Income Splitting: Opportunities & PitfallsJoan E. Jung, Partner, Michael A. Goldberg, Partner, Samantha A. Prasad, Partner, and Matthew D. Getzler, Associate – Minden Gross LLP
1
3
Attribution Rules – The Basics
• Generally applicable to the transfer and loan of property by an individual to a spouse or common-law partner (“CL partner”) and non-arm’s length minors (including nieces and nephews)
• Applicable to the period throughout which the individual (transferor) was resident in Canada
• Where applicable, the rules operate:– to prevent income splitting in respect of income from
property– to attribute income and also to attribute losses
Attribution Rules – Relevant ITA sections
• s.74.1(1) income attribution with reference to spouse and CL partner
• s.74.1(2) income attribution with reference to non-arm’s length minor; niece or nephew
• s.74.2 capital gain/loss attribution with reference to spouse or CL partner
• s.74.3 transfers to a trust for the benefit of spouse, CL partner, non-arm’s length minor, niece or nephew
4
Critical Words
• “Where an individual has lent or transferred property … either directly or indirectly, by means of a trust or by any other means whatever, to or for the benefit of …”
5
“Lent or transferred property“
• Fasken Estate 49 DTC 491 (Exch. Ct.) • “The word "transfer" is not a term of art and has not a
technical meaning. It is not necessary to a transfer of property from a husband to his wife that it should be made in any particular form or that it should be made directly. All that is required is that the husband should so deal with the property as to divest himself of it and vest it in his wife, that is to say, pass the property from himself to her. The means by which he accomplishes this result, whether direct or circuitous, may properly be called a transfer.”
6
Transfer - KieboomConcerns
• Transfer of property– s. 248(1), ITA: “… includes a right of any kind whatever
…”– Economic interest?
• See The Queen v. Kieboom 92 DTC 6382 (FCA)– Undervaluation constitutes a transfer?
• See CRA Document No. 2010-0366301I7; Interpretation Bulletin IT-511R, paragraph 1
7
Application of Kieboom
• Romkey 2000 DTC 6047 (FCA)– “right to receive .. increased measure of any future
dividends” [FCA at paragraph 21]
• Garron Family Trust 2009 DTC 1287 (TCC) affd 2010 5189 (FCA) affd 2012 DTC 5063 (SCC)– “movement of share rights attributable to existing equity”
[TCC at paragraph 288]
• Krauss 2009 DTC 597 affd 2010 DTC 5176 (FCA)– “right to participate in income” [TCC at paragraph 52]
8
Directly or indirectly … by any other means whatever
• Garron Family Trust [FCA at paragraph 79]• “Once it is accepted that an indirect transfer of the
shares of a corporation from Shareholder A to Shareholder B can be achieved by a corporate reorganization that shifts part of the value of the corporation from the class of shares owned by Shareholder A to the class of shares owned by Shareholder B, I see no principled basis for concluding that the same transaction cannot also be an indirect transfer of property “in any manner whatever” to the person that owns Shareholder B.”
