause of dust generated, especially in the sunny
and windy days in these areas.
- In areas such as batching plant No. 1 (Km123), batching No. 2 (Km132), batching plant No. 3
(Km145), the fuel stations of the Contractor were not covered carefully with canvases.
10th December, 2012
Location: Km129
Site visit: December, 10 and 18
Date first observed: 10-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s truck was not covered with canvas during material transportation.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The whole contractor’s trucks must be covered with canvas during material transportation, at the same time, the Contractor must apply suitable measures
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
42
18th December, 2012
in order to minimize dust during material transportation
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: December 17, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
December
- The Contractor has not fulfilled the instructions of Consultant about applying measures to
minimize dust generated during the construction and transportation process of raw materials,
so on some hot days, dust was still created cause such as at Km111, Km114, Km116,
Km129...
- Many Contractor's truck were still not covered wirh canvases during transporting materials at
Km114, Km117, Km129...
- Soil dropped on the transporting roads has not been collected by the Contractor at Km148,
Km119...
4.1.6 Package A6
23rd October, 2012
Location: Km156
Site visit: October, 23 and 30
Date first observed: 23-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s material transportation and construction activities are causing the dusty at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must apply suitable measures in order to minimize dust during material transportation. Referring to the letter Ref.GET3-
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
43
30th October, 2012
DOOSAN-12-A6-1066 dated 24th October, 2012.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 26, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has sprayed water on the access roads and construction site in order to minimize dust during project implementation.
In October the Consultant found that the construction activities and transportation of raw
materials of the Contractor has caused a state of dust, influencing the air environment at a
number of stations such as: Km154 - Km158; Km159; Km161 - Km162; Km165; Km174;
Km176.... The reason is that the Contractor did not apply adequate measures to minimize
dust: the trucks were not covered, the watering was not enough frequently, soil dropped was
not collected...
23rd October, 2012
Location: Km152
Site visit: October, 23 and November, 15
Date first observed: 23-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s truck was not covered with canvas during material transportation.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The whole contractor’s trucks must be covered with canvas during material transportation, at the same time, the Contractor must apply suitable measures in order to minimize dust during material transportation.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 30, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has sprayed water on the access roads and construction site in order to
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
44
15th November, 2012
minimize dust during project implementation. Simultaneously, some trucks of the Contractor have been covered with canvas during material transportation.
In November, the Consultant found that the Contractor has adopted a number of measures to
minimize the dust generated during the construction and transportation of raw materials,
reducing significantly the amount of dust generated during the execution of the project:
- Some trucks were covered with canvases during material transportation.
- The Contractor conducted watering to minimize dust during construction and materials
transportation such as at: Km156, Km159, Km160, Km174, Km154, Km180,...
However, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- At station Km159, Km160, Km165, Km174, Km155... soil from the project came down the
access roads, but the Contractor has not collected and cleaned this way, this is the cause of
dust when the media going through this area.
- At station Km189, Km186, Km176... the watering work has not been done often. Thus, on
some hot day, the dust still arised during the transportation process of raw materials in the
region.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
45
11st December, 2012
20th December, 2012
Location: Km181
Site visit: December, 11 and 20
Date first observed: 11-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s material transportation and construction activities are causing the dusty at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer requires the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to minimize dust during material transportation.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: December 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has sprayed water on the access roads and construction site in order to minimize dust during project implementation.
In December the Contractor has continued to conduct activities to reduce dust generated
during the construction process and transportation of raw materials:
- At Km156, Km158, Km160, Km165, Km176, Km186, Km190... the watering on the
transportation roads of raw materials was still conducted by the Contractor.
- At Km165, Km162, Km174... the Contractor has collected soil dropped on the transporting
roads.
- Some trucks were equipped with canvases by the Contractor during materials transportation.
Even so, on sunny and windy days, the watering work was not done with appropriate
frequency, so the transportation of raw materials has caused dust, impacting the air
environment.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
46
In addition, several trucks of the Contractor were not carefully covered by canvases during
transporting materials at Km154, Km164, Km174, Km180.
4.1.7 Package A7
In October 2012 the contractor construction works the base and subbase layers at section1;
section2 and section3 with watering car according to project regulation in order to mitigate the
concentration of dust avoid effect to local people.
So consultant required the contractor to consequences watering in order to mitigate
concentration of dust avoid effect to local people.
31.10.2012
15.11.2012
Location: Km209+329
Site visit: 31-Oct; 15-November 2012; 17-Dec 2012
Date first observed: 31-Oct 2012; 15 Nov; 17 Dec
Problems description and cause: The exist road many dust
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contactor is requested to watering frequency in order to decrease dust concentration on the exist road
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Frequency
Current status: Not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
47
17.12.2012
4.1.8 Package A8
In October and December 2012 the contractor construction works the base and subbase
layers at Km238-Km239+300 with watering car according to project regulation in order to
mitigate the concentration of dust avoid effect to local people. Hence during the transfer
material (base and subbase) the contractor has not consequence watering along the exits
road, these are effects to local people, especial at Km218+040- Km225+000. So consultant
required the contractor to implement watering in order to mitigate concentration of dust and
avoid effect to local people.
Results of the Contractor air quality monitoring (carried out by Green Environment Engineering
Joint Stock Company in November 2012) showed that construction works not effected to
ambient air quality. Results of air quality analysis are compared with QCVN 05:2009 / BTNMT:
National Technical Regulation on ambient air quality and QCVN 06:2009 / BTNMT: The
national standards on a number of toxic substances in ambient air measured as Annex 2.1.
4.2 IMPACT ON WATER RESOURCES
As Annex 2.2 there are included the results of the water quality monitoring carried out during
the period of this quarterly report.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
48
4.2.1 Package A1
Oct 16, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Location: Package A1
Site visit: 2, 5, 9, 16, 23, 30
Description: During the site inspections this month, we didn’t detect any serious problem that araises from construction activity affecting water quality.
During the site inspections in November and December 2012, we didn’t detect any serious problem affecting water quality, specially in November, when no construction works were carried out closing to water resources.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
49
4.2.2 Package A2
Oct 10, 2012
Oct 24, 2012
Location: CBP 1 of Lo River Bridge
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31
Date first observed: 22-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: Settlingponds are full and untreated wastewater spilled over the water resource
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Remove sediment from settling ponds to disposal places; handle surfaced wastewater into settling ponds. Prohibit discharge of untreated wastewater offsite. Refer to letter GET1/POS/A2/1484
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 07-Sep-2012 (immediate)
Current status: Mitigation measures have been implemented
In November 2012, by observation in the site inspections, we didn’t detect any serious problem affecting water quality because there is almost none construction work carried out closing to water resources.
In December 2012, during the site inspections, we didn’t detect any serious matter that arises from construction work affecting the water resources quality. At the sections that the construction work being close or over the water resources such as Tan Dung Bridge, Muong Dao Bridge, Ben Gao Bridge and Lo River Bridge, we didn’t find the leak of hazardous substances into water resources.
At Muong Noi Bridge, the Contractor is mobilizing the bentonite for bored pile work; the Engineer has instructed the Contractor to install the sediment basin as well as the surface
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
50
drainage to handle the bentonite slurry in case of spilling-over of bentonite slurry on ground in order to prevent leaking of it into water resource.
4.2.3 Package A3
Results of water quality monitoring in this quarter (carried out by Green Environment
Engineering Joint Stock Company), showed that construction works did not affect ambient
water quality. Results of surface water quality analysis are compared with QCVN
08:2008/BTNMT - National Technical Regulations on surface water quality and included in
Annex 2.2. As it can be proved, the monitored parameters are within permitted limits under by
the mentioned regulation.
4.2.4 Package A4
The results of the analysis of quality of surface water for the three months of the quarter,
showed in the tables in Annex 2.2, indicate that the monitoring items are within permitted limits
under by regulation Vietnam QCVN 08:2008/ BTNMT, column B1. So, construction works did
not affect to ambient water quality.
12 - November 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 02, 12, 17, 30- November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 12 - November 2012
Problems description and cause: Disposalarea is not followed the regulation which can cause sliding when it rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-November 2012
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
51
17-November 2012
06-December 2012
4.2.5 Package A5
3rd October, 2012
Location: Km123
Site visit: October, 3 and 26
Date first observed: 19-Jun-2012
Problems description and cause: Soil has been slid into Y Can lake.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must:
- Remove spoils and dispose into approved disposal
sites.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
52
26th October, 2012
- Ensure that spoils are only dumped to disposal
sites approved by local authorities and the
Consultant and that appropriate stabilization.
Responsible Party: Keangnam Contractor
Deadline: October 15, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen for this work
In October, the Contractor's major construction item is ground work (excavation, embankment,
etc.) and construction of piers and abutment of bridge, ... so there was no arisen substance
that affect seriously on the water quality of the area. However, the environment management
and control of the Contractor have not been done well; there are still some outstanding issues
as follows:
- At Van Phu bridge area, there is no improvement on the bentonite control during the
construction process.
- Waste water treatment system in the batching plant No. 1 (Km123) was severely damaged.
However, the Contractor has failed to carry out repairs to the system.
- At some workers’ camps such as: Km130, Km148, Km120 ... wastewater treatment system
has not been built by the Contractor. Thus, waste water from camps' area still flows freely.
24th September, 2012
Location: Batching plant No.1 Km123
Site visit: September, 24 and November, 10
Date first observed: 24-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Waste water treatment system was seriously damaged, but the Contractor did not repair this system.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to repair waste water treatment system at this batching plant.
Responsible Party: Keangnam Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
53
10th November, 2012
Deadline: Oct 10, 2012
Current status: Not yet repaired.
In November, the Consultant found that the region's water quality was not seriously affected by
the Contractor's construction activities. However, due to the environment management and
control of Contractor were not good in some areas, a number of issues has been remained as
follows:
- The Contractor has carried out road construction in the area Ngoi Thia bridge, but the sewers
have not been fully installed; this has affected the flow of the river as well as the quality of river
water.
- The Contractor has not repaired the wastewater treatment system in the batching Plan No. 1.
- At a number of workers’ camps such as: Km130, Km145, Km120 ... wastewater treatment
systems have not been built by the Contractor, so the waste water from camps has still flown
directly into the environment.
30th November, 2012
Location: Km129
Site visit: November, 30 and December,18
Date first observed: 30-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: In the area of Ngoi Thia brigde, the Contractor has not complied fully with the Method Statement and continued to pour soil down to the river to create access roads in the construction process. This has affected flow of the river in this area.
Recommendation and Action taken by
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
54
18th December, 2012
Engineer:
The Contractor must install adequate number and size of culverts throughout the Ngoi Thia bridge site temporary access.
Simultaneously, the Contractor must implement the instructions from the Engineer (Regarding to the letter, Ref. GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1112)
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: December 16, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
In December, through, the Contractor's construction activities generally have not caused
serious impacts on the water quality of the area. However, there are still some outstanding
issues as follows:
- In the area of Ngoi Thia brigde, the Contractor has not complied fully with the Method
Statement and continued to pour soil down to the river to create access roads in the
construction process. This has affected flow of the river in this area. This may be the cause of
the erosion of river banks. This situation is very dangerous, especially in the days of heavy rain
or during the upcoming rainy season, when the water level in the river will rise quickly and can
destroy the entire access roads of the Contractor. This has not just affected the safety of the
project, but also affected the water quality and river flow in this region.
- At the camps in some areas such as Km130, Km112, Km128,... the Contractor has still not
built waste water treatment systems, so waste water from camp areas was still discharged
directly into the environment.
- At Km124 areas, soil eroded and slided down to Ykan lake area; however, the Contractor has
not collected and move the soil eroded to the disposal area.
During the inspections on site weekly, the Consultant has requested the Contractor to resolve
these outstanding issues. Besides, the Consultant has frequently required the Contractor to
comply with the Method Statement and the Environment Control Plan during construction
process.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
55
4.2.6 Package A6
10th October, 2012
30th October, 2012
Location: North portal of the tunnel Km186+720
Site visit: October 10 and 30
Date first observed: 10-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Waste water treatment system still has not been constructed by the contractor, during construction waste water is running directly into surrounding environmental.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer strongly requires the Contractor to immediately construct and complete Waste water Treatment System at Tunnel area to meet the requirements from Method Statement approved by the Engineer mentioned in the letter No.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-393.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 19, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already installed temporary waste water treatment system at this location.
In October, through the inspection and supervision on site, the Consultant found that the
Contractor's construction activities have not caused serious impacts on the regional water
quality.
The wastewater treatment system in the batching areas: Km165, Km184, Km180 were still
maintained in good conditions.
This month, the Contractor has completed and begin operating the waste water treatment
system in the south portal of the tunnel Km186+200, and the temporary waste water treatment
system at the north portal of the tunnel Km186 +720 was also constructed.
However, at several workers' camps: Km176, Km187, Km186 ... the wastewater treatment
system has not been built by the Contractor; waste water from the camps still charged directly
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
56
into the environment. The Consultant has reminded and requested the Contractor to resolve
the outstanding issues in the site inspections.
3rd July, 2012
16th July, 2012
Location: The South Portal of the tunnel’s construction site Km186+200
Site visit: July, 3, 16 and October, 10
Date first observed: Jul-3-2012
Problems description and cause: Wastewater treatment system was not completed at the South Portal of the tunnel’s construction site Km186+200.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor is requested to immediately carry out construction of waste water treatment system at the tunnel areas to meet the Project’s requirements. Regarding to the letter Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-457.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: July 16, 2012
Current status: Wastewater treatment system has already been completed at the South Portal of the tunnel’s construction site Km186+200.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
57
10th October, 2012
In November, the Consultant found that the region's water quality was not seriously affected by
the Contractor's construction activities. Most of them did not create hazardous substances
which cause serious impact on the regional water quality.
The wastewater treatment system at the batching plants located in Km165, Km184, Km180
were still maintained. In addition, the wastewater treatment system in the south tunnel area
Km186+200 has been put into use, the temporary waste water treatment system in the north
portal of the tunnel Km186+720 was also constructed.
However, the wastewater treatment systems have not been built by the Contractor at some
areas of workers' camps such as Lang Nau bridge, Ngoi Don bridge, Km187, ... The waste
water from camps area still flows directly into the environment. The Consultant has reminded
and requested the Contractor to solve the outstanding issues in the site inspections.
15th November, 2012
Location: White stone vina’s batching plant Km184
Site visit: November,15 and December, 19
Date first observed: 15-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Waste water treatment system is not good condition;
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to repair and improve this waste-water treatment system.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
58
19th December, 2012
Deadline: November 30, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already repaired this waste water treatment system.
In December, the Contractor's construction activities have not caused serious impact on the
regional water quality, most of them has not created hazardous substances that impact
seriously the water quality.
In addition, the waste water treatment systems in areas of batching plants such as at Km165,
Km184, Km180, Km165 were still maintained operation by the Contractor.
In the south port of the tunnel Km186+200, the waste water treatment system was still ensured
by the Contractor.
However, there are some outstanding issues that have not been solved by the Contractor such
as
- In the north port of the tunnel Km186+720, the temporary waste water treatment system of
the Contractor has been operated, but it has not fully met the requirements of the project.
During the inspection on site, the Consultant has requested the Contractor to build the
wastewater treatment systems which meet the Method Statement in this area.
- In some camps areas such as at bridges Lang Lau, Ngoi Don, Km187, bridge Lang Lau,...
the wastewater treatment system has not been built by the Contractor, so the waste water from
camps area was still discharged directly into the environment.
To ensure the regional water quality, the Consultant has asked the Contractor to resolve the
outstanding issues. Also, the Consultant has frequently reminded the Contractor to comply
with the Method Statement and the Environment Control Plan during construction process.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
59
4.2.7 Package A7
05-September 2012
15-October 2012
Location: Xom Danh BridgeKm198+400
Site visit: 05-Sept and 15-October 2012
Date first observed: 16-May 2012
Problems description and cause: Thecontractor improved the settling pond to ensure the waste water of CBP are treated before discharge to water resource
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contactor had carry out according to consultant instructions
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-Sept 2012
Current status: Had improved
21-September 2012
Location: Khe Sang Bridge Km191+353
Site visit: 21-Sept and 15-October 2012
Date first observed: 16-May 2012
Problems description and cause: Thecontractor improved the settling pond to ensure the waste water of CBP are treated before discharge to water resource
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contactor had carry out according to consultant instructions
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
60
15-October 2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-Sept 2012
Current status: Had improved
25-September 2012
08-October 2012
Location: Tan Thuong Bridge Km199+050
Site visit: 25-Sept and 08-October 2012
Date first observed: 16-May 2012
Problems description and cause: The contractor improved the settling pond to ensure the waste water of CBP are treated before discharge to water resource
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contactor had carry out according to consultant instructions
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-Sept 2012
Current status: Had improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
61
24-July 2012
01-October 2012
Location: Tan Tien Bridge Km209+329
Site visit: 24-July and 01-October 2012;
Date first observed: 16-May 2012
Problems description and cause: Thecontractor improved the settling pond to ensure the waste water of CBP are treated before discharge to water resource
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contactor had carry out according to consultant instructions
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-Sept 2012
Current status: Had improved
25.12.2012
Location: Km209+329
Site visit: 25.12.2012
Date first observed: 25.12.2012
Problems description and cause: The contractor pouring earth near water source, it effect to flow rate and water quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to clear flow, stability slope and plan grass to avoid landslide and erosion.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
62
25.12.2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15.1.2013
4.2.8 Package A8
10-October 2012
2-November 2012
Location: CBP Suoi Nhu Km218+040
Site visit: 10-October and 2-November 2012
Date first observed: 10-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Thesettling ponds many mud and sands
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor is requested to dredge frequency and maintain the efficiency of settling ponds
Responsible Party: 30-October 2012
Deadline:
Current status: The contractor on going the dredge according to the consultant instructions
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
63
19-October 2012
02-November 2012
22-November 2012
Location: A2 Abutment of Son Hai Bridge Km227+065
Site visit: 19-October and 2, 22-November 2012; 27 December 2012
Date first observed: 19-October 2012,
Problems description and cause: Thewaste of the bore pipe process ware not guided into settling pond before discharge water source around
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor had provided the settling pond, but so far, the settling ponds had flooded by water and not capacity to treatment the wastewater.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 10-November 2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
64
27.12.2012
Results of the Contractor water quality monitoring (carried out by Green Environment
Engineering Joint Stock Company in November 2012) showed that construction works not
effected to ambient water quality. Results of surface water quality analysis are compared with
QCVN 08:2008 / BTNMT - National Technical Regulations on surface water quality as Annex
2.2.
4.3 IMPACT ON SOILS QUALITY
4.3.1 Package A1
Oct 05, 2012
Location: Tan Loi Bridge, Xuan Phuong Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 October and 6, 15, 20, 21, 27, 29 November; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: due to the unsuitable working methods, the riversides were undermined and this caused landslide on them. Up to now, the Contractor still has not restored these areas
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Apply riverside protection measures and restored affected area. Refer to the
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
65
Oct 05, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Nov 06, 2012
minutes of meeting REF-A1-GET1-MOM-66, 67, 68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 30-Jun-2012 (immediate)
Current status: The Contractor has not submitted the plan to restore these areas
Dec 25
Dec
Loan 23
Nov 2
5, 2012 (Xu
c 25, 2012
91/2392 – VNo
29, 2012
uan Phuong
(Tan Loi Br
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
g Bridge)
ridge)
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
66
ai Phong Traay Project
ansport Corrrridor
Loa
N
N
D
n 2391/2392
ov 20, 2012
ov 27, 2012
ec 11, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
67
Loc
Site
Dat
Prowersideons
RecEngandto ame
Res
Dea
Curbee
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: Ba T
e visit: 6, 1
te first obs
oblems desre put in dise and causesite
commendagineer: Keed upside poapproved dieting REF-A
sponsible P
adline: 20-N
rrent statusen impleme
g Transport ect
Thien Bridg
5, 20, 21, 2
served: 20-N
scription ansorder on sited the leak
ation and Aep oil barrelsition. Remsposal placA1-GET1-M
Party: Cont
Nov-2012 (
s: Mitigationted
Corridor
ge
27, 29 Nov;
Nov-2012
nd cause: Ote and in lyiof oil and p
Action takels in proper
move the polce. Refer to MOM-67, 68
tractor
immediate)
n measure
11, 25 Dec
Oil barrels ing on their
polluted soil
n by ly storage lluted soil minutes of
8
has not
c
r
4.3.2 Pac
Loan 23
Dec 1
ckage A2
Oct 03
Oct 17
91/2392 – VNo
1, 2012
3, 2012
7, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
68
Locatio
Site vis20, 21, 2
Date fir
ProblemContamrestoredinto crop
RecommEngineefor negoassets;sedimenhappeniGET1/P50, 51, 5
Respon
Deadlin
Current
ai Phong Traay Project
on: Km 42+2
sit: 3, 10, 1028 Nov; 14,
rst observe
ms descripminated agricd and the sepland
mendationer: Contactotiation to coapply the snt control ming in the fu
POS/A2/14252
nsible Party
ne: 04-Aug-
t status:
ansport Corr
200 ~ Km 4
0, 17, 24, 30, 27 Dec
ed:
ption and caculture landediment is c
n and Actiot local peopompensateurfaced run
measures to uture. Refer29, REF-A2-
y: Contracto
-2012
rridor
43+000
0, 31 Oct an
ause:d has not becontinuing t
on taken byle and authfor damage
noff, erosionprevent thi
r to letter -GET1-MO
or
nd 13,
eenracked
yorityedn and s issue
M-49,
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
69
Oct 30, 2012
Nov 13, 2012
Nov 13, 2012
In October and November:
- Damaged assets were compensated
- Mitigation measures have not been implemented
In December: Mitigation measures are being implemented
Loan 23
Dec 2
Dec 2
Oct 17
91/2392 – VNo
7, 2012
27, 201
7, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
70
Locatio
Site visNov; 14
Date fir
Problemare beincaused
RecommEngineeconcreteconcreteconstruc
ai Phong Traay Project
on: ~Km 40
sit: 3, 10, 17, 27 Dec
rst observe
ms descripng located oleaking of o
mendationer: Construed ground aed dike surrcted to prev
ansport Corr
+400
7, 24, 31 Oc
ed:
ption and caon ground inoil
n and Actiouct oil storagand waterprrounding stovent leaking
rridor
ct; 13, 20, 2
ause: Oil bn disorder a
on taken byge with leveroof roof. A orage must
g or spilling
21, 28
arrelsand
yel
t be over of
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
71
Oct 17, 2012
Nov 28, 2012
Nov 28, 2012
oil. Keep oil barrels in storage and in their upside position. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49, 50, 51, 52
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 21-Aug- 2012 (immediate)
Current status: Mitigation measures have not been applied
4.3.3 Pac
On the site
places on
environme
We have r
set right pl
Loan 23
Dec 2
Dec 2
ckage A3
es, oil barre
the site w
ent.
reminded th
aces to ens
91/2392 – VNo
7, 2012
7, 2012
els are not lo
without the
he contracto
sure safety
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
ocated at th
e concrete
or to pave i
and to avoi
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
72
he prescribe
floor. This
in concrete
d oil spill af
ai Phong Traay Project
ed place. O
s can caus
to hold the
ffected the s
ansport Corr
Oil barrels ar
se oil spill
e barrels. O
soil environ
rridor
re located in
affected t
Oil barrels m
ment.
n many
he soil
must be
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
73
25-October 2012
01-November 2012
Location: Box culvet Km64+998
Site visit: 25-October and 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 -November 2012
Date first observed: 25-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Waste oil was discharged on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-POS-A3-1549
Responsible Party: POSCO
Deadline: 01-November 2012
Current status: Implemented
01-November 2012
Location: Red river Bridge
Site visit: 01 and 08-November 2012
Date first observed: 08-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Oil barrels put anywhere on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Responsible Party: POSCO
Deadline: 08-November 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
74
08-November 2012
Current status: as of November 8th, 2012 has not been improved
06 – December 2012
06 - December 2012
Location: LungThuong Bridge
Site visit: 4, 6, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:06 – December 2012
Problems description and cause: Waste oil was discharged on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:121212-GET2-POS-A3-1638
Responsible Party: Posco
Deadline: Implemented
Current status: Improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
75
4.3.4 Package A4
In October, at Ngoi Van bridge, settling pond is full of waste bentonite and waste bentonite was
spilt over irrigation canal. This affected water and soil quality there.
Engineer has requested Contractor several times to remove all waste bentonite from settling
pond and irrigation canal to avoid contaminating natural environment.
01-August 2012
26-October 2012
Location: Ngoi Van Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26-October 2012
Date first observed:01-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Waste bentonite is discharged into irrigation canal
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-787 and GET2-KEA-A4-813
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
76
18-October 2012
02-November 2012
30-November 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26 –October and 02, 12, 17, 30– November 2012
Date first observed: 18 – October 2012
Problems description and cause: Waste bentonite is discharged into irrigation canal
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 30/12/2012
Current status: Implemented
Problems description and cause:Waste mud was overflowed to drainage canal of local people
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 30/12/2012
Current status: Implemented
In November, at Ngoi Gianh and TL321C bridge, settling pond is full of waste bentonite and
waste bentonite was spilt over irrigation canal. This affected water and soil quality there.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
77
Engineer has requested Contractor several times to remove all waste bentonite from settling
pond and irrigation canal to avoid contaminating natural environment.
12-November 2012
17-November 2012
06-December 2012
Location: TL321C Bridge
Site visit: 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 12 – November 2012
Problems description and cause: Waste mud was overflowed to drainage canal of local people
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 30/12/2012
Current status: Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
78
31-December 2012
06-December 2012
31-December 2012
Location: TL321C Bridge
Site visit: 12 – November and 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 12 – November 2012
Problems description and cause: Waste mud was overflowed to drainage canal of local people
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 30/12/2012
Current status: Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
79
4.3.5 Package A5
2nd October, 2012
25th October, 2012
30th November, 2012
Location: Van Phu bridge’s construction site
Site visit: October, 2 and November, 30,
Date first observed: 2-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Bentonite were not controlled closely by the Contractor during construction.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to apply measures in order to control bentonite during construction, prevent impact to the region’s quality soil.
Besides, the Engineer provided the instructions for the Contractor in order to solve this problem.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October, 25 2012
Current status: The Contractor has collected bentonite at this location in order to treat.
In October and November, the Consultant found that the Contractor's construction activities
have not caused serious impact on the regional soil quality; most of them did not create
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
80
hazardous substances and the construction activities were still within the limits of the project.
Anyway, some problems have to be mentioned, as follows:
October
At Km116, Km117, Km119, Km118, Km126, Km127... soil from the construction location slid
into to the agricultural land. The contractor has continuing to coordinate with authorities to
overcome and compensate for local losses.
- At Van Phu bridge, bentonite were still discharged directly on the ground; the Contractor has
not conducted bentonite collection and transported to the disposal area.
- The Contractor's fuel management was poor at the bridges Ngoi Gua, Ngoi Rao, Van Phu...
the Consultant has found traces of oil leaks on the ground in these areas.
November
- The fuel Management of the Contractor in the month still had no improvement in the area of
Ngoi Gua Bridge, Hop Minh My bridge... The Consultant has found traces of oil leaked on the
ground in these areas.
The soil from the site has slided to the areas of production of local people such as Km116,
Km117, Km119, Km118, Km126, Km127... The Contractor is continuing to coordinate with
local authorities to overcome and compensate for local people for these damages, but so far,
this problem has not been solved thoroughly by the Contractor.
4th December, 2012
Location: Km118
Site visit: December, 4 and 17
Date first observed: 4-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Soil from construction site was slid into production land of local people.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must: - Coordinate with the house owner regarding the conduct of investigation to determine the cause of
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
81
17th December, 2012
damage and to assess its extent. Based on the findings, undertake further action towards resolution of the complaint in consultation with owner. - Ensure immediately resolution of complaints.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: December 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has coordinated with local authorities and local people in order to solve this problem.
December
No serious impact on the regional soil quality was detected. However, there are still some
outstanding are as follows:
- The Contractor's fuel management has been still very poorly perfomed. There was no
improvement such as at the fuel stations: Ngoi Gua bridge, Ngoi Rao bridge, Km136 ... The
Consultant has found with streaks of oil leaked on the ground.
- The Contractor has not adequately addressed the impact of the soil from the project area slid
on the productive land of the local people such as at Km119, Km116, Km145, Km118, ...
To ensure the quality of the region's soil during the construction process of the Project, the
Consultant has asked the Contractor to resolve the outstanding issues. Also, in the weekly
inspections on site, the Consultant has frequently required the Contractor to comply with the
the Method Statement and the Environment Control and Protection Plan to prevent adverse
effects on the environment.
This month, the Consultant has also required the Contractor Keangnam to quickly proceed
grass planting at the embankment slopes and excavation slopes to prevent erosion and ensure
the stability in slopes.
4.3.6 Package A6
In this quarter the Consultant found that the Contractor's construction activities have not
caused serious impacts on the regional soil quality. Most of the construction activities have not
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
82
arised particularly hazardous substances, and the construction activities were within the limits
of the project.
October
Contractor's fuel management has improved this month.
- This month, the grass growing in negative and positive slopes to minimize erosion is
continued to be performed by the Contractor such as at Km151, Km154, Km157, Km176,
Km184, ...
- At some locations, soil from the project’s areas slided on people's land area, which affected
the soil quality such as: Km152, Km154, Km157, Km176m, Km 184, ... The Contractor is
continuing to coordinate with the authorities to overcome and compensate for local losses.
23rd October, 2012
13th November, 2012
Location: Batching plant Km163
Site visit: October, 23 and November, 13
Date first observed: 23-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Diesel leakage seen at batching plant Km165, this situation may cause impact the quality of the soil.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to apply measures in order to improve fuel control at this location, keep the project’s safety and environment.
(Regarding to the letter GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-565)
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 30, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has got actions in order to improve this work.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
83
November
The Contractor has also carried out growing grass on to protect the slopes in many areas such
as: Km155, Km151, Km154, Km165, Km174; this has limited the erosion occurred in the slope
areas.
In addition, the Contractor's fuel management was also improved this month.
In the areas of productions land where soil from the project slided on such as Km154, Km156,
Km165, Km182m, Km 187... the Contractor is continuing to coordinate with the authorities to
overcome and compensate for local losses.
24th December, 2012
31st December, 2012
Location: Construction site Km182
Site visit: December, 24 and 31
Date first observed: 24-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Through site check, the Engineer detects that Oil leakage on the ground at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required Contractor to improve the Contractor’s fuel control at this location.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: December 27, 2012
Current status: The contractor has already removed pollution soil at this location.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
84
December
The growing grass work was still deployed by the Contractor in the month such as at Km165,
Km154, Km176, Km151, Km162... This has limited erosion occurred in the slope areas.
This month, the Contractor has also taken actions to improve the fuel management: providing
fire extinguishers, installing safety fences and warning signs at the fuel stations such as in
Km186+200, Km186+720, Km164+900...
To ensure the regional soil quality, the Consultant has frequently required the Contractor to
comply with the Method Statement and the Environment Control Plan in the weekly inspection
on site.
4.3.7 Package A7
During October 2012, the consultant did not see any contractor actions, which can generate
bad effects to soils quality.
6/11/2012
Location: Store place oil and waste oil Km195+800
Site visit: 6 and 15-November 2012
Date first observed: 6-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Oil and waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the concrete floor and into store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/11/2012
Current status: The contractor had building the store and keep oil tanks and waste oil tanks on the concrete floor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
85
6/11/2012
15/11/2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
86
6/11/2012
6/11/2012
Location: Km191+353
Site visit: 6 -November 2012
Date first observed: 6-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Oil and waste oil keep on the concrete floor and into store
3/12/2012
Location: Repair place Km198+400
Site visit: 6 and 17-Dec 2012
Date first observed: 3.12.2012
Problems description and cause: The repairing the machine directly on the ground , so oil and waste oil drops on the land and effect the top soil layers
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor provide concrete floor for repair place.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
87
17/12/2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/12/2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
4.3.8 Package A8
In October consultant didn’t detect any action of the contractor which can cause bad effect to
soil quality.
20-July 2012
Location: Store place oil and waste oil Km218+040
Site visit: 20-July and 14-November 2012
Date first observed: 20-July 2012
Problems description and cause: Oiland waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the concrete floor and into the store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/7/2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
88
14-November 2012
7.12.2012
27.12.2012
Location: Store place oil and waste oil Km227+065
Site visit: 7 and 27.12.2012
Date first observed: 7.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Oil and waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the concrete floor and into the store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15.12.2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
89
4.4 NOISE AND VIBRATION LEVELS
As Annex 2.3 there are included the results of the noise and vibration levels monitored during
the period of this quarterly report.
4.4.1 Package A1
In the whole quarter, by environmental monitoring, we found that at sections Km 4+220 and Km 19+650 have arisen noises exceeded standard value, especially during the night when the Contractor carried out construction work. The PSC has requested the Contractor to limit the construction work in these areas at night to avoid the rest of local people.
4.4.2 Package A2
In this quarter, by environmental monitoring, we found that at sections Km 34+780, Km 36+500
and Km 39+130 arisen noises exceeded standard value, especially during the night when the
Contractor carried out construction work. The PSC has requested the Contractor to limit the
construction work in these areas at night to avoid the rest of local people.
In November and December, at sections Km 36+500 and Km 39+130, the exceeded level was not significant and happened in a short time, not continuously.
4.4.3 Package A3
Results of noise and vibration monitored levels in this quarter, which were carried out by Green
Environment Engineering Joint Stock Company once per month, are showed in tables in
Annex 2.3. Noise measuring results are compared with QCVN 26:2010/BTNMT - National
Technical Regulations on noise in these tables.
4.4.4 Package A4
Results of noise and vibration monitored levels in this quarter, which were carried out by Green
Environment Engineering Joint Stock Company once per month, are showed in tables in
Annex 2.3. Noise measuring results are compared with QCVN 26:2010/BTNMT - National
Technical Regulations on noise in these tables.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
90
4.4.5 Package A5
Package A5 runs mainly through a hilly area, and less through populated areas. Besides, the
construction activities of the Contractor in this month were within the limits of the project, so it
did not arise serious effects of noise and vibration on the surrounding area.
During the quarter, the transporting of materials as well as operating concrete batching plants
in the period from 10 pm to 7 am, were minimized.
However, in the batching area located close to residential areas such as batching plant No.1
(Km123), No.2 (Km132), the Contractor has not built retaining walls to minimize noise.
This noise levels monitored did not exceed Vietnamese Standards QCVN 26:2010/BTNMT
(Acoustics – Noise in public and residential areas maximum permitted noise level).
The individually-recorded results are relative random because the magnitude of noise level
recorded on site depended on the number of vehicles on the road at the time of monitoring and
activities at the construction site.
4.4.6 Package A6
Package A6 runs mainly through a hilly area, and less through populated areas, so areas
around the project were not seriously affected by noise and vibration from the construction
activities. Besides, the construction activities of the Contractor in this month were within the
limits of the project, so it did not arise serious effects of noise and vibration on the surrounding
area.
During the quarter, the transporting of materials as well as operating concrete batching plants
in the period from 10 pm to 7 am, were minimized.
In tunnel construction location, the Contractor has also equipped the workers with ear
protection equipments to prevent effects of large noise levels during construction process for
workers.
However, in the batching area located close to residential areas such as Km184, Km165,
Km162, the Contractor has not built protective walls to minimize noise.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
91
In December, at some construction locations which created high noise levels such as tunnel
construction site, Km186+200and Km186+720, the Contractor has also equipped the workers
with ear protection equipments.
4.4.7 Package A7
The construction of road base operations, transportation of materials can also cause impacts
on noise and vibration but the impacts are appraised to be acceptable and in accordance with
standards noise and vibration levels.
Result of the Contractor noise and vibration levels monitoring (carried out by Institute of
Environmental technology in October 2012) showed that construction works not effected to
noise and vibration levels.
Noise measuring results are compared with QCVN 26:2010/BTNMT: National Technical
Regulation on Noise and showed in the tables in Annex 2.3.
4.4.8 Package A8
In October, currently the batching plant of some bridges as: Suoi Trat Bridge, IC18 Bridge and
Ngoi Bo Bridge did not cause impacts on noisy and vibration because the location of
construction of the bridges is far from residential and sensitive areas.
However the concrete batching plan of Suoi Nhu Km218+040 is too near to houses of local
people, so consultant required the contractor to stop operations in the concrete batching plant
at night time to avoid effects about noising and vibrations for citizens.
In addition, the construction of road base operations, transportation of materials can also
cause impacts on noise and vibration but the impacts are appraised to be acceptable and in
accordance with standards noise and vibration levels. However, the consultant has continually
reminded the contractor to limit, and even forbid if necessary, construction activities to create
noisy and violence in the early morning, noontime or middle night.
Results of the Contractor noise and vibration level monitoring (carried out by Green
Environment Engineering Joint Stock Company in November 2012) are compared with QCVN
26:2010 / BTNMT - National Technical Regulations on noise and shown in tables (Annex 2.3).
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
92
4.5 STREAMS AND RIVERSIDES MAINTENANCE
4.5.1 Package A1
Oct 05, 2012 (Tan Loi Bridge)
Oct 05, 2012 (Xuan Phuong Bridge)
Oct 30, 2012 (Xuan Phuong Bridge)
Location: Tan Loi Bridge, Xuan Phuong Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct; 6, 15, 20, 21, 17, 29 Nov; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: due to the unsuitable working methods, the riversides were undermined and this caused landslide on them. Up to now, the Contractor still has not restored these areas and the Contractor still has not submitted any plan for restoration work.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Apply riverside protection measures and restored affected area. Refer to the minutes of meeting REF-A1-GET1-MOM-66, 67, 68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 30-Jun-2012 (immediate). As the situation has not been improved, the Engineer will request a restoration plan to be prepared in the next quarter, as a condition to continue normqal works in those locations
Current status: These areas are no longer eroded or landslide but the Contractor still has not restored affected areas
No
4.5.2
Loa
Nov 29, 20
ov 29, 2012
Package A
O
n 2391/2392
012 (Tan Lo
2 (Xuan Phu
A2
Oct 24, 201
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
oi Bridge)
uong Bridge
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
93
e)
Dec
Dec
LB
S28
D
Pao
RE
– Hai Phongghway Proje
c 25, 2012 (
c 25, 2012 (
ocation: MBridge
Site visit: 3,8 Nov;
Date first ob
Problems dere blocked bstructions
RecommendEngineer: D
g Transport ect
(Xuan Phuo
(Tan Loi Br
Muong Dao B
10, 17, 24,
bserved: O
escriptionby sedimenfrom projec
dation andDredge the s
Corridor
ong Bridge)
idge)
Bridge and
, 31 Oct; 13
Oct 24, 2012
and causentation and ct
d Action takstreams and
)
Tan Dung
3, 20, 21,
2
e: Streams
ken by d remove
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
94
Oct 24, 2012
Nov 28, 2012
Nov 28, 2012
sludge and stone to disposal place. (Oral requirement); Refer to minutes of meeting REF-A2-GET1-MOM-50, 51, 52
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: Oct 31, 2012
Current status: Mitigation measures have not been applied
Loa
No
No
De
n 2391/2392
ov 21, 2012
ov 21, 2012
ec 19, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
95
Loc
SiteDec
Dat
Proarefrom
RecEngsludmin51,
Res
Dea
Curbee
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: Tan
e visit: 13, 2c
e first obse
oblems desblocked by
m project
commendagineer: Dredge and stoutes of mee52
sponsible P
adline: Oct
rrent statusen applied
g Transport ect
Dung Bridg
20, 21, 28 N
erved: Oct
scription ansedimenta
ation and Adge the strene to dispoeting REF-A
Party: Cont
31, 2012 (i
s: Mitigation
Corridor
ge
Nov; 7, 10,
24, 2012
nd cause: Stion and ob
Action takeneams and resal place. R
A2-GET1-M
tractor
mmediate)
n measures
14, 19, 26
Streamsbstructions
n by emove
Refer to MOM-50,
s have
Loan 23
Dec 1
Dec 2
Dec 2
91/2392 – VNo
9, 2012
6, 2012
6, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
96
Locatio
Site vis
Date fir
Problemare blocfrom pro
RecommEngineesludge aminutes51, 52
Respon
Deadlin
Currentbeen ap
ai Phong Traay Project
on: Muong D
sit: 13, 20, 2
rst observe
ms descripcked by sedoject
mendationer: Dredgeand stone tos of meeting
nsible Party
ne: Oct 31,
t status: Mpplied
ansport Corr
Dao Bridge
21, 28 Dec
ed: Oct 24,
ption and cadimentation
n and Actiothe streamo disposal p
g REF-A2-G
y: Contracto
2012 (imme
itigation me
rridor
2012
ause: Streaand obstruc
on taken bys and remoplace. Refe
GET1-MOM-
or
ediate)
easures hav
amsctions
yover to -50,
ve not
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
97
4.5.3 Package A3
In October, consultant did not detect any action of the contractor which can cause bad effect to
stream and riversides maintenance.
