1
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I
Dr. A. Aziz Bazoune
King Fahd University of Petroleum & MineralsKing Fahd University of Petroleum & MineralsKing Fahd University of Petroleum & MineralsKing Fahd University of Petroleum & MineralsMechanical Engineering Department
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I2
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I3
FAILURE CRITERIA
Failure Criteria Failure Criteria ((Static Load Static Load ++Ductile MaterialDuctile Material))
66--66-- Coulomb Mohr Theory for Ductile MaterialsCoulomb Mohr Theory for Ductile Materials
� Not all materials have their tensile strength equal to their compressive strength. Examples are
Magnesium
Cast Iron
0.5uc utS S=
( )3 4S S� ∼
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I4
Cast Iron
� This section deals with materials
( )3 4uc ut
S S� ∼
uc utS S≠
syS
Practical difficulties to construct 3 Mohr circles for three tests.
Figure 6-20 Three Mohr circles, one for the uniaxial compression test, one for the test in pure shear, and one for
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I5
pure shear, and one for the uniaxial tension test are used to define failure by the Mohr hypothesis.The compressive and tensile strengths, respectively; they can be used for yield or ultimate strength .
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I6
Figure 6-20 Three Mohr circles, one for the uniaxial compression test, one for the test in pure shear, and one for the uniaxial tension test are used to define failure by the Mohr hypothesis. The compressive and tensile strengths, respectively; they can be used for yield or ultimate strength
Coulomb Mohr Theory for Ductile MaterialsCoulomb Mohr Theory for Ductile Materials
1 2 3σ σ σ≥ ≥
Failure will occur if Mohr’s circle (3-D) describing a state of
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I7
describing a state of stress in a body grows until it becomes tangent to the failure envelope.
1 3
1 31 0, 0
t cS S
σ σσ σ− = > ≤
Coulomb Mohr Theory for Ductile MaterialsCoulomb Mohr Theory for Ductile Materials
Failure will occur if
1 3
1 31 0, 0
t cS S
σ σσ σ− = > ≤
Failure criteria according to Coulomb-Mohr Theory
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I8
Factor of safety
1 31
t cS S n
σ σ− =
Special Cases: Application of CoulombSpecial Cases: Application of Coulomb--Mohr for Mohr for Plane Stress (Failure will occur ifPlane Stress (Failure will occur if☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺
Case Case 11::
A tSσ ≥
⇒A B
σ σ≥
0A B
σ σ≥ ≥1 2 3
, , 0A B
σ σ σ σ σ= = =
Case Case 22:: ⇒0A B
σ σ≥ ≥1 2 3
, 0,A B
σ σ σ σ σ= = =
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I9
⇒0A B
σ σ≥ ≥1 2 3
, 0,A B
σ σ σ σ σ= = =
1A B
t cS S
σ σ− ≥
Case Case 33::
B cSσ ≤ −
⇒0A B
σ σ≥ ≥1 2 3
0, ,A B
σ σ σ σ σ= = =
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I10
Factor of safety
1 31
t cS S n
σ σ− =
� For Coulomb-Mohr Theory we do not need the torsional shear strength circle, we can deduce it from Eq.(6-22). For pure shear .
� The torsional yield strength occurs when1 3
,τ σ σ τ= − =
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I11
� The torsional yield strength occurs when
� For yielding, Eq. (6-22) gives
y t y c
s y
y t y c
S SS
S S=
+
max sySτ =
Example Example 66--2 2 ((Textbook Page Textbook Page 268268))
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I12
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I13
66--7 7 Failure of Ductile Materials SummaryFailure of Ductile Materials Summary
� This study is limited materials and parts that are known to fail in a ductile manner.
� Experimental data
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I14
� Experimental data collected for several materials from many sources are shown in Figure 6-23.
Figure 6-23Experimental data superposed on failure theories
66--7 7 Failure of Ductile Materials SummaryFailure of Ductile Materials Summary
� Figure 6-23 shows that either the Maximum Shear Stress Theory (MSS) or the Distortion Energy Theory (DE) is acceptable for design and analysis of materials that would fail in a ductile manner.
� The selection of one or the other of these theories is something
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I15
� The selection of one or the other of these theories is something that you, the engineer, MUST DECIDE.
66--7 7 Failure of Ductile Materials SummaryFailure of Ductile Materials Summary
� For Design Purposes:
Maximum Shear Stress (MSS) Theory is
� easy
� quick to use
� conservative
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I16
� If the problem is to learn why a part failed, then the
Distortion Energy (DE) Theory may be best to use. Figure 6-23 shows that the locus of the DE passes closer to the central area of the data points, and thus is generally a better predictor of failure.
