8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 1/28
Corporate Governance
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 2/28
What is corporate governance?
• Corporate governance is the set ofprocesses, customs, policies, laws, andinstitutions affecting the way a corporation
(or company) is directed, administered orcontrolled. Corporate governance alsoincludes the relationships among the many
stake holders involved and the goals forwhich the corporation is governed.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 3/28
Stakeholders
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 4/28
Corporate governance – an academic
point of view
It can be seen as one that
addresses “the problemsthat result from the
separation of ownership
and control”.
Shareholders
Board
Employees
Management
Separation of ownership &control
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 5/28
A simple model for corporategovernance1. Shareholders elect directors as their representatives
2. Directors vote on key issues and adopt majoritydecision
3. Directors make transparent decisions for which
shareholders and others can make them accountable4. Companies adopt accounting standards that generate
information required by directors, investors, otherstakeholders for decision-making
5. Companies adopt policies and practices compatiblewith relevant national, state, and local laws
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 6/28
McKinsey & Company Report -2001
• McKinsey and company report titled “Giving New
Life to the Corporate Governance Reform Agenda for Emerging Markets” suggests a two-
version governance chain model.• The “market model” governance chain (model 1)
described below is applicable to efficient, well-developed equity markets and dispersed
ownership prevalent in the developed industrialnations like US, UK, Canada, and Australia
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 7/28
The “market model” governance chain – Model 1
Shareholder environment Independence & performance
Capital market liquidity Transparency & accountability
I n s t i t u t i o n a l c o n t e
x t C
or p or a t e c on t ex t
Sophisticatedinstitutionalownership
Activeequity
markets
Activetakeovermarket
Non-executivemajorityboards
AlignedIncentives
Highdisclosure
Shareholderequality
Dispersedownership
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 8/28
The “control model” governance chain – Model 2
Shareholder environment Independence & performance
Capital market liquidity Transparency &
accountability
I n s t i t u t i o n a l c o n t e
x t C
or p or a t e c on t ex t
Concentratedownership
Reliance onfamily, bank,public finance
Underdeveloped Newissue market
Limitedtakeovermarket
Insider boards
Incentivesaligned with coreshareholders
Limiteddisclosures
Inadequateminorityprotection
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 9/28
Corporate Misgovernance
• Misgovernance in the US
• Misgovernance in India
• Scams in India
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 10/28
Winds of change
Prior to reforms in 1991, Indian companies wereinsulated by closed economy, a sheltered market, limitedaccess to global business, lack of competitive spirit andregulatory framework – all these changed on account of:
• Market-driven performs• Economic liberalization
• Dismantling of control and quota regime
• Delicensing and deregulation of industries
• Changes in import/export policies• Globalization of the economy within and outside the
ambit of the WTO
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 11/28
Corporate governance movementin IndiaThe movement took of:• The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII)
framed a code in 1997 and 30 large listedcompanies voluntarily adopted this code
• In 1999, the Securities and exchange Board ofIndia (SEBI, set up in 1988 and was made astatutory body in 1992) appointed a committeeheaded by Kumar Mangalam Birla to mandate
international standards of corporate governancefor listed companies• By 2003 every listed company joined the SEBI
code
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 12/28
Historical perspective of corporate
governance: from a narrow to broader vision
• Traditionally, the problem of the separation ofownership by shareholders and the control bymanagement
• Historical developments of corporatemisdemeanor and growing visions of societyfollowed
• Governance should stand up to the expectations
of all stakeholders namely employees,consumers, large institutional investors,government, and the society as a whole
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 13/28
All these had gonefar beyond the originalprescription of Milton
Friedman that thecompanies shouldconduct the businesspurely in accordance
with the desires of theshareholders
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 14/28
Growth of modern ideas ofcorporate governance
Watergate scandal which brought aboutthe end of Nixon Presidency led to thedisclosure that many companies made
illegal political contributions by bribinggovernmental officials – out came thelegislation of the Foreign and CorruptPractices Act of 1977. In the same year
Securities Exchange Commission (SEC)proposed mandatory reporting on financialcontrols.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 15/28
The Cadbury Committee
• UK was rocked by aseries of scams andbusiness collapsesduring the 1980s early 1990s.In 1991, London Stock Exchange
appointed Sir Adrian Cadburycommittee to draft acode of practicesin English corporations todefine and apply internal
controls to limit their exposureto financial losses. The committeesubmitted the “Code of BestPractices” in 1992. It includedguidelines to board of directors,non-executive directors, and those
