7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
1/18
Discovery DiscussionDebateEconomic Inequality Latin America
Latin America has used education to try to bridge the
gap. Does this work in any country? Discover your
ideas. Discuss and form opinions. Debate the opinions
you have formed.
Dr. Paul R. Friesen
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
2/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 1 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
Title:
Gini back in the bottle An unequal continent is becoming less so
Discover Ideas(Outline)
Discuss the Story
(3 Question Levels)
Create Opinions
Economic Inequali ty- Latin America
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
3/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 2 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
Before you start
Look through the idea, front to back.
The ideas in red are just ideas. Students should add to these.
There is an outline page for Discovery.
There are graphic organizer pages for the Discussion and Debate sections.
The reason for the worksheets, at the end of the book, is to help you work
systematically through the material. Worksheets are helpers and can be a distraction
from the rhythm and sequence in your teaching. By putting them at the end they
become support pages versus places to stop, giving a smoother presentation.
DiscoveryIn the beginning of each story you will have a few questions to discover what you
know, or think you know about a story. The Title of the article/ story will be givenand you will be asked to discover the story by asking good questions.
In the second part ofdiscovery you will be asked to find words which you do not
know. Some of these may be highlighted already in bold. Definitions will follow to
help you discover what the writer is talking about.
Discovery will help youform a plan for the discussion and debate.
DiscussionDiscussion is not a debate, though it can quickly become one if there are strong
opposing ideas in the group.
Discussion can be a part of the discovery before you read the story. It may also come
after to discuss the ideas of the story. Sometimes a persons views may change after
reading the article, which is a good way to start a discussion.
Discussion is interaction without a lot of structure. Be careful not to confuse
discussion with argument.Debate is about argument. Discussion is about sharing
your views and interacting with others who want to expand or give a differing
viewpoint.DebateDebate is a structured idea. It means that only one person speaks in turn, and with a
specific point to address. It also has a time limit, so the speaker must be precise in
their argument. In a debate the key is to listen and be prepared to oppose the other
teams ideas. It takes research, a lot of work, and patience.
In the following story we want to begin with discovery ideas. What can you know
from a title, if you dont know about the topic?
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
4/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 3 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
In discovery you will form ideas to create basics ideas for an outline. In discussion
you will ask questions to help you build an outline for your viewpoint. In debate you
will separate the outline into two sections, for and against. At each stage you will be
able to use what you have learned before, to expand on your ideas and understand
both sides of the issue.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
5/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 4 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
DiscoveryTitle: Gini back in the bottle
An unequal continent is becoming less so
What can you know from the title?
.______________________________________________.______________________________________________.______________________________________________.______________________________________________.______________________________________________
What do I know about this topic?
.__________________________________________.__________________________________________.__________________________________________.__________________________________________
What would make me depressed?
.__________________________________________.__________________________________________.__________________________________________.__________________________________________
What do you think is a good model to close the economic gap?
___________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
6/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 5 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
.Now read the story..Create an outline of the story / paragraphs..There is a list of words on the side for you to find..After you have found the words, look in the definitions, which
follow the story.
.Discoverthe words you dont know.Economic I nequali ty
Latin America ~ Gini back in the bottle
An unequal continent is becoming less soOct 13th 2012
Michael Jackson brought Santa Marta a moment
of fame. In February 1996, the King of Pop landed
by helicopter at the top of one of Rio de Janeiros
most notoriousfavelas. Politicians tried to stop
him, but Mr Jackson had permission from the drug
barons, who ruled the slum. He danced down the steep paths between shacks
clinging precariously to the mountainside; surrounded by a cheering crowd of
Rios poorest citizens, andbelted out his hit single They dont care about us.
The music video was played around the world. It trained a spotlight on Rios
poverty and inequality.
Sixteen years later Santa Marta is once again a showcase, but of a better sort.
It was the firstfavelato be pacified under a government plan towrest
control of Rios slums from the drug lords. The place was stormed by the army
in 2008. It now has a police station, and is peaceful. It is a thriving example of
the boom at the bottom of Brazilian society.
