Factors Influencing Taiwanese Older Women's Intention to Attend Strength and Balance Training (SBT) Programs:A Guide to Increase Recruitment Rate of SBT
Programs
Shih-Fan (Sam) Lin1, Jerry W. Lee2, Naomi Modeste2, & Eric
G. Johnson2
1San Diego State University & 2Loma Linda University
The Prevalence of Falling
One third of older adults aged 65 and over fall at least once a year in the U.S. (CDC, 2006).
According to the National Health Research Institutes (2007) in Taiwan, the prevalence rate of falling adjusted for age and sex rose from 18.7% in 1999 to 20.5% in 2005.
The statistics in Taiwan show that falling is the second most common cause of death resulting from injuries (National Health Research Institutes, 2007).B
AC
KG
RO
UN
D
2
Consequences and Risks of FallingFalling among older adults is associated with
other problems (Yardley, Donovan-Hall, Francis, & Todd, 2007):◦ physical injuries and fears of falling◦ premature admissions to nursing care facilities◦ restricted mobility◦ limited independence◦ distress
The majority of older adults do not realize their potential risk for falling and neglect to report their falling events to their physicians (American Geriatric Society et al., 2001). ◦ Less than two third of respondents felt that they
were personally at risk for falls. (Wiens, Koleba, Jones, & Fenny, 2006)
BA
CK
GR
OU
ND
3
Motivation to Attend Fall Prevention Program
Older adults who were informed of their risk for falling, were more likely to perform fall risk reduction behaviors (Ness, Gurney, & Ice, 2003).◦ having vision checked◦ attending exercise programs◦ eating a calcium-rich diet
Yardley et al. (2006) found that older adults in six European countries were motivated to attend fall prevention programs by a range of perceived benefits (e.g. enjoyment, independence, and mood) and not just reduction of fall risks.
BA
CK
GR
OU
ND
4
Strength and Balance Training Program
Strength and balance training (SBT) programs are intended to reduce older adults’ risks of falling or actual occurrences of falls through exercises that facilitate muscle strength in legs and improve postural control (Yardley et al., 2007).
BA
CK
GR
OU
ND
Static Balance Stance:Up on Toes
Strength TrainingChair Squat
Center of Gravity Shift:Objects on the Floor
5
Effectiveness and Participation of SBT Programs
SBT programs are effective in reducing risks of falling and fears of falling (American Geriatric Society et al., 2001; Li et al., 2001; Liu-Ambrose et al., 2004; Sattin et al., 2005; Yardley et al., 2007).
The effectiveness of SBT programs depends largely upon the rate of participations. ◦ The rate of participation is quite low – over half of
participants in several studies refused to join SBT programs (Yardley et al., 2007).
Yardley et al. (2007) revealed that women and older respondents in their study were less inclined to participate in SBT programs. ◦ Effects of gender and age not assessed in the study◦ It is essential to understand what prompts women’s
choice to attend the program and to learn how age might influence the beliefs associated with such a choice.
BA
CK
GR
OU
ND
6
Purpose of the StudyExplore how Taiwanese older adults’ attitudes
and beliefs toward SBT programs will affect their intentions to attend such programs.
Utilize constructs of the theory of planned behavior to predict Taiwanese older adults’ intention to participate in SBT programs.
Examine how age relate to older adults’ perceptions and intentions to attend SBT programs.
PU
RP
OS
E
7
Theory of Planned Behavior
8
Intention to Attend
SBT Programs
Behavior
Attitude Toward the Behavior
Subjective Norm
Perceived Behavioral Control
Behavioral Beliefs and
Outcome Evaluation
Normative Beliefsand
Motivation to Comply
Control Beliefsand
Perceived Power Actual Behavioral
Control
Research Questions1. How are attitude, subjective norm, and
perceived behavioral control related to intentions to attend strength and balance training programs?
2. How does age relate to intentions to attend strength and balance training programs?
3. How does age relate to perceptions (attitude, subjective norm, and perceived behavioral control) about strength and balance training programs?
