8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
1/9
Climate Variability IIClimate Variability IIMechanisms and Influences on Synoptic WeatherMechanisms and Influences on Synoptic Weather
MET 171BMET 171B
SJSUSJSU
Lecture TopicsLecture Topics
IntraIntra--seasonal modes of climate variabilityseasonal modes of climate variability
Madden Julian OscillationMadden Julian Oscillation Pacific North American OscillationPacific North American Oscillation
Annular Modes (NAO, AO)Annular Modes (NAO, AO)
InterInter--annual modes of climate variabilityannual modes of climate variability
ElEl--Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO)Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO)
InterInter--decadal modes of climate variabilitydecadal modes of climate variability
Pacific Decadal OscillationPacific Decadal Oscillation
The WeatherThe Weather--Climate GapClimate Gap
Fundamental Question:Fundamental Question: Is weather predictable at lead times longer thanIs weather predictable at lead times longer than
those of deterministic numerical weather forecasts?those of deterministic numerical weather forecasts?
Need added predictive skill in the weatherNeed added predictive skill in the weather--climate gap.climate gap.
Predictability
synoptic 10 - 30 days seasonalWEATHER INTRASEASONAL CLIMATE
This Time: El Nino
Lecture OutlineLecture Outline
ElEl--Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO)Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO)
Definitions/CharacteristicsDefinitions/Characteristics
Dynamical MechanismsDynamical Mechanisms
TeleconnectionsTeleconnections -- Influence on Synoptic WeatherInfluence on Synoptic Weather
Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO)Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO)
El NinoEl Nino--Southern OscillationSouthern OscillationBig Gorilla: most influential mode of interannual climate variabBig Gorilla: most influential mode of interannual climate variab ilityility
El NiEl NiooAn anomalous warming in eastern Pacific ocean temperaturesAn anomalous warming in eastern Pacific ocean temperatures(warm water(warm water movesmoveseast)east)
La NiLa NiaaAn anomalous cooling in eastern and central Pacific oceanAn anomalous cooling in eastern and central Pacific oceantemperatures (warm watertemperatures (warm water staysstayswest)west)
Southern OscillationSouthern OscillationPressure fluctuations centers of action in the westernPressure fluctuations centers of action in the westernPacific/eastern Indian Oceans and the southeastern PacificPacific/eastern Indian Oceans and the southeastern Pacific
1997, El Nino year (warm)1997, El Nino year (warm)
1998, La Nina year (cold)1998, La Nina year (cold)
Ocean surface temperatures
El Nino/La Nina refers to Ocean, Southern Oscillation to Atmosphere
La Nada: TheLa Nada: The NormalNormal PacificPacific
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
2/9
Characteristics of El NiCharacteristics of El Nioo
Anomalous low (high) pressure in the eastern (western) PacificAnomalous low (high) pressure in the eastern (western) Pacific
Weak or even reversed trade winds across PacificWeak or even reversed trade winds across Pacific Dry (Wet) conditions in the west (east) PacificDry (Wet) conditions in the west (east) Pacific
Deep thermocline in the eastDeep thermocline in the eastupwelling cappedupwelling capped
Characteristics of La NiCharacteristics of La Niaa
Anomalous low (high) pressure in the western (eastern) PacificAnomalous low (high) pressure in the western (eastern) Pacific
Stronger than normal trade winds across PacificStronger than normal trade winds across Pacific
Dry (Wet) conditions in the east (west) PacificDry (Wet) conditions in the east (west) Pacific
Deep thermocline in the westDeep thermocline in the westshallow in the east (cool watershallow in the east (cool water upwellsupwells))
Mean SLPMean SLP
Southern Oscillation Index (SOI)Southern Oscillation Index (SOI)Tracks seeTracks see--saw in pressure between eastern Pacific/Indiansaw in pressure between e astern Pacific/Indian
Ocean and central PacificOcean and central Pacific
Uses pressure observations from Tahiti and Darwin,Uses pressure observations from Tahiti and Darwin,
AustraliaAustralia
Determining Phase of the ENSODetermining Phase of the ENSO
Southern Oscillation Index (SOI)Southern Oscillation Index (SOI) Tracks seeTracks see--saw in pressure between eastern Pacific/Indiansaw in pressure between eastern Pacific/Indian
Ocean and central PacificOcean and central Pacific
Uses pressure observations from Tahiti and Darwin, AustraliaUses pressure observations from Tahiti and Darwin, Australia
)(diff
diffavdiff
PSD
PPSOI
=
Avg. Tahiti MSLP for month Avg. DarwinMSLP for month
Long term avg. of Pdiff forthat month (climatology)
Long-term standard deviation of Pdifffor the month
Determining Phase of the ENSODetermining Phase of the ENSO
SSTSST--based methods use measurements of sea surfacebased methods use measurements of sea surface
temperature in various averaging regions of the Pacifictemperature in various averaging regions of the Pacific
ONI (ONI (Oceanic NiOceanic Nio Index)o Index): Running 3 month average of: Running 3 month average ofNino 3.4 SSTNino 3.4 SST
El Nino/La Nina conditions declared when ONIEl Nino/La Nina conditions declared when ONI exceedsexceeds
0.5C anomaly for 5+ consecutive months0.5C anomaly for 5+ consecutive months
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
3/9
ONI and SOI are the primary indexesONI and SOI are the primary indexes OLROLRAnomolyAnomoly
There are many other indexes used totrack ENSO
Where are we now?Where are we now?Last month SSTLast month SSTAnomoliesAnomolies show that EL Nino is fadingshow that EL Nino is fading..
Where are we going?Where are we going? Characteristics of ENSOCharacteristics of ENSO
Begins to develop in early summerBegins to develop in early summer
Maximum amplitude in DecMaximum amplitude in Dechence its namesakehence its namesake
Strongest atmosphericStrongest atmospheric
teleconnectionsteleconnections
in DJFin DJF
Decays rapidly FebDecays rapidly Feb--MarMar
Typically last 12Typically last 12--18 mo18 mo
Return Interval of 2Return Interval of 2--7 years : Why 27 years : Why 2--7 years?7 years?
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
4/9
Evolution of 1997Evolution of 1997--1998 El Nino1998 El Nino
Dynamical Theories of ENSODynamical Theories of ENSO
BjerknesBjerknes OceanOcean--Atmosphere FeedbackAtmosphere Feedback Positive feedback loop that fosters developmentPositive feedback loop that fosters development
Chicken (ocean) vs. Egg (atmosphere) issueChicken (ocean) vs. Egg (atmosphere) issue
Delayed Oscillator TheoryDelayed Oscillator Theory Stochastic TheoryStochastic Theory
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
5/9
HigherSSTineastPacific LowerSSTineastPacific
Winds SST
Bjerknes TheoryBjerknes TheoryBjerknes TheoryBjerknes Theory
Positive feedback between circulation and SSTPositive feedback between circulation and SST Explains the amplification of a warm or cold ENSO eventExplains the amplification of a warm or cold ENSO event
but does not explain the transition between the twobut does not explain the transition between the two Questions remain:Questions remain:
What causes transition to events of opposite sign?What causes transition to events of opposite sign? Why do events last 12Why do events last 12 --18 months on average?18 months on average?
Theory I: Delayed OscillatorTheory I: Delayed Oscillator
Idea: systematic coupled oceanIdea: systematic coupled ocean--atmosphere feedbackatmosphere feedback
Start w/ warm ENSO, apply forcing near datelineStart w/ warm ENSO, apply forcing near dateline
Relaxation of trade winds sends oceanicRelaxation of trade winds sends oceanic RossbyRossbywavewavewest (moves very slow ~ 300 days to cross Pacific)west (moves very slow ~ 300 days to cross Pacific)
Reflection of oceanicReflection of oceanic RossbyRossbywave off western boundarywave off western boundary
of Pacific sends rapid oceanic Kelvin wave (equatoriallyof Pacific sends rapid oceanic Kelvin wave (equatoriallytrapped westerly moving wave) eastward (70 days).trapped westerly moving wave) eastward (70 days).
Kelvin WavesKelvin Waves
3. Kelvin wave causes3. Kelvin wave causes thermoclinethermocline to rise across basin, having little effectto rise across basin, having little effecton SST except in eastern Pacific whereon SST except in eastern Pacific where thermoclinethermocline is shallowestis shallowest
4. Allows cool SST to return4. Allows cool SST to return
5. SST gradient5. SST gradient intensification of trade windsintensification of trade winds positive feedbackpositive feedback
6. Process repeats and switches phases periodically6. Process repeats and switches phases periodically
This idea holds that ENSO events with positive feedbacks betweenThis idea holds that ENSO events with positive feedbacks between tradetrade
wind, SST, and convection, this theory reproduce cycles of 3wind, SST, and convection, this theory reproduce cycles of 3 --5 years5 years
Theory I: Delayed OscillatorTheory I: Delayed Oscillator
4. Allows cool SST to return4. Allows cool SST to return5. SST gradient leads to intensification of trade winds5. SST gradient leads to intensification of trade winds positivepositive
feedbackfeedback
6. Process repeats and switches phases periodically6. Process repeats and switches phases periodically
This idea holds that ENSO events with positive feedbacks betweenThis idea holds that ENSO events with positive feedbacks between
trade wind, SST, and convection, this theory reproduce cyclestrade wind, SST, and convection, this theory reproduce cycles
of 3of 3--5 years5 years
Warm Water to West,
Shallow Thermocline to East,
cool SST
Oceanic waves force
thermocline to rise and fall,
but since only shallow in the
east, resulting impact in SST
is largest there
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
6/9
Top: SST anomaly and sea level anomaly; Bottom: Thermocline Depth Anomaly
Theory II: StochasticTheory II: Stochastic
ENSO events triggered by randomENSO events triggered by random forcingsforcings from the atmospherefrom the atmosphere
Indeed ENSO cycles are not regular, therefore this theory betterIndeed ENSO cycles are not regular, therefore this theory betterconforms to observationsconforms to observations
Possible connection between burst the large scale tropicalPossible connection between burst the large scale tropicalconvective complexes associated with the MJO leading to westerlyconvective complexes associated with the MJO leading to westerly
wind bursts as a triggering mechanismwind bursts as a triggering mechanism
TeleconnectionTeleconnection
