1
LEGAL AID CLINICS IN INDIA AND THE UNITED STATES – SERVICE LEARNING AND SOCIAL JUSTICE
By:
Sumit Kapoor
LL.B(Hons.), Final Year
Law School, Banaras Hindu University
2
Team 1: Access to justice
Amit Singh Dheeraj Singhal
Team 2: L.A.C in USA Meenakshi Dutta Varsha Srivastava
Team 3: L.A.C in India Abhinav Mishra Tarun Bhowmik
Team 4: Conducting Surveys Sumit Kapoor (Student Coordinator) Arpit Sharma Hriday Pratap Singh Hunter Ehwart (Missouri, U.S.A)
2 ProfessorsProf. David TushausDr. S.K.Gupta
10Student
Volunteers divided in 4 Teams
TEAM
3
SOCIAL JUSTICE & LEGAL AID CLINICS
Social Justice
Marginalised people are
given assistance.
Making concept of Access to
Justice meaningful.
Bring supressed
issues to light.Provide Legal Awareness.
Equal Access to laws,
policies and Basic Rights.
Helps society as well as court and
reduce litigation.
4
FOCUS OF TEAMS
Team 2: Legal Aid Clinics in USA L.A.C in USA an overview.
Historical background of L.A.C in USA
Characteristics of L.A.C in USA.
Coordination with other teams.
Team 1: Access to Justice Access to justice issues in India and USA.
Legal needs of the poor.
How Legal Aid Clinics are meeting need of poor's
Lack of Legal Aid Clinics present work in this area.
Cont..
5
FOCUS OF TEAMSC O N T I N U E …
Team 3: Legal Aid Clinics in USA L.A.C in India an overview.
Historical background of L.A.C in India
Characteristics of L.A.C in India.
Team4: Research and Survey Development of questionnaire.
Preparation & Dissemination of surveys.
Storing and analysis of survey results.
Coordination with other teams.
6
Pre-Development stage:
Understanding need for L.A.C in Law schools.
Analyzing L.A.C in Law School, BHU its importance and shortcomings.
Analyzing of NLSA (Legal Aid Clinic) Regulations, 2011.
Regular talks with Prof. D. Tushaus and L.A.C In charge at Law School, BHU
Development stage:
Division of questionnaire in 4 stages.
1. General Information2. Legal Aid Clinic
Information3. Opinion on Legal Aid
Clinics.4. Legal Aid Clinic
Support
Inclusion of objective andsubjective questions.
Developmentof Questionnaire
7
Creating Database & Dissemination of
questionnaire
Creating Database of Law Schools in India Collecting e-mail id and phone numbers of LAC in charge in
Law schools. Making calls and surfing website of Law Schools. Around 900 colleges database created.
Dissemination of Survey Coordinating with IT Department of Missouri western state
university. Online sending of questionnaire through e-mail and
completion of survey. Intimation via Regular reminders and calls.
8
Storage of Data&
Coordination among teams
Drive was
used
Extensivel
y
Every Team member uploaded
his work on Google drive.
Different folders on drive made
it convenient to use.
Every Member was able to
review work of other on drive.
Drive helped in storage of data
at one place.
SNAP SHOT OF DRIVE
9
PARTICIPANTS
0
2
4
6
8
10
1 12 2
5
21 1
5
1
10
1 1 1
Participant Colleges
Survey was sent to more than 600 Institutions delivering legal education in India.
35 colleges participated in survey.
Small Response rate is disappointing.
Around 10 National Law Schools Participated.
Participants from 14 states completed survey.
10
TEACHERS SERVING IN LEGAL AID CLINICS
Teacher’s Supervising LAC
0-3 4-6. 7-9. 9-12.05
10152025
25
7
0 1
Colleges
On average 3 – 5 Teachers are serving Legal Aid Clinics.
Satisfactory situation with regard to number of teachers.
Actual Participation in working of LAC is required.
