8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
1/90
[1]
Analyzing Market PotentialFor Franchisee Acquisition
Name of the company: Motilal OswalConnaught Place (New Delhi)
NAME : MOHIT CHOMAL
ENROLLMENT NO. : 08BS0001770
IBS,NOIDA
SUMMER INTERNSHIP PROGRAMFINAL REPORT
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
2/90
FINAL REPORT
ON
Analyzing Market Potential
For Franchisee Acquisition
By
MOHIT CHOMAL
A Report submitted in partial fulfillment of the
requirements of
MBA program of ICFAI Business School, Noida
Submitted To
MR. RAKESH SHARMA
Company Guide
Motilal Oswal, Connaught Place, New Delhi
Prof. Y.P.GUPTAFaculty Guide
ICFAI Business School, Noida
[2]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
3/90
TABLE OF CONTENTS
S.No. Topic Page
No.
Authorization 4
Acknowledgment 5
Executive Summary 6
Chapter 1 Overview Of Industry
1.1 Broking Industry Insight 3
1.2 Major developments in equity brokerage industry in India 7
1.3 Growth Driver of Equity Market 9
1.4 Market Analysis of Broking Business 10
1.5 Major players in the industry 12
Chapter 2 Introduction to the Project
2.1 Need for the Project 14
2.2 Objectives of the project 15
2.3 Scope of the project 16
2.4 Limitations of the Project 16Chapter 3 Introduction of Motilal Oswal
3.1 History 19
3.2 Motilal Oswal Products & Services 20
3.3 Business Acquisition Group 27
[3]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
4/90
3.4 Competitor Analysis 28
Chapter 4 Research Methodology
4.1 Methodology used for this Project 34
Chapter 5 Data Analysis
5.1 Main Broker & Sub broker Analysis 45
5.2 Detailed Analysis of the Questionnaire 47
5.3 Cross Tab Analysis 59
5.4 Prospects Generated for Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd. 66
5.5 Micro Profiling of the best Prospects 68
Chapter 6 Recommendations
6.1 Recommendations 73
6.2 Conclusion 74
Annexure
Survey Questionnaire 76
Appendix
Bibliography 80
[4]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
5/90
LETTER OF AUTHORIZATION
This is to certify that this Marketing Research report, title Analyzing the Market
Potential for Franchisee Acquisition is the bonafide work of Mr. Mohit Chomal of
ICFAI Business School, Noida.
The report will only be used for Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd. Internal use andwill not be used as a commercial data.
Authorized by:
Mr. Rakesh Sharma
Manager, BAG
Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd.
(Company Guide)
[5]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
6/90
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Words express everything
Mouth Co-ordinates,
When it comes to gratitude,
Heart comes to play.
It gives me immense pleasure for an opportunity to have undergone my Summer
internship with Motilal Oswal Securities Limited. There is always a sense of gratitude
which one expresses to other people for their helpful and needy service they render
during phases of life. I too would like to do the same as I really wish to express my
gratitude to those who have been helpful to me in getting this project completed.
In representing this report I would like to express my gratitude to Mr. RakeshSharma, Manager, Motilal Oswal Securities Limited for giving me this wonderful
opportunity to work with Business Associate Group, and providing me with his able
guidance and inspiration for the completion of project.
I would also like to express my gratitude to Mr. Munish Chauhan for his co-
operation and guidance without which this project would never have been a success.
I am also indebted to all the internal employees and fellow trainees of Motilal Oswalfor providing consistent encouragement and congenial atmosphere to complete the
project.
Last but not the least I will express my sincere thanks to Prof. Y.P. Gupta and ICFAI
Business School for providing me with support and necessary guidance and valuable
instructions for the completion of this project.
[6]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
7/90
Executive Summary
It is well evident that work experience is an indispensable part of every professional
course. In the same manner practical training is must for each and every individual
who is undergoing management course.
Without the practical exposure one cannot consider himself or herself as a qualified
capable manager. During the project period student can learn through his own
experience, the real situation of market and corporate world and to put his theoretical
knowledge into practice. Hence to fulfill the requirement, I have completed my Two
Months Internship in Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd. on the topic Market Potential for
Franchisee, given to me by my company guide.
Being new to the Stock Market, I was engrossed fully into the sector where I was told
to understand the basics of stock market, the effect of recession on this sector, I was
told to educate various sub brokers operating in Delhi about the benefits of theFranchisee being offered by Motilal Oswal, and how this opportunity can profit both
the parties. I also did a survey for extracting information from brokers, which would
be helpful for the company to find a suitable partner as a franchisee holder.
I was told to make calls and generate the franchisees for the company. Some time I
have to extract the information from my sources because no one is theyre waiting foryou its actually you, which have to make things happen in your favor. So I read
articles brochures pamphlets in my free time there. Every day have its own experience
and a short-term goal. So I adopted the line that let the dreams of today determine the
opportunities of tomorrow and I inculcated the same positive attitude in to me so that
I would work there effectively and efficiently.
[7]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
8/90
Chapter 1OVERVIEW OF INDUSTRY
[8]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
9/90
1.1 Broking Industry Insight
The equity brokerage industry in India is one of the oldest in the Asia region. India
had an active stock market for about 150 years that played a significant role in
developing risk markets as also promoting enterprise and supporting the growth of
industry.
The working of stock exchanges in India started in 1875. BSE is the oldest stock
market in India. The history of Indian stock trading starts with 318 persons taking
membership in Native Share and Stock Brokers Association, which we now know by
the name Bombay Stock Exchange or BSE in short. In 1965, BSE got permanent
recognition from the Government of India. National Stock Exchange comes second to
BSE in terms of popular.
Stock trading is a big business in any way and in any standards. With daily volumesof Rs12000-15000 crore (on the BSE and NSE) in the cash segment and a volume of
about Rs 30,000 35,000 crore in the derivative market, the size of the industry is
around Rs 5,000 crore per annum in terms of broking revenues. Meanwhile the
trading business too is booming. BSE and NSE represent themselves as synonyms of
Indian stock market. The history of Indian stock market is almost the same as the
history of BSE. The current "stock market" is comprised of 300,000 computers
situated on pro trader's desks. These computers are networked together using
sophisticated protocols. This level of information sharing makes pricing an almost
exact science.
These 300,000 computers are further linked to another 26 million computers
worldwide. These computers are located in banks, small businesses, and large
[9]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
10/90
corporations. These computers comprise the banking networks, which make
computerized transactions possible.
Finally, these computers are connected to another 300 million+ computers, which
connect and disconnect from the financial markets daily. In New York City alone,
these transactions amount to over $2.2 trillion dollars daily.
Sensex crossed the 5000 mark in 1999 and the 6000 mark in 2000. The 7000 mark
was crossed in June and the 8000 mark on September 8 in 2005 and by 2007 It has
already seen mark 14500. Many foreign institutional investors (FII) are investing in
India. The liberal economic policies pursued by successive Governments attracted
foreign institutional investors to a large scale.
The unpredictable behavior of the market gave it a tag a volatile market.India,
after United States hosts the largest number of listed companies. Global investors
now ardently seek India as their preferred location for investment.
Beginning of a New Equity Culture
A new phase in the Indian stock markets began in the 1970s, with the introduction of
Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) that led to divestment of foreign equity by
the multinational companies, which created a surge in retail investing. The early
1980s witnessed another surge in stock markets when major companies such as
Reliance accessed equity markets for resource mobilisation that evinced huge interest
from retail investors.
A new set of economic and financial sector reforms that began in the early 1990s
gave further impetus to the growth of the stock markets in India. As a part of thereform process, it became imperative to strengthen the role of the capital markets that
could play an important role in efficient mobilization and allocation of financial
resources to the real economy. Towards this end, several measures were taken to
streamline the processes and systems including setting up an efficient market
infrastructure to enable Indian finance to grow further and mature. The importance of
an efficient micro market infrastructure came into focus following the incidence of
[10]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
11/90
market abuses in securities and banking markets in 1991 and 2001 that led to
extensive investigations by two respective Joint Parliamentary Committees.
