8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
1/23
Technical Note
A Global Green New Deal forClimate, Energy, and Development
A big push strategy to
Drive down the cost of renewable energy
Ramp up deployment in developing countries
End energy poverty
Contribute to economic recovery and growth
Generate employment in all countries
and
Help avoid dangerous climate change
UnitedNationsDepartmentofEconomicandSocialAffairs
December2009
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
2/23
i
Acknowledgements
This strategy has been prepared by Alan AtKisson, consultant to the
UnitedNationsDepartmentofEconomicAffairs,withguidancefromJomoK.
Sundaram,AssistantSecretaryGeneral forEconomic and Social Affairs, and
TariqBanuri, DavidOConnor and Ivan Vera of the Division for Sustainable
Development. It is an elaboration of a strategy first spelt out in the
Departments World Economic and Social Survey 2009: Promoting
Development, Saving the Planet, whose principal authors were Richard
KozulWright and Imran Habib Ahmed, under the direction of Rob Vos,
Director,DivisionforPolicyAnalysisandDevelopment.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
3/23
ii
Key Messages
Energyisthekeytoeconomicdevelopment,andrenewableenergyisthe
keytoafuturewithoutdangerousclimatechange.
Butrenewableenergyistooexpensivetoday,especiallyfortheworld's
poor,manyofwhomhavenoaccesstomodernenergyatall.
Althoughthepriceofrenewableenergyisfalling,itwillnotfallfastenough
anywhere,onitsown,tohelptheworldwintheraceagainsttimewith
dangerousclimatechange.
Publicpoliciescanhelpproducethenecessarydeclineintheglobalpriceofrenewableenergyandmakeituniversallyaffordableinonetotwodecades.
Thekeymechanismisarapidincreaseininstalledcapacity.Abigpushin
bothpublicandprivateinvestmenttoscaleuprenewableenergywillleadto
rapidcostreduction,technologyimprovement,andlearningbydoing.
Investmentandcostreductionwillgenerateavirtuouscycleofadditional
investment,economicgrowth,employmentgeneration,energysecurity,
geopoliticalstability,internationalcooperationandemissionreductions.
Thisbigpushcannotbeimplementedbyanycountryalone.Inthefirst
decadeandahalf,itwillrequiregloballyfundedguarantees,orprice
supports(e.g.,throughaglobal"feedintariffs"program),tosubsidize
investment.
Afterthat,thevirtuouscyclewilltakeoverandmakefurtherprice
supportsorinternationaltransfersunnecessary,asrenewableenergy
becomesthedefaultoptionfornewenergyinvestmentworldwide.
Pricesupportswillbecomplementedbyaglobalrenewableenergy
extensionprogram:research,technical,andpolicysupportdesignedto
acceleratetheprocess.
ThisstrategyiscalledtheGlobalGreenNewDeal,andthetimetoadoptitis
now.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
4/23
1
Introduction: Push Down to Lift Up
Theworldcanavoiddangerousclimatechangebypushingdownthe
priceofrenewableenergy,asquicklyaspossible.
Theaimofclimatenegotiationsistoreducegreenhousegasemissionsandenable
adaptationtoclimatechangewithoutendangeringmomentumondevelopment.
Thispaperproposesanapproachthatcanhelpachievealltheseobjectivesina
practicalandtimelymanner:afocusonacceleratedinvestmentinarenewable
energyfuture.
Thereisnowbroadagreementontheneedto dramaticallyreduceglobalemissionsofcarbondioxideinthecomingdecades.Atthesame,thereisalsoagreementontheneedtodramatically increasetheeconomicprospectsoftheworld'spoorestpeople,andinparticulartoprovidethemwithmodernenergyservices.Thesegoalsareoftenseenas
being in conflictwith one another,and continuing toview them as conflicting slowsprogress towards either. Only by considering them together as a single, integratedchallengedoesawaybeyondtheimpassebecomevisible.
Butfirst,wemustchangeourstrategicperspectiveontheproblemofclimatechange.Currently, all eyes are locked on the accumulation of greenhouse gases in theatmosphere, and therefore on emissions reduction, or mitigation, as the strategic
responsetothisproblem.Butwemustrememberthatemissionsreductionisagoal;itisnot a strategy. In fact, the almost exclusive focus on emissions targets offers fewattractivechoicestonegotiators(BirdsallandSubramanian,2009).Itlockstheworldintoaperceived"winlose"oreven"nowin"scenario,asanevershrinkingemissions
piemust bedivided upamong (1) thosewhohave already eatenmore than a lion'sshare, and (2) those whose growing and justifiable hunger exceeds the size of theremainingpiecesonoffer.
As agoal, the need for emissions reduction is unimpeachable. As a strategic focus,however,itisleadingusdownadeadendpath.
Theonlyviablestrategyistocreateabiggerpieandthisrequiresustoshiftourfocus
fromtherapidreductionofgreenhouseemissionstotherapidexpansionofrenewableenergy.
Energyisthekeytoeconomicdevelopmentandsocialwellbeing,andrenewableenergyisthekeytoafuturewithoutdangerousclimatechange.Whileforestconservation,landusechanges,andefficiencymeasuresareessentialcontributorstoanypositiveclimate
scenario,therecanbenofutureclimatestabilitywithoutarapidconversionfromfossilfuelstosun,wind,andwaterbasedenergytechnologies.
Fortunately,thereareencouragingsignsthatsuchatransformationintheenergysectorisalreadyunderway.Theglobalmarketforrenewableenergyhasbeenestimatedat
$1.6trillionasof200708.Annualgrowthrateshavebeenreportedas25%forwindenergy,and80100%forsolarphotovoltaics.Withthesedramaticincreasesincapacity
havecomeequallydramaticdeclinesincost.Forexample,thecostofsolarpanelshas
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
5/23
2
fallenfrom$5perwattin2005tojustoveronedollarperwattin2009;andinjustthreeto five years, Japanese planners are expecting to cut the cost of a solar electricitygenerationsysteminhalf(EuropeanCommission,2009).Despitetheserapidadvances,renewableenergyremainsexpensive,especiallyforthe
two billion people whohave noaccess tomodernenergy services. Prices are falling,driven by increasingmarket demand, scale economies, and technologicaldiffusion aswellastechnologyimprovement.Butpriceshavenotfallenfastenoughtomakesuch
technologiesaffordableatlargescaleindevelopingandemergingindustrialeconomies.Theyhavenotfallenfastenoughtooutcompetecoal,oil,andnaturalgasas thedefaultchoicesforenergy.Theyhavenotfallenfastenoughtoofferarealisticalternativetomillionsofwomenhuddledoverwoodfires,ortootherswhocontinuetosufferfromthe
healthandplanetdamagingsootofburningbiomass.Insum,thepriceofrenewableenergyhasnotfallenfastenoughtosavetheworldfrom
experiencingdangerousclimatechange.Norwillitfallrapidlyenough,onitsown,todoso.