Meet Salete Martins, a bubbly 42-year-old, whose family moved to Santa
Marta from Brazils north-east when she was eight. By day she works as a
trainee tour guide, showing visitors around her neighborhood for a city-
financed non-profit group calledRio Top Tours. At night she studies tourism
at a local college. On weekends, she sells Bahian food from a bustling stall
near thefavelas entrance. And in between she flogs a popular
line of beauty products. Her monthly income is around 2,000
reais ($985), four times as much as she made selling
sandwiches three years ago, and more than three times the
minimum wage. She plans to launch her own tour-guide
company before the end of this year.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
7/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 6 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
Ms. Martins success is striking, even in Santa Marta. But it mirrors a trend
that has swept the whole of Latin America. Poor peoples incomes have surged
over the past decade, leading to a big drop in inequality. In most Latin
American countries the Gini coefficient in 2010 was lower than in 2000. The
regions average, at 0.5, is down from almost 0.54 a decade ago, and lower
than at any time in the past 30 years (see chart 3), though still high relative to
other regions. Judging by evidence from Argentina, the only country in Latin
America to publish statistics on tax returns of top earners, the richest 1% are
still pulling ahead of the rest. That concentration is more than made up for by
the narrowing of gaps further down the income scale.
Both shifts are reflected in popular culture. Mulheres ricas (Rich women)
is a new reality-TV show about Brazils ultra-wealthy (I bathe in mineral
water every day, said one woman in an early episode). The countrys most
popular prime-time soap is Avenida Brasil, which documents life among thenewly minted middle classes. Although Latin America saw only half the
average GDP growth of emerging Asia over the past ten years, its poverty rate
fell by 30%. Around a third of the decline is due to improvements in income
distribution.
How did a continent that had been egregiouslyunequal since the
conquistadoresland grab suddenly change course? Not because of radical
nationalization and redistribution. Latin America has a few asset-seizing hard-
left governments, notably Argentina and Venezuela, but inequality has also
fallen in countries following a more orthodox economic course, such as Chile
and Colombia. Nor is the turnaround just a side-effect of the commodities
boom. Inequality has fallen in countries that rely heavily on exports of
commodities, such as Peru, but also in those where manufacturing plays a
bigger role, such as Mexico. Nor can demography be the main cause. Poorer
Latin American families have become smaller, which reduces inequality, but
these changes were well under way in the 1980s and 1990s.
According to Nora Lustig, an economist at the University of Tulane and one of
the first to document the narrowing of the regions income gaps, two thingshave made a big difference. First, the premium for skilled workers has been
falling: a surge in secondary education has increased the supply of literate,
reasonably well-schooled workers, and years of steady growth have raised
relative demand for the less skilled in the formal workforce, whether as
construction workers or cleaners. Second, governments around Latin America
have reinforced the narrowing of wage gaps with social spending targeted at
people with the lowest incomes. These include more generous pensions and
conditional cash transfersschemes that offer payment to the poorest families
in return for meeting specific conditions, such as making sure their childrengo to school.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
8/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 7 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
The most striking change has been in education. In the past Latin American
governments lavished cash on universities. State primary and secondary
schools were underfunded and of appalling quality. That bias in favour of
tertiary education, perversely, most benefited the children of the rich, who had
attended private primary and secondary schools. But since the early 1990s
education spending has become much more progressive, with a huge
expansion in public secondary education among the poor. According to Karla
Breceda, Jamele Rigolini and Jaime Saavedra, three economists at the World
Bank, Latin American governments, on average, now spend a larger share of
GDP on education for the poorest 20% of children than does the United States.
More progressive spending has produced results. Some countries have seen an
increase of 20 percentage points in the share of children finishing secondary
school. Another study for the World Institute for Development Economics
Research in Helsinki by Guillermo Cruces, Carolina Garca Domench and
Leonardo Gasparini showed that the gap between rich and poor in secondary-school enrolment has fallen in all countries except El Salvador, Honduras,
Guatemala and Nicaragua.
Many Latin countries are also championing pre-school education. Rios city
government, for instance, has dramatically increased its network of nursery
schools since 2009, building 74 new ones in the past three years. Any child
from a family below the poverty line is guaranteed a free place in a nursery
from the age of six months.