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI),which was set up in 1988 asan administrative arrangement, was given statutory powers with the enactment of the
SEBI Act, 1992. The broad objectives of the SEBI include
to protect the interests of the investors in securities
to promote the development of securities markets and to regulate the securities
markets
The scope and functioning of the SEBI has greatly expanded with the rapid growth
of securities markets in India in the last fifteen years.
Following the recommendations of the High Powered Study Group on Establishment
of New Stock Exchanges, the National Stock Exchange of India (NSE) was
promoted by financial institutions with an aim to provide access to investors all over
the country. NSE was incorporated in Nov 1992 as a tax paying company, the first of
such stock exchanges in India, since stock exchanges earlier were trusts, being run on
no-profit basis. NSE was recognized as a stock exchange under the SecuritiesContracts (Regulations) Act 1956 in Apr 1993. It commenced operations in
wholesale debt segment in Jun 1994 and capital market segment (equities) in Nov
1994. The setting up of the National Stock Exchange brought to Indian capital
markets several innovations and modern practices and procedures such as nationwide
trading network, electronic trading, greater transparency in price discovery and
process driven operations that had significant bearing on further growth of the stock
markets in India.
Faster and efficient securities settlement system is an important ingredient of a
successful stock market. To speed the securities settlement process, The Depositories
Act 1996 was passed that allowed for dematerialization (and re-materialization) of
securities in depositories and the transfer of securities through electronic book entry.
The National Securities Depository Limited (NSDL) set up by leading financial
[11]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
12/90
institutions, commenced operations in Oct 1996. Regulations governing selection of
various types of market intermediaries as depository participations were made.
Subsequently, Central Depository Services (India) Limited promoted by Bombay
Stock Exchange and other financial institutions came into being.
Rapid Growth
The last decade has been exceptionally good for the stock markets in India. In the
back of wide ranging reforms in regulation and market practice as also the growing
participation of foreign institutional investment, stock markets in India have showed
phenomenal growth in the early 1990s. The stock market capitalization in mid-2007
is nearly the same size as that of the gross domestic product as compared to about 25
percent of the latter in the early 2000s. Investor base continued to grow from
domestic and international markets. The value of share trading witnessed a sharp
jump too. Foreign institutional investment in Indian stock markets showed
continuous rise reaching about USD10 bn in each of these years between FY04 to
FY06. Stock markets became intensely technology and process driven, giving little
scope for manual intervention that has been the source of market abuse in the past.
Electronic trading, digital certification, straight through processing, electronic
contract notes, online broking have emerged as major trends in technology. Risk
management became robust reducing the recurrence of payment defaults. Product
expansion took place in a speedy manner. Indian equity markets now offer, in
addition to trading in equities, opportunities in trading of derivatives in futures and
options in index and stocks. ETFs are showing gradual growth. Within five years of
introduction of derivatives, Indian stock markets now are ranked first in stock futures
and fourth in index futures. Indian stock markets are transaction intensive and thus
rank among the top five markets in this regard. Stock exchange reforms brought in
professional management separating conflicts of interest between brokers as owners
of the exchanges and traders/dealers. The demutualization and corporatization of all
stock exchanges is nearing completion and the boards of the stock exchanges now
[12]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
13/90
have majority of independent directors. Foreign institutions took stake in Indias two
leading domestic stock exchanges. While NYSE Group led consortium took stake in
the National Stock Exchange, Deutsche Borse and Singapore Stock Exchange bought
equity in the Bombay Stock Exchange Ltd.
1.2Major Developments in Equity Brokerage Industry in India
i) Corporate memberships
There is a growing surge of corporate memberships (92% in NSE and 75% in BSE),
and the scope of functioning of the brokerage firms has transformed from that of
being a family run business to that of professional organized function that lays
greater emphasis on observance of market principles and best practices. With
proliferation of new markets and products, corporate nature of the memberships is
enabling broking firms to expand the realm of their operations into other exchanges
as also other product offerings.
ii) Wider product offerings
The product offerings of brokerage firms today go much beyond the traditional
trading of equities. A typical brokerage firm today offers trading in equities and
derivatives, most probably commodities futures, exchange traded funds, distributes
mutual funds and insurance and also offers personal loans for housing, consumptions
and other related loans, offers portfolio management services, and some even go to
the extent of creating niche services such as a brokerage firm offering art advisoryservices.
iii) Greater reliance on research
Client advising in India has graduated from personal insights, market tips to
becoming extensively research oriented and governed by fundamentals and technical
factors. Vast progress has been made in developing company research and refining
[13]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
14/90
methods in technical and fundamental analysis. The research and advice are made
online giving ready and real time access to market research for investors and clients,
thus making research important brand equity for the brokerage firms.
iv) Accessing equity capital markets
Access to reliable financial resources has been one of the major constraints faced by
the equity brokerage industry in India since long. Since the banking system is not
fully integrated with the securities markets, brokerage firms face limitations in
raising financial resources for business and expansion. With buoyancy of the stock
markets and the rising prospects of several well-organized broking firms, important
opportunity to access capital markets for resource mobilization has become available.
The recent past witnessed several leading brokerage firms accessing capital markets
for financial resources with success.
v) Foreign collaborations and joint ventures
The way the brokerage industry is run and the manner in which several of them
pursued growth and development attracted foreign financial institutions andinvestment banks to buy stakes in domestic brokerage firms, paving the way for
stronger brokerage entities and possible scope for consolidation in the future. Foreign
firms picked up stake in some of the leading brokerage firms, which might lead to
creating of greater interest in investing in brokerage firms by entities in India and
abroad.
vi) Specialized services/niche broking
While supermarkets approach are adopted in general by broking firms, there are
some which are creating niche services that attract a particular client group such as
day traders, arbitrage trading, investing in small cap stocks etc, and providing
complete range of research and other support to back up this function.
vii) Online broking
[14]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
15/90
Several brokers are extending benefits of online trading through creation of separate
windows. Some others have dedicated online broking portals. Emergence of online
broking enabled reduction in transaction costs and costs of trading. Keen competition
has emerged in online broking services, with some of these offering trading services
at the cost of a few basis points or costs, which are fixed in nature irrespective of the
volume of trading conducted. A wide range of incentives is being created and offered
by online brokerage firms to attract larger number of clients.
viii)Compliance oriented
With stringent regulatory norms in operation, broking industry is giving greater
emphasis on regulatory compliance and observance of market principles and codes of
conduct. Many brokerage firms are investing time, money and resources to create
efficient and effective compliance and reporting systems that will help them in
avoiding costly mistakes and possible market abuses.
ix) Focus on training and skill sets
Brokerage firms are giving importance and significance to aspects such as trainingon skill sets that could prove to be beneficial in the long run. With the nature of
markets and products becoming more complex, it becomes imperative for the
broking firms to keep their staff continuously updated with latest development in
practices and procedures.
1.3 Growth Driver of Equity market
The major growth drivers for brokerage revenue and trading volume are:-
Continuous fall in brokerage fees: This is happening due more and more
interest of people in broking and huge competition in the market. Many
Broking houses are reducing their brokerage in order increase the volumes of
trading/jobbing intra-day and gross. Resulting in a compensation for the
[15]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
16/90
reduced fees. The client gets an advantage and wishes for more and more intra-
day sell and purchases. Theres a limit on the same as 8-10 times depending
upon the broking house and the reputation of the client in the market.
Adoption of technology: Earlier most of broking houses used simple
connection to connect to the BSE/NSE or the Main Broker. But, these days
many have started using V-SAT technology which is highly advanced, secure
and fast.
Centralized operations: The Back office is no more a setup in broking houses
its all web-based having its roots at the registered office of the firm. Thishelps in reducing the deviations from the set guidelines and results in fast and
secure transactions. Hence, more control, equality and effectiveness are
observed even in the remotest franchisee of the firm.
