7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
1/25
!"#$%&'()* ", -"#& )&.#-
Part B of the Colregs may well be the most difficult and complex part
where some terms and expressions are used that may create somemisunderstanding and/or doubt in the neophyte or young OOW.
The terms that need to be understood without any ambiguity are:
1.
Close-quarters situation2.
Risk of Collision
3.
Keep out of the way.
4.
Not to impede
All these term may or may not be used in connection with each other.
1
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
2/25
"#$%&'()*+,&+% %-,)*.$/
The term close-quarters situation has been defined and describe, iIn its
simplest form, in Rule 7.
(See Presentation, slides 7/27, 19/32).
In the figure of next slide, the following statements can be made: It is
obvious that vessels A and B represent a greater potential danger than
vessesl C, D and E. Further, vessel A is a greater danger to the own vessel
(as stand-off vessel) than vessel B (as give-way vessel) (Rule 15).
Vessel C is also a stand-on vessel but vessels D and E who are overtakingvessels, are definitely give-way vessels.
The minute a close-quarters situation is developing with another vessel
whether in sight or not there is a potential risk of collision and the
necessary action needs to be taken to get safely out of this situation. Once
a close-quarters situation has been cleared, risk of collision is theoreticallyalso cleared and any vessel outside the close-quarters zone must be
closely monitored until all risk of collision is finally passed.
The rule of thumb should be:
As far as possible, avoid any vessel to enter the close-quarters zone. 2
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
3/25
0)#& 1 ' 0-%2 $3 4$##-%-$/ 5+$6&+ )%& $3 0*7*+ 8()-69&/, :0)#& 1; < :=>>
"#$%& ()*+,&+% %-,)*.$/?
!@*,4A&7 B$/& -/ CD)+&!E $+ F 9-#&% 7&6&/7-/D $/?
!
G+&* :$6&/ %&*; /*++$H4A*//>
! I-B& */7 %6&&7 $3 J&%%! K*/$&)J+*=-#-,L $3 J&%%! @*B*+7% -/ ,A& J-4-/-,L
!
8M6&+-&/4&! N)7D&9&/,
In narrow channels:
Vessels will inevitably pass closer to
one another
"
""
"
"
AB
C
DE
3
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
4/25
Close-quarters situation
The distance of a close quarters situation is difficult to measure in miles.
It depends upon a number of factors:
-
Size and manoeuvring characteristics of the vessels
-
The speed of the vessels-
The traffic density
-
Experience and judgement of the Master and/of the OOW
-
Etc.
0)#& OP ' "$/7)4, $3 J&%%%
-/ +&%,+-4,&7 J-%-=-#-,LDetection by radar alone Rule 19 (d)
Distances of 2 to 3 miles are usually suggested, being the range of
visibility of the sidelights or the range of audibility of large vessels.
According the local circumstances, distances of less than 2 miles may
be sufficient (slow speed, overtaking, passing clearly astern, etc. 4
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
5/25
0-%2 $3 "$##-%-$/
In its simplest form, risk of collision may start to develop when two
or more vessels have approached one another so close, that if no
action is taken by one or all vessels, a collision would almost be
inevitable.
Risk of collision has been dealt with in Rule 7 and 8.
(See Presentation, slides 7/17, 7/19, 7/20, 7/21 and 8/12.)
As a general rule one could admit that when vessels approach one
another at a distance of 3 to 4 miles or less a potential risk of
collision is developing.