Butthisproblemisactuallyanenormousopportunityindisguiseforitisaproblem
theworld can do something about. By working together topush down the price ofrenewable energy, as rapidly as possible, we can lift up the prospects of peopleeverywhere,bothenvironmentallyandeconomically.
Creatingpositivetippingpointsandvirtuouscycles
Recent research by the United Nations and others (see, e.g., United Nations 2009,BirdsallandSubramanian2009,JacobsenandDelucchi2009)hasfocusedonwaysto
drive down the price of renewable energy in the near term, accelerate its spreadglobally, improvetheeconomiesofboththedevelopedanddevelopingworld,andendenergy poverty. This genuine "winwin" strategy carries with it another extremelyimportant benefit: it makes possible the attainment of critical emission reduction
targets,andthusreducestheriskofdangerousclimatechange.The"GlobalGreenNewDeal"(GGND)bringsthedifferentcomponentsofthestrategytogetherintoanintegratedprogram:internationalgoalsetting,limitedtimesubsidies,
targeted investments, coordinated nationaldevelopment policies, and comprehensiveextension systems. Together these can accelerate the global economy's arrival at a"positivetippingpoint"in thespreadofrenewableenergy.Pushingdownthepriceof
renewablesandremovingthebarrierstotheiradoptionwillacceleratetheprocessofindustrialscalingupinthatsectoraprocesswhichisalreadyunderway.Expandedmarketsforrenewableenergy,andfastergrowthratesinproduction,willleadtofastertechnologyimprovement,whichwillfurtherlowercostsandthusprices.Theresultwill
beavirtuouscycleofexpansion,learning,andcostreduction.Withinarelativelyshortperiodoftimebetween10and20years,dependingonhowquicklytheworldrampsuppriceswillhavefallentothepointwheresubsidiesforrenewableenergyareno
longernecessary.(Seebox,"TheGlobalGreenNewDealBytheNumbers.")
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
6/23
3
TheGlobalGreenNewDealBytheNumbers
The mechanics of the GGND strategy are straightforward. Step 1: define the globalaffordabilitytarget,assumedheretobe$0.03to0.05perkilowatthour,corresponding
roughlyto$1.00$1.50perWattinvestmentcost.Step2:Collectinformationoncurrent
investmentcosts aswellas currentand expectedfuture (in this case,2025)levelsofinstalled renewable energy capacity, assuming no global renewables investmentprogram.Step3:uselearningcurvestoestimatetheinstalledcapacitycorrespondingtothe global affordability target. Step 4: Estimate the additional investment needed toexpandinstalledcapacitytothelevelestimatedinthepreviousstep.Step5:Estimatethe share of the incremental investment that needs to be supported throughinternationalpriceguarantees.Themainvariationin theresult stems fromdifferentestimatesoftechnologylearningcurves. However, even the conservative estimates of learning curves show that theglobal affordability target can be reached with additional investment of up to $100
billion(in2005dollars)peryearoverfifteenyears.Thiswouldbringdownthecostsoftwoleadingrenewabletechnologies(solarPVandwind)toalevelthatisuniversallyaffordable.SignificantlygreaterinvestmentisnecessaryforSolarPVthanforWind,butevenwindrequiressubsidizedinvestmenttoachievethetargetpricewithinthetargettimescale.
Step
Wind SolarPV
1. GlobalAffordabilityTarget(Investmentcost$/W) 1.00 1.00
2a. Currentinvestmentcosts($/W) 1.50 2.903.40
2b. Currentinstalledcapacity(GW) 120 13
2c. Installedcapacityexpectedin2025underBAU(GW) 570 160
3. InstalledcapacitycorrespondingtoGATcost(GW) 700 1390
4a. AdditionalcapacityneededtoachieveGAT(GW) 130 1230
4b. Additionalinvestmentcost(billion2005USD) $33 $1,476
5. TOTALADDITIONALINVESTMENTCOST $10001500billion
Source:PreliminaryanalysisbyUN/DESA-DSD,usingexpectedinstalledcapacitydataprovidedby
IEA(2009),andlearningcurveestimates(investmentcostsperwattofinstalledcapacity)provided
byIIASA(2009).
Thisistheupperendofsuchestimates.Theactualfigurewouldverylikelybelower.Step5(i.e.,internationaltransfers)isnotestimatedexplicitly,butitcanbeexpectedthatatleasttwothirdsoftheadditionalcapacitywouldbedeployedindevelopingcountries.In higher income countries, the additional costs of renewable energy are generallypassedontoconsumersintheirelectricitybills.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
7/23
4
The strategic objective of the GGND is to make proven renewable technologiesuniversally affordable, so that renewable energy becomes the default choice for theworldasawhole.Makingrenewableenergyaffordabledirectlyaddressestheneedsofdeveloping countries and emerging economies, where the demand for new energyservices is most acute, and where the vast majority of new energy development is
expectedtooccurinthecomingdecades.But pushing down the price of renewable energy also ensures that, as aging
infrastructure comes up for replacement in the industrialized countries, thosereplacementswillalsoresultinashiftfromfossiltorenewablepowersources.Inbothcases,pushingdownthepricehelpspreventthelockinofinvestmentcapitalin fossilfuelbasedtechnologies,whichwouldexposethepoortodecadesofpollution,anddoom
humanitytosuffertheconsequencesofadditionalglobalwarming.The GGND involves the mobilization of largescale public and private financing for
investments,whosereturnsattheglobalscaleinclude:
Employment:Millions of new "green jobs" in a rapidly expanding renewableenergy sector in both developed and developing countries. (Investments in
renewableenergyhavebeenshowntocreatetwotothreetimesasmanyjobsasinvestments in conventional energy development.) (Pollin andGarrettPeltier,2007)
Energy Security: Increased geopolitical stability, improving the conditions fortrade and exchange of all kinds. (As nations become less dependent on theproductionandimportationoffossilfuels,theywillhavelessreasonforconflict
overthesourcesofbothenergyandemissions.)
Reduced Climate Risks: A significant reduction in costs associated with theexpecteddamagesfromacceleratedglobalwarming.(AstheSternReviewandothershavenoted,inactiononglobalwarmingcouldresultincostsashighas20%ofworldoutputinthecomingcentury.)(Stern,2006)
International Cooperation: A clear pathway for multiple actors to channelinternationalfinanceformitigation,aswellasamechanismforphasingoutsuchfinancingwithin one totwodecades. (In recentwork,Sternetal.notethat awellstructured finance scheme will create aligned incentives, encouragegovernmentsandprivatesectoractorstoworktogether,andcreatethevirtuouscycleofinvestmentanddevelopmentthatistheessenceofthisstrategy.)(Stern,2009)
Greenhouse GasMitigation: The contributionof this investment to greenhouse
gas mitigation consists of two components: direct and indirect. The directcomponentistheavoidedemissionsduetothesubstitutionofanewrenewableenergyplantforaconventionalenergyalternative,mostlikelycoal.Inthiscase,thisworksout totheavoidance ofbetween2.5and 3.5 billion tonsofcarbondioxideperyearby2025andeveryyearthereafter.Assuminganinvestmentlifeof40years,thecumulativeemissionreductionwouldbebetween100and140billiontonsofcarbondioxideatanincrementalcostofupto$1,500billion,inotherwords,between$15and$11pertonofcarbondioxide.However,thisisonly a part of the story. Once the cost of the renewable energy becomescompetitiveandaffordable,itwillbecomethedefaultoptionforfuturepowersector investments. This means that. between 2025 and 2050, the initialinvestment of $1,500billion will continue to produce additional offsetting of
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
8/23
5
carbondioxide.Ifpowersectorcapacitycontinuestogrowathistoricratesandinaccordancewithrisingdemandfromdevelopingcountries,thiswillresult inthe avoidance of an additional 8 billion tons of emissions per year at noadditionalcost.