1.4 Market Analysis of Broking Business
Buyer Power
Lack of Expertise Curtails Bargaining Power
Knowledge of the industry in which one is working is very important without
knowledge one cannot even think of growing in the market. Knowledge is the only
thing in this which cannot be Sold, purchased or stolen it can only be gained by
experience, studying or through a seniors advice. Retail investors often lack the
knowledge and expertise in the financial sector that calls them to approach the
broking houses, which have complete a research reports and market updates in order
to guide the investor decision and to create wealth.
Low Product Differentiation Proves Beneficial
[16]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
17/90
The retail broking services provided by the various companies are homogeneous with
very low product differentiation. This allows customers to enjoy a greater bargaining
power. The only difference widely observed is either the Brand of the broking or the
support which he provides apart from usual share trading.
Intensity of Competition
Move towards consolidation
Lot of brokerage companies is moving towards consolidation with the smaller ones
becoming either franchisees for the larger brokers or closing operations.
Increased Focus of Banks in Retail Broking
Various foreign banks like ABN Amro and others are planning to enter the Indian
retail brokerage industry. This can be taken as positive note from the view of the
whole industry, since it is growing so more and more people are willing to be a part of
it as well as a negative note from the view of broking houses, since it will increase
competition in the market.
Online Trading Competes with Traditional Brokerage
There is an increasing demand for online trading due to consumers growing
preference for internet as compared to approaching the brokers.
Threat of New Entrants
Entry of Foreign Players
New forms of trading including T+2 settlement system, dematerialization etc are
strengthening the retail brokerage market and attracting foreign companies to enter
the Indian industry.
Threat of Substitutes
Alternative Investment Options
[17]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
18/90
Various alternative forms of investment including fixed deposits with banks and post
offices etc act as substitutes to retail broking products and services.
1.5 Major Players in the Industry
ICICI Securities Ltd. (www.icicidirect.com)
Kotak Securities Ltd. (www.kotaksecurities.com)
India bulls Financial Services Limited (www.indiabulls.com)
India Info line (www.5paisa.com)
IL&FS invest mart Limited (www.investsmartindia.com)
SSKI Ltd. (www.sharekhan.com)
Fortis Securities (Religare) (www.fortissecurities.com)
Karvy (www.karvy.com)
HDFC Securities (www.hdfcsec.com)
Motilal Oswal Securities (www.motilaloswal.com)
[18]
http://www.hdfcsec.com/http://www.hdfcsec.com/8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
19/90
Chapter 2.
INTRODUCTION TO THE PROJECT
[19]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
20/90
Being a reputed company in the business it is of utmost importance for Motilal Oswal
to be aware of what is going on in the market, what is expected of them and how are
they performing and do they need any improvements. So, to cover all these areas a
detailed analysis of all this aspects has been done. The project revolves around the
whole financial market business. Through this project, an effort towards
understanding and throwing more light on every aspect related to the business has
been undertaken. It will surely help Motilal Oswal in getting a detailed insight into the
business and developing marketing strategy in such a way that most can be reaped
from the market of franchisee integration. Not only that, it was tried to give the
business a new dimension in terms of approaching the sub-broker to generate leads
which may in turn help in getting larger market share. The project had two market
research parts
Market survey of the prospective sub-brokers
Expansion plan of Motilal Oswal.
Besides that the marketing strategies used by other companies in same business was
studied and suggestions were drawn to develop an effective strategy.
Besides these major issues many other issues were taken care of in this report.
2.1The Need for This Project
[20]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
21/90
No study has been done on this business so far So far no study has been
done regarding this business in New Delhi, so a detailed study of the market is
required to understand it properly.
Lack of understanding of the need of the business houses Since no
segmentation study has been done the specific needs of different companies are
not known.
Focus the existing marketing team at right market The lack of
understanding of the market wastes a lot of effort of the sales team. The
business is generated through cold calls right now. But if there was a proper
understand the requirement of each type of market segment the sales team may
pitch in right mix of products to the right prospective clients.
Lot of small players cropping up It always creates a problem when the
market starts getting congested. Same is the case with the market of financial
business. Through this project I have tried to develop a structured view of the
market which will not only help in understand the whole market but also help
in targeting the marketing force at the right places to get more business. Same array of products Almost all the companies in the market are pitching
in same array of products and hence this causes more problems as the
unprofessional players are able to provide the integration at less cost. So
anyone who is able to get a supply of the major financial techniques and senses
required for setting up franchisee integration jumps into the business with a
team of local people. They not only eat up the market share but also degrade
the service level required for this type of job and hence degrade the market as awhole.
Innovation in approach required With all these problems, it becomes of
utmost importance for a company to innovate to reach at the top. So,
innovation in terms of products, lead generation, and communication strategy
is required.
[21]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
22/90
No idea of the position of the competitors The companies doesnt have any
idea what the other companies in the same business are doing to generate more
business, what are the innovations going around in the market.
Lack of understanding of the satisfaction of existing customers It always
pays to introspect oneself. But so far no formal study in this regard has been
undertaken so we dont know how we have performed so far.
2.2 Objectives of the project
Analyzing broking market potential.
Providing data driven decision for franchisee acquisition. Analyzing the franchisee model of MOSL with respect to two major broking
houses & conduct a SWOT analysis of MOSL.
Understanding the B2B marketing environment.
To increase the number of franchisee
Understanding the process of marketing research suitable for B2B
environment.
2.3 Scope of the project
The project focuses at understanding the existing forces that determine the acquiring
of a solution like Franchisee Model Integration. Through this project we have been
able to reach at a certain number of factors that are the main deciding factors that are
taken under consideration by the companies while purchasing integration products.
The project also aimed at segmenting the market and understanding the individual
needs of each market segment. This kind of exercise will not only help the company
in focusing its marketing activity to the right kind of business enterprises but will also
help in designing right mix of strategy to cater to the needs of sub-brokers in the best
way possible. It is always wise to keep a track of what the competitor proposes to do
in future as it alarms the market leader to be geared for the future. So, this study will
help the company in gaining an insight into the innovations that are being done by
[22]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
23/90
other companies in the same kind of business. It was also aimed to study the level of
satisfaction among the existing sub-brokers of the competitor company and gather
their feedback to see what more the clients expect in terms of products, consultancy,
return on investment and innovation. And last but not the least in order to make the
summer internship program more fruitful in terms of academic learning, a complete
analysis of the functioning of the franchisee integration business was done along with
the organizational structure and other minor details.
2.4 Limitations of the project
Although the project aims at making an in-depth market research but there are somepractical limitations regarding the methodology followed & the overall procedure.
These can be summed up under the following points ---
The sample taken for this research might not represent the whole population.
Since the survey is conducted exclusively on individual companies the
personal view of the respondent may make lead to some biasness in the results.
Some people do not want to give correct details required in the questionnaire.
It is also possible that some people might have given false or misleading
information.
Many people doubted the fact that the information given by them would be
kept strictly confidential.
Many big companies do not respond to such market research.
Many companies didnt respond properly and mentioned that decisions
regarding these issues are taken by their head offices.
Many companies do not wish to give out information which leads to
incomplete responses.
Many people gave unauthentic information to hide their ignorance.
[23]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
24/90
Chapter 3.INTRODUCTION OF
MOTILAL OSWAL
[24]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
25/90
Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd. (MOFSL) is a well-diversified, financial
services company focused on wealth creation for all its customers, such as
institutional and corporate clients, HNI and retail customers. Our services and product
offerings include equity broking, commodity broking, and distribution of third party
products, investment banking and venture capital management.
It is one of the most respected corporate houses known for their business research and
franchisee model initiation of sub-broker reforms besides being recognized for their
values of fair, transparent and ethical dealings.
The spirit of entrepreneurship, the vision of a dynamic tomorrow, and the capacity to
build and realize dreams! This is the essence of the Motilal Oswal. No wonder then,
Motilal Oswal has become the symbol of a vibrant multi-business enterprise touching
the lives of many and at the same time an icon of enduring ideals in a changing world.
