Future of solar axion searches with the International AXion Observatory IAXO
Igor G IrastorzaUniversidad de Zaragoza
10th Patras Workshop on Axions, WIMPs and WISPs July 3rd, 2014
Outline Axion motivation:
– Strong CP problem– Axions as CDM– Solar axions
Previous helioscopes & CAST
IAXO Conceptual Design– CDR– LoI to CERN
IAXO physics potential Status of project Next steps Conclusions
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
2
IAXO Letter of Intent: CERN-SPSC-2013-022 90 signatures / 38 institutionsIAXO Conceptual Design: JINST 9 (2014) T05002 (arXiv:1401.3233)
Axion motivation in a nutshell
Most compelling solution to the Strong CP problem of the SM
Axion-like particles (ALPs) predicted by many extensions of the SM (e.g. string theory)
Axions, like WIMPs, may solve the DM problem for free. (i.e. not ad hoc solution to DM)
Astrophysical hints for axion/ALPs?– Transparency of the Universe to UHE gammas– White dwarfs anomalous cooling point to few meV axions
Relevant axion/ALP parameter space at reach of current and near-future experiments
Still too little experimental efforts devoted to axions when compared e.g. to WIMPs… (not justified…)
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
3
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
4Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
axions
Transverse
magnetic field (B)
X rayX ra
y
detector
L
COHERENCE 1
Axion Helioscope principle Solar axions produced by photon-to-axion
conversion of the solar plasma photons in the solar core
Detectable by the Axion helioscope concept [Sikivie, PRL 51 (83)]
Solar WISPs production(see J. Redondo poster)
Axion Helioscopes Previous helioscopes:
– First implementation at Brookhaven (just few hours of data) [Lazarus et at. PRL 69 (92)]
– TOKYO Helioscope (SUMICO): 2.3 m long 4 T magnet
Presently running: – CERN Axion Solar Telescope (CAST)
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
5
CAST experiment @ CERN
LHC test magnet
Decommissioned LHC test magnet (L=10m, B=9 T) Moving platform ±8°V ±40°H (to allow up to 50 days / year of
alignment) 4 magnet bores to look for X rays 3 X rays detector prototypes being used. X ray Focusing System to increase signal/noise ratio.
X-ray focussing
optics
2 low background Micromegas
1 low background Micromegas
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
6
• Sensitivity goal: >4 orders of magnitude improvement in signal-to-noise ratio wrt CAST. (>1 order of magnitude in sensitivity of gag)
IAXO – Concept
• No technological challenge (build on CAST experience)– New dedicated superconducting magnet, built for IAXO
(improve >300 B2L2A f.o.m wrt CAST)– Extensive (cost-effective) use x-ray focalization over ~m2
area. – Low background detectors (lower 1-2 order of magnitude
CAST levels)
Enhanced axion helioscope: JCAP 1106:013,2011
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 7
IAXO – Conceptual Design• Large toroidal 8-coil magnet L = ~20 m • 8 bores: 600 mm diameter each• 8 x-ray optics + 8 detection systems• Rotating platform with services
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 8
IAXO magnetTOROIDAL
CONFIGURATIONspecifically built for
axion physics
Each conversion bore (between coils)
600 mm diameter
Cryostat
Cold mass
Bores go through cryostat
Magnetic length 20 m Total cryostat length 25 m
IAXO magnet
IAXO magnet concept presented in:• IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 23 (ASC 2012)• Adv. Cryo. Eng. (CEC/ICMC 2013)• IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. (MT 23)
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 10
IAXO x-ray optics
Focal length
ABRIXAS spare telescope, in use
in one of the 4 bores of CAST
(pioneer use of x-ray optics in axion
research)
• X-rays are focused by means of grazing angle reflection (usually 2)• Many techniques developed in the x-ray astronomy field. But usually costly
due to exquisite imaging requirements
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 11
IAXO x-ray optics• Each bore equipped with an x-ray
optics• Exquisite imaging not required• BUT need cost-effective way to
build 8 (+1 spare) optics of 600 mm diameter each
•
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 12
IAXO x-ray optics• Technique of choice for IAXO: optics made
of slumped glass substrates coated to enhance reflectivity in the energy regions for axions
• Same technique successfully used in NuSTAR mission, recently launched
• The specialized tooling to shape the substrates and assemble the optics is now available
• Hardware can be easily configured to make optics with a variety of designs and sizes
• Key institutions in NuSTAR optics: LLNL, U. Columbia, DTU Denmark. All in IAXO !
