7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
1/24
P r e c a r i o u s J a Pa n
a n n e a l l i s o n
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
2/24
P r e c a r i o u s J a Pa n
Du Univsiy ss Duha an Lnn 203
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
3/24
203 Du Univsiy ss
ihs sv
in in h Uni as ica n aci- pap Dsin by uny Lih a. yps in Minin by sn nain yss, nc.
Libay nss aain-in-ubicain Daa
isn, nn, 950
caius Japan / nn isn.
pas c
ncus bibiaphica ncs an inx.
ISBN 978-0-8223-5548-9 (ch : a. pap)
ISBN 978-0-8223-5562-5 (pb. : a. pap)
. JapanEcnic cniins989 2. Japancia cniins989 . i.
HC462.95.A45 203
952.05c23 20308903
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
4/24
C o n t e n t s
Aowldgms vii
o n e . P a i n o f L i f e
t w o . f r o m L i f e L o n g t o L i q u i d J a P a n
2
t h r e e . o r d i n a r y r e f u g e e i s m :
P o v e r t y, P r e C a r i t y , y o u t h
43
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
5/24
f o u r . h o m e a n d h o P e
77
f i v e . t h e s o C i a L B o d y i n L i f e a n d d e a t h22
s i x . C u L t i v at i n g f i e L d s f r o m t h e e d g e s
66
s e v e n . i n t h e m u d
80
Nos 207 Rfs 29 Idx 23
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
6/24
a C k n o w L e d g m e n t s
Tis bn pain an pcaiusnss, su an hphas bn as
ha as i has bn suu i. a paicuay au h-
hs h hav ivn avic, supp, an hp an h ay.
Kn Wiss has bn in iau ih abu his pjc isincpin. s y i a Du Univsiy ss an, ipany,
as a ind, h has hlpd gmina and susain h ni pjc. F
his uianc an bi in , a p hans. Oin an has a vy-
hinuip isan avis, supp, an p as ny h
can. can iain havin cp his ihu hi. Davi a has
bn qui iay in h nchs ih in Japan, ivin xainay
assisanc and wisdm vy sip and iain. F his gnsiy
an sas, a py au. Yshi Kua is a in h has hp in vy pssib ay uin ips Japan. h is savvy an in,
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
7/24
ACkNowledgmeNtS viii
sucu an un, an y b h uns p. Ki ishiua has
bn a nuy sucu sach assisan in bh y an Du-
ha. han h hpin in s any ays.
hav an uch h any ih h hav sha y
na in cnvsains n sha pics ins. n paicua,
ish han: ian Gsn ( a hs aazin chas an sus-
ins), auia Knz ( bin y iin pan), Laun an (
h sunning wk and u cnvsains n aachmn, pcaiy, and
snsing), Lay Gssbg ( his indship and u pndings abu
ac, pcaiy, an h piica), Kahy Ruy ( h supp an u
wndul alks abu vyhing), ay aunian ( bing such
an inspiain an n in such a n i), n Kab an
J nivi ( h siuain u pcaius ain up), KahiWs ( ain an ain abu , hp, an pcaiy), an au-
c ( his biian cass n pcaiy), i Ya ( u vy u-
ings in Japan and bing such a gd cllagu), Michal ad (
his avic abu his pjc an h buny his ), as Maza
( a u icius chas an u cass n nhpy caiy
an c), an h vini ( h u ush h ha has
bn such an inspiain y n). F hi supp in siciin
ncuain y as han: na Muhbach, izan hsan,ic Ln, nia M, hih asua, aa an, an Vna Das.
F invvin in h Miian 80 n han nnis Ris an
i Miyazai, an hi anizain h ossbl Fuus of Jp
pjc, Fan ain an a Ozai as as a h paicipans. n
a vy spcia hans h vis ous Jp. T an-
ivnss an ca hy av hi as as incib, ain h
ha as in an push uh in in i b. On
y vis va hs a iin ha as h s xai-nay vi hav v a in y i: a pic -nin h b.