3.1 History
[25]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
26/90
Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd. was founded in 1987 as a small sub-broking unit, with
just two people running the show. Focus on customer-first-attitude, ethical and
transparent business practices, respect for professionalism, research-based value
investing and implementation of cutting-edge technology has enabled us to blossom
into an almost 2000 member team.
Today we are a well diversified financial services firm offering a range of financial
products and services.
Motilal Oswal has a diversified client base that includes retail customers (including
High Net worth Individuals), mutual funds, foreign institutional investors, financial
institutions and corporate clients.
The headquarter is in Mumbai and as of December 31st, 2008, had a network spread
over 512 cities and towns comprising 1,428 Business Locations operated by our
Business Partners and us. As at December 31st, 2008, the total number of registered
customers wad 5, 27,368.
Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd. (MOFSL) is a well-diversified, financial
services company focused on wealth creation for all its customers, such asinstitutional and corporate clients, HNI and retail customers. Our services and product
offerings include equity broking, commodity broking, and distribution of third party
products, investment banking and venture capital management.
Mr. Motilal Oswal and Mr. Raamdeo Agrawal laid the foundation for MOFSL and
initially conducted business as a sub-broking firm. Thus, began the expedition of
building a professional organization with strong value systems, to provide investment
advice to investors.
Today, Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd. is a well-established brand among retail
and institutional investors in India, with a presence in over 1533 business locations
across over 487 cities
.
From a sub-broking firm, Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd. has today become a
[26]
http://tmp/svfk8.tmp/javascript:OpenPopUpWindow('/india_map.html','NewWin',0,0,'yes','yes',592,700)http://tmp/svfk8.tmp/javascript:OpenPopUpWindow('/india_map.html','NewWin',0,0,'yes','yes',592,700)8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
27/90
solid financial services company straddling a spectrum of businesses in the financial
services space. These businesses include Wealth Management, Institutional Equities,
Investment Banking and Venture Capital Management.
3.2 Motilal Oswal Products and Services
Today Motilal Oswal is a well diversified financial services firm offering a range of
financial products and services such as
Wealth Management
Broking & Distribution
Commodity Broking
Portfolio Management Services
Institutional Broking
Private Equity
Investment Banking Services and
Principal Strategies
[27]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
28/90
Wealth Management
Financial planning for individual, family and business wealth creation andmanagement needs. These are provided to customers through our Wealth
Management service called Purple.
Broking & Distribution services
Equity (cash and derivatives)
Commodity broking
Portfolio Management Services
Distribution of financial products
Financing
Depository Services
IPO distribution
[28]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
29/90
We offer these services through our branches, Business Partner locations, the internet
and mobile channels. We also have strategic tie-ups with State Bank of India and
IDBI Bank to offer our online trading platform to its customers.
Commodity Broking
Through Motilal Oswal Commodities Broker (P) Ltd our fully owned subsidiary; we
provide commodity trading facilities and related products and services on MCX and
NCDEX. Besides access to the best of research in the form of Daily Fundamentals &
Technical Reports on highly traded commodities, our clients also get access to our
exclusive Customized Trading Advice on both the trading platforms. We offer these
[29]
http://www.motilaloswal.com/Commodityhttp://www.motilaloswal.com/Commodity8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
30/90
services through our branches, Business Partner locations, the internet and mobile
channels
Portfolio Management Services
Motilal Oswal Portfolio Management Services offer a range of investments solutions
through discretionary services. We at Motilal Oswal have helped create wealth for our
customers through our Portfolio Management Services. Our knowledge of the markets
together with our understanding of our customers and their risk profiles has helped us
design a range of portfolio offerings for our clients. These include the Value PMS,
Bulls Eye PMS, Trillion Dollar Opportunity and Focused Portfolio Series I. As of
December 31st, 2008, the Assets under Management of our various portfolio schemes
stood at Rs.5.04bn.
Motilal Oswal group has applied to the regulatory bodies for a license to operate as a
Domestic Asset Management Company (Mutual Fund) and we expect to begin
operations soon.
Institutional Broking
We offer equity broking services in the cash and derivative segments to institutional
clients in India and overseas. These clients include companies, mutual funds, banks,
financial institutions, insurance companies, and FIIs. As at December 31st, 2008, we
were empanelled with over 300 institutional clients including 200 FIIs. We service
these clients through dedicated sales teams across different time zones.
[30]
http://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ReportID=4C85DF26-14A8-4DCF-AF90-D9368AAE1F74http://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=e424c05f-9d2a-494e-ba04-27c8a2cf6c7dhttp://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=1507a912-dded-4ca7-b987-db9295ae213bhttp://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=0115fbb7-ead7-4679-8e44-56d281869781http://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=2295fcb5-3697-4f03-920e-d189fa4bcf47http://www.motilaloswal.com/Content.aspx?ReportID=0C2B2131-A6CA-444E-A7A3-C641AFEFB554http://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ReportID=4C85DF26-14A8-4DCF-AF90-D9368AAE1F74http://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=e424c05f-9d2a-494e-ba04-27c8a2cf6c7dhttp://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=1507a912-dded-4ca7-b987-db9295ae213bhttp://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=0115fbb7-ead7-4679-8e44-56d281869781http://www.motilaloswal.com/Retail/RetailContents.aspx?ArticleID=2295fcb5-3697-4f03-920e-d189fa4bcf47http://www.motilaloswal.com/Content.aspx?ReportID=0C2B2131-A6CA-444E-A7A3-C641AFEFB5548/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
31/90
Investment Banking
We offer financial advisory services relating to mergers and acquisitions (domestic
and cross-border), divestitures, restructurings and spin-offs through Motilal Oswal
Investment Advisors Private Ltd. (MOIAPL)
We also offer capital raising and other investment banking services such as the
management of public offerings, private placements (including qualified institutional
placements), rights issues, share buy backs, open offers/delisting and syndication of
debt and equity.
MOIAPL has closed 23 transactions in 2007-08 worth US$ 1.8 billion and had 18mandates in h and as at March31, 2008.
[31]
http://www.motilaloswal.com/Content.aspx?ReportID=96D62435-6C0B-4B34-B665-48051C02C359http://www.motilaloswal.com/Content.aspx?ReportID=96D62435-6C0B-4B34-B665-48051C02C3598/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
32/90
Private Equity
In 2006, our private equity subsidiary, Motilal Oswal Private Equity Advisors Private
Ltd (MOPEAPL) was appointed as the investment manager and advisor to a private
equity fund, India Business Excellence Fund, which was launched with a target of
raising US$100 mn. The fund is aimed at providing growth capital to small and
medium enterprises in India, with investments typically in the range of US $3 mn to
US $7 mn.
MOPEAPL will manage and advise the fund and other private equity funds, which
may be raised in the future. In its final closing, in December 2007, the fund obtained
commitments of US$125 mn (Rs.4, 875 mn) from investors in India and overseas.
The Fund has deployed/ committed $ 58 mn across 8 deals.
MOPEAPL has recently launched an INR 750 Crores domestic Real Estate Private
Equity Fund called India Realty Excellence Fund sponsored by Motilal Oswal
Financial Services Ltd.
[32]
http://www.motilaloswal.com/Content.aspx?ReportID=56AB8714-FEAC-44D7-93AF-DEA458925D0Ehttp://www.motilaloswal.com/Content.aspx?ReportID=56AB8714-FEAC-44D7-93AF-DEA458925D0E8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
33/90
MARKET SHARE: EQUITY BROKING
Principal Strategies Group
For effective management of treasury operations and to capitalize on market
opportunities, the Group has set up a 30 member team which would be responsible for
effective deployment of funds into different trading and arbitrage strategies.
Focus on Research
Research is the solid foundation on which Motilal Oswal Securities advice is based.