11
STUDENTS IN LEGAL AID CLINICS
Student Volunteer in LAC
0-20 20-40 40-60 60-80 80-100
0
10
2020
5 5 2 1
Number of hours Volunteer serve LAC
0-3. 4-6. 7-9. 10-12.
0
5
10
15 13 12
16
On Average 30 – 40 students volunteer.
Many Law Schools have more than 60 student Volunteers.
Average time spent in LAC is 4 – 6 Hours.
In many Law Schools volunteer serve for 10 – 12 Hours per week.
1
2
12
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO LEGAL AID CLINICS
Financial Assistance Received by LAC
8
23
2
Yes No Uncertain
Maximum number of Legal Aid Clinics Lacks financial Assistance.
Major reason for operational Legal Aid Clinics.
13
Statements to which Participants Agreed.
SA: Strongly; Agree A: Agree; N: Neutral
Alumni can be of great help to LAC. (11 SA, 23 A)
LAC enhances lawyering skills of law students. (18 SA, 15 A)
LAC is an effective tool to provide Social Justice. (27 SA, 6 A, 1N)
LAC should be a subject for elective credit in the law curriculum. (14 SA, 18 A)
Funding of LAC is a key issue in its effectiveness. (16 SA, 11 A, 6 N
14
Justice Delivery System and Role Legal Aid Clinics can play.
Strongly Agree
Agree Neutral0
10
20
30
27 29
20 LAC should assist
Local Gram Panchyats.
LAC can play an important role in assisting Lok adalats.
15
Mixed and Negative Opinion
SA: Strongly; Agree A: Agree; N: Neutral; D: Disagree; SD: Strongly Disagree
12 SD12 D
• Poor people are aware of LAC.
3 SD22 D
• Students are overburdened by serving in LAC.
Disagree
LAC should confine itself only to give advice to its clients. (SA:10; A: 9; D:9; SD:5)
There is a lack of commitment among the LAC members. (A:17; D:10)
Faculty serving at LAC should be allowed to plead clients.(SA:3; A:14; N:11 ; D:5)
Mixed
16
Community Education Programs by Legal Aid Clinics
26
5
1
LAC’s Providing Community Ed-ucational Programs
Yes No Uncertain
This is a positive sign in providing social justice via LAC in Law Schools.
Anti-Ragging Campaign, group discussions and small Seminars for creating legal awareness.
Working for Juvenile Homes, conducting RTI awareness workshop in collaboration with local NGO’s.
Legal Literacy Camps, Community based research projects, Para-legal Training,
17
NALSA REGULATIONS, 2011 IMPLEMENTATION IN LEGAL AID CLINICS IN LAW SCHOOLS
Awareness about NALSA Rules.
Contact for establishment of LAC by N/S/DLASA.
31
3
Yes No
13
20
Yes No
1
2
18
ASSISTANCE BY N/S/DLSA TO LEGAL AID CLINICS
Technical Assistance to LAC’s by N/S/DLSA
3
29
Yes No
1
2
Financial Assistance to LAC’s in Law Schools by N/S/DLSA
1
33
Yes No
19
How to strengthen the activities of the Legal Aid Clinics in Law Schools?
Clinical components must be introduced in papers such as
ADR, Family Law etc.
Strict implementation of NALSA Rules, 2011 &
Development of Infrastructure.
Developing strong network, create online
forum for expert opinion on legal problems.
All the students must compulsorily serve LAC
at least for a year.(Most Probably in Final
Year)
Need of strong support from the
academic institution,
government bodies and above all BCI.
20
LEGAL AID CLINICS &
ROAD AHEAD Need to do something more than mere
advice.
Assisting Local Gram Panchayats & Lok adalats to
resolve the Disputes at village level.
Get involved in client counselling, in various
alternative dispute resolution process such as mediation
etc.
Play an active role in providing legal representation
in consumer forum, commissions and family
courts.
Coordinate with NGO’s, Social service groups, Local
Advocates & DLSA to work at grass root level.
LEGAL AWARENESS
21
THANK YOU