MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 1
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
2
L11 – Order-pickingMTTN25 – Warehousing and Materials Handling
Joakim KembroEngineering Logistics
Lund University2010-09-21
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
3
Warehousing and Materials Handling
Receiving StoragePut-away Pick Pack, Ship
EquipmentRacks & ShelvesHandling & TransportationAutomationMobile picking
Activity ProfilingMeasurement &Statistical analysis of Warehouse activity / Data Mining
OptimizationmodelsPick-pathsInclusion of SKU in FPALane depth & slotting
LayoutLocation of receiving & shippingAisle configuration,Stack heightForward Pick Area
BenchmarkingPerformancemeasurement
ISIT/WMSSupport the operation withspace allocation, routeplanning, consolidatedpicking and statistics
Labor ManagementSchedulingFT vs. TempsSafety regulationsUnion rules
Tools &Techniques
Processes
Resources
L11
L13
L15L11
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
4
Learning objectives
• Learn what order picking methods that are available• Understand some basic picking ergonomics• Understand advantages and disadvantages of different order
picking methods• Understand the benefits of pick-path optimization and how it is
done
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
5
Content
• Order-picking
• Ergonomics and street-smart
• Picking methods
• Pick-path optimization
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 2
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
6
Today’s focus: Order-picking
• Order-picking intensive warehouses:– Amazon.com– Adlibris.com– CDON.com– ICA (fruit & vegetables)– Elektroskandia (e.g. Cylinda)
Receiving StoragePut-away Pick Pack, Ship
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
7
Operating cost distribution in a typical warehouse (CapEx vs. OpEx)
Source: Frazelle, (2002) World-Class Warehousing and Material Handling, Figure 8-1, p.148
Order picking; 50%
Shipping; 15%
Receiving; 15%
Put‐away/ Storage; 20%
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
8
A customer order is picked and packed in order to later ship it
Customer orderCustomer: Store AB
Item Quantity
Screw 3
Cord 5 m
Plug 50
Pick orderNo: A623-432
Pick Item Quantity Aisle Position Shelf1 Screw 3 12 5 B2 Cord 5 m 14 7 A
3 Plug 50 16 3 A
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
9
We have three different types of picking in a warehouse
Receiving
Sorting
Unitizing
Shipping
Crossdock
Carton pick
Pallets
CartonsEach pick
Cartons
Eaches
Pallet reserve
Pallets
Pallets
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 3
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
10
Order-picking activities and time?
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
11
Order-picking activities and time
Activity % Order-picking time
Traveling 55%
Searching 15%
Extracting 10%
Paperwork and other activities 20%
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
12
Pick with cart
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
13
Picking small items
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 4
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
14
Picking to belt with pick to light
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
15
Pick to pallet
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
16
Picking from the 2nd level
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
17
Content
• Order-picking
• Ergonomics and street-smart
• Picking methods
• Pick-path optimization
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 5
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
18
Ergonomics: Placing the most frequently requested items on the best height
The Golden Zone
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
19
Ergonomics: Pick from pallet2. Pick from side1. Elevated floor
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
20
Warehouse street-smart
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
21
Warehouse street-smart
21
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 6
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
22
Warehouse street-smart
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
23
Content
• Order-picking
• Ergonomics and street-smart
• Picking methods
• Pick-path optimization
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
24
Picking methods
Order picking methods ‐ retrieval
Employing humans Employing machines
Picker‐to‐parts Parts‐to‐picker Automated picking Picking robots
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
25
Description of methods
• Basic order picking:– Operations with a small number of orders and high number of
picks per order• Batch picking / Multi-order picking:
– Operations with a large number of orders and low picks per order
• Zone picking:– Operations with high total numbers of SKUs, high total numbers
of orders, and low to moderate picks per order• Wave picking:
– Operations with high total number of SKUs and moderate/high picks per order
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 7
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
26
Full orders / Zone picking
Order picking method
Full order picking Zone picking(Partial order picking)
Buffer
Zon B Zon A
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
27
Basic order picking
• Product stored in fixed locations on shelves or pallet rack • One order at a time following a route up and down each aisle• Design of the picking flow should be such that the order
picker ends up fairly close to the original starting point• Picking document should have the picks sorted in the same
sequence as the picking flow• Work well in operations with a small total number of orders
and a high number of picks per order• Operations with low picks per order will find the travel time
excessive in this type of picking• Operations with large numbers of orders will experience
congestion from many pickers working in the same areas
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
28
Batch picking / Multi-order picking
• Multiple orders are grouped into small batches• Order picker will pick all orders within the batch in one pass
using a consolidated pick list• Usually the picker will use a multi-tiered picking cart
maintaining a separate carton on the cart for each order. • Batch sizes usually run from 4 to 12 orders per batch
depending on the average picks per order in that specific operation.
