8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
1/85
Estates in Land & FutureInterests
UNIT 8a
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
2/85
An estate in land is an interest in realproperty that is or may become
possessory. In property law, the rights and interests
associated with an estate in land may be
conceptually understood as a bundle ofrights because of the potential for different
parties having different interests in thesame real property.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
3/85
The law recognizes different sorts ofinterests, called estates, in real property. Thetype of estate is generally determined by thelanguage of the deed, lease, or bill of sale
through which the estate was acquired.Estates are distinguished by the varyingproperty rights that vest in each, and that
determine the duration and transferability ofthe various estates. A party enjoying anestate is called a "tenant."
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
4/85
Categories of estates
Freehold Estates rights of ownership
Fee Simple (fee simple absolute) - most rights,least limitations, indefeasible
Fee Tail - inalienable rights of inheritance
Conditional or determinable estate - voidable
ownership Life Estate - ownership for duration of
someone's life
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freehold_estate8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
5/85
Leasehold Estate-rights of possessionand usebut not ownership. The lessor
(owner/landlord) gives this right to the lessee (tenant). There are four categoriesof leasehold estates:
estate for years (tenancy for years)lease of any length with specific beginand end date
periodic estate (periodic tenancy)automatically renewing lease (month tomonth, week to week)
estate at will (tenancy at will)leasehold for no fixed time or period. It lastsas long as both parties desire. Termination is bilateral (either party mayterminate at any time) or by operation of law.
tenancy at sufferancecreated when tenant remains after lease expiresand becomes a holdover tenant, converts to holdover tenancy upon landlordacceptance;
Types of leases Gross Lease
Net Lease
Percentage Lease
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
6/85
Statutory Estates - created by law Community Property
Homestead
Dower interest of a wife in husbands property
Curtesy intrest of a husband in wifes property
Tenancy by Entirety Equitable Estate - neither ownershipnor possession
Lien
general
specific
Easement easement in gross
easement appurtenant
ingress
egress
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
7/85
Fee Simple - An estate of indefinite duration, thatcan be freely transferred. The most common andperhaps most absolute type of estate, underwhich the tenant enjoys the greatest discretion
over the disposition of the property. Conditional Fee simple - An estate lasting
forever as long as one or more conditionsstipulated by the deed's grantor does not occur. If
such a condition does occur, the property revertsto the grantor, or a remainder interest is passedon to a third party.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
8/85
Fee Tail - An estate which, upon the death of the
tenant, is transferred to his heirs.
Life Estate - An estate lasting for the natural lifeof the grantee, called a "life tenant." If a lifeestate can be sold, a sale does not change itsduration, which is limited by the natural life of theoriginal grantee.
A life estate pur autre vieis held by one person for thenatural life of another person. Such an estate may
arise if the original life tenant sells her life estate toanother, or if the life estate is originally granted pur
autre vie.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
9/85
Leasehold - An estate of limited
duration, as set out in a contract, calleda lease, between the party granted theleasehold, called the lessee, and
another party, called the lessor, havinga longer lived estate in the property. For
example, an apartment-dweller with a
one year lease has a leasehold estatein her apartment. Lessees typically
agree to pay a stated rent to the lessor.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
10/85
A tenant enjoying an undivided estate in
some property after the termination of someestate of limited duration, is said to have a"future interest." Two important types of futureinterests are:
Reversion - A reversion arises when a tenantgrants an estate of lesser maximum durationthan his own. Ownership of the land returns
to the original tenant when the grantee'sestate expires. The original tenant's futureinterest is a reversion.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
11/85
Remainder - A remainder arises when atenant with a fee simple grantssomeone a life estate or conditional fee
simple, and specifies a third party towhom the land goes when the life estateends or the condition occurs. The third
party is said to have a remainder. The
third party may have a legal right to limitthe life tenant's use of the land.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
12/85
Estates may be held jointly as jointtenants with rights of survivorship or as
tenants in common. The difference in these two types of
joint ownership of an estate in land is
basically the inheritability of the estate.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
13/85
In joint tenancy (sometimes called tenantsof the entirety when the tenants aremarried to each other) the surviving tenant(or tenants) become the sole owner (or
owners) of the estate. Nothing passes to the heirs of the
deceased tenant.