In November, the stream is not affected by contractor’s construction acitvity. However, at the
Red River Bridge, local people entered site area to catch fishes in spite of prohibition.
08-November 2012
08-November 2012
Location: Red river Bridge
Site visit: 01, 08, 21, 29 – November 2012
Date first observed: 08 – November 2012
Problems description and cause: People arbitrarily in fishing area under construction
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Remind contractor to forbid people not to be in site.
Responsible Party: POSCO
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Implemented
At other places, consultant did not detect any action of the contractor which can cause bad
effect to stream and riversides maintenance.
In December, consultant did not detect any action of the contractor which can cause bad effect
to stream and riversides maintenance.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
98
4.5.4 Package A4
01-August 2012
11-October 2012
Location: Ngoi Van Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26 – October 2012
Date first observed:01-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Spoil is landslide into river-bed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-813
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 20-September 2012
Current status: So far the contractors not yet plant grass to prevent landsides and erosion in raining season
12 - November 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 02, 12, 17, 30- November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 12 - November 2012
Problems description and cause: Disposalarea is not followed the regulation which can cause sliding when it rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
99
17-November 2012
06 - December 2012
31 - December 2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-November 2012
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
100
4.5.5 Package A5
Through the inspection and supervision on site in the forth quarter 2012, the Consultant found
that the Contractor did not have many actions to improve the environment control and
protection at the construction locations near rivers and streams:
- A number of small irrigation works of the region were affected by the Contractor's
construction activities at stations Km117, Km119, Km123, Km124, Km126, Km127, ...
- Erosion of stream banks continued to occur at the construction location Ngoi Lau bridge.
- Measures to maintain the status of rivers and streams at the construction locations such as
Ngoi Rao bridge, Ngoi Lau bridge, Ngoi Gua bridge,.. were not applied by the Contractor.
15th August, 2012
3th October, 2012
Location: Ngoi Gua bridge’s construction site
Site visit: August 15 and October 3
Date first observed: 15-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: At Ngoi Gua bridge site (Km128) temporary crossing, only a small pipe culvert was provided which is insufficient to carry heavy flows during the rainy season
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must install additional culverts at Ngoi Gua bridge site temporary access to ensure that rainy season flows will not cause damage to the river bed and embankment.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: The Contractor do not comply with fully the requirements from the Engineer for this work.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
101
3rd February, 2012
5th October, 2012
Location: Ngoi Lau bridge’s construction site
Site visit: February 3 and October 5
Date first observed: 3-Feb-2012
Problems description and cause: At Ngoi Lau bridge site (Km120) temporary crossing, only a small pipe culvert was provided which is insufficient to carry heavy flows during the rainy season
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must install additional culverts at Ngoi Lau bridge site temporary access to ensure that rainy season flows will not cause damage to the river bed and embankment.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: February, 30 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already installed pipe culverts in order to ensure water flow of the stream.
3rd December, 2012
Location: Km129
Site visit: December, 3 and 17
Date first observed: 3-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: The region’s irrigation system was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer requires the Contractor to immediately repair this irrigation system.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
102
17th December, 2012
Deadline: December 10, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already repaired this irrigation system.
In December, in the area of Ngoi Thia bridge, the Contractor has not complied fully with the
Method Statement and continued to pour soil down to the river to create access roads in the
construction process. This has affected the flow of the river in this area. Also, this may be the
cause of the erosion of river banks. This situation is very dangerous, especially in the days of
heavy rain or during the upcoming rainy season, when the water level in the river will rise
quickly and can destroy the entire access roads of the Contractor. This has not just affected
the safety of the project, but also affected the water quality and river flow in this region.
4.5.6 Package A6
3rd October, 2012
Location: Km184
Site visit: October, 3 and 23
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The region’s irrigation system was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer requires the Contractor to immediately repair this irrigation system.
Responsible Party: DOOSAN Contractor
Deadline: October 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has coordinated
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
103
23rd October, 2012
with local authorities and local people in order to solve this problem.
In October, the Consultant found that the Contractor's construction activities have not caused
serious impacts on the region's irrigation system.
At the construction location going through rivers and streams, the Contractor has installed
permanent access roads with large culverts to ensure the flow of streams such as at: Ngoi
Rom bridge, Ngoi Nhuoc bridge, Ngoi Chac bridge, Lang Nhay bridge...
Measures to prevent erosion of stream banks occurring at Ngoi That bridge were also applied.
However, in the construction process, the Contractor has affected some small irrigation
systems of the area such as at: Suoi Nau bridge, Km184... In this month, the Contractor has
coordinated with the authorities to resolve the outstanding issues.
23rd October, 2012
Location: Km162
Site visit: October, 23 and November, 5
Date first observed: 23-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The region’s irrigation system was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer requires the Contractor to immediately repair this irrigation system.
Responsible Party: DOOSAN Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
104
5th November, 2012
Deadline: October 30, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has coordinated with local authorities and local people in order to solve this problem.
In November, the Consultant found that the Contractor's construction activities have not
caused serious impact on the region's irrigation system. The contractor has adopted several
measures to maintain the condition of streams and rivers at the construction locations such as
clearing and ensuring the flow of water through the construction area such as: Ngoi Rom
bridge, Ngoi Cong bridge, Ngoi Hut bridge...
However, there are still some outstanding issues such as:
- The access road through streams at Ngoi Giam bridge was severely damaged. However, the
Contractor has not repaired this.
- During construction process, the Contractor has affected some small irrigation systems of the
region such as at: Ngoi Nau bridge, Km184, Km156, Km176, Km182...
11th December, 2012
Location: Km165
Site visit: December, 11 and 19
Date first observed: 11-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: The region’s irrigation system was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer requires the Contractor to immediately repair this irrigation system.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
105
19th December, 2012
Responsible Party: DOOSAN Contractor
Deadline: December 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already repaired this irrigation system.
In December, the Consultant found that the irrigation system, the status of the region's
streams and river banks were not severely affected by the construction activities of the
Contractor.
At stations Ngoi Thap bridge, Ngoi Chac bridge, ... the permanent access roads with large
drainage pipes at the construction locations through the streams were maintained in good
condition.
At stations Ngoi Cong bridge, Ngoi Hut bridge, Ngoi Rom bridge, Suoi Quan bridge, Ngoi Don
bridge,... the Contractor has ensured the flow of a streams.
However, in the construction process, the Contractor has affected some small irrigation
systems of the region such as in: Lang Lau bridge, Km182, Km156, Km176, Km179, Km188 ...
the Consultant has asked the Contractor to coordinate with local authorities to resolve the
outstanding issues.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
106
4.5.7 Package A7
28-June 2012
15/11/2012
Location: Pile culvert Km194+462
Site visit: 28-June and 15-November 2012
Date first observed: 15-June 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth full inside pile culvert, which can cause flood by obstruct flow rates
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractors are required to reclean to ensure flow rates in raining season according to letters No: Ref.GET4-GRBCC-653
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: The contractor had overcome but not satisfy
11/12/2012
Location: Pipe culvert Km193+379
Site visit: 11 and 25.12.2012
Date first observed: 11.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Earth full inside pile culvert, which can cause flood by obstruct flow rates
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractors are required to reclean to ensure flow rates in raining season
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
107
25/12/2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 20.12.2012
Current status: The contractor had overcome but not satisfy
4.5.8 Package A8
19-October 2012
03-October 2012
Location: Stream near IC17 Bridge Km233+540
Site visit: 19-Sept. and 03-October 2012
Date first observed: 19-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Streamis obstructed by landside and erosion leading to effect to follows and water quality.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractors are required to reclean to ensure flow rates in raining season
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-October 2012
Current status: The contractor had mobilized equipments to clear follows.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
108
2.11.2012
22.11.2012
27.12.2012
Location: Abutment A2 of Son Hai Bridge Km227+065
Site visit: 2.11; 22.11 and 27.12.2012
Date first observed: 2.11.2012
Problems description and cause: The waste of the bore pipe process ware not guided into settling pond before discharge water source around
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor had provided the settling pond, but so far, the settling ponds had flooded by water and not capacity to treatment the wastewater.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 10.11.2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
109
4.6 EROSION RISKS AND STABILITY IN SLOPES
4.6.1 Package A1
In this period, during the site inspections, we didn’t see any serious problem of erosion on site.
Almost the slopes of embankment sections were compacted and some sections were grassed
such as section Km 16+000 ~ Km 17+000, section Km 21+950 ~ Km 22+480 and section Km
25+000 ~ Km 26+000.
4.6.2 Package A2
Oct 03, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Location: Km 42+200 ~ Km 43+000
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 30, 31 Oct; 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov; 13, 20, 21, 28 Dec
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: Due to lack of surfaced runoff control measures so the erosion and landslide happened on slope of embankment
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Apply the surfaced runoff, erosion and sediment control measures to prevent this issue happening in the future. Refer to letter GET1/POS/A2/1429; REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49, 50, 51, 52
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 04-Aug-2012 (immediate)
Current status: Mitigation measures are being implemented
Loan 23
Dec 1
Dec 2
Oct 15
91/2392 – VNo
4, 2012
7, 2012
5, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
110
Locatio
Site vis28 Nov;
Date fir
ProblemContracto carriecauses
RecommEngineeslope anpreventminutes
ai Phong Traay Project
on: Km 45+9
sit: 3, 10, 15 14, 27 Dec
rst observe
ms descripctor didn’t coed out the whigh risk of
mendationer: Calculatnd apply thelandslide h
s dated Octo
ansport Corr
900 ~ Km 4
5, 17, 24, 31c
ed: 15-Oct-2
ption and caomply with m
work with upf landslide in
n and Actiote the stabile protectionhappening. Rober 15, 20
rridor
46+000
1 Oct; 13, 2
2012
ause: Themethod sta
pright slope n this area
on taken bylization of th
n measure tRefer to site12; minutes
20, 21,
tementthat
yheoes of
Loa
O
No
De
n 2391/2392
Oct 24, 2012
ov 21, 2012
ec 27, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
111
mee
Res
Dea
Curbee
– Hai Phongghway Proje
eting REF-A
sponsible P
adline: imm
rrent statusen implemen
g Transport ect
A2-GET1-M
Party: Cont
mediate
s: Mitigationnted
Dec 27,
Nov 28,
Corridor
MOM-50, 51
tractor
n measures
2012
2012
, 52
s have not
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
112
4.6.3 Package A3
22-August 2012
18-October 2012
Location: Cam Phu Bridge, Km61+583
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 -October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 -November 2012
Date first observed: 22-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
113
22-August 2012
18-October 2012
11-November 2012
Location: Km67+840
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 -October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 - November 2012
Date first observed: 22-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
114
22-August 2012
18-October 2012
11-November 2012
Location: Km 68+440
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 –October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 -November 2012
Date first observed: 22-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
115
22-August 2012
18-October 2012
11-November 2012
Location: Km 68+100
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 –October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 -November 2012
Date first observed: 22-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
116
22-August 2012
18-October 2012
11-November 2012
Location: Km 68+800
Site visit: 22-August and 18-October 2012; 11-November 2012
Date first observed: 22-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
117
22-August 2012
11-November 2012
Location: Km67+840
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 -October 2012
Date first observed: 22-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
04 – December 2012
Location: Km73+670
Site visit: 4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:04 – December 2012
Problems description and cause: Mud and soil slid into rice fields and it was not removed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:121215-GET2-POS-A3-1647
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15 – December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
118
11 - December 2012
Current status: Improved
04 – December2012
11-December 2012
Location:Km74+480
Site visit: 4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:4 - December 2012
Problems description and cause: Mud and soil slid into rice fields and it was not removed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121215-GET2-POS-A3-1647
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15 – December 2012
Current status: Improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
119
04 – December 2012
11-December 2012
Location:Km74+760
Site visit:4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:4 - December 2012
Problems description and cause: Mud and soil slid into rice fields and it was not removed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121215-GET2-POS-A3-1647
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15 – December 2012
Current status:Not Improved
04 – December 2012
Location: Km75+390
Site visit: 4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:4 - December 2012
Problems description and cause: Mud and soil slid into rice fields and it was not removed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121215-GET2-POS-A3-1647
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15 – December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
120
11-December 2012
Current status:Not Improved
04 – December 2012
11-December 2012
Location:Km75+480
Site visit:4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:4 - December 2012
Problems description and cause: Mud and soil slid into rice fields and it was not removed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121215-GET2-POS-A3-1647
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15 – December 2012
Current status:Improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
121
04 – December 2012
11-December 2012
Location: Km76+125
Site visit: 4, 6, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:4 - December 2012
Problems description and cause: Mud and soil were dug at location of apron but not cleaned outiside
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121215-GET2-POS-A3-1647
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15 – December 2012
Current status:Improved
Several meetings have been organized by committee of Phu Tho Town in presence of
committee of Phu Tho Town, VEC, EPMU2, GET2, POSCO and two sub-contractors (Long
Vuong and Sao Vang) to solve the problems concerning on compensation for damage of
landslide into rice fields.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
122
4.6.4 Package A4
19-September 2012
11-October 2012
Location: Km105+620
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26 –October;
Date first observed:19-September 2012
Problems description and cause: Earthwas landside into rice field due toheavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 25-September 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
19-September 2012
Location: Km 93+700
Site visit: 02, 12, 17, 30 - November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 19-September 2012
Problems description and cause: Earth was landside into rice field due to heavy rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope to avoid erosion
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
123
17-November 2012
31-December 2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 25-September 2012
Current status: contractor has not planted grass yet to prevent landsides and erosion in rainy season
4.6.5 Package A5
31th July, 2012
Location: Ngoi Lau bridge’s construction site
Site visit: July, 31 and October, 10
Date first observed: 31-Jul-2012
Problems description and cause: Erosion of stream banks was happened by the Contractor’s construction activities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to
implement following tasks:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
124
10th October, 2012
- Apply measures in order to prevent erosion of
stream banks at this location.
- Comply with Environmental Protection and
Control Plan during construction.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: August 15, 2012
Current status: Erosion of stream banks continued to occur on site of Ngoi Lau bridge.
In October, the Contractor has continued to coordinate with local authorities to carry out
settlement of landslides from the project area to the local people’s production land at: Km111,
Km116, Km118, Km120, Km136, Km145...
In addition, the Contractor has also submitted measures to grow grass at positive and negative
slopes. The grass growing will help limit erosion and landslides occurred in the near future.
However, in this month, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- Erosion of stream banks continued to occur on site of Ngoi Lau bridge.
- At Km111, slope erosion phenomenon at positive slope occurred. However, the Contractor
has not applied any measures to remedy this problem.
10th August, 2012
Location: Km116
Site visit: August, 10 and November, 18
Date first observed: 10-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: Soil eroded from the project on the production land of local people
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to
implement following tasks:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
125
16th November, 2012
- Coordinate with the house owner regarding the
conduct of investigation to determine the cause
of damage and to assess its extent. Based on
the findings, undertake further action towards
resolution of the complaint in consultation with
owner.
- Ensure immediately resolution of complaints.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: September 5, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has still working with all levels of authorities to determine the compensation for the damages to the people. However, this work has not been thoroughly addressed.
In November, the Contractor has continued coordinating with local authorities to carry out
settlement of landslides from the project area to the production land of the local population; but
this work has not been thoroughly addressed.
This month, the Contractor has conducted testing grass growing in the embankment area.
During some rainy days in this month, erosion has occurred in the embankment areas such as
Km118, Km119, Km138...
24th September, 2012
Location: Km118
Site visit: September, 24 and December, 18
Date first observed: 24-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Soil eroded from the project on the production land of local people
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to
implement following tasks:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
126
17th December, 2012
- Coordinate with the house owner regarding the
conduct of investigation to determine the cause
of damage and to assess its extent. Based on
the findings, undertake further action towards
resolution of the complaint in consultation with
owner.
- Ensure immediately resolution of complaints.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 20, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has still working with all levels of authorities to determine the compensation for the damages to the people. However, this work has not been thoroughly addressed.
In December, there were no serious accidents related with erosion and slopes stability, in
Package A6.
However, in some areas where soil eroded from the project on the production land of local
people at Km116 area, Km119, Km118, Km145, etc., the Contractor have still working with all
levels of authorities to determine the compensation for the damages to the people. However,
this work has not been thoroughly addressed.
To ensure the environment of the Project as well as to prevent the risk of erosion and
landslides, the Consultant has requested the Contractor to apply effective measures to solve
this issue. Also, in the site inspections, the Consultant has also required the Contractor to
comply with all the requirements in the Method Statement and the environment control and
protection plan during construction process.
This month the Consultant has also required the Contractor Keangnam to quickly proceed
grass growing at the regional slopes and embankments areas to prevent erosion and ensure
the stability of the slopes.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
127
4.6.6 Package A6
3rd October, 2012
23rd October, 2012
Location: Km151+500
Site visit: October, 3 and 23
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Disposal areas spread in the bank of the river without the choke dikes affect the river’s flow and environment seriously.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to implement tasks as follows:
- This violation must be stopped immediately.
- Apply suitable measures in order to keep the project’s environment at this location.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 20, 2012
Current status: The Contractor do not continue dump unsuitable material at this disposal area, at the same time, the Contractor has already covered with canvas at the slope at this location.
In October, the Contractor has continued to deploy the grass growing at slopes in areas such
as: Km156, Km152, Km151, Km157, Km159, Km165,... this work has contributed significantly
to reduce erosion and landslides.
In addition, in this month, the Contractor has continued to coordinate with local authorities to
carry out settlement of landslides from the project area to the ground of local production land
at: Km154, Km157, Km156 , ....
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
128
23rd October, 2012
5th November, 2012
Location: Km188+600
Site visit: October, 23 and November, 5
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Disposal areas spread in the bank of the river without the choke dikes affect the river’s flow and environment seriously.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to implement tasks as follows:
- This violation must be stopped immediately.
- Apply suitable measures in order to keep the project’s environment at this location.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 30, 2012
Current status: The Contractor do not continue dump unsuitable material at this disposal area, at the same time, the Contractor has already covered with canvas at the slope at this location.
In November, through the inspection and supervision on site, the Consultant found that the
Contractor has continuing to deploy the grass growing in the embankment slopes areas such
as: Km154, Km156, Km161, Km162, Km176 ..., and slope areas of the excavation sector:
Km154, Km165 ... This work has contributed significantly to reduce erosion and landslides
occurring. In addition, the Contractor has continued to coordinate with local authorities to carry
out settlement of landslides from the project area to the production ground of local people.
In December, the growing grass work was still deployed by the Contractor in the month such
as at Km165, Km154, Km176, Km151, Km162... This has limited erosion occurred in the
slopes areas.
Also, some families have been paid compensation by the Contractor for the damages such as
at Minh Tan Dist, Chau Que Ha Dist.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
129
4.6.7 Package A7
15-October 2012
31-October 2012
15/11/2012
Location: Excavation slope Km204+100
Site visit: 15 and 31-October 2012; 15-November 2012; 17 December 2012
Date first observed: 15-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Slopehad landside and erosion by raining
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to settling the safety fence and signpost around the landside and erosion areas, after that apply the slope protection method to overcome as soon as possibility.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: As soon as possible
Current status: So far the contractors had settled the safety fence and signpost to warning the local people do not cross the these are location
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
130
17/12/2012
4.6.8 Package A8
01-October 2012
Location: Embankment slope Km222+700-Km222+800
Site visit: 01 and 10-October 2012; 27 December 2012
Date first observed: 01-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Earths of embankment and slope ware landside and erosion into garden, ponds damaged to property and farm produce
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to plant grass to prevent landsides and erosion in raining coming season in the letter No: Ref. GET4- Vinaconex- 616
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15-October 2012
Current status: The contractor is coordinating with client and local people in order to compensate and apply the
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
131
10-October 2012
27.12.2012
protection slope method.
23/8/2012
Location: Embankment slope Km230+295
Site visit: 23-August and 14-November 2012
Date first observed: 23-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Local people obstructed construction works due to soil of embankment and slope ware landside and erosion into garden, ponds and them house damager to property and farm produce
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
132
14/11/2012
10-October 2012
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor was required to compensate and apply the slope protection method avoid repeat.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15-October 2012
Current status: The contractor is coordinating with client and local people in order to compensate and apply the protection slope method.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
133
4.7 HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES MANAGEMENT
4.7.1 Package A1
Oct 05, 2012
Oct 09, 2012
Location: Km 15+000
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct,
Date first observed: 05-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Oilbarrels were put in disorder on site and in lying on their side
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Keep oil barrels in properly storage and upside position.
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 06-Oct-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has been implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
134
Oct 30, 2012
Location: Bon Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30
Date first observed: 30-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Oilbarrels were put in disorder on site and in lying on their side
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Keep oil barrels in properly storage and upside position.
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: Mitigation measure has been implemented (reported by Inspector)
Nov 20, 2012
Location: Ba Thien Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 29 Nov; 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Dec
Date first observed: 20-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Oilbarrels were put in disorder on site and in lying on their side and caused the leak of oil and polluted soil onsite
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Keep oil barrels in properly storage and upside position. Refer to minutes of meeting REF-A1-GET1-MOM-67, 68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 20-Nov-2012 (immediate)
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
4.7.2
Loa
N
D
Package A
O
n 2391/2392
Nov 27, 201
Dec 11, 201
A2
Oct 17, 201
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
12
12
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
135
L
S28
D
Pbad
REco
– Hai Phongghway Proje
ocation: ~K
Site visit: 3,8 Nov; 14, 2
Date first ob
Problems dearrels are bisorder and
Recommendngineer: Concreted gr
g Transport ect
Dec 11
Km 40+400
10, 17, 24,27 Dec
bserved:
escriptionbeing locate caused lea
dation andConstruct oilround and w
Corridor
, 2012
0
, 31 Oct; 13
and causeed on groundaking of oil
Action tak storage wi
waterproof r
3, 20, 21,
e: Oild in
ken by th level roof. A
Loan 23
Oct 1
Nov 2
Nov 2
91/2392 – VNo
17, 2012
28, 2012
28, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
136
concrconstof oil. upsidGET1
Resp
Dead
Currenot be
ai Phong Traay Project
reted dike sructed to prKeep oil ba
e position. 1-MOM-49,
onsible Pa
line: 21-Au
ent status: een applied
D
D
ansport Corr
urroundingrevent leakiarrels in stoRefer to do50, 51, 52
arty: Contra
ug- 2012 (im
Mitigation md
Dec 27, 201
Dec 27, 201
rridor
storage mung or spillin
orage and incument RE
actor
mmediate)
measures h
12
12
ust be ng over n their F-A2-
have
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
137
4.7.3 Package A3
26-September 2012
5-October 2012
Location: Red river bridge
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 –October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 -November 2012
Date first observed: 26 - September 2012
Problems description and cause: Chemical barrels were not located in prescribed places
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to set up the fence surrounding store
Responsible Party: POSCO
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Implemented
26-September 2012
Location: Red river bridge
Site visit: 06, 12, 19, 26 - September and 25-October 2012; 01, 08-November 2012
Date first observed: 26-September 2012
Problems description and cause: Settling pond was full of slurry
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to remove all slurry to disposal area
Responsible Party: POSCO
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
138
25-October 2012
01 – November 2012
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Implemented
04 – December2012
Location: Lung Th ng bridge
Site visit: 4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December 2012
Date first observed:04 – December 2012
Problems description and cause:Chemicalbarrels were not located in prescribed places
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121212-GET2-POS-A3-1638
Responsible Party: POSCO
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
139
06-December 2012
4.7.4 Package A4
13 – September 2012
Location: QL32C Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23,26 – October; 02, 12, 17, 30 - November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 13 – September 2012
Problems description and cause:Chemical barrels are not located at prescribed area
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to keep chemical barrels at prescribed area
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
140
11 – October 2012
12 – November 2012
31 – December 2012
02 – November 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 02, 12, 17 – November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 02 – September 2012
Problems description and cause: Chemical barrels are not located at prescribed area
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to keep chemical barrels at prescribed area
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
141
12 – November 2012
17 – November 2012
Current status: Not implemented
06 – December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
142
4.7.5 Package A5
16th October, 2012
26th October, 2012
Location: Ngoi Gua bridge’s construction site
Site visit: October, 16 and 26
Date first observed: 16-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s fuel control is bad at Ngoi Gua bridge, some fuel tanks was put directly on the ground without fuel leakage prevention equipments.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to apply measures in order to improve fuel control at this location, keep the project’s safety and environment.
(Regarding to the letter GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-565)
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 20, 2012
Current status: Not yet implemented.
In this quarter, the Consultant found that there was not any serious accident related to
hazardous substances in the project area.
However, in October, the fuel management of the Contractor had no improvement: the fire
fighting equipments and equipments to prevent fuel leakage have not been fully provided in a
number of fuel stations such as: Km130, Km114, Km128, Km145...
In addition, the warning signs and safety fences have not been fully installed in the fuel
stations areas such as at Km130, Km145...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
143
24th September, 2012
10th November, 2012
Location: Km118
Site visit: September, 24 and November, 10
Date first observed: 24-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s fuel control is bad this location construction site, some fuel tanks was put directly on the ground without fuel leakage prevention equipments.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to improve fuel control at this location in order to ensure the Project’s environment.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already improved fuel control at this location.
In November, still some outstanding issues as follows:
- The fire fighting equipment has not been supplied by the Contractor at some fuel station such
as: Km126, Km145...
- At stations Km112, Km148, Km130, the safety fences and warning signs have not been fully
installed at the fuel stations.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
144
3rd December, 2012
18th December, 2012
Location: Ngoi Buc bridge’s construction site
Site visit: December, 3 and 18
Date first observed: 3-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s fuel control is bad at Ngoi Buc bridge’s construction site, some fuel tanks was put directly on the ground without fuel leakage prevention equipments.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must improve fuel control at all construction sites (regarding to the letter GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-565)
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: December 15, 2012
Current status: Not yet improved
In December, these are the main findings:
- The Contractor has not provided adequate fire safety devices and equipments to prevent fuel
leakage in these areas.
- The safety fences and safety signs have not been fully installed at the fuel station areas.
- The fuel tanks were still indiscriminately thrown on the ground at the construction locations.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
145
4.7.6 Package A6
10th October, 2012
30th October, 2012
Location: Km186+100
Site visit: October, 10 and 30
Date first observed: 10-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Fuel tanks were put directly on the ground
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must provide fuel control at this location, at the same time, implement fully requirements and instruction from the Engineer mentioned the letter Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-11-A6-566
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 23, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
This quarter, the Consultant found that there was no serious effect on the environment from
the hazardous substances in the process of the project.
In October and November, the contractor had some improvement in the fuel management:
- The warning signs and safety fences were installed at the fuel stations such as: Km186+200,
Km171+100...
- The fire equipments were maintained at the fuel stations such as: Km165, Km186+200,
Km186+720, Km171+100...
However, at some fuel stations, fuel leak prevention equipments were still not provided such
as at: Km155, Km186... The Consultant found traces of oil leaked on the ground.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
146
10th October, 2012
6th November, 2012
Location: Batching plant Km180
Site visit: October, 10 and November, 6
Date first observed: 10-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Fuel tanks were put directly on the ground
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must provide fuel control at this location, at the same time, implement fully requirements and instruction from the Engineer mentioned the letter Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-11-A6-566
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 23, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has got actions in order to improve this work.
However, in some areas, the fuel management was still poorly performed, specifically:
- At some locations of fuel stations such as Km155, Km165, Km186, the Contractor has not
provided the equipment to prevent oil leakage.
- Warning signs, safety fences have not been fully installed at the fuel stations of Ngoi Don
bridge, Km187...
- The Consultant has found traces of oil leaked on the ground in the location Km186 +200.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
147
11th December, 2012
19th December, 2012
Location: Km155+300
Site visit: December, 11 and 19
Date first observed: 11-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s fuel control is not good at this location (e.g. No safety fence and signboards at fuel store areas; fuel tanks were put directly on the ground,…).
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must provide fuel control at this location, at the same time, implement fully requirements and instruction from the Engineer mentioned the letter Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-11-A6-566
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: December 18, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
In December, the fuel management of the Contractor has been done well in a number of areas
such as:
- The warning signs and fences have been maintained at the fuel station area Km164+900.
- Arranging fuel neatly and build storage house with canopies such as at batching plants
Km180, Km165.
Some outstanding issues are the following:
- There was no improvement in fuel management at station Km155+300, Ngoi Don bridge...;
the fuel tanks were thrown indiscriminately on the ground.
- The safety warning signs and safety fences have not been installed at the fuel stations
Km155+300, Lang Nheo bridge, Dai Viet bridge.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
148
4.7.7 Package A7
6/11/2012
6/11/2012
15/11/2012
Location: Store place oil and waste oil Km195+800
Site visit: 6 and 15-November 2012
Date first observed: 6-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Oil and waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the concrete floor and into store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/11/2012
Current status: The contractor had building the store and keep oil tanks and waste oil tanks on the concrete floor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
149
6/11/2012
6/11/2012
Location: Km191+353
Site visit: 6 -November 2012
Date first observed: 6-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Oiland waste oil keep on the concrete floor and into store
11/12/2012
Location: Oil and waste oil keep at Km198+400
Site visit: 11.12.2012 and 4.1.2013
Date first observed: 11.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Oiland waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
150
4/1/2013
concrete floor and into store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30.12.2012
Current status: The contractor had moved the oil tanks and wastes oil tanks to right place
4.7.8 Package A8
20-July 2012
Location: Store place oil and waste oil Km218+040
Site visit: 20-July and 14-November 2012
Date first observed: 20-July 2012
Problems description and cause: Oiland waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the concrete floor and into the store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/7/2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
151
14-November 2012
7.12.2012
27.12.2012
Location: Store place oil and waste oil Km227+065
Site visit: 7 and 27.12.2012
Date first observed: 7.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Oiland waste oil keep directly on the ground, it can effect to soil quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to keep oil tanks and waste oil tank on the concrete floor and into the store.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15.12.2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
152
4.8 UNSUITABLE MATERIAL DISPOSALS AND BORROW PITS
4.8.1 Package A1
In the site inspections in this period, we didn’t find any problem regarding unsuitable material disposals (see table included in Annex 4). It’s also noted that there is no borrow pit submitted by the Contractor during this month.
4.8.2 Package A2
Oct 03, 2012
Oct 03, 2012
Location: Interchange No. 6
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: TheContractor disposed the unsuitable material along through way and at section where is close to resident area
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Requested the Contractor to remove all unsuitable material to approval disposal places. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 07-Jun- 2012 (immediate)
Current status: Almost the unsuitable material has been removed from construction site
Loa
O
O
De
n 2391/2392
Oct 10, 2012
Oct 17, 2012
ec 26, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
153
Loc
Site
Dat
ProConrive
RecEngdispmatGET
Res
Dea
Curimp
Loc
Site
Dat
Promat
RecEngthesubmatthe
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: Lo R
e visit: 3, 10
e first obse
oblems desntractor disprside
commendagineer: Remposal area; terial on siteT1-MOM-49
sponsible P
adline: 12-O
rrent statuslemented
cation: Km
e visit: 5, 10
e first obse
oblems desterial is bein
commendagineer: TheContractormit the dispterial in this Engineer a
g Transport ect
River Bridge
0, 17, 24, 3
erved: 10-O
scription anposed the le
ation and Amove dischaprohibit disc
e. Refer to d9
Party: Cont
Oct- 2012
s: Mitigation
32+500 ~ K
0, 14, 26
erved: 26-D
scription anng disposed
ation and Ae Engineer h
to immediaposal place
section andpproves the
Corridor
e
1
Oct-2012
nd cause: Teftover conc
Action takenarged concrcharge of udocument R
tractor
n measure h
Km 33+000
Dec-2012
nd cause: Ud along thro
Action takenhas orally reately stop th
for unsuitabd remove it e disposal p
Thecrete on
n by rete to
unsuitableREF-A2-
has been
Unsuitableugh way
n by equestedhis activity; bleright after
place
4.8.3 Pac
Loan 23
Dec 2
ckage A3
12-Septe
11-Octo
91/2392 – VNo
6, 2012
ember 2012
ober 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
2
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
154
Respon
Deadlin
Currentdisposadisposa
Locatio
Site vis11, 21,
Date fi
Probledischar
RecomEngineslurry to
Respo
Deadlin
Curren
ai Phong Traay Project
nsible Party
ne: Immedia
t status: Thl activity bul place
on: Red riv
sit: 01, 05,29 - Novem
rst observe
ms descriprged on rive
mmendationeer: Requeo disposal a
nsible Part
ne: Immedi
nt status: Im
ansport Corr
y: Contracto
ate
he Contractut still has no
er Bridge
11, 18, 25mber 2012
ed: 26-Sep
ption and cer-bank
n and Aest Contracarea
ty: POSCO
iately
mplemented
rridor
or
tor has stopot submitted
5 – Octobe
ptember 201
cause: Slur
ction takector to rem
O
d
ppedd the
er; 1, 8,
12
rry was
en by ove all
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
155
Disposals area section 7
Material borrow section 6
Location: Disposals area section 7 and material borrow pit section 6
Site visit: 01 – November, 2012
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: Contractordisposal and use of material borrow pits purposes
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Responsible Party: POSCO
Deadline:
Current status:
Now, Borrow pit in section 3 is full. Consultant had required the Contractor to submit a
proposal for a new borrow pit (121212-GET2-POS-A3-1639). Until now the contractor has not
not submitted yet
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
156
4.8.4 Package A4
09-August 2012
05-October 2012
12 - November 2012
Location:QL32C Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23,26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30–November 2012
Date first observed:09-August 2012
Problems description and cause:Waste Bentonitewas spilt over settling pond
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to remove all sediment from settling pond to disposal area
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
157
01-August 2012
11-October 2012
12-November 2012
Location: TL321C Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23,26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30–November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 01-August 2012
Problems description and cause:Settling pond was full of waste Bentonite
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to remove all waste bentonite to disposal area
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
158
17-November 2012
30-November 2012
06 - December 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23,26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30–November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 17 - November 2012
Problems description and cause: Disposalarea is not followed the regulation which can cause sliding when it rains
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: GET2-KEA-A4-909
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-November 2012
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
159
31 - December 2012
4.8.5 Package A5
Up to October, the Contractor has submitted 43 disposal areas, including 16 already approved
and 27 which have not been approved by the Consultant.
3rd January, 2012
Location: Km148
Site visit: January 3 and November 27
Date first observed: 3-Feb-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor disposed unsuitable material into areas which unapproved by local authorities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to combine with local authorities in order to comply with regulation of Vietnam, at the same time, the Engineer required the Contractor to apply measures in order to keep the region’s environment during construction.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: February, 30 2012
Current status: The Contractor has got approval
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
160
27th November, 2012
letter from Van Yen district people’s committee for disposal area. Now, there is any problem relating to environmental issues at this disposal area.
In November, some disposal areas were have been completely filled, such as: Km116,
Km147, ... Local people have started to plant trees there; this has contributed to protect the
regional environment of the disposal areas.
Up to now, the Contractor has submitted 51 disposal areas, including 16 approved by the
Consultant and 35 not yet approved. In December, the Consultant approved 12 new disposal
areas.
10th February, 2012
Location: Km145
Site visit: February 10 and December 17
Date first observed: 10-Feb-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor disposed unsuitable material into areas which unapproved by local authorities.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to combine with local authorities in order to comply with regulation of Vietnam, at the same time, the Engineer required the Contractor to apply measures in order to keep the region’s environment during construction.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
161
17th December, 2012
Deadline: March 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has got approval letter from Van Yen district people’s committee for disposal area. Now, there is any problem relating to environmental issues at this disposal area.
4.8.6 Package A6
At the end of this quarter, the Contractor had submitted 83 disposal areas, including 62
approved and 21 not approved by the Consultant.
At some stations, the Contractor has gathered the unsuitable soil in locations near the river
such as: Km151, Km159, Km161, Km187, Km188 ... The Consultant has requested the
Contractor to immediately stop dumping in these areas and move the entire unsuitable
material to the disposal areas approved by the Consultant.
4.8.7 Package A7
10-October 2012
Location: Waste disposal Km201+815
Site visit: 24-July and 5-Sept. 2012
Date first observed: 16-May 2012
Problems description and cause: The contractors dumping the unsuitable material on riverside, which can erosion and landside into river
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to stability slope and plant grass to protect the
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
162
24-October 2012
slope not erosion and landside into river
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-October 2012
Current status: The contractor had stabilities slope and planted grass to prevent erosion and landslide into river
25.12.2012
25.12.2012
Location: Km209+329
Site visit: 25.12.2012
Date first observed: 25.12.2012
Problems description and cause: The contractor pouring earth near water source, it effect to flow rate and water quality
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to clear flow, stability slope and plan grass to avoid landslide and erosion.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15.1.2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
163
4.8.8 Package A8
In this period, also some unsuitable material disposals were approved by consultant and the
contractor have been used to gather organic soil. Now those disposals have been stabilized
(no erosion, landslides) and some of them are used to grow cassava, maize or grass, as it
happened in the unsuitable material disposal at Km240+100.
4.9 WASTE AND CLEANLINESS ON SITE
4.9.1 Package A1
Oct 05, 2012
Location: Trung Kien Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed: 14-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: Site is dirty and untidy with trash and material
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Rearrange the construction site to keep it in tidy and cleanliness condition. Refer to document REF-A1-GET1-MOM-65
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 12-Dec-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
Loan 23
Oct 0
Oct 3
Dec 1
Nov 2
91/2392 – VNo
5, 2012
0, 2012
1, 2012
20, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
164
Locatio
Site vis
Date fir
Problemdirty an
RecomEnginekeep it to docu
Respon
Deadlin
ai Phong Traay Project
D
on: Box culv
sit: 6, 15, 2
rst observe
ms descripd untidy wit
mmendationeer: Rearranin tidy and cment REF-
nsible Part
ne: 21-Nov-
ansport Corr
ec 11, 2012
vert – Km 2
1, 27 Nov
ed: 20-Nov-
ption and cth trash and
n and Actionge the concleanlinessA1-GET1-M
ty: Contract
-2012
rridor
2
21+208
-2012
cause: Sited material
on taken bynstruction si condition.