NuSTAR optics assembly machine
NuSTAR telescope
~400 mm Ø
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 13
IAXO x-ray optics
IAXO optics conceptual design
AC Jakobsen et al, Proc. SPIE 8861 (2013)
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 14
IAXO low background detectors
• 8 detector systems• Small gas chamber with Micromegas readouts for
low-background x-ray detection• Shielding
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 15
IAXO low background detectors• Small Micromegas-TPC chambers:
• Shielding• Radiopure components• Offline discrimination
• Goal background level for IAXO:• 10-7 – 10-8 c keV-1 cm-2 s-1
• Already demonstrated:• ~8×10-7 c keV-1 cm-2 s-1
(in CAST 2013 result)• Below 10-7 c keV-1 cm-2 s-1
(underground at LSC – 2014 - unpublished)
• Active program of development. Clear roadmap for improvement.
History of background improvement of Micromegas detectors at CAST
Nominal values at CAST 2003
2004 2006
2008-10
Values underground (Canfranc)
Latest CAST SSMM 2013
levels
IAXO goalsSee JINST 8 (2013) C12042 &
JINST 9 (2014) P01001Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014 16
IAXO pathfinder at CASTExploratory optics+detector system
• IAXO optics+detector joint system• Newly designed MM detector (following IAXO CDR)• New x-ray optics fabricated following technique proposed for IAXO (but much
smaller, adapted to CAST bore)• It will take data in CAST in 2014 & 2015
• First time low background + focusing in the same system• Very important operative experience for IAXO
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 17
Detector built. New optics to
come to CAST in the next weeks…
IAXO sensitivity prospects
Astrophysical hints for ALPs
Much larger QCD axion
region explored
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 18
2
1
3
?
Additional IAXO physics cases• Detection of “BCA”-produced solar axions
(with relevant gae values)
• More specific WISPs models at the low energy frontier of particle physics:– Paraphotons / hidden photons– Chamaleons– Non-standard scenarios of axion
production• Microwave LSW setup
• Use of microwave cavities or dish antennas, DM axion searches
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 19
Possible additional technologies to push E thresholds down:
• GridPix• TES• Low-noise CCDs
IAXO as “generic axion/ALP facility”
See talk of B. Doebrich & J. Redondo
IAXO status of project
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 20
• 2011: First studies concluded (JCAP 1106:013,2011)
• 2013: Conceptual Design finished (arXiv:1401.3233).– Most activity carried out up to now ancillary to other groups’ projects (e.g. CAST)
• August 2013: Letter of Intent submitted to the CERN SPSC – LoI: [CERN-SPSC-2013-022]– Presentation in the open session in October 2013:
• January 2014: Positive recommendations from SPSC.
• 2014: Transition phase: In order to continue with TDR & preparatory activities, formal endorsement & resources needed.– Some IAXO preparatory activity already going on as part of CAST near term program.– Preparation of a MoU to carry out TDR work.– First IAXO-specific funding approved! (one week ago).
CERN SPSC recommendations
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 21
SPSC Draft minutes [Jan 2014]
The Committee recognises the physics motivation of an International Axion Observatory as described in the Letter of Intent SPSC-I-242, and considers that the proposed setup makes appropriate use of state-of-the-art technologies i.e. magnets, x-ray optics and low-background detectors. The Committee encourages the collaboration to take the next steps towards a Technical Design Report. The Committee recommends that, in the process of preparing the TDR, the possibility to extend the physics reach with additional detectors compared to the baseline goal should be investigated. The collaboration should be further strengthened. Considering the required funding, the SPSC recommends that the R&D for the TDR should be pursuit within an MOU involving all interested parties.
Next steps• Start works towards a Technical Design Report. As part
of such:– Construction of a demostration coil IAXO-T0– Construction of a prototype x-ray optics IAXO-X0– Construction of a prototype low background detector
setup IAXO-D0– Complete pathfinder project detector+optic at CAST– Coordination activities. Update physics case. Site.