In some jurisdictions the magic words "withright of survivorship" must be used or thetenancy will assumed to be tenants incommon.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
14/85
Tenants in common will have a heritableportion of the estate in proportion to
their ownership interest which ispresumed to be equal amongst tenantsunless otherwise stated in the transfer
deed.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
15/85
Property Rights - enjoyed by tenants under the
various estates
These include the right to:
Decide how a piece of real property is
used; Exclude others from enjoying the property;
Transfer (alienate) some or all of these
rights to others on mutually agreeableterms
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
16/85
Historical Review
In Common Law, real property wasproperty that could be protected by
some form of real action, in contrast topersonal property, where a plaintiffwould have to resort to another form of
action.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
17/85
The law now broadly distinguishesbetween real property (land andanything affixed to it) and personal
property (everything else, e.g., clothing,furniture, money). The conceptualdifference was between immovableproperty, which would transfer titlealong with the land, and movable
property, which a person would retaintitle to.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
18/85
Words of Purchase and
Words of Limitation Words of Purchase - "to A"
Words of Limitation - "for life" or
"and her heirs"
Words of Inheritance
Words of Condition"as long as A lives on the land"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
19/85
Fee Simple:
Words of Limitation Words of general inheritance
"to A and his/her heirs"
"to the Church of England its successorsand assigns"
"to the heirs of B [and their heirs]"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
20/85
Fee Tail:
Words of Limitation Words of special inheritance General: "to A and the heirs of his body"
Male: "to A and the male heirs of his body" Female: "to A and the female heirs of her
body"
Special: "to A and the heirs of his bodybegotten upon the body of his present wifeX"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
21/85
Fee Tail:
Words of Limitation Words of special inheritance
"to A and A's issue"
"Die without issue" or "Have issue"
C.L. = indefinite failure of issue
Modern = definite failure of issue
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
22/85
Fee Simple Conditional
(Before Statute DeDonis) "to A and the heirs of her body"
If A had issue born alive, then A could grantaway a fee simple
If A had no such issue, then at A's death
the property reverted back to A's grantor
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
23/85
Fee Tail - Modern Law
New fee tails abolished, grantee gets afee simple.
Grantee gets a common law fee simpleconditional.
Grantee gets a life estate, grantee's issue
get a fee simple remainder. New fee tails can be created but can
easily be disentailed by will or deed.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
24/85
Life Estate:
Words of Limitation "to A"
"to A for life"
"to A in fee simple" (?)
"to A forever
"to A for the life of A"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
25/85
Life Estate Pur Autre Vie:
Words of Limitation "to A for the life of B"
"to B for life
then B grants B's interest to A
In both cases:
A = tenant pur autre vie
B = the measuring life
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
26/85
Term of Years - Expiration and
Words of Limitation Words of limitation set a definitely
ascertainable period of time.
"to A for one day" "to A for five years"
"to A for 999 years"
Automatic expiration at end of specified
duration.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
27/85
Fee Simple - Expiration
Words of limitation set an indefinite
duration.
Expires at an owners death intestatewithout heirs.
Freely inheritable (by descent).
Freely transferable by will or by inter vivos
grant.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
28/85
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
29/85
Life Estate - Duration
Words of limitation set an indefinite
duration. Expires at death of life tenant.
Not inheritable or devisable.
Limited transferability by grant.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
30/85
Life Estate Pur Autre Vie:
Expiration Expires at death of the measuring life
Death of life tenant before death of
measuring life
O to A for the life of B ?
O
TG A Dies B Dies
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
31/85
All Estates Can be Determinable
i.e., subject to forfeiture
i.e., subject to a conditional limitation
Example: "as long as the property is
used for agricultural purposes
Termination prior to expiration
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
32/85
All Estates Can be Subject to a
Condition Subsequent Example: "on the condition that the land
not be used for industrial purposes, and if
the land shall ever be used for industrialpurposes then the grantor and his/her
heirs may re-enter and retake the land"
Termination prior to expiration
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
33/85
All Estates Can be
Vested or ContingentAn estate is vested if:
Owned by living person; and
Owned by an ascertained person; and
No condition precedent to the estate
becoming a present possessory estate.
Might have to wait for the natural expiration
of prior estate(s).
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
34/85
All Estates Can be Present or
Future Interests Present Interest - Owner has the
exclusive right to present possession of
the property.