5
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
6/25
0)#& 1 ' 0-%2 $3 4$##-%-$/
Risk of Collision (Rule 7, (a))
It is difficult to define "risk of collision", but,the view of A.N. Cockcroft is, that "risk may
be considered to begin when two vesselshave approached so close to one another
that a departure from the rules by either
would bring danger of collision" 6
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
7/25
0)#& 1 ' 0-%2 $3 4$##-%-$/
0-%2 $3 "$##-%-$/ (Rule 7, (a))
Factors determining Risk of Collision :
! The bearing of the vessel(s)
! Distance between two vessels
! Speed of approach
! Do courses cross one another
!The number of vessels in the vicinity
If there is any doubt such risk shall be deemed to exist
7
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
8/25
0)#& 1 ' 0-%2 $3 4$##-%-$/
0-%2 $3 "$##-%-$/ (Rule 7, (a))
Some of the main difficulties in the Colregs are :
How far apart must vessels be before there is
risk of collision
When is a stand-on vessel obliged to keep
course and speed
8
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
9/25
0)#& 1 ' 0-%2 $3 4$##-%-$/
At a distance of 14,76 miles,
there is no risk of collision;
hence, the Colregs do not yet
apply
Risk of Collision (Rule 7, (a))
Risk of collision does not apply to vessels at great distances and with a
low speed of approach
Example
9
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
10/25
0)#& 1 ' 0-%2 $3 4$##-%-$/
On the open sea, a distance of
6 miles or less and with a high
speed of approach, risk of
collision may start to develop;
hence, the Colregs do apply
Risk of Collision (Rule 7, (a))
Example
In rivers, narrow channels, canals and harbours, risk of collision applies
at relative shorter distances
10
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
11/25
Keep out of the Way
When there is risk of collision between two vessels one of them musttake avoiding action (or keep out of the way) to avoid a possible
collision. There are some exceptions such as Head-on situations,
permissive actions, last minute actions and Dual actions.
(See also the relevant slides which deal with this subject).
11
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
12/25
The colregs are not applicable at long range, when thedistance between the two ships is so big that the risk of
collision does not yet exist:
Both vessels are then free to take any action
What is long range ?
This is not quantified in the colregs
It varies for each vessel according to her manoeuvringcharacteristics and dimensions
Rule 8 - Action to avoid collision
Keep in mind that : See also Rule 7, (a)
12
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
13/25
Every vessel which is directed to keep out of the way of another
vessel shall, so far as possible, take early and substantial action
to keep well clear.
Q&&6 $), $3 ,A& R*L
13
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
14/25
0)#& OS ' G4.$/ =L D-J&'H*L J&%%
K*-/ 9&*%)+&% =L D-J&'H*L J&%%
T*2& &*+#L *4.$/ :-/ *96#& .9&>
T*2& %)=%,*/.*# *4.$/ :4$)+%& */7U$+ %6&&7> Q&&6 H# 4#&*+ :6*%% *, * %*3& 7-%,*/4&>
14
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
15/25
V$, ,$ W96&7&
Not to impede may well be the most difficult term used in the Colregs. It
is also the term which is least understood by students and young OOW.
Not to impede the passage means that a vessel shall not hamper,
hinder or obstruct the passage of another vessel.
Some vessels like vessels proceeding in a narrow channel, sailingvessels, fishing vessels, deep draught vessels, etc. often cannot
maneuver at liberty or take avoiding action and hence, they should not
be impeded in their activities or in their conditional status.
Not to impede can also be described as stay away, and dont bother
the other vessel. In fact, allow her sufficient sea-room.
15
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
16/25
V$, ,$ W96&7&
Where does the expression Not to Impede appear:
! Rule 8f: Action to avoid collision
! Rule 9b: Narrow channels sailing vessels less than 20m
! Rule 9c: Narrow channels fishing vessels
! Rule 9d: Narrow channels crossing vessels
! Rule 10i: Traffic Separation
fishing vessels
! Rule 10j: Traffic Separation sailing vessels less than
20m
! Rule 18d: Responsibilities between vessels constrained by
their draught
In fact, not to impedeshould also apply to vessels not under
command, vessels restricted in their ability to maneuver (dredgers,
buoying ships, cable layers, etc),
(See also the relevant slides which deal with this subject).