9
Directly or indirectly … by any other means whatever
• Garron Family Trust considered s. 94, ITA rather than the attribution rules, but similar wording– Implies looking through corporations– See also St – Pierre and Lafontaine v. The Queen 2008
DTC 3730 (TCC) affd 2008 DTC 6639 (FCA)
10
Extended application –subsection 74.1(3), ITA
• Where the transferred or loaned property is used to either repay borrowed money that was used to acquire property or to reduce an amount payable for that property
• s. 74.1(1) or (2) will apply to income/loss thereafter on a proportionate basis, based on FMV of loaned/transferred property to the cost of the property acquired
11
Extended application –subsection 74.1(3), ITA
12
Arm’s length lender
1. LoanTaxpayer who acquires income producing property
Taxpayer’s spouse
2. Gift3. Gift used to repay loan
Extended application –subsection 74.5(7), ITA
• Guaranteeing loans (or interest thereon) made by third party to a “specified person” as defined in s.74.5(8)– Includes spouse, CL partner, non-arm’s length minor
(including niece or nephew)– Includes a corporation (other than SBC) of which any of
the above is a “specified shareholder”• If applicable, property loaned by third party to
“specified person” deemed to be loaned by the individual
13
Extended application –subsection 74.5(7), ITA
• Joint line of credit on which one spouse draws down (see CRA Document No. 2009-031704)– Secured by family home to which other spouse had
contributed most of the capital• CRA position
– Providing collateral not a transfer– Question of fact whether s.74.5(7) engaged– Joint and several liability, therefore yes
14
Extended application –subsection 74.5(6), ITA
• Sometimes referred to as intermediary rule or back to back rule, but broader– No series concept (see St-Pierre and Lafontaine 2008
DTC 3730 (TCC) affed 2008 DTC 6639 (FCA)) • s. 74.5(6)(b) requires property transferred to another
person “on condition” that property (not necessarily the same property) be transferred or lent directly or indirectly to or for the benefit of a “specified person”
15
Extended application –subsection 74.5(6), ITA
• But s.74.5(6)(a) does not require a transfer “on condition”– Where an individual has transferred or lent property and
that property (or property substituted therefor) is transferred or lent by any person (not necessarily the person to whom the individual transferred or lent) directly or indirectly to or for the benefit of a “specified person”
16
Attribution of income from property only
• s. 74.1 not applicable to income from business• Note s. 96(1.8) which deems income from a partnership
to be income/loss from property for purposes of s.74.1 among others– Provided the person to whom property is transferred or
lent is a “specified member” of the partnership, see definition in s.248(1)
17
Section 74.2 - Disposition of property?
• s. 74.2 deems an amount to be the transferor spouse’s taxable capital gain or allowable capital loss from the disposition of property
• Can transferor potentially claim capital gains exemption on the attributed taxable capital gain?– Yes, see s.74.2(2)
• Can transferor potentially claim ABIL on the attributed allowable capital loss?– No, see CRA Document Nos. 9621015 and 931818
18
When does attribution cease?
• Generally if the individual transferor ceases to be resident in Canada
• In the case of minors, s. 74.1(2) ceases to apply in the year in which the recipient (i.e., the person to whom property was loaned or transferred) attains age 18– But beware s.56(4.1) which may apply to loan
19
When does attribution cease?
• In the case of spouse or CL partner, s.74.5(3) may apply if living separate and apart– Note election required under s.74.5(3)(b) with respect to
capital gains attribution under s.74.2 • Repayment of loan to cease attribution requires
repayment with the original loaned property or property substituted therefor– See 1993 Revenue Canada Round Table, Q.36
20
Section 160 - Joint and several liability
• Assuming transfer of property• s.160(1)(d): joint and several liability for any increase
in transferor’s Part I tax liability resulting from inclusion of attributed income under s.74.1-75.1
• s.160(1)(e): joint and several liability for any tax liability of transferor for the year of transfer or preceding year to extent that FMV of transferred property exceeded FMV of consideration (if any)
21
Section 120.4 – Tax on split income
• General rule : increases to 29% rate on “split income” of a “specified individual” with no credits other than dividend tax credit and foreign tax credit, s.120.4(2) and (3)
• If applicable:– Attribution rules in s.74.1, 74.3 and 75(2) do not apply,
s.74.5(13)– Rules in s.56(2), (4) and (4.1) do not apply, s.56(5)
22
Section 120.4 – Tax on split income
• Relevant definitions, s.120.4(1)• “Specified individual”
– a resident minor (under age 18) with at least one parent resident in Canada