From forwardlooking firms in the energy sector, to individual householders in theworld'spoorestcountries,toskilledworkersandexpertsinallcountries,aGlobalGreenNewDealcreatesmanywinnersintheglobaleconomy.ImplementingtheGGNDwilllay
thefoundationforanew,selfsustainingcycleof greengrowthglobally,whilesteeringthe world on a course toend the scourge of energy poverty and avoid the threat ofdangerousclimateinstability(Figure1).
Figure1.AschematicofhowtheGlobalGreenNewDealwillworktoaccomplishitsobjectives
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
9/23
6
TheElementsofaGlobalGreenNewDeal
TheGGNDinvolvestherapiddeploymentofnineintegratedmechanismsthatwillworktogetherasarenewableenergyaccelerator:
TheGGNDRoadMap1 SetTargets:Setcleartargetsforbothrenewableenergycosts (i.e.,thecostneedstobecomeaffordableaswellascompetitivewithconventionaltechnologies,currentlybetween$0.03and$0.05/kWh),andfor theyearbywhichthetarget cost is to bereached(e.g.,aglobaltargetyearof2025).Givenknownratesofcostreduction,thiswillimplyacorollarytargetforrenewableenergyinstalledcapacity.
2. SetPriceGuarantees:Determinea scheduleofguaranteedprices("tariffs")tobeofferedtosuppliersofrenewableenergy,basedonestimatesofcurrentandfuture
costs. The tariffs offered to new entrants in the market would decline by apredetermined amount every year, converging on the target price by the targetyear. This tariff schedule would provide a strong incentive for accelerated
investmentanddevelopmentofinstalledcapacityinthenearterm.3. Determine Host Country Contributions: Create a formula for estimating the
shareof the feedintariffto bepaidbythehost country.This formulawouldberelated toper capita income ineach country, the cost of specific renewable andconventionalalternatives,domesticinvestmentcapacity,andotherrelevantfactors.
4. Establisha Global InvestmentFundforRenewables:Aglobalinvestmentfund
for renewable energy is essential for underwriting the gap between the feedintariffsthatneedtobeofferedtosupplierstomakerenewablescompetitive,andtheshareofthesubsidythatcanbecontributedbyhostcountries.Theinvestmentfundwillguaranteeforafixedperiodoftime asubsidizedpriceforthedeliveryofnew
renewableenergyindevelopingcountries.
5. ProvideAdditional Support totheLeastDevelopedCountries: Supportcouldincludelowinterestloans,e.g.,forgridexpansion,financialassistanceforcapacitybuildingandinstitutionaldevelopment,technicalassistance,orsubsidizedaccesstotechnologicalinformation.
6. Create Mechanisms to Serve Off-Grid Communities: Offer special provisions
withintheglobalfinancingschemetosupportrenewableenergydevelopmentforoffgridcommunities,e.g.,supplementarysubsidiesorassistanceforbuildinglocalgrids.
7. Create aNetwork of Innovation Centers: Buildingon the analogyoftheGreenRevolution,establishanetworkofresearchandextensioncentersthatwilladapttechnical knowledge to local conditions, and make that knowledge available topolicymakers,investors,andcommunities.
8. Create a Global Climate Conservation Corps: Learning from the lessons ofseveral successful largescale initiatives including thePeace Corps, theCivilian
ConservationCorps,andMdecinsSansFrontiresestablishandrecruita globalbody of skilled practitionerswho can support national institutions and serve astheirlinktointernationalexpertsandknowledgebases.
9. Developthe AppropriateInstitutionalArchitecture:Carefulattentionmustbepaidtocreatingappropriateinstitutionalvehiclesbothnewandinrelationshiptoexisting bodies to channel the resources from the global feedin fund, through
nationalenergyadministrations,torenewableenergysuppliers.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
10/23
7
Agreement and action onthese elementsas rapidlyaspossible,ata global scale,willspeed renewable energy toward its own "global tipping point" a point of selfsustainingtakeoffpoweredbyacceleratedlearningandexpandingmarkets.
While the GGND is a new, comprehensive strategic approach, it brings together theconvergingconclusionsofseveralrecentglobalanalyses,allofwhichpointtoacentralroleforincreasedpublicinvestmentinrenewableenergy,particularlyinthedeveloping
world (e.g., Stern, 2009; Birdsall and Subramanian, 2009; UNEPSEFI, 2009). Thestrategyalsobuildsonwhat isalreadyhappening:successfulmodelsforeachofthesemechanismsexist,inboththedevelopinganddevelopedworld.Anumberofdevelopingcountries(notablyChina, India, andBrazil) havealready established keyelementsof
suchpolicy, finance,andtechnical supportmechanisms.However,thescaleexpansionneededtobringaboutthenecessarycostreductionislargerthanwhatcanbeachievedby these countries acting alone. The GGND will supplement national actions with
internationalsupport,andsimplyenabledevelopingcountriestodomoreandmorequickly.
The GGND also encourages an even faster diffusion of working models in the
industrializedworld,wherecountrieslikeDenmark,Germany,andSpainhaveledtheway on developing the necessary technologies, policies and programs. These earlyinvestments in renewable energy are already being rewarded with both nearterm
financialreturnsandlongertermcompetitiveness;theGlobalGreenNewDealwillworkto amplify these effects, reward innovative enterprises, expand employmentopportunities in technologically advanced countries, and spread the benefits morerapidlytoothercountries.
TheGGNDensures longrunpredictability andmarket stability for renewableenergy
producersaswellasequipmentsuppliers,andthuscreatesthebasisforeffectivepublicprivatepartnership,mobilizationoflargescaleprivatesectorresourcesforinvestmentandinnovation,capacityexpansion,andcostreduction.The GGND also ensures that international resources are linked to tangible outputs
(deliveryoffinalrenewableenergyservices)ratherthaninputs.Finally,adopting the GGNDwill bringmany benefitsof the kind that economists call"intangibles,"butthatarewidelyrecognizedasbothrealandnecessaryforsuccessinanyventureofmagnitude.Theseinclude:
afeelingofhopeandoptimism specifically,thatlargescaleproblemslikeglobal
warmingandenergypovertycanbesolved;
an encouragement to entrepreneurship there are genuine businessopportunitiestopursue;and
a sense of common strategic focus on the goal of reducing the price ofrenewableenergy,andacceleratingaglobaltransitiontoacleanenergyfuture.