4. How are behavioral beliefs, normative beliefs, and control beliefs associated with strength and balance training programs related to attitude, subjective norm, and perceived behavioral control, respectively?
9PU
RP
OS
E
Design and RecruitmentCross-sectional study designStudy Site
◦Taiwan Silver College of Presbyterian Church - Suang Lien Branch (TSCPCSL) – provide education to those who wish to learn in late-life.
Recruitment◦All participants were recruited from the
study site◦Flyers & the school administrator
encouraged participationInclusion Criteria
◦Aged 55 and over◦Cognitively intact
Need to be able to understand informed consent and questionnaire.
10ST
UD
Y D
ES
IGN
InstrumentsA two-stage protocol suggested by Ajzen
(2006) was followed
1st Stage: two focus groups were conducted prior to the development of actual questionnaire◦Use open-ended questions◦Elicit behavioral, normative, and control
beliefs associated with SBT programs◦Saturation of responses was reached after
interviewing 12 students (6 males and 6 females) from the study site.
◦Conduct content analysis – belief items used in questionnaire
2nd Stage: the initial questionnaire was created◦Belief questions were added
11ST
UD
Y D
ES
IGN
Questionnaire ConstructionPilot test of the questionnaire
◦Tested on a convenience sample of 15 students from the study site.
◦Participants made recommendations regarding questionnaire format and wording
◦Finalize questionnaire according to comments received
The finalized questionnaire was translated into a Chinese version utilizing the back translation process (Jones, Lee, Phillips, & Jaceldo, 2001).
ST
UD
Y D
ES
IGN
12
Questionnaire Content1. Cognitive Screening (AD 8)
• Screen for participants’ cognitive ability
2. Theory of planned behavior constructs• Attitude , subjective norm, perceived behavioral
control, & behavioral, normative, and control beliefs
• Use semantic differential scales and Likert-type scales
3. Balance-maintaining confidence• Activities-specific Balance Confidence Scale-
Chinese (Mak, Lau, Law, Cheung, & Wong, 2007)• Assesses an individual’s confidence in performing
16 activities of daily living without losing one’s balance or becoming unsteady (higher scores mean greater confidence)
4. Demographics
13ST
UD
Y D
ES
IGN
Continuous VariablesIntention (Scale: 1-8)Two forms of attitude (Scale:1-8)
◦ Instrumental: worth or usefulness of the specific behavior
◦ Experiential: affect or feeling toward the behavior
Two forms of subjective norm (Scale: 1-8) ◦ Descriptive: whether referent others approve or
disapprove of the behavior◦ Injunctive: whether referent others themselves
engage in the behavior Two forms of perceived behavioral control
(Scale:1-8)◦ Perceived capability: perceived difficulty in
performing the behavior◦ Controllability: belief about their control over
the behavior
14VA
RIA
BL
ES
Continuous VariablesBehavioral belief (1-8)
◦ Behavioral belief strength × outcome evaluation
Normative belief (1-8)◦ Normative belief strength × motivation to
comply
Control beliefs (1-8)◦ Control belief strength × perceived power
Age (demographic)
Activities-specific balance confidence (ABC) scores◦ On a scale of 0-100%
15VA
RIA
BL
ES
Data Collection ProceduresAll data collection occurred in the
study site.
The investigator guided participants to complete informed consents and questionnaires.
Collection of signed informed consent prior to data collection.