Kai a, han yu his i.
as ish han y caus in h Dpan uua n-
hpy a Du hi vyay ciaiy, incua ynais,
and supp; and u xcpinal gadua sudns, and paiculaly
hs h hav sha inss an chas aun pcaiy, paiy,
an hp: Lia a, Yain bai, Juni Kn, au ha, Yas-
min Cho, and Alyssa Miller. As at home, I have been grateul or those whoxn ppuniis spa sh, an h any n-
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
8/24
ACkNowledgmeNtS ix
a inacins v civ hi h. Ts incu (Dpans
nhpy Dpans an nsius Eas sian uis a):
Middlbuy llg, Rishchau Insiu, avad Univsiy, William
and May llg, Univsiy n, ufs Univsiy, Univsiy
Capetown, University o Pittsburgh, Cambridge University, New York Uni-
vsiy, niana Univsiy, p Univsiy Japan, phia Univsiy
in ky, Univsiy h alina mbk, ha n a Ric
Univsiy, Univsiy ba, Univsiy a a u, nsi-
u Ehny a caia inica, aina Univsiy inap,
Bandis Univsiy, Univsiy alinia a Bkly, and Univsi
aFscai.
Givn h nau y pjcn pcaiy in aiy sus ha can
a ah bu as inship an hp as ja in cn-sany snifn hins u n h un ah han in a sysaic
i p-ain pan. as sin u haship in ishin
pp an ncssaiy n sha abu hi n ivs hav an
outsider poke her nose into. And yet many generously helped me, and those
h av invis, invi in hi sphs aciviy ( aciv-
is, pss, pubic spain, vyay i), ypicay i s in h is
hnusy busy schus. aicua hans Yuasa Mah
a in his NPo, Myai, an a i an xnsiv invi,Kiua aih in h pay shs uia an
pn up h h, uzui aayui inucin
his NPo an yuh supp cn in aa an ain h o
o m scn, Kaaa Ki h ah a U o jGna
Yji, Un higki and all h h paicipans h plgy -
sach up a y Univsiy hi nu n hp, Dhi
Masa cin in his acivis sin sina an invv-
n ih h aaya us Fun, suin Kji an a h bs the Kowaremono perormance group, Ochi oshi and Shikimura Yoshiko
hi inship an hspiaiy in aa, Ky van a his
hlp and supp mulipl summs in ky, Kus Kik h
cninu inship, Un hizu inviin in h h, n
h bihay, an invi. n aiin u i han: aiya
Kain, Miyam Michik, Osawa Machik, suumi Waau, Yshimi
hunya, Mi Yshishi, Rbcca Jacbsn, sumi ishi, umazaki
hi, uaaa Yui, aaa , an Kani Mai.Finally, in a bk abu a pcaiusnss ha xnds amily and
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
9/24
ACkNowledgmeNtS x
h, un y n. y sns, a an Davi az, h
a nin hi ay aay h, a s ucy hav h in y
i an b na in a in hi n. y sibins an hi
pans, ucy hav hi ah an sha ca-ivin ih
n anh, an u . y h, ih in u vnin chas
an ai h snh an siinc sh has cai his sa h
li. nd hali, I hank vyhing: ading vy wd,
bin sa abu vn ub hins, an pin y i ss pcai-
us han i u b ihu hi.