]
A nudge in the right direction
Conditional cash transfers (CCTs) reinforce this focus on schooling. These
stipends cost relatively little (typically 0.2-0.8% of GDP) but influence the
priorities of many. About a quarter of Brazils population now gets some
money from Bolsa Famlia, the countrys CCT scheme. State and local
governments piggyback on top. In Rio, for instance, the city supplements
Bolsa Famlia payments for 700,000 of its poorer families. If children do
exceptionally well in exams, a bonus is paid. If they miss school, the payment
stops. Ms. Martins realized her 14-year-old was skipping school, only when
her monthly stipend was docked. Several academic studies in Mexico showthat kids in CCT schemes stay at school longer.
Better education is boosting social mobility. Historically, the link between
parents and childrens education has been closer in Latin America than
anywhere else. In Peru, for instance, almost 70% of a childs educational
achievement can be predicted from its fathers schooling. But a forthcoming
report from the World Bank suggests that the current generation of Latin
American children are both better educated than their parents, and moving
relatively faster up the education ladder. And, like Indias poorest castes,disadvantaged indigenous people have made big gains.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
9/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 8 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
These newly educated workers enjoy far better prospects in the formal
workforce than their parents did. State pensions have become more generous.
Countries from Argentina to Bolivia have introduced non-contributory
pension schemesin effect, a promise of government support for the elderly.
Minimum wages across the continent have soared. Brazils has risen by more
than 50% in real terms since 2003. And since pension benefits are linked to
the minimum wage, the two trends reinforce each other.
The precise contribution of better education, better opportunities for less
skilled workers and bigger social spending differs by country. An analysis by
Ms Lustig, Luis Lpez-Calva of the World Bank and Eduardo Ortiz-Juarez of
the United Nations Development Programme suggests that narrower wage
gaps explain most of the reduction in inequality throughout the region.
According to calculations by Marcelo Neri, of the Institute for Applied
Economic Research, government transfers explain about one-third of the dropin inequality in Brazil.
Vocabulary Check
Find the colored words. Write a definition you can discover from the story if
possible.
__________
1. ______________________________________________________
__________2. ______________________________________________________
__________
3. ______________________________________________________
__________
4. ______________________________________________________
__________
5. ______________________________________________________
__________
6. ______________________________________________________
__________
7. ______________________________________________________
__________
8. ______________________________________________________
__________
9. ______________________________________________________
___________
10. ______________________________________________________
__________
11. ______________________________________________________
__________
12. ______________________________________________________
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
10/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 9 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
__________
13. ______________________________________________________
__________
14. ______________________________________________________
__________
15. ________________________________________________________________
16. ______________________________________________________
__________
17. ______________________________________________________
__________
18. ______________________________________________________
__________
19. ______________________________________________________
__________
20. ______________________________________________________
__________21. ______________________________________________________
__________
22. ______________________________________________________
__________
23. ______________________________________________________
__________
24. ______________________________________________________
__________
25. ______________________________________________________
__________
26. ______________________________________________________
__________
27. ______________________________________________________
__________
28. ______________________________________________________
__________
29. ______________________________________________________
__________
30. ______________________________________________________
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
11/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 10 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
DiscoveryWhat do I know about this topic?
List at least four (4) different ideas you have found in this story..__________________________________________.__________________________________________.__________________________________________.__________________________________________
Use them when you make your outline.
Discussion
Level I
.Education is the only way to help people become equal. Explain..Latin America does not have a rich/poor problem, or does it?.What is the biggest problem in Latin America?
Level II
.Will paying parents to keep their children in school help the economic inequality?.Will education solve the drug and gang problems in Latin America? Explain..Will increasing the minimum wage solve the economic inequality?.Why does education help solve economic inequality? Explain.
Level III
.What is the solution to Indias caste system and economic inequality? Explain..Would giving stipends to families work in all countries? Explain..What other solutions would work globally to bring the economic gap together?
You now have everything you need to fill out your outline.
Look at your answers, underDiscussion, andfill it outto reflect the
new ideas. These new ideas will help you form your debate ideas better.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
12/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 11 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
In debate you will have a statement not a question. You have to react to the statement
with facts, not opinions.
Discussions are based a lot on opinions and answer questions. This is wherethese two ideas, though similar, are different.
