8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
1/19
East Meets West:
A Comparison of Cultures and Lifestyles in Terms of Music Cognition
by Ben Silverman
Abstract
Music is a powerful controller of our feelings, behavior, attention, and culture.
It affects our memory, ability to focus, and our emotion. I have spent my whole life
experiencing the musical climate that western composers, musicians, producers, engineers,
and promoters have created. I have been aware of this fact since I became a musician, and
even though I have since branched out and explored the art and music of other cultures,
the Western-temperament, Western scales/rules, and general sound of Western music has
been imbedded in my mind. This is most likely due to the amount of Western music I was
exposed to since birth, especially before I could fully understand and conceptualize what I
was listening to.
My goal for this case study is to determine how much of an influence a
persons natural musical climate and upbringing has on the way they interpret music of their
own culture, and of other cultures. I prepared two tests to carry out on four groups of
people. The test was designed to highlight the differences in perception of music between
non-musically-oriented minds and musically oriented minds, and people who have lived
their entire lives immersed in Western music environments and people who have lived their
entire lives immersed in Eastern music environments.
Musical minds were able to easily identify each chord, harmony, rhythm,
chord progression, and musical nuance, and they have knowledge, or an experience of this
in their western music memory. Non-musicians mostly seemed to hear each sample as if it
was the first time. Without knowledge of what they were hearing, they had little referenceto match what they heard with. Had harder time explaining themselves, and their answers
not only differed from the musicians answers, but often varied within their own group.
Western listeners had experiences with Western music their whole lives, so
they were able to match what they heard in the tests with similar motifs and sounds theyve
been exposed to throughout the years. Their answers were fairly consistent with themselves
and with the other Western listeners. When they listened to the western music, their answers
were less consistent. Eastern listeners showed a similar (but opposite) consistency (though
to a less significant degree) .
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
2/19
Overview
Music has a spiritual, almost mystical ability to manipulate our emotions. Recently, there
has been more serious, academic attention payed to music cognition, music psychology, and the
general neuroscience of music, as people like Daniel Levitin, Oliver Sacks, Mark Tramo, enter
the mainstream. here are dozens of new books examining the intersection of neuroscience and
music, but even for the biggest and most elaborate studies, one crucial imperfection always
exists. Emotional responses to anythingare always subjective. People have different reactions to
musical stimuli possibly because of their memories tied to certain sounds, various associations
with other sounds and experiences, their emotional health, and countless other combinations of
factors.
Because of the subjectivity of human emotions, it is difficult for experimenters to find
appropriate controls for tests. My goal was to compare emotional reactions to musical stimuli
while taking factors of subjectivity, upbringing, and musical environments into consideration. I
hoped to determine whether emotions that are caused by music are dependent on the culture that
the perceiver was raised in, and if musical intervals are interpreted the same way by someone
who grew up surrounded by a western-tempered twelve-tone scale as someone who is primed by
an Eastern, or non-tempered scale. I used a controlled experiment setting to find out what degree
responses from test subjects from various backgrounds depend on their culture and musical
history. This would help to explain how much of an effect a persons culture and lifestyle has on
the way their brains respond to music.
Hypothesis: The cultural upbringing, and the general musical environment experienced
while growing up significantly affects the way a music-listener interprets music. While our ability
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
3/19
to feel specific emotions from music is largely a genetic feature that all humans share, ones
cultural upbringing is enough to create major differences between the way they feel from their
cultures music, and the way other feel from theirs.
Background
Western music has a 12-tone chromatic scale, from which chords and 7 note diatonic
scales are assembled. In western-tempered music theory, the smallest possible increment
between two notes is equal to a half-step (which can be expressed as 1/12 of an octave, 100
cents, or 16/15 x the first frequency). While it may be possible for different cultures to have the
same tones and some of the same relationships between tones in their music, most Eastern
cultures have different arrangements of their notes, different intervals between them, and a
different number of notes between an octave.