Tracking platform. Gas system. Software– Feasibility studies for “IAXO-DM” options.
• TDR completion is a ~2-4 MEUR effort.• Memorandum of Understanding in preparation among
interested parties• Search for new interested partners
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 22
IAXO-T0
Conclusions
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 23
• Axion searches increasingly strong physics case. • To be taken seriously: time for large projects.• In particular, solar axions CAST has been a very important milestone in
axion research during the last decade– 1st CAST limits most cited exp. axion paper– Largest effort/collaboration in axion physics so far
• IAXO, a forth generation axion helioscope, natural and timely large-scale step to come now. It can probe deep into unexplored axion+ALP parameter space. – But also several additional physics cases
• LoI to CERN recently proposed. Positive recommendation from SPSC. MoU to start TDR under preparation.
• First firm steps for IAXO to become a large “generic axion facility” with discovery potential in the next decade.
More news in Zaragoza Patras2015!!
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
24
Backup slides…
IAXO costs
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 25
Laboratory engineering, maintenance & operation and physics exploitation not included
IAXO in astroparticle roadmaps
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 26
• ASPERA/APPEC Roadmap acknowledges axion physics, CAST, and recommends progress towards IAXO.
• Important community input in the European Strategy for Particle Physics• Presence in the Briefing Book of the ESPP, which reflects also APPEC
roadmap recommendations.• ESPP recomends CERN to follow APPEC recomendatons.• Important effort in relation with US roadmapping (Snowmass, and P5
process). Snowmass reports speak very favourably of axion physics and IAXO.
C. Spiering, ESPP Krakow
IAXO timeline
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 27
~18 months -> TDR + preparatory activities
~3.5 years construction
~2.5 years integration +
commissioning
Axion parameter space
White Dwarfs
Astrophysical hints for ALPs
CDM “classical window”
Vaxuum mis. + defects
mixed CDM
Axions asHDM
CDM “anthropic window”
WISPy CDMJCAP06(2012)013
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 28
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza 29
?
?
AXION theory motivation Axion: introduced to solve the strong CP
problem
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
30
In QCD, nothing prevents from adding a term like that to the lagrangian:
This term is CP violating. 2 contributions of
very different origin…
• Why so small?
• High fine-tunning required for this to work in the SM
From non-observation of neutron electric dipole moment:
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
31
AXION theory motivation Peccei-Quinn solution to the strong CP problem
New U(1) symmetry introduced in the SM: Peccei Quinn symmetry of scale fa
The AXION appears as the Nambu-Goldstone boson of the spontaneous breaking of the PQ symmetry
q absorbed in the definition of a
q = a/fa relaxes to zero… CP conservation is preserved “dinamically”
“Axion lagrangian”
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
32
THE AXION
Basic properties:– Pseudoscalar particle– Neutral– Gets very small mass through mixing with
pions– Stable (for practical purposes). – Phenomenology driven by the PQ scale fa.
(couplings inversely proportional to fa)
The PQ scenario solves the strong CP-problem. But a most interesting consequence is the appearance of this new particle, the axion. (Weinberg, Wilcek)
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
33
AXION phenomenology Axion-photon coupling
present in every model.
This is probably the most relevant of axion properties. Most axion detection strategies are based on the axion-photon
coupling
Axion-photon conversion in the presence of an electromagnetic field (Primakoff effect)
Beyond axions
Diverse theory motivation– Higher scale symm. breaking– String theory– DM / DE candidates– Astrophysical hints
Generic Axion-like particles (ALPs) parameter space
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
34
AXIONS Minicharged particlesChamaleonsHidden photons
/ paraphotons
WISPs (Weakly interacting Slim Particle)
ALPS
AXION as Dark Matter?
