1
Electronic Information Electronic Information Resources for Fraud Resources for Fraud
ExaminersExaminers
Presented to the
Spokane Chapter
Association of Certified Fraud Examiners
2008 Annual Fraud Conference
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/20091
2008 Annual Fraud Conference
November 14, 2009
By
Jim Cronin, CFE, MPA
Seattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
Objective:
Provide attendees of all experience levels useful knowledge of public and proprietary information sources that will assist
th i d ti f d
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
them in conducting fraud investigations
Housekeeping• All handouts (and more) are on my
SkyDrive• My business cards are available up front.• Send me an email!!
• I will respond with link to the Skydrive
• Call me with questions – I’m always happy
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
to help.• If you see something interesting … Call or
email me!
2
OverviewOverview• Legal & Ethical
Considerations• What
information is available?
• Public vs
• Uses of Information in Fraud Investigation
• Sources of Information
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/20094
• Public vs. Proprietary Sources
• Investigative Tools
• Search Techniques
• Questions and Discussion
Legal & Ethical ConsiderationsLegal & Ethical Considerations
• FCRA• GLB• DPPA• Privacy Act• NCIC Information
Invasion of Privacy
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/20095
• Invasion of Privacy• Public Disclosure
Laws• FOIA• State Laws
Ethical ConsiderationsEthical Considerations• Professional Responsibilities as CFE’s• Advances in Law vs. Technology• Future Trends
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/20096
3
GLB Permissible Purposes
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
DPPA Permissible Purposes
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
Uses of Information in Fraud Uses of Information in Fraud InvestigationsInvestigations
• Confirming Identities• Alias identification• Locating People• Address Histories• Reveal Business
Affiliations• Criminal Histories
• Background Investigations
• Asset & Encumbrance Investigations
• Expert Witness Location & Evaluation
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/20099
• Litigation Histories• Financial Profiles• Claims Histories
4
Alias IdentificationAlias IdentificationIf you’re not who you say you are, everything else is
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200910
MOOT!
Address HistoriesAddress HistoriesYou need to know
what addresses your subject has used in order to know where to look for records.
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200911
Address Histories cont’d…Address Histories cont’d…• Remember…..
Nobody lives in a Post Office Box!
• Everybody has a physical location.
• Most of us have physical addresses!
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200912
physical addresses!
5
Financial ProfilesFinancial Profiles
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200913
For SubrogationFor Subrogationand Debt Recovery/and Debt Recovery/
Judgment EnforcementJudgment Enforcement
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200914
Background ChecksBackground Checks
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200915
6
Criminal Histories may reveal: Criminal Histories may reveal:
• Additional aliases
• Relevant moral turpitude issues
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200916
Witness LocatesWitness Locates
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200917
Medical HistoriesMedical Histories
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200918
7
PrePre--Existing Injuries? Existing Injuries?
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200919
Litigation HistoriesLitigation Histories
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200920
Uses of Litigation Histories:Uses of Litigation Histories:
• Confirm identities
• Identify aliases• Address
History
• Persons knowledgeable of subject
• Prior injuries• Many
personal
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200921
• Financial Profile
• Character & credibility
• Earnings Potential
• Assets
personal injury suits are not found in the ISO claims database
8
Investigative ToolsInvestigative Tools
•Publications•Hardware•SoftwareW b Sit
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200922
•Web Sites
BRBPUB.COMBRBPUB.COM
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200923
Adobe Acrobat Professional
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
9
Adobe Acrobat ProfessionalAdobe Acrobat Professional• Ability to scan large quantities of documents to a single file
• Can print from any program to PDF file
• Can combine multiple PDF’s to single file.
• Automatic Bates Stamping
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200925
Automatic Bates Stamping• OCR large documents• Allows for text searching• Text highlighting, add note features • Redaction• Stamps
Fujitsu ScanSnapFujitsu ScanSnap
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200926
• $475• Includes Adobe Acrobat Standard Edition• B&W and Color• One or Two Sided Scanning• One Button Scanning• Scans to PDF Only• Automatic deskew• 15 pages per minute
Dymo LabelwriterDymo Labelwriter• Fast• Great for
single labels• Autoformats
text
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200927
10
Complex Loss AnalysisComplex Loss Analysis
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200928
CaseMapCaseMap
•CaseSoft• Integrated Suite
•Casemap•TimeMap
• Text Searching• Produces
reports• Multi-User
Capable
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200929
• Can handle million page files
• Sorting by date/source
• Filtering
• Export to TimeMap
• Links to individual documents
CaseMap CaseMap Facts ScreenFacts Screen
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200930
• Date & Time• Fact Text
11
CaseMap CaseMap Facts ScreenFacts Screen
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200931
Time MapTime Map• User friendly• Stand Alone or Export from
CaseMap• Unlimited Number of Events• Customizeable
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200932
Time MapTime Map• TimeLine Generator• Stand-Alone or integrated with CaseMap• Horizontal or Vertical Timelines• Specific Dates or Date Ranges• Great for spotting inconsistencies in
testimony and document trails
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200933
testimony and document trails• Simple and intuitive
12
Handout – Theft Timeline
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
ABC Flowcharter
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
Flow ChartingFlow Charting• Shows relationships between:
• People• Events• Places
• Key Features:• Flexible
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200936
• Graphic – Easy for Reader to Quickly Understand Complex Relationships
13
Microsoft Streets & TripsMicrosoft Streets & Trips
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200937
Microsoft Streets & TripsMicrosoft Streets & TripsCont’dCont’d
• GPS Compatible• Map out field work in
office• Save to memory stick• Open file in vehicle• Prepare Route, using
GPS
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200938
• Use for billing travel time and distance
• Predictible• Always in client favor• Verifiable
• Great time & Stress Saver!