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
10/24
o n e . Pa i n o f L i f e
T sy abb h nains anin. T by a y--ya-
an, uiyin aay, as iscv n nh a savin
ah. y an a pubic fcia, h an as inay. u
h i ac in h apan buiin h ca h twenty years. A welare recipient ever since disease kept him rom work, he
as suny uns u b cu . Wih n n un , h an
was dad in h mnhs. ll aln, h kp a diay, pndingpag
a paha h cuny as in ciizns i hi h, su-
in iv, hav n cus bu i. y h n, huh, his huhs
w nly n d. Tis las ny was wha shckd ppl h ms
[] an is a a ic ba (og b) (Yuasa 2008a).
an is an cavin h cus Japans asa pain icball, a symbl li and h culual sul Japan , whn lacking,
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
11/24
CHAPter oNe 2
ah, sin, h u sussnss h is. T sy as chiin.
u, ccuin in Juy 2007, i ca a a n suin ih ns sii-
laly pinnd h cllaps mundan vydaynss livs a nc
bsss ih an hn unu by , huan cnncin, h.
Only n ya ali, xampl, anh cas a mummid bdy
ha bn p in h sa ciyKia Kysh iy. T cicusancs
siia: a i-a an sav ah a an a h. Tis
an ha as bn ni a bu, in his cas, ha nv bn an
i n h gunds ha h had amilyw adul snswh culd d
hi. u aiia ains sain an ny n sn, h
a a cnvninc s, gav his ah d. nd his, as h mdia -
p i, nv aun han an ccasina ba . Unab
wk and (wic) dnid wla, h man livd in an apamn hcun ainain; a uiiis ha bn cu an n han bn pai
nhs hn h i (Yuasa 2008a, 43).
Lie, tenuous and raw, disconnected rom others and surviving or dying
aln; such sis cycl hugh h nws hs days and hugh h
cicuiy inmain, cmmunicain, and ac ha s limn vy-
aynss pp in a psinusia sciy i Japan. i abu
a hss juni hih sch sun (Hmusu gus) bca a
naina bss hn as in Dcb 2007. Win by a auscian (aua ishi),1 i h, a a v an a havin
aay s his h canc, a by cs h n ay a ba-
up apan an a ah h s his chin sipy sca (s).
Dciding nd himsl ah han budn his siblings, amua
has his nihbh pa (nicna shi pa) an ivs, as h
says, like an animal: sleeping inside playground equipment, scavenging or
cins na vnin achins, ain caba an pin (aua
2007). Wha as (in cha s an n a shs an bsis) -a upn s h cpa ais a na i uc
scraping by in a park. Tat, along with the tragic story o amily dissolution
an ahy abannn: ha a his, as auas i ca i, an
nainin sy pvy (hiizu 200829). ic b, visin,
an vi vsins in 2008 an auas s-ca shi pa is
now a tourist site. As one commentator put it, we couldnt imagine a story
i his n yas a, bu n, in vy Japans aiy, h is s un-
happinss (hiizu 20082).T anuish vyay i hs h hav sciay ihan
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
12/24
PAIN o lIe 3
a cndiin said ac a las n millin Japans dayhas bn
an up by pp cuu. Ts iniviuas, ca omo, n ih-
a an ain in a sin hy ay, i v, av. iii
a sciay iscnnc an ach huan cnac: hss a
h, as n hiii scib i (suin 2004). M n a
han a an s cny yun aus, his is h picin ivn
hiiii in nhk osoh sy a univsiy pu h is
nin his uh ya isain. Win by a s-av hiii
as a ay a ny by nv avin h, nhk oso is viviy
bua. Zin in, as s aua, n h aphic ais a u
xisnc, h sy is sai b aisic in capuin h vyay iu-
as, nain bsssins, an paayzin usins a hiii. h
sa i, his s as a nv (2002) an vn in h ana(20047) an ani (2006) vsinshas bn ha as y n-
ainmn. Wih a sylin ha jags bwn ngams, ic wbsis,
suici pacs, an pyai schs, nhk oso as p, ah
xynicay, as nn-sp hiii acin.