16
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
17/25
0)#& X ' G4.$/ ,$ *J$-7 4$##-%-$/
Y$ /$, -96&7& ,A& 6*%%*D& Rule 8 (f) (i)
Difference between keep out of the wayand not
to impede
Keep out of the way only applies when risk of collision
exists and one of the two vessels has to take decisiveaction to avoid it
Not to impede.Risk of collision does not yet exist and the
concerned vessel is, in effect, being asked to take earlyactionto avoid such a risk developing
For more details regarding the terms: Close-quarters situation,
Risk of Collision, Not to Impede and Keep Out of the Way,
see COMPLEXITY of some TERMS after the Rule 19 slides 17
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
18/25
Keep out of the way applies as soon asrisk of collision between two ships starts to materialize
Not to impede applies before
risk of collision appears
! when there is a risk of collision
!the give-way vessel must take action to avoid it
! the vessel takes action so that"! no risk of collision starts to develop
Rule 16 - Action by give-way vessel
Do not confuse keep out of the way with not to impede
18
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
19/25
0)#& X ' G4.$/ ,$ *J$-7 4$##-%-$/
Y$ /$, -96&7& ,A& 6*%%*D& Rule 8 (f) (ii)
The obligation not to impede the passage or safe passage of another
vessel, remains even if a risk of collision already exists
In other words:
If risk of collision has developed between a not to impedevessel andanother vessel, the not to impedevessel will not automatically become a
stand-on vessel and the other vessel a give-way vessel
The not to impede vesselwill not be relieved of her obligation to keep
out of the way. Any stand-on action required by any other Rule will be
overridden
The not to impedevessel will not be relieved of her obligation
to also take the necessary action to allow sufficient room for the
passage or safe passage of the other vessel 19
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
20/25
)/& ,"0. -)12&- (3 1
!"%%(-("3 -()01)("3
20
R l 17 A ti b t d l
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
21/25
THE FOUR STAGES IN A COLLISION SITUATION
1. At long range/ Action not yet compulsory but permitted:
Before risk of collision exists both vessels are free to
take action
2. Risk of collision begins to apply:
The give-way vessel must take actionThe stand-on vessel must keep course and speed
3. When it becomes apparent that give-way vessel is
not taking appropriate action:
The stand-on vessel gives the required whistle signal R34(d)and takes action to avoid collision by her manuvre alone
4. Collision cannot be avoided by the give-way vessel
alone:
The stand-on vessel is required to take action to contribute
to the avoidance of collision
Rule 17 - Action by stand-on vesselGeneral considerations
21
R l 17 A ti b t d l
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
22/25
Action not yetcompusory
but permitted
Keep course andspeed
Action permittedSignal required
Action required
The distances at which the variousstages apply will vary considerably:
! Great for high speed vessels in
crossing situation
! In open sea, crossing situation
between power-driven vessels:
a)
outer limit to keep course and speed is
about 5 to 8 miles
b)
outer limit for permissive action is
about 2 to 3 miles
THE FOUR STAGES IN A COLLISION SITUATION
Rule 17 - Action by stand-on vesselGeneral considerations
22
R l 17 A ti b t d l
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
23/25
THE FOUR STAGES IN A COLLISION SITUATION
Action not yetcompulsory
but permitted
Keep course andspeed
Action permittedSignal required
Action required
Between 5
and 8 miles
About 2 to
3 miles
Rule 17 - Action by stand-on vesselGeneral considerations
23
Summary
Less than 1 mile
E l N Ch l
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
24/25
Example Narrow Channel
1068 4 2 A
B
C
DE
F
G
H
B: Oncoming vessel 5; Must
keep Sb of channel
A: Own vessel - VLCC
C: Sailing vessel 9,5
May act freely.
No risk of collision
D: Vessel fishing 6
Not impeding.
No risk of collision
E: Yacht < 20 m. 3,6
Impeding + Risk ofcollision
F: Power-driven vessel
Impeding + risk of collision
G: Power-driven vessel 8Not impeding + No risk of collision yet24
7/24/2019 Complexity of Some Terms
25/25
THE FOUR STAGES IN A COLLISION SITUATION
Conclusion
The previous slides are only guidelines and examples to determine atwhich distance vessels may or must take action to avoid risk of
collision or indeed a collision.
Vessels come in such a variety of sizes, speeds, manoeuvring
characteristics, etc. that strict guidelines are impossible to be given.
Special circumstances may also have their importance such as narrowchannels, hazards to navigation, the degree of visibility visibility, force
and direction of the wind, etc.
The experience of the Master and the OOW play of course a
predominant role in judging when and how to take an avoiding action.
It is consequently important to judge each situation separately and
always act according to good seamanship,
HIC AT NUNC
(Here and now)25