MOM-67, 68
tor
is
yite to Refer8
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
165
Nov 20, 2012
Nov 27, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has rearranged the construction
Nov 27, 2012
Location: Trung Kien Bridge, Ba Thien Bridge
Site visit: 6, 15, 20, 21, 27, 29 Nov; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed: 27-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Dirt is tracked onto public road cause dirtiness and difficulty for travelers
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Mobilize the water truck and worker to clean and remove the soil on public road. Refer to minutes of meeting REF-A1-GET1-MOM-68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Loan 23
Nov 2
Nov 2
Dec 2
91/2392 – VNo
29, 2012
29, 2012
25, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
166
Deadlin
Curren
In Octohas moareas binspect
In Deceimplem
ai Phong Traay Project
ne: 27-Nov-
t status:
ober and Noobilized the wbut we still foions
ember: Mitiented
D
D
ansport Corr
-2012 (imm
ovember: Twater truck ound the di
gation mea
Dec 11, 201
Dec 25, 201
rridor
ediate)
The Contracto clean the
rtiness in th
asure has be
2
2
ctorese
he site
een
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
167
4.9.2 Package A2
Oct 03, 2012
Oct 03, 2012
Location: Interchange No. 6
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: TheContractor disposed the unsuitable material along through way and at section where is close to resident area
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Requested the Contractor to remove all unsuitable material to approval disposal places. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 07-Jun- 2012 (immediate)
Current status: Almost the unsuitable material has been removed from construction site
Nov 13, 2012
Location: TL306II Bridge
Site visit: 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov; 14, 27 Dec
Date first observed: 13-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: The dirt is tracked onto public road and caused dirtiness and difficulty for travelers
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Mobilize the water truck and worker to clean and remove the soil on public road. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-51, 52
Loan 23
Nov 2
Dec 1
Dec 2
91/2392 – VNo
1, 2012
4, 2012
7, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
168
Respon
Deadlin
Currentthe watesometimthis area
ai Phong Traay Project
nsible Party
ne: 13-Nov-
t status: Ther truck to c
mes we still a
ansport Corr
y: Contracto
2012 (imm
he Contractclean this sefound the d
rridor
or
mediate)
tor has mobection; howedirtiness sta
bilizedever,
atus in
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
169
4.9.3 Package A3
15-August 2012
25-October 2012
01-November 2012
Location: Km68+000
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 –October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 – November 2012
Date first observed: 15-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Provincialroad was full of soil due to landslide
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to remove all earth on provincial road to disposal to ensure safe travel
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August, 2012
Current status: Not implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
170
12-September 2012
11-October 2012
08-November 2012
Location: Red river bridge
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 –October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 – November 2012; 4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December, 2012
Date first observed: 12-September 2012
Problems description and cause: A lot of rubbish was discharged near site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to clean rubbish on site
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 19-September, 2012
Current status: Not Implemented
06-December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
171
29-November 2012
4.9.4 Package A4
05-September 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23,26 – October; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 19-September 2012
Problems description and cause: Access road was full of mud when it rained
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to clean all mud to ensure safe travel when it rains
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-August, 2012
Current status: Improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
172
11 – October 2012
17 – November
06 – December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
173
4.9.5 Package A5
In this forth quarter 2012, the sanitary works in site were still quite well maintained by the
Contractor. Some construction locations were clean and neat such as at:Km111, Km112,
Km114, Km116, Km117, Km138...
- But the daily hygiene routine has still not been done in many areas of workers'
camps such as at: Km112, Km128, Km120...
- Also, at some construction locations such as: Bridges Van Phu, Ngoi Lau, QL37,
Ngoi Gua ... the construction materials were not tidy and neat stored.
However, because the Contractor has failed to fully comply with the requirements and
guidances from the Consultant, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- In October, bentonite has not been strictly controlled in the construction process in the area
of Van Phu bridge...
- In November, the fuel management has been still poorly performed in the regions of Ngoi
Gua bridge. In the site inspections, the Consultant found the oil leaked on the ground in this
area.
- In December, Waste was still indiscriminately thrown on the ground at some camps: Km130,
Km118, Km112...
- There was no improvement in the fuel management at Km130, Ngoi Gua bridge, Km136,
Ngoi Thia bridge... fuel tanks were thrown indiscriminately on the ground.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
174
2nd November, 2012
26th November, 2012
Location: Ngoi Rao bridge’s construction site
Site visit: September, 24 and October, 11
Date first observed: 24-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: theconstruction materials were not tidy and neat arranged.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to maintain the site in clean condition, the Consultant also requested the Contractor to regularly perform periodical cleaning works at all construction locations.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 5, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
2nd November, 2012
Location: Van Phu bridge’s construction site
Site visit: November, 2 and 26
Date first observed: 2-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Rubbishwas thrown on the ground, it was not collected by the Contractor.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Contractor must collect rubbish and remove into right disposal areas.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
175
26th November, 2012
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: November, 20 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already collected rubbish and removed into right disposal areas.
3rd December, 2012
18th December, 2012
Location: Ngoi Buc bridge’s construction site
Site visit: December, 3 and 18
Date first observed: 3-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Construction site was not tidy and clean.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to improve environmental control at this location.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: December 15, 2012
Current status: Now, Construction site is tidy and clean.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
176
4.9.6 Package A6
3rd October, 2012
23rd October, 2012
Location: South portal of the tunnel Km186+720
Site visit: October 3 and 23.
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Tunnel construction site is not tidy and clean.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Construction material and equipments must be arranged orderly and suitably.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has got actions in order to improve this work.
In this quarter, the sanitary works on site were still maintained by Contractor; some
construction locations were kept in rather good conditions, clean and neat: Km154, Km157,
Km161, Km165, Km174, Km184, Km182, Km186...
But At some of the bridge construction locations such as: Lang Lau Bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge,
Dai Viet bridge, Suoi Nau bridge... the materials of construction were not tidy arranged.
Some situations were found along the three months:
In October, at workers’ camps areas Km184, Km165, Km161, garbage was thrown
indiscriminately without collected and treated by the Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
177
In November, at Km161, Km155, Km174, the soil from the construction location has filled the
roads, but the Contractor did not collect it and also the soil dropped from the trucks.
At workers’ camps areas Km176, Ngoi Giam bridge, Ngoi Don bridge, the garbage was thrown
indiscriminately without collected and processed by the Contractor.
In December, Waste was still indiscriminately thrown on the ground in some camps areas
such as: Km186+200, Ngoi Don bridge, Lang Nau bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge...
Also, there was no improvement of the fuel management in the region Km155+300, Ngoi Don
bridge ... fuel tanks were thrown indiscriminately on the ground.
3rd November, 2012
16th November, 2012
Location: Ngoi Giam bridge’s construction site
Site visit: November, 3 and 16
Date first observed: 3-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Construction site is not tidy and clean.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Construction material and equipments must be arranged orderly and suitably.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: November 10, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has arranged construction material, equipments and clean this construction site.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
178
3rd November, 2012
16th November, 2012
Location: Batching plant Km180
Site visit: December, 5 and 24
Date first observed: 5-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Construction site is not tidy and clean.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Construction material and equipments must be arranged orderly and suitably.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: December 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has arranged construction material, equipments and clean this batching plant.
4.9.7 Package A7
01-October 2012
Location: Ram AII Bridge Km199+050
Site visit: 1 and 15-October 2012
Date first observed: 01-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Theconstruction works not tidy and many rubbish on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to arrange the construction work and collect and classification according to regulation
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
179
15-October 2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15-November 2012
Current status: So far the contractor didn’t collect and transfer the rubbish to treatment area according to regulations
01-November 2012
6-November 2012
Location: Ram AII Bridge Km199+050
Site visit: 1 and 6-November 2012
Date first observed: 01-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Theconstruction works not tidy and many rubbish on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to arrange the construction work and collect and classification according to regulation
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15-November 2012
Current status: So far the contractor didn’t collect and transfer the rubbish to treatment area according to regulations
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
180
3.12.2012
25.12.2012
Location: Khe Sang Bridge Km191+353
Site visit: 1 and 25.12.2012
Date first observed: 3.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Theconstruction works not tidy and many rubbish on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to arrange the construction work and collect and classification according to regulation
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15.12.2012
Current status: So far the contractor didn’t collect and transfer the rubbish to treatment area according to regulations
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
181
4.9.8 Package A8
10-October 2012
2-November 2012
Location: Girder casting yard of Suoi Nhu Bridge Km218+040
Site visit: 10-October and 2-November 2012
Date first observed: 10-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Theconstruction works not tidy and many rubbish on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to arrange the construction work and collect and classification according to regulation
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: The worker is collecting and classification to treatment
9/11/2012
Location: Girder casting yard of Ngoi Bo Bridge Km238+265
Site visit: 9 and 22-November 2012
Date first observed: 9-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Theconstruction works not tidy and many rubbish on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to arrange the construction work and collect and classification according to regulation
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
182
22/11/2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve
7.12.2012
14.12.2012
Location: Girder casting yard of Suoi Trat Bridge Km231+889
Site visit: 7 and 14.12.2012
Date first observed: 7.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Theconstruction works not tidy and many rubbish on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to arrange the construction work and collect and classification according to regulation
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15.12.2012
Current status: had improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
183
4.10 BIODIVERSITY PRESERVATION
4.10.1 Package A1
In this period, during the site inspections, we didn’t find any serious impacts, which arise from construction activities of the project, on biodiversity preservation.
4.10.2 Package A2
In this period, during the site inspections, we didn’t find any serious impacts, which arise from construction activities of the project, on biodiversity preservation.
4.10.3 Package A3
In this period, according to the observations and based on the monitoring results of analysis
the environmental air quality, noise and surface water in this quarter shows that ecosystems
and the resident activities of the local community people around of construction area are still
normally, not detected any bad impact from the construction activities on them. Until now, The
Consultant has not received report about plants and animals died by machinery or vehicle
operations inside the limits of construction zone or in the close sorroundings.
4.10.4 Package A4
In this period, according to the observations and based on the monitoring results of analysis
the environmental air quality, noise and surface water in this quarter shows that ecosystems
and the resident activities of the local community people around of construction area are still
normally, not detected any bad impact from the construction activities on them. Until now, The
Consultant has not received report about plants and animals died by machinery or vehicle
operations inside the limits of construction zone or in the close sorroundings.
4.10.5 Package A5
In this period, the Contractor's major construction items were ground works (excavation,
embankment, etc.) and the construction of piers and abutments for structures, so they have
not arisen serious impacts on the environment and biodiversity of the area.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
184
However, to ensure the environment of the area, the Consultant has frequently required the
Contractor to comply with the Method Statement and the Environment Control Plan to prevent
adverse impacts to the regional fauna and flora.
4.10.6 Package A6
In this period, the Contractor's major construction items were ground work (excavation,
embankment, etc.) and the construction of piers and abutments for structures, so they have
not arisen serious impacts on the environment and biodiversity of the area.
However, to ensure the environment of the area, the Consultant has frequently required the
Contractor to comply with the Method Statement and the Environment Control Plan to prevent
adverse impacts to the regional fauna and flora.
4.10.7 Package A7
Up to now, site clearing of contractor is most completed, from Km190+420 to Km218+040.
Construction work s didn’t cause animal extinction or damaged.
4.10.8 Package A8
Up to now the activities of the Contractor didn’t cause negative effect to animals, plants and
biodiversity preservation. However, consultant always reminded the contractor to apply some
methods to mitigate impact to environment in general and living beings particularly, on the
construction site.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
185
4.11 WORKERS’ CAMPS CONDITIONS
4.11.1 Package A1
Oct 05, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Nov 27, 2012
Location: Trung Kien Bridge,
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct; 6, 15, 20, 21, 27, 29 Nov; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed: 14-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: Disposeof trash surrounding worker’s camps caused dirtiness and the septic tanks are dirty and foul odor
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Implement housekeeping worker in regular basis to keep the living condition of workers in cleanliness and sanitary condition. Refer to document REF-A1-GET1-MOM-65, 66, 67
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 30-Sep-2012 (immediate)
Current status:
In November: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
In December: Mitigation measure has been been implemented
Loan 23
Nov 2
Dec 2
Oct 0
91/2392 – VNo
27, 2012
25, 2012
9, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
186
Locatio
Site vis
Date fir
Problemworker’and the
RecomEngineregularworkersRefer to(Oct); R
ai Phong Traay Project
D
D
on: Underpa
sit: 2, 5, 9,
rst observe
ms descrips camp is d
e toilets are
mmendationeer: Implem
basis to kes in cleanlino documentRefer to doc
ansport Corr
ec 25, 2012
ec 25, 2012
ass NH2
16, 23, 30 O
ed: 18-Sep-
ption and cdirty with tradirty and un
n and Actioent housek
eep the livingness and sat REF-A1-Gcument REF
rridor
2
2
Oct; 11, 15
-2012
cause: Theash surroundnusable
on taken bykeeping worg condition
anitary condGET1-MOM-F-A1-GET1-
Dec
ding
yrker in ofition.-65-
Loa
O
O
D
n 2391/2392
Oct 09, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
ec 11, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
187
MO
Res
Dea
Cur
In Oimp
In Dbee
– Hai Phongghway Proje
OM-66 (Dec
sponsible P
adline: 19-S
rrent status
October: Mplemented
December:en impleme
g Transport ect
)
Party: Cont
Sep-2012 (
s:
Mitigation me
Mitigationnted
Dec 11, 2
Corridor
tractor
immediate)
easure has
measure ha
2012
been
as not
Loan 23
Dec 1
Oct 1
Oct 1
91/2392 – VNo
1, 2012
6, 2012
6, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
188
Locatio
Site vis29 Nov
Date fir
Problemworker’
RecomEngineregularworkersRefer to66
Respon
Deadlin
Currenimplem
ai Phong Traay Project
on: Dai Duo
sit: 5, 9, 16;
rst observe
ms descrips camp is d
mmendationeer: Implem
basis to kes in cleanlino document
nsible Part
ne: 10-Oct-
t status: Mented
ansport Corr
ong Bridge
, 23, 30 Oct
ed: 18-Sep-
ption and cdirty with tra
n and Actioent housek
eep the livingness and sat REF-A1-G
ty: Contract
2012 (imme
Mitigation me
rridor
t; 6, 15, 20,
-2012
cause: Theash surround
on taken bykeeping worg condition
anitary condGET1-MOM-
tor
ediate)
easure has
27,
ding
yrker in ofition.-65,
been
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
189
Oct 30, 2012
Nov 20, 2012
Nov 20, 2012
Oct 05, 2012
Location: Cam I Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct; 6, 15, 20, 27, 29 Nov; 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Dec
Date first observed: 05-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Disposeof trash surrounding worker’s camps caused dirtiness and the septic tank was broken but has not been reinstalled yet
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Implement housekeeping worker in regular basis and reinstall the septic tanks to keep the living condition of workers in cleanliness and sanitary condition. Refer to
Loan 23
Oct 2
Oct 2
Nov 0
91/2392 – VNo
3, 2012
3, 2012
06, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
190
docume
Respon
Deadlin
Currenthe wortank for
ai Phong Traay Project
ent REF-A1
nsible Part
ne: 12-Oct-
t status: Trker’s camp r workers
D
D
ansport Corr
-GET1-MO
ty: Contract
2012 (imme
he Contractbut has no
ec 11, 2012
ec 11, 2012
rridor
OM-65, 66, 6
tor
ediate)
tor has cleaot provided s
2
2
67, 68
anedseptic
Loa
N
N
O
n 2391/2392
ov 06, 2012
ov 20, 2012
Oct 23, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
191
Loc
Site29
Dat
Proof tdirt
RecEngregwor(Or
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: Ngu
e visit: 5, 9Nov;
te first obs
oblems desrash surrouiness
commendagineer: Impular basis trkers in clearal requirem
g Transport ect
Dec 25, 2
uyen Tat Th
9, 16, 23, 30
served: 23-O
scription anunding work
ation and Aplement houo keep the anliness an
ment)
Corridor
2012
hanh Bridge
0 Oct; 6, 15
Oct-2012
nd cause: ker’s camps
Action takeusekeeping living condid sanitary c
e
, 20, 27,
Dispose caused
n by worker in
ition of condition.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
192
Oct 30, 2012
Nov 06, 2012
Nov 06, 2012
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 30-Oct-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
193
Oct 09, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Location: TL302CI Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct;
Date first observed: 09-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Disposeof trash surrounding worker’s camps caused dirtiness
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Implement housekeeping worker in regular basis to keep the living condition of workers in cleanliness and sanitary condition. Refer to document REF-A1-GET1-MOM-65
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 10-Oct-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
4.11.2 Package A2
Oct 10, 2012
Location: TL306I Bridge
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 30, 31 Oct
Date first observed: 24-Jul-2012
Problems description and cause: Livingcondition of workers working here is very poor. Lack of first aid kit, fire extinguisher and septic tank
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Reinstall the worker’s camp which meets the cleanliness and sanitary condition.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
194
Oct 31, 2012
Sanitation must be supplemented enough to ensure the sanitary condition for workers. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 20-Aug-2012 (immediate)
Current status: The Contractor has provided first-aid kit, fire extinguisher and septic tank for workers but has not reinstall the worker’s camp
Oct 03, 2012
Oct 17, 2012
Location: Interchange No. 6
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31 Oct; 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov;
Date first observed: 03-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Theworker’s camp and septic tank are dirty with trash due to lack of housekeeping activity
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Implement housekeeping work in regular basis to keep the worker’s camp in cleanliness and sanitary condition. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49, 50
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 06-Oct-2012 (immediate)
Current status: The mitigation measure has been implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
195
Nov 21, 2012
Nov 21, 2012
Oct 24, 2012
Location: Muong Dao Bridge and Ben Gao Bridge
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31 Oct; 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov; 10, 14, 19, 26 Dec
Date first observed:
Ben Gao Bridge: 17-Oct-2012
Muong Dao Bridge: 24-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause:
Muong Dao Bridge: the worker’s camp is dirty with trash surrounding
Ben Bao Bridge: the septic tank were removed but has not been reinstalled
Recommendation and Action taken by
Nov 2
Nov 2
Loan 23
Oct 24
21, 2012 (M
21, 2012 (M
91/2392 – VNo
4, 2012
Muong Dao B
Muong Dao B
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
Bridge)
Bridge)
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
196
EngineeregularworkerscleanlinrequiremGET1-M
Respon
Deadlin
Currentnot been
D
ai Phong Traay Project
er: Implemebasis and in
s to keep theess and san
ment). RefeMOM-50, 51
nsible Party
ne: Ben Gao
Muong D
t status: Thn implemen
Dec 26, 201
ansport Corr
ent housekenstall the see worker’s cnitary condr to docume
1, 52
y: Contracto
o Bridge: 23
Dao Bridge
he mitigationted
2 (Muong D
rridor
eeping workeptic tank focamp in ition. (Oral ent REF-A2
or
3-Oct-2012
: 25-Oct-20
n measure
Dao Bridge)
k in or
2-
012
has
)
Loa
Nov 21, 20
O
O
n 2391/2392
12 (Ben Ga
Oct 03, 2012
Oct 10, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
ao Bridge)
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
197
Loc
Site
Dat
Prowortras
RecEngreguclearequ
Res
Dea
Curnot
– Hai Phongghway Proje
Dec 26,
cation: Lo R
e visit: 3, 10
e first obse
oblems desrker’s camp sh due to lac
commendagineer: Impular basis toanliness anduirement)
sponsible P
adline: 06-O
rrent statusbeen imple
g Transport ect
2012 (Muo
River Bridge
0, 17, 24, 3
erved: 03-O
scription anand septic
ck of house
ation and Aplement houo keep the wd sanitary c
Party: Cont
Oct-2012 (im
s: The mitigemented
Corridor
ong Dao Bri
e
1
Oct-2012
nd cause: Ttank are di
ekeeping ac
Action takenusekeeping worker’s ca
condition. (O
tractor
mmediate)
gation meas
dge)
Therty with
ctivity
n by work in mp in
Oral
sure has
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
198
Oct 17, 2012
4.11.3 Package A3
All workers’ camps have been equipped fire extinguisher and first aid kids in package A3.
11-October 2012
Location: Workers’ camps at Red river bridge
Site visit: 01, 05, 11, 18, 25 –October; 1, 8, 11, 21, 29 -November 2012
Date first observed: 11 – October 2012
Problems description and cause: Toilet is duty in workers’ camps
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to clean toilet
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
199
08 – November 2012
15-August 2012
07 – December 2012
Location:Workers’ camps of contractors TGT
Site visit:15-August and 07– December 2012
Date first observed:11 – October 2012
Problems description and cause: Toilet is duty in workers’ camps
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to clean toilet
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
200
4.11.4 Package A4
Contractor did not provide fire extinguisher and first aid kid for workers’ camp at TL321C, 32C,
Ngoi Van bridge...
30-August 2012
11-October 2012
Location:Workers’ camps at Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012
Date first observed:30- August 2012
Problems description and cause: Toilet is very dirty
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to clean toilet.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
201
11-October 2012
18-October 2012
12-November 2012
Location:Workers’ camps at Ngoi Van Bridge
Site visit: 11 and 18 -October 2012; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed:11- October2012
Problems description and cause: Toilet is very dirty
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to clean toilet.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not improved
31 - December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
202
aid kid for workers’ camp
fire extinguisher for workers’ camp
Location: TL321C, 32C, Ngoi Van bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause: Contractor had provide fire extinguisher and first aid kid for workers’ camp
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Improve
4.11.5 Package A5
Common situations during this quarter were the following:
- The trashes have not been provided at the camps areas such as: Km112, Km118, Km128.
The Consultant found garbage thrown indiscriminately on the ground in the camps areas.
- The daily hygiene routine has still not been done in many areas of workers' camps such as:
Km112, Km118, Km128, Km120...
In October, through the inspection of workers’ camps conditions, the Consultant found that
there was not much improvement for this month; there are still some outstanding issues such
as:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
203
- Clean toilets and/or wastewater treatment system have not been built up at camps Km130,
Km120, Km145...
In November, there were some improvements as follows:
- The Contractor has provided fire fighting equipments, first aid kits at Km112 camps area,
Km118...
- Clean toilets were built at camps areas Km112, Km128..., but:
- First aid kits, fire extinguishers have not been provided at camp areas Km149, Km136...
- The clean toilets have not been built by the Contractor at camp area Km149.
In December, the Contractor has conducted activities to ensure the working and living
conditions in camps for workers, as for example:
- Clean water was guaranteed in the camps such as at Km112, Km132, Km145.
- The fire fighting equipments, first aid kits, trash cans... were still fully equipped at camps such
as Km112.
However, in some camps, living and working conditions were not properly guaranteed:
- Clean toilets were not built in the camps areas Km130, Km136...
- First aid kits, fire extinguishers have not been provided in a number of camps such as:
Km130, Km136...
To ensure the living and working conditions for workers in the camps areas, the Consultant
has reminded the Contractor on these outstanding issues. Also, in the inspection on site, the
Consultant has frequently requested the Contractor to carry out the daily sanitary work in the
camps areas to maintain them clean and neat.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
204
26th September, 2012
11th October, 2012
Location: the workers’ camp at Ngoi Rao bridge
Site visit: September, 26 and October, 11
Date first observed: 26-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Fuel tanks were put directly on the ground without any safety control measures.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to
implement following tasks:
- Remove fuel tanks to fuel storage area.
- Improve working and living condition at this camp.
- Comply with Project Safety Plan approved by the Engineer.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 5, 2012
Current status: Not yet improved
12th July, 2012
Location: Km118
Site visit: July, 12 and November, 26
Date first observed: 12-Jul-2012
Problems description and cause: Clean toilets were not built in the camps areas
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to built
sanitary toilet at this location, simultaneously, the
Engineer also required the Contractor ensure
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
205
26th November, 2012
living and working condition for workers at this
camp.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: August 10, 2012
Current status: Sanitary toilet has already built at this camp.
10th November, 2012
10th December, 2012
Location: Km130
Site visit: November, 10 and December, 10
Date first observed: 10-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Clean toilets were not built in the camps areas
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to built
sanitary toilet at this location, simultaneously, the
Engineer also required the Contractor ensure
living and working condition for workers at this
camp.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: November 30, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
206
4.11.6 Package A6
During this forth quarter, some improved situations were observed:
- Drinking water was still supplied to the camps areas.
- At the end of the period, the fire fighting equipments, first aid boxes, trash cans... were still
fully equipped at camps such as: Km164+900, Km176, Km186+720, Km184, Km186+200,
Km157...
- Clean toilets were not built in the camps areas Lang Nau bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge, Km176...
On the other hand, we have to mention the following comments:
October
- The daily hygiene routine was still not done in a number of workers’ camps such as at the
locations Ngoi Giam bridge, Km186, Km176, Km184...
- The wastewater treatment systems have not been built in the camp area: Km186, Km184,
Km176...
November
- The periodic cleaning is conducted regularly in a number of camps areas such as: Km165,
Km184, Km186+200.
- The daily and periodical hygiene works have still not been done in a number of workers’
camps such as at Ngoi Giam bridge, Lang Nau bridge, Km176.
- The wastewater treatment systems have not been built in the camp areas: Km186, Km184,
Km176...
December
- Some camps were maintained in clean condition, and sanitary works were conducted
regularly such as at: Km164+900, Km184, Km157...
- Clean toilets were also built such as in the regions Km164+900, Km157, Km186+200...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
207
- Waste was still indiscriminately thrown on the ground in some camps areas such as:
Km186+200, Ngoi Don bridge, Lang Nau bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge...
- First aid kits, fire extinguishers have not been provided in a number of camps such as:
Km155+300, Lang Nau bridge, Km179.
3rd October, 2012
10th October, 2012
Location: Worker’s camp Km184
Site visit: October, 3 and 10
Date first observed: 13-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Dustbins, first aid kits, fire-extinguishers were not provided at this worker’s camp.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to provided dustbins, first aid kits, fire-extinguishers for this worker’s camp
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 9, 2012
Current status: The Contractor provided dustbins, first-aid kits, fire-extinguishers for this camp.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
208
3rd October, 2012
10th October, 2012
Location: Worker’s camp Km165
Site visit: October, 3 and 10
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Rubbishes were thrown on the ground
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to provide dustbins this worker’s camp, simultaneously, to clean this camp.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 9, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has complied with the requirements from the Engineer in order to solve this work.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
209
4th September, 2012
19th December, 2012
Location: Worker’s camp Km184
Site visit: September, 4 and December, 19
Date first observed: 4-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: There was not sanitary toilet at this camp.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
The Engineer required the Contractor to build sanitary toilet at this camp.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 3, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has complied with the requirements from the Engineer.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
210
4.11.7 Package A7
15/11/2012
20/11/2012
Location: Worker camps at Km193+379
Site visit: 15 and 20-Nov 2012; 25 Dec 2012
Date first observed: 15-Nov 2012
Problems description and cause: The toilet had not provide septic tank and the ceramic to prevent odour and ensure clean
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor is required to provide septic tank and the ceramic for toilet to prevent odour and ensure clean
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 20-Nov 2012
Current status: The contractor not yet provided the septic tank and the ceramic for toilet to prevent odour and ensure clean
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
211
25.12.2012
4.11.8 Package A8
16-May 2012
19-October 2012
Location: Worker camps at Ngoi Bo Bridge Km238+265
Site visit: 16-May and 19-October 2012; 27 Dec 2012
Date first observed: 16-May 2012
Problems description and cause: At these worker camps the rubbish and waste watersponds around
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor collect and classification rubbish according to regulation.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Problems description and cause: At these worker camps the contractor provided rubbish bins and the worker camp clear and tidy
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
212
27.12.2012 27.12.2012
14/11/2012
14/11/2012
Location: Worker camps at Son Ha Brdige Km224+369
Site visit: 14-November 2012
Date first observed: 14-November 2012
Problems description and cause: At these worker camps the contractor not provide first aid kit and fire extinguishers
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to provide the aid kit and fire extinguishers
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30/11/2012
Current status: The contractor not yet improve
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
213
4.12 LABOUR SAFETY EQUIPMENT
4.12.1 Package A1
Oct 05, 2012
Oct 16, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Location: Trung Kien Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct; 6, 15, 20, 21, 27, 29 Nov; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed: 05-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdidn’t use PPE at work
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Stop the construction activity; provide enough PPE and safety facilities for workers and ensure all workers to use enough PPE at work. Reinstall the electric system and ensure that it’s safe enough for use. Refer to document REF-A1-GET1-MOM-65, 66, 67, 68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: The status of lack of PPE at work was usually detected onsite. The PSC has many time requested the Contractor to correct this issue but there is no improvement recorded.
The Contractor aready reinstalled the electric system to ensure the electric safety for workers
Loan 23
Nov 0
Nov 2
Dec 1
91/2392 – VNo
06, 2012
27, 2012
1, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
214
ai Phong Traay Project
ansport Corrrridor
Loa
D
O
O
n 2391/2392
ec 25, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
215
Loc
Site29
Dat
Prodidnsafewordoe
RecEngproequworreqRE
Res
Dea
Cur
Octfaci
Novinsp
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: Box
e visit: 5, 9Nov;
te first obs
oblems desn’t use PPEety ladder orkers workinesn’t have c
commendagineer: Stovide enoug
uiment/facilirkers to useuirement). RF-A1-GET1
sponsible P
adline: Imm
rrent status
tober: Stopilities are pr
vember: Wpections
g Transport ect
x culvert ~ K
9, 16, 23, 30
served: 30-O
scription anE at work anor scaffold sng at heightcover
ation and Aop the consth PPE and ities for wore enough PPRefer to min
1-MOM-66,
Party: Cont
mediate
s:
p the work urovided eno
We still found
Corridor
Km 20+448
0 Oct; 6, 15
Oct-2012
nd cause: Wnd there wasystem instat. Welding m
Action taketruction actisafety
rkers and enPE at work nutes of me67, 68
tractor
until the safeough.
d this issue
, 20, 27,
Workerss no alled for machine
n by vity;
nsure all (Oral
eeting
ety
in the site
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
216
Nov 27, 2012 Nov 20, 2012
Nov 20, 2012
Nov 27, 2012
Location: Ba Thien Bridge
Site visit: 6, 15, 20, 27, 29 Nov;
Date first observed: 20-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdidn’t use PPE at work
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Stop the construction activity; provide enough PPE and safety equiment/facilities for workers and ensure all workers to use enough PPE at work. Refer to minutes of meeting REF-A1-GET1-MOM-67, 68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: We still found this issue in the site inspections
Loa
N
N
D
n 2391/2392
ov 20, 2012
ov 27, 2012
ec 11, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
217
Loc
Site
Dat
Proof atheund
RecEngproequwormin67,
Res
Dea
Cur
In Nbee
In Dimp
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: Ngu
e visit: 6, 1
te first obs
oblems desaccident fro
Contractorder launche
commendagineer: Stovide enoug
uiment/facilirkers to usenutes of me
68
sponsible P
adline: Imm
rrent status
November:en impleme
December:plemented
g Transport ect
uyen Tat Th
5, 20, 27, 2
served: 06-N
scription anm falling in
r doesn’t insd PCI girde
ation and Aop the consth PPE and ities for wore enough PPeting REF-A
Party: Cont
mediate
s:
Mitigationnted
Mitigation
Corridor
hanh Bridge
29 Nov; 11,
Nov-2012
nd cause: work at hei
stall the safeers
Action taketruction actisafety
rkers and enPE at work.A1-GET1-M
tractor
measure ha
measure ha
e
25 Dec
High risk ight due to ety net
n by vity;
nsure all Refer to
MOM-66,
as not
as been
Loan 23
Dec 2
Nov 2
Nov 2
91/2392 – VNo
25, 2012
20, 2012
27, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
218
Locatio
Site vis
Date fir
Problemworkers
RecomEngineprovideequimeworkersminutes68
Respon
Deadlin
Currenbeen im
ai Phong Traay Project
on: Cam I B
sit: 6, 15, 20
rst observe
ms descrips didn’t use
mmendationeer: Stop thee enough PPent/facilitiess to use enos of meeting
nsible Part
ne: Immedia
t status: Mmplemented
ansport Corr
Bridge
0, 27, 29 No
ed: 20-Nov-
ption and cenough PP
n and Actioe constructPE and safefor workers
ough PPE ag REF-A1-G
ty: Contract
ate
Mitigation med
rridor
ov;
-2012
cause: ThePE at work
on taken byion activity;etys and ensurat work. RefGET1-MOM
tor
easure has
y
re all fer to
M-67,
not
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
219
4.12.2 Package A2
Oct 24, 2012
Oct 24, 2012
Location: Box culvert 42+050
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31 Oct;
Date first observed: 24-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Theworkers didn’t use PPE at work and lack of safety work ways.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Provide PPE for workers and ensure they use enough PPE at work; install safety work way and platform. (Oral requirement)
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 25-Oct-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
Oct 03, 2012
Location: Interchange No. 6
Site visit: 3, 10, 17, 24, 31
Date first observed: 03-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Theworkers didn’t use PPE at work
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Provide PPE for workers and ensure they use enough PPE at work. Refer to document REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49
Responsible Party: Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
220
Oct 24, 2012
Deadline: 04-Oct-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
Nov 13, 2012
Nov 13, 2012
Location: Qua Bao Bridge and Box culvert Km 47+431
Site visit: 13, 15, 38 Nov;
Date first observed: 13-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Theworkers didn’t use PPE at work and lack of safety work ways.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Provide PPE for workers and ensure they use enough PPE at work; install safety work way and platform. (Oral requirement)
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 13-Nov-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has been implemented
Loa
De
De
De
n 2391/2392
ec 26, 2012
ec 26, 2012
ec 27, 2012
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
221
LocBrid
Site
Dat
Prowor
RecEngtheens
Res
Dea
Curimp
Loc
Site
Dat
Proworsafe
RecEngtheenssafeens
– Hai Phongghway Proje
cation: TL3dge
e visit: 5, 10
e first obse
oblems desrkers didn’t
commendagineer: TheContractorure they us
sponsible P
adline: Imm
rrent statuslemented
cation: Box
e visit: 14, 2
e first obse
oblems desrkers didn’t ety work wa
commendagineer: TheContractorure they us
ety work waure the safe
g Transport ect
06I Bridge a
0, 14, 19, 2
erved: 26-N
scription anuse PPE at
ation and Ae Engineer h
to provide Pse enough P
Party: Cont
mediate
s: Mitigation
culvert Km
27
erved: 26-N
scription anuse PPE at
ay
ation and Ae Engineer h
to provide Pse enough Pay also musety at work
Corridor
and Muong
6
Nov-2012
nd cause: Tt work
Action takenhas orally inPPE for wo
PPE at work
tractor
n measure h
m 47+431
Nov-2012
nd cause: Tt work and l
Action takenhas orally inPPE for wo
PPE at workt be installe
Dao
The
n by nstructedrkers and
k
has been
Theack of
n by nstructedrkers and
k; the ed to
4.12.3 Pac
Loan 23
Dec 2
Dec 2
ckage A3
26-Sep
91/2392 – VNo
7, 2012
7, 2012
ptember 20
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
12
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
222
Respon
Deadlin
Currentimpleme
Lo
Sit11
Da
Prodo
ReEnanwo
ai Phong Traay Project
nsible Party
ne: 28-Dec-
t status: Mented
ocation: IC8
te visit: 01, 21, 29 -No
ate first obs
oblems denot use en
ecommendngineer: Red propose
orker contin
ansport Corr
y: Contracto
-2012
itigation me
8 bridge
, 05, 11, 1ovember 20
served: 26-
escriptionough PPEs
ation andequire the slabour safe
nues to viol
rridor
or
easure has
18, 25 –Oc012
-September
and causs while work
d Action subcontractoety for worate the reg
been
ctober; 1, 8
r 2012
e: Workersking on site
taken byor to remindkers. If any
gulation, wil
8,
s
ydyll
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
223
5-October 2012
be fired.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
08-November 2012
21-November 2012
Location: Box culvert Km64+998
Site visit: 08 and 21-November 2012
Date first observed: 08-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdo not use enough PPEs while working on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the subcontractor to remind and propose labour safety for workers. If any worker continues to violate the regulation, will be fired.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
224
08-November 2012
21-November 2012
Location: Red river bridge
Site visit: 08 and 21-November 2012
Date first observed: 08-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Electric fire was not safe.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the subcontractor change Electric fire safety.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
04 - December 2012
Location: Lung Thuong Bridge
Site visit: 4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December, 2012
Date first observed:04-December 2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdo not use enough PPEs while working on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the subcontractor to remind and propose labour safety for workers. If any worker continues to violate the regulation, will be fired.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
225
06-December 2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
4.12.4 Package A4
13-September 2012
18-October 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 13-September 2012
Problems description and cause: Electriccontact is not safe on site
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to hang electric contact up and protect it by box
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status:
In November: Not yet improve up to now
In December: Improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
226
12-November 2012 06-Decbember 2012
30-August 2012
18-October 2012
Location: Ngoi Van bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23, 26-October; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012
Date first observed:30-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Temporarybridge is not safe enough for traveling
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to make new handrail
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: Not Implemented
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
227
05-October 2012
18-October 2012
Location:Ngoi Van bridge
Site visit:05 and 18-October 2012
Date first observed:05-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Worker did not PPes
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to make new handrail
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not Implemented
4.12.5 Package A5
This quarter, the Contractor has not mobilized personnel for Safety Manager position, so the
safety works of the Contractor during the period have not been implemented properly. Also,
the Contractor has not hold meetings on the safety of the workers and engineers.
Since there was no improvement in the safety management of Contractor quarter, the
Consultant has proposed alternative EPMU to replace Safety Manager and requested the
Contractor to have strong action to ensure the safety of the project.
Also, many workers could be seen without waring personal protection equipment during the
working process.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
228
In November; in addition, the safety equipments such as: fire prevention equipment, safety
fences, warning signs have not fully provided in fuel station areas such as Km112, Ngoi Gua
bridge, Km148, Km145 ...
In December, many workers still not awared of using personal protective equipment when
working on site, as it happened at stations Ngoi Thia bridge, Ngoi Vien bridge, Ngoi Gua
bridge, Km124...
No improvement at the fuel stations such as Km130, Ngoi Gua bridge, Km136, Ngoi Thia
bridge...
First aid kits, fire extinguishers have not been provided in several camps such as: Km130,
Km136...
In the area of Ngoi Vien bridge, the safety conditions in the construction process are very poor:
no safety scaffoldings, no safety access stairs...
The Consultant has frequently required the Contractor to strictly comply with the Contractor’s
Method Statement and Safety Control Plan of the project during construction process.
10th October, 2012
Location: Ngoi Thia bridge’s construction site
Site visit: October, 10 and 16; November, 25
Date first observed: 10-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Some workers do not use fully PPR during work, not ensuring safety.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to ensure that all the workers must use fully PPE during working time in order to keep the project’s safety during construction.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: The Contractor has provided PPE for the workers at this location (e.g. helmet, safety shoes,…)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
229
16th October, 2012
15th November, 2012
15th November, 2012
Location: Ngoi Buc bridge’s construction site
Site visit: November, 15 and December, 7
Date first observed: 15-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Some workers do not use fully PPR during work, not ensuring safety.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to ensure that all the workers must use fully PPE during working time in order to keep the project’s safety during construction.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
230
7th December, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has provided PPE for the workers at this location (e.g. helmet, safety shoes,…)
17th December, 2012
27th December, 2012
Location: Ngoi Vien bridge’s construction site
Site visit: December, 7 and 27
Date first observed: 7-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Someworkers do not use fully PPR during work, not ensuring safety.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to ensure that all the workers must use fully PPE during working time in order to keep the project’s safety during construction.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: No improvement seen
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
231
4.12.6 Package A6
During this period, all months, Contractor
- Organized meetings on safety for workers and engineers to promote and remind the
importance of safety in the construction process as well as the importance of personal
protective equipment PPE and safety equipment.
