1
Managing the Internationalization
Process
Chapter-6
Global Strategic Development
2
Objectives
Understand the motives for internationalization;
Explain the theories underpinning the internationalization process;
Explain the born global concept; Understand the different modes of entry
strategies employed by multinational firms;
Understand the de-internationalisation process.
3
Introduction
Motives for Decision to Internationalize Organizational Factors
Decision making characteristics Firm specific factors
Environmental factors Unsolicited proposal The ‘bandwagon’ effect Attractiveness of the host country
4
Organizational Factors
Decision making characteristics: Foreign travel and experience abroad Foreign language proficiency The decision-maker background Personal characteristics
Firm-specific factors: Firm size International appeal
5
Environmental Factors
Unsolicited proposal: some unsolicited proposal from foreign governments, distributors, or clients are hard to resist and may stimulate a firm to go international.
The ‘Bandwagon’ effect: following the leader
Attractiveness of the host country: market size, high purchasing power, high demand for industrial and consumer goods.
6
Internationalization Process
How firm Internationalize? Johnson & Paul (1975) made two
observations about the way in which firm internationalize-
1. Firms start exporting to neighboring countries, or countries that are comparatively well known or relatively small ‘Psychic distance ’ :Experiential Knowledge.
2. Firms expand their international operation sequentially :Result of Incremental Decisions
7
Johnson & Paul (1975) identified four successive stages in the firm’s international expansion:1. No regular export activities;
2. Export export activities via independent representatives or agents;
3. The establishment of an overseas subsidiary;
4. Overseas production and manufacturing
Internationalization Process
8
Internationalization Process
Johnson & Paul’s (1975) work was further developed and refined by Johnson & Vahlne (1977), who formulated a ‘dynamic’ Uppsala Model – a model in which the outcome of one cycle of events constitutes the input to the next.
9
Uppsala Model
The model proposes that internationalization is a gradual process dependent on experiential knowledge and incremental steps.
Experiential knowledge: knowledge obtained from experience. Better knowledge leads to stronger market commitment.
Incremental steps: expanding operation step by step
10
Market Commitment: the concept of market commitment suggests that resources located in a particular market presents a firms’ commitment to that market, so FDI means higher market commitment than exporting or licensing.Market commitment is composed of two factors:
The amount of resource committed: size of investment
Degree of commitment: difficulty of finding & transferring an alternative use for the resources.
Uppsala Model
11
Leads to
Leads to more
Market Knowledge
Market Commitment
Market Knowledge
Market Commitment
Uppsala Model
The process of Internationalization: interplay between the development of knowledge about the foreign market and operation on one hand and increasing commitment of resources to foreign market on the other
12
Limitations
Does not explain what triggers the first internationalization process.
Does not explain the mechanism by which experiential knowledge of a foreign market affects commitment.
Uppsala model focuses on Country similarity theory, however, Starbucks expanded their operation first in Japan
13
Limitations
The basic assumption of Uppsala model is that lack of knowledge about foreign markets is a major obstacle in the international operations.
However firm can acquire knowledge through external sources. So rather than ‘learning by doing’ firm could also go for ‘learning from imitation’, incorporating people, and forming strategic alliances.
14
Exceptions
Firms that have surplus resources and experience can take larger internationalization steps.
When market conditions are stable and homogeneous, relevant market knowledge can be gained from other sources than experience
When the firm has considerable experience of market with similar condition, it may be possible to generalize this experience to specific market
15
Born Global Firm
A Born Global (BG) firm represents a relatively new breed of the SME (Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise) that undertakes early and substantial internationalization.
Primarily a niche player, born global display high degree of entrepreneurial orientation, proactiveness, and customer service.
In the contemporary era, born global make up the fastest growing segment of exporters in most countries.
16
Born Global Firm Born global are typically avid users of the
Internet and modern communications technologies, which further facilitate early and efficient international operations.
Though their limited resources prevent them from engaging in FDI, BG’s can excel in exporting, licensing, and franchising. History and Heraldry, a born global in England that
specializes in gifts for history buffs and those with English ancestry- It recently opened a North American subsidiary in Florida.
QualComm, founded in California in 1985, initially developed and launched the e-mail software, Eudora, the firm eventually grew to become a major MNE on the strength of substantial international sales.