Future Interest - Owner has no right to
possess the property until one or more
prior estates end by failure, expiration,
termination or otherwise.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
35/85
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
36/85
Joint Tenants
(One Estate) Own undivided = shares in the property.
Survivorship defeats death-time transfers.
C.L. presumption when grant was silent.
Permitted in real and personal property.
Partition and Severance applicable.
Own by the whole and by the share.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
37/85
Joint Tenants - Unities
TIME: all interests must vest at thesame time.
POSSESSION: all interests must beundivided rights to possess the entireproperty.
TITLE: all interests must derive from thesame document.
INTEREST: all estates must be of thesame type and duration.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
38/85
Tenancy by the Entirety
Four joint tenancy unities plus unity of
MARRIAGE.
Presumption when grant is silent butgrantees are husband and wife.
Permitted in real and personal property.
No right to partition or severance.
Allowed in a plurality of states.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
39/85
Tenancy by the Entirety
C.L. Treatment - Husband could grantaway the entire estate subject to the wife'sright of survivorship. Estate could be
levied by husband's separate creditors. Modern Treatment - Any attempted grant
by either spouse is wholly void. Estate can
not be levied by separate creditors ofeither spouse.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
40/85
Husband and Wife at C.L.
During marriage - Husband entitled toexclusive possession of, and rents andprofits from, all of his wife's freeholds.
Curtesy - Widower had a life estate in alllands in which his deceased wife hadseisin at any time during the marriage;
provided, that issue had been born aliveduring the marriage. (Legal and equitablefreeholds.)
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
41/85
Husband and Wife at C.L.
Dower - Widow has a life estate in 1/3 of
all lands in which her deceased husband
had seisin at any time during the marriage.
(Legal freeholds only.)
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
42/85
Cotenant Liability
All cotenants are not in possession.
No liability unless:
Bailiff or property manager Rent received from non-cotenants Ouster Exploitation of natural resources
Sale or Partition No accounting or contribution for
business activity.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
43/85
Cotenant Liability
Accounting and Contribution upon a sale:
Rental value
Mortgages, taxes, insurance
Improvements
Liability equal to each cotenant'sproportionate undivided share.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
44/85
Reversionary Interests in a
Fee Simple Absolute Grantor All reversionary interests are vested.
Fee Tail - Reversion in Fee Simple Life Estate - Reversion in Fee Simple
Term of Years - Reversion in Fee Simple
Fee Simple Absolute - None
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
45/85
Reversionary Interests in a
Fee Simple Absolute Grantor
Fee Simple Determinable a/k/a
Fee Simple Subject to a Conditional
Limitation
Possibility of Reverter in Fee Simple
"toA
and her heirs so long as the land is
used for agricultural purposes"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
46/85
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
47/85
Possibility of Reverter:
Example 1
"to A and her heirs so long as the land is
used for residential purposes"
O had a fee simple absolute.
O conveyed a determinable fee simple.
O owns a possibility of reverter in fee simple.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
48/85
Possibility of Reverter:
Example 2
"to A for life so long as A lives on the land
O owned a fee simple
O conveyed a determinable life estate O owns a reversion in fee simple
No possibility of reverter for the life of A
(between A moving and dying).
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
49/85
Power of Termination/Right of
Entry for Cond. Broken
F. S. Subject to Cond. Subsequent
Power of Termination a/k/a
Right of Entry for Condition Broken "to A and her heirs on the condition
that if the land shall ever be used for
commercial purposes the grantor andher heirs shall have the right to re-enterand retake the premises"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
50/85
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
51/85
Remainders
Future interest which is not owned bythe person who created the interest.
Can be in fee simple or in fee tail or for
a life estate.
Can be vested or contingent.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
52/85
Vested Remainders
(Indefeasibly) Vested Remainder
Vested Remainder Subject to Complete
Divestment (or Defeasance)
Vested Remainder Subject to Open a/k/a
Vested Remainder Subject to Partial
Divestment (or Defeasance)
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
53/85
Indefeasibly Vested Remainders
"to A for life, then to B and her heirs
B owns an indefeasibly vested fee simpleremainder.
"to A for life, then to B for life
B owns an indefeasibly vested life estateremainder.
Becomes a present estate after priorestate(s) expire.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
54/85
Vested Remainder Subject to
Complete Divestment
"to A for life; then to B and her heirs; but ifB does not survive C, then to C and herheirs"
B owns a vested fee simple remaindersubject to complete divestment undermodern law.
