NAME OF FIRM(S)
1 Metric Engineering Inc.
1A - Proposer's Experience and Qualifications (Max. 35 points) 28 30 32 902A - Proposer's Team Experience (Max. 35 points) 28 29 30 873A - Experience of Senior Project Administrator/Engineer (Max. 10 points) 6 8 9 234A - CEI Philosophy, Methodology and Process (Max. 10 points) 8 8 9 255A - Technical Approach (Max. 10 points) 7 8 8 23
Qualitative Scores 77 83 88 248 3
Ale
jand
ro B
arrio
s (M
iam
i-Dad
e C
ount
y)
Gira
ldo
"Ger
ry"
Mar
quez
(OC
I/CO
M)
FIN
AL
RA
NK
SUB
-TO
TAL
QU
ALI
TATI
VE S
CO
RES
TOTA
L SC
OR
ES
Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager
REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034
Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI
EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING
John
De
Pazo
s (O
CI/C
OM
)CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP
PROJECT B-30624
Thursday, May 3, 2018 EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS
TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034
DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENT
Page 1 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson
Ale
jand
ro B
arrio
s (M
iam
i-Dad
e C
ount
y)
Gira
ldo
"Ger
ry"
Mar
quez
(OC
I/CO
M)
FIN
AL
RA
NK
SUB
-TO
TAL
QU
ALI
TATI
VE S
CO
RES
TOTA
L SC
OR
ES
Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager
REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034
Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI
EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING
John
De
Pazo
s (O
CI/C
OM
)CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP
PROJECT B-30624
Thursday, May 3, 2018 EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS
TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034
DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENT
2 R.J. Behar & Company, Inc.
1A - Proposer's Experience and Qualifications (Max. 35 points) 27 29 34 902A - Proposer's Team Experience (Max. 35 points) 27 31 34 923A - Experience of Senior Project Administrator/Engineer (Max. 10 points) 9 9 9 274A - CEI Philosophy, Methodology and Process (Max. 10 points) 9 8 9 265A - Technical Approach (Max. 10 points) 9 9 10 28
Qualitative Scores 81 86 96 263 2Page 2 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson
Ale
jand
ro B
arrio
s (M
iam
i-Dad
e C
ount
y)
Gira
ldo
"Ger
ry"
Mar
quez
(OC
I/CO
M)
FIN
AL
RA
NK
SUB
-TO
TAL
QU
ALI
TATI
VE S
CO
RES
TOTA
L SC
OR
ES
Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager
REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034
Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI
EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING
John
De
Pazo
s (O
CI/C
OM
)CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP
PROJECT B-30624
Thursday, May 3, 2018 EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS
TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034
DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENT
3 Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc.
1A - Proposer's Experience and Qualifications (Max. 35 points) 30 31 32 932A - Proposer's Team Experience (Max. 35 points) 30 31 32 933A - Experience of Senior Project Administrator/Engineer (Max. 10 points) 9 9 8 264A - CEI Philosophy, Methodology and Process (Max. 10 points) 9 8 9 265A - Technical Approach (Max. 10 points) 9 9 9 27
Qualitative Scores 87 88 90 265 1Page 3 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson
Name Score JP Score GM Score AB TQP1 Criteria 1 Criteria 2 Criteria 22 Criteria 3 Criteria 4 TQP2 TQP3 Percentage FinalCalvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. 87 88 90 265 93 93 26 26 27 265 265 88.3% 1R.J. Behar & Company, Inc. 81 86 96 263 90 92 27 26 28 263 263 87.7% 2Metric Engineering Inc. 77 83 88 248 90 87 23 25 23 248 248 82.7% 3
Tota
l Poi
nts P
erce
ntag
e
EVALUATION SCORES
BY COMMITTEE
Prop
oser
's Qu
alific
atio
ns an
d Ex
perie
nce
Tota
l Poi
nts
EVALUTION SCORES BY CRITERIA
Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager
SUMMARY TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034
Gira
ldo
"Ger
ry" M
arqu
ez (O
CI/C
OM)
Aleja
ndro
Bar
rios (
Miam
i-Dad
e Cou
nty)
CEI P
hilo
soph
y, Me
thod
olog
y and
Pro
cess
Tota
l Qua
litat
ive P
oint
s
(A
ll Com
mitt
ee M
embe
rs)
Prop
oser
's Te
am E
xper
ience
John
De P
azos
(OCI
/COM
)
FINA
L RA
NKIN
G
Tech
nica
l App
roac
h
Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI
Expe
rienc
e of S
enio
r Pro
ject
Adm
inist
rato
r/Eng
inee
r
EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETINGThursday, May 3, 2018
Tota
l Qua
litat
ive P
oint
s
(A
ll Eva
luat
ion
Crite
ria)
DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENTREQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034
CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP
PROJECT B-30624
Page 4 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson