19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 1
Climatic Extremes and Rare Events: Statistics and Modelling
Andreas Hense, Meteorologisches Institut
Universität Bonn
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 2
Overview
• Definition• References/Literature/Ongoing work• Precipitation data• Theory GEV/GPD• Comparison between observations and simulation• Conclusion
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 3
Definition acc. to IPCC TAR WGI
• Rare events: occurences of weather or climate states of high/low quantiles of the underlying probability distribution e.g. less than 10% / 1% ; higher then 90% / 99%
• weather state: temperature, precipitation, wind – timescale O(1day) or less– univariate: one point, one variable– multivariate: field of one variable– multivariate: one point several variables
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 4
Definition acc. to IPCC TAR WGI
• Climate states: aggregated state variables– time scale O(1m) and larger– heat waves, cold spells– stormy seasons– droughts and floods (2003 and 2002)
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 5
Definition acc. To IPCC TAR WGI
• Extreme events depend – costs or losses– see Extreme weather sourcebook by Pielke and
Klein (http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/sourcebook)
– personal perception
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 6
References/Literature/Ongoing Workwithout claiming completeness
• BAMS: 2000, Vol. 81, p.413 ff• MICE Project funded by EU Commission (J.
Palutikof, CRU) http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/projects/mice/html/extremes.html
• NCAR: Weather and Climate Impact Assessment Science Initiative http://www.esig.ucar.edu/extremevalues/extreme.html
• KNMI: Buishand Precipitation and hydrology• EVIM: Matlab package by Faruk Selcuk, Bilkent
University Ankara, Financial Mathematics
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 7
Precipitation data for illustration
• Daily sums of precipitation in Europe – 74 Stations 1903-1994
• A-GCM simulations ECHAM4 - T42 – GISST forced 40°-60°,0°-60°E daily sums
• annual mean precipitation ECHAM3 and HadCM2 ensembles of GHG szenario simulations
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 8
Theory for rare events
• Frechet,Fisher,Tippet: generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution summarizes Gumbel, Frechet and Weibull,provides information on maximum or minimum only
• Peak-over-threshold: generalized Pareto distribution GPD
• Rate of occurence of exceedance: Poisson process• last two provide informations about the tail of the
distribution of weather or climate state variables
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 9
Generalized Pareto Distribution
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 10
1/q-return value
u = 20 mm/day for the observations = 10 mm/day for simulations
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 11
Maximum likelihood estimation
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 12
Comparing observations with simulations
• Scale difference between point values and GCM grid scale variables
• two standard approaches– statistical downscaling, MOS: loss of variance
through regression– dynamical downscaling using a RCM
• upscaling of observations– fit e.g. q-return values with low order
polynomials in latitude,longitude,height
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 13
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 14
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 15
Comparing observations with simulations
• ECHAM4-T42 simulates a 20 year return value of daily precipitation similar to the 10 year return values of observations
• 10 year return values in ECHAM4-T42 are ~ 20% smaller
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 16
Uncertainty
• Large confidence intervals for estimated parameters (shape, return values)
• for models reduction through ensemble simulations
• model error estimation through multimodel analysis
• necessary for analysis of changes
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 17
Uncertainty of annual mean precipitation changes
19. September 2003 Int.Conference Earth Systems Modelling 18
Conclusion • Generalized Pareto distribution approach appears
fruitful for model as well as observation analysis• Systematic differences in the tail distributions of
precipitation between model and observations• despite upscaling (projection on large scale structures in
observations and simulations) result of coarse model scales?
• requires an analysis of the spatial covariance structure of the observations
• Ensemble simulations allow for an adjustment• Multivariate methods are necessary