JAMM 100JAMM 100 11
Media Ethics, Part 2Media Ethics, Part 2
How professional codes How professional codes guide journalists’ guide journalists’ behaviorbehavior
JAMM 100JAMM 100 22
Schedule UpdateSchedule Update
Today: Ethics, Part 2Today: Ethics, Part 2 Friday: Guest speakerFriday: Guest speaker
– Ted Warren, The Associated PressTed Warren, The Associated Press– Photojournalism in the digital eraPhotojournalism in the digital era
Next week: Media LawNext week: Media Law
JAMM 100JAMM 100 33
Calculating your gradeCalculating your grade
3 exams @ 100 = 3003 exams @ 100 = 300 1 paper @ 30 = 301 paper @ 30 = 30 Clicker quizzes: 20 @ 10 = 40Clicker quizzes: 20 @ 10 = 40 Total points so far:Total points so far: 340340
Still to come: 1 paper, 1 exam, extra creditStill to come: 1 paper, 1 exam, extra credit
Total points for semester: 500Total points for semester: 500
JAMM 100JAMM 100 44
Student Course EvaluationsStudent Course Evaluations
On-line at: On-line at: http://www.webs.uidaho.edu/studentevals/
Please be constructive, specific in Please be constructive, specific in responses to open-ended questionsresponses to open-ended questions
Surveys are anonymous, confidentialSurveys are anonymous, confidential Last day to participate: Sunday, Dec. 12Last day to participate: Sunday, Dec. 12
JAMM 100JAMM 100 55
Clicker Quiz #1Clicker Quiz #1
Which philosopher advocated the Golden Which philosopher advocated the Golden Mean, which suggests moderation Mean, which suggests moderation between extremes?between extremes?
a) Socratesa) Socrates
b) Sophoclesb) Sophocles
c) Platoc) Plato
d) Aristotled) Aristotle
e) Thucydidese) Thucydides
JAMM 100JAMM 100 66
Clicker Quiz #1Clicker Quiz #1
Which philosopher advocated the Golden Which philosopher advocated the Golden Mean, which suggests moderation Mean, which suggests moderation between extremes?between extremes?
d) Aristotled) Aristotle
JAMM 100JAMM 100 77
Ethics: EnforcementEthics: Enforcement
Journalists aren’t licensed, so face no Journalists aren’t licensed, so face no formal sanctions for unethical actsformal sanctions for unethical acts
Many groups have ethics codes, but Many groups have ethics codes, but lack enforcement powerlack enforcement power
Peer pressure, public embarrassment Peer pressure, public embarrassment are only consequences for violationsare only consequences for violations
JAMM 100JAMM 100 88
Professional CodesProfessional Codes
Radio-TV News Directors AssociationRadio-TV News Directors Association American Advertising FederationAmerican Advertising Federation Society of Professional JournalistsSociety of Professional Journalists Public Relations Society of AmericaPublic Relations Society of America
JAMM 100JAMM 100 99
Code of EthicsCode of Ethics
Public Relations Society of AmericaPublic Relations Society of America Act as responsible advocatesAct as responsible advocates Provide a voice in Provide a voice in marketplace of ideasmarketplace of ideas Adhere to highest standards of accuracy, Adhere to highest standards of accuracy,
truthtruth
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1010
SPJ Code of EthicsSPJ Code of Ethics
Society of Professional JournalistsSociety of Professional Journalists Seek truth and report itSeek truth and report it Minimize harmMinimize harm Act independentlyAct independently Be accountableBe accountable
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1111
Common ethical violationsCommon ethical violations
SensationalismSensationalism Conflict of interestConflict of interest FakeryFakery PlagiarismPlagiarism
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1212
FakeryFakery
1992: Dateline NBC1992: Dateline NBC– Report on safety of Chevrolet trucksReport on safety of Chevrolet trucks
Claim: side-mounted fuel tanks prone to Claim: side-mounted fuel tanks prone to explode in collisionexplode in collision
NBC rigged gas tanks with ignitersNBC rigged gas tanks with igniters Video showed fuel spill, flames Video showed fuel spill, flames
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1313
1992: NBC1992: NBC
VIDEO: VIDEO: When Good Journalists Do Bad When Good Journalists Do Bad Things: Truthtelling & the Public TrustThings: Truthtelling & the Public Trust
Poynter Institute: Poynter Institute: www.poynter.org
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1414
1992: NBC1992: NBC
GM filed lawsuit; lawyers negotiatedGM filed lawsuit; lawyers negotiated NBC retracted story, apologizedNBC retracted story, apologized NBC News President Michael NBC News President Michael
Gartner resignedGartner resigned GM used PR strategy for crisis GM used PR strategy for crisis
managementmanagement
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1515
PlagiarismPlagiarism
The act of taking ideas, thoughts The act of taking ideas, thoughts or words from another and or words from another and passing them off as your ownpassing them off as your own
Closely related to Closely related to fabricationfabrication (making up stories, facts, quotes)(making up stories, facts, quotes)