35
non baryonic Dark
Matter ~26.8 %
Visible < 1%
“Dark energy
” ~68.3%
Baryonic < 5%
Galactic scale
Cosmologicalscale
Can not be baryonic Can not be relativistic (CDM) Can not be standard (neutrinos) Need to go beyond the SM WIMPs AXION
S
SUSY PQWW
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
AXION as Dark Matter? Axions are produced in the early Universe by a number
of processes:– Axion realignment– Decay of axion strings– Decay of axion walls
36
NON-RELATIVISTIC(COLD) AXIONS
RELATIVISTIC(HOT) AXIONS
Axion mases ma > ~0.9 eV gives densities too much in excess to be compatible with latest CMB dataHannestad et al, JCAP 08 (2010) 001
(arXiv:1004.0695)
Axion mass giving the right CDM density? Depends on cosmological assumptions:
“classical window” ~10-5 – 10-3 eV “anthropic window” ~ much lower masses possible Other subdominant CDM / non-standard scenarios
– Thermal production
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
Axion DM after BICEP2 Quite an impact… (a few preprints)
– Marsh et al. arXiv:1403.4216 – L. Visinelli, P. Gondolo arXiv:1403.4594 – Choi el al.arXiv:1404.38803. – Chun. arXiv:1404.4284 – E. Di Valentino et al. Mena. arXiv:1405.1860among others…
In summary: if “high inflation scale” interpretation of BICEP2
results is right… “classical window” (high mass) scenario is favored.
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
37
Solar Axions Solar axions produced by photon-to-
axion conversion of the solar plasma photons in the solar core
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
axions
Solar axion flux [van Bibber PRD 39 (89)] [CAST JCAP 04(2007)010]
Solar physics +
Primakoff effect
Only one unknown parameter gag
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
38
Axions in Astrophysics
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
39
Axions are produced at the core of stars, like the Sun, by Primakoff conversion of the plasma photons.– Axions drain energy from stars and may alter their lifetime.
Limits are derived to the axion properties
Axion decay a g g may produce gamma lines in the emission from certain places (i.e. galactic center).
Astrophysical hints for axions/ALPs Anomalous gamma transparency of the Universe
(observation of gamma rays from from distant sources) very light ALPs
Anomalous cooling of white dwarfs– Favors few meV axions
See PDGand references therein
Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
40
Detecting DM axions: “haloscopes”
Resonant cavities (Sikivie,1983)– Primakoff conversion inside a
“tunable” resonant cavity– Energy of photon = mac2+O(b2)
B0
Axion DM fieldNon-relativisticFrequency axion mass
Primakoff conversion of DM
axions into microwave
photons inside cavity
If cavity tuned to the axion frequency,
conversion is “boosted” by
resonant factor (Q quality factor)
Cavity dimensions smaller than de
Broglie wavelength of
axions
Axion DM detection – new ideas
Recent papers proposing new detection schemes. Very active field!– Precession of nuclear spins (CASPERs): PRD 84, 055013
(2011) and arXiv:1306.6089 – Long thin cavities in dipole fields: PRD85 (2012) 035018– Directional effect in long thin cavities: JCAP 1210 (2012)
022– Dish antenna: JCAP 1304 (2013) 016– Directional effect in dish antenna: arXiv:1307.7181– LC circuit in B field: PRL 112, 131301 (2014)– Active resonators: arXiv:1403.6720 – Cavitiy with wires: arXiv:1403.3121 (also old Sikivie
paper) Patras Axions-WIMPs, CERN, July 2014
Igor G. Irastorza / Universidad de Zaragoza
41
InGrid Detectors Micromegas built on top of a CMOS ASIC Bump bond pads of the ASIC are used as charge collection pads Mesh made of thin aluminum foil One hole per readout pixel → well aligned → each primary electron can be seen as one hit on a pixel
Cosmic ray track 2 X-ray photons of a 55Fe source
Background Suppression Knowledge of individual primary electrons gives detailed information on signal shape Different event shape variables can be used to distinguish background events (tracks) from signal events (photons) First likelihood ratio-based analysis reached a background suppression of 120 Threshold of detector is dominated by transmission of entrance window Good energy resolution with pixel counting eliminating contribution of gas amplification
pixels per track length
Efficiency vs. background rejection
Detailed desciption in: C. Krieger, J. Kaminski and K. Desch, InGrid-based X-ray detector for low background searches, NIM A729 (2013) 905–909
Spectrum of a 55Fe source