• “Split income”– taxable dividends received by “specified individual” on
shares of a corporation other than shares listed on a designated stock exchange or shares of mutual fund corporation
• including by allocation and payment through a trust, s.104(13)
23
Section 120.4 – Tax on split income
– Amounts included in income of a “specified individual” under s.15 as a benefit or loan, because of ownership by any person of shares of a corporation (excluding listed shares)
– Amounts included in income from a partnership or trust to extent that amounts are derived from provision of goods or services by the partnership or trust to or in support of a business carried on by:
• a person related to the specified individual at any time in the year
• a corporation of which a related person is a “specified shareholder” at any time in the year
• a professional corporation of which a related person is a shareholder at any time in the year
24
Section 120.4 – Tax on split income
• “Split income” definition proposed to be amended by Federal Budget 2014– To include income that is paid or allocated to a “specified
individual” from a partnership or trust which is derived from a business or rental of property if a related person:
• Actively engaged on a regular basis in activity of the particular partnership or trust of earning income from business or rental of property
• In the case of a partnership, has an interest in the partnership
25
Section 120.4 – Tax on split income
• “Excluded amount”– Applicable if property giving rise to the income or
capital gain which would otherwise be “split income” was acquired by the individual as a consequence of death of:
• parent• any other person, where the individual is a full time
student at a post-secondary institution or eligible for the disability tax credit in the year
26
Section 120.4 – Tax on split income
• Transmogrification rule in s.120.4(4)– Capital gain from disposition of unlisted shares to a
person non-arm’s length with the “specified individual” deemed to be a taxable dividend and not a capital gain
• Joint and several liability of “specified individual” and parent, s.160(1.2)
27
Corporate Attribution RulesSection 74.4
• S.74.4: Conditions– Transfer/loan of property to company either directly or
indirectly by means of a trust or otherwise• Transfers can include corporate reorganizations where
as part of the transaction, shares are transferred or exchanged
– One of the main purposes is to reduce transferor’s income and benefit a “designated person”
• Designated person: spouse, or child, niece, nephew or other non-arm’s length person who has not reached the age of 18 in the year
• Designated person must be a “specified shareholder” of company (i.e. who owns directly or indirectly 10% of more of the issued shares of any class at any time)
29
Effect of Corporate Attribution Rules
• S. 74.4(2): Taxable benefits, based on prescribed interest rates applied to the “outstanding amount” (per s.74.4(3)) of the loan/transfer will apply for periods throughout which:– person is a “designated person” and a “specified shareholder”– Transferor is a Canadian resident– Corporation is not a small business corporation
• This deemed income inclusion can potentially result in double taxation
30
Corporate Attribution Rules
• When can the corporate attribution rules apply?– Estates freezes – Interest-free loan to corporation– “Derivative transfers” (Back to back
transfers)
31
Estate Freezes
• Typically involves a transfer of shares to a holding company or exchange of shares as part of a reorganization of the capital of a company
• Designated persons usually receive new growth shares in corporation
32
Opco
MinorKids
Parent
Opco
Holdco
Parent MinorKids
Interest-free Loans to Corporations
• Parent transfers cash to Opco by way of an interest-free loan
• Parent has reduced income as any future income from the loan amount will go to the Trust for minor kids
33
Opco
MinorKidsParent
Loan
Derivative Transfer
• Can extend the application of the corporate attribution rules
• Husband lends property to Opco 1 • Opco then lends to Opco 2 which is wholly owned
by wife
34
Opco 1
Husband Wife
loan
Opco 2
Exceptions to the Corporate Attribution Rules
• Small Business Corporation Status– CCPC, all or substantially all (90%) of the FMV of
assets of which (at any particular time) is attributable to assets that are used principally (50%) in an active business carried on primarily in Canada
– Easy to go offside the 90% test
– If offside, corporate attribution rules will apply throughout the period during which corporation is offside
35
Exceptions to the Corporate Attribution Rules
• S. 74.4 Clause inserted in Trust – Track to wording of the actual clause
– Will lose ability to distribute to the spouse during marriage
– Will restrict ability to multiply the capital gains exemption through the Trust