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1616
Plagiarism: Case studiesPlagiarism: Case studies
1981: Janet Cooke1981: Janet Cooke 1998: Stephen Glass1998: Stephen Glass 2003: Jayson Blair2003: Jayson Blair
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1717
Janet CookeJanet Cooke
Washington Post, 1981Washington Post, 1981 ‘‘Jimmy’s World’Jimmy’s World’ 8-year-old heroin 8-year-old heroin
addictaddict Illustrated urban drug Illustrated urban drug
problems in D.C.problems in D.C. Cooke won PulitzerCooke won Pulitzer
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1818
Janet CookeJanet Cooke
Problems Problems with ‘Jimmy’s with ‘Jimmy’s World’:World’:
Jimmy didn’t existJimmy didn’t exist Story couldn’t be Story couldn’t be
verifiedverified Post returned PulitzerPost returned Pulitzer Cooke resignedCooke resigned
JAMM 100JAMM 100 1919
Stephen GlassStephen Glass
Writer for Writer for The New The New RepublicRepublic
Fabricated dozens of Fabricated dozens of stories, 1997-1998stories, 1997-1998
Subject of movie Subject of movie (2003): (2003): Shattered Shattered GlassGlass
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nA4N9ex56jA
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2020
Jayson BlairJayson Blair
New York TimesNew York Times Fabricated storiesFabricated stories
– Cut and pasted from Cut and pasted from other newspapers’ other newspapers’ Web sitesWeb sites
– Made up sources & Made up sources & descriptionsdescriptions
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2121
Jayson BlairJayson Blair
Resigned May, 2003Resigned May, 2003 Blamed Blamed TimesTimes editors editors Interview with Katie Interview with Katie
Couric, 2004Couric, 2004 http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/211
34540/vp/4455995#4455995
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2222
Fallout from Blair AffairFallout from Blair Affair
2 top editors 2 top editors resignedresigned
Times appointed Times appointed ombudsmanombudsman to to improve credibilityimprove credibility
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2323
Holding the media accountableHolding the media accountable
1.1. Ombudsmen (or women)Ombudsmen (or women)
2.2. Journalism reviewsJournalism reviews
3.3. Watchdog groupsWatchdog groups
4.4. News councilsNews councils
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2424
OmbudsmanOmbudsman
Staff member Staff member assigned to hear, assigned to hear, respond to audience respond to audience complaintscomplaints
Original purpose: Original purpose: government position government position in Swedenin Sweden
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2525
OmbudsmanOmbudsman
Also known as:Also known as: Ombuds officerOmbuds officer Reader representativeReader representative Reader advocateReader advocate Public editor (Public editor (New York TimesNew York Times))
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2626
www.newsombudsmen.orgwww.newsombudsmen.org
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2727
Journalism reviewsJournalism reviews
Columbia Journalism Columbia Journalism Review (CJR)Review (CJR)
American Journalism American Journalism Review (AJR)Review (AJR)
Quill (published by Quill (published by SPJ)SPJ)
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2828
Watchdog groupsWatchdog groups
Founded in 1986 by Jeff CohenFounded in 1986 by Jeff Cohen Believes corporate media has Believes corporate media has
conservative biasconservative bias Monthly magazine: Monthly magazine: Extra!Extra!
JAMM 100JAMM 100 2929
Watchdog groupsWatchdog groups
Media Research CenterMedia Research Center Conservative group Conservative group
founded by Brent founded by Brent Bozell, 1987Bozell, 1987
Believes media have Believes media have liberal biasliberal bias
JAMM 100JAMM 100 3030
NewsNews Councils Councils City or state groupsCity or state groups Public & media Public & media
membersmembers Review complaints Review complaints
& issue reports& issue reports No enforcement No enforcement
powers except powers except public opinionpublic opinion
JAMM 100JAMM 100 3131
News CouncilsNews Councils
Mission:Mission: To help maintain public trust To help maintain public trust and confidence in the news media … and confidence in the news media … by creating a forum where the public by creating a forum where the public and the news media can engage each and the news media can engage each other in examining standards of other in examining standards of journalistic fairness.journalistic fairness. www.wanewscouncil.orgwww.wanewscouncil.org
JAMM 100JAMM 100 3232
Clicker Quiz #2Clicker Quiz #2
Which of the SPJ ethical standards Which of the SPJ ethical standards did NBC violate with the Dateline did NBC violate with the Dateline report?report?
a.a. Seek truth and report itSeek truth and report it
b.b. Minimize harmMinimize harm
c.c. Act independentlyAct independently
d.d. Be accountableBe accountable