8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
1/40
DEVELOPMENT OF BROADBANDINFRASTRUCTURE IN BOR AND BRANICEVO
DISTRICTS
TECHNICAL AND ECONOMICAL VIEW
DRAFT
LAST MILE" BROADBAND SOLUTION IN EASTERNSERBIA
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
2/40
3
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
Balcan Broadband rural project - Phoenix
The Phoenix Project
This is for
my Son
and for all
my fellow
homolian
villagers
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
3/40
4
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
This document was inspired by an unofficial group of people that worked hard
during past 5 years only with strong dedication and involvement in providing high
speed broadband internet to Homolie mountain rural area and its inhabitants,
from 2006 until now, and also with great likeminded people, and strong support
we have found in our online European community and especially on the EU
Linked-in pages European Union Regional and Rural Development Participants
...
SINCERITAS CITRA POMPAM
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
4/40
5
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
Content
1. Background/Conditions ................................................................................ 8
1.1. Geographic ..........................................................................................101.2. Situation before the project .................................................................11
1.3. The needs of target groups .................................................................14
2. Project description...................................................................................... 152.1. Project goals........................................................................................16
2.2. Project alternatives and technical solution .........................................17
3. How are decisions taken? .......................................................................... 19
4. Model of financing ...................................................................................... 20
5. Project results, subsequences and effects................................................ 21
6. Recommendations ..................................................................................... 237. Anexes........................................................................................................ 26
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
5/40
6
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
Preface
The phoenix (Ancient Greek: , phonix, Persian: , Arabic: ) is amythical sacred firebird that can be found in the mythologies of the Persians, Greeks, Romans,
Egyptians, Chinese .
A phoenix is a mythical bird that is a fire spirit with a colorful plumage and a tail of gold and
scarlet (or purple, blue, and green according to some legends).
It has a 500 to 1000 year life-cycle, near the end of which it builds itself a nest of twigs that then
ignites; both nest and bird burn fiercely and are reduced to ashes, from which a new, young
phoenix or phoenix egg arises, reborn anew to live again.
The new phoenix is destined to live as long as its old self. In some stories, the new phoenix
embalms the ashes of its old self in an egg made of myrrh and deposits it in the Egyptian city of
Heliopolis (literally "sun-city" in Greek).
It is said that the bird's cry is that of a beautiful song.
The Phoenix's ability to be reborn from its own ashes implies that it is immortal, though in
some stories the new Phoenix is merely the offspring of the older one.
The European Commission has set highly ambitious objectives for broadbanddevelopment, because smart investments into high and very high speed broadband
infrastructures are crucial to create jobs, increase economic performance and to unlock thecompetitive potential of the EU in the long term.
The Europe 2020 Strategy ("EU2020") has underlined the importance of broadband
deployment to promote social inclusion and competitiveness in the EU and has also set
ambitious targets for broadband development. In 2010, the European Commission has
launched one of the flagship initiatives of the EU2020 strategy, the Digital Agenda, which
restated the objective of EU2020 to bring basic broadband to all Europeans by 2013 and seeks
to ensure that, by 2020, (i) all Europeans have access to much higher internet speeds of above
30 Mbps and (ii) 50% or more of European households subscribe to internet connections above100 Mbps.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
6/40
7
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
It is estimated that to achieve the first objective, up to 60 billion of investment would be
necessary and up to 270 billion for the second. Such investments will primarily come from
commercial operators. However, the ambitious objectives of the EU2020 strategy and the
Digital Agenda cannot be reached without the smart use of public funds. Public funding and
State aid will play an important role to complement private investments and to extend
broadband and very high speed, next generation access ("NGA") network coverage to areas,
where market operators are unlikely to invest on commercial terms in the near future
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
7/40
8
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
1. Background/Conditions
The facts:
141902 Households
449219 Inhabitants
335 Villages
15 Cities
300 Villages with more than 200 inhabitants
243 Villages with more than 400 inhabitants
84 Villages with more than 1000 inhabitants
The economy of the municipality of Bor and Branicevo district is in very poor condition. Most
companies operate with losses and the privatization process is underway. Liquidity is one of
many problems faced by enterprises, lack of financial resources and unfavorable credit policy
prevents the revitalization of the economy. Decline in purchasing power of the population
causes a drop in turnover of commercial firms. Most companies recorded declines in agricultura
production and reduce capacity utilization.
One of the most important problems in the municipalities of these districts is unemployment,
with average unemployment significantly above the average of the Republic of Serbia (23%).
This problem has become especially pronounced with the process of restructuring and
privatization. Poverty arises here as an important general social problem. It can not be
expressed only by the number of users MOP or number of users of the right to child allowance,
but the inability to earn even for the average shopping basket. Crossreference this with the
lack of education and learning facilities, and programes .