DA
TA C
OL
LE
CT
ION
16
17
346 Participants
responded to questionnaire
s
341 Participants
248 Participants
26 Males(10.5%)
221 Females(89.1%)
One did not report gender
5 were eliminated due to inadequate cognitive ability
Missing data were treated with Expectation
Maximization Algorithms
Those responded to <80% of total
questions were eliminated
Those who responded to <50% of questions in each main section
were eliminated
Data Cleaning
Data AnalysisData were entered and analyzed
with SPSS 16.0Frequency
◦Distribution of categorical demographic variables
Central tendency measures◦Age◦Balance-maintaining confidence
Multiple Linear Regression◦Prediction of intention◦Prediction of attitude, subjective, norm,
and perceived behavioral control 18AN
ALY
SIS
19
Attitude Toward the Behavior
Subjective Norm
Perceived Behavioral
Control
Intention to Attend
SBT Programs
Basic Model:INT = ATT + SN + PBC
Behavioral Beliefs and
Outcome Evaluation
Normative Beliefsand
Motivation to Comply
Control Beliefsand
Perceived Power
ATT = BB1 + BB2 +BB3 + …BB8
SN = NB1 + NB2 + NB3 + …NB5
PBC = CB1 + CB2 + CB3 + …CB8
Regressions
20
Participants’ Balance Maintainin
g Confidenc
e
Age
Attitude Toward the Behavior
Subjective Norm
Perceived Behavioral
Control
Intention to Attend
SBT Programs
With addition of age:INT = ATT + SN + PBC + AGE
With addition of ABC:INT = ATT + SN + PBC +
ABC
ABC = ATT + SN + PBC
Basic model:INT = ATT + SN +
PBC
Regressions
Characteristics of ParticipantsAverage age: 72 (SD = 8.72, SE = 0.56).
Most well represented religious groups: 54.8% Buddhists and 23.1% Christians (compared to 4.1% of Christians living in Taiwan).
The education level was quite high (80% with high school or higher degrees) – compared to 5 years (elementary school) of education among older adults in general public.
65.6% had never fallen on the ground during last year; 18.6% had fallen once and 11.3% had fallen twice.
Average balance-maintaining confidence: 73.3% (SE = 1.36) – similar to 71.6% found among community dwelling older adults in Hong Kong.
21RE
SU
LTS
Characteristics of Participants (Cont.)
81.9% had never engaged in SBT exercises and 81.4% never engaged in Tai-chi exercises.
61.1% perceived their health status as fair and 23.1% perceived as good.
22RE
SU
LTS
23
β = 0.19**
r = 0.53***
β = 0.37***
r = 0.64***
β = 0.20*
r = 0.57***
Attitude
SubjectiveNorm
Perceived Behavioral
Control
Intention to Attend SBT Programs
R2 =
0.45***, N =
221
Intention Regressed on Attitude, Subjective Norm, and Perceived Behavioral Control (Basic Model)
*p ≤0.05, **p ≤ 0.005, ***p ≤ 0.001
N = Number of participants with complete data.
Perceived behavioral control has the strongest prediction of intention.
Age vs. Theory of Planned Behavior Variables Perceived behavioral control was the
only theory of planned behavior variable that had significant association with age (r = -.14, p = 0.034).
24RE
SU
LTS
25
Addition of Age in the Model
Variables r β B 95% C.I. (B)
lower upper
1. Age -0.11 -0.07 -0.01 -0.03 0.01
2. Attitude 0.53 *** 0.19 ** 0.23 ** 0.07 0.39
Attitude × Age 0.04 0.01 -0.01 0.02
3. Subjective Norm 0.57 *** 0.18 * 0.21 * 0.03 0.40
Subjective Norm × Age -0.21 * -0.03 * -0.05 -0.01
4. Perceived Behavioral Control 0.64 *** 0.42 *** 0.52 *** 0.31 0.72
Perceived Behavioral Control × Age 0.05 0.01 -0.02 0.03
*p ≤0.05 **p ≤ 0.005 ***p ≤ 0.001
Dependent variable: IntentionATT, SN, and PBC remained significant.
RE
SU
LTS
Only SN x Age interaction term is significant
Interaction: Subjective Norm & Age
26
(-1 SD) (+1 SD)-0.40
-0.30
-0.20
-0.10
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
-0.33
0.46
-0.03-0.10
Younger Age (-1 SD); around age of 63Older Age (+1 SD); around age of 81
Inte
nti
on
Score
s
Subjective Norm
Average Age: 72 (SD = 8.72)
27
Addition of ABC in the Model Dependent variable: Intention ATT, SN, and PBC remained significant ABC positively and significantly correlate (r=0.28,
p≤0.001) with intention, but the relationship disappeared after the inclusion of TBP variables in the model (β=0.02, ns).