C owns a shifting executory interest in feesimple under modern law.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
55/85
Vested Remainder Subject to
Open (or Partial Divestment)
"to A for life, then to A's children and theirheirs" (opens as children as born).
If A has a child C1 at the time of the grant,then C1 owns a vested fee simpleremainder subject to open.
If C2 is born two years later, then C1 andC2, as cotenants, would own a vested feesimple remainder subject to open.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
56/85
Contingent Remainders
Contingent Remainders
Shifting Executory Interests
Springing Executory Interests Contingent remainders, executory
interests and vested remainders subject
to open (CR or EI*) are the only interestswhich are subject to the rule againstperpetuities.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
57/85
Contingent Remainders
Must follow one or more prior freeholds;and
Possibility of vesting between the time ofthe grant which created the estate and theexpiration or sooner termination of theprior freehold(s).
"to A for life; then to B and her heirs if Bmarries C"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
58/85
Contingent Remainders
Alternative contingent remainders
"to A for life; then to the B and her heirs if B
survives A; but if A does not survive B, then toC and her heirs"
B and C each own a contingent fee simple
remainder only one of which will everbecome a possessory estate.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
59/85
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
60/85
Shifting Executory Interests
"to A and her heirs; but if the land isever used for commercial uses, then to
B and her heirs" B's interest:
is a future interest because it has nopresent right to possession;
is contingent because it has a conditionprecedent;
would prematurely terminate A's.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
61/85
Springing Executory Interests
"to A and the heirs of her body starting oneyear from today
Purports to transfer seisin from the grantorto a grantee any time later than the time ofthe grant which purports to create theinterest.
No possibility of vesting before expiration ortermination of prior freehold(s).
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
62/85
C.L. Rules w/r/t Creating and
Transferring Freehold Estates
A present freehold could only be created ortransferred by a feoffment.
A reversion could be created by afeoffment or by a grant.
A remainder could only be created by a
grant. Only reversionary interests could follow a
grant of a fee simple.
C l / / C i d
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
63/85
C.L. Rules w/r/t Creating and
Transferring Freehold Estates
No shifting executory interests.
Grantor could not create a freehold
contingent remainder which wouldterminate another freehold estate prior
to its natural expiration.
"to A and her heirs, but if the land shallever be used for commercial purposesthen to B and her heirs"
C L R l / / C i d
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
64/85
C.L. Rules w/r/t Creating and
Transferring Freehold Estates
No springing executory interests. No legal contingent freehold interest
could follow a term of years. "to A for 1 year, then to B and his heirs if
B marries C"
A freehold could not be created tocommence in futuro. "to A and the heirs of her body from and
after B's death"
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
65/85
C L R l / / C i d
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
66/85
C.L. Rules w/r/t Creating and
Transferring Freehold Estates No springing executory interests. A contingent remainder is destroyed if
it does not vest before the expiration
or sooner termination of a priorfreehold. "to A for life, then to B for life, then to C
and her heirs if C marries D"
C's estate was destroyed upon the deathof the survivor of A and B, if she had notyet married D.
C L R l / / C i d
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
67/85
C.L. Rules w/r/t Creating and
Transferring Freehold Estates A contingent remainder is destroyed if
it does not vest before the expiration orsooner termination of a prior freehold.
"to A for life, then to B and the heirs of hisbody if B marries C, then to D and hisheirs"
A and D could conspire to intentionally
destroy C's contingent remainder by aforfeiture or merger of A's life estate.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
68/85
M E ti
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
69/85
Merger - Exception
If a life estate and the next vestedestate (i.e., a fee tail or a fee simple)are created in the same person by thesame document, then the two estatesdid not merge so as to destroy acontingent remainder.
"to A for life, then to B and the heirs ofher body if B survives A, then to A andher heirs" (???)
R l i Sh ll ' C
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
70/85
Rule in Shelley's Case:
Applicable Fact Patterns
"to A for life . . . then to A's heirs [and
their heirs]"
"to A for life . . . then to the heirs of the
body of A [and their heirs]"
"to A and the heirs of her body . . . thento A's heirs [and their heirs]"
R l i Sh ll ' C
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
71/85
Rule in Shelley's Case
If a document creates a freehold in Aand purports to create a fee simple (or
fee tail) remainder in A's heirs, then theremainder becomes a fee simple (or feetail) in A.
