Computing the Image of the City
Bin JiangUniversity of Gävle, Swedenhttp://fromto.hig.se/~bjg/
Outline of the talk
The image of the city How the city looks like? Gaussian way of thinking Scaling way of thinking
Head/tail division rule Head/tail breaks How to compute the image of the city? Conclusion
2
3
The image of the city
Portugali 1996
Five city elements
4
© Lynch (1960)
More attention on large and complex objects
5
© Yarbus (1967)
6© Jiang and Liu (2012)
Two key concepts of the image of the city
Legibility refers to a particular (visual) quality or (apparent) clarity that makes the city’s layout or structure recognizable, identifiable, and eventually imageable in the human minds.
Imageability is a quality of a city artifact that gives on an observer a strong vivid image.
Gibson’s affordance: A city or city artifacts due to their distinguished properties (geometric, visual, topological or semantic) affords remembering to shape a mental map in the human minds.
7
How to obtain the image of the city?
It is obtained through interviewing city residents by map drawing, comparing with photographs, and walking in the physical spaces in the city.
Qualitative approach in essence. Herewith I propose a quantitative approach:
computing the image of the city
8
Which pattern looks like the city?
9
Scaling of geographic space (a hidden order)
10
Jiang B., Liu X. and Jia T. (2011), Scaling of geographic space as a universal rule for map generalization, Preprint: http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.1561.
11© Fischer (2010)
12© Watz (2008)
13
Jackson Pollock (1912–1956)
14
Fractal flames (http://electricsheep.org/)
15
To create beauty (http://electricsheep.org/)
16
17
Why atoms are so small?
In his 1945 book what is life? Schrödinger asked the above question.
The answer is that the high level of organization necessary for life is only possible in a macroscopesystem; otherwise the order would be destroyed by microscope fluctuations.
Atoms > molecules > cells >tissues > organs > body
18
The fine structure creates soul in terms of
Christopher Alexander
Geometric order vs structural order
19
20
21
22
23
Hidden order: Watts Towers
24
Hidden order: Watts Towers (detailed looks)
25
26
27
A power law and its cousins
28
xy lnln
xy
Head/tail division rule
Given a variable x, if its values follow a heavy tailed distribution, then the mean of x can divide all the values into two parts: those above the mean in the head and those below the mean in the tail (Jiang and Liu 2012).
29
Head/tail movement
AT&T Britinica National mapping agency
Skype Wikipedia OpenStreetMap
30
Head/tail breaks
Iteratively apply the head/tail division rule to dataset with a heavy tailed distribution, untill the data in head is no longer heavy tailed distributed, or specifically, the number in the head is no longer a minority (e.g., < 40%).
Both the number of classes and class intervals are automatically or naturally determined.
For example, four classes: [min, m1), [m1, m2), [m2, m3), [m3, max].
Head/tail breaks is more natural than natural breaks.
31
Why more natural than natural breaks?
Reflects human binary thinking. Captures the scaling pattern of the data Both the number of classes and class intervals
are automatically or naturally determined. Reflects figure/ground perception. Essence of nature is ”far more small things than
large ones”.
32
Computing the image of the city
Step 1: organize all city artifacts layer by layer Step 2: all the city artifacts must be organized in
terms of city artifacts rather than geometric primitives such as points, lines and polygons
Step 3: rank the city artifacts of the same type from the largest to the smallest
Step 4: partition all the artifacts into two categories: those below the mean (in the tail) and those above the mean (in the head)
Step 5: continue step 4 until the artifacts in the head are non longer heavy tailed
33
34
Far more short streets than large ones
35
36
37
Conclusion
The image of the city is computable. This is based on the assumption that the city
holds the living structure or scaling pattern –far more small things than large ones.
The image of the city arise out of the underlying scaling.
Legibility and imageability are measurable. My proposal relies on increasing availablity of
geographic information on cities (e.g., GPS trajectories etc.).
38
Thank you very much!!!
Questions and comments?
39