Variables r β 95% C.I.
lower upper
1. Attitude 0.53 *** 0.18 * 0.05 0.32
2. Subjective Norm 0.57 *** 0.20 * 0.06 0.35
3. Perceived Behavioral Control 0.64 *** 0.36 *** 0.20 0.53
4. ABC Scores 0.28 *** 0.02 -0.09 0.13
*p ≤0.05 **p ≤ 0.005 ***p ≤ 0.001
RE
SU
LTS
28
ABC Regressed on Theory of Planned Behavior Variables
Dependent variable: Participants’ balance-maintaining confidence (ABC) score
Only PBC significantly predicts ABC score◦ The correlation between ABC scores and intention was
mainly mediated by the impact of balance confidence on perceived behavioral control.
Theory of Planned Behavior Variables r β 95% C.I.
lower upper
1. Attitude 0.32 *** 0.13 -0.03 0.29
2. Subjective Norm 0.26 *** -0.07 -0.25 0.11
3. Perceived Behavioral Control 0.40 *** 0.37 *** 0.17 0.56
*p ≤0.05 **p ≤ 0.005 ***p ≤ 0.001 RE
SU
LTS
Relationship Between Intention & ABC Scores
29
Participants’ Balance
Maintaining Confidence
Intention to Attend SBT Programs
Attitude Toward the Behavior
Subjective Norm
Perceived Behavioral
Control
The correlation between ABC and intention was mainly mediated by the
impact of balance confidence on TBP constructs with the
strongest influence on perceived behavioral
control.
Comparison of Religious GroupWe examined the interactions of religion
and other study variables for all models directly predicting intention for the two largest religious groups in our sample (Christians and Buddhists).
No significant interactions between religion and any other independent variable examined in these regressions. ◦ The predictors of intention were not different
between Christian and Buddhist participants.
The relatively high proportion of Christians in our sample is not a threat to generalizability.
30RE
SU
LTS
31
R2 =
0.44***, N =
221
Attitude
SubjectiveNorm
Perceived Behavioral
Control
R2 =
0.56***, N =
221R2
= 0.59***, N
= 221
β r Outcome Beliefs0.36*** 0.63*** Become more independent in daily life0.17 0.60*** Improve physical health condition0.14 0.52*** Increase social activities0.07 0.51*** Improve mental health condition0.08 0.47*** Reduce risk of falling
-0.07 0.42*** Reduce fear of falling-0.04 0.36*** Receive gift from the instructors after completion of the program
0.06 0.30*** Produce minor pains in the body
β r Referent Others0.40*** 0.70*** Family0.31*** 0.67*** Doctors0.03 0.65*** Friends0.01 0.64*** Classmates0.06 0.61*** Community members
β r Control Beliefs0.27* 0.72*** Program in place familiar to participants0.23** 0.69*** Being able to control the amount of exercises participants do in the
program0.15* 0.64*** Have enough willpower to complete the program0.11 0.70*** Program in place convenient to participants0.08 0.65*** Have free time in the next 6 months0.04 0.40*** Declines in mental condition0.01 0.59*** Exercise in a group setting where participants could be around their
peers
-0.02 0.37*** Declines in physical condition
*p ≤0.05, **p ≤ 0.005, ***p ≤ 0.001; N = Numbers of participants with complete data.
Significant Interaction: Behavioral Beliefs vs. Outcome Evaluation
32
(-1 SD) (+1 SD) (-1 SD) (+1 SD) (-1 SD) (+1 SD)-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
-0.57
0.04
-0.44
0.00
-0.28
-0.49
0.310.22
-0.35
0.80
0.11
0.66
Low Outcome Evaluation (-1 SD) High Outcome Evaluation (+1 SD)A
ttit
ud
e S
core
s
Likelihood to Improve Mental
Health
Likelihood to Reduce Fall
Risks
Likelihood to Receive Gifts
After Completing the
Program
Interpretation of Interactions• Among people who thought the outcome of
mental health improvement less likely, a low evaluation of the mental health outcome was associated with more negative attitude toward the SBT program.