TheGGNDrepresentsaglobalopportunityforcooperation,foronlybypushingtogether,and pushing hard, canwe lower the price of renewable energy enough to lift manymillionsoutofenergypovertyandprovideclean,affordableenergytotheworld.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
11/23
8
The Case for a Global Green New Deal: Changing theGame on Climate, Development, and EnergyThe GGND represents a new approach toaddressing, simultaneously, the problem ofglobalwarmingandtheimperativeofbringingenergyandeconomicdevelopmenttotheworld'spoorestpeoples.Butwhiletheoverallconceptisnew,theelementsoftheGGNDare based on existing models and supported by extensive current research. Thefollowing sections summarize the case for the GGND, explain the underlyingassumptions,anddescribehowthestrategywouldworkinmoredetail.
A.Climate,development,andenergyareinterconnectedissues.TherationalefortheGGNDbeginswithafundamentalinsight:climatechangeisnota
problemthatissomehowsetapartfromotherproblems. Inparticular,itis intimatelyconnectedtoboththetypeofdevelopmentandtheenergypathchosentopowerthat
development.BehindtheGGNDisthefollowingpostulate:Amassivedeploymentofnonrenewable,fossilbasedenergytechnologiesinthedevelopedworldiswhatenabledthosecountriestoattainunprecedentedlevelsofprosperitywithinashortspanoftime;butitalsoledto
the current climate dilemma. A rapid and equally massive deployment of clean,renewableenergytechnologiesinthecountriesofthedevelopingworldcanenablethemtoattainsimilarlevelsofprosperityand,whenjoinedtoalargescaleenergyswitchin
developedcountries,canleadtheworldoutofthatdilemma.The energy needs of the world's poor have long been overlooked in the global
discussion on climate change, in terms of both current needs and future planning.(Figure 2) And yet, the poor also represent the world's largest undeveloped energymarket.Today,about1.6billionpeoplelackaccesstoelectricity;
and 2.4 billion still cook withfirewood.By2050,therewillbe3billionadditionalpeoplelivingon planet Earth, and the vast
majority of them will berelatively poor urban dwellersin developing countries. If the
energy systems developed to
providelight,heat,mobility,andother services to all of thesepeoplearebasedonfossilfuels,
there will be no possibility ofattaining the emissionreductions necessary tomaintainclimatestability.Providingenergytotheworld'spoorshouldnotmerelybeseenasa"longtermvision";itisanurgentglobalimperative.Energyservicesarekeyinputstodevelopmentgenerally,andtohumandevelopmentin
particular. Improvements in health, education, and standards of living are closelycorrelated with access to energy. Inadequate and unreliable energy services are
Figure2.Distributionofcountriesshowingthecorrelation
betweenTotalPrimaryEnergySupply(TPES)andscoreonthe
HumanDevelopmentIndex(HDI).Source:UnitedNations,
basedonUNDPandIEAdata.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
12/23
9
centrally implicated in the inability to provide clean drinking water or sanitationfacilities.Ontheotherhand,mostlowcostenergysourcesavailabletodaytomeettheneedsofthepoorareneithercleannorrenewable.Theycontributetogreenhousegasemissions
and often carry with them significant health risks, such as respiratory illness fromexposuretosootparticles.
Whenthelowcostenergyneedsofthepoorareseenasbeinginoppositiontoemissionreduction goals, agreement on a way forward becomes exceedingly difficult. But bylooking atclimate change and developmentasunitedbyacommonissueenergyratherthandividedbyit,truewinwinsolutionsbecomepossible.
TheGGNDofferssuchawinwinsolutionintheformofastrategythatmeetstheneedsofdevelopingnations forenergydevelopment,whileacceleratingprogresstowardthe
goal of a lowemissions economy for theworld as awhole. It functions as a bridgebetweenperspectivesandpriorities,providingeveryoneattheclimatenegotiatingtable
withacommongoal:theprovisionofclean,affordable,renewableenergytoall.
B. The world has a common interest in reducing the price of
renewableenergy,worldwide,asrapidlyaspossible.Thenext1020yearsareacriticalwindowfortheimplementationoftheGGND,because
somuchnewenergydevelopmentwillbeplannedandimplementedduringthisperiod.Ifrenewableenergyistocontributeasignificantportionofnewenergydevelopment,especiallyinthedevelopingworld,reducingitspriceisessential.
AsofAugust2005,about1.4billionpeopleinthedevelopingworldwerelivingonlessthan$1.25perday(theWorldBankspovertyline).However,evenpeoplelivingontendollarsperdaycannotaffordtobuyadequateamountsofrenewableelectricityatthe
current price per kilowatthour, which ranges from about 36 cents from solarphotovoltaicpanelstoaslowas10centsfromawindturbine.Forlowincomepeoplearoundtheworld,energythatcostsmorethan35centsperkilowatthourissimplynotaffordable;andsointheabsenceofsubsidiesrenewableenergywillnotbetheirchoice.
From a developing country perspective, a strategy of simply increasing the price ofconventionalenergytomakerenewableenergymorecompetitivemakesnosense.Norcanthegovernmentsofdevelopingandemergingmarketcountriesaffordto subsidize
renewable energy on a large scale, given current costs and per capita incomes.Meanwhile, in the developedworld, the strategyof simply waiting for themarket toproduce competitive renewable energy, andgreenhousegasemissionreductions, has
also been "failing to deliver" (The Economist, 15 October 2009, citing Committee onClimateChange,2009).Tomakeprogressatapacethatcanwintheraceagainsttimewithglobalwarming,weneed a global strategy for reducing the price of renewable energy, everywhere. Thisrequires accelerating the process by which the price of these new technologies isalreadyfalling:thatis,byscalingup.For example, in Europe today, every time the amount of wind generation capacitydoubles,thepriceof electricityproduced bywindturbines fallsby 9 to17% (Krohn,EuropeanWindEnergyAssociation,2009).Witheachnewwindturbine,theindustry
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
13/23
10
learnshowtomakethesemachinesmoreefficientlyandmoreeffectively,thusdrivingdown the costsper kilowatthour. Economists call this effect a "learning curve": themorerenewableenergygeneratingcapacitygetsinstalled,themorewelearnabouthowtoproducerenewableenergy,andthelessexpensiveitbecomes.
Such steep and beneficial learning curves are associated with several socalledemerging technologies, includingwind energy, solar photovoltaic and concentratedsolarenergy(Figure3).Incontrast,maturetechnologies,suchasHydroPPL(Figure
3), have stable cost curves with relatively small opportunities for further costreductions.Currentevidencesuggestsaverylargepotentialforcostreductionsinwindand solar energy. There is even evidence to suggest that their learning curves arechanging in favorableways, creatingtheprospectthat a virtuouscycle of investment
scaleupandcostreductionwillhappenevenfasterthancurrentanalysesmightpredict.Forexample,aconsortiumofsolarcellcompaniesinChinahastwicerevisedestimatesonthespeedofcostreductionjustsince2007.Theyhavemoveduptheplannedtarget
yeartoachieveagovernmenttargetprice($0.146perkWh)from2020to2012,becauseofunexpectedlyfasttechnologicaladvancesandlowerpolysiliconprices(Saber,2009).