- Arranged personnal to inspect on site and remind workers to use full PPE during
working on site.
- Equipped personal protective equipment (helmet, goggles, ear protection equipment,
etc.) for workers in the tunnel construction location; Arranging staff to ensure all
workers fully use PPE when working at tunnel construction site.
In October, through the inspection and supervision on site, the Consultant found that the
Contractor has continued to take actions to ensure the safety of the project:
- Many workers were aware of the use of PPE in the working process.
- The fire fighting equipments, first aid kits have been provided at a number of camps: Km184,
Km186...
However, there are still some outstanding issues in the safety control of the Contractor as
follows:
- Some workers still did not use full protection equipments when working at: Lang Nhay bridge,
Ngoi That bridge, Km165...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
232
- The safety equipments such as fire extinguishers, first aid kits were not fully provided in many
camps areas of Lang Nau bridge, Km161...
In November, there were still some outstanding issues in the safety control as follows:
- At some bridge construction locations such as: Lang Nhay bridge, Dao Viet bridge, Ngoi Don
bridge,... some workers have still not used fully protective equipments in the process of
working on high place such as safety ropes, safety helmets.
- The safety equipments such as fire extinguishers, first aid kits were not fully provided in some
camp areas such as Lang Lau bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge.
In addition, in this month, the Consultant has organized a safety and environment training for
Contractor and Subcontractors of package A6 to raise the awareness of safety and the
environment work in the implementation process of the project.
In December, the Contractor has been continuing to conduct activities to ensure the safety of
the project:
- Many workers of the package A6 have more awareness in using personal protective
equipment during working process.
- At some fuel stations such as Km164+900, Km186+200, Km171+100... fire fighting
equipments were maintained.
Some some outstanding issues in the safety control have to be mentioned:
- First aid kits, fire extinguishers have not been provided in a number of camps: Km155+300,
Lang Nau bridge, Km179.
- Some workers still did not have the awareness of using fully protective equipment during
working such as at: Km155, Ngoi Giam bridge, Ngoi chac bridge...
Location: Km165
Site visit: October, 10 and 23
Date first observed: 10-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Some workers
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
233
10th October, 2012
23rd October, 2012
do not use fully PPR during work, not ensuring safety.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to ensure that all the workers must use fully PPE during working time in order to keep the project’s safety during construction.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: The Contractor has provided PPE for the workers at this location (e.g. helmet, safety shoes,…)
Location: Ngoi Don bridge’s construction site
Site visit: November,5 and 13
Date first observed: 5-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Some workers do not use fully PPR during work, not ensuring safety.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to ensure that all the workers must use fully PPE
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
234
5th November, 2012
13th November, 2012
during working time in order to keep the project’s safety during construction.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: The Contractor has provided PPE for the workers at this location (e.g. helmet, safety shoes,…)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
235
11th December, 2012
19th December, 2012
Location: Ngoi Don bridge’s construction site
Site visit: December, 11 and 19
Date first observed: 11-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Some workers do not use fully PPR during work, not ensuring safety.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to ensure that all the workers must use fully PPE during working time in order to keep the project’s safety during construction.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: Immediate
Current status: The Contractor has provided PPE for the workers at this location (e.g. helmet, safety shoes,…)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
236
4.12.7 Package A7
01-October 2012
30-October 2012
11.12.2012
Location: Thin Thung II Bridge Km199+050
Site visit: 1 and 30-October 2012; 11 Dec 2012
First observed: 1-October 2012
Problems description and cause: The worker supported the full labour equipment during the working time
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The consultant had issued letter No: Ref. GET4- GRBCC- 735 with contents: “The Second time warning to Pan Lin Feng (Phan Lam Phong)- Safety manager of package A7”
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: In this period, the contractor had didn’t improve
Location: Tan Tien Bridge Km209+329 and Khe Dai Bridge Km201+815
Site visit: 20-November 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
237
20-November 2012
20-November 2012
First observed: 20-November 2012
Problems description and cause: The worker supported the full labour equipment during the working time
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The consultant had issued letter No: Ref. GET4- GRBCC- 735 with contents: “The Second time warning to Pan Lin Feng (Phan Lam Phong)- Safety manager of package A7”
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: During on November the contractor had didn’t improve
4.12.8 Package A8
10-October 2012
Location: Construction works of Lang Tra Bridge Km220+993
Site visit: 10 and 19-October 2012
Date first observed: 10-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdon't wear enough labour protection while working
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the subcontractor to remind and propose labour safety for workers. If any worker continues to violate the regulation, will be fired.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
238
19-October 2012
9/11/2012
22/11/2012
Location: Construction works of IC17 Bridge Km233+540
Site visit: 9 and 22-November 2012
Date first observed: 9-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdon't wear enough labour protection while working
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the subcontractor to remind and propose labour safety for workers. If any worker continues to violate the regulation, will be fired.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
Location: Construction works of Xuan Giao Bridge Km232+437
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
239
14.12.2012
27.12.2012
Site visit: 14 and 27.12.2012
Date first observed: 14.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Workersdon't wear enough labour protection while working
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the subcontractor to remind and propose labour safety for workers. If any worker continues to violate the regulation, will be fired.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Daily
Current status: Not yet improve up to now
4.13 TRAFFIC CONDITIONS AND SIGNPOSTING IN ROADS
4.13.1 Package A1
Location: Tan Loi Bridge
Site visit: 5, 9, 16, 23, 30 Oct;
Date first observed: 08-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: Lack of security fence and signboard system
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Install the fence and signboard system
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
240
Oct 23, 2012
Oct 23, 2012
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 02-Sep-2012 (immediate)
Current status: Mitigation measure has not been implemented
Nov 27, 2012
Location: Trung Kien Bridge, Ba Thien Bridge
Site visit: 6, 15, 20, 21, 27, 29 Nov; 11, 25 Dec
Date first observed: 27-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Dirt is tracked onto public road cause dirtiness and difficulty for travelers
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Mobilize the water truck and worker to clean and remove the soil on public road. Refer to minutes of meeting REF-A1-GET1-MOM-68
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 27-Nov-2012 (immediate)
Loa
N
N
D
n 2391/2392
Nov 29, 201
Nov 29, 201
Dec 25, 201
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
241
Cu
Inthestil
Inim
– Hai Phongghway Proje
urrent statu
Novembere water trucll found the
Decemberplemented
g Transport ect
us:
r: The Contrck to clean t
dirtiness in
r: Mitigation
Dec 11, 2
Dec 25, 2
Corridor
ractor has mthese areasn the site ins
measure h
2012
2012
mobilizeds but we spections
has been
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
242
4.13.2 Package A2
Oct 03, 2012
Oct 10, 2012
Location: Muong Noi Bridge
Site visit: 3, 10, 16, 17, 24, 31
Date first observed: 03-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: Lack of safety fence
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:Install safety fence to ensure traffic condition and safety on site. (Oral requirement)
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 10-Oct-2012
Current status: Mitigation measure has been implemented
Oct 30, 2012
Location: TL305 Bridge
Site visit: 3, 10, 15, 17, 24, 30, 31 Oct; 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov; 5, 14, 26 Dec
Date first observed: 27-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: The detour road deteriorated and cause difficulty for road users
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:Supplement the sub-base to level the surface of detour road as well as raise the elevation of
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
243
Oct 30, 2012
detour road; install the drainage system to avoid the water stagnancy. Refer to letter GET1/POS/A2/1529, GET1/POS/A2/1580, GET1/POS/A21601, GET1/POS/A2/1624, REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49, 50, 51, 52
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 30-Sep-2012 (to be extended to 10-Nov-2012)
Current status:
In October and November: Mitigationmeasures have not been implemented
In December: The Contractor has leveled and increase the elevation of detour road, but it is still noted that the slippery status happened in rainy days
Loan 23
Nov 2
Nov 2
Dec 0
91/2392 – VNo
8, 2012
8, 2012
5, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
244
ai Phong Traay Project
D
ansport Corr
Dec 26, 2012
rridor
2
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
245
Oct 30, 2012
Oct 30, 2012
Nov 28, 2012
Location: TL306I Bridge
Site visit: 3, 10, 15, 17, 24, 30, 31 Oct; 13, 20, 21, 28 Nov; 5, 10, 14, 26 Dec
Date first observed: 27-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: The detour road deteriorated and cause difficulty for road users
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:Supplement the sub-base to level the surface of detour road as well as raise the elevation of detour road; install the drainage system to avoid the water stagnancy. Refer to letter GET1/POS/A2/1580, GET1/POS/A21601, GET1/POS/A2/1624 and minutes of meetings REF-A2-GET1-MOM-50, 51, 52;
Responsible Party: Contractor
Deadline: 10-Nov-2012
Current status:
In October and November: Mitigationmeasures have not been implemented
In December: The Contractor has leveled and increase the elevation of detour road, but it is still noted that the slippery status happened in rainy days
Loan 23
Nov 2
Dec 0
Nov 2
91/2392 – VNo
8, 2012
5, 2012
8, 2012
VIE: GMS Kuoi Bai – Lao
unming – Hao Cai Highwa
246
Locatio
Site vis
Date fir
Problemdeteriorroad cau
RecommEngineepublic roon site. GET1-M
Respon
ai Phong Traay Project
D
on: TL306II
sit: 13, 20, 2
rst observe
ms descripated and diusing difficu
mendationer: Reinstaoad to ensuRefer to mi
MOM-51, 52
nsible Party
ansport Corr
Dec 26, 2012
Bridge
21, 28 Nov;
ed: 13-Nov-
ption and cart was trackulty for trave
n and Actioll safety fen
ure traffic coinutes of me2, letter GET
y: Contracto
rridor
2
14, 27 Dec
-2012
ause: Fencked onto puelers
on taken bynce and cleaondition andeeting REFT1/POS/A2/
or
c
ceublic
yand safety -A2-/1602
4.13.3
Loa
No
De
Package A
0
n 2391/2392
ov 21, 2012
ec 14, 2012
A3
08-August 2
2 – VIE: GMSNoi Bai –
2
2
2012
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hig
247
Dea
Curbee
– Hai Phongghway Proje
adline: 16-N
rrent statusen implemen
Location:
Site visit:8, 11, 21,
Date first
Problemsfence was
RecommeEngineer:the fence
g Transport ect
Nov-2012
s: Mitigationnted
Dec 27,
: TL320B br
: 01, 05, 1129 –Novem
observed:
s descriptis broken dow
endation a: Requestor set up ne
Corridor
n measure h
2012
ridge
1, 18, 25 -Omber 2012
: 08 - Augus
on and cawn
and ActionContractor
ew one
has not
October, 1,
st 2012
ause: Safe
n taken byr to repair
,
e
yr
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
248
18-October 2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 19-September 2012
Current status: Not Improved
18-October 2012
08-November 2012
Location: TL320C bridge
Site visit: 18–October and 08–November 2012
Date first observed: 18 – October 2012
Problems description and cause: Safefence was broken down
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to repair the fence or set up new one
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30-October 2012
Current status: Not Improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
249
08-August 2012
11-December 2012
Location: PhongChau bridge
Site visit: 08-August4, 7, 11, 18, 25 - December, 2012
Date first observed:08-August2012
Problems description and cause: Safe fence was broken down
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: 121212-GET2-POS-A3-1638-Request to treat safety work at Lung Thuong and PhongChau bridge.
Responsible Party:
Deadline: immediately
Current status: NotImproved
4.13.4 Package A4
The sites were full of mud because It rained heavily in October. It was very difficult to travel
along local roads. Signposting in access roads were not set up as our requirement.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
250
30-August 2012
25-October 2012
Location: Ngoi Van Bridge
Site visit: 25 – October 2012
Date first observed:30-August 2012
Problems description and cause: Safe fence was broken down
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to set up safe fence
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 10-September 2012
Current status:Improve
02 - November 2012
Location: TL321C Bridge
Site visit: 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012l; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed: 04 - October 2012
Problems description and cause: Safe fence was broken down
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to set up safe fence
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM
Deadline: 30-October 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
251
17-November 2012
12 - December 2012
31-December 2012
Current status:
In November: Improved
In December: Not improved
31-December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
252
4.13.5 Package A5
26th September, 2012
10th October, 2012
Location: Access road Km112
Site visit: September, 26 and October, 10
Date first observed: 26-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Safetyfences and signboards were not installed fully at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to install safety fences and signboards at this location in order to keep the project’s safety.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Jul 12, 2012
Current status: Safety signboards have been installed at this location.
In October, the Consultant found that the Contractor's traffic maintenance had not much
improvement; there are still some outstanding issues, which have not been addressed as
follows:
- The Contractor has not repaired the public roads affected by the construction and
transportation of raw materials process such as at: Hop Minh My bridge, Km148, Km112... this
makes it difficult for the traffic driving through this area.
- At some locations, warning signs and safety fences have not been fully installed such as: the
intersections with public roads like: Km112, Km148, Km132... or the construction locations
near the public road such as Km145, Km116...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
253
- At some locations, soil dropped on the public roads during construction and transportation of
raw materials has not been collected by the Contractor such as: Km118, Km148...
26th June, 2012
16th November, 2012
Location: NR37 bridge’s construction site
Site visit: June, 26 and November, 16
Date first observed: 26-Jun-2012
Problems description and cause: Safety fences and signboards were not installed fully at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to install safety fences and signboards at this location in order to keep the project’s safety.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Jul 12, 2012
Current status: Safety signboards have been installed at this location.
In November, tthe main outstanding issues are the following:
- The Contractor's construction process has influenced the quality of public roads in some
areas such as Km148, Hop Minh My bridge. However, the Contractor has not repaired the
roads; this has caused difficulties for the traffic media to flow through the area.
- In some areas, soil has dropped on the public roads during construction and transportation of
raw materials without being collected by the Contractor such as at: Km118, Km148, Km124...
- The fences and warning signs have not been completely supplied and installed at the
construction locations such as: the intersections with public roads: Km112, Km148, Km132...
or construction locations near public roads such as Km145, Km116...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
254
17th December, 2012
28th December, 2012
Location: Construction site Km124
Site visit: December, 17 and 28
Date first observed: 17-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Safety fences and signboards were not installed fully at construction site which intersecting with public road.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to install safety fences and signboards at this location in order to keep the project’s safety.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Dec 22, 2012
Current status: Safety fences and signboards still have not been installed at this location.
In December, it could be observed that:
- The Contractor has not repaired a number of public roads damaged by the construction
activities of the Contractor such as at Km148, Hop Minh My bridge, ... this made it difficult for
the media going through these areas.
- At stations Km118, Km148, Km124, the Contractor has not yet collected soil dropped on the
public roads during transportation of raw materials.
- The Contractor has not allocated personnel to guide and control traffic at the construction
locations near the public roads such as Km148, Km124, Km118, ...
- The Contractor has not fully installed safety fences and warning signs at some construction
locations such as: the construction locations intersecting the public roads: Km112, Km148,
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
255
Km132, Ngoi Rao bridge, QL37... or the construction locations near the public roads such as
Km145, Km116...
4.13.6 Package A6
3rd October, 2012
30th October, 2012
Location: Km156
Site visit: October, 3 and 30
Date first observed: 3-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s material transportation and construction is causing impact to quality of public road.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to immediately repair damaged roads in order to ensure the region’s traffic.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: October 23, 2012
Current status: The Contractor repair this damaged roads in order to maintain the region’s traffic.
In October, the Consultant found that the Contractor has continued works to ensure the traffic
and safety of the project during the construction process:
- Arranging personnel to inspect, guide and ensure traffic on site in the construction locations
intersecting with public roads.
- Carrying out repairing public roads affected by the construction activities of the Contractor
like Km159, Km174, Km190, Km186...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
256
- Installing warning signs and safety fences in the construction locations near the public roads
such as: Km151, Km161, Km186, Ngoi Giam bridge...
However, at some locations, soil dropped on the public roads during construction and
transportation of raw materials have not been collected by the Contractor such as at stations:
Km151, Km154, Km174...
6th August, 2012
16th November, 2012
Location: Km186
Site visit: August, 6 and November, 16
Date first observed: 6-Aug-2012
Problems description and cause: The Contractor’s material transportation and construction is causing impact to quality of public road.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to immediately repair damaged roads in order to ensure the region’s traffic.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: August 30, 2012
Current status: The Contractor repair this damaged roads in order to maintain the region’s traffic.
In November, the Contractor has taken some actions to ensure the safety and traffic of the
region, namely:
- Carrying out repairing public roads which were affected by the construction activities of the
Contractor such as at: Km172, Km176, Km174, Km190...
- Installing warning signs and safety fences at the construction locations near the public roads
such as at: Km161, Km165, Km186...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
257
- Arranging the personnel for site inspection to ensure traffic at the construction locations
intersecting with public roads.
However, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- At the stations Km155 +300, Km161, Km174, Km159, the Contractor has still not collected
soil which was slid down a public road.
- At Km190, Km187, Km174, Km176, the construction locations near the public roads;
however, the Contractor has not fully installed safety fences and warning signs at the
construction locations.
15th November, 2012
19th December, 2012
Location: Km155+300
Site visit: November, 5 and December, 19
Date first observed: 5-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: At stations Km155+300, the Contractor has not carried out collecting soil eroded and slid down on the public roads, and the Contractor has not repaired damaged public roads.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to immediately repair damaged roads in order to ensure the region’s traffic.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: November 30, 2012
Current status: No improvement seen
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
258
10th November, 2012
19th December, 2012
Location: Km151+900
Site visit: November, 10 and December, 11
Date first observed: 5-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: PCPCs were placed on the provincial road’s areas that do not ensure safety for vehicles travelling through this location, Km151+900.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to immediately remove these RCPCs to the right places so as to ensure safety traffic.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: November 22, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already removed these RCPCs to the right places.
In December, the Consultant found that the Contractor has continued to conduct activities to
ensure traffic and safety in the project’s implementation process:
- Works of repairing the damaged roads were still done by the Contractor at: Km156, Km174,
Km186...
- Relocating the RC pipe culvert located near public roads to ensure traffic safety at Km152,
Km154.
- Safety fences and warning signs were provided at positions close to the provincial roads:
Km165, Km174, Km159... and the construction locations intersecting with public roads such
as: Km161, Ngoi Giam bridge...
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
259
- Arranging personnel to inspect on site to ensure traffic at the construction locations
intersecting with public roads.
- At Km165, Km162, Km174... the Contractor has collected soil dropped on the roads of
transporting materials.
However, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- At stations Km155+300, Km151+100... the Contractor has not carried out collecting soil
eroded and slid down on the public roads, and the Contractor has not repaired damaged public
roads.
- At Km187, Km186, Km176, the construction locations are near the public roads; however, the
Contractor has not fully installed safety fences and warning signs at the construction locations.
- Some Contractor's access roads have not been maintained in good condition, which made it
difficult for the traffic, especially on rainy days such as at: Km155, Km164 Km183...
To ensure safety and traffic of the project, the Consultant has requested the Contractor to
apply radical measures to resolve these outstanding issues. In addition, the Consultant has
also required the Contractor to comply with the Method Statement and Traffic Maintenance
and Ensuring Plan to prevent adverse impacts on the regional traffic.
4.13.7 Package A7
01-October 2012
Location: Exist road at Km194+200
Site visit: 1 and 8-October 2012;
Date first observed: 01-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Theaccess roads many mud and difficult traffic
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor is required to repair and consolidate the road surface to convenient traffic for local people
Responsible Party:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
260
08-October 2012
Deadline: Frequency
Current status: The contractor didn’t repair the exist road to convenient traffic for local people
06-November 2012
03-December 2012
Location: Exist road at Km198+400
Site visit: 6 Nov; 3 Dec and 4 Jan 2013
Date first observed: 06-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Theaccess roads many mud and difficult traffic
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The contractor is required to repair and consolidate the road surface to convenient traffic for local people
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Frequency
Current status: The contractor didn’t repair the exist road to convenient traffic for local people
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
261
4.1.2013
4.13.8 Package A8
19-October 2012
2-November 2012
Location: Exist road at Km244+155
Site visit: 19-October and 2-November 2012
Date first observed: 19-Oct 2012
Problems description and cause: Existroad many mud and slip, it is difficult for traffic
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to repair to ensure traffic influence for local people
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 30/10/2012
Current status: The contractor had repair exist road and makes good condition for traffic of local people
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
262
03-October 2012
19-October 2012
9/11/2012
Location: Exist road at Km 220+794
Site visit: 3 and 19-October 2012, 9 November 2012
Date first observed: 3-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Exist road many mud and slip, it is difficult for traffic
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to repair to ensure traffic influence for local people
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/10/2012
Current status: The contractor didn’t repair exist road and makes good condition for traffic of local people
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
263
14-November 2012
22-November 2012
7.12.2012
Location: Exist road at Km237+000
Site visit: 14 and 22-November 2012; 7 Dec2012
Date first observed: 14-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Existroad many mud and slip, it is difficult for traffic
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to repair to ensure traffic influence for local people
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 15/11/2012
Current status: The contractor didn’t repair exist road and makes good condition for traffic of local people
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
264
4.14 SIGNPOSTING IN DANGEROUS SURFACES
4.14.1 Package A1
In this period, in the site inspections, we didn’t detect the problem regarding signposting in
dangerous surfaces/areas. However, the Engineer has recommended the Contractor to pay
attention to this matter and immediately apply the necessary countermeasures if there is any
issue happened on site in order to prevent accident.
4.14.2 Package A2
In this period, in the site inspections, we didn’t detect the problem on the sites. However, the
Engineer also recommended the Contractor to pay attention to this issue if it happens and the
necessary countermeasures must be applied to prevent accident happening.
4.14.3 Package A3
05-October 2012
Location: Box culvet Km64+998
Site visit: 05-October 2012
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause:
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Responsible Party:
Deadline:
Current status:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
265
08-November 2012
Location: TL320B
Site visit: 08-November 2012
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause:
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Responsible Party:
Deadline:
Current status:
06-December 2012
Location: Red river Bridge
Site visit: 06-December 2012
Date first observed:
Problems description and cause:
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer:
Responsible Party:
Deadline:
Current status:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
266
4.14.4 Package A4
13-September 2012
11-October 2012
17-November 2012
Location: Ngoi Gianh Bridge
Site visit: 05, 11, 18, 23,26 – October; 02, 12, 17, 30 – November 2012; 06, 12, 19, 31 – December 2012
Date first observed:13-September 2012
Problems description and cause: Signposting at dangerous surface was not set up
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Request Contractor to set up safe signposting
Responsible Party:
Deadline: 20-September 2012
Current status: improve
31-December 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
267
4.14.5 Package A5
3rd October, 2012
16th October, 2012
Location: Ngoi Rao bridge construction site
Site visit: October, 3 and 16
Date first observed: 23-Oct-2012
Problems description and cause: There are not safety fences and safety signboard at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to install safety fences and signboards at this location in order to keep the project’s safety.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: October 12, 2012
Current status: Not yet implemented.
October
- The fences and warning signs at the construction locations Ngoi Rao bridge, Ngoi Gua
bridge, Ngoi Lau bridge have been severely damaged. However, the Contractor has failed to
carry out repairing the safety factors.
- The safety fence and warning signs have not been installed in dangerous surfaces such as:
Access roads Km114, Km115, Km118, Km119... the underground drainage area Km117,
drainage area Km118, irrigation culvert Km119... Ngoi Thap bridge, Ngoi Thia bridge...
- At QL37 bridge, Hop Minh My bridge, Van Phu bridge... safety fences and warning signs
have very poor quality, which do not fully meet the requirements of the project.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
268
2nd November, 2012
27th November, 2012
Location: Fuel storage area Km112
Site visit: November, 2 and 27
Date first observed: 2-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Safety fences and signboards were not installed fully at fuel storage area.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to install safety fences and signboards at this location in order to keep the project’s safety.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Nov 10, 2012
Current status: Safety fences and signboards were installed at this location.
In November, the Consultant found that the Contractor's safety control has not been fully paid
attention:
- The safety fences and warning signs have very poor quality; they do not fully meet the
requirements of the project such as at the bridge areas of the Ngoi Buc bridge, Hop Minh My
bridge, Van Phu bridge... However, there is no action to repair and replace the safety factors in
these areas.
- The safety fences and warning signs have not been installed in hazardous surfaces such as:
access roads Km114, Km115, Km118, Km119... the underground drainage pipe Km117,
drainage area Km118, drainage irrigation Km119...
- The fences and warning signs at the construction sites of Ngoi Rao bridge, Ngoi Gua bridge
were severely damaged; however, the Contractor has failed to carry out repairing and
installation of the safety factors.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
269
- The fences and warning signs have not been completely supplied and installed at the
construction locations such as: the intersections with public roads: Km112, Km148, Km132...
or construction locations near public roads such as Km145, Km116...
17th December, 2012
27th December, 2012
Location: Ngoi Vien bridge’s construction site
Site visit: December, 17 and 27
Date first observed: 17-Dec-2012
Problems description and cause: Safety fences and signboards were not installed fully at construction site which intersecting with public road.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to install safety fences and signboards at this location in order to keep the project’s safety.
Responsible Party: KEANGNAM Contractor
Deadline: Dec 22, 2012
Current status: Safety fences and signboards still have not been installed at this location.
In December, the safety control of the Contractor did not have many improvements respect to
the previous months. Some outstanding issues are as follows:
- The Contractor has not fully installed safety fences and warning signs at some construction
locations such as: the construction locations intersecting with public roads: Km112, Km148,
Km132, Ngoi Rao bridge, QL37... or the construction locations near the public road such as
Km145, Km116...
- Some safety fences have been installed at some construction locations such as: Ngoi Buc
bridge, Van Phu bridge, access roads Km114, Km115, Hop Minh My bridge... However, these
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
270
safety fences have poor quality, do not meet the requirements of the project. So far, the
Contractor does not have any action to repair and replace the safety factors in these areas.
- The safety fences and warning signs have not been installed in hazardous surfaces such as:
access roads Km116, Km118, Km119... the the underground drainage pipe Km117, Km124,
drainage pipe Km118 , Km142, Km141, drain irrigation Km119, Km123, Ngoi Vien bridge...
To ensure the safety of the project, the Consultant has requested the Contractor to apply the
appropriate measures as well as fully install safety fences and warning signs in dangerous
surfaces.
4.14.6 Package A6
17th October, 2012
28th October, 2012
Location: Km159
Site visit: September, 26 and October, 10
Date first observed: 26-Sep-2012
Problems description and cause: Construction site is closed to public road, risk of rock falling down can be happened, but lack of safety signboards at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to apply measures in order ensure safety during work at this location, at the same time, the Engineer also required the Contractor to install fully safety signboards.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: Sep 30, 2012
Current status: Safety signboard has been installed at this location.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
271
In October, through the inspection and supervision on site, the Consultant found that the
Contractor has continued to take actions to ensure safety in dangerous surfaces such as:
- Arranging staff to test safety and traffic on the site, reminding about safety and traffic issues.
- The warning signs in dangerous surfaces were remained, such as in slope areas where
landslide easily occures Km154, Km155, access road: Km184, Km 186, the bridge
construction locations: Khe Chuong bridge, Lang Nhay bridge, Ngoi Nhuoc bridge...
- The safety slogans and safety signs were remained on site to raise the awareness of the role
of the safety for workers in the process of working such as at: Km186+200, Km186+720, Dai
Viet bridge, Ngoi Rom bridge...
However, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- Some access roads such as Km154, Km155, Km176... bridge construction location: Ngoi
Nhuoc brigde, Lang Nhay bridge, Ngoi Hut bridge... the safety fences and warning signs were
heavily damaged, but still not be fixed by contractors.
- At stations Km190, Km174, Km176, the construction locations near the public road, but the
Contractor has not fully installed safety fences and warning signs there.
13th November, 2012
Location: Km174
Site visit: November, 13 and 27
Date first observed: 13-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Construction site is closed to public road, risk of rock falling down can be happened, but lack of safety signboards at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer requires the Contractor to apply measures in order ensure safety during work at this location, at the same time, the Engineer also required the Contractor to install fully safety signboards.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
272
27th November, 2012
Deadline: Nov 20, 2012
Current status: Safety signboard has been installed at this location.
In November, the Consultant found that the Contractor has implemented a number of actions
to ensure safety in hazardous surfaces such as:
- Arranging personnal to test safety and traffic on site, reminding about safety and traffic
issues.
- Installing safety fences and warning signs in dangerous surfaces, such as: slope areas where
landslides could happen like Km154, Km155, access roads: Km184, Km 186, the areas of
bridge construction: Khe Chuong bridge, Lang Nhay bridge, Ngoi Nhuoc bridge...
- Installing safety slogans and safety signs at the construction locations to raise the awareness
of the role of the safety for workers in the working process such as at: Km186+200, Dai Viet
bridge, Ngoi Rom bridge...
However, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
- At station Ngoi Giam bridge, Ngoi Hut bridge, Lang Nhay bridge, Ngoi Chac bridge, fences
and warning signs were severely damaged; however, the Contractor has not repaired.
- At Km155, Km166, Km171, Km174, safety fences and warning signs have not been fully
installed on the access roads.
- At Km159, Km174, Km190, the construction locations near the public roads; however, the
Contractor has not fully installed safety fences and warning signs at the construction locations.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
273
5th November, 2012
19th December, 2012
Location: Lang Nhay bridge’s construction site
Site visit: November, 5 and December, 19
Date first observed: 5-Nov-2012
Problems description and cause: Safety fences and signboards were not installed fully at this location.
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: The Engineer required the Contractor to immediately installed fully safety fences and signboards at this location.
Responsible Party: Doosan Contractor
Deadline: November 15, 2012
Current status: The Contractor has already
installed safety fences and signboards at this
location.
In December, the main issues were the following:
- Arranged personnel to test safety and traffic on the site, reminding about safety and traffic
issues.
- The safety fences and warning signs were still remained in dangerous surfaces such as:
slopes areas where landslide may happen such as Km154, Km155, the access roads: Km184,
Km 186, the bridge construction locations: Khe Chuong bridge, Lang Nhay bridge, Ngoi Nhuoc
bridge...
- Some safety slogans and safety guidelines were maintained at the construction locations
such as: Km186+200, Dai Viet bridge, Ngoi Rom bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge...
However, there are still some outstanding issues as follows:
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
274
- The Contractor has not repaired some severely damaged fences such as in the area of Lang
Nau bridge, Ngoi Chac bridge, Ngoi Giam bridge, Lang Nhay bridge...
- The safety fences and warning signs have not been fully installed in the access roads such
as: Km155, Km163, Km171, Km184...
To ensure the safety of the project, the Consultant has requested the Contractor to apply the
appropriate measures as well as fully install safety fences and warning signs in dangerous
surfaces.
4.14.7 Package A7
01-October 2012
15-October 2012
Location: Khe Hong Bridge Km232+379
Site visit: 1and 15-October 2012;
Date first observed: 1-October 2012
Problems description and cause: Safetyfence not meet standard at construction work
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor improve the Safety fence at construction work
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: The contractor not yet improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
275
15-November 2012
27-November 2012
25.12.2012
Location: Ram AII Bridge Km199+050
Site visit: 15 and 27-November 2012; 25 Dec 2012
Date first observed: 15-November 2012
Problems description and cause: No safety fence and signpost at dangerous position
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Required the contractor to install the safety fence and signpost at dangerous position
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: The contractor not yet improved
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
276
01-November 2012
15-November 2012
Location: Km204+100
Site visit: 1 and 15-November 2012
Date first observed: 1-November 2012
Problems description and cause: Thecontractor had installed the safety fence and signpost at dangerous position, which can be landside and erosion.
4.14.8 Package A8
24-September 2012
Location: Xuan Giao Bridge Km232+437
Site visit: 24-Sept and 19-October 2012; 9-November 2012
Date first observed: 24-Sept 2012
Problems description and cause: InConstruction work near rail way, there is not any signpost, fence and many pools
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to install the signpost, fence and make trench at that
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
277
19-October 2012
9-November 2012
construction work near rain way
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: The contractor not yet improved
14.12.2012
Location: Ic 18 Bridge Km244+540
Site visit: 14 and 27.12.2012
Date first observed: 14.12.2012
Problems description and cause: Construction work near railway is not signposted, has no fence and some pools may be observed
Recommendation and Action taken by Engineer: Require the contractor to install the signpost, fence and make trench at that construction work near railway
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
278
27.12.2012
Responsible Party:
Deadline: Immediately
Current status: The contractor not yet improved
4.15 ACCIDENTS DUE TO THE LACK OF SAFETY MEASURES. RESPONSIBLES
During this period, forth quarter 2012, through the inspection and supervision on site,
Consultant didn’t notice about any serious accident happened due to lack of safety measures.
Also, Consultant did not receive any report regarding significant accidents in any package.
However, the Consultant has often required the contractors to comply with the Methods
Statement as well as the project’s Safety Plan and to improve the management and control of
safety issues to ensure the project’s safety during construction process and prevent
unfortunate accidents in the future.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
279
4.16 CONTRACTORS’ ENVIRONMENTAL AND SAFETY SPECIALISTS MOBILIZATION
As this issue is one of the most important ones for the right implementation of the contractors’ ECP and ECAP, here is presented a summary
table of the currently situation, updated until December 2012, in each package about the mobilization of contractors’ environmental and safety
managers. Some remarks are also considered inside the table.