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
8/40
9
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
The area of our interest,Eastern Serbia in project proposal, is about 7000km2 and with more
than 300.000 residents, about 100000 households-while 50-60% of urban area inhabitants have
access to the broadband internet, in 2010 only 20-25% in rural areas In these sparsely
populated areas, where income is generally low, private telecommunication operators do not
want to invest because it is not profitable. Or they are investing but their services are over paid
and bad quality . Only towns are cabled at present (the optical cable is one of the channels for
the "broadband" and there are no plans to change this in the short term. If the market were left
to decide, villages with populations of 5 000 or less would not be connected to the cable for
another twenty years. it`s largely depopulated underdeveloped and with practical no way of
developing sustainable industry,agricultural or modern IT society . This network must be the
foundation stone of changing the people`s life for the better . Phoenix Innovative Approach ,
for local community,against the digital divide, for e-inclusion, as a part of the actions of the
CRD wants to change that. The goal is to make broadband Internet accessible to all inhabitants
including those living in the most remote areas. As part of an ongoing experiment 147 villages
in 3 counties (Bor Branicevo and Zajecar ) will be connected to the broadband, iptv - along with
some inovative services that we are developing. What do we need broadband if we don`t know
to use it or how to use the benefits of it?
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
9/40
10
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
1.1. Geographic
Branicevo region occupies the territory
3,865 km Population (census 2002)
200,503 density 51.88/km The
Branievo District ( ,
Branievski okrug) expands in the north-
east of Serbia. It has a population of
200,503. Seat of the District is in the city of
Poarevac, Settlements 189 Cities and
towns 7 Villages 182
Bor region occupies the territory 3,507 km
Population (census 2002) 200,503 density
41.8/kmBor District ( , Borski
okrug) is a district (okrug) of Serbia with
seat in Bor. It has a population of 146,551
(2002 census).Municipalities 4 Settlements
90 Cities and towns 6 Villages 84Population (census 2002) 137,561
(source: Department of Statistics)
1.2. Situation before the project
When planning to implement a broadband data transfer network, the present situation was
examined and the possibilities to use already built infrastructure and driven broadband network
were investigated. The worst situation is in a mountainous region that includes the east, south
and west, Serbia with 42% of the total territory of Serbia is the most rural region, which
generally are characterized by abandoned land resources, shortages of labor, disorganized
market and lack of adequate rural services. In this area has 20% of the population of Serbia, but
the average population density in the lowest compared to other rural areas. Every third
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
10/40
11
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
resident has completed primary education, the employment rate is the least favorable in the
country, and more than 35% of the employed population works in the primary sector, mainly in
agriculture and mining. Realized domestic product per capita is only 53% of the national DP,
and given the high share of primary sector, the region formed nearly 19% of the DP of theprimary sector of Serbia. However, the national domestic product region of the secondary
sector accounts for only 10%, which is an extremely small proportion considering the area that
includes this area. The economic structure is based on the depletion of natural resources and
raw material production and industry-leading manufacturing and supply of electricity, gas and
water.
Agricultural areas make up 55% of the total territory, which is much less than in other rural
areas, and lower productivity due to the modest investment and equipment holdings. The
specificity of this region is a high percentage of unused land, particularly in the southeastern
part, and the reasons are at a disadvantage in the age structure of population, lack of adequate
machinery, unavailability of land and poor soil quality. Besides wheat, the major products,
vegetables and raspberries growing in whose leading Zlatibor district, which deviates from the
regional average and growing cattle, and the Raska district is one of the largest breeders in the
country. Although the region has the greatest potential for tourism in Serbia, where some
destinations like Zlatibor, Kopaonik, the Spa or Guca absorb over 60% of the national tourism
traffic, pending infrastructural problems, which are remarkable in southeastern Serbia, cause
continuous depopulation of the region, its economic marginalization and emphasized rural
poverty.
Serbia has more than 25% population with broadband connection,
But this statistic hides serious inequalities, especially in the case of the broadband Internet and
cable tv access. Profound differences exist in East Serbia between the urban centers and the
small isolated, disadvantaged villages in the countryside or mountains.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
11/40
12
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
In these sparsely populated areas, where income is generally low, private telecommunication
operators do not want to invest because it is not profitable. Or they are investing but their
services are over paid and awful . Only towns are cabled at present and there are no plans to
change this in the short term. If the market were left to decide, villages with populations of 5000 or less would not be connected to the cable for another twenty years.
Public workshops, education, continuing education, internet training rooms, ecdl training for
every village inhabitants and farmers would be provided in the following 3 years of project
implementation.
Public Internet centers will be set up as bridgeheads against the digital divide.1
Mobile connection operators also have enough explicated infrastructure, but the
technologies (GPRS, EDGE, HSCSD) used at present time do not give opportunity to reach
induced requirements for broadband networks (technological channel permeability
restriction).
In bigger towns of Bor and Branicevo regions smaller internet service conveyors present,
but their services spread is not marked and their infrastructure according to territorial
aspects is not explicated.