Relatedly,studieson thecostsof compliancewithgovernmentenvironmentalpolicies
and regulations support the conclusion that ex ante costs are often overestimatedbecauseof a failure to take into account scale economiesand technological advances(EC2005).
Although learning rates haveoccasionally been described interms of the cost decline per
year,theirprimarydriveristhe
installed capacity. (Figure 3)
Thatis,pricesfallwithgrowinginstalled capacity because ofsuchfactorsasalargermarket,greater market stability andpredictability, standardization
of equipment and componentproduction, competitionamongst suppliers, improveddesigns,andlearningbydoing.In sum, one can accelerateprogressdownalearningcurve
by speeding up the increase ininstalled capacity. The GGNDproposes to do just that, byreducing the primary barrier standing between developing countries and currentrenewableenergytechnologies:theirrelativelyhighprice.Usingpublicinvestmentsand subsidies to reduce the price to rough parity with fossil fuels, combinedwith astablepolicyenvironment and technical support,will remove themajor constraint toacceleratinginstalledcapacity.Itwillalsounlockwavesofdemandanddrivetherapiddeploymentof thesetechnologies. Asthetechnologiesspread,industriesscaleup,andcapacitydoublingtimesdecrease,thenpriceswillfall,followingthewellknownpatternofthelearningcurve.HavingdescribedthedriveroftheGGNDthetechnologylearningcurvewenowturntotheaccelerator:pricesupports.
Figure3.Thegreatertheinstalledcapacityofanenergy
technology,thelowerpriceforeverynewunitinstalled.
(Source:Nakicenovic,IIASA,2009)
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
14/23
11
C. A globally coordinated program of price support guarantees for
renewable energy will unleash a transformation in the global
energysector.Countrieshaveusedavarietyofmechanismstopromoterenewableenergy,including
directpublic investment,investmentincentives(e.g.,low interest rates, taxwriteoffs,accelerated depreciation), portfolio obligations, and feedintariffs. While all policymechanismshavehadtheirshareofsuccess,themostdramaticexpansioninrenewable
energycapacitywaswitnessedunderthefeedintariffprogramsenactedinGermanyandSpain."Feedintariffs"obligateelectricitygridstopurchaserenewableenergyasitbecomesavailable(to"feeditin"),andtheyoffertopotentialprovidersofrenewableenergyaguaranteedprice(the"tariff,"orratepaidfortheelectricity).Thetariffsare
generally fixedfora givenperiod, between10and20years,at levels thatensuretheprofitabilityoftheinvestment.Theexistenceofaguaranteethatsuccessfuldevelopment
ofa solaror wind energy installationwill berewardedwith a customeras well asasubsidized price essentially levels the playing field, removing the cost barrier torenewableenergydevelopmentincomparisontofossilfuelbasedtechnologies.Theeffectiveness of the feedin
tariff policy is by now wellestablished.Astudycomparingthe effect of these policies to
other policy mechanismsdesigned to support thespreadofwindenergy found that theyresulted in 7-8 times as much
installed wind capacity.(European Commission, asreported by Thomas B.
Johansson, Chair,GlobalEnergyAssessment) (Figure 4) Theoverall success of the German,Spanish, Danish and other
nationallevel feedin programshasinspiredsimilarinitiativesinChinaand,morerecently,SouthAfricaandIndia,aswellasbyregionalandstategovernmentsintheUK,US,andAustralia.Todaywellover50countriesnowhavefeedintarifflawson thebooks,andsmallerscaleexperiments
arenowaglobalphenomenon.Ofthedifferentoptionstosupportrenewableenergy,thefeedintariffisincreasingly
seenasthepolicyofchoicethatprovidesthemostbenefitatleastcost(DBClimateChangeAdvisors,2009).Itcanbeappliedconsistentlyandtransparently,whilebeingreadilyadaptedtodifferentspecificconditionsindifferentcountries.Wherefeedintariffshavebeenemployedindevelopingcountries,theyoftenhavetobeaccompaniedbygovernmentbudgetaryallocationstocoverthedifferentialbetweentheguaranteed price that the utility pays to the renewable energy suppliers, and theaverageratethatitisallowedtochargeconsumersforeachkilowatthourofelectricity.Thisdependenceonnationalbudgetstocoverthedifferenceplacesacaponthetotalexpansionof renewable energy thatcan take place ina developing country,and thuscreates a disincentive for expanded renewable energy investment. International
Figure4.Countriesusingfeed-intariffscomparedtocountries
usingotherformsofpolicysupportforwindenergy.
(Source:EuropeanCommission,2008,citedbyJohansson,
2009)
Figure4.Countriesusingfeed-intariffscomparedtocountries
usingotherformsofpolicysupportforwindenergy.
(Source:EuropeanCommission,2008,citedbyJohansson,
2009)
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
15/23
12
financingtosupportthetariff,orpriceguarantee,willremovethisconstraintandcreatehighly favorable conditions for accelerating renewable energy investment anddevelopment.Asthephraseitselfindicates,feedintariffpolicieshavebeenemployedexclusivelyin
regard to grid connections. Given the current level of grid development in mostdeveloping countries, the policy frameworkwouldneed tobe amended tobeable toincludeoffgridareasaswell.
In practical terms, the GGND involves linking the demonstrated favorability andeffectiveness of feedintariff policies with the rapidly growing energy needs ofdeveloping countries, offering suitablemechanisms for finance, policy, and technical
supportforrapidscaleup. Itdeliverstherightmixofpolicyandmarketstabilitythat,accordingtorecentresearchsummarizedbySternetal.,cancreatethehighestpossibleleverage for public financing, mobilizing up to 15 times the original investment in
additional,followonfunding(Stern,2009,andUNEPSEFI,2009).
The GGND Road Map (page 6) brings together elements of successful programs,including feedintariffs aswell asothercomplementary actions, in such awayas to
accelerate the process ofpolicy design and technology diffusion and adoption that isalreadyoccurring,removemajorbarriersandobstacles,andadapttheprogrambothtointernationalrequirementsandlocalconditions.