PACKAGECURRENT STATUS
POSITION PROPOSED APPROVED MOBILIZED NAME REMARKS
A1Environmental manager
Yes Yes Yes Jeon Dae Kyun Temporary approval. In October he left the project, so Contractor had to propose a new manager
Yes Yes Yes Jeon YoSung Sub
Temporary approved in November. If no negative consideration, he will be definitively proposed for approval at the end of February
Safety manager Yes Yes Yes Le Dinh Quyen
A2Environmental manager Yes Yes Yes Kwak Ki Jin Temporary approval in October,
Final approval in NovemberSafety manager Yes Yes Yes Kim Jeong Ho
A3Environmental manager Yes Yes Yes Jo Seung Kwan
Safety manager Yes Yes Yes Nguyen Thanh Cong
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
280
PACKAGECURRENT STATUS
POSITION PROPOSED APPROVED MOBILIZED NAME REMARKS
A4
Environmental manager Yes No No Do Huy Giang
In May, Mr. Do Huy Giang was proposed for this responsibility and temporary accepted (June) for a trial by PSC, until the final approval from EPMU. But since the first moment PSC realized that he was not really mobilized for this position as he never attended PSC’s requests and never attend the site inspections. Therefore, the Engineer decided to propose the Client to reject him. Until December, no one was in charge of these matters in package A4
Safety manager Yes Yes Yes Nguyen Danh Nam
A5 Environmental manager No
The Engineer required the Contractor to immediately mobilize personnel to hold this position (October : Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-904; November: Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1036)December: The Engineer required again the Contractor to immediately mobilize personnel to hold this position (Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1114) No action was taken by Contractor
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
281
PACKAGECURRENT STATUS
POSITION PROPOSED APPROVED MOBILIZED NAME REMARKS
Safety manager No
In October, the candidate has not enough knowledge and experience to meet requirements of this position (Ref. GET3-GET-A5-032) In November, the Engineer required the Contractor to immediately mobilize personnel to hold this position (Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1036) In December: The Engineer required again the Contractor to immediately mobilize personnel to hold this position (Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1114)No action was taken by Contractor
A6Environmental manager Yes Yes Yes Song, Hwa Seo
Safety manager Yes Yes Yes Kwon, Oh Lin
A7Environmental manager Yes Yes Yes Zhou Guo Mou
Safety manager Yes Yes Yes Phan Lin Feng
A8Environmental manager Yes Yes Yes Tran Van Dinh
Safety manager Yes Yes Yes Mai Xuan Lap
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
282
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
283
5 REFERENCE DOCUMENTS RELATIVE TO ENVIRONMENT, HEALTH AND SAFETY ISSUES
5.1 PACKAGE A1
No Document reference Date Remark
1 GET1/POS/A1/1624 Oct 03, 2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis - September, 2012
2 GET1/POS/A1/1639 Oct 18, 2012 Km 09+128: Safety measure and project progress
3 GET1/POS/A1/1643 Oct 27, 2012 Storm Preventative
4 GET1/POS/A1/1648 Oct 31, 2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis - October, 2012
5 REF-A1-GET1-MOM-65 Oct 11, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
6 GET1/GET/040 Nov 06, 2012 The Contractor’s Key Personnel (Environmental Specialist)
7 GET1/EPMU1/A1/433 Nov 23, 2012 Report on Environmental and Safety Status onsite
8 REF-A1-GET1-MOM-66 Nov 08, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
9 REF-A1-GET1-MOM-67 Nov 22, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
10 REF-A1-GET1-MOM-68 Nov 29, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
11 GET1/POS/A1/1704 Dec 14, 2012 Proposal of Landscaping Material
12 GET1/POS/A1/1685 Dec 03, 2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – November 2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
284
5.2 PACKAGE A2
No Document reference Date Remark
1 GET1/POS/A2/1533 Oct 03, 2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis - September, 2012
2 GET1/POS/A2/1539 Oct 08, 2012 Grass Sodding Material – 1st source
3 GET1/POS/A2/1562 Oct 19, 2012 Section 8: Request to solve the grievance of local authority
4 GET1/POS/A2/1572 Oct 27, 2012 Storm Preventative Application
No Document reference Date Remark
5 GET1/POS/A2/1580 Oct 31, 2012 Bridges TL306I and TL305: Request to improve the traffic condition
6 GET1/POS/A2/1581 Oct 31, 2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis - Oct, 2012
7 REF-A2-GET1-MOM-49 Oct 11, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
8 GET1/GET/A2/039 Nov 03, 2012 Proposal for Environmental Specialist of the Contractor
9 GET1/EPMU1/A1/433 Nov 23, 2012 Report on Environmental and Safety Status onsite
10 GET1/POS/A2/1601 Nov 13, 2012 Bridges TL306I and TL305: Request to improve the traffic condition
11 GET1/POS/A2/1602 Nov 13, 2012 Bridges TL306II: Traffic Control
12 REF-A2-GET1-MOM-50 Nov 08, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
13 REF-A2-GET1-MOM-51 Nov 22, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
14 REF-A2-GET1-MOM-52 Nov 29, 2012 Minutes of meeting between EPMU, GETINSA and POSCO
15 GET1/POS/A2/1629 Dec 03, 2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – November, 2012
16 GET1/POS/A2/1640 Dec 06, 2012 Proposal of Landscaping Material
17 GET1/POS/A2/1641 Dec 07, 2012 Muong Noi Bridge: Request to apply the traffic protection measure
18 GET1/POS/A2/1660 Dec 20, 2012 Km 29+865: Request to solve the grievances of local people
19 GET1/POS/A2/1680 Dec 28, 2012 Section 8: Serious warning the Contractor of local’s grievance settlement
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
285
5.3 PACKAGE A3
Nº Document reference Date Remark
1 GET2-POS-A3-1514 04/10/2012 Accept Environmental monitoring report in September
2 GET2-POS-A3-1544 23/10/2012 Request to report on treatment progress of soil sliding in details
3 GET2-POS-A3-1549 29/10/2012 Request the Contractor to deal with oil leaking problem
Nº Document reference Date Remark
4 GET2-POS-A3-1590- 16/11/2012 Approve environmental monitoring report october
5 GET2-EPMU2-A3-428 12/12/2012
Report on progress of treating filling work due to construction process of roadbase which affects to drainage system at Hung Lo commune-Kim Duc commune, Viet Tri
6 GET2-EPMU2-A3-429 12/12/2012 Report on progress of treating soil sliding at Thanh Ba district, section 6-
7 GET2-POS-A3-1638 12/12/2012 Request to treat safety work at Lung Thuong and PhongChau bridge-
8 GET2-POS-A3-1639 12/12/2012 Waste disposal matter and using borrow pit
9 GET2-EPMU2-A3-430 15/12/2012
Report on prigress of treating soil sliding at Chi Tien (Thanh Ba district) TienKien (Lam Thao district), Ha Loc, Ha Thach, Phu Ho (PhuTho town)
10 GET2-POS-A3-1647 15/12/2012 Request the Contractor Posco to push up progress of treating soil sliding
11 GET2-POS-A3-1648 15/12/2012 Disposal area in section 3
12 GET2-POS-A3-1665 25/12/2012 Request to stop construction to treat landslide problem at section 6
5.4 PACKAGE A4
Nº Document reference Date Remark
1 GET2-KEA-A4-859-EN 15/10/2012 Approve Environmental monitoring report in September
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
286
2 GET2-KEA-A4-871-EN 23/10/2012 Letter to request Detail report about progress of solving landslide
3 GET2-KEA-A4-878-EN 25/10/2012 Request Report of detail progress of solving flood due to construction
4 GET2-KEA-A4-903 16/11/2012 Approve environmental monitoring report october
5 GET2-KEA-A4-909 22/11/2012 Warning the Contractor Keangnam about environmental matters in Package A4.
6 GET2-KEA-A4-930 12/12/2012 Warn the contractor Keangnam about late mobilizantion of Environment specialist – Package A4
7 GET2-KEA-A4-931 12/12/2012 Disposal and using Borrow material pit – Package A4
5.5 PACKAGE A5
No Document reference Date Remark
1 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-902 Oct 9, 2012 Approval of Report on Environmental
Monitoring for September 2012
2 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-903 Oct 9, 2012 Complaints information and reception
system
3 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-904 Oct 9, 2012 Warning to KEANGNAM Contractor
4 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-913 Oct 15, 2012 Borrow pits – package A5
5 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-916 Oct 15, 2012
Requires the Contractor to submit summary of approval sites for batching plants, borrow pits. Quarries and disposal areas
6 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-956 Oct 24, 2012 Comment on documents of disposal
areas – Package A5
7 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-955 Oct 24, 2012 Comment on Method statement for
sodding
8 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-955 Oct 24, 2012
Requires the Contractor to submit reports relating to environmental and safety issues
9 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-954 Oct 24, 2012
Requires the Contractor to submit reports relating to environmental and safety issues
10 Ref. GET3-GET-A5-032 Oct 24, 2012 Reject the Contractor’s safety manager with comments - Package A5
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
287
11 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-964 Oct 27, 2012 Urgent notice for the storm and flood
12 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1005 Nov 9, 2012 Approval of Report on Environmental
Monitoring for October 2012
13 Ref. GET3- EPMU3-12-A5-293 Nov 21, 2012
Environmental and Safety training sessions for contractor and subcontractor on package A5 and package A6
14 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1032 Nov 21, 2012
Environmental and Safety training sessions for contractor and subcontractor on package A5
15 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1035 Nov 21, 2012
Request the Contractor to apply measures in order to ensuring the safety and traffic
Nº Document reference Date Remark
16 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1036 Nov 21, 2012
Require the Contractor to mobilize personal for Safety Manager and Environmental Manager
17 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1057 Nov 28, 2012 Approval with comments on Disposal
areas
18 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1113 Dec 14, 2012 Disapproval of Disposal areas
19 Ref. GET3- EPMU3-12-A5-1114 Dec 14, 2012
Require the Contractor to mobilize personal for Safety Manager and Environmental Manager
20 Ref. GET3- EPMU3-12-A5-1112 Dec 14, 2012
Require the Contractor to apply measures in order to ensuring the safety and environment at construction site of Ngoi Thia bridge
21 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1123 Dec 17, 2012 Approval with comments on Disposal
areas
22 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1129 Dec 18, 2012
Require the Contractor to apply measures in order to keep safety at Ngoi Vien bridge’s construction site
23 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1142 Dec 19, 2012 Approval of Report on Environmental
Monitoring for November 2012
24 Ref.GET3-KEANGNAM-12-A5-1174 Dec 28, 2012
Warning to Keangnam Contractor about safety issues at Ngoi Vien bridge’s construction site
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
288
5.6 PACKAGE A6
No Document reference Date Remark
1 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1014 Oct 15, 2012 Approval of Report on Environmental
Monitoring for September 2012
2 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1013 Oct 15, 2012
Requires the Contractor to submit summary of approval sites for batching plants, borrow pits. Quarries and disposal areas
3 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1018 Oct 16, 2012 Approval with comments on Disposal
areas
4 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1066 Oct 24, 2012
Request the Contractor to apply measures in order to minimize dust during construction and material transportation
No Document reference Date Remark
5 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1069 Oct 24, 2012
Request the Contractor to dump unsuitable material into disposal areas approved by the Engineer
6 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1067 Oct 24, 2012
Require the Contractor to apply measures to keep the Project’s safety and traffic at Ngoi Giam II bridge construction site Km163+150
7 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1079 Oct 25, 2012 Urgent notice for the storm and flood
8 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1102 Oct 31, 2012 Approval of Report on Environmental
Monitoring for October2012
9 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1103 Oct 31, 2012 Approval with comments on Disposal
areas
10 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1131 Nov 7, 2012 Approval with comments on Disposal
areas
11 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1133 Nov 8, 2012 Instructions to Contractor on safety for
explosive
12 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1134 Nov 8, 2012
Reminding Contractor on Personal Protection Equipment of workers at Km163
13 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1135 Nov 8, 2012
Warning to Doosan contractor for uncomplying with project’s requirements about safety for explosive
14 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1140 Nov 9, 2012 Reply to the Contractor’s letter
No.DHIC-12-CT-229
15 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN- Nov 9, 2012 Comment on Method Statement for
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
289
12-A6-1138 grassing works at cutting slope
16 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1175 Nov 21, 2012
Environmental and Safety training sessions for contractor and subcontractor on package A6
17 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1218 Nov 28, 2012 Approval of Report on Environmental
Monitoring for November 2012
18 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1250 Dec 7, 2012 Reminding the Contractor on safety
for tunnelling work
19 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1235 Dec 4, 2012
Additional extension land for construction km 159+040; 169+900 and 181+520 (reply to letter ref.263’12-A6).
20 Ref.GET3-DOOSAN-12-A6-1270 Dec 17, 2012
Require the Contractor to submit construction schedule during Solar Calendar New Year Holidays 2013.
5.7 PACKAGE A7
Nº Document reference Date Remark
1 Ref. GET4- GRBCC- 738 5-Oct-2012 Report to explain on carry out Importing seeds of grass and carry out grassing at Package A7
2 Ref. GET4- GRBCC- 767 26-Oct-2012 Requesting more date and proposals about slope stabilization Km203+880 to Km204+100 Package A7
3 Ref. GET4- GRBCC- 768 26-Oct-2012 Cordon off areas nearly slope instability Km203+880 to Km204+100
4 Ref. GRBCC- EPMU4-103 2-Nov-2012 Proposal for paying the works of grassing of package A7
5 Ref.GET-GUA-070 30-Oct-2012 Heath and Safety condition in the site laboratory package A7 Km207+400
6 Ref. GRBCC- GETINSA-CORE-027 5-Nov-2012
Heath and Safety condition in the site laboratory package A7 Km207+400- Supplement device
7 Ref. GET4- GRBCC- 780 19-Nov-2012 Approve the Environment Monitoring Report at Construction Stage (phase 8- November 2012) - package A7
8 Ref. GET4- GRBCC-812 26-Dec-2012 Require to stop pouring earth at 190+420; Km201+815 and Km209+329
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
290
5.8 PACKAGE A8
Nº Document reference Date Remark
1 Ref. GET4- Vinaconex- 625 2-Oct 2012 Cofferdam of P5, and temporary bridge, Suoi Trat Bridge
2 Ref. GET4- Vinaconex- 653 12-Nov 2012 The second time warning to Nguyen Trong Minh- site manager in Son Hai Bridge Km227+065.55
3 A8/LC/121204-02 04/12/2012Submit the Report environmental monitoring on construction stage (phase 9- November 2012)
4 Ref. GET4- Vinaconex-678 13/12/2012 Approved the Report environmental monitoring on construction stage (phase 9- November 2012)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
291
6 GRIEVANCE INTAKES. PUBLIC CONSULTATION
As Annex 1 we include some grievance intakes (public consultations), written in a form sheet by Consultant, about complaints which were expressed by local people affected by the construction works, to the environmental or social impact specialists.
It’s supposed that these are not the only existing complaints, but the only ones received or collected by Consultant.
On the other hand, after being implemented in some packages the system to collect complaints by the contractors, the Consultant has not received any information from contractors.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
292
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
293
ANNEX 1: GRIEVANCE INTAKES. PUBLIC CONSULTATION
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
294
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
295
Package A1
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you. Package A1 Location Km 4+200 Contact Information
Name NGUYEN VAN THANG Gender Male x Female
Home Address VQ2, Battalion 41, grigate 134, arm Signal – Tan Dan commune, Soc Son dist
AgePhone No.
City/Province Hanoi Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
- Km 4+400: due to the Contractor usually doesn't spray water on surface of embankment section so level or airborne dust during construction activities is high. Sometime, the Contractor carried out watering but only on a short section and that's not enough to minimize the dust.
- We suggest that the Contractor has to spray water along whole working section to limit the spread of airborne dust, especially during the dry season.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 22-Dec-11
Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms
Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
PHAM NGOC TRANG
Position of staff ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST
Type of Grievance COMPLAINT AND SUGGESTION
Remarks The Engineer has requested the Contractor to usually water the surface of embankment in this area during hot windy days to minimized the spread of dust
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
296
Update on the case:
Date: Update
27-Mar-12 The Contractor doesn't often water on surface of embankment in dry days so there is high spread of airborne dust during those days.
03-May-12 There was almost none construction work carried out in this area this time so the spread of dust was reduced
05-Jun-12 There was almost none construction work carried out in this area and due to the wet weather so the spread of dust was reduced
21-Aug-12 There was almost none construction work carried out in this area, especially the transportation work, and due to the wet weather so the spread of dust is inadequate
18-Sep-12 The Contractor has already watered the surface of embankment in this area during transporting material for embankment work so the spread of dust is mitigated
23-Oct-12 The Contractor maintains the watering activity on surface of embankment and public road in hot windy days so the spread of airborne dust was minimize
21-Nov-12 Sometimes the Contractor doesn’t water the surface of embankment in hot windy day so the spread of dust is very high. We requested the Contractor to spray water in this area usually to mitigate the spread of dust
26-Dec-12 The Contractor maintains the watering activity on surface of embankment and public road in hot windy days so the spread of airborne dust was minimize
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A1 Location Km 13+800 Contact Information
Name NGUYEN THI THUAN Gender Male x Female
Home Address Luong Cau village, Son Loi commune, Binh Xuyen Dist
AgePhone No.
City/Province Vinh Phuc Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below: - Km 13+100 ~ Km 13+900: the Contractor has usually sprayed water the surface of embankment section, where is under construction, so the level of airborne dust is acceptable. We suggest that the Contractor maintains this action to minimize the disturbance from construction work to public areas although there is no construction activity in this section this time.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
297
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
PHAM NGOC TRANG
Position of staff ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST Type of Grievance COMPLAINT AND SUGGESTION Remarks
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
20-Mar-12The Contractor carries out the embankment work at section that is close to resident area and there is a high spread of vibration. We request the Contractor to reduce the level of vibration during construction work implementation.
03-May-12 The Contractor usually spray water on surface of embankment to reduce the spread of dust and the embankment was high now so the vibration due to construction work no longer affected the houses
14-Aug-12 The Contractor usually watered the surface of embankment section during transporting the material for embankment work so the spread of dust is mitigated
18-Sep-12 The Contractor usually watered the surface of embankment section during transporting the material for embankment work so the spread of dust is mitigated
23-Oct-12 The Contractor maintains the watering activity on surface of embankment and public road in hot windy days so the spread of airborne dust was minimize
21-Nov-12 The Contractor maintains the watering activity on surface of embankment and public road in hot windy days so the spread of airborne dust was minimize
26-Dec-12 The Contractor maintains the watering activity on surface of embankment and public road in hot windy days so the spread of airborne dust was minimize
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
298
Package A2
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A2 Location Km 29+865 Contact Information
Name NGUYEN THI THANH Gender MaleFemale X
Home Address Cam Trach village, Dao Tu commune, Tam Duong district
AgePhone No.
City/Province Vinh Phuc Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
The Contractor constructed embankment going through this area but didn’t install the drainage; this issue caused flooding in my garden in the rain and killed my trees. Besides, our pond was also full filled by sediment tracked from embankment. We request the Contractor to compensate for the damage caused by construction activities of the project.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 19-Dec-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
PHAM NGOC TRANG
Position of staff ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST Type of Grievance COMPLAINT AND SUGGESTION Remarks
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
299
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the project implementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contact information to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform us by writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A2 Location Km 34+780 Contact Information
Name PHAM VAN HONG Gender Male x Female
Home Address Doai village, Hoang Dan commune, Tam Duong dist
AgePhone No.
City/Province Vinh Phuc Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
- Km 34+780: the Contractor carries out the construction work but there is no sediment control measure applied so the dirt is usually tracked onto public road; besides the Contractor doesn't water the surface of embankment section or public road so the level of airborne dust is high. Sometime, the Contractor carried out the construction work by night and didn't apply noise control measure therefore construction activities disturbed the resident area.
- We request the Contractor to apply the suitable measures to minimize the spread of airborne dust and limit the construction work by night to reduce disturbance on resident area.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 22-Dec-11 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
PHAM NGOC TRANG
Position of staff ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST Type of Grievance COMPLAINT AND SUGGESTION Remarks For a long time, the Contractor didn’t carry out the construction work in this area
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
300
Update on the case: Date: Update
06-Mar-12This time there is no construction activity in this area so resident area is not affected by construction work of project. However, the Contractor needs to limit the tracking of dirt onto public road when he back to work to minimize the spread of airborne dust in this area
27-May-12 There was almost none construction work carried out in this area this time so noise and dust that arise due to construction activity is inappreciable
04-Jul-12 There was almost none construction work carried out in this area this time so noise and spread of airborne dust is inadequate
24-Oct-12 There was almost none construction work carried out in this area this time so noise and spread of airborne dust that arise from construction activity is acceptable
14-Dec-12 The construction work is only carried out during the day and it caused not much noise or dust
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A2 Location Km 39+200 (CBP “C”) Contact Information
Name (CONFIDENTIAL) CHU KHANH TOAN Gender
Male x Female
Home Address Area 10, Nuong Cau village, Tien Lu commune, Lap Thach dist
Age 34 Phone No.
City/Province Vinh Phuc Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
- The Contractor has replaced the dust collection system so the spread of the dust is mitigated; however, sometimes the Contractor carried out the work during the night that caused the noise and affected the living of local people. We request the Contractor to limit the work at night.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
301
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 29-Aug-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
PHAM NGOC TRANG
Position of staff ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST Type of Grievance COMPLAINT AND SUGGESTION
Remarks The Engineer already requested the Contractor to limit the work at night to avoid the disturbance on resident area
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
24-Oct-12 Sometimes, the Contractor carried out the work at night and this caused the noise affecting the rest of local people; however, the affected period was short and level of noise was not too loud
27-Dec-12 Sometimes, the Contractor still carried out the work at night and this caused the noise affecting the rest of local people; this work happened in a short time and the arisen noise was not too loud
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you. Package A2 Location Km 42+900 Contact Information
Name NGUYEN VAN PHUONG LO DUC THANG Gender Male x
Female
Home Address Yen Phu village, Dong Thinh commune, Song Lo dist
AgePhone No.
City/Province Vinh Phuc Email
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
302
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
- Km 42+200 ~ Km 45+000 the Contractor doesn’t carry out the watering activity on the surface of embankment section so during the dry season the level of airborne dust is very high. - We request the Contractor to spray water suitably on embankment section to minimize the spread of airborne dust. The Contractor can employ the local people to do this work.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 22-Dec-11 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
PHAM NGOC TRANG
Position of staff ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST Type of Grievance COMPLAINT AND SUGGESTION
Remarks The Engineer has requested the Contractor to maintain the watering activity on the surface of embankment to mitigate the spread of dust during transporting the material for embankment work
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
29-Mar-12There is still no improvement on last public consultation. The Contractor still doesn’t water the surface of embankment section so the spread of dust in this season is high, especially in hot and dry days
25-Apr-12 The Contractor still doesn’t water the surface of embankment section so the spread of dust is still high, especially during hot windy days
06-Jun-12 There was no construction work carried out in this area this time and due to wet weather so the spread of dust is minimized
24-Jul-12 Due to there was almost none construction work carried out in this area this time and the wet weather so the spread of dust is unremarkable
19-Sep-12 The Contractor is carrying out the embankment work but he didn’t water the surface of embankment during transportation so the spread of dust is high. We request the Contractor to spray water to mitigate the spread of dust in this area
24-Oct-12 The contractor maintained the watering activity on embankment section so the spread of dust during the hot windy days was mitigated
14-Dec-12 The contractor maintained the watering activity on embankment section so the spread of dust during the hot windy days was mitigated
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
303
Package A3
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name
Thank you. Package A3 Location Construction site, Red river bridge Contact Information
Name Mr. Son Gender Male x Female
Home Address Khu 8, Sai Nga commune, Cam Khe district
Age 34 Phone Nº
City/Province Phu Tho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (Red river bridge), construction activities were carried out in the night time. This affected local people’s rest. How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 26th–October-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks Remind Contractor to minimize working in the night time in order to avoid to disturb local people.
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
304
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A3 Location Construction site, Red river bridge
Contact Information
Name Mr. Tuan Gender Male x Female
Home Address Khu 8,Sai Ngacommune, Cam Khe district Age 35
Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (Red river bridge), construction activities were carried out in the night time. This affected local people’s rest.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 21th –November-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks Remind Contractor to minimize working in the night time in order to avoid to disturb local people.
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
305
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you. Package A3 Location Construction site, Km61+583 Contact Information
Name Mr. Huong Gender Male x Female
Home Address Ha Thach commune, PhuTho Town Age 52 Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (Cam Phu Bridge), Earth was landside down rice field due to heavy rains. This reduced production of owners’ rice field.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 11th–November-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion Remarks Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope in oder to avoid erosion.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
11thNovember, 2012 No improvement seen for this work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
306
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km61+583 18th-October, 2012
Description Earth was landside down rice field due to heavy rains. Influence the production of the family.
Location Km61+583 11th-November, 2012
Description Earth was landside down rice field due to heavy rains. Influence the production of the family.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
307
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A3 Location Construction site, Red river bridge
Contact Information
Name Mr. Quynh Gender Male x Female
Home Address Khu 8, SaiNgacommune, Cam Khe district Age 30
Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (Red river bridge), construction activities were carried out in the night time. This affected local people’s rest.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 25th –December-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks Remind Contractor to minimize working in the night time in order to avoid to disturb local people.
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
308
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A3 Location Construction site, Km 75+390
Contact Information
Name Mr. Nam Gender Male x Female
Home Address Chi Tiencommune, Thanh Ba District Age 36
PhoneNº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (Km 75+390), Earth was landside down rice field due to heavy rains. This reduced production of owners’ rice field.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 11th–December-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion Remarks Request Contractor to plant grass on the slope in oder to avoid erosion.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
11thDecember, 2012 No improvement seen for this work
ATTACHEDPHOTOS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
309
Location Km 75+390 11th-December, 2012
Description Earth was landside down rice field due to heavy rains. Influence the production of the family.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
310
Package A4
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A4 Location Construction site, QL32C bridge
Contact Information
Name Mrs. Bao Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district Age 41
Phone Nº
City/Province Phu Tho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (QL32C bridge), building activities were carried out in the night time. This affected local people’s rest.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 11th–October-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion Remarks Remind Contractor to minimize working in the night time to avoid disturbing local people.
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
311
Update on the case: Date: Update
11th –October-12 Not Improved
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A4 Location Construction site, QL32C bridge
Contact Information
Name Mr. Hai Gender Male x Female
Home Address Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district Age 52
Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (QL 32C bridge), his house is cracked because of vibration of construction activities
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 11th–October-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion Remarks Request Contractor to improve method statement to assure safety for the nearby houses
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
11th –October-2012 Not Improved 30th–November-2012 Not Improved 19th–December-2012 Not Improved
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the project
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
312
implementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A4 Location Construction site, QL32C bridge
Contact Information
Name Ms. Nhung Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district Age 36 Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (QL32C bridge), Construction activities were carried out at night. This caused noise affected to people’s leisure time
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 30th–November-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks Request Contractor to reduce construction activities at night in order to avoid to disturb people ‘s leisure time
Signature of the staff
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A4 Location Construction site, QL32C bridge
Contact Information
Name Mr. Nhung Gender Male x Female
Home Address Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district Age 36
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
313
Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (QL32C bridge), his house is cracked because of vibration of construction activities
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 19th–December-2012 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion Remarks Request Contractor to improve method statement to assure safety for the nearby houses
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
314
Project NoiBai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A4 Location Construction site, QL32C bridge
Contact Information
Name Ms. Hai Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address QuanKhecommune, Ha Hoa district Age 41
Phone Nº
City/Province PhuTho province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
-At this location (QL32C bridge), Construction activities were carried out at night. This caused noise affected to people’s leisure time
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 19th–December-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Tran QuangThien
Position of staff Environmental Specialist– ST2 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks Request Contractor to reduce construction activities at night in order to avoid to disturb people ‘s leisure time
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
315
Package A5
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform us bywriting/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A5 Location Construction site, Km129+280
Contact Information
Name Mr. Trung Gender Male x Female
Home Address Y Can commune, Tran Yen District Age 38
Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
- At this location (Km129+280), quality of public road was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities, difficultly to vehicles traveling through this location.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 15-August-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to repair damage points of public road in order to ensure the region’s traffic, simultaneously, the Contractor also is requested to apply suitable measures in order to avoid repeat of these problems. However, the Contractor doesn't implement fully the requirements from the PSC.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
26th Sep, 2012 No improvement seen for this work
10th October, 2012 The Contractor has already repaired this damage points in order to maintain the region’s traffic.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
316
Location Km129+280 15th August, 2012
Description Quality of public road was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities, difficultly to vehicles traveling through this location.
Location Km129+280 26th September, 2012 Description No improvement seen for this work
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
317
Location Km129+280 10th October, 2012
Description The Contractor has already repaired this damage points in order to maintain the region’s traffic.
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A5 Location Construction site, Km124+650
Contact Information
Name Ms. Mai Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address Minh Tien commune, Tran Yen District Age 45 Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
- At Km124+650, soil from construction site sliding into irrigation canal, this situation is causing impact to the region’s irrigation system.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 20-Sep-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
318
Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Dinh Cong Ton
Position of staff Resettlement Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to repair the region’s irrigation system, simultaneously, the PSC also requested the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to prevent erosion will be happened in coming time. However, the Contractor doesn't implement fully the requirements from the PSC.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
26th November, 2012 The Contractor is combining with local authorities in order to make measures to solve this remaining.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km124+650 20th Sep, 2012
Description Soil from construction site sliding into irrigation canal, this situation is causing impact to the region’s irrigation system.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
319
Location Km124+650 26th Sep, 2012
Description The Contractor’s Engineer checking on the site together with local authorities and local people in order to make measures to solve this remaining.
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A5 Location Construction site, Km129
Contact Information
Name Mrs. Ha Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address Y Can commune, Tran Yen District Age 53
Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km129), The Contractor's construction activities and material transportation are causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 1-October-12
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
320
Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to solve this remaining such as: 1. Combine with local authorities in order to repair the region’s irrigation system. 2. Undertake further action towards resolution of the complaint.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
27th November, 2012 The Contractor is repairing this irrigation system.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km129 1st October, 2012
Description The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
321
Location Km129 2nd November, 2012 Description The Contractor’s workers are repairing this irrigation system.
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A5 Location Construction site, Km145
Contact Information
Name Mr. Lam Gender Male x Female
Home Address Yen Hop commune, Tran Yen District Age 62
Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km145), The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 16-November-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
322
Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to solve this remaining such as: 1. Combine with local authorities in order to repair the region’s irrigation system. 2. Undertake further action towards resolution of the complaint.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
2nd December, 2012 The Contractor is combining with local authorities in order to make measures to solve this remaining.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km145 16th November, 2012
Description The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
323
Location Km145 2nd December, 2012
Description The Contractor’s Engineer checking on the site together with local authorities and local people in order to make measures to solve this remaining.
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A5 Location Construction site, Km124
Contact Information
Name Mr. Hung Gender Male x Female
Home Address MinhTien commune, Tran Yen District Age 58
PhoneNº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km124), quality of public road was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities, difficultly to vehicles traveling through this location.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 5-December-12
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
324
Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to repair damage points of public road in order to ensure the region’s traffic, simultaneously, the Contractor also is requested to apply suitable measures in order to avoid repeat of these problems. However, the Contractor doesn't implement fully the requirements from the PSC
Signature of the staff
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km124 5th December, 2012
Description Quality of public road was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities, difficultly to vehicles traveling through this location.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
325
Package A6
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A6 Location Construction site, Km159+300
Contact Information
Name Miss. Phuong Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address Tan Hop commune, Van Yen District Age 26
Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km159+300), quality of public road was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities, difficultly to vehicles traveling through this location.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 3-October-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to repair damage points of public road in order to ensure the region’s traffic, simultaneously, the Contractor also is requested to apply suitable measures in order to avoid repeat of these problems. However, the Contractor doesn't implement fully the requirements from the PSC.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
30th October, 2012 The Contractor has already repaired this damage points in order to maintain the region’s traffic.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
326
Location Km159+300 3rd October, 2012.
Description Quality of public road was impacted by the Contractor’s construction activities, difficultly to vehicles traveling through this location.
Location Km159+300 30th October, 2012.
Description The Contractor has already repaired this damage points in order to maintain the region’s traffic.
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you.
Package A6 Location Construction site, Km174
Contact Information
Name Mr. Trong Gender Male x
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
327
Female
Home Address Chau Que Ha commune, Van Yen District Age 49
Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email
Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km174), The Contractor's construction activities and material transportation are causing dusty, this situation has been impacted to air quality.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 10-October-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to minimize dust during project implementation such as: 1. Water suitable the surface of embankment section to minimize the spread of airborne dust along through way. 2. All the trucks of the Contractor must be covered with canvas during material transportation.
Signature of the staff
Update on the case: Date: Update
6th November, 2012 The Contractor has sprayed water on construction sites and access roads in order to minimize dust during project implementation.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
328
Location Km174 10th October, 2012.
Description The Contractor's construction activities and material transportation are causing dusty, this situation has been impacted to air quality.
Location Km174 6th November, 2012
Description The Contractor has sprayed water on construction sites and access roads in order to minimize dust during project implementation.
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you. Package A6 Location Construction site, Km182 Contact Information Name Mr. Ke Gender Male x
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
329
Female
Home Address Chau Que Thuong commune, Van Yen District
Age 53 Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km182), The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 1-November-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to solve this remaining such as: 1. Combine with local authorities in order to repair the region’s irrigation system. 2. Undertake further action towards resolution of the complaint.
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
330
Update on the case: Date: Update
27th November, 2012 The Contractor is combining with local authorities in order to make measures to solve this remaining.
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km182 1st November, 2012.
Description The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
Location Km182 6th November, 2012.
Description The Contractor’s Engineer checking on the site together with local authorities and local people in order to make measures to solve this remaining.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
331
Project Noi Bai – Lao Cai welcomes complaints, suggestions, comments and queries regarding the projectimplementation and its stakeholders. We encourage person with grievance to provide their name and contactinformation to enable us to get in touch with you for clarification and feedback.
Should you choose to include your personal details but want that information to remain confidential, please inform usby writing/typing "(CONFIDENTIAL)" above you name.
Thank you. Package A6 Location Construction site, Km162 Contact Information
Name Mrs. Ngoc Gender MaleFemale x
Home Address Dong An commune, Van Yen District Age 48 Phone Nº
City/Province Yen Bai province Email Compliant/Suggestion/Comment/Question Please provide the details (who, what, where and how) of your grievance below:
At this location (Km162), The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
How do you want us to reach you for feedback or update on your comment/grievance?
- Contact in person.
Portion to be filled in by the staff: Date received: 3-December-12 Received through X In person _mail _email _fax _phone _sms Name of staff who received comment/ complaint
Nguyen Minh Tuan
Position of staff Environmental Specialist - ST3 Type of Grievance Complaint and Suggestion
Remarks
The PSC has requested the Contractor to apply suitable measures in order to solve this remaining such as: 1. Combine with local authorities in order to repair the region’s irrigation system. 2. Undertake further action towards resolution of the complaint.
Signature of the staff
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
332
ATTACHED PHOTOS
Location Km162 3th December, 2012.
Description The Contractor's construction activities is causing impact the region’s irrigation system, this situation is causing an obstruction of water flow into some rice-field of local people.
Projectimplemeinformati
Should yby writing
Thank yoPackageContact
Name
Home Ad
City/Prov
Compliagrievanc
How do y
- Contac
PortionDate recReceivedNamereceived complainPositionType of G
Remarks
Signature
Loa
Noi Bai – Lntation and ion to enable u
you choose tog/typing "(CON
ou. eInformation
ddress
vince
ant/Suggestioe below:
- The folloto revoke
you want us to
t in person.
to be filled ineived: d through of staff wh commen
ntof staff Grievance
s
e of the staff
n 2391/2392
Lao Cai welcits stakeholdeus to get in tou
include your NFIDENTIAL)
A7
Nguyen V
Khe U- Ta
Lao Cai
on/Comment/
ow rate in dowe land, but so
o reach you fo
n by the staff:
X Inhont/
The PSCreturn to c
2 – VIE: GMS Noi Bai –
comes complaers. We encouch with you f
personal deta)" above you n
Locatio
Van Chuong
an Thuong- Va
/Question Ple
wn stream of pifar the contra
or feedback or
:
n person _
C has requesteconstruction w
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hi
333
Package
aints, suggesourage persofor clarification
ails but want tname.
on
an Ban
ease provide
ipe culvert flewctor din’t pay
r update on yo
mail _ema
N
EnviroCom
ed the Contraworks as soon
– Hai Phongighway Proje
A7
stions, commn with grieva
n and feedbac
that informatio
Km204+113
Ge
AgePho
Em
e the details
w into fields, Cyet the compe
our comment/g
24- October 2il _fax _p
Nguyen Huu T
onmental Spemplaint and Suactor to coordas possible.
g Transport ect
ents and quance to provick.
on to remain c
nder MF
eone Nº
(who, what,
Client coordinaensation mone
grievance?
2012 phone _sm
Trung
ecialist ST4 uggestion dinate with clie
Corridor
eries regardide their nam
confidential, pl
Male Female
where and
ated with housey for househo
ms
ent to take in
ng the projeme and conta
lease inform u
x
how) of you
sehold in ordeold.
nformation and
ectact
us
ur
er
d
Project Noi implementatioinformation to
Should you chby writing/typi
Thank you. Package Contact Infor
Name
Home Addres
City/Province
Compliant/Sugrievance bel
-
How do you w
- Contact in p
Portion to beDate receivedReceived throName of sreceived complaint Position of staType of Griev
Remarks
Signature of t
Update on thDate
3-Decemb
Loan 23
Bai – Lao Con and its sto enable us to
hoose to incluing "(CONFID
Armation
N
ss K
L
uggestion/Coow:
The follow ratto revoke land
want us to reac
erson.
e filled in by td:ough staff who comment/
affvance
Tre
he staff
he case: e:er 2012
91/2392 – VN
Cai welcomestakeholders. Wget in touch w
ude your persoENTIAL)" abo
A7
Nguyen Thi Mi
Khe U- Tan Th
Lao Cai
omment/Ques
te in down stred, but so far th
ch you for fee
the staff:
X In pers
The PSC has eturn to const
VIE: GMS KuNoi Bai – Lao
s complaints,We encouragwith you for cla
onal details bove you name
Location
inh
huong- Van Ba
stion Please
eam of pipe cuhe contractor d
dback or upda
son _mail
requested thtruction works
unming – Hao Cai Highw
334
suggestionsge person witarification and
ut want that in.
Km20
an
provide the
ulvert flew intodin’t pay yet th
ate on your co
15- No _email _
Nguy
EnvironmeComplain
e Contractor as soon as po
The compl
ai Phong Traway Project
s, comments th grievance feedback.
nformation to
04+307
Gender
AgePhone N
details (who
o fields, Clienthe compensat
omment/grieva
ovember 2012_fax _phone
yen Huu Trung
ental Specialisnt and Suggesto coordinateossible.
Update aint was not s
ansport Corr
and queries to provide th
remain confid
MaleFema
Nº
o, what, whe
t coordinated wion money for
ance?
2e _sms
g
st ST4 stion e with client to
solved
rridor
regarding thheir name an
dential, please
ale x
ere and how)
with householr household.
o take informa
he projectnd contact
e inform us
) of your
d in order
ation and
Projectimplemeinformati
Should yby writing
Thank yo
Package
Contact
Name
Home Ad
City/Prov
Compliagrievanc
-
-
How do y
- Contac
PortionDate recReceivedNamereceived complainPositionType of G
Remarks
Signature
Projectimpleme
Loa
Noi Bai – Lntation and ion to enable u
you choose tog/typing "(CON
ou.
e
Information
ddress
vince
ant/Suggestioe below:
While constru
We suggest slope protect
you want us to
t in person.
to be filled ineived: d through of staff wh commen
ntof staff Grievance
s
e of the staff
Noi Bai – Lntation and i
n 2391/2392
Lao Cai welcits stakeholdeus to get in tou
include your NFIDENTIAL)
A8
Tran Thi C
Co Hai- S
Lao Cai
on/Comment/
uction the eart
the contractoion’s method t
o reach you fo
n by the staff:
X Inhont/
The PSC areas fillelandsides
Lao Cai welcits stakeholde
2 – VIE: GMS Noi Bai –
comes complaers. We encouch with you f
personal deta)" above you n
Locatio
Cuc
Son Hai- Bao T
/Question Ple
th overflew in
r to compensto avoid erosio
or feedback or
:
n person _
has requesteed by earth,
s when heavy
comes complaers. We enco
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hi
335
Package
aints, suggesourage persofor clarification
ails but want tname.
on
Thang
ease provide
house, garden
sate for the hoon and landsid
r update on yo
mail _ema
N
EnviroCom
ed the Contracand apply t
raining.
aints, suggesourage perso
– Hai Phongighway Proje
A8
stions, commn with grieva
n and feedbac
that informatio
Km230+295
Ge
AgePho
Em
e the details
n and pond at
ouse, garden des when hea
our comment/g
26- October 2il _fax _p
Nguyen Huu T
onmental Sspemplaint and Suctor to to comhe slope pro
stions, commn with grieva
g Transport ect
ents and quance to provick.
on to remain c
nder MF
eone Nº
(who, what,
Km230+295
areas are fillavy raining
grievance?
2012 phone _sm
Trung
ecialist ST4 uggestion
mpensate for thotection’s met
ents and quance to provi
Corridor
eries regardide their nam
confidential, pl
Male Female
where and
led by earth,
ms
he house, garthod to avoid
eries regardide their nam
ng the projeme and conta
lease inform u
x
how) of you
and apply the
rden and pondd erosion and
ng the projeme and conta
ectact
us
ur
e
dd
ectact
information to
Should you chby writing/typi
Thank you.
Package
Contact Infor
Name
Home Addres
City/Province
Compliant/Sugrievance bel
- Wasquali
- She
How do you w
- Contact in p
Portion to beDate receivedReceived throName of sreceived complaint Position of staType of Griev
Remarks
Signature of t
Loan 23
o enable us to
hoose to incluing "(CONFID
A
rmation N
ss A
L
uggestion/Coow: hing basic waity used for fa
required the c
want us to reac
erson.
e filled in by td:ough staff who comment/
affvance
Ts
he staff
91/2392 – VN
get in touch w
ude your persoENTIAL)" abo
A8
Nguyen Thi Sin
An Thang- Son
Lao Cai
omment/Ques
aters from comily life.
contractor to d
ch you for fee
the staff:
X In pers
The PSC has settling pond
VIE: GMS KuNoi Bai – Lao
with you for cla
onal details bove you name
Location
nh
n Ha- Bao Tha
stion Please
oncrete batchi
dig a trench to
dback or upda
son _mail
requested th
unming – Hao Cai Highw
336
arification and
ut want that in.
Km21
ang
provide the
ing plant coul
guide the was
ate on your co
14- No _email _
Nguy
EnvironmenComplain
he Contractor
ai Phong Traway Project
feedback.
nformation to
18+040
Gender
AgePhone N
details (who
ld osmose int
shing basic wa
omment/grieva
ovember 2012_fax _phone
yen Huu Trung
ntal Sspecialisnt and Suggesto dig a tren
ansport Corr
remain confid
MaleFema
Nº
o, what, whe
to a private w
ater sinto the
ance?
2e _sms
g
st ST4 stion ch to guide t
rridor
dential, please
ale x
ere and how)
well, affecting
settling pond
the washing w
e inform us
) of your
to water
water into
Projectimplemeinformati
Should yby writing
Thank yo
Package
Contact
Name
Home Ad
City/Prov
Compliagrievanc
-
-
How do y
- Contac
PortionDate recReceivedNamereceived complainPositionType of G
Remarks
Signature
Loa
Noi Bai – Lntation and ion to enable u
you choose tog/typing "(CON
ou.
e
Information
ddress
vince
ant/Suggestioe below:
While constrKm237+150
We request thslope protect
you want us to
t in person.
to be filled ineived: d through of staff wh commen
ntof staff Grievance
s
e of the staff
n 2391/2392
Lao Cai welcits stakeholdeus to get in tou
include your NFIDENTIAL)
A8
Nguyen T
Dong Luc
Lao Cai
on/Comment/
uction works,
he contractor ion methods t
o reach you fo
n by the staff:
X Inhont/
The PSC were filledwhen hea
2 – VIE: GMS Noi Bai –
comes complaers. We encouch with you f
personal deta)" above you n
Locatio
Thi Lien
c-Gia Phu- Bao
/Question Ple
the earth in
to compensato avoid erosio
or feedback or
:
n person _
has requested by earth, anavy rains
S Kunming –– Lao Cai Hi
337
aints, suggesourage persofor clarification
ails but want tname.
on
o Thang
ease provide
the down st
te for the fieldson and landsid
r update on yo
mail _ema
N
EnviroCom
ed the Contrand to apply slo
– Hai Phongighway Proje
stions, commn with grieva
n and feedbac
that informatio
Km237+150
Ge
AgePho
Em
e the details
ream of pile
s and pond ardes when heav
our comment/g
7- December il _fax _p
Nguyen Huu T
onmental Spemplaint and Suctor to compe
ope protection
g Transport ect
ents and quance to provick.
on to remain c
nder MF
eone Nº
(who, what,
culvert overfl
reas that werevy rains
grievance?
