crime and air pollution
Ozone Depleting Substances
Henk Ruessink
ECENA course, Boedapest, December 2008
2
What are ODS?
• Substances that destroy the ozone layer– Cfc – Chloro Fluoro Carbons– Hcfc – Hydro Chloro Fluoro Carbons– Other ODS
• ODS are man-made volatile compounds– Refrigerants– Foaming agents, sprays– Solvents– Fire Extinghuisers (halons)
3
The Ozone Layer
• Protects our planet from the sun• Filters ultraviolet-B radiation• UV-B is harmful for health, nature and materials• Found in at 10 and 50 km altitude – stratosphere• Concentration of varies through natural causes
4
The Ozone Hole• 1985: thinning of OL above Antartica• Scientific evidence ODS play important role• Emission lags behind usage of ODS• Ongoing decreases of OL from 1970s• UV-B radiation increased ever since
5
Intermezzo: Effect of UV-B radiation
• Human health – skin cancer, cataract, immune deseases
• Environmental – More tropospheric ozone (thus respiratory illness)– Climatic impacts
• Ecosystems – Terrestial and aquatic– Food chains and cycles
• Materials – Damaging properties, e.g. of plastics
8
Worldwide response
• First alert: Vienna Convention 1985 (non-binding)• Formal Multilateral Agreement in Sept. 1987
Montreal Protocol on Substances that deplete the Ozone Layer
• Into force: January 1989• Protocol ratified by 193 nations• Missing: Andorra, San Marino, Timor Leste
9
Basics of the Montreal protocol
• Phased banning of production, trade and use of ODS• Ultimate goal: elimination• Different timeframes per subgroup of ODS, e.g.
– CFC phased out from 1991 to 1996– HCFC phased out from 1996 to 2030
• Some exemptions for ‘essential use’• For developing countries: delayed phase out • Implementation through national or regional legislation
10
European Regulation ODS
• Regulation EU 2037/2000 of June 2000• Works directly in the EU Member States• Based on Montreal Protocol and its amendments• Refers to:
– production, – Import & export – trade & application– recycling & destruction
• Enforcement and sanctioning: national responsibility
11
Enforcement aspects
• MP does not have strong own enforcement chapter• Enforcement through national implementation• (Inter)national cooperation is essential, however
– Particularly between Customs and Environmental agencies
• Still substantial illegal trade in banned products• Indications that up to 20% of trade is illegal• Value of this black market: up to 60 million USD
12
Drivers for illicit operations
• Market mechanism of demand and supply– Growing consumption, globalisation– Different time-frames for developing and developed countries
• Economic incentives– Making money (criminals)– Saving expenses (consumers)
• Regulatory aspects– Legislation ‘defines’ new crime– Opportunities through ambiguity, unclearity, contradictions – Lack of effective (inter)national control and enforcement
13
Fraudulent approaches
• Recycled versus virgin• Mislabeling CFC, e.g. as HCFC• Using wrong customs codes• Traditional smuggling of containers, cylinders• Smuggling in (used) compressors or equipment