Freehold and remainder must eitherboth be legal or both be equitable.
Other estates may intervene.
R l i Sh ll ' C
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
72/85
Rule in Shelley's Case
"to A for life, remainder to A's heirs" R.S.C. - "to A for life, remainder to A and
her heirs"
Merger - "to A and her heirs" "to A and the heirs of his body,
remainder to As heirs" R.S.C. - "to A and the heirs of his body,
remainder to A and his heirs" Merger - does not apply
R l i Sh ll ' C
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
73/85
Rule in Shelley's Case
"to A for life, then to B and the heirs ofher body if B survives A, remainder toA's heirs"
R.S.C. - "to A for life, then to B and theheirs of her body if B survives A, remainderto A and her heirs"
Merger - does not apply
A grants "all my interest in Greenacre toC". C gets a fee simple absolute.
D t i f W thi Titl
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
74/85
Doctrine of Worthier Title
Testamentary Branch - Heirs takefreeholds by descent rather than bypurchase.
O devises land "to my eldest son S" At O's death, S is the sole heir.
Inter VivosBranch - No remainders can
be granted to the grantor's heirs. O grants "to O for life remainder to my
heirs"
M d R l ft St t t f
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
75/85
Modern Rules after Statute of
Uses and Statute of Wills Shifting executory freeholds - okay Springing executory freeholds - okay
Contingent freehold remainders - never
destructible Rule in Shelley's Case - abolished
Doctrine of Worthier Title
Testamentary Branch - abolished I.V. Branch = rule of construction
Rule Against Perpetuities - created
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
76/85
Statute of Uses
Didn't abolish uses (equitable estates). Immediately transformed certain uses into
the corresponding legal estates.
Modern trusts are okay. Feoffment to uses:
O enfeoffed T and his heirs to the use of Aand her heirs.
A's use was executed giving A a legal feesimple.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
77/85
Statute of Uses
The bargain and sale:
O bargained and sold to the use of A and
his heirs. The covenant to stand seised:
O covenanted to stand seised to the use
of O's son A and his heirs. In both cases, A's use was executed
giving A a legal fee simple.
Rule Against Perpetuities:
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
78/85
Rule Against Perpetuities:
Statutory Rule
A CR or EI* is not valid unless it mustnecessarily vest or fail within the ruleperiod.
Rule Period = 90 years from time ofcreation of the CR or EI*.
Time of creation:
Devise - death of the testator
Grant - delivery & acceptance of deed
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
79/85
C L What Might Happen?
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
80/85
C.L. What Might Happen?
Rule and Wait and See Rule
O devises "to A in fee simple; but if the landis ever not used for mining, then to B in feesimple.
Time of creation = time of O's death.
Measuring lives = A and B.
Rule period starts at O's death. Rule period ends on the 21st anniversary of
the death of the survivor of A and B.
C L What Might Happen?
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
81/85
C.L. What Might Happen?
Rule and Wait and See Rule Today - O grants "to A for life, then to B in
fee simple if B marries C.
Time of creation = today.
Measuring lives = O, A, B and C.
Rule period starts today.
Rule period end on the 21st anniversary of
the death of the survivor of O, A, B and C. Passes C.L. Rule & Wait and See Rule.
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
82/85
Common Law What Might
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
83/85
Common Law What Might
Happen? Rule
It is ALWAYS possible for any living
person to have children or to have
additional children.
A child is ALWAYS born during the
lifetimes of both biological parents. There are NO EXCEPTIONS.
C L What Might Happen?
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
84/85
C.L. What Might Happen?
Rule and Wait and See Rule
Today O grants "to all grandchildren of
A who reach age 21.
A's kids: C1 (age 45) and C2 (60)
C1's kids: GC1 (18) and GC2 (19)
Time of creation - today.
Measuring lives O, A, C1, C2, GC1 and
GC2.
C L What Might Happen?
8/8/2019 Intro. to Planning Law#8a
85/85
C.L. What Might Happen?
Rule and Wait and See Rule
A has C3 one year from today - C3 isnot a measuring life.
One month later all of the measuringlives (O, A, C1, C2, GC1 and GC2) die.
21 years elapse (rule period ends).
Then C3 has GC3 whose interestpurportedly vests when GC3 turns 21.