2012 phone _sm
Trung
ecialist ST4 uggestion ensate for then methods to a
Corridor
eries regardide their nam
confidential, pl
Male Female
where and
ew into fields
e filled by earth
ms
e fields and poavoid erosion
ng the projeme and conta
lease inform u
x
how) of you
s and pond a
h, and to apply
ond areas thaand landsides
ectact
us
ur
at
y
ats
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
338
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
339
ANNEX 2: DATA OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY PARAMETERS ANALYSIS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
340
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
341
ANNEX 2.1: AIR QUALITY PARAMETERS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
342
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
343
PACKAGE A1
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km 4+220 Pagoda Oct Nov Dec
25 26 25 6,800 6,900 6,900 28 29 28 290 290 280 130 130 130
Km 13+100 Resident area
Oct Nov Dec
28 28 28 6,700 6,900 6,800 38 39 37 290 290 290 120 120 120
Km 19+650
Schooland
resident area
Oct Nov Dec
27 26 27 5,900 5,800 5,800 27 26 26 280 270 280 130 120 130
Km 24+900 Nursery Garden
Oct Nov Dec
38 36 37 6,100 6,000 6,500 29 27 28 280 270 270 120 110 120
QCVN 05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 150 (24-hr)
Weather conditions: cloudy, light windy
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
344
PACKAGE A2
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km 34+780 Resident area
Oct Nov Dec
28 24 23 6,900 6,200 6,100 28 25 24 280 230 220 130 110 110
Km 36+500 Resident area
Oct Nov Dec
26 28 28 6,900 6,800 6,900 26 29 28 290 290 280 120 130 120
Km 39+130 Resident area
Oct Nov Dec
27 28 27 6,700 6,900 6,800 28 29 29 280 290 290 130 130 130
QCVN 05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 150 (24-hr)
Weather conditions: sunny, light windy
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
345
PACKAGE A3
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10
Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km48+500 Residential area
16/10/2012 13/11/2012 13/12/2012
119 94 102 3367 3335 3452 22,8 20.5 21.1 163 181 193 105 126 130
Km55+500 Residential area
16/10/2012 13/11/2012 13/12/2012
69 58 63 3729 3685 3702 52,5 50.4 52.3 193 212 225 124 141 154
Km67+700 Residential area
17/10/2012 14/11/2012 14/12/2012
49 41 47 3689 3612 3624 21,9 19.7 21.1 255 267 253 123 141 132
Km78+900 Street 17/10/2012 14/11/2012 14/12/2012
59 50 53 3574 3521 3428 53 45 39 268 282 289 120 134 142
QCVN 05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 150 (24-hr) November: Sunny, Windy; November: Sunny, Windy; December: Cloudy, Windy
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
346
PACKAGE A4
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10
Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km91+150 School 18/10/2012 15/11/2012 05/12/2012
135 118 103 3291 3225 3189 42 40.5 37.5 187 196 213 128 142 155
Km95+100 Residential area
18/10/2012 15/11/2012 05/12/2012
51 40 34 3589 3524 3476 62 51 45 163 189 207 74 86 94
CPBTanThanh
Residential area
18/10/2012 15/11/2012 05/12/2012
91 80 70 3155 3128 3084 58 40 37 212 245 267 132 146 155
Km88+300 Residential area
18/10/2012 15/11/2012 05/12/2012
155 141 132 4122 4056 3955 30.5 28.7 25.3 164 180 196 121 132 151
Km104+900 Residential area
19/10/2012 16/11/2012 06/12/2012
142 142 130 3984 3875 3682 589 57.3 54.1 161 180 193 124 135 144
Km106+500 Residential area
19/10/2012 16/11/2012 06/12/2012
158 140 131 4276 4132 4045 57 205 226 140 156 183 72 132 145
Km106+800 School 19/10/2012 16/11/2012 06/12/2012
44 32 28 3878 3697 3614 57 42 37 117 125 140 72 89 94
QCVN 05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 150 (24-hr) October, November and December: Cloudy, windy
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
347
PACKAGE A5
According to Environmental Monitoring Plan approved by the Engineer through the letter Ref. GET3-KEANGNAM-11-A5-037 dated 28th March,
2011, the contractor carries out the Environment monitoring with frequency: 1 time / 1 month. Include some indications: SO2, CO, NOx, TSP,
PM10
Weather condition: - 9th October, 2012: Sunny, average temperature of 23.7, windy speed 1.2 m/s. North-East windy direction
- 19th November, 2012: Sunny, average temperature of 20.1, windy speed 0.8 m/s. North-East windy direction
- 14th December, 2012: Sunny, average temperature of 24.6, windy speed 0.9 m/s. South-East windy direction
Station Sensitive Receptors
Sampling Date & Time, weather
condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP HCOct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km117+050 A1 13:30h, 9/10/2012 7:30h, 19/11/2012
13h:20, 14/12//2012 212 178 182 1604 1612 1514 153 132 151 121 103 102 - - -
Km117+050 A2 14:45h, 9/10/2012 8:40h, 19/11/2012
13h:50, 14/12//2012 198 188 157 1749 1560 1704 143 137 172 136 95 152 - - -
Km117+050 A3 15:30h, 9/10/2012 10:30h, 9/11/2012
14h:20, 14/12//2012 183 178 134 1903 1739 1532 123 114 156 137 112 138 - - -
Km118+820 A4 7:45h, 9/10/2012
13:00h,19/11/2012 15h:00, 14/12//2012
198 187 224 1849 2123 2621 164 157 132 169 158 162 - - -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
348
Station Sensitive Receptors
Sampling Date & Time, weather
condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP HCOct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km118+820 A5 8:50h, 9/10/2012
13:50h,19/11/2012 15h30:, 14/12//2012
235 212 242 2293 2014 2425 178 160 135 179 160 186 - - -
Km118+820 A6 9:50h, 9/10/2012
14h:10,19/11/2012 16h:00, 14/12//2012
245 222 232 2043 2113 2235 157 150 173 243 233 201 - - -
Km121+433 A7 16:10h, 9/10/2012 15:50h,19/11/2012 17h:05, 14/12//2012
254 243 251 2212 2014 2633 154 145 183 78 71 153 - - -
Km121+433 A8 17:05h, 9/10/2012 16:40h,19/11/2012 17h:30, 14/12//2012
165 157 272 1542 2113 2982 176 143 162 132 121 130 - - -
Km121+433 A9 18:00h, 9/10/2012 17:45h,19/11/2012 18h:00, 14/12//2012
168 164 284 2124 1533 2832 159 153 164 143 143 169 - - -
QCVN05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 5000 (1-hr)
Notes:
A1, A2, A3: Sampling points are close to Bao Long Church area (Km117+050): (GPS: N 21.40.269; E 104.53.057)
A4, A5, A6: Sampling points are close to Hop Minh My bridge construction site (Km118+820): (GPS: N 21.40.801; E 104.52.259)
A7, A8, A9: Sampling points are close to National Road bridge construction site (Km121+433): (GPS: N 21.41.609; E 104.51.171)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
349
PACKAGE A6
According to Environmental Monitoring Plan approved by the Engineer through the letter Ref. Ref. GET3-DOOSAN-11-A6-139 dated 16th April,
2011, the contractor carries out the Environment monitoring with frequency: 1 time / 3 month. Include some indications: SO2, CO, NOx, TSP,
PM10
Weather condition: no rain, light wind
Station Sensitive Receptors
Sampling Date & Time, weather
condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP HCOct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km155+360 A6/K1 7h:40, 2/12/2012 - - 170 - - 2150 - - 30 - - 200 - - - Km155+360 A6/K2 18h:35,2/12/2012 - - 140 - - 2010 - - 50 - - 240 - - - Km155+360 A6/K3 22h:00,2/12/2012 - - 160 - - 1890 - - 40 - - 180 - - - Km159+400 A6/K4 8h:00, 2/12/2012 - - 190 - - 2340 - - 50 - - 230 - - - Km159+400 A6/K5 19h:40,2/12/2012 - - 170 - - 2160 - - 70 - - 220 - - - Km159+400 A6/K6 22h:15,2/12/2012 - - 180 - - 1820 - - 60 - - 200 - - - Km162+800 A6/K7 8h:15, 2/12/2012 - - 170 - - 2450 - - 50 - - 250 - - - Km162+800 A6/K8 20h:45,2/12/2012 - - 170 - - 2370 - - 60 - - 230 - - - Km162+800 A6/K9 23h:10,2/12/2012 - - 160 - - 1910 - - 40 - - 190 - - - Km165+300 A6/K10 9h:00,2/12/2012 - - 190 - - 3370 - - 60 - - 250 - Km165+300 A6/K11 21h:20,2/12/2012 - - 180 - - 2360 - - 70 - - 210 - - - Km165+300 A6/K12 23h:30,2/12/2012 - - 180 - - 1780 - - 50 - - 190 - - -
QCVN05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 5000 (1-hr)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
350
Notes:
A6/K1, A6/K2, A6/K3: Sampling points are close to Tan Hop Church area (Km155+360) – X (m): 2.423.253 – Y (m): 461.635
A6/K4, A6/K5, A6/K6: Sampling points are close to Tan Hop Primary School area (Km159+400) – X (m): 2.425.610 – Y (m): 458.440
A6/K7, A6/K8, A6/K9: Sampling points are close to Vinasan’s concrete station (Km162+800) – X (m): 2.428.188 – Y (m): 456.100
A6/K10, A6/K11, A6/K12: Sampling points are close to White stone vina’s concrete station (Km165+300) – X (m): 2.430.266 – Y (m): 455.303
PACKAGE A7
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km192+420 KK01 9h00 – 10h00
15/10/2012 - 66 - - 911 - - 24 - - 118 - - - -
Km198+400 KK02 14h00-15h00 16/10/2012
- 68 - - 1031 - - 27 - - 87 - - - -
Km199+260 KK03 13h00-14h00 15/10/2012 - 77 - - 1316 - - 52 - - 98 - - - -
Km191+353 KK04 8h00-9h00 15/10/2012
- 72 - - 728 - - 15 - - 91 - - - -
Km203+400 KK05 16h00-17h00 15/10/2012
- 68 - - 672 - - 31 - - 82 - - - -
Km205+500 KK06 8h00-9h00 16/10/2012 - 71 - - 731 - - 36 - - 87 - - - -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
351
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km210+680 KK07 11h00-12h0016/10/2012
- 71 - - 751 - - 37 - - 68 - - - -
Km194+670 KK08 10h00-11h00 15/10/2012
- 69 - - 691 - - 23 - - 102 - - - -
Km203+420 KK09 15h00-16h00 15/10/2012 - 68 - - 672 - - 31 - - 82 - - - -
Km206+000 KK10 9h00-10h00 16/10/2012
- 73 - - 731 - - 36 - - 87 - - - -
Km199+800 KK11 14h00-15h00 15/10/2012
- 70 - - 814 - - 35 - - 85 - - - -
Km209+300 KK12 10h00-11h00 16/10/2012
- 66 - - 1072 - - 43 - - 83 - - - -
Km211+500 KK13 13h00-14h00 16/10/2012
- 69 - - 807 - - 38 - - 73 - - - -
Km197+080 KK14 11h00-12h00 15/10/2012
- 67 - - 1648 - - 45 - - 116 - - - -
QCVN 05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 150 (24-hr)
Notes:
KK01: Xuan Sang 1 Primary School, Xuan Sang 1 Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van ban District (coordinates N: 22007.895’; E:104023.844’)
KK02: Concrete mixing plant No.1, Ngam Thin Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22009.615’; E:104020.459’)
KK03: Concrete mixing plant No.2, Dap Tran Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22009.249’; E:104020.751’)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
352
KK04: Bridge girder casting yard, Xuan Sang 2 Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22007.442’; E:104024.026’)
KK05: Equipment gathering yard, worker’s living area, Khe U Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22011.545’;
E:104019.420’)
KK06: Cam Con Primary School, Khe Mai Hamlet, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22012.167’; E:104018.523’)
KK07: Cam Con Health Center, Tan Tien Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22014.142’; E:104016.553’)
KK08: Drainage casting yard No.1, Khe Quat Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22008.585’; E:104022.537’)
KK09: Khe U Primary School, Khe U Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22011.604’; E:104019.474’)
KK10: Residential areas at the right side of project road, Ban Ly Hamlet, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22012.217’;
E:104018.563’)
KK11: Tan Thuong Secondary School, Khe Tep Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22011.021’; E:104020.370’)
KK12: Drainage casting yard No.2, Bong 1 Hamlet, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22013.532’; E:104016.995’)
KK13: Cam Con Secondary School, Hamlet 2, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22014.380’; E:104016.388’)
KK14: Tan An Kinder Garden, Tan Duong Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22009.511’; E:104021.960’)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
353
PACKAGE A8
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
PARAMETERS, μg/m3
SO2 CO NOx TSP PM10Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec Oct Nov Dec
Km219+800 KK01 9h30,14/11/2012 - 46 - - 2300 - - 31 - - 185 - - - -
Km222+580 KK02 10h30, 14/11/2012 - 42 - - 2100 - - 29 - - 122 - - - -
Km224+396 KK03 11h30, 14/11/2012 - 35 - - 1950 - - 27 - - 161 - - - -
Km233+540 KK04 13h,14/11/2012 - 60 - - 3000 - - 48 - - 225 - - - -
Km231+910 KK05 14h,14/11/2012 - 44 - - 2150 - - 32 - - 204 - - - -
Km239+560 KK06 15h,14/11/2012 - 37 - - 1880 - - 28 - - 176 - - - -
Km244+570 KK07 16h,14/11/2012 - 43 - - 2200 - - 34 - - 255 - - - -
Km218+040 KK08 8h30,14/11/2012 - 54 - - 2650 - - 38 - - 238 - - - -
QCVN 05:2009/BTNMT 350 (1-hr) 30,000 (1-hr) 200 (1-hr) 300 (1-hr) 150 (24-hr)
Notes:
KK-01: Near the starting point of project. Sonha primary School -No 2. Anthang branch (GPS: X: 0444528; Y: 2465155);
KK-02: Sonha primary School -No 2. Sonha commune (GPS: X: 0442467; Y: 2467048);
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
354
KK-03: Near Nangsom pre-school. near gate of Kheden village. Sonha commune (GPS: X: 0441002; Y: 2468268);
KK-04: Xuangiao road junction (GPS: X: 0434014; Y: 2471438);
KK-05: Mixing concrete station - Near Xuangiao High school - Langpheo branch (GPS: X: 0434634; Y: 2470881);
KK-06: Giaphu primary School -No 3 (GPS: X: 0428722; Y: 2474582);
KK-07: Point of intersection with Binhminh road (IC 18) near petrol station (GPS: X: 0425492; Y: 2478828);
KK-08: The concrete mixing plant (GPS: X: 0445343; Y: 2463947).
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
355
ANNEX 2.2: WATER QUALITY PARAMETERS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
356
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
357
PACKAGE A1
October
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml)
Petrolium(mg/l)
DO (mg/l)
Ca Lo River – Phuc Yen, Vinh Phuc
Upstream 7.91 49 22 3,310 0.062 5.68
Downstream 7.88 45 38 3,000 0.061 5.72
Quang Khai River, Binh Xuyen, Vinh Phuc
Upstream 7.52 47 30 3,200 0.065 5.65
Downstream 7.49 44 36 3,400 0.078 5.34 QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT, Column B1 5.5~9 50 100 7,500 0.10 4
November
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml)
Petrolium(mg/l)
DO (mg/l)
Ca Lo River – Phuc Yen, Vinh Phuc
Upstream 7.93 47 22 3,000 0.055 5.69
Downstream 7.89 44 34 2,800 0.056 5.77
Quang Khai River, Binh Xuyen, Vinh Phuc
Upstream 7.55 46 28 3,100 0.057 5.68
Downstream 7.54 42 31 3,200 0.054 5.51 QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT Column B1 5.5~9 50 100 7,500 0.10 4
December
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml)
Petrolium(mg/l)
DO (mg/l)
Ca Lo River – Phuc Yen, Vinh Phuc
Upstream 7.99 48 28 3,400 0.059 5.69
Downstream 7.87 45 36 2,900 0.058 5.77
Quang Khai River, Binh Xuyen, Vinh Phuc
Upstream 7.18 43 22 3,000 0.051 5.68
Downstream 7.32 40 20 2,800 0.053 5.51 QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT Column B1 5.5~9 50 100 7,500 0.10 4
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
358
PACKAGE A2
October
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml) Petrolium DO
(mg/l)
Lo River – Central point
Upstream 6.61 47 36 3,300 0.052 6.01 Downstream 7.32 41 24 3,100 0.050 6.18
Lo River – Right side
Upstream 7.36 46 28 2,800 0.049 6.18 Downstream 7.29 44 30 3,100 0.047 6.24
Lo River – Left side
Upstream 6.69 48 26 3,300 0.043 6.12 Downstream 7.28 42 32 3,000 0.044 6.11
Tan Dung Bridge
Upstream 6.19 41 24 2,800 0.041 5.58 Downstream 7.42 46 33 3,500 0.055 5.49
Muong Dao Bridge
Upstream 6.51 43 28 2,200 0.056 5.81 Downstream 7.76 47 22 3,400 0.048 5.76
Ben Gao Bridge
Upstream 7.15 45 23 3,200 0.047 6.03 Downstream 6.91 46 38 3,600 0.056 5.91
Song Dao Bridge
Upstream 6.99 46 27 2,900 0.040 5.48 Downstream 7.17 41 32 3,600 0.048 5.65
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT Column B1 5.5~9 50 100 7,500 0.10 4
November
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml)
Petrolium(mg/l)
DO (mg/l)
Lo River – Central point
Upstream 6.83 46 34 3,200 0.065 6.03
Downstream 7.71 45 22 3,400 0.061 6.11
Lo River – Right side
Upstream 7.62 48 28 3,100 0.059 6.12
Downstream 7.45 47 32 3,300 0.057 6.19
Lo River – Left side
Upstream 6.91 49 31 3,400 0.058 6.10
Downstream 7.40 48 33 3,600 0.055 6.05
Tan Dung Bridge
Upstream 6.33 44 29 2,800 0.051 5.59
Downstream 7.41 47 30 3,300 0.054 5.56
Muong Dao Bridge
Upstream 6.65 48 25 2,700 0.056 5.94
Downstream 7.91 45 23 3,200 0.059 5.89
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
359
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml)
Petrolium(mg/l)
DO (mg/l)
Ben Gao Bridge
Upstream 7.32 46 24 3,000 0.055 6.08
Downstream 6.99 47 36 3,400 0.057 5.99
Song Dao Bridge
Upstream 6.82 42 20 2,200 0.049 6.14
Downstream 7.23 41 22 3,500 0.042 6.12
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT Column B1 5.5~9 50 100 7,500 0.10 4
December
Location pH TSS(mg/l)
Total Fecal Coliform
(MPN/100ml)
TotalColiform
(MPN/100ml)
Petrolium(mg/l)
DO (mg/l)
Lo River – Central point
Upstream 6.88 45 38 3,400 0.061 6.08
Downstream 7.75 46 28 3,200 0.065 6.13
Lo River – Right side
Upstream 7.68 49 29 3,300 0.057 6.14
Downstream 7.49 48 34 3,500 0.059 6.12
Lo River – Left side
Upstream 6.65 47 32 3,600 0.058 6.11
Downstream 7.48 46 35 3,800 0.054 6.08
Tan Dung Bridge
Upstream 6.37 45 28 2,900 0.053 5.55
Downstream 7.42 46 32 3,500 0.059 5.58
Muong Dao Bridge
Upstream 6.69 47 26 2,800 0.058 5.96
Downstream 7.98 44 25 3,300 0.057 5.83
Ben Gao Bridge
Upstream 7.37 46 26 3,300 0.058 6.09
Downstream 6.91 45 35 3,200 0.055 5.92
Song Dao Bridge
Upstream 6.86 46 24 2,600 0.052 6.18
Downstream 7.24 44 20 2,800 0.057 6.15
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT Column B1 5.5~9 50 100 7,500 0.10 4
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
360
PACKAGE A3
October
Order MonitoringItems
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 67+000
pH 6,73 6,71 6,72 5,5 – 9 TSS 48 46 47 50 Fecal Coliform 38 38 38 100 Total Coliform 6.950 6.950 6.950 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 10 12 11 15 COD 19 19 19 30 Total Nitrogen 1,64 1,62 1,63 -Total Phosphor 1,41 1,41 1,41 -
Km 78+000
pH 6,71 6,71 6,71 5,5 – 9 TSS 46 44 45 50
Fecal Coliform 36 36 36 100 Total Coliform 6.900 6.900 6.900 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 10 10 10 15 COD 18 16 17 30 Total Nitrogen 1,54 1,56 1,55 -Total Phosphor 0,79 0,81 0,80 -
November
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 67+000
pH 6,67 6,69 6,68 5,5 – 9 TSS 41 39 40 50
Fecal Coliform 44 44 44 100 Total Coliform 7.050 7.050 7.050 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 14 16 15 15 COD 22 22 22 30 Total Nitrogen 1,82 1,80 1,81 -Total Phosphor 1,59 1,59 1,59 -
Km 78+000 pH 6,63 6,63 6,63 5,5 – 9 TSS 41 39 40 50
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
361
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Fecal Coliform 38 40 39 100 Total Coliform 7.000 7.000 7.000 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 12 12 12 15 COD 20 18 19 30 Total Nitrogen 1,66 1,66 1,66 -Total Phosphor 0,89 0,87 0,88 -
December
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 67+000
pH 6,59 6,57 6,58 5,5 – 9 TSS 35 35 35 50
Fecal Coliform 41 43 42 100 Total Coliform 7.100 7.100 7.100 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 15 13 14 15 COD 23 23 23 30 Total Nitrogen 1,82 1,84 1,83 -Total Phosphor 0,94 0,94 0,94 -
Km 78+000
pH 6,70 6,72 6,71 5,5 – 9 TSS 38 36 37 50
Fecal Coliform 48 48 48 100 Total Coliform 7.210 7.210 7.210 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 16 18 17 15 COD 26 26 26 30 Total Nitrogen 1,89 1,87 1,88 -Total Phosphor 1,73 1,71 1,72 -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
362
PACKAGE A4
October
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 88+700
pH 6,82 6,84 6,83 5,5 – 9 TSS 44 46 45 50
Fecal Coliform 45 43 44 100
Total Coliform 6.900 6.900 6.900 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 11 13 12 15 COD 25 23 24 30 Total Nitrogen 1,20 1,22 1,21 -Total Phosphor 0,61 0,59 0,60 -
Km 97+500
pH 6,69 6,67 6,68 5,5 – 9 TSS 45 43 44 50
Fecal Coliform 37 37 37 100 Total Coliform 6.950 6.950 6.950 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 12 14 13 15 COD 24 24 24 30 Total Nitrogen 1,26 1,24 1,25 -Total Phosphor 0,83 0,83 0,83 -
Km 101+000 to Km 101+900
pH 6,82 6,82 6,82 5,5 – 9 TSS 41 39 40 50
Fecal Coliform 24 24 24 100 Total Coliform 6.150 6.150 6.150 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 10 12 11 15 COD 21 19 20 30 Total Nitrogen 1,21 1,23 1,22 -Total Phosphor 0,75 0,73 0,74 -
Km 109+000
pH 6,89 6,89 6,89 5,5 – 9 TSS 43 41 42 50
Fecal Coliform 19 19 19 100 Total Coliform 6.930 6.930 6.930 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 10 12 11 15 COD 23 23 23 30 Total Nitrogen 1,36 1,34 1,35 -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
363
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Total Phosphor 0,79 0,77 0,78 -
Km 108+227
pH 6,71 6,71 6,71 5,5 – 9 TSS 45 47 46 50
Fecal Coliform 40 42 41 100 Total Coliform 6.800 6.800 6.800 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 14 12 13 15 COD 25 25 25 30 Total Nitrogen 1,30 1,28 1,29 -Total Phosphor 0,95 0,95 0,95 -
November
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 88+700
pH 6,66 6,68 6,67 5,5 – 9
TSS 37 39 38 50
Fecal Coliform 46 46 46 100
Total Coliform 6.950 6.950 6.950 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 12 14 13 15 COD 27 27 27 30 Total Nitrogen 1,31 1,33 1,32 -Total Phosphor 0,66 0,66 0,66 -
Km 97+500
pH 6,53 6,55 6,54 5,5 – 9
TSS 35 35 35 50 Fecal Coliform 41 39 40 100 Total Coliform 7.000 7.000 7.000 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 10 12 11 15 COD 23 23 23 30 Total Nitrogen 1,32 1,34 1,33 -Total Phosphor 0,90 0,92 0,91 -
Km 101+000 to Km 101+900
pH 6,75 6,73 6,74 5,5 – 9 TSS 33 33 33 50
Fecal Coliform 27 29 28 100 Total Coliform 6.250 6.250 6.250 7.500
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
364
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 10 8 9 15 COD 17 17 17 30 Total Nitrogen 1,29 1,29 1,29 -Total Phosphor 0,83 0,81 0,82 -
Km 109+000
pH 6,80 6,80 6,80 5,5 – 9 TSS 36 34 35 50
Fecal Coliform 21 23 22 100 Total Coliform 7.000 7.000 7.000 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 12 14 13 15 COD 25 25 25 30 Total Nitrogen 1,41 1,43 1,42 -Total Phosphor 0,88 0,88 0,88 -
Km 108+227
pH 6,64 6,64 6,64 5,5 – 9 TSS 38 36 37 50
Fecal Coliform 45 45 45 100 Total Coliform 6.600 6.600 6.600 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 11 9 10 15 COD 20 22 21 30 Total Nitrogen 1,35 1,35 1,35 -Total Phosphor 0,86 0,86 0,86 -
December
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 88+700
pH 6,73 6,73 6,73 5,5 – 9
TSS 33 31 32 50
Fecal Coliform 52 50 51 100
Total Coliform 7.090 7.070 7.080 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 12 10 11 15 COD 21 19 20 30 Total Nitrogen 1,41 1,41 1,41 -Total Phosphor 0,74 0,72 0,73 -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
365
Order Monitoring Items
Max. value (mg/l)
Min. value (mg/l)
Average Value (mg/l)
QCVN 08:2008/BTNMTColumn B1
Km 97+500
pH 6,62 6,60 6,61 5,5 – 9
TSS 28 28 28 50 Fecal Coliform 46 44 45 100 Total Coliform 7.100 7.100 7.100 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 14 12 13 15 COD 25 25 25 30 Total Nitrogen 1,45 1,43 1,44 -Total Phosphor 1,05 1,05 1,05 -
Km 101+000 to Km 101+900
pH 6,78 6,76 6,77 5,5 – 9 TSS 29 29 29 50
Fecal Coliform 33 31 32 100 Total Coliform 6.300 6.300 6.300 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 11 9 10 15 COD 18 18 18 30 Total Nitrogen 1,34 1,32 1,33 -Total Phosphor 0,95 0,95 0,95 -
Km 109+000
pH 6,89 6,87 6,88 5,5 – 9 TSS 30 30 30 50
Fecal Coliform 26 24 25 100 Total Coliform 7.100 7.100 7.100 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 15 13 14 15 COD 27 27 27 30 Total Nitrogen 1,55 1,53 1,54 -Total Phosphor 0,96 0,96 0,96 -
Km 108+227
pH 6,74 6,72 6,73 5,5 – 9 TSS 31 31 31 50
Fecal Coliform 50 48 49 100 Total Coliform 6.700 6.700 6.700 7.500 Petroleum KPH KPH KPH 0,1 BOD 13 11 12 15 COD 26 24 25 30 Total Nitrogen 1,47 1,47 1,47 -Total Phosphor 0,99 0,97 0,98 -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
366
PACKAGE A5
According to Environmental Monitoring Plan approved by the Engineer through the letter Ref.
GET3-KEANGNAM-11-A5-037 dated 28th March, 2011, the contractor carryied out the
Environment monitoring with frequency: 1 time / 1 month. Include some indications: pH, DO,
TSS, COD, BOD5, Surfactant, Oil and grease, Fecal coliform, total coliform.
October
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100mlMPN/100ml
Km145+500 W1 8h:10,9/10/2012 6.9 6.4 37 13 <5 <0.1 <0.1 54 1200
Km145+500 W2 8h:25,9/10/2012 7.3 6.3 36 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 45 1210
Km145+500 W3 8h:35,9/10/2012 7.1 6.5 43 9 <5 <0.1 <0.1 42 930
Km145+500 W4 8h:40,9/10/2012 6.2 6.3 42 9 <5 <0.1 <0.1 48 830
Km126+000 W5 9h:10,9/10/2012 7.3 6.4 32 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 45 940
Km126+000 W6 9h:25,9/10/2012 7.4 6.3 28 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 43 690
Km126+000 W7 9h:40,9/10/2012 7.5 6.1 24 9 <5 <0.1 <0.1 40 940
Km126+000 W8 10h:009/10/2012 7.3 6.3 29 7 <5 <0.1 <0.1 37 840
Km122+000 W9 10h:40,9/10/2012 7.1 5.8 27 14 8 0.08 0.04 45 5300
Km122+000 W10 10h:50,9/10/2012 6.9 5.7 26 14 7 0.09 0.04 254 5200
Km122+000 W11 11h:15,9/10/2012 7.2 5.7 26 17 11 0.14 0.06 345 5700
Km122+000 W12 11h:30,9/10/2012 6.8 5.8 27 14 8 0.12 0.04 323 6800
QCVN08:08 5,5-9 4 50 30 15 0,4 0,1 100 7500 Weather condition: Sunny, average temperature of 23.7, windy speed 1.2 m/s. North-East windy direction
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
367
November
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100mlMPN/100ml
Km145+500 W1 7h:45,19/11/2012 6.8 6.3 45 13 <5 <0.1 <0.1 44 230
Km145+500 W2 8h:00,19/11/2012 7.2 6.2 45 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 34 330
Km145+500 W3 8h:15,19/11/2012 7.3 6.4 44 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 34 540
Km145+500 W4 8h:25,19/11/2012 6.9 6.4 45 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 45 650
Km126+000 W5 9h:50,19/11/2012 7.2 6.3 40 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 23 630
Km126+000 W6 10h:00,19/11/2012 7.1 6.3 38 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 19 570
Km126+000 W7 10h:10,19/11/2012 7.3 6.2 34 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 32 780
Km126+000 W8 10h:20,19/11/2012 6.9 6.2 34 8 <5 <0.1 <0.1 34 830
Km122+000 W9 10h:45,19/11/2012 7.3 5.6 35 13 6 0.05 0.04 40 4300
Km122+000 W10 11h:00,19/11/2012 6.7 5.7 32 13 7 0.04 0.03 183 4500
Km122+000 W11 11h:15,19/11/2012 7.1 5.3 32 14 6 0.09 0.03 256 5540
Km122+000 W12 11h:20,19/11/2012 6.9 5.5 35 13 6 0.08 0.02 232 6300
QCVN08:08 5,5-9 4 50 30 15 0,4 0,1 100 7500 Weather condition: Sunny, average temperature of 20.1, windy speed 0.8 m/s. North-East windy direction
December
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100mlMPN/100ml
Km145+500 W1 7h:30,14/12/2012 7.4 6.7 28 7 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 65 1300
Km145+500 W2 7h:50,14/12/2012 7.3 6.4 25 7 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 30 730
Km145+500 W3 8h:10, 7.4 6.6 25 7 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 45 630
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
368
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100mlMPN/100ml
14/12/2012
Km145+500 W4 8h:30,14/12/2012 7.4 6.5 26 7 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 33 640
Km126+000 W5 9h:40,14/12/2012 7.1 6.4 23 8 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 38 760
Km126+000 W6 9h:55,14/12/2012 6.8 6.4 26 8 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 54 730
Km126+000 W7 10h:10,14/12/2012 6.7 6.3 24 8 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 48 700
Km126+000 W8 10h:2014/12/2012 6.8 6.3 25 7 < 5 < 0,1 < 0,1 53 680
Km122+000 W9 11h:00,14/12/2012 7.3 5.7 27 22 13 0,14 0,06 48 4800
Km122+000 W10 10h:10,14/12/2012 7.1 5.5 27 19 12 0,13 0,07 530 5400
Km122+000 W11 11h:25,14/12/2012 7.3 5.6 25 17 12 0,14 0,07 510 5100
Km122+000 W12 11h:35,14/12/2012 7.1 5.3 25 24 15 0,15 0,07 540 5500
QCVN08:08 5,5-9 4 50 30 15 0,4 0,1 100 7500 Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Notes:
W1: Ngoi Thia river (Km145+500) – The bridge pier (N21050’961’’; E104042’500’’)
W2: Ngoi Thia river (Km145+500) – 50m from the bridge pier (toward upstream)
(N21050’960’’; E104042’483’’)
W3: Ngoi Thia river (Km145+500 – 200 m from the bridge pier (toward downstream)
(N21050’982’’; E104042’521’’)
W4: Ngoi Thia river (Km145+500 – 400 m from the bridge pier (toward downstream)
(N21050’998’’; E104042’539’’)
W5: Y Can lake (Km126+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 1 (N21044’038’’;
E104049’496’’)
W6: Y Can lake (Km126+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 2 (N21044’046’’;
E104049’503’’)
W7: Y Can lake (Km126+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 3 (N21044’067’’;
E104045’553’’)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
369
W8: Y Can lake (Km126+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 4 (N21044’079’’;
E104045’571’’)
W9: Nuoc Mat lake (Km122+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 1 (N21044’741’’;
E104050’492’’)
W10: Nuoc Mat lake (Km122+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 2
(N21044’711’’; E104050’935’’)
W11: Nuoc Mat lake (Km122+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 3
(N21044’726’’; E104050’955’’)
W12: Nuoc Mat lake (Km122+000) – Surface water sample at position No. 4
(N21044’725’’; E104050’965’’)
* Nuoc Mat lake (W9, W10, W11 and W12) has a small area and locates in the residential area
with dense population density. The area of lake tends to be smaller because of site clearance
as well as encroachment by inhabitants. Because domestic wastewater from residential areas
discharges into Nuoc Mat lake, water quality of the lake in polluted partly although the
measured values are within acceptable limits in QCVN 08:2008 – column B1.
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
370
PACKAGE A6
According to Environmental Monitoring Plan approved by the Engineer through the letter Ref. Ref. GET3-DOOSAN-11-A6-139 dated 16th April,
2011. The contractors carry out the Environment monitoring with frequency: 1 time / 1 month. Include some indications: pH, DO, TSS, COD,
BOD5, Surfactant, Oil and grease, Fecal coliform, total coliform.