66--7 7 Failure of Ductile Materials SummaryFailure of Ductile Materials Summary
� For ductile materials with , the Mohr Theory is the best available. However, the theory requires the results from three separate modes of tests, graphical construction of the failure locus, and fitting the largest Mohr’s circle to the failure locus.
yt ycS S≠
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I17
� Coulomb-Mohr Theory (CM) which requires only tensile and compressive yield strengths and represents an alternative to Mohr Theory. It is easily dealt with in equation form.
Example Example 66--33
A certain force F applied at D nearthe end of the 15-in lever shownin Fig. 6-24, which is quite similarto a socket wrench, results incertain stresses in thecantilevered bar OABC. The barOABC is of AISI 1035 steel, forgedand heat treated so that it has a
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I18
and heat treated so that it has aminimum (ASTM) yield strength of81 Kpsi. We presume that thiscomponent would be of no valueafter yielding. Thus the force Frequired to initiate yielding canbe regarded as the strength of thecomponent part. Find this force.
Figure. 6-24
Example Example 66--3 3 (Cont.’ d)(Cont.’ d)
Assuming lever DC strong enough
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
34 3
34 3
2 32 1432142.6
64 1
2 16 151676.4
32
x
zx
M d FMc MF
I d d
T d FTr TF
J d d
σπ π π
τπ π π
= = = = =
= = = = =
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I19
( ) ( )34 3
76.432 1
zx FJ d d
τπ π π
= = = = =
Using the DE theory, we find, from Eq. (6-15)
Equating the Von Mises stress to , we solve for and get
( ) ( ) ( )1 21 2 2 2' 2 2
3 142.6 3 76.4 194.5x zx
F F Fσ σ τ = + = + × =
yS
81,000416
194.5 194.5lbf
yS
F = = =
F
Example Example 66--3 3 (Cont.’ d)(Cont.’ d)
In this example the strength of the material point A is . The strengthof the assembly or component is .
Using the MMS Theory, for a point undergoing plane stress with only one non-zero normal stress and one shear stress, the two nonzero principal stresses and will have opposite signs and hence fit case 2 for the MSS Theory. From Eq. (4-13)
( )1 2
2
σ
81kpsiy
S =416 lbfF =
Aσ Bσ
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I20
case 2 for the MSS Theory, Eq. (6-5) applies and hence
( )2
1 22 2 2
2 42
xA B zx x zx
σσ σ τ σ τ
− = + = +
( )
( ) ( )
1 22 2
1 22 2
4
142.6 4 76.4 209 81,000
388 lbf
x zx yS
F F F
F
σ τ+ =
+ = =
=
Example Example 66--4 4 ((Textbook Page Textbook Page 271271))
The cantilever tube shown in Fig. 6-25 is to be made of 2014 aluminum alloy treated to obtain a specified minimum yield strength of 276 MPa. We wish to select a stock-size tube from Table A-8 using a
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I21
tube from Table A-8 using a design factor . The bending load is F=1.75 kN, the axial tension is P = 9.0 kN, and the torsion is T = 72 N.m. What is the realized factor of safety?
4dn =
Figure 6-25
Example Example 66--4 4 ((Textbook Page Textbook Page 271271))
( )( )120 1.75 29 9 105o ox
dP Mc d
A I A I A Iσ = + = + = +
SOLUTION
The normal stress for an element on the top surface of the tube at the origin is
(1)
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I22
The torsional stress at the same point is
( ) ( )72 2 36o o
zx
d dTr
J J Jτ = = = (2)
Example Example 66--4 4 ((Cont.’dCont.’d))
0.276S
For accuracy, we choose the DE as the design basis. The Von Mises stress is
(3)( )1 2
2 2' 3
x zxσ σ τ= +
On the basis of the given design factor, the goal for is 'σ
Slide #
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I23
ME ME 307 307 MACHINE DESIGN IMACHINE DESIGN I23
0.276' 0.0690
4GPa
y
d
S
nσ ≤ = =
Programming Using MATLAB or EXCEL , entering metric sizes from Table A-8 reveals that a 42-X 5- mm is satisfactory. The Von Mises stress is found to be
for this size. Thus the realized factor of safety is
(4)
' 0.06043GPaσ =
0.2764.57
' 0.06043
ySn
σ= = =