• Batch picking systems may use extensive logic programmed to consolidate orders with the same items
• Batch picking can greatly reduce travel time by allowing the picker to make additional picks while in the same area
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
29
Picking all the items for one order
Full order picking
Single order picking Batch picking
+
• Fast to pick one order
• Easy to keep track
• Less room for errors
-
• Low efficiency (A lot of transport)
+
• High efficiency (Less transport)
-
• More room for errors
• Need to keep track of progress
One order at a time
Several orders at a time
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 8
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
30
Partial order picking (zone picking)
+• No congestion – Only one picker per zone• Picker learn zone
– Faster routing– Knowledge about details
-• Work with balancing zones• Unbalances always occur between pickers• Buffers between zones are needed• No traceability for finding errors
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
31
Different forms of zone picking
Progressive assembly
A B C
An order passes through zones in a specified order
Downstream sortation
A B C
Sortation
Each zone work independent with its specific items on each order:•It’s fast to get an order through•Requires expensive sorting after the picking•No risk for starvation between zones
Wave picking
A B C
Sortation
Zones are synchronized so that pickers work in a wave:•It’s fast to get an order through•Can reduce the need for sortation•Zones have to wait for each other
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
32
Zone picking in detail
• Picking area is broken up into pick zones (assembly lines)• Order pickers are assigned a specific zone, and only pick
items within that zone• Orders are moved from one zone to the next as the picking
from the previous zone is completed• Conveyor systems are used to move orders from zone to
zone• Important to balance the number of picks per zone to
maintain a consistent flow • Separate zones provide for specialization of picking
techniques (automated handling in one and manual handling in the next)
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
33
Wave picking in detail
• Rather than orders moving from one zone to the next for picking, all zones are picked at the same time
• Items are later sorted and consolidated into individual orders/shipments
• Wave picking is the quickest method (shortest cycle time) for picking multi-item orders
• Wave picking may be used to isolate orders by specific carriers, routes, or zones
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 9
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
34
Content
• Order-picking
• Ergonomics and street-smart
• Picking methods
• Pick-path optimization
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
35
Travel time to retrieve an order is a direct expense
• Largest component of labor in a typical distribution center• Travel time is waste (no value added)• Affects customer service (faster retrieval, better service)• Order picking for only 2–4 SKUs and a few locations:
– Sequence locations to be visited to minimize travel– Solved for each trip an order picker must make into the
warehouse– Unlike the fast-pick area, where the general path of travel is
common and known in advance– Pick-path optimization becomes very important
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
36
The problem of pick-path optimization
• Visiting a given set of locations as quickly as possible: “Traveling Salesman Problem”
• TSP is difficult in several senses:– There is no known fast solution technique that works in general– Randomly-generated instances, even small ones, can be
surprisingly time-consuming to solve– Optimum, or even good solutions can be complex and hard to
describe• NP-hard problem• Solving by complete enumeration
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
37
Traveling salesperson problem (TSP)
• A classic operations research problem• Applies to pick-path optimization• Usually last-mile to customer• Extended version referred to as the Vehicle Routing Problem
(VRP)
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 10
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
38
Denoting the TSP
• G = (N,A)– N, set of nodes– A, set of arcs
• Each arc (i,j) in A is associated with:– cij, traveling cost per unit flow (symmetric)– xij, 1 if arc is traversed, otherwise 0
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
39
Example: Pick-path optimization
cij 1 2 3 4
1 0 4 3 4
2 4 0 2 4
3 3 2 0 1
4 4 4 1 0
Distance matrix Network
11
22
44
33
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
40
Beehive
• Shortest path between the different locations• Groups of 2• 2 minutes• Prepare to give an answer
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
41
Example: Short-haul transportation planning
cij 1 2 3 4
1 0 4 3 4
2 4 0 2 4
3 3 2 0 1
4 4 4 1 0
Distance matrix Network
11
22
44
33
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 11
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
42
Order-retrieval in a warehouse presents a special case of the TSP
• Travel is constrained by aisles and this special structure makes it possible to find optimal solutions quickly by computer
• Most WMSs do not support pick-path optimization:– Geometric layout of the warehouse (including distances between
all pairs of storage locations)– Time-consuming to gather– Problem of communicating the path to the picker– WMS tells the picker only the sequence of locations, not the
actual path to follow
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
43
Short travel paths that are realizable by an order picker without a detailed warehouse map
• Find an efficient global path to visit all the storage locations of a warehouse
• Sort pick lines on a customer order by storage location so that they appear in the same sequence as the efficient global path
• Global path is efficient => – The sub-path induced on each customer order is likely to be
efficient
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
44
Path outlines
• A good global path should:– Induce short sub-paths on the customer orders, – Help the picker visualize the next location and how to travel
there most directly• Three commonly found path outlines:
– Along a single aisle– Through static shelving is the so-called serpentine pick path– The branch-and-pick, which sequences only the aisles and not
the locations within an aisle• Store popular SKUs close to the path outline, so that they can
be reached with little or no detour• Store SKUs according to affinity
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
45
Pick-path optimization
• Restrict the picker to revisit a previously-visited aisle• Each order-picker can be imagined to follow this rule:
– Pick all the required items from the current aisle and travel forward to the next aisle
• Two ways of traveling to the next aisle:– Travel all the way through the current aisle– Enter the aisle only as far as necessary to pick all required items
therein and then return to the same end of the aisle
MTTN25 2011‐09‐21
Warehousing and Materials Handling 12
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
46
Learning objectives
• Learn what order picking methods that are available• Understand some basic picking ergonomics• Understand advantages and disadvantages of different order
picking methods• Understand the benefits of pick-path optimization and how it is
done
LUNDS UNIVERSITETLUNDS UNIVERSITET
47
Thank you for today!
Joakim KembroPhD Candidate
Department of Industrial Management and Logistics
Box 118, SE-221 00 LUND, SwedenVisiting address Ole Römers väg 1, Lund
Phone +46 46 222 33 27Fax +4 46 222 46 15
E-mail [email protected]