17
Born Global Firm
Characteristics Experience early, rapid, and substantial
internationalization Fewer financial and other resources than
traditional exporters Formed by technically inclined, market-oriented
business people with entrepreneurial drive Often enjoy internationally recognized technical
eminence and universal appeal in given product category
18
Born Global Firm
Emergence often associated with significant product/process breakthrough or innovation
Products often involve advanced technology, substantial added value, superior quality, and differentiated design
Internationalization typically via exporting and facilitated through network relationships
Heavy user of advanced IT and communications technologies
19
Some will exceed$100 million
Nichelimits
Managetransitionissues early
Createinternationalposition
Begin exportingearly (2 years)
Smalldomesticsales only
Product orprocessdevelopment
Time
Size
CredibilityFinanceExport
FinanceForeign representationExport know-how & skillsMarket information
Innovation… the next product
Born Global Firm
20
Dunning’s Eclectic Paradigm
Foreign market entry mode should be a trade-off between Risk and Return.
Dunning’s Eclectic Framework suggests that firms should consider the following three variables while selecting their entry modes- Ownership advantage Location advantage Internalization advantage
21
Dunning’s Eclectic Paradigm Ownership advantage: Tangible and intangible
resources owned by a firm which provide it a competitive advantage over industry. If firms have lower level of OA than it should not enter into the foreign market
Location advantage: How attractive a specific country is in term of market potential and investment risk. Usually market with high potential and high Investment risk in such market firms prefer high control entry mode
Internalization advantage: it refers to the benefit of keeping assets and skills within the firm when there exist a potential hazard for opportunistic behaviour by external parties.
22
Entry Mode Strategies
Export
Licensing
Foreign Direct Investment
23
Export
The action by the firm to send produced goods and services from the home country to other countries.
Advantages: Does not require a high resource commitment in the
targeted country. Inexpensive way to gain experiential knowledge and
EOS in foreign markets Low cost strategy to expand sales in order to achieve
economies of scale Easy to withdraw operation
24
Export
Disadvantages: Hard to control operations abroad Provides very small experiential knowledge in foreign
markets.
Risks: When countries experience major political instability:
delays and defaults on payments, exchange transfer blockage, confiscation of property.
No control over cost: land transport to port, shipping cost, insurance, foreign exchange risk.
25
Export
26
Licensing
The transfer of patented information and trademarks, information and know-how, including specifications, written documents, computer programs, and so forth , as well as information needed to sell a product or service, with respect to a physical territory. 1
Licensing does not mean duplicating the product in several countries.
1. Mottner & Johnson, 2000: 171
27
Licensing Advantages:
Does not require a high resource commitment in the targeted country
Can be used as a step towards a more committed mode of entry
Low cost strategy to expand sales in order to achieve economies of scale.
Obtain extra income from technical expertise and service and spread around the cost of R&D
Retain established markets that have been closed or threatened by trade restrictions
Reach new markets not accessible by export from existing facilities
28
Disadvantages: Hard to monitor partners in foreign markets High potential for opportunism Hard to enforce agreements Provides a small experiential knowledge in
foreign markets
Licensing
29
Risks: Sub-optimal choice Risk of opportunism Quality risks Production risks Payment risks Contract enforcement risk Marketing control risk
Licensing
30
31
Licensing
32
International Franchising
Contract based organizational structure for entering new markets.
It involves a franchisor firm that undertakes to transfer a business concept that it has developed, with corresponding operational guidelines, to non-domestic parties for a fee.
Franchising allows the franchisor more control over the franchisee and provides for more support from the franchisor to the franchisee than is the case in the licensor-licensee relationship.
33
International Franchising
Advantages: Require a moderate resource commitment in
the targeted country Moderate cost strategy to expand sales in
order to achieve economies of scale. Speedy entry to foreign market Retain established markets that have been
closed or threatened by trade restrictions Reach new markets not accessible by export
from existing facilities
34
International Franchising
Disadvantages: High monitoring cost High potential for opportunism Could damage firms’ reputation and image Does not provide experiential knowledge in
foreign markets
35
Risks: Franchisee might not follow the directives of
franchisor. Communicating wrong concept Potential risk of free-ride by franchisee believing
that franchisors efforts are sufficient for the franchise to succeed
Franchisee could try to increase profits by reducing the quality of inputs
A franchise may damage the franchisor image and reputation in the host country, because customers often can not distinguish between franchised and company-owned outlets.