– Drafting tricks? CRA has said you need a blanket prohibition so cannot draft to say s.74.4 clause not applicable while Opco is a small business corporation or while transferor is non-resident
36
Avoiding the Corporate Attribution Rules
• Situations where Corporate Attribution Rules are not triggered– Start-Up situations
• Corporate attribution rules are limited to the value of the corporate at the time of the “reorganization”
• No real value at the time of a start-up
37
Avoiding the Corporate Attribution Rules
• Stock Dividend Freeze– No transfer – Freeze shares are issued by corporation
38
Opco
Parent
New freeze shares
Minor Kids
Avoiding the Corporation Attribution Rules
• Reverse Freeze – A Technical Escape? – Transfer of assets from Opco to new Subco– Issuance of freeze shares from Subco to Opco on transfer– New growth shares of Subco issued to Trust– No “transfer” by individual in respect of a designated person;
rather only a transfer between corporations– Beware of bonusing down and parent lends back to the
corporation
39
Parent
Minor Kids
Opco
Subco
Effective Use of Trusts In Income Splitting
• Trust Basics– Income splitting– Capital gains exemption multiplication
• Specific income splitting opportunities– Prescribed rate loans– Testamentary trusts– Ontario surtax planning– Alberta trusts– S.94(1) trusts
41
Trust Basics
• It’s not all about tax– Effective management and administration of
property for a trust’s beneficiaries
• But focus today – income splitting
42
Tax Effective Use of Trusts
• Outright transfers v. transfer in trust– Generally possible to enjoy similar tax
benefits• Income splitting• Capital gains exemption (“CGE”)
multiplication– But many non-tax advantages of trusts
• Control • Flexibility
43
Outright Transfers v. Transfer in Trust
• Freeze: shares issued to spouse & kids– Tax Benefits similar to using a trust
• Income splitting • CGE multiplication
– Simple to implement and maintain but• Lose flexibility of making changes to
ownership • Incapable beneficiaries• Exposure to creditors• Expanded ownership rights
44
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Income splitting is possible because– Trust deed:
• Empowers trustees to make broad discretionary allocations of income and capital
• Defines income as income for ITA purposes
45
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• If a deed does not define income then income has meaning under trust law– Does not include capital gains or “deemed”
(phantom) income for ITA purposes such as:• Deemed dividends (e.g., on redemption)• Deemed capital gains (e.g., on 21st
anniversary)• May not be able to allocate deemed income
to beneficiaries– Capital encroachment powers may assist
46
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Income splitting is possible because– S.104(13)
• Amounts “payable” to beneficiary taxed to beneficiary
– Payable – either paid or legally enforceable right of beneficiary in the year s. 104(24)
• Trust gets a deduction s.104(6), – Losses cannot be allocated to beneficiaries
47
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Income splitting is possible because– Many technical rules in s.104 ensure
income maintains character when allocated including as:
• Dividends (s.104(19))• CDA (s.104(20))• Capital gains eligible for CGE (s.104(21) &
s.(21.2))
48
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Multiplying the CGE– Direct share ownership
• Loss of control and flexibility– Discretionary family trust
• CGE flow-through rules (s.104(21) & s.(21.2))
49
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Special income splitting rules where amounts are not payable– S.104(14) – preferred beneficiary election
• Application limited to disabled beneficiaries since 1995
50
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Special income splitting rules where amounts are not payable– S.104(18) – Age 40 Trusts
• Income of the trust in year not made payable• Held in trust for an individual who has not
turned 21 in year• Individual’s rights vest in year not because of
exercise or failure to exercise discretion• Rights not subject to condition other than
individual survive to an age not exceeding 40
51
Trust Technical Taxation Basics
• Allocations and Distributions in Breach– Income will remain taxable in trust – Rollout under s.107(2) will be denied– Recipient may be subject to tax under
S.105(1)
52
Prescribed Rate Loan Planning
• No interest/low interest loans to benefit certain NAL persons may be subject to personal attribution rules– Exception for “Loans for Value” – s.74.5(2)
53
Prescribed Rate Loan Planning
• What is a Loan for Value?– Interest rate of at least the prescribed
rate– Interest paid on or before January 30 of
the following year– Lose exemption from attribution forever if
interest in respect of any particular year not paid on time
54
Prescribed Rate Planning
• Direct or to a Trust?• Why make a Loan for Value Now?