T cnacin i in a nuus xisnc spu acin a i-
n in in h su 2008. sin vin aacs, a an
an cnspicuusy pubic, pau y sain in Jun. T s
pac in ihabaa (ys cnics an ou [an] isic) n aunay a nn hn h ss ha bn cs psians. Divin
his uc in h cssin an hn jupin u sab vicis, a
wny-v-ya-ld man killd svn ppl wihin minus. mp-
ay h a h ha s his jb, Ka hi iv a siay,
unsabl li sangd m his pans and lackingas h cmplaind
in h lng ail psings h lf n a wbsivyhing human
wh, including a gilind. Wihu anyhing liv and n plac
call hm (ibasho), Ka wn kihabaa andmly kill. is aci a sis cpyca aacs in pubic sins i as. T p-
pas sha cain i cicusancs ih Ka: siu, jb ins-
cuiy, aiia sann, pcaius xisnc. n hi s
yun, h as aac h su as ci by a svny-nin-
ya- hss an h, sabbin n in hibuya ain sa-
in, sai h iv as b ca pisn h sh u n sh-
an .
Tis vinc as nab h ipsna i as. Ran aacsn sangs by ppl dspaly discnncd hmslvs. Bu sis
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
13/24
CHAPter oNe 4
m inima vilnc a cmmn as wll. Ts ms spcacu-
laly nwswhy hav akn plac wihin amilisha uni assignd,
by sciy an h sa, h spnsibiiy uin caivin an vn
scialiy isl. In h sam mnh h kihabaa killings a svny-
svn-ya- an in y n his ichn an i his i ih
a hamm. ppanly nagd ha sh had calld him a nuisanc, h
man hn pcdd kill h s his hushlda sn, daugh-
in-a, an anchi: his ni bi n ny ca bu huan cn-
tact. As it was reported, this dangerous old man (abunai ojchan) thought
h b happy nc his aiy as a. as iiay a sh ha
c visi, c hi a a, an can his apan ha a n-
a by i his h a ya ai in May. n ha has bn h
psisn nd in amilial aackschildn agains pans and pa-iculaly mhshis n was spcially gusm. Dcapiaing h,
h svnn-ya- hn cai his hs ha ih hi a a-
a cub an a an inn ca. us aan si cayin h
hah by cnss h pic bu cu iv n iv i-
in a h h cai ba n u aains. s h ia p
i, h yuh ha spp in sch abu a nh b an as
ain icain anxiy hich h ha bn biy hspiaiz.
ha, hv, h ha bn a sun. n ac, i as in an a hihy an hih sch ha bh h by an his yun
bh ivin h in an apan aay h.
StorIeS rom tHe vyay h ah sas aiy i. Unas cips
h amilia and uin. disqui bushing h suac wh h all
na can un ay. Mhs bha, sans i, chin
abann, aus sav. Ts cauinay as , an , a
a n unin inscuiyaia, scia, xisnia. u hapcisy hy cauin aains? n, h pin, (h) s n
ain pcin?
tHe APANeSe Are cainly n aln in xpincing pcaiy hs
ays. Tis cniin has bc v aiia an ispa in h
h ny-s cnuy. i in h aah ab pin,
in h ac Gc anin v cs avin h e, an in h is
a nv-nin cnic cisis ha has ny xacba ha as a-ay a isin aphic ba ciizns a is pvy, is-
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
14/24
PAIN o lIe 5
as, unpyn, a. Evyh pp a suin, cauh by h
insabiiis an inquiis niba bais un a. n h acc-
ain, an spa, a a ic ha has pivaiz an
o lie and deregulated more and more o capitalisms engine or extracting
prots, the struggleand ofen ailureo everyday lie has become an all cn sy a any pp aun h .
