1
The Smart Transmission Grid
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
Lou Fusco Director
Engineering and Technology
2
Energy services to 15 MM people (1 in 21 Americans)
• 5.1 MM Electric customer accounts
• 4.3 MM Natural Gas customer accounts
70,000 square miles with diverse topography
20,000 employees
A regulated investor-owned utility
Ranked the greenest utility in the United States
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
3 Reliable Service
Reasonable Cost
Smart Grid
Environmental Sustainability
Balancing Competing Priorities
4
A Smart Grid
Power Plants
Transmission Networks
Substations Distribution Networks
Consumers
Overlay with intelligence and automation
Sense Communicate Compute Control
5
A Dynamic Balance Of Resources
Renewable Resources Balancing Resources
Smart Grid
6
Transmission System Applications
Advanced Protection & Control System
Remedial Action Scheme (RAS)
Substation Automation Substation Modular Protection and Control (MPAC)
7
Pacific Intertie – AC RAS Pacific Intertie is a critical infrastructure for stabilizing the Western North American power grid
• Three AC lines and one HVDC line
• Largest single electricity transmission program in the United States
• Capable of transmitting up to 7,900 MW: 4,800 MW on AC; 3,100 MW on DC
AC Intertie Remedial Action Scheme (RAS) • Collects data in the substation
• Modulates data onto multiple carriers
• Transmits data to central location
• Demodulates data
• Connects data to two controllers
8
Pacific Intertie RAS
• Trips “Armed” Generation
• Trips Interties
• Insert “Chief Joe” Braking Resistor
• Suspends Automatic Generation Control
• Reactive Devices capacitors and reactors
• Trips “Firm” load
• Trips “Pump” load
Initiates NE/SE Separation
Western Electric Coordinating Council
9
RAS: An Effective But Aging System
In operation since late 1980’s
Very high reliability/availability >99.995
Enables significant increase in grid transfer limit capability (approx 3600 MW)
Protects WECC area from widespread system outages, system collapse and total blackouts
Advantages of new devices & digital paths Include:
• Synchronized RAS systems
• Same data is sent to two places
• Sustained stable RAS performance
• Minimized substation design work and maintenance
• Obsolescence of the substation devices is systematic and uniform
Today’s System
10
New RAS Requirements
Capture the real-time power system state: Flows, frequency, angle, temperature, wind speed, and statuses
Minimize use of transducers to gain accuracy
Transmit measured values to multiple remote locations
Receive and transmit to remote sites, and execute any control actions determined by the controller
Have power system information available at a monitored location for future activation
Perform automatic self diagnostics
11
System Architecture
Upgraded hardware with backup at remote location
AS IS: Obsolete hardware TO BE: Redundancy at single site
12
Messaged Versus Hardwired
Advantages: • Replace local control wiring with IED relays and data
communications via LANs
• No need for periodic testing (devices communicate continuously)
• Minimizes hardware installation
• Saves space
• Provides almost endless expansion capabilities
• No need to update wiring diagrams
• No contacts, debounce filtering, not prone to noise
13
Interactive HMI
14
Success
New C&D Systems operational 4/29/2010
Project started in June 2006
Project cost $12M under budget
No injuries or mis-operations
RAS A&B systems in San Francisco scheduled for replacement
Extensive testing performed
15
Substation Automation
Need for a cost effective, state of the art, replacement strategy for substation automation and protection
Provide interface to a consolidated grid control center, operated by an Energy Management System
Modular Protection Automation and Control (MPAC) created to implement our vision
16
MPAC Success
Deployed MPAC since 2005 with ~50 buildings on sites
Plan to install another 60-70 in the next 5-6 years as part of the transmission system modernization efforts
Key metrics:
1. Cost saving (20% reduction)
2. Procurement schedule (40% reduction)
3. Delivery schedule (38% reduction)
4. Terminal clearance schedule (60% reduction)
5. Project schedule to Operational (23%)
17
MPAC Benefits
Improved Reliability:
Replace deficient protection schemes
Improve visibility, controllability and accuracy for the operators
Improve ability to remotely control equipment to speed restoration
Improved Efficiency:
Replace obsolete control room equipment
Reduced need to clear relay terminals for maintenance
Improve major equipment maintenance triggers
Replace equipment on a wholesale approach
18
MPAC Benefits
Cost Savings:
Reduced cost to engineer, construct, and maintain
Reduce protection scheme maintenance
Improved Safety and Environmental Performance:
Provide remote control
Minimize exposure to employees on existing panels and buildings
Improved Compliance:
Improved ability to evaluate and analysis system events
19
Legacy Control Center Equipment
20
MPAC Interior
21
MPAC Exterior
22
At PG&E, We Are Committed To Sustainability