• As perceived likelihood that the program would reduce risk of falling increased, the attitude toward SBT programs grew more favorably regardless individuals’ evaluation of the outcome.
• When individuals highly evaluated receiving a gift after program completion, the greater the perceived likelihood of the gift, the more positive the attitude toward the programs. However, for individuals who evaluated such gifts more negatively, an increased perceived likelihood of a gift was associated with a more negative attitude toward the program.
33RE
SU
LTS
34
Significant Interaction: Normative Beliefs vs. Motivation to Comply
(-1 SD) (+1 SD) (-1 SD) (+1 SD) (-1 SD) (+1 SD)-1.00
-0.50
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
-0.62
-0.34
-0.61
-0.18
-0.56
0.22
-0.11
1.07
-0.15
0.94
-0.53
0.87
Low Motivation to Comply (-1 SD) High Motivation to Comply (+1 SD)
Su
bje
ctiv
e N
orm
Sco
res
Doctors Classmates Community Members
Interpretation of InteractionsThe more participants believed that
referent others want them to engage in SBT programs, the higher the subjective norm score. This relationship is stronger among individuals who have higher motivation to comply.
This is true for all the referent others: doctors, classmates, and community members
35RE
SU
LTS
36
Significant Interaction: Control Beliefs vs. Perceived Power
(-1 SD) (+1 SD) (-1 SD) (+1 SD) (-1 SD) (+1 SD)-1.00
-0.50
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
-0.64 -0.59
-0.04
-0.85
-0.07
-0.75
0.09
1.14
0.43 0.460.37 0.44
This Control Factor Would Make Less Positive Impact to Attendance of SBT Programs (-1 SD)This Control Factor Would Make More Positive Impact to Attendance of SBT Programs (+1 SD)
Perc
eiv
ed
Beh
avio
ral C
on
trol
Sco
res
Likelihood to Perform SBT Exercise in a Place that is Familiar to Participants
Likelihood to Have Mental
Health Declines
Likelihood to Have Physical
Health Declines
Interpretation of Interactions• Those who evaluated performing
exercise in a familiar place as having more positive impact on program attendance, an increase in the likelihood of this factor is associated with stronger perceived behavioral control.
• For participants who evaluated that having a mental/physical decline in the future would have more hindering impact on program attendance, the greater the likelihood of future mental/physical declines, the weaker the participants’ perceived behavioral control.
37RE
SU
LTS
Intention & Age EffectParticipants’ intentions to attend SBT
programs were fairly strong.◦ This does not guarantee a high rate of
participation.
Although a non-significant result, age was negatively correlated with intention.◦ Focus the promotion of SBT programs to
individuals with more advancing age (high risk & lack intentions).
Age was significantly and negatively correlated with perceived behavioral control.◦ Need to find solutions to increase older
adults’ perceived ability to attend SBT programs. Provide optimal dose of exercise that tailors to
individuals in different age categories (old, older, oldest).
38CO
NC
LU
SIO
N
Determinants of IntentionAttitude, subjective norm, and perceived
behavioral control – all significantly and positively correlated with intention.◦ Perceived behavioral control had strongest
predicting power of intention
The most influential predictor of attitude: becoming more independent in daily life.
Family and doctors were two referent groups that had independent prediction of subjective norm.