Almost 10% of revenue is invested on equity research and we hire and train the best
resources to become advisors. At present we have 23 equity analysts researching over
27 sectors. From a fundamental, technical and derivatives research perspective;
Motilal Oswal's research reports have received wide coverage in the media (over a
1000 mentions last year). Our consistent efforts towards quality equity research have
reflected in an increase in the ratings and rankings across various categories in the
Asia Money Brokers Poll over the years
[33]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
34/90
3.3 Business Acquisition Group (BAG)
The firm has a dedicated BAG department which deals with the acquisitions of
business partners at various locations all over India. This department has helped
Motilal Oswal to Grow at a very fast pace. Such a rapid growth is observed due to
acquisitions of the best businesses at most profitable locations.
Making a firm as a business partner is a tuff job. Since, as soon it becomes your
business partner its own identity is lost and its entire works are perceived as part of
the firm. It carries the brand along with it.
Business acquisitions act as dual benefit to the partnering firm as well as Motilal
Oswal.
On one hand, it provides the best research, brand and other associations benefits to
the firm joining hands. On the other, it expands Motilal Oswals foot in the country
and further Since, The firm was already performing. Hence, the risk for the company
reduces.
Anyhow, its works slow but has better results than simply selling the business
partnerships to inexperienced partners.
There are more than 1800 sub-brokers in Delhi & NCR area out of which Motilal has
only 20 Sub-brokers. There is a huge gap between the market share of Motilal and
other broking firms.
Hence, The Company wishes to bridge this gap by acquiring sub-brokers of other
firms. Like Share khan, SMC Global etc.
[34]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
35/90
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
36/90
Strength & weakness in respect to MOSL
Strength: -
Brand name associated with UTI
bank
Low security deposit Sharing starts with 60:40 ratio
No fixed charge for VSAT, Rs
5000 PM that also refundable if
brokerage earned by UTISEL is
Rs 1,50,000 in a quarter
Local servicing
Weakness: -
No exposure on security
Neither dedicated BD team nor
any mkt support.
No focus on research and services
No concept of dedicated
activation team for new
franchisee.
Only 15 days back office training
Low focus on cross selling of
products
Margin funding is not promoted Diversified business
[36]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
37/90
ICICI Direct.com
Model: - Online franchisee
Products: - NSE / BSE / NCDEX / MFs / IPO / insurance
Registration: - Rs 10,000 each for BSE & NSE
Deposit required: - Rs. 40000 + Rs 25000 for registration
Brokerage: - 30 paisa and 75 paisa
Sharing: - Rupee1/- ~ 2 Lk: - 30%, Rs. 2 Lk ~ 7.5 Lk: - 35%,
Rs. 7.5 Lk ~ 15 Lk: - 40%, Rs. 15 Lk ~ 25 Lk: - 45%,
Rs. 25 Lk +: - 50%
DP account: - Rs. 500 PA +Rs 10-30 per outgoing
Connectivity: - Broadband
Mkt support: - no (flex sheet, visiting card and pamphlets)
Software charges: - free
Training: - 1 week
Margin funding: - not for retail client
Exposure: - 4-6 times on intraday, no exposure on delivery
[37]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
38/90
Strength & weakness in respect to MOSL
Strength: -
11 lakh customer base (appox)
Low security deposit
Very efficient software
User friendly usage
Broadband connectivity
Real time settlement
Weakness: -
No exposure on security
No dedicated BD team nor any
mkt activity support
No focus on research and
services
No concept of dedicated
activation team for new
franchisee
Only 1week back office training.
Low focus on cross selling of
products
No exposure on delivery High brokerage charge
[38]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
39/90
SWOT ANALYSIS OF MOTOLAL OSWAL
Strength
Brand name World class service Dedicated business
development team 3 months dedicated activation Strong research based advice Focus on wealth management Cross selling of 3rd party
product Focus only on one business
Weakness
High Deposit Low focus on brand
promotion Servicing through central
level Technology and connectivity
is not highly up scaled
[39]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
40/90
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
41/90
Chapter 4.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
4.1 Methodology used for the project:
This project followed a simple & systematic methodology. I have followed a phase by
phase approach to complete this project.
1st PhaseIn the 1st phase I was informed about the whole business of franchisee integration. I
received complete knowledge about the details of the business and how it is done at
Motilal Oswal by Mr. Rakesh Sharma. In this stage I went through some websites to
find out more about this particular business. After joining the company on 13th Feb,
2009, problem definition was the most important task undertaken as it was going to
[41]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
42/90
determine the future course of action. The right understanding of the problem was as
important as the entire project itself. The project guide
Mr. Rakesh Sharma was a big help to me in determining this step. He not only
explained the in and out of the business but also the problems that the franchisee team
had been facing so far. After having a detailed conversation for several days
following problems were identified. I realized that no study has been done on this
particular business so far so I took it up as a job to do a complete analysis of the
business along with the problems defined by Mr. Rakesh Sharma. So I decided that
there will be three parts in my project pertaining to the three main parts that exists in
any business i.e.
Competitors analysis
Target customer analysis
Business from the target customer
For this systematic and standard steps were followed which formed the later phases of
my project.
Phase 2: Problem Definition
After joining the company on 13th Feb, 2009, problem definition was the most
important task undertaken as it was going to determine the future course of action.
The right understanding of the problem was as important as the entire project itself.
The project guide Mr. Rakesh Sharma was a big help to me in determining this step.
He not only explained the in and out of the business but also the problems that the
sales team had been facing so far. Besides that I also visited various internet sites to
gain an insight about the problem that the company might be facing.
After having a detailed conversation for several days following problems were
identified.
Management Decision Problem:
[42]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
43/90
a. How to maintain the leadership in the market that is becoming congested
by small players?
b. How to capture new market segments and what are the needs and
expectations of these segments?
c. What can be done towards sub-broker satisfaction and sub-broker loyalty?
Marketing Decision Problem:
a. What are the different segments of the market and what are their needs?
b. What are the actions going around in the market and how the competitor
companies are working to get an edge over Motilal Oswal?
c. What are the main benefits provided by the competitor companies to offer
their franchisee?
d. In a market where almost all the companies are offering same products
what more can be done to maintain the status of market leader?
e. What do the existing franchisees feel about the overall product?
f. Is there a need for enhancing the existing communication strategy of the
company?
The problem definition stage helped me clearly understand the expectation of the
company from the project and the direction in which one needs to move to achieve
those expectations.
Diagram: The process of Problem definition
[43]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
44/90
Phase 3: Developing an Approach to the Problem
Once the problems faced by the company were identified the next step included the
development of the approach to the problem, i.e. defining the research problems and
presenting them in a form which may be helpful in the process of market research. In
this step proper statement of problem was set up which is Expansion Plan of Motilal
Oswal that is of interest to the researcher.
Motilal Oswal has only twenty two (22) franchisee in Delhi & NCR, whereas the
actual potential is in between one hundred (100) to one hundred fifty (150). For the
Market Expansion Plan, Motilal Oswal needs to increase its total number of
franchisee in Delhi & NCR.
Preparing the statement of Research Objective
The objective of the project is To increase the number of franchisees.
Motilal Oswal has comparatively lesser number of franchisees in comparison to its
competitors like Reliance Money, Kotak Securities, Religare, Angel Broking etc.
Companys motive is to expand the market. So it has to increase the number of its
sub-brokers in Delhi & NCR region.
Phase 4: Research Design Formulation
Market research involves lot of effort and time, so it is always best to be very clear as
to what has to be done and how it has to be done and this was decided in the third step
of the project. From the understanding of the project I decided to go for a survey
research first to get a better idea of the market. And then go for the main descriptive
research. In this step following decisions were taken:
[44]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
45/90
1. Information should be obtained from sub-brokers currently operating in Delhi
& NCR region.
2. Time Allotted: 03 Months
3. Budget Allotted: Stipend for trainees
4. The first step towards the research will begin with a survey research. In this
research different sub-brokers of our competitor company across Delhi & NCR
will be contacted over the phone and will be asked few questions from a pre-
designed questionnaire. This step will give us some idea about our competitors
and how they are seeing the market. This will also help us to understand up to
what extent they are associated with their main broker.