Debate is about facts and statements.
When you make a statement, from a story,you must consider what the coreissue is. If you have made a good outline, you will have this already
discovered.
This story is from economics. The core issue could be;
social economicpolitical culture
In todays world the topics could range from;
social responsibility government controlpeople power democracy
the super-rich economics
These are all good argument that you would want to research for your argument, or
write in your essay. Build the argument starting from Why? Once you have
determined the Why? you can find facts to support your idea.
Countries which spend money on education incentives will reduce theirincome gap disparity.
All families should receive stipends to keep their high school students inschool.
Countries should spend most of the money on preschool education, not middleor high school.
Before you startchoose one of the above statements to focus on. Choose afor or against position.
Research to find FACTS for your position.
List the facts.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
13/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 12 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
Write out your argument in a long paragraph format. Include the oppositeposition in your writing.
You need to write out both sides so you can understand theother sides argument.
Discovery OutlineMain topic ________________________
Find one(1) key ideain each paragraph. (3-5 words)
Paragraph 1 ______________________________
Paragraph 2 ______________________________
Paragraph 3 ______________________________
Paragraph 4 ______________________________
Paragraph 5 ______________________________
Write two thingsabout the main paragraph idea.
Paragraph 1 ______________________________
A. ______________________________
B. ______________________________
Paragraph 2 ______________________________
A. ______________________________
B. ______________________________
Paragraph 3 ______________________________
A. ______________________________
B. ______________________________
Paragraph 4 ______________________________A. ______________________________
B. ______________________________
Paragraph 5 ______________________________
A. ______________________________
B. ______________________________
In the introduction you use the 5 paragraph ideas to communicate the order ofyour argument/ essay.
In the conclusion you repeat what you have said about the points of eachparagraph.
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
14/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 13 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
Graphic Organization ~
Main topic = 5 Paragraph Topics
Main
topic
paragraph 1
________________________________________________
paragraph 2________________________________________________
paragraph 3
________________________________________________
paragraph 4________________________________________________
paragraph 5
________________________________________________
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
15/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 14 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
Discussion Graphic ~ Is this phenomenon a problem / becoming a problem in
todays society?
Answer ~ I think economic inequality is (a / becoming a) problem because
Problem /
Economic Inequality
Spending goverment moneyon preshool education will
solve the economic gap.
Respond
Respond
Minimum wage is the problem.We should raise the minimum
wage to a living standard.
Respond
Respond
Latin America's solutions willwork in any coutnry, because
we all pay taxes to governments.
Respond
Respond
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
16/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 15 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
graphic ~ choose one statement from the list
above.
Write it here _____________________________________________
________________________________________________________
To make your argument you should understand that they are connected.
In the next two charts (1) list your argument facts and ideas, (2) show how your
argument connects to both the center point and the other points.
FactsFor Against
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Add more if needed
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
17/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 16 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Graphic organizers from MS Office templates
graphic ~ choose one statement from the list
above.
Now start the .
As a team choose which points they will speak about.
Each person will listen for the opposite point and create a new
response to what the other person has said.
A: point 1
B: responds to the point and give a new point.
C: responds to B and give a new point.
After all persons have spoken each person can respond to any point given by the
opposite team, or add more points from their team which will need responding to
from the opposite team.
If this -- then
If this -- then
If this -- then
If this -- then
If this -- then
Write your statement position here.________________________________________
________________________________________
________________________________________
______________________________
7/30/2019 Discover Discussion Debate - Economic Inequality - Latin America
18/18
Discovery Discussion Debate
Design Dr. Paul R. Friesen 2013 Page 17 of17
Original Story copyright of original author
Dear Teacher/ Student,
After you have finished this please look for more in this series to challenge yourself.
This is only part of a curriculum. It starts with Dr. Roys Everything Grammar.
Dr. Roys Everything Grammar Volumes I and II will develop the skills of story andessay writing, while at the same time building a foundation in grammar. The
repetition of grammar, combined with reason and speaking, culminating in a story or
essay will prepare students for this series.
Going beyond this book is a book to expand the outlines into essays. Good essays are
able to build and defend an argument. Building a structure for debate will springboard
off this skill set.
Dr. Paul R. Friesen