Givn h xmiy dpivain xpincd by s many h
wlds inhabians day, Japan wuld sm m nabl is vas
ah an ha s say is h s avanc cnsu cuu in h
. Evn ay, as cas a h busin is hihy n-
bubb cny, Japan bass h hi sns cny in h
(havin s h scn psiin cny hina). n any visi-
h has cny bn Japan i n ha pan ss si a bis businss vn picy ban-na s. Y Japan as has
h scn hihs v pvy an h Oanisain Ecnic
-pain an Dvpn (oeCd) b cunis. acua as
h numb ppl wh all blw hal h man incm, Japan
ih a a 5.3 pcnis scn ny h Uni as, hich has
a a 7. pcn. n 2007 his cnsiu ny iin Japans: n
u six. (Tis cpas ih an ava 0.7 pcn in oeCd -
b cunis an 4.5 pcn a cunis i ay.) Fuh, a cuny ha nc pidd isl n lilng mplymn, n- hid
a s ay a ny iuay py. in jbs ha a
pa im, mpay, cnac lab, igula wks lack jb scu-
iy, bns, cn as. supisin 77 pcn an ss han h
pvy v, quaiyin hby h vnns n caibainas
in p. T siuain is vn s n an yuhs; n-
hal o all young workers (between the ages o feen and twenty-our) and
70 pcn a a s a iuay py (Yuasa 2008a).ov, a s spn in Japan sinc h cunys iacu-
lus cvy af is dvasaing da in h cnd Wld Wa, has
un. acss h ba, cus. u h ans h p a
in (4.6 pcn chin; 20. pcn y), as is an aa-
nss ha hy acuay xis. F ny ha a sisic chan in h by
pliic has akn plac in cn yas: m a sciy wih a vas (and
aiay scu) i cass n ha is n, as is vaiusy ca,
dwnsaming, biplaizd, and iddld by class dinc. s acivisYuasa Ma (2008c) pus i, h svs (m) ha pp nc
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
15/24
CHAPter oNe 6
ab cun nhh savins in h ban, aiis n cu un
in i n, ucaina cniasa yin up. Japan is a
sciy n n inns an ss, jus ss. u, as Yuasa pins
u, pvy (hinkon) is m han maial dpivain aln. I als is
a sa dspain, panic v db cllcs and n, a li livd
n h . n, by his niin, Japan is bcin an ipvish
cuny. sciy h hp has un scac an h uu has b-
c ba incncivab ah.
Oy, n phaps, h as siiny in in h yas
pivain in h a. Tn, as nvis Muaai Ry has n,
n n ha anyhin bu hp. ay, by cnas, hp is h ny hin
ppl dn hav, as Muakami w h bm yas h bubbl
cny in his bssin bKb o u o osodsu (T Exus a uny p, 2002). p ha bc s cnsu by ai-
ais by h 980s ha iv an hp anyhin byn piva acqui-
siin as bbin aay. u hins ny sn. Whn h bubb bus
in 99, iin a cssin ha in n (an n), pp ban
ls n nly hi abiliy cnsum bu hi jbs, hms, and uu
plans. F b ws, h maialis dams pswa Japan a
cin unn.
PrecarityIS A word h is. ic up s by Eupan scia
an ab vns in h 970s,pinxs shi in a sa
capialism wad m xibl, cningn, and igula wk. is
bas, pcaiy s cniins ha a pcaius; pcaius
is pyn ha is uncain, unpicab, an isy h
pin vi h (Kab 2009, 2). y his niin, s
wk ms wks aund h wld has bn hisically pcai-
us, hich as pcaiy ss h xcpin han h u (isn anRssi 2008). a a s in h ay in h in-
a cny ha is, by niin, pcaius (anin 20). n in h
United States most jobs were precarious and most wages unstable until the
n h Ga Dpssin. u, in h cas h Uni as, h v-
nn spp in, bsin scia pcins an cain jbs ih
h Da. n as Fis h an unins (an s ihs
ccivy baain) snhn, ua u-i jbsan accss
h i cassbca h n by h 950s (Kab 20). nhs vp cunis ha, i h Uni as, njy a pi
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
16/24
PAIN o lIe 7
psa Fis ha acc is ciizns (in h c c
a las) scu mplymn, i is h dviain m his nm ha h
p(an h pcaia as h pcaius paia iu-
lar workers) in large part reers. Precarity reerences a particular notion o,
an scia cnac aun, . W ha is scu; ha scus
n ny inc an jb bu iniy an isy, inin capiais an
iniacy in an aciv si scuiy is (an 20). caiy
as h ss hish ss shin ha ny cain cunis,
at certain historical periods, and certain workers ever had in the rst place.