Dictation EquipmentDictation Equipment• Differs from simple
recorders• Ability to rewind, play,
record with one hand• Allows capturing
complex thoughts while they’re fresh in your mind
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200939
• Great for Brainstorming
• Requires Playback equipment/software
14
Individual Information Individual Information FormForm
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200940
Leveraging InformationLeveraging Information• Every data source is a tool in our toolbox.• Leverage that information into additional
informatiion• Accurint + Criminal Filing Database =
Identity Confirmation
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200941
Leveraging Information
• Data searching is a lot like rock climbing.• Often cannot go directly from point “A” to “B”• Often necessary to move laterally first
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
•Start with a “toehold”
15
Planning the InvestigationPlanning the Investigation
Consider the issues which needto be addressed, what informationis already known, and the toolsavailable to find needed info.
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200943
Each “tool” in our toolbox is different. Know what tools areavailable, how to use them, andwhich ones to use when.
“Logic Path”“Logic Path”• What do I know about this
case?• What do I suspect? • What issue(s) am I trying to
resolve?
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200944
resolve?• What information would help
resolve the issue(s) in question?
• Where can I get this information?
Favorite Search TechniquesFavorite Search Techniques• Leveraging Information• Cross-referencing• Outlining Cases• Timelines• Flow Charting
Shotgun Searches
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200945
• Shotgun Searches• Text String Searches in large PDF files
16
“Shotgun Searching” “Shotgun Searching” • Methods:
• By telephone• By mail• By Posted Sign
• Characteristics:• Labor Intensive
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200946
• Hit and Miss• Must be Focused
• Can be very effective
“Shotgun Searching”“Shotgun Searching”by telephoneby telephone
• Run searches by:• Name• Address Range• Other Limiters
• Download results to Excel Spreadsheet in Accurint
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200947
• Autoformat• Hide unneeded columns• Insert Column for annotating contact
attempts made• Export to Word, insert in Report of
Investigation
CrossCross--ReferencingReferencing• Cross-Referencing is the Key to
Successful Fraud Investigation!• Tools:
• Search Matrixes• Timelines• Spreadsheets
S i li d S ft
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200948
• Specialized Software• Text String Searches within large PDF
documents
17
Matrix Forms
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200949
Nationwide Proprietary Nationwide Proprietary Online SourcesOnline Sources
• Accurint/IRB• Merlin• OpenOnline• CourtLink
• NewsBank• Proquest• iOffice• LocatePlus
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200950
• CourtTrax
Search Engines
• Google• Cheat Sheet – Handout• Google Alerts• Google News Archive
• Wayback Machine• Yahoo Site Explorer
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
18
Nationwide Public Nationwide Public Online Data SourcesOnline Data Sources
• PACER• EDGAR
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200952
Regional Proprietary Regional Proprietary Database SourcesDatabase Sources
• DCS – Texas• OpenOnline –
• Washington• Oregon• Ohio
• Motznik – Alaska• Merlin – California
• Court Trax• Washington• Oregon• Alaska • Utah• Arizona• Virginia
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200953
• Courtlink –• Washington• Oregon• New York• Ohio• Federal Courts
• Clark County Nevada• Hawaii• New Mexico• Federal Courts
Nationwide
Statewide WashingtonPublic Databases
• JIS/SCOMIS• WA Courts – Free site
• WA DOL – IVIPS• WA DOL –
Professional Licensing• WA Department of
Revenue
• WA UCC Filings • WA Charities• Domestic Partnerships• Medical Provider
Lookup• Contractor Licensing• Insurance Licensing
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
• WA Secretary of State-Corporations
• WA State Digital Archives
• WSP Watch
g• CPA Licensing• Hunting & Fishing
Licenses• Inmate Locator
19
Washington Statewide Non-Government Databases
• Washington State Bar Association
• Washington Voters• Sound Politics
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
Washington County Public Databases
• Recorder• Assessor• Jail Register• Employee Directory
• Nationwide link to all county governments
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
Washington City Databases• Seattle Business Licenses• Seattle Fire Dispatches• Seattle Municipal Courts
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
20
Social Networking Sites• ZoomInfo• MySpace• LinkedIn• Classmates.com• Reunion.com
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
Communications Sources• Phone Disk• ReadNotify• Slydial - (267) 759-3425• SkipTracy
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
SkipTracy.ComSkipTracy.Com
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200960
• Opening Screen• Calling Cards:
• Captures numbers on both ends of call• Sends email• Sent with “glossy” promo letterr• Rechargeable/Variable Minutes
• Outbound Calls with Altered Caller Identification
21
Online DemosOnline Demos
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200961
Questions & Questions & DiscussionDiscussion
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200962
Jim Cronin, CFE
Seattle Insurance & Legal
Investigations
Jim Cronin, CFESeattle Insurance and Legal Investigations
11/15/200963
(206) 992-1555