1Digital Agenda website: http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/digital-agenda/index_en.htm
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
12/40
13
Damirerbanovi Datasphere Communications, Center for Rural Development
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
13/40
1.3. The needs of target groups Organizations and companies of regionmunicipalitiesAccording to the present situation in companies it is possible to segregate the most important
needs of companies of region municipalities
Possibility to exchange information between the institutions and companies of the regionmuch faster and operative;
To reduce information exchange costs and outlays for ITT; To increase work efficiency of employees in administrative institutions of public sector; To increase the confidentiality of information exchange; To improve quality of public services offered;
To establish the infrastructure for implementation of public electronic services.
Households and business companies of the region
83percent of Branicevo and 75 percent of the Bor region residents live in villages. The biggest
part of the residents live in small townships, where there are no possibilities to use broadband
internet connection. Present infrastructure development of data transfer, limited competitive
surroundings and financially weak market of users do not compound presumptions for further
development of broadband network infrastructure. One of the greatest needs of users
(household and business companies) is a possibility to use broadband connections (mostly in
villages).
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
14/40
The most needed types of services:
1. Home use - possibilities to use broadband connections for teleconferences, to warrantsafety (possibilities to connect video cameras), to exchange huge data flows (video
information, pictures, etc.);
2. Workplace use - possibility to work in any place - unnecessary to drive to a workplace. Apossibility is compounded to use present appliques from home or clients office. A possibility
to collaborate with associates by conferences and in video mode;
3. Health protection - Patients and treatment specialists can use this type of service. Video
conferences in real mode could allow patients to communicate with doctors with the help of
video conference, it is possible to look after elder people with expedition;
4. Purchases. Allows to search, review, and order and also pay for purchases by internet.
With help of broadband connection part of the products (music, videos, movies, etc.) could
be delivered by the internet;
5. Public dominance. Due to broadband connections residents are allowed to use electronic
services. In future the possibility to prosecute political debates and discussions of public
groups with help of video conference would appear;
6. The study. Broadband connection allows to study at the distance;
7. Culture. Allows held aloof users to be informed about future/past events;8. Transport. With the help of broadband connection, users can get more information by the
internet. Therefore, transportation expenses decrease and traffic jams on the roads as well.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
15/40
2. Project description
2.1. Project goals
The goals of the project - to allow residents, companies, institutions of Bor and Branicevo
region municipalities to use broadband data exchange network, to improve public institutions
management of the region and quality of extended services.
The results of the project - broadband data exchange network infrastructure is established,
including "last mile" solutions, which marks 95 percent of the territory of the municipality. More
than 300 public administrative, educational and other institutions are connected to seamless
computer network and conditions are compounded for effective information exchange betweenthese institutions. The most part of the residents in municipalities of Bor and Branicevo region
live in villages. There are 74.6 percent of the village residents in Bor region municipality and
83.4 percent of all the residents of Branicevo region live in villages. Small and markedly
scattered townships dominate on the territory. Present IT infrastructure is weakly developed,
and broadband connection services are possible only in biggest townships.
Households and business company's
Opportunities of households and business companies to use internet services in small
village vicinities are limited. Not enough developed infrastructure is one of the reasons which
determines low rate of internet usage in the households of both regions.
In order to solve present problems it is intended to create broadband data transfer network in
municipalities of Bor and Branicevo regions. Broadband data transfer network establishment
using the combination of optical and wireless technologies was chosen for effectuation of the
project because of bad regional informational infrastructure and a great amount of scattered
town ships on the territory. During the project broadband data exchange network infrastructurewill be established in the territories of Bor and Branicevo region municipalities, counting "last
mile" solutions and public, administrative, education, etc. institutions will be connected to
seamless computer network of Bor and Branicevo region.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
16/40
The project will be effectuated in two stages. On the fist stage is the researchign and planning
then building infrastructure is being established. The propriety of infrastructure will belong to
municipalities of Bor and Branicevo region. On the second stage the established infrastructure
will be given to the operator to maintain, that is for private juridical entity, which will be chosen
in public contest in the way of competitive dialogue. An operating contract will be signed withthis operator. The contract with network operators will strictly regulate retention of infrastructure,
the pricing aspects of services and will secure speedy broadband connection development in
regions.
The operator MUST agree that he would provide free broadband services fro
townships and rural communes where it is not commercialy justified to rent the
bandwith and where telecentres would be implemented (via another IPA project)
Second goal
Education e-education and continuous education ,the project that would capitalise
from this Phoenix project.
2.2. Project alternatives and technical solutionAt the moment all set of technological solutions is being used, which can extend broadband
data transfer services: Cable modem. This solution is very beneficial when cable teleoperator network is
developed on the territory but the prospect of technology and its development is obscure, as the
equipment used is expensive, and more modern and more improvable solutions appear on the
market.
ADSL - asynchronous data transfer digital line. At its time it was one of the moderntechnologies, which formatted possibilities to extend broadband data transfer network for less
expenses. But at the present time the imperfect speed is noticed when sending data, and the
further edification of this technology created WDSL technology.
WDSL technology is distinguished by very high permeability and has the prospect ofdevelopment. One of the main defects is a very small effective distance from a connection
commutation unit to the ultimate user, just 1.2 km. This doesn't pander demands of a villageterritory, as residents are scattered on the big territory.