Experimental Procedure
I prepared a two-part experiment designed to identify whether different perceptions of
music are products of emersion in a specific culture, or are simply inborn, genetic features of the
brain. The first procedure of my experiment involves comparing the emotional and psychological
reactions to a prepared set of musical stimuli between avid, professional musician listeners, and
non-musical listeners. I have identified several willing test subjects from each category. The
first three subjects are in the musical category. These subjects are current UMass music
students, who teach, and play on a professional (and semi-professional) level. The four subjects
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
4/19
from the non-musical category include a UMass physics graduate student, a physician, and a
3D art teacher at Brandeis University, and a UMass English major.
All four of the non-musical subjects claim to have never felt a connection to, or
actively (and closely) listened to a piece of music. They have never played an instrument, have
never purchased music (or sought it out online), and have never chosen to go to a concert. They
all have explained that their experience with anything related to music has only been an
incidental, and background encounter. I teach drum lessons to the physics graduate student,
who signed up on a whim, in an effort to expand her horizons and interests. Similarly, I teach
guitar lessons to the physician, who received an acoustic guitar as a gift, and decided to try to
learn it. The Bradeis art teacher was a co-worker of mine who I will email the audio test to.
The second main phase of the experiment is to perform a similar experiment on two
groups of test subjects. The first group consists of Westerners (all Americans), while the second
group consists of people from other countries with a different set of musical customs and rules
(different scales, chords, and harmonies, different common time signatures, different timbres of
instruments, and possibly a different function of music in society). The test subjects in this group
are of Chinese, Indian, Turkish, and Cambodian descent. I played two series of audio clips for
the groups. The first series is a collection of clips of works by European and American
composers and musicians using western-tempered scales. The second series is a collection of
clips of works by Indian, Japanese, and African composers and musicians. The first series will
consist of four 30-second clips of:
- The second movement from Bachs Concerto for 2 violins in D minor-Lost of Love by The Bad Plus- The 5th movement (Jeux De Cits Rivales) in Igor Stravinkys Le Sacre du Printemps-Roses Are Free by Ween
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
5/19
The second series will consist of four 30-second clips of:
- 5 in the Morning, 6 in the Afternoon by Shakti-Dhun by Ravi Shankar and Ustad Alla Rakha- The Yamato Drummers of Japan-Polyphonic Singing of the Aka Pygmies
NOTE: The Eastern selection of music clips does not directly correspond to the nationalities
of the Eastern test subjects. I took this into consideration and am weighing certain responses
differently.
I prepared a short survey inquiring about the emotional, and psychological reactions of
each sample group after listening to both sections of clips.
Results:
Non-Musician responses to chords, scales, and chord progressions:
N.S. J.K. J.L. M.S.
major 3 pretty pretty pretty/uplifting pretty/other(soothing)
perfect 5 pretty/other (solid) other (stern) pretty/confusing pretty/other(forceful)
major 7 ugly/confusing confusing/other(unsettling)
pretty/uplifting pretty/other
(melancholy)
minor chord depressing depressing/ confusing
depressing depressing/
confusing
flat 5 ugly/confusing ugly/other (spine-chilling)
ugly/other (sour) ugly/chaotic
min 2 ugly/confusing ugly/other (Jaws) ugly ugly/chaotic
suspended 2chord
pretty/confusing pretty pretty/other
(soothing)
pretty/other
(mellow, soothing,smooth
augmented 5 confusing ugly/confusing ugly/other (weird) confusing/other(jarring)
dominant 7ugly/confusing pretty/other
(unexpected)pretty/other(playful)
other(lighthearted, silly)
minor 7 depressing/confusing
depressing pretty/depressing
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
6/19
N.S. J.K. J.L. M.S.
1 ionian p p/other (basic) p p/other (do remi)
2 dorian up p/us p p
3 phrygian up/us p/us up p/other (middleeastern)
4 lydian p/us p/us p/us p
5 mixo up/us p/us p/us p/us
6 aeolian up/us up/r up/r p/other (sad)
7 locrian up/us up/us up other (sad)
8 whole tone up/r up/us up/other(dreamlike)
other (weird)
9 mel. min. up/us up/r p/other(medievalsounding)
us/other(changing)
10. superloc. up/us up/us us other (weird,middleeastern)
(note: up=unpleasant; us=unsettled; r=resolved; p=pleasant)
N.S. J.K. J.L. M.S.
