champions & trolls the highs & lows of life as a
Community manager
16 january 2014
(or more accurately… a personal reflection on 10 years of the CIPD online community…)
The early days… before the forums
These days… it’s all about ‘me’http://www.newyorker.com/humor/issuecartoons/2013/11/25/cartoons#slide=1
what do our members want & need?
community = it’s all about ‘us’
2003
The community ‘pilot’ began in September.
2003
and within 3 weeks… we had to learn to deal with difficult questions
2003
You cannot always ‘vet’ who wants to be your friend
2004
Anyway… the “Communities” (as we’ve come to know them) were launched in January, after a successful four-month pilot.
August - joined
2004
0
250
500
750
1,000
Jan04Feb
04
Mar04
Apr04
May04
Jun04Jul04
Aug04
Sept0
4Oct0
4
Nov04
Dec04
Unique ContributorsPosts
“Joining the CIPD is one of the best investments I have made in 13 years of self-employment.” - Rachel B
2005
We invited active community members to Wimbledon in October (& Feb 2006) and asked them if they would like to become ‘Champions’.
Ask me about the case of mistaken identity :)
2005
The ‘Champions’ are our greatest asset in the community… they do the heavy-lifting & are there when I feel deflated
2005
People I want to hug. Reward the community that make our project possible.
“Thanks everyone for the brilliant suggestions, and to the couple of people who have sent private messages. I’m in a good position to proceed now” - Jennifer R
2005
The discussion forums were ‘locked down’ to members-only in June.
j
“I am even more grateful that your responses are as I had hoped, and I can demonstrate to the CEO that you share my opposition to the "barmy" idea, with rational argument and examples.” - Rosemary B
At that time 93% of visitors were already members.
2005
0
250
500
750
1,000
1,250
Jan04Feb
04
Mar04
Apr04
May04
Jun04Jul04
Aug04
Sept0
4Oct0
4
Nov04
Dec04
Jan05Feb
05
Mar05
Apr05
May05
Jun05Jul05
Aug05
Sept0
5Oct0
5
Nov05
Dec05
Unique ContributorsPosts
Member-only service from
20 June
“Crumbs! It’s surprising what you can learn from these ‘ere forums” - Tim B
Cranfield Institute of Management refer to our forums as “a golden benchmark” of online communities.
2006
“This is the first time I have read a Communities page, and have found it quite illuminating! It is heartening to know that people who have to make/enforce such decisions do give them serious thought, even if the issue seems clear-cut at the outset.” - Rachel C
2006
A source for stories…
“I am very impressed and pleased with the level of support shown by CIPD members. Any career shift can be daunting, especially at this time, but such assistance is extremely helpful." - Ben S
2006
Started a private board for ‘Champions’ in May.
“Our ability to sound off a little here is something I for one value a great deal: it clears a lot of air and I believe lets us approach the community knowing we have a professional "safety-valve" of colleagues (and friends) within the "Chumps". We can disagree without undermining each other, tease out the knots from some of the more tangled threads and poke a bit of fun at each other (on those we know and love on-site) without being, or being found, offensive. I would hate to lose that safety-net.”
2006
0
250
500
750
1,000
1,250
1,500
Jan04
Mar04
May04Jul04
Sept0
4
Nov04
Jan05
Mar05
May05Jul05
Sept0
5
Nov05
Jan06
Mar06
May06Jul06
Sept0
6
Nov06
Unique ContributorsPosts
2007
A relaunch on Telligent’s Community Server platform in September.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/3484005849/
But it’s worth saying... ’community’ is about people, not platforms
tech 10%
people 90%
NFEK
LM
n
m2007
June - joined March - joined
2007
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
Jan04
Mar04
May04Jul04
Sept0
4
Nov04
Jan05
Mar05
May05Jul05
Sept0
5
Nov05
Jan06
Mar06
May06Jul06
Sept0
6
Nov06
Jan07
Mar07
May07Jul07
Sept0
7
Nov07
Unique ContributorsPosts
New tech platform on
16 Sept
“I love these forums! I’m currently studying an MBA in HR and for me I learn something new every day. It’s one of the websites I make a point of visiting every day!” - Helen V
2008
A social KPI was added to the balanced scorecard (‘visits to the online community’).
“Although I am not a regular poster I am an avid lurker and learn so much from the communities. I find reading about the application of employment law and knowledge 10x more useful than sitting with a textbook or magazine article… The Communities are invaluable to me and the primary reason I renew my CIPD membership each year.” - Leanne A
We are in business.
2008
The “CIPD Member” group on LinkedIn was created in May. It is a very different place (now has 24,000 members).
http://gapingvoid.com/2007/04/07/tiny-ship/
2008
The Apprentice (BBC)
Everyone was talking about this
“...one lives and learns from these forums.” - David B
2008
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
Jan04
Apr04
Jul04Oct0
4
Jan05
Apr05
Jul05Oct0
5
Jan06
Apr06
Jul06Oct0
6
Jan07
Apr07
Jul07Oct0
7
Jan08
Apr08
Jul08Oct0
8
Unique ContributorsPosts
New tech platform in
Sept ‘07
2009
Opinion changes over time. A few years ago more managers were getting the jitters & worrying that staff would spend too much time using social media at work
behaviours established inside the workplace
2009
http://www.flickr.com/photos/subtle_devices/2143383372/
Heather Champ
“Being a community manager is like being a piñata. People beat you with sticks and you still need to give them candy.”
1968
“When I grow up I want to be a community manager.”
Communities need filling, prodding, shepherding, policing, nurturing…
2009
Guidelines help set expectations about community members’ participation
“You always get more than your bargained for on this site, not only informative responses but comedy and poetry thrown in. I always come away from reading a thread a little wiser and often with a smile.” - Tina D
2009
Chief Advisor of Doing Things the Right Way
2009
Acknowledge when people are right - even if they are hostile
It would be a mistake to dismiss as “the awkward squad”, rather than as the critical friends or ‘strategic provocateurs’ they really are.