FTTH is the most modern technology which gives opportunity to transfer big amounts ofinformation on the big distances. But infrastructure on village territories is not developed, and its
expansion is very expensive.
Wireless technologies. These technologies started to develop apace and improve togetherwith GSM network development. These technologies capacitate to extend broadband network
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
17/40
service on the big territory for small expenses. Because of standard solutions the installation
and coordination of this equipment at last days is very simplified. One of the main defects is
possible mistake generation while transferring data, but modern devices already have mistake
correction solutions and mistakes display fractionally in modern devices.
Perfection/modernization of created networks is very simple with these technologies and is notexpensive (actually only small units are changed).
Four project effectuation alternatives were separated:1. Broadband satellite data transfer network;2. Broadband Optical data transfer network;3. Broadband wireless WLAN data transfer network ( 802.3 (CSMA/CD), 802.11B);
4. Broadband wireless WiMAX data transfer network (802.16 standard);
5. Optics and wireless connection technology network (optics + wireless connection).
After application for financing from EU Structural funds was submitted the project had to
be integrated with state IT development projects. The result is such:
Strategy for the Development of Broadband Access
in the Republic of Serbia project must include additional nodes and installed additional fiber-
optical cables to the wireless towers. Bor and Branicevo project uses this infrastructure to get
broadband to the towers. Bor and Branicevo project has chosen to use WiMAX technology to
cover the whole region area.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
18/40
3.How are decisions taken?
The municipalities of Bor and Branicevo regions have supported the project. A feasibility study(investment project) will be prepared by the project partners. Later this feasibility study togetherwith the application will be submitted to Information Society Development subprogram (priority)under EU Structural Funds (priority No 3.3).The major problems in initiation phase:
The project had to be matched/integrated with national project, The technical solution had to be modified as some time after preparation of feasibility study has
passed and the solutions became old, The whole methodological approach has to be changed and adapted to the transnational
cooperation with the enormous interest showed by the new project partners Infrastructure management model had to be selected,
State aid rules had to be analyzed and carefully interpreted, Land ownership and projection must be done very carefully.
The main impact to the region cannot easily be measured as the project is not started yet.The major problem is the selection of network Management Company. Currently the plan is to setthe tender to select a company for renting the whole network or a parrt of it and no decision hasbeen made yet. The management company will have to offer wholesale services to any companyat the same price. The other major problem is state aid.
Land ownership and projection problem
The projection phase must be done very carefully, as land owners are not willed to acceptchanges in their property. Even if land intended to build infrastructure belongs to municipality, alot of efforts to convince surrounding land owners to change their plots is needed in order to getpower supply. Land owners are not willed to accept power lines go through their land, as itdecreases land price and usable land area. The alternative is to use existing towers but that mustbe arranged by the state or state owned telecommunication provider.In order to bridge this problem land for building towers must be selected very carefully, taking intoaccount:
land ownership, availability of electricity, Suitability for the tower to serve wide reception area (the higher stands the tower, the wider
reception area is served) - the land must be on higher grounds.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
19/40
4. Model of financing
The project is financed exclusively by public sector. No private sector financing will be used. Borand Branicevo region municipalities would have to apply to get financing from EU Structural funds,3.3 measure Information society development".
Investments of the project consist of 4 main parts: Network equipment Central units (server) equipment;
Computer Equipment; Consultative expenses
Approximately 90% of the budget is dedicated to infrastructure development, and the rest of
the budget is used for administrative purposes (audit, administration services, technicalsupervision, feasibility study and etc.). The biggest part of the project investment will costequipment purchase - 56 percent of all projects budget. Construction works in project structure willtake 34 percent. The interesting point is that feasibility study must be prepared before theapplication.
Operational model
Operational model is based on renting the infrastructure to operator.As infrastructure is based on Wireless / WiMAX technology, the operator must process
WiMAX license. Currently RATEL in Serbia process such licenses. The tender participants will have
to give a proposal only for wholesale prices (different prices for different bandwidth). The operatorwill have a right to offer retail services, but wholesale price will have to be the same equal to allmarket participants. The contract is intended to be signed for 5+2 years. The retail price will bemonitored but not regulated.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
20/40
5. Project results, subsequences and effects
The results of the project Appointed broadband data transfer network infrastructure in villages, where there is no
beneficial electronic infrastructure development possibilities in the conditions of free market. The"last mile" infrastructure is established in the municipalities of Bor and Branicevo regions. Datatransfer network will cover 95 percent ofBor and Branicevoand Alytus municipality territory.
Signed contract with network operator, who maintains established broadband data transfernetwork.
After implementing the project all rural institutions and stakeholders would be connected tothe broadband network
All institutions will be connected into inside network and will be able to use internetconnection. That way internet usage in Bor and Branicevoregion municipality institutions willincrease from 20 % to 60 - 86%, Internet will give conditions to increase wide information spreadand employees' competition.
Subsequences of the project.