As mentioned in the GGND Road Map (Paragraph 4), a new global investment fundneeds to be established to contribute the global share of the subsidy for renewableenergy servicesand supplement the national guarantees offered byeach country.As
such, the Fund will reduce uncertainty and ensure predictability in the renewableenergyindustry.Onceitisinplaceandadequatelyresourced,itwouldhelpstimulatea
rapid and massive expansion in the market for solar, wind and other renewabletechnologies and speed them toward an economic tipping point, after which theywouldbeontracktobecomethedominantenergyoptionontheplanet.Thepricesupportmechanismsneedto bestructured insuchawayas toreward the
mostefficientrenewableenergysuppliersandtogivethemanincentivetoreducecostsasrapidlyaspossible.TheconceptofadecliningtariffschedulementionedintheGGNDRoadMap(Paragraph2)seekstoensurethisbystipulatingthatpricesupportsdeclineanddisappearwithinadefinedperiodoftime(1020years).Producerswouldracetoenterthemarketaheadofthedecliningsubsidyandestablishtheircompetitivepositioninthemarketplace.Whereappropriate,countriescouldchooseadditionalpolicies(suchasrenewableportfoliostandardsandinnovativefinancingofupfrontcosts)thatwould
encourage utilities and local governments to bemore proactive in cooperatingwithrenewableenergysuppliers.If the GGND were launched immediately, the economics and the technologies of theworld energy sector could be transformed by 2025. With renewable energy costsbecoming competitive with fossil fuels, subsidies could soon be discontinued. Themajorityoftheworld'spoorwouldhaveaccesstoenergyfromaffordable,renewablesourcesthenewdefaultoption.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
16/23
13
D. A largescale global investment in renewable energy will bring
multipleeconomic,social,andenvironmentalbenefitsespecially
tothedevelopingworld.
The GGND would transform the global economy, to the great benefit of peopleeverywhere. For example, renewable energy is a much more effective engine foremploymentcreationthanfossilfuelbasedenergyproduction:researchsuggeststhatit
producestwotothreetimesasmanyjobs,incomparisonwithconventionalfossilbasedenergydevelopment.(PollinandGarrettPeltier,2008)
Windandsolarenergysystemsdohavetheproblemofintermittencythatis,theyarelessavailablewhenthewindisnotblowingorwhenthesunisobscuredandthiswillneedtobeaddressedinthecomingdecadeasthescalingupprocessgainsspeed.Buttechnologyisalsoadvancingintheareaofenergystorage.Initially,theexpansionof
intermittent renewable technologies might need to be accompanied by additionalconsumerguidanceon tailoring demand toavailability, as isoftenprovided inmany
developing countries whose energy systems are subject to frequent serviceinterruptions. More generally, renewable energy is also viewed as a more resilient,reliable,andsafetechnology:windandsolarbasedsystemsbreakdownfarlessoftenthanfossilfuelcombustionbasedsystems,theyaresimpler,lessdangeroustooperate,andfarlesspolluting.
For energy importers (a term that includesall but a handful ofcountries), economicstabilitywillalsobenefitfromcreatinga globalenergysectorthatis farlessrelianton
imports.Poorcountriesespeciallywillbeshieldedfromtheimpactsontheirbalanceofpaymentsandgrowthprospectsfromglobalpriceswingsandpeaks.The reduction in fossilfuel emissions will also bring significant health benefits by
reducingexposuretopollutantslikesootandgroundlevelozone.Andwhilerenewableenergyinstallationstakeupspaceonthelandorinthewater,thiscanbemanagedinwaysthatareminimallydisruptivetonaturalecosystems.
Private companies producing and installing renewable energy technologies, and theprivate banks and international financial institutions that finance them, are alreadysignificantbeneficiariesof theworld'stransition towardrenewableenergy.TheGGND
wouldcertainlyacceleratethattrendaswell.Butalsobenefittingwouldbecompaniesthatprovidematerialinputsforproductionofrenewableenergy,aswellascompaniesprovidingsuchassociatedservicesas smartgriddevelopment,smartmetering,energystorageandbatteries.Thesetechnologieswouldgetasignificantboostasabyproduct
oftheGGND,fromprivateinvestorsaswellasfrominternationalfinancinginstitutionssuchastheWorldBankandregionaldevelopmentbanks(whowouldplayacrucialrolein financing the development of smart grids, for example). All of this additional
economic activity would further accelerate the "virtuous cycle" of investment andtechnologyimprovement.AGGNDcouldbeanengineoftrue"greengrowth,"improvingpercapitaincomesandemploymentincountriesaroundtheworld.Thegreaterlevelsofjobgeneration,energyreliability, technology advance, and economic stability, together with reducedvulnerability to fossilfuel price fluctuations, can be expected to support the world'slongtermrecoveryfromtherecentfinancialcrisis.Overall, the GGND is expected to put the future world economy on a more solidfoundation for longtermsustainable development. Thisexpectation is supportedby
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
17/23
14
United Nations economic models looking at the impact of high levels of publicinvestmentinlowemissionsenergy(WorldEconomicandSocialSurvey2009)aswellas relevantcase studies. In Germany,for example, approximately 280,000 jobs havebeencreatedinrenewableenergytwothirdsofthemasadirectresultofthecountry'srenewableenergylaws.Andtherateofjobgrowthisstillincreasing.(GermanMinistry
ofEnvironment,2009)
E. Direct public investment and investment support are essential;
offsets and other market mechanisms focused on the price of
carbonarenotsufficienttoachievethegoal.ThelogicoftheGGNDisstraightforward.Toaddressclimatechange,renewableenergymust bemade both competitive and affordable. To do this, the installed capacity of
renewableenergymustbeexpanded.Toexpandcapacity,therewillbeaneedforsomeform of subsidy in the near term, either from governments or from consumers.
Subsidiesforrenewableenergyarehappeningtoday,butinanuncoordinatedmanner.Newenergyinfrastructureisbeingbuiltrapidlyindevelopingcountries,buttheshareofrenewable energy is limited by the lack of financial and technological resources.Effectiveglobalcooperationintheformofadditionalfinancialresourcesandtechnologytransferwillbeneededtoscaleupthenationaleffortstotherequiredlevel.
TheGGNDsupportssimultaneousinvestmentintwoglobalgoods,namely,socialandeconomicdevelopmentbasedonrenewableenergy,andclimatestabilization.Itinvolves
publicinvestmentinenergyinfrastructureaswellasinvestmentsupporttorenewableenergy suppliers, to ensure adequate private rewards for supplying these socialbenefits.Itoffersastraightforwardbusinessproposition:dowellbydoinggood.Fornational economies, this largescale investment in bringing renewable energy to the
developingworldandmakingituniversallyaffordablewillbringbenefits,intermsofemployment,growth,greatermacroeconomicstabilityandenergysecurity.
