Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 1
Three Elements to a Successful Financial Literacy Education
Program
Leslie E. Linfield, Esq.October 29, 2008
Building Assets of People, Families & Communities
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 2
The easiest way for your children to learn about money
is for you not to have any.
Katharine Whitehorn
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 3
There are three parts to a successful financial literacy education program
They are:• Quality Financial Education
Products• Qualified and Trained Financial
Educators• Evaluation Program in Place to
Measure Results
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 4
Quality Financial Education Products
• There are over 1,000 financial literacy education programs available today for the K-Adult market,
• This does not include the materials that organizations produce for their own use.
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 5
Quality Financial Education Products
• What should a quality financial literacy education program entail?
• How do you tell a good program from a bad program?
• Is this objective or subjective?• What tools are out there to help you?• Standards and Benchmarks
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 6
Quality Financial Education Products
• Testing students’ knowledge based on the content of the program will help you determine if the program is effective.
• Pre-testing gives you a baseline• Post-testing will show you
knowledge transferences• 10-25 questions • Multiple choice or true/false is
acceptable
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 7
Quality Financial Education Products
• National Standards in K-12 Personal Finance Education were created by the Jump$tart Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy (www.jumpstart.org)
• National Standards for Adult Financial Literacy Education were created by the Institute for Financial Literacy (www.financiallit.org)
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 8
Qualified and Trained Financial Educators
• Do you use paid staff or volunteers?• Do they receive special training?• Are they experienced educators?• Are they required to do ongoing
professional development?• What makes a good educator?
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 9
Qualified and Trained Financial Educators
• Professional certification as a financial literacy educator
• Ongoing professional development• Student evaluation of the educator• Supervisor evaluation of the educator
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 10
Qualified and Trained Financial Educators
• Center for Financial Certifications offers the Certified Educator in Personal Finance (CEPF)
• Heartland Institute of Financial Education offers the Certified Financial Educator (CFE)
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 11
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• “However, even with the wide range of measures being used, the majority of financial education programs are still evaluated using "program output" criteria such as the number of program participants, number of programs delivered, and number of educational materials distributed. These measures are not adequate when assessing the effectiveness of financial education and can often be misleading since they do not capture changes in knowledge or financial behavior. Effective program evaluations identify whether program participants achieve intended learning outcomes such as those associated with
knowledge, skills, and behavior.” (Are We Making the Grade? A National Overview of Financial Education and Program Evaluation? Dr. Lyons et al. 2006)
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 12
• Program output = bad!• Number of people attended
• Number of classes per year
• Number of pamphlets handed out
• So what is an effective financial literacy program evaluation?
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 13
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• You and your funders will want to see several things:
• Demographics information on your students,
• Students’ confidence levels about their personal finances,
• Students’ attitudes about their personal finances and,
• Students’ behaviors regarding their personal finances.
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 14
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• Demographics information will tell you who is attending your education session:
• Gender• Age• Employment Status• Educational Attainment• Marital Status • Veteran Status• Income Status• Race
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 15
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• Demographics information can help you to better define your service population
• Apply for grant programs• More specifically tailor education
programs
• Avoid “Program Output” reporting
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 16
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• Behavioral Economics Based Evaluation (confidence, attitude, behavior surveying) will allow you to determine if your overall financial literacy education program is having an impact by looking at the students before and after.
• This is done with pre and post surveying.
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 17
Measuring Confidence
• This measure allows you to see how they feel about the questions:
Your Confidence to:
Not Confident
A little Confident
Somewhat Confident Confident
Very Confident
Request a free credit report annually.
1 2 3 4 5
Correct a mistake on your credit report.
1 2 3 4 5
Use credit responsibly. 1 2 3 4 5
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 18
Measuring Attitudes
• This measure allows you to see how they think about the questions:
Statement
Strongly disagree Disagree Undecided Agree
Strongly agree
Paying my credit card bills on time is important to me.
1 2 3 4 5
Making a plan to rebuild my credit is a priority.
1 2 3 4 5
Knowing what is in my credit report is important to me.
1 2 3 4 5
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 19
Measuring Behavioral Change
• This measure allows you to see how they intend to change or actually did change their behavior:
As a result of this program, do you plan to: No Maybe Yes
Already doing this
Does not apply
Pay off your credit card balances monthly.
1 2 3 4 5
Request a free credit report annually from one of the three major credit bureaus.
1 2 3 4 5
Take the necessary precautions to avoid identity theft and fraud.
1 2 3 4 5
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 20
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• Take the results of the pre-testing and post-testing to demonstrate students actual financial literacy knowledge acquisition
• This helps you to show what the students have learned through your program
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 21
Evaluation Program in Place to Measure Results
• National Endowment for Financial Education (NEFE) Financial Education Evaluation Online Toolkit (www.nefe.org)
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 22
Successful Financial Literacy Education Program
• The three parts needed for an effective financial literacy education program are:
• Quality Financial Education Products• Qualified and Trained Financial
Educators• Evaluation Program in Place to Measure
Results
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 23
Effective Financial Literacy Education Evaluation Program
• The three components of an effective evaluation program include:
• Pre and post testing based on the actual education program to show knowledge transferences
• Student & supervisor evaluations of the educators to ensure qualified instruction
• Pre and post surveying of students to measure behavioral changes
Institute for Financial Literacy © 2008 24
Thank you!
• For any questions, please contact:
Leslie Linfield