It is planned that established broadband connection infrastructure given to possess it byprivate operators will decrease the price for internet services in villages. This will institute
conditions for internet permeability to upsurge rapidly in Bor and Branicevoregion municipalities.Presumptive that during 2-3 years network operators will extend broadband internet services to35-50% households at least, where it is impossible to use broadband internet at thistime. In 2 years network operators will have at least 10.000 - 30.000 new clients(households, business companies and institutions) in Bor and Branicevoregion.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
21/40
In this case internet plough in regions will raise more than 25%. During 3 years about 3000-10.000new work places are created in the sphere of services and datasphere of virtual information.Created broadband data transfer network of municipality institutions will institute conditions forrapid information exchange among institutions. More rapid information exchange will mean:
Closer intercommunication between institutions; More effective public possession and control of publicinstitutions ; Better quality of extended public services;
Significally improved the work efficiency of the public institutions in Bor and Branicevoregions andaccording to it, the gratification of the residents and companies' of extended public services isexpected to increase.Expenses for data/information exchange of municipality institutions decrease;Increasing of the quality of education, selfeducation and offering the access to te e-learnignsystems.
The major confidentiality of exchanged information is warranted; Conditions are intended for educational institutions to use remote education programs; The infrastructure is being established, and for this reason public electronic services will be
extended for the residents of the region and business companies; After the implementation of the project the computer literacy of the employees in
municipality institutions will improve. Internet consumption in the households of Bor and Branicevo regions is increasing the
established infrastructure will institute conditions for fast new user subordination to the datatransfer network.
The effect of the project:
The regional investment climate is improving;Broadband data transfer network will institute conditions for extension of more different servicesin regions (slow connection was not able to warrant it).The residents of regions will have better access to the resource information. Village residents willbe more informed and involved in social and economical activity of the region. Residents (theircommunities) will be able to involve themselves into remote studies, use e-business and e-medicine services.Project implementation will institute conditions to decrease social- economical gap between
villages and biggest country towns. Conditions are instituted for residents, institutions, companiesof the regions to present e-services. The use of electronic services will determine hyper workefficiency and reduced transportation expenses.Conditions are instituted for region residents to obtain ITT skills and this will enable them to adjustit to professional activity, proximately increasing labor remit of the region, and institutingconditions for less unemployment in the region.
Potential marketThe establishment of infrastructure by municipality resources will institute conditions for operatorsto decrease investment needs for infrastructure establishment in commercially off-puttingterritories. Less private operator investments will institute assumptions to cut prices for extended
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
22/40
services and to inscribe major resources for popularizing new products, which will proximatelyincrease permeability of internet consumption in Bor and Branicevo regions. With reference topresent information almost 60% of Bor and Branicevoregion municipality residents at this time donot have opportunity to use broadband data transfer networks. In this case potential market ofbroadband data transfer network in Bor and Branicevo region is at least 10 thousand households,
Educing pessimistic presumption, that network operators will reach only 40% of internet
consumption work, and broadband internet connection price for residents will reach 1000 din (10eur) per month, and for companies 3000 din (30 eur) per month, then credible income of operatorsin Bor and Branicevoregion municipality would be about 10 million din (100.000 eur),
6. Recommendations
Technology
Technologies are developing very fast, so the latest technologies must be used. This is whyinvestment project must be not older than 1 year old, otherwise investment project must beupdated.It seems, that the best solution is to utilize STATE fiber optic cable infrastructure together withwireless technology for last mile in under populated areas.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
23/40
Financing
Bor and Branicevo last mile case would be financed from state and EU Structural funds. There isno chance for such projects to be financed from EU SF from 2012-2013 financing period. Theoverall budget for broadband networks is estimated to be 80 million din . So the only other
financing solution is national/municipality budget or public- private partnership.
Problems during initiation and implementation
Major problems address during project initiation and implementation:
The project had to be matched/integrated with national projects, Infrastructure management model has to be carefully selected, State aid rules have to be addressed while selecting infrastructure management model and
must be addressed before project implementation,Land ownership and projection phase must be done very carefully (especially power supply
problem).
Brief comments on some key issues :
(1) Approaches or projects that involve application or dissemination of technology (no matter
what), tend to be driven by the technology side, and target the macro-level in recipient countries,
even in the cases when the end-users or beneficiaries are local people.
(2) This project appears to be supply driven. That is, it is not clear that there is a demand, particular
in the rural areas, and among a majority of the population. How to build that demand?
(3) The type of "network" that is referenced here would seem to emphasize the technological side.
Contrary to this, the type of network that I am concerned with are basically human direct
interaction networks that have evolved, through use of ICTs, into virtual networks. I have built and
maintained a number of such networks, for specific purpose foci and activities. Throughout, the
focus is on the individuals as the key nodes that constitute the network (and not, e.g., computers
and servers).
(4) In ICT projects there is a tendency to focus on the form, that is, the mediating technology, and
less on the content, that is, what kind of knowledge and information that will flow through this
network. Traditional network analysis, as originally developed in the social sciences, can say a lotabout the latter, and how to move from the former to the latter.