Specific options formobilizing international finance for green energy investments indevelopingcountrieshavealreadybeguntobeexploredanddescribedinseveralrecentinstitutionalandindependentstudies(Stern,2009;Avato,2008;Mendona,2007;UNEPSEFI, 2009). Some of the mechanisms to raise the funds might include: traditional
government treasury bonds, "green" bonds linked to renewable energy investments,auctioningofnationalorinternationalCO2emissionallowances,carbontaxes,leviesoninternational passenger and freight transport, a tax on financial transactions, anallocationofdevelopedcountrySDRs,tonameafew.Carefulreviewoftheseandother
optionswouldbeamongthefirstordersofbusinessinplanningtheimplementationofaGlobalRenewableEnergyFund,withthelikelyconclusioninvolvingamixofoptions.Complementaryinvestmentsingriddevelopment(e.g.,transmissionlinesfromsolaror
windinstallationstocities)inthedevelopingcountrieswouldlikelybefinancedthroughexistingmechanismsandagenciessuchastheWorldBankandregionaldevelopmentbanks.Ofcourse,theneedforpolicydirectionandenhancedpublicsupporttoinvestmentinrenewable energy isnot limited to the developingworld. As noted above, the moststrikingsuccessesinswitchingto renewableenergyhavetakenplaceincountriesthatadopted feedin tariff programs. Similarly, as cited earlier, recent analyses in the UKsuggest that efforts to reduce carbon emissions by relying primarily on the marketdeliveronlyafractionofthedesiredresult(CommitteeonClimateChange,1999).Whilecapandtrade programs, carbon offset purchases, carbon taxes, and other economic
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
18/23
15
instrumentswillcontinuetobehelpfuladditionstothepolicymix,theyappearunableon their own to stimulate the development of the market for carbonfree energysolutions at anything like the required pace to address climate change by makingrenewableenergyaffordabletothepoor.
Estimatesonthescaleofinvestmentrequiredtobringaboutatruetransformationinthe global energy sector vary, but a preliminary review of current learning curveanalysessuggeststhatinvestmentsatthe levelof approximately$100billionperyear,
deployed over a fifteenyear period, would be sufficient to increase the installedcapacityofrenewableenergytothepointwherecostsweredrawndowntothelevelofaffordability in developing countries. That is, in the next fifteen to twenty years(dependingonhowquicklyinvestmentswererampedup),cleanandrenewableenergy
couldcomedowntothe35centsperkilowatthourlevelthatwouldputitinreachofnearlyeveryoneontheplanet(Seebox,page3).
AdoptionandimplementationoftheGlobalGreenNewDealisnotdependentonraisingthat levelof investment immediately. Themechanismsdescribed here can beput in
placeat lower levels of investment,and then ramped upover a 35 year period (forexample), asadditional informationbecomesavailableon how thesemechanisms are
workingandasconfidencegrowsintheireffectiveness.Still,therearepayoffstoearlyandrapidscaleup(thatis,to frontloadinginvestments),both inprogressingtowardstheMillenniumDevelopmentGoals(MDGs)andinavoidingdangerousclimatechange.
Eachyearsdelayinreducingemissionsaddssignificantlytothecostsandreducesthechances of avoiding dangerous climate change (AVOID, Met Office Hadley Center,2009). But inability tomobilize funds for $100 billionperyear investments at theoutsetisnotareasontoforegothissignificantopportunitytocooperateincreatinga
sustainableenergyfuture.
A"globalfeedintariff"programofpricesupportforrenewablegeneratedelectricityisapaymentondeliverymechanism;fundsflowonlywhentheelectricitycomeson line,thatis,whenrealandtangiblebenefitsarebeingprovided.Experiencesuggeststhattheexistenceofan internationallyguaranteedpricesupportforrenewableenergywilladdressthetraditionalissuesofinvestorconfidenceassociatedwithrenewableenergy,
opening the door toprivate bank lending and otherdebt financiersof new capacity.(Experience in Spain suggests that banks and other financers see investments inrenewableenergy,backedupbya feedintariff,asverysafe;andDeutscheBanknotesthat withina consistent anddurable integratedpolicy framework incentives suchasfeedintariffsareakeydriverofinvestability(DBClimateChangeAdvisors,2009).)
F. A complementary global programof coordinated policyguidanceandlargescaleextensionactivitieswillensuresuccess.
While price is the principal obstacle to the spread of renewable energy in both thedevelopedandthedevelopingworld,itisnottheonlyone.TheGlobalGreenNewDeal
includes a commitment to a largescale program of policy and extension support.Creatingapredictableenablingenvironmentfortherapidspreadofthesetechnologiesisanessentialelementforthesuccessofthisstrategy.Thesehavebeenaddressedin
Points7,8,and9oftheRoadMapdescribedabove.Models for globally coordinated extension programs do exist. The GreenRevolution,
notwithstandingitsenvironmentalandsocialdrawbacks,doesprovideanexampleofaglobal strategy that delivered new technologies from the hands of a few hundred
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
19/23
16
scientiststomillionsofpoorfarmers(mostofwhomwereilliterate)inpoorcountriesatabreathtakingspeedandscale.Theinnovationsincludedtheestablishmentofresearchinstitutesandextensionprogramstoassistfarmersandotheragriculturalsectoractorswith the adoption of new seeds and growing methods. These programs also helpedcreateintegratedsystemsofpolicy,technology,andcapacitythatensuredrapiduptake
andresulted,asiswidelyknown,ingreatlyincreasedagriculturalyields.Point 7 of the Road Map (Create a Network of Innovation Centers) envisages the
creationofasimilarnetworkofinstitutesandcenterstosupportboththedesignandharmonizationofpolicyandtheadoptionandadaptationofsuitablerenewableenergytechnologies.Whilethefundingandgoalsettingwillbeglobal,theimplementationofthe actual policies and energy systems must happen at the national level, with full
respectfornationaldifferencesandpreferences.Tofurtheracceleratetheprocess,Point8 oftheRoadMapproposestheestablishment
ofa"GlobalClimateConservationCorps,"aglobalcorpsofexpertsandextensionagentswho could back up the national institutions, provide training, technical support, and
helping hands. Ideally, experts in universities, technical institutions, industryassociations,andvolunteernetworkscouldbemobilizedthroughfinancialsupportas
wellasnetworkdevelopmenttoparticipateinaglobalenterprise.Participantsinthisprogram could be drawn from young entrants to related professions, experiencedprofessionals, and highlyskilled retirees from both the developing and developed
world.Forsome,themotivationtoparticipatewouldbetheidealofservice;forothers,especiallyyoungpeoplefromdevelopingcountries,theprogramwouldserveasonthejob training and an employment opportunity. It would also help to accelerate thedevelopmentof thenextgenerationoftechnicalexpertstoservicearapidlyexpanding
industry.
Sincerenewableenergyinstallationscanbedecentralizedandsmallscale,mechanismsand policies are needed to accommodate smallscale and offgrid installations,particularly in developing countries (see Point 6 of the Road Map). While large,industrialscale installations of solar, wind, andother technologies are central to theGlobal Green New Deal, the extension model is ideally suited to this additional
decentralizeddimensionandmediumandsmallscaleinstallations.These programs, in addition to materially supporting and accelerating theimplementationofarenewableenergyrevolution,willcreateaglobalfeelingofhopeandinspirationintangiblesthatareimportanttomeetingthechallengesweface.Inatimewhentheworldislockedinaliteralraceagainsttime,withboththeeradicationofpovertyandtherestorationofclimatestabilityasconjoinedgoals,theseprogramsofon
thegroundcooperationmayproveasimportanttosuccessasfinancialinvestmentsandtechnicaladvances.