II/IV 4:4 time unpredictable unpleasant unpredictable weird
II/III 4:4 time pleasant pleasant/weird pleasant/ catchy
pleasant/catchy
II/V 5:4 time weird chaotic chaotic weird/chaotic
IV/V 4:4 time pretty/catchy catchy catchy predictable/ catchy
IV/V 4:4 time(down halfstepfrom prev.
sample)
unpleasant/weird
unpleasant/unpredictable
unpleasant/weird
unpleasant/catchy/weird
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
7/19
Musician responses to chords, scales, and chord progressions:
C.H. B.F. N.R.
maj 3 pretty pretty/ resolved pretty/basic/ resolved
perfect 5 other(resolved)
resolved perfect/ resolved
maj 7 pretty pretty/delicate pretty/longing
min chord depressing depressing depressing/ basic
b5 chaotic chaotic/ dissonant
chaotic
b2 chaotic chaotic/ dissonant
chaotic
sus2 chord pretty/soothing pretty/mellow/
relaxing
very pretty/
meditative
aug5 chaotic chaotic/ dissonant
chaotic
dom7 lighthearted complex/goofy pleasant/silly
min7 pretty/ depressing
pretty/depressing
depressing
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
8/19
C.H. B.F. N.R.
1 ionian major/basic major major
2 dorian sad/complex minor/complex minor
3 phrygian sad/complex minor/complex minor
4 lydian major/complex major/complex major/chaotic
5 mixo major/complex major/complex major/chaotic
6 aeolian minor/basic/ resolved
minor/basic minor/basic
7 locrian sad/chaotic/ unsettled
unsettled/minor minor/unsettled
8 whole tone chaotic/ unsettled
unsettled unsettled/ dreamlike
9 mel. min. sad/medieval altered/ unsettled
unsettled/altered
10. superloc. altered, minor,unsettled
altered/unsettled
unsettled/chaotic/minor
C.H. B.F. N.R.
II/IV 4:4 time slightlyunresolved
slightlyunresolved
atypical
II/III 4:4 time predictable/resolved
pleasant/resolved
resolved/predictable
II/V 5:4 time unpredictableat first/pleasant
pleasant/5:4 jumpy/ predictable/pleasant
IV/V 4:4 time uplifting/ predictable
predictable/major
major/predictable
IV/V 4:4 time(down halfstepfrom prev.
sample)
uplifting/predictable
same, down ahalfstep
major/predictable
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
9/19
Easterner responses to music clips:
Section 1 N.S. M.P. 2 A.H. D.G.
Clip 1 - Bach sad/rushed pretty/mostly
uninteresting
pretty/
depressing
pretty/sad
2 - Bad Plus sad/pretty sad/slow sad/pretty/slow pretty/sad/ lonely
3 - Stravinsky ugly/chaotic/fast
ugly/ugly butenjoyable.
frenetic pretty/fast/ intense//moviesoundtrack?
4 - Ween pretty/weird predictable/ weird
pleasant/predictable
pleasant/weird/funny
Section 2
Clip 1 - Shakti pretty/chaotic pretty/ unpredictable
unpredictable/pleasant/cheerful
unpredictable/fast
2 - Shankar pretty/chaotic pretty/ unpredictable
unpredictable/trippy
unpredictable/fast
3 - Yamato unpredictable/ bombastic,
powerful
intense/fast powerful unpredictable/ fast
4 - Pygmies chaotic/ mesmerizing
hard to listen toat times, prettyat other times
weird/atonal atonal
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
10/19
Westerner responses to music clips:
Section 1 M.P. N.M. M.S.
Clip 1 - Bach minor/complex/
predictable
minor/standard predictable
2 - Bad Plus melancholy sad/beautiful cathartic/pretty/ heartwrenching
3 - Stravinsky interesting/pretty bombastic/chaotic/ beautiful
pretty/exciting/unpredictable/harsh
4 - Ween predictable/goofy/ fun
predictable/silly/great
predictable/cheerful/brown
Section 2
Clip 1 - Shakti beautiful/ unpredictable
not sure of timesignature or key
fast/magical
2 - Shankar unrecognizablescale/intriguing
not sure of timesignature or key
peaceful/meditative
3 - Yamato complex timesignatures/impecable timing
complex/tight/intense
intense/intimidating
4 - Pygmies interestingharmonies/atonal atpoints
strange harmonies/beautiful/interesting atypical harmonies/beautiful
On the next page are the experiment forms that I asked the test subjects to fill out:
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
11/19
A.) ChordsImmediately after hearing each sample (1-10), circle one (or more) of the followingadjectives that best describes your emotional reaction to the sound you hear.
1. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________2. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________3. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________4. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________5. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________6. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________7. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________8. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________9. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________10. Pretty Ugly Depressing Uplifting Confusing/Chaotic other: ________________________________
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
12/19
B. (Scales)
Immediately after hearing each sample, indicate the emotional response that mostaccurately represents your experience:
1. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________2. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________3. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________4. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________5. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________6. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________7. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________8. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________9. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________10. Pleasant Unpleasant Resolved Unsettled other: ___________________________________________
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
13/19
C.) Chord Progressions
After listening to the chord progression, circle the most accurate description of how itsounds to you.
1. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic catchyother: ____________________________
notes: ________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
2. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic catchyother: ____________________________
notes: ________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
3. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic catchyother: ____________________________
notes: ________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
4. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic catchyother: ____________________________
notes: ________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
5. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic catchyother: ____________________________
notes: ________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
14/19
A.) Music Set: 1
After listening to each clip of music, circle the most accurate description of how it
sounds to you.
1. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic weird catchyother: _______________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
2. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic weird catchyother: _______________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
3. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic weird catchyother: _______________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
4. pleasant/pretty unpleasant/ugly predictable unpredictable/chaotic weird catchy
other: _______________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
15/19
____________________________________________________________________________________
Conclusions
The musicians were easily able to identify certain intervals, scales, and patterns. This
made their answers more consistent with themselves, and each other for two reasons.
First, they were able to match certain musical aspects with experiences they have had or
lessons they have learned. For example, many music students learn about these test items early in
their education. They might originally learn or discover the formal, academic descriptions of
specific musical features, and forever make associations between the sounds of the chords and
scales, and the way they are intended to be used. The three musician test subjects are very
proficient musicians, and have the ability to easily recognize the name and sounds of chords
upon hearing them. This allows them to make the association between the name of the chord and
the name of the emotion that is traditionally associated with it (for example, minor always
means sad in our Western musical culture).
The second reason is because they have spent years playing music, listening to music,
and working on ear training. This allows them to not only correctly identify each interval they
hear, but helps them to consistently identify the emotion that the sound influences. The non
musicians responses seemed less consistent with their own answers, and with the rest of their
group (and with the musicians group). Even though some of the non-musicians might have
been exposed to many of the chords in the test (subconsciously, or actively), they demonstrated
that they make fewer consistent associations between sounds and emotions than the musicians
group. This is likely due to one, or more of the following three reasons:
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
16/19
Reason 1: They havent had training that enforces formalized connections between
musical elements and emotions
Reason 2: They havent spent much time actively listening to music (especially certain
songs more than once). Usually, the more a listener hears a song, the more they become attuned
to the general mood and atmosphere of the piece of music. Once they begin to become aware of
this mood/atmosphere, they can start making connections between the mood and the actual
mechanics of the music.
Reason 3: Their brains are playing tricks on them. For example: major 7 chord, has an
inversion of a minor 2 interval embedded in it. It is a dissonant interval, which might make a
non-musician test subject treat it as an unpleasant, chaotic chord. A trained musician, on the
other hand, might recognize the chord as a major 7, and know for a fact that it is a major,
pleasant-sounding chord, regardless of how it sounds.
These findings, to some extent, suggest that the non-musicians sometimes display a more
uninhibited, honest reaction to a musical stimulus. While a music student might automatically
associate a learned emotion with a chord they recognize, a non-musician with no previous
knowledge of music, might simply report that a chord is ugly because it sounds ugly to them.
They most likely have a shorter thought process for assigning an emotion to an audio stimulus
because all they have to consider is the immediate way the sound makes them feel. There is little
or no prior knowledge to influence or complicate their decision.