(5) Culture vs. technology. I would like to make a plea for situating technology, any technology,
including ICTs, within a cultural context. Basically, ICTs is nothing but means of reconfiguring and
reconstituting traditional basic human communication, whether it it 1-to-1 or many-to-many. But
in this lies also a danger, as technology very easily changes the message, the content of
communication.
by permission of Supras consulting ltd.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
24/40
(6) Speaking only with reference to rural areas in Eastern Europe, t is not clear to me that the
majority of the rural population understand how this is going to help them. And, furthermore, how
to structure and present relevant capacity building to achieve this is far from clear.
(7) Who will the users for broadband access in rural areas be, I wonder? My guess is that it will
probably be a rather limited/small category? There is nothing inherently wrong with that. The
concern this raises, however, is who gets direct access, and whether there will be controls to access
(the key impediments or controls may turn out to be costs and hardware).
(8) Capacity building will be necessary, primarily on issues like why this technology comes, why it is
necessary, and how to utilize it. Furthermore, how it may necessitate changes in social
organization - in public sector, civil society and private sector - and in the relations between them.
(9) The digital gap does not apply only to developing economies, it is as evident in transition
economies. More importantly, in countries that have embarked upon the road to modernization viause of ICTs, a domestic digital gap can be found, often along the lines of the traditional urban-rural
dichotomy.
(10) Knowledge is power. ICT gives access to power, which means that there are very real
possibilities that ICTs will lead to increase in differences between those that are informed /
have knowledge, and those that are not informed, and do not have knowledge.
(11) Civil society is incipient in Eastern Europe. A democratic implementation of your project
would depend on high levels of transparency and decentralization, together with ability to
associate formally, which today is not available in large parts of Eastern Europe.2
2SUPRASMr. Lars Soeftestad, CEO. Supras Consult Limited (registered in Norway and UK)www.supras.biz
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
25/40
ANEX I
Household Download Index
Based on millions of recent test results from Speedtest.net, this index compares and ranks
consumer download speeds around the globe. The value is the rolling mean throughput in Mbps
over the past 30 days where the mean distance between the client and the server is less than 300
miles.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
26/40
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
27/40
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
28/40
ANEX II
ANEX III
Technological opportunities for further development of the Project Idea
Internet and communications
MAIN NODES
Backhaul links, inter communities links, combination of fiber and wireless links
Servers, NAS, stations, multicast servers- heart of the network. Dataloggers: measurement
equipment
MEDIUM NODES
Links, last mile links, connecting the villages, measurement equipment
SMALL VILLAGE NODES
Wireless local links, end users
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
29/40
Entertainment and e*content providing
Establishment of a fully independent channel of communication phones and Skype video calls
through the IP network protocol or the Internet,
Establishment of independent media channels for distribution of digital television, digital radio, (in
Serbia is transferred to the digital DVB-T H.264 4 as of 2012) which will be distributed to end-users
via cable or the Internet. Without paying licenses for frequencies and the like. Therefore an
increase of good quality of entertainment for a fair price.
Climate change and weather monitoring
Unifaied Data loggers connected to LAN network and links, with unique MAC addresss-es and ip
addresses . Data loggers are connected with sensors, for measuring wind speed/direction and solar
radiation. Also they are connected with mini climate stations. Data loggers are safestoring the
measured data on several displaced servers for safety.
RAPID response systems
Alternative network for audio /phone and video communication, in case of natural or other disastercan dedicate nearly all resources to the people in need.
safety servers storing and keeping data safely.
Smart networks Internet III
NAS, Mulitcast servers, Internt caching, Multicasting for the digital radio and tv, local network
usage and utilisation.
Education and e-Education (Remote education)Rural Education Project,
Creating a reading room, mini-classrooms in the villages, the collection and storage of digital data
to the volunteers or members of the village, traditional music, old pictures, videos, clips,
interviews, scanned documents via a network infrastructure - the scientific impact and opportunity
for development for our people, to show what we can, from the poverty we can extract only the
knowledge and perseverance. And respect for our forefathers.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
30/40
- Prepare workshops and training facilities using internet in remote areas basics
- Internet for rural areas pamlflets
- ECDL preparation and training
- Protection online
- Protection from abuse and child safety
- Constant learning advocacy
- Constant reading advocacy
- Self developiing and healthy living
- Renewable energies: Training for solar and wind utilisation and repair
- Using the internet and renewable resources for better farming or live stock breeding
- Ensure transparency in decision making, establish good governance and encourage public
participation and citizenship
- Rising awarenes of e*government and distant learning systems DLS
Provide the appropriate conditions for safe living, maintaine social cohesion in the city center andrevitalize the city center
Strengthen social welfare and solidarity for the citizens
Implement comprehensive active inclusion strategies for the socially disadvantage groups such as
immigrants, homeless, substance users
Safeguard a decent socio-economic living standard for vulnerable groups through upgrading of
their skills, their inclusion in the labor force and their income and through the reduction of their
concentration in the city center (population diffusion)
Safeguard the provision of high standard social services, especially in education, healthcare,
social insurance and welfare to all citizens by upgrading these services
Erase of awareness on sustainable development, especially to residents and other stakeholders
and beneficiaries
Strengthen the social policy of local authorities and governments of EU member states
Good governance, transparency and participation of all interested parties in the design,
implementation and monitoring of policies
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
31/40
Energy
All the power companies needs the various data and fast. They spend hundreds of thousands of
euros in wind measurement which are implemented by untrained teams, solar measurement is
expensive, we offer a middle way solution , and laying a founding stone for future smartgrids:
By 2050, the power system needs to look a lot different to todays.