on reporting and control.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 16/28
The Sarbanes –Oxley Act (SOA)2002• In the US, stock market began
declining in early 2000. Well-known companies like Enron,WorldCom Adelphia, GlobalCrossing, Dynegy and a few
others steeped in corruption,fraud, deception collapseddamaging investor confidence.Stock prices plummeted andinvestors lost billions of dollars.Investigations by the US
Congress and the Securitiesand Exchange Commission(SEC) brought about acomprehensive Act, theSarbanes-Oxley Act was enactedinto law on July 30, 2002.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 17/28
Sen. Paul Sarbanes Michael Oxley
The Sarbanes – Oxley Act was formulated toprotect investors by improving the accuracy andreliability of corporate disclosures. The actcontained a number of provisions that
dramatically change the reporting and corporatedirector’s governance obligations of publiccompanies, the directors, and officers.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 18/28
Issues in Corporate Governance
• Corporate governance means differentthings to different people. But to all,corporate governance is a means to an
end, the end being long term shareholder ,and importantly, stakeholder value. Goodcorporate governance practices involve
some critical and crucial issues. Theseare:
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 19/28
Distinguishing the roles of boardand management
• Business is to be managed “by or under
the direction’” of the board. The
responsibility of managing the business is
delegated to the CEO, who in turndelegates to other senior managers. Theboard is positioned between the
shareholders (owners) and the company’smanagement. The board holds importantfunctions:
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 20/28
1. Appoint and remove CEO
2. Indirectly oversee the conduct of the business
3. Review and approve company’s financial
objectives, corporate plans and objectives
4. Advice and counsel top management
5. Identify and recommend candidates to
shareholders for electing directors6. Review systems to comply with laws and
regulations
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 21/28
Composition of board and otherrelated issues• Committee elected by the shareholders of a limited company for the
policies of the company – sometimes full-time functional directorsare also appointed.
• The SEBI appointed Kumar Mangalam Birla’s report defined thecomposition of the board as:
“The board of directors of a company shall have an optimumcombination of executive and non-executive directors with not lessthan 50 per cent of the board of directors to be non-executivedirectors. The number of independent directors would dependwhether the chairman is executive or non-executive. In case of anon-executive chairman, at least one –third of the board shouldcomprise independent directors and in case of executive chairman,at least half of the board should be independent directors.”
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 22/28
Board of Directors
Executive Directors Non-Executive Directors
Independent Directors Affiliated Directors(Nominee Directors)
Types of Directors
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 23/28
• Executive director – an executive of thecompany and also a member of the board
• Non-Executive director – no employmentrelationship
• Independent non-executive directors – free fromany business or other relationship which mayinterfere with the exercise of independent
judgment
• Affiliated director – who has some kind ofindependence, yet may have links withsuppliers, customers, etc.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 24/28
Roles of CEO and Chairperson
• The composition of the board is a major issue
• Professionalizing of family companies should start withthe composition of the board.
• Combining the roles of CEO and Chairperson prevalent
in US and India result in conflicting interests anddecision making. In UK and Australia the CEO can notbe the chairperson of the board.
• CEO is to lead the senior management and thechairperson is to lead the board and more over it may betoo heavy to handle both jobs by one person.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 25/28
Disclosure and Audit
• The Cadbury Report termed audit as “one of the corner stones of corporate governance”.Audit provides a basis for reassurance to theshare holders and everyone else who has a
financial stake in the company. Audits raise ahost of issues:1. Should boards establish audit committees?
How should it be composed?
2. How to ensure the independence of theauditor?3. What about the non-audit services rendered by
the auditors?
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 26/28
Recent corporate scandalsinvolving auditors
Arthur AndersenAccountancy firm ArthurAndersen was declaredguilty of obstructing
justice by shredding
documents relating to thefailed energy giant Enron.The verdict could be thedeath knell for the 89-yearold company, once one ofthe world's top fiveaccountants.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 27/28
• Andersen has already lost much of itsbusiness, and two-thirds of its once 28,000strong US workforce. Following the
conviction, multi-million dollar lawsuitsbrought by Enron investors andshareholders demanding compensation
are likely to follow, and could bankrupt thefirm.
8/3/2019 Corporate Governance Summary
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corporate-governance-summary 28/28
Satyam
• Price Waterhouse resigned as statutory auditor ofSatyam Computer Services Ltd with effect from February12, 2009, while stating that it would co-operate with theongoing investigations into the Rs 7,800 crore fraud at
the IT major.