5. Then the survey research part will follow in which the questionnaire will be
designed directly on the laptop, in word format so that responses can be
directly stored in softcopies. This strategy will not only save paper and make
the project environment friendly but also save us from the extra effort entering
the data on the laptop after collecting it.
6. Then the next step would be to meet them and ask them for information
relating to the questionnaire.7. Based on the outcome, proper schedule will be designed for the project which
will have provision for all the activities that are required to be undertaken.
8. Throughout the project internet will be used a lot to read about the different
companies in the same business in Delhi & NCR. And any special features
thus noticed will be documented.
9. And then a database of the companies, which will be visited for the responses,
will be collected from the various sites of stock exchange.10.Then the actual primary data collection step will take place in which sub-
brokers from the data base will be visited and then the responses will be
collected from people responsible for such kind of decision making.
11. On the basis of terms and conditions for franchisee of Motilal Oswal, trainees
are asked to provide extra information on the back page of the filled-up
questionnaire by observing the office set up. This includes number of
[45]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
46/90
computers, employees, terminals, area of office, decoration, branches. If
everything matches with the desired profile then they will recommend the
respective sub-broker.
12. The trainees are asked to collect the visiting card of the respective sub-broker
they are visiting to avoid any unfair means in data collection and also not to
disclose their identity.
13. Once the survey is done, then the responses will be checked for any incomplete
ones and theyll be discarded.
14. Then a meeting with the respective client is fixed for Senor Manager to have
the detailed discussion via telecalling by the trainees.
15.During the meeting the trainees are asked to be present over there to learn
various skills and expertise which are required in todays competitive world.
16. Then the collected data will be analyzed using SPSS.
17. This analysis will be documented.
18.The entire project will be reviewed once and then the final report will be
prepared.
Schedule of the Project:
The Timeline decided for the project:
16th Feb 21st Feb : Identification of the problem and defining it.
23rd Feb 28th Feb : Questionnaire Designing
2nd Mar 21st Mar : Data Collection
23rd Mar 28th Mar : Data Analysis.
30th Mar 18th Apr : Fixing Meeting via Telecalling
20th Apr 16th May : Meeting with Client
18th May 21st May : Review of Project
22nd May 28th May : Final report preparation
29th May : Final report submission.
[46]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
47/90
Diagram: the Flow of the work to be done for theProject
Phase 5: Survey Research
The primary objective of survey research is to provide an insight and anunderstanding into the details of the problem. For this a database of sub-brokers in the
same business across Delhi & NCR was collected. Fifteen companies were found to
be major players across Delhi & NCR. The list of the companies can be found in
Annexure 1.
Designing Questionnaire
This was the next step that was undertaken. In this step first of all the questionnaire
was designed to collect the responses of the companies regarding the franchisee. The
questionnaire was designed in word format.
It was intended from the beginning to make this project an environment friendly
project and use as few papers as possible.
[47]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
48/90
OBJECTIVES OF QUESTIONNAIRE:
The Questionnaire is developed while keeping in mind, the owner of a franchisee.
Since, ultimately he has to decide to become a part of MOSL.
(A Copy of a Blank and Filled questionnaire is attached in appendix)
To know Owners experience in the industry.
To know the willingness/interest of the owner in the business.
Is he having proper i.e. skills for the business.
To know how long that firm is serving the clients in that area and by what rate
is it growing.
Whats his perception about being more successful broker in the area?
What he feels he needs to satisfy his clients.
What challenge he is facing currently or he can face in the coming time and
what he learned out of it?
How far does he plan to go in coming 5 years?
Does he require any type of support in achieving his goals or does he feel he is
self sufficient.
What qualities he feels he needs to acquire to achieve his goals.
Phase 6: Analysis
In this phase the first job that was done was coding the data collected from the market
research in statistical software called SPSS so that it can be analyzed and
meaningful results can be drawn from them. Due to the small sample size of the sub-
brokers survey, no quantitative analysis was done just the important outcomes were
analyzed and documented in the analysis chapter in this report.The coded data from the prospective sub-brokers survey was used to analyze that
which is the factors that mainly affect the buying behavior of the companies. I also
tried to study what are the reasons that prevent or defer the franchisee integration
project.
[48]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
49/90
After everything was analyzed the results were taken into consideration and I tried to
present feasible solutions to the problems that exist. Also proper segmentation was
done according to the need of different market segments.
All the observations made and analyzed are given in the Analysis chapter later in the
report.
Phase 7: Report Preparation
In the final part of the project different suggestions and conclusions were drawn and
then the final report was prepared.
[49]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
50/90
Chapter 5.DATA ANALYSIS
5.1 MAIN BROKER & SUB BROKER ANALYSIS
Data has been analyzed using SPSS. Analysis includes Descriptive analysis(Frequencies), Non Parametric test (Chi Square) & Cross Tab Analysis.
The very first thing that a respondent writes in the questionnaire is his details like his
name, Address, Age etc. and the most importantly whether he is a main broker or a
sub broker.
[50]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
51/90
Type of broker
2 6.7 6.7 6.7
28 93.3 93.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Main Broker
Sub Broker
Total
ValidFrequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
Type of broker
Type of broker
Sub BrokerMain Broker
Frequency
30
20
10
0
In Data Collection Period, I was able to interview 30 Respondents; The Sample taken
consists of 2 Main Brokers & 28 Sub brokers. In this project, Sub brokers were the
target respondents, however few main brokers were also been visited in order to learnsome difference between a Main Broker & a Sub broker.
[51]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
52/90
Test Statistics
22.5331
.000
Chi-Squarea
df
Asymp. Sig.
Type of
broker
0 cells (.0%) have expected frequencies less than
5. The minimum expected cell frequency is 15.0.
a.
Since, Asymp. Sig. 0.000 < 0.05. Hence, there is a significant difference between
number of Main Brokers and Number of Sub brokers.
Hence, the objective is achieved to gain knowledge about main brokers and collected
data of sub brokers to find prospective clients.
Characteristics of a Main Broker:-
A Main Broker has a hoarding in his office stating that he is member at NSE
and/or BSE whereas a sub broker has a hoarding or certificate of association
with a main broker.
In comparison to Sub brokers, Most Main Brokers have a Big Office with
more than 40 systems. Main Brokers were not that helpful in disclosing the details. An average
waiting time at a Main broker was at least 20 minutes even after market hours.
I.e. after 4 P.M.
Some of the major Differences that were observed during the visit are as under:
MAIN BROKER SUB BROKER
A Main Broker gets BSE/NSE
Listing with an initial deposit of
minimum of Rs. 5 crore with
SEBI
A Main Broker is the one who is
directly attached with a Stock
Exchange
One can become a Sub broker
with even a Rs. 50 thousand of
deposit with a Main Broker.
A sub broker is the one who is
attached to stock market via a
[52]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
53/90
A Main Broker can serve to
anyone
Main broker.
A sub broker has specificclientele like, Retail customers.
5.2 Detailed Analysis of the Questionnaire
Question 1:- How long have you been in this line?
Years since respondent is in the business
2 6.7 6.7 6.7
11 36.7 36.7 43.3
17 56.7 56.7 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
< 2yr
2 to 5yrs
> 5yrs
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
Years since respondent is in the business
Years since respondent is in the business
> 5yrs2 to 5yrs< 2yr
Frequency
20
10
0
[53]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
54/90
The table above represents that out of 30 respondents only two respondents is new to
the market as they have less than 2 years of experience and majority of respondent
have more than 5 years of experience.
Test Statistics
11.400
2
.003
Chi-Squarea
df
Asymp. Sig.
Years
since
responde
nt is in the
business
0 cells (.0%) have expected frequencies less than
5. The minimum expected cell frequency is 10.0.
a.
Since, Asymp. Sig. 0.003< 0.05. There is significant difference in the population of
experienced & young players. This shows market is having experienced people & the
prospective clients appear to be much in the population.
[54]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
55/90
Question 2: What brought you to stock markets and made you think of a career
in it?