This creates huge business opportunities for the information,
communication and technology (ICT) sector to help redefine the
power network. Because a smart grid has power supplied from a
diverse range of sources and places, it relies on the gathering and
analysis of a lot of data. Smart grids require software, hardware and
data networks capable of delivering data quickly, and of responding to
the information that they contain. Several important ICT players are
racing to smarten up energy grids across the globe and hundreds of
companies could be involved with smart grids.3
3Battle of the grids 2011 Report by Greenpeace
European [R]evolution
How Europe can go 100 % renewable and phase out dirty energy
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
32/40
ACTIVITIES :: Broadband :: Wireless
Wireless
Wireless technologies are increasingly important in meeting the need for broadband
communication services.
Spectrum has been designated for electronic communication services, technically optimised in
particular for wireless broadband access through several Commission Decisions, but in many
Member States substantial parts of this spectrum are still subject to restrictions on assignment or
parts of it have not been assigned at all.
As demand for wireless services increases, the key priority will be to make effectively available to
users those frequencies that have already been earmarked through harmonised allocations,
including radio spectrum to be released from the digital dividend and from the reutilisation of
frequencies hitherto reserved for second-generation (GSM) services. Secondly, sufficient and
appropriate spectrum for both the coverage and the capacity needs of wireless broadband
technologies should be designated and made available to achieve the target set for 2020.
Broadband development can be further enhanced by pro-competitive measures such as the
introduction of spectrum trading and measures to prevent potential distortions when existing
licences are modified.
The Commission is proposing coordinated action to achieve these objectives in its first draft multi-
annual Radio Spectrum Policy Programme, submitted for adoption by the European Parliament
and Council. However, individual Member States could help achieve the broadband coverage
target rapidly if they immediately adopted policies to:
* Make available sufficiently large bands of spectrum
* Award rights of use quickly;
* Increase flexibility and competition;
* Allow secondary trading to adapt to market developments.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
33/40
For Radio Spectrum Policy Programme see: here
http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/activities/broadband/wireless/index_en.htm
The Commission adopted on 20 September 2010 its proposal to the European Parliament and
Council for a first Radio Spectrum Policy Programme which outlines at a strategic level how the use
of spectrum can contribute to the most important political objectives of the European Union from
2011 to 2015. The proposal is part of a package of measures regarding broadband
communications; wireless broadband is essential to deliver the target of broadband for all by
2013, which is one of the key goals of the Digital Agenda for Europe.
http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/policy/ecomm/radio_spectrum/eu_policy/rspp/index_en.h
tm
I want us to be able to lift our investment in broadband through deeper cooperation across the
industry and different levels of government. But I want to be clear that I wont heistiate to use new
powers under the telecoms rules entering into force in May 2011 to ensure appropriate and
consistent application of remedies.
http://blogs.ec.europa.eu/neelie-kroes/nga2011/
http://blogs.ec.europa.eu/neelie-kroes/
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
34/40
THE PROPOSED MAIN WIRELESS TO OPTICAL NODES :
SR
Bor - Majdanpek
Zajecar
Petrovac-Zagubica
Kucevo
Veliko Gradiste - Bela Crkva
RO
Moldova Noua - Oravita
Drobeta Turnu Severin
Calafat
Izvorele-Vanju Mare
BG
Kula - Vidin
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
35/40
Imagine the homolian sheephearder that has his little youtube channel where potential
buyers can see the bringing out the lambs, how are the sheeps tended and fed, how they
prepare the sheep and goat cheese ....
This product he can order directly via broadband and deliver from the mountain to the plains of
Serbia Romania and Bulgaria. ... :)
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
36/40
Digital Agenda: Vice-President Kroes calls on 21 Member States to take urgent measures on
mobile satellite services
Neelie Kroes, European Commission Vice-President for the
Digital Agenda, has issued an urgent call to twenty one EU
countries to rapidly introduce all the legislative measuresnecessary to allow the pan-EU deployment of mobile satellite
services that could be used for high-speed internet, mobile
television and radio or emergency communications to EU
consumers and businesses. According to the timetable agreed by
a Decision of the European Parliament and the EU's Council of
Ministers in 2008, Mobile Satellite Services (MSS) should be deployed in all EU Member States by
May 2011 at the latest (MEMO/09/237). But, more than twenty months after the Commission
selected two operators to provide such pan-European services, 21 Member States have not yet
adopted all the national rules needed to facilitate MSS deployment. Vice-President Kroes recently
appealed also to the two operators concerned to step up their efforts. The key role that wirelessbroadband (both satellite and terrestrial) can play to ensure broadband coverage, including in
remote and rural areas, is underlined in the Digital Agenda for Europe (see IP/10/581,
MEMO/10/199 and MEMO/10/200).