– Historically low prescribed rate of 1%• Long-term enhancement of income splitting
benefits– Rates may be higher in the future
55
Prescribed Rate Loan Planning
• Caution - refinancing old Prescribed Rate Loans– Cannot simply amend rate– Cannot simply refinance– Must dispose of acquired property and
repay old loan, only then can one advance a new low rate loan
56
Testamentary Trust Planning
• The estate itself and Trusts formed by will– Purposes: administration, control, tax etc.
• Some common types of trusts– Estate– Spousal– Family trusts– Insurance trusts– Spendthrift/Henson trusts– US beneficiary trusts
57
Testamentary Trust Planning
• Tax advantage of testamentary trusts– Spousal trusts – defer death taxes– Income splitting with beneficiaries– Income taxed at graduated rates
58
2015 Testamentary Trust Tax Savings First $135,000 of Income – by
Province
59
PROVINCE SAVINGS*Alberta $10,750
British Columbia $20,750
Manitoba** $14,500
New Brunswick $26,500
Newfoundland / Labrador** $13,000
Nova Scotia $19,000
Northwest Territories $17,250
Nunavut $17,000
Ontario $23,500
Prince Edward Island** $15,500
Quebec $15,500
Saskatchewan $14,250
Yukon $19,000
*All figures have been rounded
June 2013 Consultation Proposals
• Beginning in 2016 elimination of:– Graduated rates after first 36 months of estate – Exemption from income tax installment rules– Exemption from calendar taxation year– Exemption in computing AMT– Preferential treatment under Part XII.2– Ability to automatically qualify as a personal
trust– Ability to make ITCs available to beneficiaries
60
Whirlwind Legislative Process –Bill C-43 is the Law of the Land
• Final legislation extremely problematic – Nearly all original proposals enacted with
significant further restrictions and surprises that will severely impact traditional testamentary planning, spouse trust and other trust planning with no grandfathering
• Bill C-43 enacted Dec. 16, 2014 with effect as law of the land on January 1, 2016– Is this the final word?
61
Bill C-43 –Testamentary Trusts some of the key surprises
• Income of a testamentary spousal trust in year of death of spouse beneficiary taxed to spouse beneficiary not the trust– Inequitable results– Technical drafting issues
• Is spouse beneficiary taxed on capital or income account?
61a
Bill C-43 –Testamentary Trusts some of the key surprises
• Access to many traditional testamentary planning techniques only available to GREs– 164(6) planning– Certain charitable planning
• GREs are only certain qualifying estates and can last for no more than 36 months– Other than certain trusts for disabled persons
other trusts formed under a will are not GREs
61b
Bill C-43 – Practice Points
• Consider revisiting– Not only pure tax planned testamentary trusts
but all testamentary trusts and, in particular, spousal trusts
– Self-Benefit, Alter-ego and Joint Spousal Trusts• But what are the solutions? What if the law
changes?• Non-tax planned testamentary trusts and
lifetime trusts will likely continue to be in use
61c
Ontario Surtax Planning
• Planning Point - Ontario– Ontario surtaxes do not apply when
determining tax rate• Surtaxes will apply when minor’s Ontario
tax liability exceeds surtax thresholds• Annual savings for top rate Ontario
taxpayer per minor beneficiary about $2,860 on just over $42,000 of ordinary investment income “split income”
62
Alberta Trust Planning
• Alberta Advantage…
Alberta RatesTop Rate 39.00%Capital gains 19.50%Eligible dividends 19.29%Ineligible dividends 29.36%
63
Alberta Trust Planning
…gives rise to the Alberta Trust– Trust resident in Alberta with non-Alberta
resident beneficiaries– Income taxed in Alberta Trust– Capital distributed tax-free to beneficiaries
64
Alberta Trust Planning
…gives rise to unhappy other provinces– Anti-avoidance rules (including prov. GAAR)
• Eliminate benefits• Double tax?