October
Station Sensitive Receptors
Sampling Date & Time, weather
condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100ml MPN/100ml
Km165+100 NM1 7h:45, 4/10/2012 6.3 6.4 45 7.8 3.9 0.004 0.06 27 561 Km165+100 NM2 8h:00, 4/10/2012 7.5 6.3 44 6.8 3.4 0.003 0.05 22 647 Km165+100 NM3 8h:15, 4/10/2012 7.2 5.6 47 8.1 4.0 0.005 0.03 25 514 Km165+100 NM4 8h:25, 4/10/2012 7.6 6.1 46 9.3 4.7 0.004 0.04 26 484 Km186+200 NM5 9h:50, 4/10/2012 6.2 6.5 39 5.6 2.8 0.003 0.06 23 525 Km186+200 NM6 10h:00, 4/10/2012 6.6 6.4 38 5.9 2.9 0.004 0.04 29 547 Km186+200 NM7 10h:10, 4/10/2012 7.2 6.3 37 6.4 3.3 0.002 0.03 25 463 Km186+200 NM8 10h:20, 4/10/2012 7.4 6.5 38 6.2 3.1 0.003 0.04 27 489 Km186+730 NM9 10h:45, 4/10/2012 7.1 6.4 31 8.4 4.2 0.006 0.08 28 496 Km186+730 NM10 11h:00, 4/10/2012 6.9 6.2 33 7.5 3.8 0.005 0.07 26 475 Km186+730 NM11 11h:15, 4/10/2012 7.1 6.3 32 9.6 4.7 0.003 0.05 24 487 Km186+730 NM12 11h:20, 4/10/2012 7.2 6.1 34 9.7 4.5 0.004 0.05 28 471
QCVN08:08 5,5-9 4 50 30 15 0,4 0,1 100 7500 Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
371
November
Station Sensitive Receptors
Sampling Date & Time, weather
condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100ml MPN/100ml
Km165+100 NM1 8h:10, 9/11/2012 6.3 6.2 44 7.5 3.7 0.005 0.07 31 623 Km165+100 NM2 8h:25, 9/11/2012 7.4 6.5 47 6.4 3.2 0.002 0.08 25 686 Km165+100 NM3 8h:40, 9/11/2012 7.2 5.1 45 8.3 4.1 0.004 0.05 23 617 Km165+100 NM4 8h:55, 9/11/2012 7.5 6.4 43 8.4 4.2 0.006 0.06 27 534 Km186+200 NM5 9h:30, 9/11/2012 7.2 6.2 37 6.5 3.3 0.004 0.07 25 621 Km186+200 NM6 9h:40, 9/11/2012 6.9 6.8 35 6.1 3.1 0.005 0.05 26 614 Km186+200 NM7 10h:00, 9/11/2012 7.0 6.3 36 5.9 2.9 0.003 0.04 24 547 Km186+200 NM8 10h:10, 9/11/2012 7.2 6.1 33 5.8 2.7 0.002 0.06 22 525 Km186+730 NM9 10h:30, 9/11/2012 7.1 6.5 32 7.4 3.2 0.005 0.08 27 518 Km186+730 NM10 10h:45, 9/11/2012 6.9 6.4 35 7.2 3.6 0.006 0.06 24 506 Km186+730 NM11 11h:00, 9/11/2012 7.0 6.0 34 8.9 4.8 0.004 0.03 23 534 Km186+730 NM12 11h:20, 9/11/2012 7.1 6.4 31 8.8 4.3 0.003 0.06 29 496
QCVN08:08 5,5-9 4 50 30 15 0,4 0,1 100 7500 Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
372
December
Station Sensitive Receptors
Sampling Date & Time, weather
condition
pH DO TSS COD BOD5(20oC) Surf. Oil and
Grease Fecal
Coliform Total
Coliform
- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l MPN/100ml MPN/100ml
Km165+100 NM1 14h:30, 2/12/2012 7.0 6.8 37 7.8 3.5 0.003 0.05 43 541 Km165+100 NM2 15h:05, 2/12/2012 7.0 6.3 38 7.3 3.7 0.005 0.07 36 573 Km165+100 NM3 15h:45, 2/12/2012 7.1 5.1 48 8.6 4.1 0.003 0.06 27 497 Km165+100 NM4 16h:40, 2/12/2012 7.1 5.6 46 8.4 4.3 0.006 0.05 29 485 Km186+200 NM5 7h:30, 2/12/2012 6.9 5.3 39 5.9 2.8 0.004 0.04 38 546 Km186+200 NM6 8h:05, 2/12/2012 6.9 5.2 36 6.5 3.4 0.006 0.07 44 533 Km186+200 NM7 8h:30, 2/12/2012 7.1 4.7 48 6.4 3.6 0.003 0.06 37 487 Km186+200 NM8 9h:00, 2/12/2012 7.1 4.6 45 7.7 3.3 0.002 0.07 38 494 Km186+730 NM9 10h:10, 2/12/2012 7.1 5.4 46 9.6 4.7 0.005 0.05 45 575 Km186+730 NM10 10h:30, 2/12/2012 7.0 5.6 43 10.3 5.0 0.004 0.06 43 573 Km186+730 NM11 11h:00, 2/12/2012 7.1 4.7 47 11.5 6.5 0.002 0.07 36 496 Km186+730 NM12 11h:30, 2/12/2012 7.1 4.3 49 14.5 7.4 0.005 0.08 39 499
QCVN08:08 5,5-9 4 50 30 15 0,4 0,1 100 7500 Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Notes:
NM1: Ngoi Hut bridge area (Km165+100) – Upper layer of water samples (time 1) – X (m): 2.430.208 – Y (m): 455.312
NM2: Ngoi Hut bridge area (Km165+100) – Upper layer of water samples (time 2) – X (m): 2.430.208 – Y (m): 455.312
NM3: Ngoi Hut bridge area (Km165+100) – Under layer of water samples (time 1) – X (m): 2.430.208 – Y (m): 455.312
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
373
NM4: Ngoi Hut bridge area (Km165+100) – Under layer of water samples (time 2) – X (m): 2.430.208 – Y (m): 455.312
NM5: Tunnel’s south portal area (Km186+200) – Upper layer of water samples (time 1) – X (m): 2.444.056 – Y (m): 441.293
NM6: Tunnel’s south portal area (Km186+200) – Upper layer of water samples (time 2) – X (m): 2.444.056 – Y (m): 441.293
NM7: Tunnel’s south portal area (Km186+200) – Under layer of water samples (time 1) – X (m): 2.444.056 – Y (m): 441.293
NM8: Tunnel’s south portal area (Km186+200) – Under layer of water samples (time 2) – X (m): 2.444.056 – Y (m): 441.293
NM9: Tunnel’s north portal area (Km186+730) – Upper layer of water samples (time 1) – X (m): 2.444.379 – Y (m): 440.636
NM10: Tunnel’s north portal area (Km186+730) – Upper layer of water samples (time 2) – X (m): 2.444.379 – Y (m): 440.636
NM11: Tunnel’s north portal area (Km186+730) – Under layer of water samples (time 1) – X (m): 2.444.379 – Y (m): 440.636
NM12: Tunnel’s north portal area (Km186+730) – Under layer of water samples (time 2) – X (m): 2.444.379 – Y (m): 440.636
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
374
PACKAGE A7
Contractor for package A7 monitored water quality once per quarter, in October
October
Parameters Unit NM-1A NM-1B NM-2A NM-2B NM-3A NM-3B QCVN
08:2008/BTNMT(A2)
pH - 7,1 7,1 7,1 6,9 7,1 7,0 6-8.5 Temperature oC 23 23 24 22 23 23 - DO mg/L 6,8 7,0 6,7 6,7 6,6 6,6 5TSS mg/L 0,1 0,12 0,85 0,83 0,18 0,21 30 COD mg O2/L 15 13,5 12,1 12,4 40,1 41,3 15 BOD5 mg/L 14,2 13,2 30,1 32,7 34,3 34,7 6 Coliform MPN/100mL 15 21 38 41 210 232 5000 Grease & oil mg/L 0,15 0,14 0,11 0,11 0,12 0,13 0.02 NO3
- mg/L 0,5 0,53 0,37 0,38 0,62 0,61 5 NH4
+ - N mg/L 0,15 0,17 0,52 0,54 0,41 0,47 0.2 SO4
2- mg/L 4250 4730 3780 3820 2760 2810 - PO4
3- mg/L 0,05 0,045 0,009 0,01 0,015 0,017 0.2 Total N mg/L 0,01 0,01 0,008 0,008 0,03 0,03 - Total P mg/L 0,02 0,03 0,016 0,02 0,04 0,037 - Fe mg/L 2,1 1,97 3,2 2,85 0,5 0,65 1.0 Cd mg/L <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 0.005 As mg/L <0,001 <0,001 <0,001 <0,001 0,002 0,001 0.02 Mn mg/L 0,043 0,051 0,050 0,055 0,112 0,108 - Pb mg/L 0,001 0,001 0,001 0,001 0,001 0,001 0.02 Zn mg/L 0,082 0,079 0,055 0,062 3,440 3,523 1.0
Parameters Unit NM-4A NM-4B NM-5A NM-5B NM-6A NM-6B QCVN
08:2008/ BTNMT(A2)
pH - 7.0 7.2 7.1 7.0 7.1 7.2 6-8.5
Temperature oC 24.5 25 24.5 22.4 23.5 22.5 -
DO mg/L 6.7 6.8 6.5 6.8 6.9 6.7 5
TSS mg/L 0.1 0.13 0.09 0.11 0.12 0.11 30
COD mg O2/L 6.8 7.1 18.2 17.8 12.5 13.1 15
BOD5 mg/L 32.4 31.5 16 15,8 39.5 38.9 6
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
375
Parameters Unit NM-4A NM-4B NM-5A NM-5B NM-6A NM-6B QCVN
08:2008/ BTNMT(A2)
Coliform MPN/100mL 75 69 64 62 120 126 5000
Grease & oil mg/L 0.13 0.13 0.18 0.17 0.17 0.18 0.02
NO3- mg/L 0.51 0.57 0.47 0.79 0.9 0.91 5
NH4+ - N mg/L 0.35 0.4 0.72 0.71 0.6 0.65 0.2
SO42- mg/L 2110 2020 2690 2720 3710 3690 -
PO43- mg/L 0.02 0.006 0.01 0.005 0.007 0.01 0.2
Total N mg/L 0.015 0.016 0.02 0.02 0.05 0.04 -
Total P mg/L 0.078 0.081 0.021 0.022 0.03 0.032 -
Fe mg/L 1.2 1.17 0.81 0.92 0.62 0.61 1.0
Cd mg/L <0.0002 <0.0002 <0.0002 <0.0002 <0.0002 <0.0002 0.005
As mg/L <0.001 0.002 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.02
Mn mg/L 0.058 0.062 0.049 0.046 0.106 0.113 -
Pb mg/L 0.004 0.0038 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.02
Zn mg/L 0.080 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.060 0.064 1.0
Parameters Unit NM-7A NM-7B NM-8A NM-8B QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT(A2)
pH - 6.7 7.1 6.8 6.8 6-8.5
Temperature oC 23 23.5 23 24.5 -
DO mg/L 7.0 7.0 6.8 7.0 .
TSS mg/L 0.07 0.08 0.81 0.90 30
COD mg O2/L 32.1 33.3 20.5 20.7 15
BOD5 mg/L 15.2 15.7 31.8 30.9 6
Coliform MPN/100mL 200 203 240 251 5000
Grease & oil mg/L 0.16 0.16 0.11 0.11 0.02
NO3- mg/L 0.85 0.9 1.2 1.22 5
NH4+ - N mg/L 0.03 0.03 0.05 0.06 0.2
SO42- mg/L 3210 3230 4690 4630 -
PO43- mg/L 0.03 0.031 0.001 0.001 0.2
Total N mg/L 0.1 0.15 0.1 0.09 -
Total P mg/L 0.037 0.042 0.042 0.026 -
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
376
Parameters Unit NM-7A NM-7B NM-8A NM-8B QCVN 08:2008/BTNMT(A2)
Fe mg/L 1.25 1.31 0.92 0.97 1.0
Cd mg/L <0.0002 <0.0002 <0.0002 <0.0002 0.005
As mg/L 0.001 0.001 0.001 <0.001 0.02
Mn mg/L 0.091 0.102 0.045 0.042 -
Pb mg/L <0.001 <0.001 0.001 0.001 0.02
Zn mg/L 0.046 0.048 0.054 0.051 1.0
Notes:
NM-1A: 100m upstream of Com Stream (Coordinates N: 22009,227’, E: 104020,747’)
NM-1B: 100m downstream of Com Stream (Coordinates N: 22009,294’, E: 104020,763’)
NM-2A: 100m upstream of Khe Sang Stream (Coordinates N: 22015,210’, E: 105048,008’)
NM-2B: 100m downstream of Khe Sang Stream (Coordinates N: 22007,448’, E: 104024,075’)
NM-3A: 100m upstream of Khe Quat Stream (Coordinates N: 22008,536’, E: 104022,536’)
NM-3B: 100m downstream of Khe Quat Stream (Coordinates N: 22008,560’, E: 104022,561’)
NM-4A: 100m upstream of Khe U Stream (Coordinates N: 22011,531’, E: 104019,354’)
NM-4B: 100m downstream of Khe U Stream (Coordinates N: 22011,544’, E: 104019,408’)
NM-5A: 100m upstream of Bong Stream (Coordinates N: 22013,446’, E: 104016,961’)
NM-5B: 100m downstream of Bong Stream (Coordinates N: 22014,536’, E: 104016,760)
NM-6A: 100m upstream of Cam 4 Stream (Coordinates N: 22009,509’, E: 104021,959’)
NM-6B: 100m downstream of Cam 4 Stream (Coordinates N: 22015,210’, E: 104015,445’)
NM-7A: 100m upstream of Mai Hong Stream (Coordinates N: 22008,572’, E: 104022,565’)
NM-7B: 100m downstream of Mai Hong Stream (Coordinates N: 22008,607’, E: 104022,597’)
NM-8A: 100m upstream of Ban Ly 1 Stream (Coordinates N: 22012,324’, E: 104018,185’)
NM-8B: 100m downstream of Ban Ly 1 Stream (Coordinates N: 22011,299’, E: 104019,176’)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
377
PACKAGE A8
In this package water quality is monitored once per quarter, in November.
November, 2012
Parameters Unit NM-1A NM-1B NM-2A NM-2B NM-3A NM-3B
QCVN08:2008/
BTNMT(A2) pH - 6,93 6,85 6,72 7,03 7,11 7,13 6,5-8,5 Temperature oC 22,4 21,8 24,8 23,6 22,9 23,2 - DO mg/l 6,2 5,9 5,8 5,8 6,3 6,3 >5 TDS mg/l 1007 1016 990 1006 1014 1018 - TSS mg/l 21,3 25,0 23,5 26,8 20,5 27,1 30 COD mg/l 8,7 9,6 8,0 9,0 8,8 10,2 15 BOD5 mg/l 3,5 4,0 3,2 3,6 3,5 4,5 6 Coliform MPN/100ml 800 850 920 980 1000 1050 5000 Oils & grease mg/l 0,006 0,008 0,004 0,005 0,005 0,006 0,02 NO2
- mg/l 0,010 0,012 0,008 0,009 0,008 0,010 0,02 NO3
- mg/l 3,35 3,41 3,52 3,56 3,39 3,44 5 NH4 - N mg/l 0,085 0,096 0,098 0,105 0,102 0,110 0,2 PO4
3- mg/l 0,063 0,065 0,060 0,062 0,064 0,068 0,2 Ni mg/l <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 0,1 Fe mg/l 0,615 0,590 0,556 0,502 0,458 0,380 1,0 Cd mg/l <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 0,005 Hg mg/l <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 <0,0002 0,001 As mg/l 0,006 0,005 0,006 0,005 0,007 0,006 0,02 Cu mg/l 0,052 0,045 0,041 0,038 0,036 0,034 0,2 Pb mg/l <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 <0,002 0,003 0,003 0,02 Zn mg/l 0,015 0,012 0,014 0,011 0,013 0,010 1,0
Note:
NM-1A: Upstream bridge across Nhu stream (100m) (GPS: X: 0445339; Y: 2463829);
NM-1B: Downstream bridge across Nhu stream (100m) (GPS: X: 0445555; Y: 2463862);
NM-2A: Upstream bridge across Trat stream (100m) (GPS: X: 0434831; Y: 2470952);
NM-2B: Downstream bridge across Trat stream (100m) (GPS: X: 0434763; Y: 2471041);
NM-3A: Upstream bridge across Ngoi Bo river (100m) (GPS: X: 0429896; Y: 2474104);
NM-3B: Downstream bridge across Ngoi Bo river (100m) (GPS: X: 0429890; Y: 2474154).
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
378
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
379
ANNEX 2.3: NOISE LEVELS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
380
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
381
PACKAGE A1
October
Noise Monitoring Result
Location Monitoring value (dBA) Standard value (dBA)
6h – 21h 21h – 6h 6h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km 4+220 62 60 55 45 Km 13+100 61 54 70 55 Km 19+650 61.2 60.3 55 45 Km 24+900 60.5 54 70 55
November
Noise Monitoring Result
Location Monitoring value (dBA) Standard value (dBA)
6h – 21h 21h – 6h 6h – 21h 21h – 6h Km 4+220 62 61 55 45
Km 13+100 61 54 70 55 Km 19+650 55 45 55 45 Km 24+900 61 54 70 55
December
Noise Monitoring Result
Location Monitoring value (dBA) Standard value (dBA)
6h – 21h 21h – 6h 6h – 21h 21h – 6h Km 4+220 61 60 55 45
Km 13+100 60,2 54 70 55 Km 19+650 60,4 55 55 45 Km 24+900 61 54 70 55
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
382
PACKAGE A2
October
Noise Monitoring Result
Location Monitoring value (dBA) Standard value (dBA)
6h – 21h 21h – 6h 6h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km 34+780 60 59 55 45 Km 36+500 61 58 70 55 Km 39+130 60 59 70 55
November
Noise Monitoring Result
Location Monitoring value (dBA) Standard value (dBA)
6h – 21h 21h – 6h 6h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km 34+780 55 45 55 45 Km 36+500 59 57 70 55 Km 39+130 63 59 70 55
December
Noise Monitoring Result
Location Monitoring value (dBA) Standard value (dBA)
6h – 21h 21h – 6h 6h – 21h 21h – 6h Km 34+780 55 45 55 45 Km 36+500 58.6 57 70 55 Km 39+130 58.9 58 70 55
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
383
PACKAGE A3
October
Noise measuring
Vibration measuring
November
Noise measuring
Vibration measuring
StationMonitoring Value (dBA) Standard Value (dBA)
6h-10h 10h-14h 14h -18h 6h - 21h
Km 48+500 53 55 55 55 Km 55+550 68 69 67 70 Km 67+700 66 70 69 70 Km78+900 67 70 70 70
Station Max. Value (mg/m3)
Min. Value (mg/m3)
Average. Value (mg/m3)
Standard Value (mg/m3)
Km 48+500 0,051 0,051 0,051 0,055 Km 55+550 0,051 0,051 0,051 0,055 Km 67+700 0,052 0,052 0,052 0,055 Km78+900 0,041 0,039 0,040 0,055
Monitoring Value (dBA) Standard Value (dBA) Station 6h-10h 10h-14h 14h -18h 18h - 21h
Km 48+500 54 54 55 55 Km 55+550 66 67 65 70 Km 67+700 67 69 68 70 Km78+900 66 69 70 70
Station Max. Value (mg/m3)
Min. Value (mg/m3)
Average. Value (mg/m3)
Standard Value (mg/m3)
Km 48+500 0,055 0,053 0,054 0,055 Km 55+550 0,046 0,044 0,045 0,055 Km 67+700 0,049 0,047 0,048 0,055 Km78+900 0,044 0,044 0,044 0,055
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
384
December
Noise measuring
Vibration measuring
PACKAGE A4
October
Noise measuring
StationMonitoringValue (dBA) Standard Value (dBA)
6h-10h 10h-14h 14h -18h 18h - 21h
Km 48+500 53 50 52 55 Km 55+550 68 64 66 70 Km 67+700 68 65 68 70 Km78+900 67 68 70 70
Station Max.Value(mg/m3) Min. Value(mg/m3) Average.
Value(mg/m3)Standard Value
(mg/m3)Km 48+500 0,052 0,050 0,051 0,055 Km 55+550 0,047 0,049 0,048 0,055 Km 67+700 0,045 0,045 0,045 0,055 Km78+900 0,040 0,040 0,040 0,055
MonitoringValue (dBA) Standard Value (dBA)Station 6h-10h 10h-14h 14h -18h 6h - 21h
Km 91+150 54 52 53
70
Km 95+100 70 67 68 Tan ThanhCBP 68 65 70 Km88+300 to Km88+500 69 67 70 Km104+900 to Km105+350 67 64 70 Km106+500 to Km107+600 67 63 69 Km106+800 51 50 53
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
385
Vibration measuring
November
Noise measuring
Vibration measuring
Station Min. Value Max. Value Average Value Standard Value (mg/m3)
Km 91+150 KPH KPH KPH
0,055
Km 95+100 KPH KPH KPHTan ThanhCBP 0,043 0,043 0,043 Km88+300 to Km88+500 0,035 0,035 0,035 Km104+900 to Km105+350 0,020 0,020 0,020 Km106+500 to Km107+600 0,026 0,024 0,025 Km106+800 0,020 0,020 0,020
MonitoringValue (dBA) Standard Value (dBA)Station 6h-10h 10h-14h 14h -18h 6h - 21h
Km 91+150 51 53 53
70
Km 95+100 69 67 69 Tan ThanhCBP 68 64 69 Km88+300 to Km88+500 70 67 69 Km104+900 to Km105+350 62 60 64 Km106+500 to Km107+600 63 61 65 Km106+800 52 51 53
Station Min. Value Max. Value Average Value Standard Value (mg/m3)
Km 91+150 KPH KPH KPH
0,055
Km 95+100 KPH KPH KPHTan ThanhCBP 0,040 0,040 0,040 Km88+300 to Km88+500 0,032 0,034 0,033 Km104+900 to Km105+350 0,017 0,019 0,018 Km106+500 to Km107+600 0,022 0,022 0,022 Km106+800 0,016 0,018 0,017
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
386
December
Noise measuring
Vibration measuring
PACKAGE A5
October
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding
value Working shift
6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km 117+050 N1 9 / 10 / 2012 54.1 41.4 55 45 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for extremely quiet areas (QCVN
26:2010/BTNMT) - Noise primarily generated from the vehicle the vehicles or motorbike but constructional equipment Weather condition: Sunny, average temperature 23.7ºC, wind speed 1.2 m/s. North-East wind direction
MonitoringValue (dBA) Standard Value (dBA)Station 6h-10h 10h-14h 14h -18h 6h - 21h
Km 91+150 50 52 53
70
Km 95+100 67 69 68 Tan ThanhCBP 63 67 65 Km88+300 to Km88+500 66 69 68 Km104+900 to Km105+350 60 64 64 Km106+500 to Km107+600 60 62 63 Km106+800 50 52 53
Station Min. Value Max. Value Average Value Standard Value (mg/m3)
Km 91+150 KPH KPH KPH
0,055
Km 95+100 KPH KPH KPHTan ThanhCBP 0,042 0,040 0,041 Km88+300 to Km88+500 0,036 0,034 0,035 Km104+900 to Km105+350 0,015 0,015 0,015 Km106+500 to Km107+600 0,024 0,024 0,024 Km106+800 0,019 0,017 0,018
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
387
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding value
Working shift 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km118+820 N2 9 / 10 / 2012 62.9 51.3 70 55 Km121+433 N3 9 / 10 / 2012 67.3 51.4 70 55 - -
- The value of noise level referred to standards applied for commerce, office, industry area. - Noise primarily generated
Weather condition: Sunny, average temperature 23.7ºC, wind speed 1.2 m/s. North-East wind direction
November
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding
value Working shift
6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km 117+050 N1 19 / 11 / 2012 53.2 43.5 55 45 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for extremely quiet areas (QCVN
26:2010/BTNMT) - Noise primarily generated from the vehicle the vehicles or motorbike but constructional equipment Weather condition: Sunny, average temperature of 20.1, windy speed 0.8 m/s. North-East windy direction
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding value
Working shift 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km118+820 N2 19 / 11 / 2012 62.4 52.1 70 55 Km121+433 N3 19 / 11 / 2012 64.2 50.2 70 55 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for commerce, office, industry area. - Noise primarily generated Weather condition: Sunny, average temperature of 20.1, windy speed 0.8 m/s. North-East windy direction
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
388
December
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding
value Working shift
6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km 117+050 N1 14 / 12 / 2012 52,7 43,2 55 45 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for extremely quiet areas (QCVN
26:2010/BTNMT) - Noise primarily generated from the vehicle the vehicles or motorbike but constructional equipment
Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding value
Working shift 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km118+820 N2 14 / 12 / 2012 65,2 53,2 70 55 Km121+433 N3 14 / 12 / 2012 63,1 46,3 70 55 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for commerce, office, industry area. - Noise primarily generated
Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Notes:
According to Environmental Monitoring Plan approved by the Engineer through the letter Ref.
GET3-KEANGNAM-11-A5-037 dated 28th March, 2011, the contractor carries out the
Environment monitoring with frequency: 1 time / 1 month.
N1: Sampling points are close to Bao Long Church area (Km117+050): (GPS: N 21.40.269; E 104.53.057)
N2: Sampling points are close to Hop Minh My bridge construction site (Km118+820): (GPS: N 21.40.801; E 104.52.259)
N3: Sampling points are close to National Road bridge construction site (Km121+433): (GPS: N 21.41.609; E 104.51.171)
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
389
PACKAGE A6
December
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding
value
Working shift 6 h – 21h21h – 6h6 h – 21h21h – 6h 6 h – 21h21h – 6h
Km155+360 N1 2 / 12 / 2012 54.9 43.5 55 45 - - Km159+400 N2 2 / 12 / 2012 50.7 42.9 55 45 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for extremely quiet areas (QCVN
26:2010/BTNMT)
Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Station Sensitive Receptors
SamplingDate & Time,
weather condition
Result (dB) (average) QCVN 26:2010 Exceeding
value Working shift
6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h 6 h – 21h 21h – 6h
Km162+800 N3 2 / 12 / 2012 58.4 46.2 70 55 Km165+300 N4 2 / 12 / 2012 61.6 50.6 70 55 - - - The value of noise level referred to standards applied for commerce, office, industry area. - Noise primarily generated
Weather condition: Sunny, light wind
Notes:
According to Environmental Monitoring Plan approved by the Engineer through the letter Ref.
Ref. GET3-DOOSAN-11-A6-139 dated 16th April, 2011, the contractor carries out the
Environment monitoring with frequency: 1 time / 3 month.
N1: Sampling points are close to Tan Hop Church area (Km155+360) – X (m): 2.423.253 – Y (m): 461.635
N2: Sampling points are close to Tan Hop Primary School area (Km159+400) – X (m): 2.425.610 – Y (m): 458.440
N3: Sampling points are close to Vinasan’s concrete station (Km162+800) – X (m): 2.428.188 – Y (m): 456.100
N4: Sampling points are close to White stone vina’s concrete station (Km165+300) – X (m): 2.430.266 – Y (m): 455.303
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
390
PACKAGE A7
November
Noise monitoring results
Location Sample Sampling Date & Time, weather condition
Noise (dBA) Leq Lmax L50
Km192+420 01 9h00 – 10h00. 15/10/2012 57.0 78.2 49.6 Km198+400 02 14h00-15h00. 16/10/2012 67.4 84.6 61.9 Km199+260 03 13h00-14h00. 15/10/2012 62.2 79.3 57.6 Km191+353 04 8h00-9h00. 15/10/2012 61.1 83.2 51.4 Km203+400 05 16h00-17h00. 15/10/2012 65.9 85.0 55.7 Km205+500 06 8h00-9h00. 16/10/2012 66.7 85.8 59.0 Km210+680 07 11h00-12h00. 16/10/2012 64.9 85.9 59.2 Km194+670 08 10h00-11h00. 15/10/2012 61.8 79.9 54.5 Km203+420 09 15h00-16h00. 15/10/2012 65.9 81.8 62.3 Km206+000 10 9h00-10h00. 16/10/2012 65.5 88.2 56.7 Km199+800 11 14h00-15h00. 15/10/2012 57.1 82.0 54.3 Km209+300 12 10h00-11h00. 16/10/2012 64.6 84.1 52.4 Km211+500 13 13h00-14h00. 16/10/2012 65.9 81.8 62.3 Km197+080 14 11h00-12h00. 15/10/2012 65.5 88.2 56.7
TCVN 5949:1998 70 - -
Vibration Monitoring Results
Location Sample Sampling Date & Time, weather condition Laeq (m/s2) Lveq (m/s) Frequency
(Hz) Km192+420 01 9h00 – 10h00. 15/10/2012 0.000889 0.000271 8Hz Km198+400 02 14h00-15h00. 16/10/2012 0.001157 0.000229 8Hz Km199+260 03 13h00-14h00. 15/10/2012 0.001114 0.000221 8Hz Km191+353 04 8h00-9h00. 15/10/2012 0.000981 0.000196 8Hz Km203+400 05 16h00-17h00. 15/10/2012 0.001072 0.000213 8Hz Km205+500 06 8h00-9h00. 16/10/2012 0.001152 0.001015 8Hz Km210+680 07 11h00-12h00. 16/10/2012 0.001107 0.000220 8Hz Km194+670 08 10h00-11h00. 15/10/2012 0.001283 0.000255 8Hz Km203+420 09 15h00-16h00. 15/10/2012 0.001072 0.000213 8Hz Km206+000 10 9h00-10h00. 16/10/2012 0.001152 0.001015 8Hz Km199+800 11 14h00-15h00. 15/10/2012 0.001333 0.000265 8Hz Km209+300 12 10h00-11h00. 16/10/2012 0.001727 0.002561 8Hz Km211+500 13 13h00-14h00. 16/10/2012 0.001483 0.000295 8Hz
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
391
Location Sample Sampling Date & Time, weather condition Laeq (m/s2) Lveq (m/s) Frequency
(Hz) Km197+080 14 11h00-12h00. 15/10/2012 0.00155 0.000309 8Hz
TCVN 6962:2001 0.055
Note:
01: Xuan Sang 1 Primary School, Xuan Sang 1 Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van ban District (coordinates N: 22007,895’; E:104023,844’)
02: Concrete mixing plant No,1, Ngam Thin Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22009,615’; E:104020,459’)
03: Concrete mixing plant No,2, Dap Tran Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22009,249’; E:104020,751’)
04: Bridge girder casting yard, Xuan Sang 2 Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22007,442’; E:104024,026’)
05: Equipment gathering yard, worker’s living area, Khe U Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22011,545’; E:104019,420’)
06: Cam Con Primary School, Khe Mai Hamlet, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22012,167’; E:104018,523’)
07: Cam Con Health Center, Tan Tien Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22014,142’; E:104016,553’)
08: Drainage casting yard No,1, Khe Quat Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22008,585’; E:104022,537’)
09: Khe U Primary School, Khe U Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22011,604’; E:104019,474’)
10: Residential areas at the right side of project road, Ban Ly Hamlet, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22012,217’; E:104018,563’)
11: Tan Thuong Secondary School, Khe Tep Hamlet, Tan Thuong Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N: 22011,021’; E:104020,370’)
12: Drainage casting yard No,2, Bong 1 Hamlet, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22013,532’; E:104016,995’)
13: Cam Con Secondary School, Hamlet 2, Cam Con Commune, Bao Yen District (coordinates N: 22014,380’; E:104016,388’)
14: Tan An Kinder Garden, Tan Duong Hamlet, Tan An Commune, Van Ban District (coordinates N:
22009,511’; E:104021,960’)
PACKAGE A8
November
Noise measuring
Location Sampling Site Sampling Date & Time, weather condition
Noise (dBA) Leq Lmax L50
Km219+800 01 9h30, 14/11/2012 55,3 66,0 59,5 Km222+580 02 10h30, 14/11/2012 55,7 63,0 58,3 Km224+396 03 11h30, 14/11/2012 62,7 70,2 66,9 Km233+540 04 13h, 14/11/2012 60,9 63,8 66,9
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
392
Location Sampling Site Sampling Date & Time, weather condition
Noise (dBA) Leq Lmax L50
Km231+910 05 14h, 14/11/2012 65,8 78,5 72,6 Km239+560 06 15h, 14/11/2012 53,3 67,1 58,4 Km244+570 07 16h, 14/11/2012 60,3 73,1 67,7 Km218+040 08 8h30, 14/11/2012 55,6 62,8 57,7
QCVN 26:2010/BTNMT 70 - -
Vibration measuring
Location Sampling Site Sampling Date & Time, weather condition Lva (m/s2) Lv (m/s) Frequency
(Hz) Km219+800 01 9h30, 14/11/2012 0,00336 0,00142 1-80 Km222+580 02 10h30, 14/11/2012 0,00134 0,00063 1-80 Km224+396 03 11h30, 14/11/2012 0,00626 0,00300 1-80 Km233+540 04 13h, 14/11/2012 0,00765 0,00283 1-80 Km231+910 05 14h, 14/11/2012 0,00393 0,01125 1-80 Km239+560 06 15h, 14/11/2012 0,00137 0,00072 1-80 Km244+570 07 16h, 14/11/2012 0,00105 0,00121 1-80 Km218+040 08 8h30, 14/11/2012 0,00213 0,00072 1-80
QCVN 27:2010/BTNMT 0,055
Note:
L1, L2, L3: Times measuring during 01 hour, 10 minutes measured each time.
N-01: Near the starting point of project, Sonha primary School -No 2, Anthang branch (GPS: X:
0444531; Y: 2465155);
N-02: Sonha primary School -No 2. Sonha commune (GPS: X: 0442464; Y: 2467044);
N-03: Near Nangsom pre-school, near gate of Kheden village. Sonha commune (GPS: X: 0440998; Y:
2468266);
N-04: Xuangiao road junction (GPS: X: 0434010; Y: 2471438);
N-05: Xuangiao High school - Langpheo branch (GPS: X: 0434757; Y: 2470841);
N-06: Giaphu primary School -No 3 (GPS: X: 0428723; Y: 2474576);
N-07: Point of intersection with Binhminh road (IC 18) near petrol station (GPS: X: 0425479; Y:
2478816);
N-08: The concrete mixing plant (GPS: X: 0445364; Y: 2463930).