G. Both renewable energy technologies and complementary
technologieswillbeadaptedtonationalsituations.Althoughexplicitmentionhasbeenmade above ofwindturbines, solar photovoltaic
arrays,solarheatconcentrators,waveandtidalenergyconvertors,andotheremergingrenewabletechnologiespowered(ultimately)byincomingsolarradiation,anumberofother technologies would be needed to achieve success. As noted earlier, the GGND
would include measures to support the adoption and diffusion of complementarytechnologies.Theseinclude:
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
20/23
17
"Smartgrids"and"smartmeters."Thesearenowpickingupspeedinthedevelopedworld and should also be the focus of leapfrog technology efforts in the developingworld.
Efficiencytechnologies.Inthebuildingsector,rapidadvancesarepermittingdrasticreductionsintheenergyneedsofbothnewandretrofittedhousing.Light,heat,cooling,and other energydependent services can now be provided at fractions of previous
electricityconsumption,dependingonthedesignsandmaterialsusedandthemethodsemployed. The GGND should include mechanisms that encourage an equally rapidspreadinthesetechnologiesaswell.
Selectedspecificandacutepriorities. TheGGNDcouldpotentiallyincludeprovisionsto address a limited number of nongrid but energyrelated issues that have beenidentified as acute, globalscale problems, such as the black soot emitted by cooking
fires (which is both a serious health hazard and a dangerous addition to globalwarming).TheextensionprogramoftheGGNDcould,forexample,beusedinconcert
withpolicyandfinancemechanismstoplanandaccelerateaconversiontocleanerandmoresustainable cooking technologies. Indeed, thegreen revolution extensionmodel
appearswellsuited to fostering adoptionofnew cooking technology byhundreds ofmillionsofdispersedruralhouseholds.
Finally,theproposednetworkofresearchandpolicyinstitutionswouldkeepacloseandcontinuouseyeoninnovationsanddevelopmentsemergingaroundtheglobe.Itwouldprovideanalysesonnewopportunities to further improve the implementation of theprogramwithbettertechnologiesandadditionalpolicysupport.
Seizing the Opportunity for an Energy TransformationAtthishistoricaljuncture,theinternationalcommunityofnationsfacesunprecedented
challenges.Itmustfindawaytoaddressthefollowingsimultaneously:tostimulateandsustain global economic recovery, to end poverty, and to avert dangerous climatechange. The GGND is a strategy designed to contribute substantially to all three
objectives.Whiletherearedetailsremainingtobedeveloped,thebroadoutlinesareclear.Addressingthecloselylinkedchallengesofclimatechange,sustainableeconomicdevelopment, and global energy poverty will require greatly enhanced levels ofcooperationamongnationsarequirementthatinitselfcouldgenerateverypositive
impactsintermsofglobalunderstanding,trust,andcollaboration.
Thetransformationoftheworld'senergysectorisanopportunitynottobemissed.The
word "transformation" can often be misused but, in this case, the term is bothappropriateandtimely. Atransformationintheglobalenergysectorisnotoptionalifwearetoconfrontthechallengesweface,especiallythatofavertingdangerousclimatechange.Therapidgrowthinenergydemandindevelopingcountriesandan inevitable
declineintheavailabilityofcheapandabundantoilmakeanearlystartonarenewableenergytransformationallthemoreimperative.
A globalscale combination of targeted price supports, policy coordination, andextensionprogramstorampuprenewablesoverthenext1020yearshasthepotentialtomakethetransformationhappen.Bypushingdownthepriceofrenewableenergy,wecanraiselivingstandardsofpoorpeople,boostoureconomiesandsignificantlyincrease
ourchancesoflivinginaworldofrelativeclimatestability.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
21/23
18
It is realistic to imagine that implementation of this strategy couldbeginwithin twoyears of the conclusion of the Copenhagen climate summit (CoP15). Internationaldialoguenecessarily takes time, but two yearswould beadequate for anacceleratedprogramof fashioning therelevant globalpolicyagreements, thoroughlyinvestigating
thefinancingoptions,anddrawinguptheappropriateinstitutionaldesigns.Thistwoyear period of implementation planningwould afford the opportunity for additionalresearch and refinement as well as pilot testing, drawing on examples and models
aroundtheworld,ofthosemechanismsandprogramsenvisionedunderthisstrategy.Itwouldgive the international community the opportunity toestablish, in time for the20thanniversaryoftheUnitedNationsConferenceonEnvironmentandDevelopment,afullyconvincingandconfidenceinspiringresponsetothechallengesacknowledgedand
thepromisesmadeinAgenda21.Great global transitions do not happen instantaneously. Years of visionary thinking,
innovativeactions,andmanysmallstepsseemtoproduceonlymarginalresultsforaperiodoftime;butoncetheyreachatippingpoint,theircollectiveimpactgeneratesan
acceleratingvirtuouscycle,andtheoutcomebecomesoverwhelminglygreaterthanthesumoftheinitialincrementalsteps.
Soit can bewiththeadoptionand implementationof this strategy. The incrementalactions of nations, international institutions, and initiatives large and small, in the
public,private,andcivilsocietysectors,overmanyyears,havepavedthewayforthisopportunity.Thepartsareallthere.Itistimetosumthemuptomakeabigpushthatwillcarryusbeyondthetippingpointandtoachieveanimpactgreaterthanwhatwecurrentlybelievetobepossible.
ThetimehascomeforaGlobalGreenNewDeal.
SourcesAvato, Patrick, and Jonathan Coony (2008). Accelerating Clean Energy TechnologyResearch, Development, and Deployment: Lessons from Nonenergy Sectors. WorldBankWorkingPaperNo.138.
AVOID Met Office Hadley Center (2009). Can we achieve 2 C? Briefing paperpreparedbyAVOIDConsortium: MetOfficeHadley Center,Walker Institute, Tyndall
CentreforClimateChangeResearch,GranthamInstitute,UKDepartmentofEnergyand
ClimateChange.Banuri,Tariq(2007).Adevelopmentroundofclimatenegotiations.Paperpreparedfor
theStockholmEnvironmentInstitute.March.Birdsall,Nancy,andArvindSubramanian(withDanHammerandKevinUmmel)(2009).
EnergyNeedsandEfficiency,NotEmissions:ReframingtheClimateChangeNarrative.CenterforGlobalDevelopment,WorkingPaper187(November).CommitteeonClimateChange(UK)(2009).MeetingCarbonBudgets-theneedforastepchange.FirstannualprogressreporttotheUKgovernment.
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
22/23
8/3/2019 Cc Global Green New Deal
23/23
UnitedNations,Departmentof EconomicandSocialAffairs(UN/DESA)(2009).WorldEconomicandSocialSurvey2009:PromotingDevelopment,SavingthePlanet.United Nations Environment Program, Sustainable Energy Finance Initiative (UNEPSEFI) (2009). Public Finance Mechanisms to mobilise investment in climate change
mitigation: Anoverview ofmechanisms beingused today to help scale up the climatemitigationmarkets,withaparticularfocusonthecleanenergysector.AdvanceDraft.