– Case-law – Garron*– BEPS Etc.?
*Fundy Settlement v. The Queen, 2012 DTC 5063 (SCC)
65
Alberta Trust Planning
• Alberta Advantage…
Alberta RatesTop Rate 39.00%Capital gains 19.50%Eligible dividends 19.29%Ineligible dividends 29.36%
66
Section 94 Trusts
• Residence of trusts under Canadian law:– Common-law resident
• “Central management and control” – Garron*– Pure non-resident trusts (“NRTs”) – NRTs deemed resident under s. 94
• Extremely broad deeming rule applies if there is either:
– Resident contributor– Connected contributor
*Fundy Settlement v. The Queen, 2012 DTC 5063 (SCC)
67
Section 94 Trusts
• Some reasons to use Pure NRTs and s.94 NRTs instead of onshore trusts include:– To benefit non-residents– For privacy– Access to a wider range of investments– Access more favourable, trust, insolvency
and other legislation
68
Section 94 Trusts
• Favourable tax treatment (outside Alberta)
69
Alberta Rates39.00%19.50%19.29%29.36%
S.94 RatesTop Rate 42.92%Capital Gains 21.46%Eligible Dividends 28.55%Ineligible Dividends 31.41%
Various Income Splitting Strategies
• Discretionary Dividend Shares• Stock Dividend Freezes• Downstream Freezes• Start-Up Freezes• Spousal Swaps
74
Discretionary Dividend Shares
• What are they?– Shares with nominal value that can receive
unlimited dividends at the directors’ discretion
• How are they used to split income?– Issue to spouse, issue or others and have
dividends from the corporation be taxed in their hands instead of an individual in a higher tax bracket
75
Value of Discretionary Dividend Shares
• Share attributes that support lack of value: – Non-voting– Non-participating on dissolution other return
of “redemption amount”– Redeemable by corporation at nominal
redemption amount– Discretionary dividends have no reference
to priority
76
Value of Discretionary Dividend Shares
• Share attributes (cont.): – Constating documents should provide that
dividends may be declared on one or more classes of shares to the exclusion of any one or more other classes of shares
• Corporate Steps– Valid subscription and payment– Payment of dividends to registered holders– Respect non-impairment clauses
77
Value of Discretionary Dividend Shares
• But…..is their value really nominal? – When were they issued?
• On incorporation?• As part of an estate freeze?• Without a reorganization of share capital?
– S.69(1)(b) issue?
– Ideal to issue upon incorporation or in the course of an estate freeze
• Risks– S. 15(1), s.110.6(7), GAAR, tax on
transfer?78
Stock Dividend Freezes
• Alternative method of effecting an estate freeze
• May not run afoul of the corporate attribution rules– a stock dividend does not in itself constitute
a transfer directly or indirectly … to a company by an individual
79
How are they done?
• Articles of amendment filed, if necessary, creating a new class of freeze shares
• Stock dividend on the common shares consisting of freeze shares in amount sufficient to reduce the common shares to a nominal value
• New common shares acquired by the beneficiaries of the freeze – Personal attribution rules should be
considered80
After
Opco
ParentTrust
10,000 Class A Shares
acb = $1fmv = $1M
100 common shares
acb = $1fmv = $1
82
Characteristics of Freeze Shares Issued on Stock Dividend
• low stated capital– minimize the deemed dividend, based on an
increase to the stated capital• CRA unwilling to recognize a PAC
– stock dividend freeze does not involve a transfer of property in a non-arm’s length transaction
– Must be pretty certain of shares’ FMV or could be adverse unintended tax consequences
83
Subsection 15(1.1)
• If s.15(1.1) applies, the fair market value of the stock dividend could be brought into the recipient’s income– Imperative that payment of stock dividend
not shift value among classes of shares
84
Subsection 15(1.1) cont.