Three dominant control factors significantly predicted perceived behavioral control.◦ SBT programs in familiar place◦ Participants being able to control amount of
exercise desired◦ Participants having enough willpower to complete
the program
39CO
NC
LU
SIO
N
Limitations of the StudyGeneralizability
◦ Healthy and adequately educated participants◦ Lack random selection of target population◦ Only women were included
Artificially lowered intention as women lack intention to attend SBT programs
Volunteer effects
No follow up on participants’ actual attendance to strength and balance training programs◦ Limiting the study’s ability to assess the correlation
between intention and actual behavior
LIM
ITA
TIO
NS
40
Recommendations to Increase Recruitment Rate
During the promotion campaign of strength and balance training programs, health care professionals should:
1. Focus the campaign message on the program’s benefit of helping older adults become more independent in daily life.
2. Focus the promotion of the program to individuals in the more advanced age range as this group of people are generally at higher risks of falling and lack adequate intention to participate in such programs. While the old-old (70-79) and the oldest-old (80+) groups are less likely to ambulate around the community or have the strength to exercise compared to the young old (60-69), health care professionals should consider designing home-based and age-appropriated exercise intervention for these particular groups of individuals. Recruitment materials should emphasize the fact that the intervention requires no traveling to an exercise site and exercises are designed appropriately for their age.
41RE
CO
MM
EN
DA
TIO
NS
Recommendations to Increase Recruitment Rate
3. Stress the likelihood of mental health improvement as an outcome of the program to increase the positive attitude among older adults who place less positive value on mental health improvements.
4. Inform potential participants that mental or physical health declines will not prevent them from attending the SBT program as the program is tailored to participants with various levels of mental and physical health.
5. Emphasize the programs’ potential to reduce fall risks and strengthen older adults’ perceived value of fall risk reduction in order to maximize participants’ positive attitude toward program participation.
42RE
CO
MM
EN
DA
TIO
NS
Recommendations to Increase Recruitment Rate
6. Inform potential participants who highly value a gift after program completion about a forthcoming gift to increase their positive attitude toward program participation. For those who evaluate receiving gifts less positively, health care professionals should ask if there is anything that could be substitute as an incentive to participate in the program.
7. Provide realistic depiction of the program during campaign period by broadcasting a video that illustrates examples of strength and balance training exercises performed in the program.
8. Emphasize how safeguards have been implemented in the program to prevent potential falls during the exercise class as this will reduce fear of falling among potential participants and possibly increase their willingness to attend SBT programs. Assessment of balance confidence at the beginning of the program is also important because this will allow instructors to provide special attentions to individuals with less balance-maintaining confidence and possibly increase their adherence to the SBT programs.
43RE
CO
MM
EN
DA
TIO
NS
Recommendations to Increase Recruitment Rate
9. Provide potential participants with a list of myths about attending a strength and balance training program and encourage the potential participants to pass on the information to relatives, friends, or neighbors whom they consider their opinions are important. This strategy to promote attendance will possibly be more beneficial for the young-old group as they still retain an adequate social network. For the old-old and oldest-old groups who lack an adequate social network, health care professionals should help them expand their social network by assigning counselors or social workers who can regularly contact them and encourage their engagement in strength and balance exercises.
44RE
CO
MM
EN
DA
TIO
NS
While designing the strength and balance training programs, health care professionals should consider the following:
1. Conduct the program in a place that is familiar to participants as this will reduce environmental distractions and may alleviate participants’ potential anxiety levels.
2. Provide lessons that deal with the skills needed to strengthen participants’ perseverance to complete the program (e.g. use of relaxation skills to resist temptation to quit exercising) as this may reduce the attrition rate of the program.
3. Have participants sign a contract during the enrollment stage of the program to potentially increase participants’ commitment to complete the program.
45
Recommendations to Increase Recruitment Rate
RE
CO
MM
EN
DA
TIO
NS
4. Allow participants to choose the amount of exercise they wish to perform as this may allow participants to feel that they have adequate control over their own program. This should be advertised in the recruitment materials to increase potential participants’ desires to attend SBT programs. Health care professionals are strongly advised to first develop the SBT programs then create the recruitment materials to allow potential participants to have an in-depth understanding of what the program may entail.
5. Provide appropriate dose of exercise to participants across different age groups (young-old, old-old, and oldest old) and various levels of physical and mental conditions as this can increase their perceived ability to accomplish the SBT program.
46
Recommendations to Increase Recruitment Rate
RE
CO
MM
EN
DA
TIO
NS