International Franchising
36
International Franchising
International franchising is likely to succeed when certain market conditions exist: The franchisor has been successful
domestically: unique products and/or advantageous operating procedures and systems.
The factors that contributed to domestic success are transferable to foreign locations.
The franchisor has already achieved considerable success in franchising in its domestic market.
37
38
International Franchising
39
Foreign Direct Investment
A firm invests directly in production or other facilities, over which it has effective control, in a foreign country.
FDI’s require a business relationship between a parent company and its foreign subsidiary.
For an investment to be regarded as an FDI, the parent firm needs to have at least 10% of the ordinary shares of its foreign affiliates.
40
Foreign Direct Investment
Types of FDI: Joint Venture
Wholly Owned Enterprises Wholly owned subsidiary/ Greenfield
Investment Merger & Acquisition
41
Joint Venture
A joint venture is a special type of strategic alliance in which two or more firms join together to create a new business entity that is legally separate and distinct from its parents.
Exe: New United Motor ManufacturingInc. or NUMMI - owned by Toyota and General Motors.
42
Wholly Owned Enterprises
In contrast to exporting, licensing and franchising, wholly owned subsidiaries involve a higher degree of risk. Multinational firms have two options: Greenfield investment- investment in a
completely new facility- , or Acquire or Merge with an already
established local firm.
43
Greenfield
This strategy entails building an entirely new subsidiary in a foreign country from scratch to enable foreign sales and operation. Greenfield investment signifies that the parent
company has decided to clone its strategy and structure in the foreign plant by transferring its technology, supply chain, organizational structure, and corporate culture.
44
Greenfield
Advantages: Low risk of technology appropriation Able to control operation abroad. Provides high experiential knowledge in
foreign markets Low level conflict between the subsidiary
and the parent firm Managers of foreign subsidiaries have a
strong attachment to the parent firm.
45
Greenfield
Disadvantages: Could not rely on pre-existing relationship; Adds extra capacity to the existing market; The firm is seen as a foreign firm by local
stakeholders. Managers face problems to get accustomed
to the local systems
46
Risks: The risk of building relationships with
customers, suppliers and government officials in the new country
The risk of recruiting managers and employees familiar with local market conditions
The risk of being seen as a foreign firm by local stakeholders.
Greenfield
47
International Merger is a transaction that combines two companies from different countries to establish a new legal entity.
International Acquisition refers to the acquisition of a local firm’s assets by a foreign company. In an acquisition, both local and foreign firms may continue to exist.
Mergers and Acquisitions
48
Types of M&AsHorizontal M&As: involve two competing
firms in the same industry Vertical M&As : involve a merger
between firms in the supply chain. Conglomerate M&As: involve a merger
of two companies from two unrelated industries.
Mergers and Acquisitions
49
Mergers and Acquisitions
Motives Strategic motives
Economic motives
Personal motives
50
Mergers and Acquisitions Advantages:
Low risk of technology appropriation Increased market power Able to control operation abroad. Provides high experiential knowledge in foreign
markets Overcome entry barriers Lower risk compared to developing new products Increased diversification Avoid excessive competition Increased speed to market Take advantage of pre-existing relationship Does not add extra capacity to the market
51
Mergers and Acquisitions
Disadvantages: Integration difficulties Managers might have a weak attachment to
parent company Very risky method Inadequate evaluation of target: Large or
extraordinary debt Too much diversification
52
Risks: Managers of the acquired foreign subsidiary
may not accept the parent company. Might have a problem of integrating different
cultures, structures, procedures and technologies
Mergers and Acquisitions
53
Type of EntryType of Entry CharacteristicsCharacteristics
ExportingExporting High cost, low control
LicensingLicensing Low cost, low risk, little control, low returns
Strategic alliancesStrategic alliances Shared costs, shared resources, shared risks, problems of integration
AcquisitionAcquisition Quick access to new market, high cost, complex negotiations, problems of merging with domestic operations
New wholly owned New wholly owned subsidiarysubsidiary
Complex, often costly, time consuming, high risk, maximum control, potential above-average returns
54
Entry modes: Risk vs. Control
55
De-internationalisation refers to “any voluntary or forced actions that reduce a company's engagement in or exposure to current cross-border activities." When to exit How to exit
De-internationalization