• S. 15(1.1) applies where:– it can reasonably be considered that one of
the purposes of the payment of the stock dividend was to significantly alter the value of an interest in the corporation of any “specified shareholder” of the corporation
85
Subsection 15(1.1) cont.
• CRA view that s.15(1.1) generally not applicable when stock dividend paid to a person who owns all of the shares of the corporation– Suggestion that s.15(1.1) won’t apply
unless the payment of the stock dividend itself would result in an increase or decrease in the value of a specified shareholder’s interest in the payer corporation
86
Downstream Freezes
• A freeze of a subsidiary or other downstream corporation
• Implemented in a number of circumstances, for example: – when growth shares are to be distributed
out of a family trust and new freeze desired – where a refreeze is undesirable
87
Implementation of Downstream Freeze
• Exchange by Holdco of common shares held in Opco for freeze shares
• Common shares of Opco ultimately to be held in the hands of the beneficiary of the freeze
88
Traditional Freeze
90
Opco
Holdco
NewTrustParent
Original Freeze Shares
New Freeze Shares
c/s
c/s
Trust
Downstream Freeze: After
Opco
Holdco
TrustParent
Freeze Shares c/s
Freeze Sharesacb = $1fmv = $1M
NewTrust
Common Sharesacb = $1fmv = $1M
91
Downstream Freeze and the Corporate Attribution Rules
• Corporate attribution rules may not apply to a downstream freeze because exchange of shares takes place at corporate level and not personal level– Back-to-back rules in s.74.5(6) could apply
93
Back-to-Back Rules
• First part of provision applies where:– individual has transferred or lent property
(i.e., the shares of Opco originally transferred by Parent to Holdco)
– to another person (i.e., Holdco) – and that property or substituted property
(i.e., the Opco shares) – is in turn transferred (i.e., exchanged by
Holdco for freeze shares of Opco) – to or for the benefit of a “specified person
(i.e., Opco) with respect to the individual
94
Back-to-Back Rules cont.
• The “individual”– Generally includes corporations with family
members who are designated persons as significant shareholders
• If applicable:– individual who made the first transfer (i.e.,
Parent) deemed to have made the second transfer (i.e., the downstream freeze), thus causing corporate attribution rules to apply
• When applicable??95
Start-up Freezes
• Ideal time to get a desired structure in place at the outset
• Implementation of freeze or even just using a discretionary trust from the outset provides flexibility and reduces costs at a later date
• Limits application of certain tax provisions
96
Benefit of Start-Up Freeze
• Can start income splitting immediately, if possible
• May allow income splitting when income does start coming
• May be important to have structure in place in order to multiply lifetime capital gains exemption– Increase in value attributable to shares– 2-year holding period
97
Spousal Swaps
• Allows spouse to pay tax on income or capital gains with respect to property transferred between spouses– Transfer must be at fair market value
• Potentially subject to capital gains on assets transferred
• Use of losses to shelter gains– If for anything less, attribution rules will
apply• All income attributed to transferor
98
Spousal Swaps cont.
• Transfer interest in principal residence?– Typically asset with significant value– Typically non-income earning– Disposition typically exempt from capital
gains tax on account of principal residence exemption
– Must consider land transfer tax
• Other real estate (i.e., rental or business)– Land transfer tax and recapture
considerations99
This webinar is brought to you by Wolters Kluwer and in partnership with Minden Gross LLP.
For more information please contact customer service at 1-800-268-4522.
Visit www.cch.ca/ExpertEdge for a full list of our webinars.
Joan E. Jung(416) 369-4306
Michael A. Goldberg(416) 369-4317
Samantha A. Prasad(416) 369-4155
Matthew Getzler(416) 369-4316
100