This Question asks the respondent about his main objective to get into the stock
market. It helps us in knowing about the persons instinct behind getting into this
business, for example one came in this business for short term profits or really wants
to grow the business & wants to cash out the brokerage in the bull market.
What brought the repondent to this business
3 10.0 10.0 10.0
12 40.0 40.0 50.0
15 50.0 50.0 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Good short term profits
Cash out the
brokerage oppurtunity
in a bull market
Develop required skills
to develop and serve
large clients
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
[55]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
56/90
What brought the repondent to this business
What brought the repondent to this business
Develop required sk i
Cash out the brokera
Good short term profF
requency
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Analysis:
The table above clearly shows that 50% of the respondents needs to develop the
required skills in order to serve the large client base. So this population can be the
target for Motilal Oswal to acquire them & partner their growth by helping themgathering the required skills through its support
Question 3: Whats your Educational Background and did you undergo any
formal training?
As per SEBI norms a person having an NCFM certificate in either of two modules or
both namely, Capital market and derivative market can operate the trading terminal
which is a basic Qualification in this business.
[56]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
57/90
Qualification of the respondent
21 70.0 70.0 70.0
7 23.3 23.3 93.3
2 6.7 6.7 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Basic qualificationalong with exchange
required certifica
Profess qualification
along with exchange
reqd certificate
Additional self
development and
mkrt related prg
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
Qualification of the respondent
Qualification of the respondent
Additional self deveProfess qualificatioBasic qualification
Frequency
30
20
10
0
Analysis:
It can be easily interpreted from the table that only 2 respondent
has additional qualification.
[57]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
58/90
Major respondent have basic Qualification of NCFM which is a good
sign as the population is adhering to the rule of SEBI of being NCFM
qualified.
Question 4: How long has this setup been in place & your
growth story?
Length of the current setup
4 13.3 13.3 13.3
10 33.3 33.3 46.7
16 53.3 53.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
5yrs
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
Length of the current setup
Length of the current setup
>5yrs2 to 5 yrs
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
59/90
Question 5: What qualities make a successful broker?
Qualities attributed to be a successful broker
15 50.0 50.0 50.0
5 16.7 16.7 66.7
10 33.3 33.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Higher ratio of
succesful trading calls
A culture of researched
idea's with good infra
and service
All of the above
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
[59]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
60/90
Qualities attributed to be a successful broker
Qualities attributed to be a successful broker
All of the aboveA culture of researcHigher ratio of succ
Frequ
ency
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Analysis:
50% of the respondents thinks that Higher ratio of successful calls given to the
customer is the key to become a successful broker. Motilal Oswal being best for its
Equity research in the industry can approach these clients as they would like to take
the research services of Motilal Oswal Securities in order to give more successful
calls to their customers.
Question 6: What are the factors for having a satisfied
client?
[60]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
61/90
Factors needed to satisfy cleints
23 76.7 76.7 76.77 23.3 23.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Prompt and timely serviceAll of the above
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
Factors needed to satisfy cleints
Factors needed to satisfy cleints
All of the abovePrompt and timely se
Frequen
cy
30
20
10
0
Analysis:
More than 76% of the respondents believe that prompt & timely addressing of the
client Queries plays an important role for having satisfied clients. For the proper
address to the queries of the customer, the Sub broker would require the Customer
Care Support & Motilal Oswal is the only company in the industry which provides
[61]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
62/90
this service to their Franchisee owners & hence these respondents can be convinced
by providing solution to this problem.
Question 8: What are the immediate challenges for this
industry & your plan to tackle this?
Immediate challenges for the industry
2 6.7 6.7 6.7
10 33.3 33.3 40.0
18 60.0 60.0 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Lack of interest
Fresh capital dryingup in Indian and
foriegn markets
Cut cost & wait for
good times
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
[62]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
63/90
Immediate challenges for the industry
Immediate challenges for the industry
Cut cost & wait forFresh capital dryingLack of interest
Freq
uency
20
10
0
Analysis:
Around 60% of the population believes that immediate challenge for the industry is to
cut down on cost & wait for good times to come for the market which is an intelligent
option to go with. So, Majority of the population is still optimistic about the market in
the time of the recession & they are waiting for the good times to come.
Question 9: What is your perception about the road aheadfor this industry?
[63]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
64/90
Perception about the road ahead as an industry
21 70.0 70.0 70.0
9 30.0 30.0 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
Recession would bot lastlonger than 2 quarters
The next cycle could be
bigger than previous one
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
Perception about the road ahead as an industry
Perception about the road ahead as an industry
The next cycle couldRecession would bot
Frequen
cy
30
20
10
0
Analysis:
70% of the respondents are optimistic & they feel that recession in the market would
not last more than 2 Quarters. Hence this population wants to grow & expand the
business after waiting for some time.
[64]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
65/90
Question 11: Where do you see your business after 5 years?
Where do you see your business after 5 years
12 40.0 40.0 40.0
6 20.0 20.0 60.0
1 3.3 3.3 63.3
10 33.3 33.3 96.7
1 3.3 3.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
NR
Having 10 branches
1 crore revenue per
monthTo be number one broker
others
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
[65]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
66/90
Where do you see your business after 5 years
Where do you see your business after 5 years
others
To be number one bro
1 crore revenue per
Having 10 branches
NR
Frequ
ency
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Analysis:
Majority (40%) of the respondents were not interested in revealing their goals,
however out of the responses received 33% wants to be a no. 1 broker of their
respective area.
Question 12: In order to achieve the goal what kind of support they require?
[66]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
67/90
BRND_VAL
4 13.3 13.3 13.31 3.3 3.3 16.7
1 3.3 3.3 20.0
2 6.7 6.7 26.7
22 73.3 73.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
NRRank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Rank 4
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
SUCSCALL
4 13.3 13.3 13.3
6 20.0 20.0 33.3
12 40.0 40.0 73.3
7 23.3 23.3 96.7
1 3.3 3.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Rank 4
Total
ValidFrequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
BCKOFF
3 10.0 10.0 10.0
14 46.7 46.7 56.7
6 20.0 20.0 76.7
7 23.3 23.3 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Total
Valid
Frequency PercentValid
PercentCumulative Percent
Marketing & business Development support
1 3.3 3.3 3.3
9 30.0 30.0 33.3
7 23.3 23.3 56.7
10 33.3 33.3 90.0
3 10.0 10.0 100.0
30 100.0 100.0
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Rank 4
Total
Valid
Frequency Percent
Valid
Percent
Cumulativ
e Percent
[67]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
68/90
Marketing & business Development support
Marketing & business Development support
Rank 4Rank 3Rank 2Rank 1NR
Frequency
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Analysis:
More than 50% of the respondents have ranked Marketing & Business Development
Support either 1 or 2, which means this support plays an important role in the growth
of the sub brokers.
[68]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
69/90
5.3CROSS TAB ANALYSIS
Analysis - 1
Years since respondent is in the business * Length of the current setup
Crosstabulation
Count
2 2
2 9 11
1 16 17
4 10 16 30
< 2yr
2 to 5yrs
> 5yrs
Years since respondent
is in the business
Total
5yrs
Length of the current setup
Total
[69]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
70/90
Years since respondent is in the business
> 5yrs2 to 5yrs< 2yr
Count
20
10
0
Length of the curren
5yrs
An
alysis:
Majority of the Respondents have entered into the market with their own set
up. Group which has experience more than 5 years also has its set up in place for
more than 5 years.
Hence the respondents (More than 50 %) have good hands on experience in
running a set up.
So Motilal Oswal should partner its Franchisee with these respondents because
of their experience in running a setup.
Analysis 2
[70]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
71/90
Years since respondent is in the business * Qualities attributed to be a successful broker
Crosstabulation
Count
2 2
4 2 5 11
9 3 5 17
15 5 10 30
< 2yr
2 to 5yrs
> 5yrs
Years since respondent
is in the business
Total
Higher
ratio of
succesful
trading
calls
A culture of
researche
d idea's
with good
infra and
service
All of the
above
Qualities attributed to be a successfulbroker
Total
Years since respondent is in the business
> 5yrs2 to 5yrs< 2yr
Count
10
8
6
4
2
0
Qualities attributed
Higher ratio of succ
esful trading calls
A culture of researc
hed idea's with good
All of the above
Analysis:
Higher ratio of successful calls given by broker is seems to be everybodys
choice.