Defined:Defined: Interconnection between atmospheric circulation in oneInterconnection between atmospheric circulation in one
sector of the globe to influence directly or indirectly circulatsector of the globe to influence directly or indirectly circulationion
patterns that span large areaspatterns that span large areas
Low Frequency :Low Frequency : Longer than synoptic timescale (weeks to decades)Longer than synoptic timescale (weeks to decades)
Teleconnection toTeleconnection to MidlatitudesMidlatitudes
Low PressureTropical Convection
Example:Example: Variable 1:Variable 1: Changes in tropical Pacific SSTChanges in tropical Pacific SST
Variable 2:Variable 2: Changes in strength/location of subtropical jet overChanges in strength/location of subtropical jet over
Pacific and downstream precipitation patterns over Western USPacific and downstream precipitation patterns over Western US
Composite:Averages taken over all El Nino (La Nina) winters
Warmest SST
http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/enso/images/u200.comp.gif
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
7/9
http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/enso/images/z200.comp.gif http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/enso/images/u200.comp.la.gif
http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/enso/images/z200.comp.la.gif
Which map shows average winterWhich map shows average winter
precipitation anomaly for El Ninoprecipitation anomaly for El Nino
conditions, and which for La Nina?conditions, and which for La Nina?
ENSO Signals (WinterENSO Signals (Winter PrecipPrecip)) ENSO Signals (Winter Temp)ENSO Signals (Winter Temp)
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
8/9
ENSOENSOTeleconnectionsTeleconnections
ENSO phases alter synoptic patternsENSO phases alter synoptic patterns
Major US changes during warm events:Major US changes during warm events:
-- Subtropical Jet Extends eastward and southSubtropical Jet Extends eastward and south
-- Blocking patterns migrate eastwardBlocking patterns migrate eastward
-- PersistantPersistant positive PNA patternpositive PNA pattern
-- colder and wetter along the southern tiercolder and wetter along the southern tier
Major US changes during cold events:Major US changes during cold events:
-- subtopicalsubtopical jet weakensjet weakens
-- drier and warmer in southern tierdrier and warmer in southern tier
-- cold and wet in Pacific Northwest.cold and wet in Pacific Northwest.
-- more negative PNA patternsmore negative PNA patterns
ENSOENSOTeleconnectionsTeleconnections
Tropical Cyclone Frequency (warm phase)Tropical Cyclone Frequency (warm phase)
Reduction in TC over Australia & NW PacificReduction in TC over Australia & NW Pacific(warm water and convection shifts east)(warm water and convection shifts east)
Reduction in TC over Atlantic (increased verticalReduction in TC over Atlantic (increased vertical
shear)shear)
Increase in eastern PacificIncrease in eastern Pacific -- near Hawaii (increasednear Hawaii (increased
SST+ convection)SST+ convection)
ENSO and Global TemperatureENSO and Global Temperature
Atmosphere gains a tremendous amountAtmosphere gains a tremendous amount
of energy during ENSO events due to theof energy during ENSO events due to the
increased latent heat from the ocean.increased latent heat from the ocean.
Global temperatures spike noticeablyGlobal temperatures spike noticeably
during strong El Nino events (1C).during strong El Nino events (1C).
InsertInsert CoolingCooling Graphic HereGraphic Here
Decadal Climate VariabilityDecadal Climate Variability
InvolvesInvolves memorymemory of system: persistence of cool SST from oneof system: persistence of cool SST from onewinter to the nextwinter to the next
This means ocean processes play big role. Cool water in winterThis means ocean processes play big role. Cool water in winterduring deep mixed layer gets stored below mixed layer induring deep mixed layer gets stored below mixed layer in
summer only to reemerge next wintersummer only to reemerge next winterpersistencepersistenceStill not completely resolved whether PDO is real or artifact ofStill not completely resolved whether PDO is real or artifact of
climate systemclimate system
PDO: El NinoPDO: El Ninos Grandfathers Grandfather
Interplay between the PDO and the dominant ENSO cycles importantInterplay between the PDO and the dominant ENSO cycles important
-- 1983 and 1997 strong ENSO events occurred in years in which the1983 and 1997 strong ENSO events occurred in years in which the PDO was in a warm phasePDO was in a warm phase
leads to amplification of ENSO signal.leads to amplification of ENSO signal.
-- Switch in PDO phase in 1977 plays big role in climate patternsSwitch in PDO phase in 1977 plays big role in climate patterns across the Westacross the West
Stronger impact
2-7 yr quasi-periodic
Lasts 1-2 years
Tropical roots
Weaker impact
40 year cycles
Last ~ 2 decades
Extratropical roots
Warm Phase Warm Phase
8/3/2019 Climate Variability II (DL)
9/9
Back to the Cold Phase???Back to the Cold Phase???