Neelie Kroes said: "Member States should urgently take all measures necessary to allow the
introduction of mobile satellite services throughout the EU. Mobile satellite services have an
important role to play in providing innovative services to businesses and citizens across Europe,
including in rural or remote areas, and in meeting our Digital Agenda targets of making broadband
available to everyone in Europe."
Twenty one Member States have not yet put in place all the necessary legislative measures to allow
Inmarsat Ventures Limited and Solaris Mobile Limited, the two operators selected in May 2009 to
provide pan-European mobile satellite services, to offer mobile satellite services from May 2011.
Vice-President Kroes has written today to the twenty one Member States in question urging them
to remove remaining legal uncertainties, such as licence fees, and to put in place all necessary
implementation measures without further delay. The twenty one Member States are Belgium,
Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia,
Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, The Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain and
the United Kingdom.
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
37/40
Background
The Commission proposed to create a single selection and authorisation process for mobile
satellite services (MSS) at EU level to facilitate the emergence of a Single Market for mobilesatellite services and maximise its potential, to the benefit of consumers and businesses.
The approach was endorsed by the European Parliament and the EU's Council of Ministers on 30
June 2008, when they adopted a Decision for the selection procedure for MSS to be organised at
European level (IP/07/1243). The Decision established a selection and authorisation process that
ensures a coordinated introduction of MSS in the EU. On 13 May 2009, the Commission selected
Inmarsat Ventures Limited and Solaris Mobile Limited as the pan-EU mobile satellite service
operators (MEMO/09/237).
For more information:
The study on measures taken by Member States for the introduction of mobile satellite services
can be found here:
http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/policy/ecomm/current/pan_european/index_en.htm
Neelie Kroes' website:
http://ec.europa.eu/commission_2010-2014/kroes/
Digital Agenda website:
http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/digital-agenda/index_en.htm
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
38/40
Danube
Key Issues
Transport
Basin has a lot of potential for sustainable continental voyage, and the river itself has a central
place. This requires improving the management, availability of equipment and qualified
personnel.Physical capacity of the Danube and its tributaries should be increased, and remove
existing obstacles in order to ensure the proper level of buoyancy, NAIADES implementation of
programs and respecting environmental laws, based on the "Joint Statement on Inland Navigation
and Environmental Sustainability in the Danube River Danube. Innovative technologies should be
supported, in accordance with market needs. Better training and career development should be to
overcome the lack of young personnel (sailors, captains, etc.)Road, rail and air infrastructure is often inefficient or simply missing, especially when it comes to
cross-border links. Implementation of TEN-T priority projects and rail corridors under Regulation
(EC) No 913/2010 must be done on time. Since agreement on the transportation community
provides better integration of the Western Balkans. Multimodality and interoperability, through
the exploration potential of the river as a key element in modern logistics, of crucial
importance. Needed are also links izmeu north and south. Danubian Functional air block (FAB) is
essential for the management of flights, as well as improvement of regional airport capacity.
Energy
Periodic crises highlight the vulnerability of the region. The quality of infrastructure, security of
supply, the organization of the market unviable requirements, energy efficiency and renewableenergy sources are often problematic. Modernization and expansion of power networks, especially
in terms of interconnection, through the implementation of the Programme for the European
energy recovery and strengthening of the TEN-E network is essential. It is necessary that there is
exchange of experiences, particularly in the field of"smart grid", "smart cities! And eco-
innovation.
Culture and Tourism
With a common history and tradition, culture and art that reflect the diversity of communities in
the region, as well as an exceptional natural heritage, the region is an attractive asset. The Danube
Delta is a world heritage building, which offers sports and other recreational opportunities. Only a
common and sustainable approach to improving the publication of these resources should makethe Danube region to European and international brand.4
4Brisel, COM (2010) 715 / 4 COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT,EUROPEAN COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN SOCIO-ECONOMIC COMMITTEEAND REGIONAL COMMITTEEEU Strategy for the Danube region{SEC(2010) 1489}{SEC(2010) 1490}{SEC(2010) 1491}
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
39/40
8/6/2019 ICT Phoenix Draft
40/40
Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond
measure. It is our light, not our darkness, that frightens us most. We ask ourselves, 'Who am I to be
brilliant, gorgeous, talented, and famous?' Actually, who are you not to be?
You are a child of God. Your playing small does not serve the world. There is nothing enlightened about
shrinking so that people won't feel insecure around you. We were born to make manifest the glory of God
that is within us.
It's not just in some of us; it's in all of us. And when we let our own light shine, we unconsciously give
other people permission to do the same.
As we are liberated from our own fear, our presence automatically liberates others.
Maryanne Williamson