2009
…but do not feed the trolls
2009
We consulted…
2009
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Jan04
Apr04Jul04
Oct04
Jan05
Apr05Jul05
Oct05
Jan06
Apr06Jul06
Oct06
Jan07
Apr07Jul07
Oct07
Jan08
Apr08Jul08
Oct08
Jan09
Apr09Jul09
Oct09
Unique ContributorsPosts
New tech platform in
Sept ‘07
“Thank you for your feedback... It has been really useful particularly as I’m the only HR person within the organisation and have no one to bounce my thoughts off.” - Helen M
2010
2010
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
21 April
5,505 visitors
10%
90%26%
74%
Visits to the online community in Dec 2013
CIPD website
2010
“As someone new to HR, your responses are tremendously helpful to me. I want to be doing the right thing by staff and having the opinions of HR professionals gives me the confidence to challenge these behaviours.” - Mary M-B
2010
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Jan04
Apr04Jul04
Oct04
Jan05
Apr05Jul05
Oct05
Jan06
Apr06Jul06
Oct06
Jan07
Apr07Jul07
Oct07
Jan08
Apr08Jul08
Oct08
Jan09
Apr09Jul09
Oct09
Jan10
Apr10Jul10
Oct10
Unique ContributorsPosts
New tech platform in
Sept ‘07
“I think that these discussions are great because as someone who is working in a HR role but learning the ropes at the same time, to hear everyone else's views and experiences really helps me. This thread alone has addressed several issues... seeing the other side of the coin. I am off to read other threads to see what I can learn.” - Clare D
2011
Think carefully about what you want to say & the type of response you want to elicit.
“...the forum is well respected by the people I work for who are not in HR. If we have a particular staff issue, I will be asked ‘what was the feedback from the forum?’ It is particularly valuable to have replies with a different view point to my own, hopefully helping to make the final decision a fair one.” - Kathryn G
2011
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Jan04
Jun04
Nov04
Apr05
Sept0
5Feb
06Jul06
Dec06
May07Oct0
7
Mar08
Aug08
Jan09
Jun09
Nov09
Apr10
Sept1
0Feb
11Jul11
Dec11
Unique ContributorsPosts
New CIPD website on
28 Feb
"(The Directors) have realised that they have an issue with HR not being taken seriously in the company... This probably wouldn't have happened if I hadn't spoken to them this morning - and if I didn't have your support and guidance I may not of, so I am very grateful to you all.” - Sam O
2011
Connections created between people who before now would not have crossed paths without significant effort
target moments
http://www.flickr.com/photos/69024001@N00/140411433/
2012
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Jan04
Jun04
Nov04
Apr05
Sept0
5Feb
06Jul06
Dec06
May07Oct0
7
Mar08
Aug08
Jan09
Jun09
Nov09
Apr10
Sept1
0Feb
11Jul11
Dec11
May12Oct1
2
Unique ContributorsPosts
New CIPD website in
Feb ‘11
“The answers were as I thought, but it is still helpful to have a support network at your fingertips.” - Katie M
2013
Communities reinvented?
“CIPD forums have saved my bacon a few times.” - Charlie K
2013
Between May and September, referrals from visits to the online community generated £18,000 in membership renewals.
“I love the community. On the whole, 99% of contributors both ask and answer with a genuine openness and honesty (even though it may not read that way at first). The time and effort that a number of the community contribute - it would be interesting to calculate the actual cost / value of that to members” - Mike M
2013
Activity in October
288,526 pageviews
25,977 visits
373 contributors
6,452 unique visitors
posts2,388
2013
90230
20
8%
49%
43%
The 20 most active contributors made 43% of all the posts*
Contributors
First time posters
First time posters
26%68%
6%
Posts (%)* this is entirely normal and to be expected. (Figures from December 2013)
2013
Not all will contribute. Not all need to contribute to create social value
http://www.flickr.com/photos/edublogger/490871942/
2013
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Jan04
Aug04
Mar05
Oct05
May06
Dec06
Jul07Feb
08
Sept0
8
Apr09
Nov09
Jun10
Jan11
Aug11
Mar12
Oct12
May13Dec
13
Unique ContributorsPosts
New CIPD website in
Feb ‘11
New tech platform in
Sept ‘07
“I have to admit that the Communities is the main reason I renew. Since I've been in my standalone role I find it invaluable and would have many a sleepless night without it!” - Sally W
2014
“The forum is a terrific resource that I make use of daily to keep myself up to speed. There's nowhere better for seeing how HR practice happens in the real world.” - Robey J
2014
Our members will increasingly want to access & post to the community from their mobile device and tablets.
“Thank you for sharing your valuable experiences which continue to inspire and steer me in the right direction.” - Gwinyai M
2014We know that members spend at least twice as long on the forums than elsewhere on the website. These members purchase more products as a consequence of their engagement and our engagement with them.
We know the online community is a highly valued benefit of membership, and an important place for staying in touch with CIPD, especially while ‘in transition’.
“Much of the art of community is subtle, undocumented, and unwritten” - Jono Bacon
The next challenge: to move from institutions to networks…
2014
Designed for divisions
Designed for connections
"It's not just about delivering content to members, it's about the convening power to help members discover each other.” - Steve B
Thanks to…• Flickr Creative Commons and the people who licensed their photos • Jono Bacon and Heather Champ for being so quotable • Dave Gray for permission to use his graphic • Dilbert.com for the cartoon strip • Kevin & Amanda for their free fonts
“Much of the art of community is subtle, undocumented, and unwritten” - Jono Bacon