[71]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
72/90
Respondents who have experience more than 2 years are also emphasizing on
research ideas coupled with good infrastructure.
Apart from this few of the respondents believes that for a successful broker one
cannot rely on any one particular quality, & one should try to have all thequalities.
Analysis 3
Immediate challenges for the industry * Perception about the road ahead
as an industry Crosstabulation
Count
2 2
7 3 10
12 6 18
21 9 30
Lack of interest
Fresh capital drying
up in Indian and
foriegn markets
Cut cost & wait for
good times
Immediate
challenges
for the
industry
Total
Recession
would bot
last longer
than 2
quarters
The nextcycle could
be bigger
than
previous
one
Perception about the road
ahead as an industry
Total
[72]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
73/90
Immediate challenges for the industry
Cut cost & wait for
Fresh capital drying
Lack of interestC
ount
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Perception about the
Recession would bot
last longer than 2 q
The next cycle could
be bigger than prev
Analysis:
The above cross tab analysis shows that the respondent who is optimistic & wants to
cut down the cost & waiting for the good time to come is also optimistic about the
market & saying recession would not last for more than 2 quarters means he is notpessimist & can guide the customers in a right way telling them about the correct
market scenario.
[73]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
74/90
Analysis 4
Where do you see your business after 5 years
others
Tobenum
beronebro
1crorerevenueper
Having10branches
NR
Count
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Marketing & business
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Rank 4
Analysis:
Around 40% of the respondents have not revealed about their goals.
Out of the responses received, respondents who want to have 10 branches
ranked Marketing & Business Development support as 1.
Respondents who want to be a number 1 broker of their area have ranked
this service as 2 & 3, as they do not wish to expand their branches.
[74]
Where do you see your business after 5 years * Marketing & business Development support Crosstabulation
Count
1 2 1 6 2 12
4 1 1 6
1 1
2 4 4 10
1 1
1 9 7 10 3 30
NR
Having 10 branches
1 crore revenue per
month
To be number one broker
others
Where do you
see your
business after
5 years
Total
NR Rank 1 Rank 2 Rank 3 Rank 4
Marketing & business Development support
Total
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
75/90
Analysis 5
Where do you see your business after 5 years
others
To be number one bro
1 crore revenue per
Having 10 branches
NR
Coun
t
10
8
6
4
2
0
BRND_VAL
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Rank 4
Analysis:
[75]
Where do you see your business after 5 years * BRND_VAL Crosstabulation
Count
2 2 8 12
2 1 3 6
1 1
1 9 10
1 1
4 1 1 2 22 30
NR
Having 10 branches
1 crore revenue per
month
To be number one broker
others
Where do you
see your
business after
5 years
Total
NR Rank 1 Rank 2 Rank 3 Rank 4
BRND_VAL
Total
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
76/90
Most of the big figures across categories are coming under rank 4, which means in
achieving any of the goals mentioned brand value doesnt play an important role.
Analysis 6
[76]
Where do you see your business after 5 years * SUCSCALL Crosstabulation
Count
2 3 6 1 12
2 1 3 6
1 1
2 5 2 1 10
1 1
4 6 12 7 1 30
NR
Having 10 branches
1 crore revenue per
month
To be number one broker
others
Where do you
see your
business after
5 years
Total
NR Rank 1 Rank 2 Rank 3 Rank 4
SUCSCALL
Total
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
77/90
Where do you see your business after 5 years
others
To be number one bro
1 crore revenue per
Having 10 branches
NR
Count
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
SUCSCALL
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Rank 4
Analysis:
Above cross tabulation shows that respondents who have their goal as to be number
1 broker of their area are ranking Successful calls as rank 1 & 2 as these
respondents are not interested in expanding their horizons.
Analysis 7
[77]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
78/90
Where do you see your business after 5 years * BCKOFF Crosstabulation
Count
1 7 3 1 12
2 2 1 1 6
1 1
5 1 4 10
1 1
3 14 6 7 30
NR
Having 10 branches
1 crore revenue per
month
To be number one broker
others
Where do you
see your
business after
5 years
Total
NR Rank 1 Rank 2 Rank 3
BCKOFF
Total
Where do you see your business after 5 years
others
To be number one bro
1 crore revenue per
Having 10 branches
NR
Count
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
BCKOFF
NR
Rank 1
Rank 2
Rank 3
Analysis:
Respondents who want to be a no. 1 broker has ranked back office support as 1
or 3.
None of the respondent has ranked back office support as 4
[78]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
79/90
5.4 Prospects Generated For Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd.
[79]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
80/90
Case Summariesa
Sub Broker Pradeep Kumar
1 1Sub Broker Rishab Jain
Sub Broker Rahi Makkar
Sub Broker Param Hans Gupta
Sub Broker Ankur Gupta
Sub Broker Aman
Sub Broker Gaurav dhawan
Sub Broker Jitendra Acchra
Sub Broker Deepak Sanghwan
Sub Broker Rahul Securities
Sub Broker Pankaj Kumar
Sub Broker Karni Kalra11 11
Sub Broker Monu Kashyap
Sub Broker Rajesh Jain
Sub Broker Manu Singhal
Sub Broker Harish Sharma
Main Broker Nitin
Sub Broker Avnish Gupta
Sub Broker Deepak Singhal
Main Broker Sunil garg
Sub Broker Ashok Gupta
Sub Broker Mahindra Pal
10 10
Sub Broker Rajiv Gupta
Sub Broker Ajay Rastogi
Sub Broker Adarsh Arora
Sub Broker M.R. Sharma
Sub Broker Gopal Prasad Gupta
Sub BrokerAshish Kumar
Dalmia
Sub Broker Umesh Narang
Sub Broker Sanjay Garg
8 8
30 30
1
NTotal
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11NTotal
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
NTotal
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
NTotal
3
NTotal
TOTAL
Type of broker Name of repondent
Limited to first 100 cases.a.
[80]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
81/90
Analysis:
This table represents the clients having 0, 1, 2 and 3 values. These values are
calculated as the sum of three variables which were given either 1 or 0 value
depending upon various responses given by respondents in the questionnaire.
The clients having a sum as 3 are the best prospects as they wants to grow and wish to
be associated with Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd.
From the above table it is observed that, there are 8 prospects having a bright chance
for becoming a part of Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd. as they filled their Questionnaire
as follows:- Ranked Marketing - Business Development and Brand Value as 1 or 2.
Experience more than 5 years or Want to cash out the brokerage opportunity in
bull market.
Having 10 branches or to be the number one broker of that area as his 5 year
goal.
The above 3 criterias were selected after a brain storming session with all
trainees & Company Mentor. These options suits best for a Motilal Prospect as itprovides the Best Marketing-Business Development Support and is known for its
Brand Value & Equity Research in the Industry.
[81]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
82/90
Chapter 6RECOMMENDATIONS
[82]
8/14/2019 Final Report @ Mohit
83/90
6.1RECOMMENDATIONS
Eight prospects have been generated out of the analysis of 30 respondents on
different parameters. BAG department should approach these prospects only
after doing the detailed study of their respective questionnaire as it will give
them a good idea about the prospect & Conversation would become much
easier & hence the chances of Conversion.
Apart from concentrating on experienced players, Motilal Oswal shouldpartner with the sub brokers who are in group 2 5 years as they are
enthusiastic & can also generate good volumes.
Since Sub brokers are not concentrating on the marketing front, Motilal Oswal
must expand its marketing & business development efforts for them.
Since the survey results reveal that Customer care support is required by the
sub brokers, Motilal Oswal expand on its customer care front by increasing the
no. of customer care executives.
Motilal Oswal should have