My second test, which examined the role a cultural background plays in the perception of
music from ones own culture and other cultures yielded complex, and somewhat inconclusive
and inconsistent results. Although the charts in the discussion section above show the 2 sets of
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
17/19
clips divided clearly into East and West, they were presented to the test subjects in a random
order.
The test group of Western music listeners all share a similar musical background; They
are all familiar with Western music and have been active listners for years. They consider music
to be an important part of their lives, and each are able to easily associate emotional reactions to
music. They differ, however in how actively they listen, play, and analyze music. The first
Western test subject is a non-profession, casual multi-instrumentalist, the second was a
classical voice minor/guitarist/singersongwriter, and the third is an avid listener of every genre of
music. Subject 1 has the most technical knowledge of the mechanics of music and music theory.
Subject 2 is fairly experienced in performance and songwriting, and has a relatively advanced
knowledge of music theory. Subject 3, has no playing experience, not theory knowledge, but
actively listens to an extremely large variety of music. All three showed similar reactions to the
Western selection of music clips.
While Subjects 1 and 2 attempted to apply Western theoretical terms to the Eastern
music, Subject 3, consistently explained his reactions to the musical stimuli with more creative
and emotional terms, and less technical terms. Most likely, due to Subject 3s lack of technical
musical and instrumental expertise (Subject 3 only has listening experience),he was able to use
more universal emotional terms, and relate more closely to the Eastern music, even though he
is an American, like Subjects 1 and 2. This helps to demonstrate that music cognition might be a
genetic attribute which can be corrupted by cultural practices (for example: formal music
educations which teach you to hear something and analyze it a certain way).
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
18/19
The four test subjects who have been primed by music of the Eastern hemispheres
cultures have different opinions and outlooks on music than the group of Western subjects. Also,
each of the Eastern subjects have been in the US for different amounts of time. This will help in
my study to identify more clearly how much being born and raised in a certain culture affects
music perception, compared to being currently surroundedby it. (For example: how different are
the perceptions of someone who spent their whole life in one country before moving here 2
months ago and someone who spent their first 7 years in a country before moving here 15 years
ago.)
The results of the Eastern listeners was the most inconclusive part of the test. Their
answers were not as distinct from the Western listeners group as I had hypothesized. I did,
however, find that their responses to both the Western music clips contained mostly simple terms
about the mechanics of the pieces (I observed several mentions of the terms loud, fast,
chaotic). There were also several expressions of basic emotions (pretty, sad). There were
more other responses to the music from their own culture, suggesting that they might have had
an easier time creatively and abstractly connecting to the music, since it is slightly more familiar
to them either subconsciously or consciously. Though the evidence was relatively vague and
insubstantial in this last set of the test, the evidence still points more in the direction of my
hypothesis.
The data also aligned appropriately with the amount of time the Eastern test subject has
lived in their original country. For example: Subject 4, who moved from Cambodia to the US at
age 7 showed significantly more other responses that express more complicated emotional
reactions to the set of Western music. This is likely because he has spent significantly more
8/2/2019 "Feeling Music"
19/19
time in this cultural environment that the other Eastern test subjects. Also, as I hypothesized,
his reactions to the Western music set were still generally less specific, and were described
with fewer creative terms.
The data becomes inconclusive again when considering the Eastern groups responses
to the Eastern music selection. While my hypothesis outlines the correlation between ones
cultural background and the way they interpret music, the answers in this section are
undoubtedly less specific (and less consistent with each other and themselves) than the
Westerners responses were to their own cultures music. Perhaps this can be explained by the
fact that while all of the Western test subjects are American, the Eastern subjects are of
different nationalities. I took this into consideration while reviewing their responses, but to
supplement this experiment in the future, I would probably use groups of the same nationality/
location. I would also play music from their specific country/region, as well as other Eastern
music and compare the results.
Further steps that I will take will be to put these audio samples and test forms online. This
will allow me to crowd source data using social media like Facebook, Twitter, and tumblr.
This study is significant because it, and studies like it, help to identify the "music gene". I
hope to find out whether the actual music influences emotions and feelings on a blank, open
mind, or if the culture that the mind exists in primes the mind to feel certain ways from music
and sounds.