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
393
ANNEX 3: DOCUMENTATION RECEIVED FROM CONTRACTORS DURING THE PERIOD
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
394
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
395
DOCUMENTS RECEIVED FROM CONTRACTORS DURING THE THIRD QUARTER 2012 PACKAGE CONTRACTOR REFERENCE DESIGNATION REV APPROVED
A1 POSCO POS-A1-SS-293/2012
Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – October, 2012
1 Yes
A1 POSCO POS-A1-SS-326/2012
Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – November, 2012
1 Yes
A1 POSCO POS-A1-SS-353/2012 Proposal of Landscaping Material 1 Yes
A1 POSCO POS-A1-SS-373/2012
Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – December, 2012
1 Yes
A2 POSCO POS-A2-SS-402/2012 Proposal of Grass sodding material – 1st source 1 Yes
A2 POSCO POS-A2-SS-439/2012 Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – October 2012 1 Yes
A2 POSCO POS-A2-SS-488/2012
Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – November 2012
1 Yes
A2 POSCO POS-A2-SS-437/2012 Proposal of Landscaping Material 1 Yes
A2 POSCO POS-A2-SS-551/2012
Report on Environmental Monitoring and Analysis – December 2012
1 Yes
A3 POSCO POS A3-SS-532/2012 Environmental monitoring report for September - 2012 1 Yes
A3 POSCO POSA3-SS-530/2012 Submission of disposal area No.12 for section 1 1 Yes
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
396
DOCUMENTS RECEIVED FROM CONTRACTORS DURING THE THIRD QUARTER 2012 PACKAGE CONTRACTOR REFERENCE DESIGNATION REV APPROVED
A3 POSCO POS A3-SS-623/2012 Environmental monitoring report in October - 2012 1 Yes
A3 POSCO POS A3-SS-623/2012 Environmental monitoring report for November - 2012 1 Yes
A4 KEANGNAM KNEA4-GET-2012-586 Environmental monitoring report for September - 2012 1 Yes
A4 KEANGNAM KNEA4-GET-2012/674 Environmental monitoring report for October- 2012 1 Yes
A4 KEANGNAM KNEA4-GET-2013/007 Environmental monitoring report for November - 2012 1 Yes
A5 KEANGNAM KNE-NBLC5-VEC&GET-12-680 Report on Environmental monitoring of September 2012 1 Yes
A5 KEANGNAM KNE-NBLC5-VEC&GET-12-735 Method Statement for sodding 1 No
A5 KEANGNAM KNE-NBLC5-VEC&GET-12-781 Report on Environmental monitoring of October 2012 1 Yes
A5 KEANGNAM KNE-NBLC3-VEC&GET-12-789 Documents of disposal areas; 1 Yes
A5 KEANGNAM KNE-NBLC5-VEC&GET-12-441
Report document for the Propose Disposal areas for Huong Giang company 138+000 – Km139+000 1 No
A5 KEANGNAM KNE-NBLC5-VEC&GET-12-873 Report on Environmental monitoring of November 2012 1 Yes
A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-056 Environmental monitoring plan of package A6 in October 2012 1 Yes
A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-057 Submission of Environmental monitoring report for September 2012 1 Yes
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
397
DOCUMENTS RECEIVED FROM CONTRACTORS DURING THE THIRD QUARTER 2012 PACKAGE CONTRACTOR REFERENCE DESIGNATION REV APPROVED
A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-058 Request for Approval of new disposal areas (sub-section 1-1b) 1 No A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-059 Weekly tunnel safety checklist (Period: 13rd – 19th October, 2012) 1 Yes A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-061 Request for Approval of new disposal areas (sub-section 2-4) 1 Yes A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-062 Submission of Environmental monitoring report for October 2012 1 Yes A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-063 Request for Approval of new disposal areas (sub-section 3-1) 1 Yes A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-064 Environmental monitoring plan of package A6 in November 2012 1 Yes
A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-070 Submission of Environmental monitoring report for November 2012 1 Yes
A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-072 Environmental monitoring plan of package A6 in December 2012 1 Yes
A6 DOOSAN DHIC-12-SET-073 Submission of Environmental monitoring report for December 2012 1 Yes
A7 GRBCC Ref.GRBCC/GETINSA/A7/1400
Submitting Environmental Monitoring Report on construction stage (phase8)– October 2012
A1 Yes
A7 GRBCC Ref.GRBCC/GETINSA/A7/1340
Propose to approve document of Asphalt mixing plant Km203+300
A1 Yes
A7 GRBCC Ref.GRBCC/GETINSA/A7/1370
Propose to approve document of Asphalt mixing plant Km195+800
A2 Yes
A7 GRBCC Ref.GRBCC/GETINSA/A7/1382
Submitting summarize Environmental licenses of mixing plants A1 Yes
A8 VINACONEX A8/LC/121204-02 Report Environmental Monitoring on construction stage phase 9 – November 2012
1 Yes
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
398
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
399
ANNEX 4: STATUS OF THE DOCUMENTATION RELATED TO BORROW PITS, QUARRIES, SOIL DISPOSALS AND CONCRETE BATCHING PLANTS
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
400
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
401
Note: a – For public lands, indicate whether it is the property of the commune, district, province, etc. b – Indicate the beneficial use of the property before it was acquired for the project (e.g., rice field, acacia plantation, etc.). If none, provide a short
description, e.g., grassland, abandoned/idle farm lot, etc. c – Specify which government agency (e.g., District People’s Committee) issued the approval, including any written agreement between the contractor
and the land owner
Package A1
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A1/BP6Minh Tri and Minh Phu Commune, Soc Son District, Hanoi city
832,862 Industrialcrop land 31-Aug-09 31-Aug-09
A1/BP16
La Mai Hill, Huong Son Commune, Binh Xuyen District, Vinh Phuc Province
606,590 Industrialcrop land 06-May-10 27-Apr-10 06-May-10 27-May-13
A1/BP17
Go De Hill, Huong Son Commune, Binh Xuyen District, Vinh Phuc Province
263,290 Industrialcrop land 06-May-10 27-Apr-10 06-May-10 27-May-13
A1/BP21Dong Mo Hill, Nam Son Commune, Soc Son District, Hanoi City
492,800 Industrialcrop land 25-Mar-11 01-Nov-10 25-Mar-11 30-Nov-15
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
402
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A1/SG1
Go De Hill, Huong Son Commune, Binh Xuyen District, Vinh Phuc Province
100,000 Industrialcrop land 13-Jan-11 27-Apr-10 13-Jan-11 27-May-13
A1/SG4
Dong Giang Hill, Trung My Commune, Binh Xuyen District, Vinh Phuc Province
90,000 Industrialcrop land 22-Mar-12 27-Apr-10 22-Mar-12 27-May-13
QUARRIES
Package / Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A1/Q1 Quang Son commune, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc
123,000 2,611,729 Rock-mine 13-Dec-11 08-Apr-10 13-Dec-11 17-Apr-25
A1/Q2 Trung Mau commune, Binh Xuyen dist, Vinh Phuc
640,000 75,187,000 Rock-mine 13-Dec-11 21-Jul-04 13-Dec-11 30-Jun-14
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A1/SD1
Trung Mau village, Trung My commune, Binh Xuyen district, Vinh Phuc province
200,000m2
200,000m3
Hoang Chi Thanh Hoang Van Ngoc
Dong Ich hamlet, Trung My commune, Binh Xuyen dist, Vinh Phucs
Borrow pits 20-Dec-10 06-Dec-10 20-Dec-10
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
403
BATCHING PLANTS
Package/CBP No. Location Appropriate
settling pond Noise and
dustmeasures
Ownershipa PriorLand Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A1/CBP1 Underpass NH2 Yes Yes Evernew Holding., JSC
A24-BT4, My Dinh commune, Tu Liem dist, Hanoi
Unidentified 10-May-11 Unidentified 10-May-11
A1/CBP2 Underpass NH2 Yes Yes Ngoc Mai Construct-ion., JSC
Tho Dan village, Kim No commune, Dong Anh dist, Hanoi
Unidentified 29-Jun-11 Unidentified 29-Jun-11
A1/CBP3 Km 13+500 Yes Yes POSCO
POSCO E&C – Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway project – Huu thu village, Kim Long commune, Tam Duong dist, Vinh Phuc
Pond 27-Jan-10 05-May-08 27-Jan-10
A1/CBP4 Km 25+000 Yes Yes POSCO
POSCO E&C – Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway project – Huu thu village, Kim Long commune, Tam Duong dist, Vinh Phuc
Long term cropland 27-Jan-10 05-May-08 27-Jan-10
Package A2
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A2/BP4
Chay Hill, Vinh Phu village, Hop Hoa town, Tam Duong District, Vinh Phuc Province
327,167 Industrialcrop land 01-Apr-10 29-Dec-09 01-Apr-10 29-Dec-12
A2/BP5Rung Nen hill, Thanh Van-Dao Tu Commune, Tam Duong District,
508,467 Industrialcrop land 01-Apr-10 23-Mar-10 01-Apr-10 30-Apr-13
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
404
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
Vinh Phuc Province
A2/BP7
Nhon Huc & Go Bep Hill, Tu Yen Commune, Song Lo District, Vinh Phuc Province
941,590 Industrialcrop land 15-Nov-10 01-Oct-10 15-Nov-10 01-Oct-13
A2/BP11
Quan Hill, Phu Ninh Commune, Phu Ninh District, Phu Tho Province
297,000 Industrialcrop land 01-Jun-12 19-May-10 01-Jun-12 19-May-12
A2/BPSG1
Rung Nen hill, Thanh Van-Dao Tu Commune, Tam Duong District, Vinh Phuc Province
508,467 Industrialcrop land 19-May-12 23-Mar-10 19-May-12 30-Apr-13
A2/BPSG5 Dinh Chua Hill, Tien Lu Commune, Lap Thach District, Vinh Phuc Province
623,837 Industrialcrop land 09-Jul-12 18-Oct-10 09-Jul-12 18-Oct-12
QUARRIES
Package / Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A2/Q1 Quang Son commune, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc
123,000 2,611,729 Rock-mine 13-Dec-11 08-Apr-10 13-Dec-11 17-Apr-25
A2/Q2 Trung Mau commune, Binh Xuyen dist, Vinh Phuc
640,000 75,187,000 Rock-mine 13-Dec-11 21-Jul-04 13-Dec-11 30-Jun-14
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
405
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A2/SD1
Fields 99 and 99(1), map No. 21, Cau hamlet, Hoang Dan commune, Tam Duong district, Vinh Phuc province
9,110 m2 30,000 m3 Hoa Hung Co.,Ltd
Hoang Dan commune, Tam Duong dist, Vinh Phuc
Privateland 12-Jul-10 09-Jul-10 12-Jul-10
A2/SD2Tu Du commune, Lap Thach district, Vinh Phuc province
60,000 m2 60,000 m3 Tu Du commune
Tu Du CPC, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc Wild land 04-Jun-10 Mar-10 04-Jun-10
A2/SD3
Dong Go area, map No. 07, Tien Lu commune, Lap Thach district, Vinh Phuc province
2,000 m2 4,000 m3 Tien Lu commune
Tien Lu CPC, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc Wild land 04-Jun-10 28-May-10 04-Jun-10
A2/SD4
Dong Ai area, map No. 19, Tien Lu commune, Lap Thach district, Vinh Phuc province
12,000 m2 24,000 m3 Tien Lu commune
Tien Lu CPC, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc
Agriculturalland (re-settlementarea)
04-Jun-10 28-May-10 04-Jun-10
A2/SD5
Field No. 155, map No. 12, Phu Thinh village, Tu Yen commune, Song Lo district, Vinh Phuc province
5,566 m2 11,132 m3 Tu Yen commune
Tu Yen CPC, Song Lo dist, Vinh Phuc Wet land 20-May-10 11-May-10 20-May-10
A2/SD6
Map No. 38, Khan Tat hill, Dao Tu commune, Tam Duong district, Vinh Phuc province
10,300 m2 10,300 m3 Ly Van Hung Dao Tu commune, Tam Duong, Vinh Phuc Borrow pit 31-Mar-10 25-Mar-10 31-Mar-10
A2/SD7
Field No. 1, map No. 3, Bo U hill, Dao Tu commune, Tam Duong district, Vinh Phuc province
9,400 m2 9,400 m3 Nguyen Anh Chien
Dao Tu commune, Tam Duong, Vinh Phuc Borrow pit 31-Mar-10 25-Mar-10 31-Mar-10
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
406
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A2/SD8
Field No. 185, Dong Ich commune, Lap Thach district, Vinh Phuc province
30,560 m2 30.560 m3 Dong Ich commune
Dong Ich CPC, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc Wild land 17-Mar-10 08-Mar-10 17-Mar-10
A2/SD9
Field No. 613, Dong Ich commune, Lap Thach district, Vinh Phuc province
10,345 m2 10,345 m3 Dong Ich commune
Dong Ich CPC, Lap Thach dist, Vinh Phuc Wild land 17-Mar-10 08-Mar-10 17-Mar-10
A2/SD10
Field No. 78, Gian village, Cao Phong commune, Song Lo district, Vinh Phuc province
3,268 m2 6,536 m3 Nguyen Van Luu
Cap Phong commune, Song Lo dist, Vinh Phuc
ONT, CLN (rural land and long termcropland)
25-Mar-10 20-Mar-10 25-Mar-10
A2/SD11
Fields No. 337, 475, 481, Dong Hang Phien village, Dong Thinh commune, Song Lo district, Vinh Phuc province
13,863 m2 100,000m3
Dong Thinh commune
Dong Thich CPC, Dong Thinh commune, Song Lo dist, Vinh Phuc
18-Mar-10 Mar-10 18-Mar-10
BATCHING PLANTS
Package/CBP No. Location Appropriate
settling pondNoise and
dustmeasures
OwnershipaPrior Land
UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A2/CBP1 Km 39+118 Yes Yes Vinh Sinh Co.,Ltd
160 – Dinh Dong – Le Chan dist, Hai Phong City
Agriculturalland 17-Nov-10 Unidentified 17-Nov-10
A2/CBP2 Lo River Bridge Yes Yes POSCO
POSCO E&C – Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway project – Huu thu village, Kim Long commune, Tam Duong dist, Vinh Phuc
Agriculturalland 15-Jun-11 05-May-08 15-Jun-11
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
407
BATCHING PLANTS
Package/CBP No. Location Appropriate
settling pondNoise and
dustmeasures
OwnershipaPrior Land
UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A2/CBP3 Lo River Bridge Yes Yes POSCO
POSCO E&C – Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway project – Huu thu village, Kim Long commune, Tam Duong dist, Vinh Phuc
Wild land 25-Jun-11 05-May-08 25-Jun-11
Package A3
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A3/BPX1
Hill: Bo Gia, Bo O (Km 52+500) 28,500 220,000 Kim Duc
Commune
POSA3-CT-01 Forest Zone 2/20/2012
Phu Tho ProvincePeoplecommittee
10/17/2011 12/31/2012 Lang Nga Hill (Km 53+700) 50,000 300,000 Tien Kien
Commune
Bong Xa Hill (Km 54+000) 29,000 200,000 Tien Kien Commune
A3/BPX2Electric pole hill - Phu Ho commune, Phu Tho Town (Km 64+000)
328,295 Phu Ho Commune POSA3-CT-26 Forest Zone 1-Mar-12
Phu Tho Peoplecommittee
23-Mar-12 31-Dec-12
A3/BPX4Thung mountain - Dong Thanh Commune, Thanh Ba District (Km 72 + 300)
26,668 135,000DongThanhCommune
POSA3-CT-12 Garden Zone 13-Aug-09 Phu Tho Peoplecommittee
11-Mar-11 31-May-12
A3/BPX5
Hill: Ho Den, Nuong Thang, Nha Coc - Thanh Xa commune, Thanh Ba District (Km 76 + 400)
83,528 304,014 Thanh Xa Commune POSA3-CT-33 Garden Zone 26-Apr-12
Phu Tho Peoplecommittee
7-Mar-11 31-Dec-12
A3/BPX6 Hill: Nuong Phe, Ong 126,320 950,000 Thanh Nga POSA3-CT-34 Forest Zone 14/5/2012 Phu Tho 14-May-12 31-Dec-12
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
408
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
Duoc, Nuong Dieu, Nuong Son, Nha Vam, Ca - Thanh Nga Commune, Cam Khe District (Km 81+000)
Commune People committee
QUARRIES
Package/ Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A3/Q1 Hang Nuoc mountain - for blinding stone material
54,000 105,000 Huong Can Commune
Thanh Cong Company Mountain 8-Jul-08
Phu Tho PeopleCommittee
25-Nov-10 31-Dec-13
A3/Q2
Khuon Giang & Hang Hut Mountain - for subbase and base course material
96,890 2,325,360 Son Duong District
FOMICO Company Mountain 1-Jun-09
Tuyen QuangPeoplecommittee
A3/Q3 Quang Son Mountain - for subbase and base course material
165,400 2,611,729 Lap Thach District Hung Vi Company Mountain 8-Apr-10
Vinh Phuc Peoplecommittee
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
OwnershipaPrior Land
Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A3/SD1 DA Km 53+360 3,200 14,400 Nguyen van Hoa, Nguyen Van Chung Garden 3-Jun-10 Engineer 13-Jun-10 30-Nov-12
A3/SD2 DA in Kim Duc Commune 14,080 181,000 2/16/2011 Engineer 2/18/2011 10/30/2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
409
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
OwnershipaPrior Land
Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
No.1 - Km49+500 2,350 46,000 Le Van Ngu
No.2 - Km49+600 1,954 37,000 Nguyen Tien Dung
No.3 - Km 50+900 2,146 29,000 Le Dinh Chat
No.4 - Km51+400 1,940 35,000 Nguyen Thi Ly
No.5 - Km 52+800 5,690 34,000 Nguyen Thi Tuat
A3/SD3
DA in Hung Lo Commune 53,489 500,000
4/22/2011 Engineer 4/26/2011 11/30/2012
Area No. 8 25,602
500,000
Nguyen Xuan Thuong
Area No. 8 6,612 Nguyen Van Sang
Area No. 8 1,860 Cao Van Chinh
Area No. 8 6,239 Cao Van Duong
Area No. 8 13,176 Cao Van Minh
Area No. 12 6084 50.000 Nguyen Van Bay Garden 30-Nov-12 Engineer 19-Sep-12 The end of the project
A3/SD4 DA in Phu NinhDistrict 21,000 147,000 Phu Ninh Commune 13-Oct-10 Engineer 14-Oct-10 31-Dec-12
A3/SD5 DA in Tien Kien Commune 15,724 94,344 Nguyen Cong Chuc 4-Nov-11 Engineer 10-Nov-11 31-Dec-12
A3/SD6 DA in Phu Ho Commune 25,000 150,000 Nguyen Van Thai 25-Feb-11 Engineer 27-Feb-11 15-Jun-12
A3/SD7 DA in Van Lung Commune 11,508 69,500 Van Lung Commune 13-Oct-10 Engineer 18-Oct-10 31-Aug-12
A3/SD8 DA in Vo Lao Commune 12,850 89,950 Dinh Tien Minh 6-Sep-10 Engineer 9-Sep-10 31-May-12
A3/SD9DA in Chi Tien & Hoang Cuong Commune
13,170 92,190 Tran Quy Cuong 19-Aug-10 Engineer 21-Aug-10 31-Dec-12
A3/SD10 DA Yen Tap Comm 10,280 100,000 17-Aug-12 Engineer 19-Aug-12 19-Aug-14
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
410
BATCHING PLANTS
Package/ SD No. Location
Appropriate settling pond
Noise and dust
measures
OwnershipaPrior Land
UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A3/CBP1 Batching Plant D Yes Yes Thien Tan Company B33-10/HDKT N/A 5-Nov-10 Engineer 6-Nov-10 30-Sep-13
A3/CBP2 Batching Plant E Yes Yes
A3/CBP3 Bai Bang Batching Plant Yes Yes Song Lo Construction
company POSA3-CT-029 N/A 13-Aug-10 Engineer 14-Aug-10 30-Sep-13
A3/CBP4 Song Hong 1 Batching Plant Yes Yes
Cienco 4 Company POSA3-CT-019 N/A 6-Jun-11 Engineer 6-Jun-11 30-Sep-13
A3/CBP5 Song Hong 2 Batching Plant Yes Yes 16-Nov-11 Engineer 16-Nov-11 30-Sep-13
Package A4
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume (m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A4/BP1
Hill Th , zone 10, Xuan Ang commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
39,000 473,277.7 Xuan Ang Commune
Mr Tuan. Xuan Ang President
Artificial forest land, farm land…
27 June 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
27 June 2012
4th Quarter 2013
A4/BP2
Hill S t, zone 1, Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
34,000 93,180 Quan Khe Commune
Mr Tuoc. Quan Khe president
Artificial forest land, farm land…
26 June 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
26 June 2012
4th Quarter 2013
A4/BP3
Hill Bóng a, zone 3, Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
36,000 193,909 Quan Khe Commune
Mr Tuoc. Quan Khe president
Artificial forest land, farm land…
26 June 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
26 June 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
411
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume (m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A4/BP4Quyet Tien commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
45,400 292,012 Hien Luong Commune
Mr Nguyen. Hien Luong president.
Artificial forest land, farm land…
26 June 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
26 June 2012
4th Quarter 2013
A4/BP5
Hill Lau, zone 5, Vo Tranh commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
16,800 156,423 Vo Tranh Commune
Mr Thinh. Vo Tranh President
Artificial forest land, farm land…
23 Apr 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
23 Apr 2012
4th Quarter 2013
A4/BP6
Hill Tr ng, zone 1, Hien Luong commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
55,000 864,270 Hien Luong Commune
Mr Nguyen. Hien Luong president.
Artificial forest land, farm land…
23 Apr 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
23 Apr 2012
4th Quarter 2013
QUARRIES
Package / Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A4/Q1 Quan Khe commune, Ha Hoa district, Phu Tho province.
92,000 1,128,000 Quan Khe Commune
Mr Tuoc. Quan Khe president
Living land, Rice field, fruit plantation, grave area.
19 June 2012
Phu Tho ProvincialPeople’sCommittee
Novem-ber 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
412
SPOIL DISPOSAL AREAS
SD No. Location Approved
Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
Xa Minh Coi, Ha Hoa
1 Km 90+080 1266.2 16400 Nguyen Thi Rang Pending Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
2 Km 90+220 111.02 2500 Bui Van Nhu Pending Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
3 Km 90+220 637.6 12250 Nguyen Y Nguyen Ward 7, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
4 Km 90+280 453.6 8200 Nguyen Viet Hung Pending Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
5 Km 91+200 172.8 12000 Le Quang Thang Pending Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
6 Km 92+000 850 16369 Phung Thi Khoa Ward 5, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
7 Km 92+100 702.1 11200 Nguyen Van Giao Ward 1, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
8 Km 92+510 504.2 6000 Nguyen Van Cuong
Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
9 Km 92+600 522.2 6500 Nguyen Van Cuong
Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
413
SPOIL DISPOSAL AREAS
SD No. Location Approved
Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
10 Km 92+850 822.73 14300 Do Thi Nu Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
11 Km 93+050 376.2 6100 Nguyen Van Thoa Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
12 Km 93+160 687.6 13400 Nguyen Van Thoa Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
13 Km 93+100 326.3 5800 Le Thi Loan Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Fish pond, but not efficient
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
14 Km 93+600 1354.8 18200 Ly Minh Tam Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
15 Km 93+700 650 5350 Nguyen Ba Ngoc Ward 2, Minh Coi Commune, Ha Hoa
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
20 Oct. 2010
Minh Coi Commune
20 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
Xa Bang Gia, Ha Hoa
1 Bai ui 3600 28800 Bang Gia Commune
Mr. Thinh Chairman of Bang Gia Commune
Fish pond 12 Dec. 2010
Bang Gia Commune
12 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
2 Ward 11 3800 11400 Nguyen Van Quan Ward 11, Bang Gia Commune Fish pond 19 Nov.
2010 Bang Gia Commune
19 Nov. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
Xa Vo Tranh, Ha Hoa
1Cap Tien, Ward 6, Vo Tranh
1200 3600 Tran Thien Le Ward 6, Cap Tien, Vo Tranh Commune Fish pond
10January, 2011
Vo Tranh Commune
10January, 2011
4th Quarter 2013
2 Dong Mai, Ward 5 1500 6000 Vo Tranh
Commune Ward 5, Vo Tranh Commune Fish pond
10January, 2011
Vo Tranh Commune
10January, 2011
4th Quarter 2013
Xa Hien Luong, Ha Hoa
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
414
SPOIL DISPOSAL AREAS
SD No. Location Approved
Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
1 Cutural house 1620 3240 Mr Nguyen, Chairman of Hien Luong Commune
Hien Luong Commune
Low elevation, flood area need to raise level
17 Dec. 2010
Hien Luong Commune
17 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
2 Ward 2 1200 1800 Mr Nguyen, Chairman of Hien Luong Commune
Hien Luong Commune
Low elevation, flood area need to raise level
17 Dec. 2010
Hien Luong Commune
17 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
3 Pond of Mrs Hoan, Ward 2 1200 2400 Mrs Hoan Ward 2, Hien Luong
Commune Fish pond 17 Dec. 2010
Hien Luong Commune
17 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
4Old brick productionarea
4000 6000 Dong Trua Au Co Cooperative
Excavated area for brick production needs to be recovered
17 Dec. 2010
Hien Luong Commune
17 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
Xa Quan Khe, Ha Hoa
1Fish pond of Mr. Cuong’s house
690 1244 Nguyen Van Cuong
Ward 1, Quan Khe Commune, Ha Hoa
Fish pond, but not efficient
7 Oct. 2010
Quan Khe Commune
7 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
2Fish pond of Mrs. Oanh’s house, Ward 1
900 2160 Do Thi Oanh Ward 1, Quan Khe Commune, Ha Hoa
Fish pond, but not efficient
7 Oct. 2010
Quan Khe Commune
7 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
3Fish pond of Mr. Chau’s house
624 1560 Do Ngoc Chau Ward 3, Quan Khe Commune, Ha Hoa
Fish pond, but not efficient
7 Oct. 2010
Quan Khe Commune
7 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
4 Pond, Ward 1 5788 36000 Mr Doanh, Chairman of Quan Khe Commune
Quan Khe Commune
Fish pond, but not efficient
7 Oct. 2010
Quan Khe Commune
7 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
5 Dyke, Ward 1 400 23152 Mr Doanh, Chairman of Quan Khe Commune
Quan Khe Commune
Low elevation, flood area, cannot cultivation
7 Oct. 2010
Quan Khe Commune
7 Oct. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
Xa Son Nga, huyen Cam Khe
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
415
SPOIL DISPOSAL AREAS
SD No. Location Approved
Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
1 Km 81+020 800 8000 Nguyen Van Yen Ward 3, Son Nga Commune
Low elevation, need to raise level for cultivation
29 Dec. 2010
Son Nga Commune
29 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
2 Km 81+020 400 2400 Nguyen Minh Duc Ward 3, Son Nga Commune
Low elevation, need to raise level for cultivation
29 Dec. 2010
Son Nga Commune
29 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
3 Km 81+080 240 960 Hoangf Van Ba Ward 3, Son Nga Commune
Low elevation, need to raise level for cultivation
29 Dec. 2010
Son Nga Commune
29 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
4 Km 80+800 2000 20000 Hoa Mai Company Son Nga Commune Backfill for brick production area
29 Dec. 2010
Son Nga Commune
29 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
Xa Phung Xa, huyen Cam Khe
1 Km 82+080 300 600 Nguyen Thi Thung Ward 2, Phung Xa Commune
Pond, and low area, need to
28 Dec. 2010
Phung Xa Commune
28 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
2 Km 82+100 2200 8800
M. Toa, Vice Chairman of Phung Xa Commune
Phung Xa Commune Fill for stadium of the commune
28 Dec. 2010
Phung Xa Commune
28 Dec. 2010
4th Quarter 2013
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / SD No. Location
Appropriate settling pond
Noise and dust
measures
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A4/CBP1 Ha Hoa Bridge Yes Yes Bang Gia
Communce
Mr. Long Chairman of Bang Gia Communce
Pending 1 Jan. 2012
Bang Gia Communce
1 Jan. 2012
1 Jan. 2016
A4/CBP2Zone 4, Minh Coi commune,Ha Hoa
Yes Yes Ho Van Thai 01696.643.932 farm land 14 Dec
2012 Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Nguyen Tien Loi 01686.352.890 farm land 14 Dec 2012
Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
416
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / SD No. Location
Appropriate settling pond
Noise and dust
measures
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
district Nguyen Tuan Hong 0975.247.493 farm land 14 Dec
2012 Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Nguyen Xuan Liem 01689.338.258 farm land 14 Dec 2012
Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Phung Duc Thu 01275.168.096 farm land 14 Dec 2012
Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Tran Van Nhan 0210.6291.937 farm land 14 Dec 2012
Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Nguyen Hong Phuong 01678.814.448 farm land 14 Dec
2012 Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Nguyen Van Sy 01687.147.867 farm land 14 Dec 2012
Minh Coi commune certified
1st Quarter 2012
4th Quarter 2013
Package A5
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / Quarry No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
Completion Actual
Completion
A5/SD1 Km111+740 4,094 14,201 Minh Quan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD2 Km111+680 16,580 59,245 Minh Quan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD3 Km113+100 4,427 29,358 Minh Quan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD4 QL32 9,600 43,790 Minh Quan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD5 Km112+600 19,370 60,750 Minh Quan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD6 Km116+480 1,940 12,731 Bao Hung Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
417
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / Quarry No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
Completion Actual
Completion
A5/SD7 Km125+300 3,566 8,273 Minh Tien Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD8 Km118+755 560 28,528 Bao Hung Commune 9-Oct-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD9 Km119+680 1,560 43,759 Hop Minh Commune 9-Oct-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD10 Km120+180 64,699 Hop Minh Commune 9-Oct-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD11 Km126+620 4,721 Y Kan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD12 Km126+750 2,448 Y Kan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD13 Km129+300 2,427 Y Kan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD14 Km130+620 2,238 11,700 Y Kan Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD15 Km131+840 2,158 28,167 Quy Mong Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD16 Km132+440 2,465 19,720 Quy Mong Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD17 Km133+680 1,875 18,750 Quy Mong Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD18 Km136+320 2,175 32,190 Quy Mong Commune 17-Sep-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD19 Km138+000 6,003 Hoang Thang Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD20 Km136+750 1,980 8,329 Quy Mong Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD21 Km137+420 5,437 45,891 Hoang Thang Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD22 Km137+980 1,244 5,980 Hoang Thang Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD23 Km140+140 13,940 Xuan Ai Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD24 Km141+160 11,681 Xuan Ai Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD25 Km141+240 3,599 Xuan Ai Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD26 Km140+520 6,015 Xuan Ai Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD27 Km140+860 15,826 Xuan Ai Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD28 Km145+000 4,500 26,286 Yen Hop Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
418
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / Quarry No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
Completion Actual
Completion
A5/SD29 Km146+250 3,500 11,584 Yen Hop Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD30 Km146+720 1,734 6,937 Yen Hop Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD31 Km147+200 1,488 11,583 Yen Hop Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD32 Km148+300 1,023 15,000 Yen Hop Commune 27-Aug-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD33 Km111+740 2184 6282 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD34 Km111+740 1280 7919 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD35 Km111+680 2677 6150 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD36 Km111+860 4603 5000 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD37 Km111+800 9300 48095 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD38 Km110+100 9600 43790 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD39 Km110+340 330 1650 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD40 Km110+360 7070 29100 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD41 Km111+670 12000 30000 Minh Quan Commune 28-Nov-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD42 Km148+300 150000 Yen Hop Commune 17-Dec-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD43 Km146+250 11584 Yen Hop Commune 17-Dec-12 Tran Yen GOV
A5/SD44 Km145+000 26286 Yen Hop Commune 17-Dec-12 Tran Yen GOV
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit
No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
Completion Actual
Completion
A5/BP1 Km111+170 120,000 Minh Quan commune Mountain
A5/BP2 Km111+540 130,000 Minh Quan commune Mountain
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
419
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow Pit
No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
Completion Actual
Completion
A5/BP3 Km116+600 33,000 Bao Hung commune Mountain
A5/BP4 Km117+120 37,000 Hop Minh commune Mountain
A5/BP5 Km117+400 15,000 Hop Minh commune Mountain
A5/BP6 Km118+100 20,000 Hop Minh commune Mountain
A5/BP7 Km120+340 10,000 Au Lau commune Mountain
A5/BP8 Km120+860 30,000 Au Lau commune Mountain
A5/BP9 Km121+180 40,000 Au Lau commune Mountain
A5/BP10 Km123+760 20,000 Minh Tien commune Mountain
A5/BP11 Km124+600 80,000 Minh Tien commune Mountain
A5/BP12 Km125+460 35,000 Minh Tien commune Mountain
A5/BP13 Km125+700 25,025 Minh Tien commune Mountain
A5/BP14 Km125+720 30,000 Minh Tien commune Mountain
A5/BP15 Km125+880 100,000 Minh Tien commune Mountain
A5/BP16 Km129+440 130,000 Y Can commune Mountain
A5/BP17 Km129+240 70,000 Y Can commune Mountain
A5/BP18 Km129+160 50,000 Y Can commune Mountain
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
CompletionActual
Completion
A5/CBP1 Km 124+000 Song Hong Concrete JSC
Side Cut of idled land 31/10/201 Tran Yen GOV 17/9/2011
A5/CBP2 Km 136+000 Licogi 15 grass land 31/10/2011 Van Yen GOV 4/12/2011
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
420
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land UsebApproval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
CompletionActual
Completion
A5/CBP3 Km 145+200 Thanh Thu-Bao Tin idled grass land 27/6/2011 Van Yen GOV 10/12/2011
A5/CBPdtx
KCN Dam Hong
Dong Tam Xanh Investment and Construction JSC
commercial lot 26/1/2011 Van Yen GOV 30/7/2011
A5/CBP 4 Km145+100 Trancosin commercial lot 6/10/2012 Van Yen GOV 12/11/2012
Package A6
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package/Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
CompletionActual
Completion
A6/SD1 Disposal Area No.1/Bãi s 1 2,838 54,528 Tan Hop Commune 27-Mar-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD2 Disposal Area No.2/Bãi s 2 985 17,971 Tan Hop Commune 27-Mar-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD3 Mr. Hoa's Garden 1,500 6,000 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD4 Mr. Dung's Garden 3,000 12,000 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD5 Mr. Thang's Garden 3,000 12,000 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD6 Mr. Thuc's Garden 1,200 4,800 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD7 Tan Hop Commune Disposal Area 3,000 12,000 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD8 Mr. Nguyen Duy Thanh's area 28,766 Tan Hop Commune 15-May-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD9 Km 153+700 ~ Km 154+000 (R) Disposal Area No.1 3,018 15,303 Tan Hop Commune 01-Oct-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD10 Mr. Hieu's Garden 2,077 9,347 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
421
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package/Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
CompletionActual
Completion
A6/SD11 Tan hop's Primary School 2,171 9,770 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD12 Tan hop's Children School 6,466 29,097 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD13 Ms. Hien's Garden 7,526 33,867 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD14 Mr. Thong's Garden 3,422 15,399 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD15 Ms. Huong's Garden 6,877 30,947 Tan Hop Commune 11-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD16 Disposal Area No.1 3,752 18,193
A6/SD17 Disposal Area No.2 4,163 30,572
A6/SD18 Disposal Area No.3 2,383 22,253
A6/SD19 Km 157+100 1986 18,412
A6/SD20 Km166+600 3,258 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD21 Km167+300 5,380 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD22 Km168+700 24,318 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD23 Km168+000 11,882 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD24 Km168+050 2,819 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD25 Km165+400 1,317 6,959 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD26 Km165+400 51,127 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD27 Km166+478 20,083 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD28 Km166+688 1,594 7,680 Dong An Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD29 Km175+240 965 3,859 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD30 Km175+460 1,090 4,361 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD31 Km175+720 2,515 10,059 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD32 Km176+200 2,383 9,534 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD33 Km176+560 6,939 27,756 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Jul-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD34 Km167+500 3,333 29,105 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Dec-12 Van Yen GOV
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
422
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package/Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
CompletionActual
Completion
A6/SD35 Km177+500 1,054 9,329 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Dec-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD36 Km177+200 2,422 44,043 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Dec-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD37 Km177+210 1,071 17,617 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Dec-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD38 Km171+200 932 16,888 Chau Que Ha Commune 28-Dec-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD39 Mrs. Vach Disposed Area 488 1,220 Chau Que Ha Commune 26-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD40 Mr. Quang & Khoa Disposed Area 1,980 4,950 Chau Que Ha Commune 26-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD41 Mr. Thang Lien Disposed Area 2,660 6,650 Chau Que Ha Commune 26-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD42 Mr. Viet Disposed Area 380 950 Chau Que Ha Commune 26-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD43 Mr. Vien Disposed Area 1,275 3,188 Chau Que Ha Commune 26-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD44 Mr. Binh Disposed Area 2,922 7,305 Chau Que Ha Commune 26-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD45 Km 184+900 (R) 27,000 Chau Que Thuong Commune
A6/SD46 Km188+200 46,690 162,582 Chau Que Thuong Commune 05-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD47 Km190+110 6,910 17,032 Chau Que Thuong Commune 05-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD48 Km187+300 1,102 15,780 Chau Que Thuong Commune 05-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD49 Km187+900 691 5,404 Chau Que Thuong Commune 05-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD50 Km189+600 1,146 19,898 Chau Que Thuong Commune 05-Oct-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD51 Km187+660 2,446 13,684 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD52 Km188+440 995 5,396 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
423
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package/Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
CompletionActual
Completion
A6/SD53 Km188+600 1,185 4,387 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD54 Km189+600 3,586 14,962 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD55 Km190+140 1,075 18,519 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD56 Km188+400 2,439 14,981 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD57 Km188+500 1,945 12,833 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD58 Km189+200 2,148 18,714 Chau Que Thuong Commune 03-Oct-11 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD59 Km186+145 7,231 96,979 Chau Que Thuong Commune 26-Nov-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD60 Disposal Area No.2/Bãi s 2 19,993 Chau Que Thuong Commune 04-Jun-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD61 Disposal Area No.3/Bãi s 3 480 3,638 Tan Hop Commune 16-Oct-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD62 Disposal Area No.1/Bãi s 1 1,211 Chau Que Ha Commune 31-Oct-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD63 Disposal Area No.2/Bãi s 2 9,781 Chau Que Ha Commune 31-Oct-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD64 Disposal Area No.3/Bãi s 3 17,769 Chau Que Ha Commune 31-Oct-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD65 Disposal Area No.4 51,276 Chau Que Ha Commune 31-Oct-12 Van Yen GOV
A6/SD66 Disposal Area No.1 6,700 66,997 Chau Que Ha Commune 7-Nov-12 Van Yen GOV
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
424
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / Borrow Pit No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
OwnershipaPriorLand Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated
Completion Actual
Completion
A6/CBP1 Km 163 Vinasan 10-Jun-2010 Van Yen GOV
A6/CBP2 Km 165 Whitestone Vina Van Yen GOV
A6/CBP3 Km 180 Whitestone Vina 29-Sep-10 Van Yen GOV
A6/CBP4 Km 185 Whitestone Vina 26-Aug-11 Van Yen GOV
Contractor didn’t provide any information regarding the quarries used for the construction works in Package A6. In this package, no borrow pits
are needed for the construction activities.
Package A7
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow PitNo.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A7/BP1 Km207-Km218+040 30.000 300.000m3
Cam4- Cam Con committee- Bao Yen district- Lao Cai Provice
Hill land 11/5/2011 DONRE OF Lao Cai Provice
30/5/2011 11/10/2011 30/10/2011
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
425
QUARRIES
Package / Quarry No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A7/Q1 Until now, although it was requested several times by the Engineer, Contractor has not provided yet any information about this quarry
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A7/SD1 Km191+600 106.000 1.060.000 Tan An- Van Ban- Lao Cai idle farm lot 19/4/2010
Contact between the contractor and land owner with confirm of communepeople’scommittee
30/4/2010 15/12/2010 30/11/2010
A7/SD2 Km195+800 103.000 1.030.000 Tan An- Van Ban- Lao Cai idle farm lot 19/4/2010 30/4/2010 15/12/2010 30/11/2010
A7/SD3 Km197+200 65.000 260.000 Tan An- Van Ban- Lao Cai idle farm lot 19/4/2010 30/4/2010 15/12/2010 30/11/2010
A7/SD4 Km198+400 8.000 120.000 Tan An- Van Ban- Lao Cai rice field 19/4/2010 30/4/2010 15/12/2010 30/11/2010
A7/SD5 Km203+440 10.000 70.000 Khe U- Tan Thuong- Van Ban- Lao Cai rice field 7/5/2010 30/5/2010 31/12/2011 20/10/2011
A7/SD6 Km203+440 30.000 210.000 Khe U- Tan Thuong- Van Ban- Lao Cai rice field 7/5/2010 30/5/2010 31/12/2011 25/11/2011
A7/SD7 Km206+500 8.000 40.000 Ban Ly- Cam Con- Bao Yen- Lao Cai
acaciaplantation 10/5/2010 25/5/2010 31/12/2011 20/8/2011
A7/SD8 Km205+000 10897.6 54488 Ban Ly2- Cam Con- Bao Yen- Lao Cai idle farm lot 19/5/2010 15/5/2010 31/12/2011 29/9/2011
A7/SD9 Km206+200 3772.3 18861.5 Ban Ly1- Cam Con- Bao Yen- Lao Cai idle farm lot 19/5/2010 15/5/2010 31/12/2011 29/9/2011
A7/SD10 Km209+280 2.848.5 14.242.5 Bong 1- Cam Con- Bao Yen- Lao Cai rice field 1/2/2012
A7/SD11 Km210+360 3.044.6 21.312.2 Tan Tien- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC
rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD12 Km210+360 5.281.9 36.973.3 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD13 Km210+360 2.703.8 18.926.6 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
426
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A7/SD14 Km210+380 3.735 26.145 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD15 Km210+380 1.592.1 11.144.7 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD16 Km210+400 1.800 10.800 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD17 Km216+260 2.010.3 12.061.8
Hong Cam- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC
rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD18 Km216+840 5.760.5 34.563 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD19 Km216+980 3.470.7 22.559.55 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD20 Km217+960 1.549 10.068.5 rice field 1/2/2012 15/2/2012 5/2012
A7/SD21 Km207+000 5.887.3 41.211.1 Tan Thanh- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC rice field 1/2/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD22 Km209+820 2.282.5 15.977.5 Tan Tien- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC rice field 1/2/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD23 Km210+740 151.5 1.090.8
Tan Tien- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC
rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD24 Km210+760 1.500 14.250 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD25 Km210+780 145.3 1.191.46 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD26 Km210+800 1.390 8.618 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD27 Km210+820 1.141 8.215.2 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD28 Km211+200 1.490 11.026 Con2- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD29 Km216+520 9.127 86.706.5
Hong Cam- Cam Con- Bao Yen- LC
rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD30 Km216+520 7.385 66.465 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD31 Km216+640 11.075 110.750 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD32 Km217+080 14.655 131.895 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD33 Km217+280 7.865 86.515 rice field 7/5/2012 20/5/2012 6/2012
A7/SD34 Km189+700 15.555.56 140.000 Hamlet1- Que Thuong- Van Yen- Yen Bai idle farm lot 20/10/2011 1/11/2011 25/3/2012
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
427
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A7/SD35 Km191+350 15.000 120.000 Xuan Sang1-Tan An- Van Ban- Lao Cai idle farm lot 22/10/2011 15/11/201
1 3/2012
A7/SD36 Km199+100 10.769.23 70.000 Cau Thin- Tan Thuong- Van Ban- Lao Cai idle farm lot 21/10/2011 12/11/201
1 3/2012
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / SD No.
Location Appropriate settling pond
Noise and dust
measures
Ownershipa Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A7/CBP1 Km191+353 Settling pond had provided
Khe Sang BCP
Xuan Sang2- Tan An commune - Van Ban District- Lao Cai
Abandoned 7/9/2012 Van Ban District people’scommittee
18/3/2011 25/3/2013
A7/CBP2 Km199+860 Settling pond had provided
TanThuongBCP
Khe Quat- Tan An commune- Van Ban District- Lao Cai
Abandoned 7/9/2012 Van Ban District people’scommittee
14/11/2011 25/3/2013
A7/CBP3 Km198+400 Settling pond had provided
Xom Danh BCP
Ngam Thin- Tan Thuong commune - Van Ban District- Lao Cai
rice field Van Ban District people’scommittee
15/1/2011 25/3/2013
A7/CBP4 Km209+329 Settling pond had provided
Tan Tien BCP
Bong1- Cam Con commune - Bao Yen District- Lao Cai
Hill land Bao Yen District people’scommittee
25/3/2011 25/3/2013
A7/ABP1 Km195+800 Settling pond had provided
TrancosinABP
Tan Son- Tan An- Van Ban- Lao Cai Hill land 7/11/2012
Van Ban District people’scommittee
15/11/2012 25/3/2013
A7/ABP2 Km203+100 Settling pond had provided Trico ABP Tan Thuong- Van
Ban- Lao Cai Hill land 11/10/2012 Van Ban District people’scommittee
14/12/2012 25/3/2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
428
Package A8
BORROW PITS
Package / Borrow PitNo.
Location Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A8/BP1 Km234-Km235 105.000 500.000m3
/year
Hùng Th ng and Dong Cam- Gia Phu Committee- Bao Thang District- Lao Cai Prov.
Hill land 10/01/2011 Lao Cai Prov. people’scommittee
31/01/2011 31/01/2012 12/2011
QUARRIES
Package / Quarry No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Volume
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation Schedule
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Estimated Completion
Actual Completion
A8/Q1 38.800 45.000m3/year
Ban Cam quarry
Ban Cam committee- Bao Thang District- Lao Cai Provice
Hill land 7/4/2011
Lao Cai Provincepeople’scommittee
April-2011 December- 2015
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A8/SD1 Km218+500 2.612 11.754 An Thang- Son Ha- Bao Thang- Lao Cai rice field 20/7/2010
Contactbetween the contractorand land owner with
8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD2 Km222+500 952 1.904 An Hong- Son Ha- Bao Thang- Lao Cai
rice field 20/7/2010 8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD3 Km223+050 1.386 3.465 rice field 20/7/2010 8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD4 Km234+860 10.000 120.000 Tien Loi2- Xuan Giao- Bao Thang- Lao Cai
rice field 10/8/2010 8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD5 Km234+860 2.680 8.000 rice field 10/8/2010 8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD6 Km234+840 10.000 120.000 rice field 10/8/2010 8/2010 11/2010
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
429
SPOILS DISPOSAL AREAS
Package / SD No. Location
Approved Area (m2)
Approved Capacity
(m3)
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A8/SD7 Km237+580 730 1.900 Phu Xuan- Gia Phu- Bao Thang- Lao Cai rice field 20/6/2012
confirm of communepeople’scommittee
1/7/2010 11/2010
A8/SD8 Km237+195 652 2.000
Son Ca- Gia Phu- Bao Thang- Lao Cai
rice field 20/6/2012 1/7/2010 11/2010
A8/SD9 Km237+160 360 1.200 rice field 3/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD10 Km237+060 350 1.255 rice field 20/7/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD11 Km237+060 488 1.200 rice field 28/7/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD12 Km238+500 4.900 7.350
Ben Den- Gia Phu- Bao Thang- Lao Cai
rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD13 Km238+500 300 450 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD14 Km238+500 2.400 3.600 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD15 Km238+500 3.000 7.500 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD16 Km238+500 9.600 19.200 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD17 Km238+500 3.000 6.000 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD18 Km238+500 3.000 6.000 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
A8/SD19 Km238+500 4.00 8.00 rice field 10/8/2010 15/8/2010 11/2010
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / SD No. Location Appropriate
settling pond Noise and
dustmeasures
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A8/CBP1 Km218+040 Settling pond had provided Suoi Nhu BCp
An Thang hamlet, Son Ha commune, Bao Thang, Lao Cai
Abandoned 16/7/2012 Bao Thang District people’s committee
1/4/2011 1/8/2013
A8/CBP2 Km231+889 Settling pond had provided Suoi Trat BCP
Giao Binh hamlet, Xuan Giao commune, Bao Thang, Lao Cai
Hill land 16/7/2012 Bao Thang District people’s committee
11/1/2011 1/8/2013
Loan 2391/2392 – VIE: GMS Kunming – Hai Phong Transport Corridor Noi Bai – Lao Cai Highway Project
430
BATCHING PLANTS
Package / SD No. Location Appropriate
settling pond Noise and
dustmeasures
Ownershipa
Prior Land Useb
Approval Operation
Name Contact Info Date Agencyc Start Est. End Actual End
A8/CBP3 Km238+265 Settling pond had provided Ngoi Bo BCP
Ben Pha hamlet, Gia Phu commune, Bao Thang, Lao Cai
Abandoned 16/7/2012 Bao Thang District people’s committee
24/1/2011 1/8/2013
A8/ABP1 Km238+265 Settling pond had provided
Noise and dustmeasureshadsupportwith plant
Ngoi Bo ABP Ben Pha hamlet, Gia Phu commune, Bao Thang, Lao Cai
Abandoned Not yet Not yet Not yet