Japan was n hs placs. Wha i had b, and wha has b-
cm his in h pcaiizain lab and li in h las w d-
cas, is h subjc his b. caius Japan, a cuny suc by a
aica chanin scicnic ains in ps-psa ishacnvys, an s cny inp as, a naina isas. n his
vn b h Ga Eas Japan Eahqua an accpanyin sunai
pun h nhas cas h cuny n Mach , 20, nin
i a y asan ah an bis. Tis cisis z u ha i-
aiz a uinss xisin aay. u n ny u. T sunai i-
a n in h Daiichi uca an in Fuushia ha sp
adiain. I was a nucla disas miniscn h dpping h
amic bmbs ha ndd h cnd Wld Wa and killd upwads n hun y husan a ishia an ihy husan a aa-
sai in uus 945a in Japans uniqu hisy as h s, an
ny, cuny b h vici nuca aa. ic bbs an
unbaabl wund bu als ndd Japans miliais ambiins nd
Eas sia is ipia ain. n in bacin a un h c-
cupain i (ainy ican) cs, Japan n is psa
pid asunding cnsucin, achiving high cnmic gwh
an asnica puciviy in c i.uca aiain an u. san cbinain ha ixs his-
is as as aphs. F i h isas a h Daiichi nuca ac
in Fuushia pv is Japans viciizain an vuna-
biiy a h n h acic Waan h i is an unnab,
invisib cnainainh sa u ha pu ha ha bn
si n h casin sina shin s: a iquiizain in scic-
nmic lains ha sad in h mid-1990s (bu acually b) wih
h un xibl mplymn and is ansmain wk and hpac. Tis is ca d in Japansh iquiizain xi-
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
17/24
CHAPter oNe 8
biizain an i. n iqu Japan a chan in h ic
sps in vyay ainaiy: ains nc vau hi suinss
in spac (sayin in h sa cpany nihbh cas) an
duabiliy v im (lilng maiags, gup mmbships, and jbs).
ciaiy ay has bc puncua an unhin. n ih
pacab an s is h hyh scia ipannc: -
ainships ha insananusy cnnc, iscnnc, nv sa up in
h s pac. On-hi a Japans iv an hs ays an h ph-
nmna bh Neet (n in ducain, mplymn, aining) and
hikikmi (scial wihdawal) a wll knwn amng yuhs. s Iv
land in h pcss ldwk in summs sinc 2008, many Japa-
ns ny, ha hy n bn (anyh), an a suin
by. cn spcia n pubic visin ncapsua cun cni-ins scia i ih h ab mu sh ainss sciy.
cia pcaiy. Liqui Japan.
Japan ha bn ubin n b h cn isas ahqua,
sunai, an nuca ac accin. s un, a sns i-
balance, the premonition o water turning everything into mud. Te events
o 3/11 spawned a crisis o unimaginable intensity. Over eighteen thousand
a issin a; h hun y husan ispac; as un-
imaginabl and nging damag businsss, ppy, livsck, andeveryday lie; and trillions o yen in clean up, reconstruction, and compen-
sation. Beyond those killed, it has made lie even less sae than it was beore
s any: pcaiy innsi. has as hn in i aspcs
i ha pcaius aay; h ac, xap, ha s any h
s in h Fuushia nuca pans , bh b an a 3/,
pa h pcaia (cs 88 pcn)ispsab s h
h say h Japans (as in canin up an cnainin h spa
and xpsu adiain) a nw s inimaly inwind. ws -ps n pcaius pyn (ispach, cnac, ay ab) a uch
cn hs ays, an h pcaia hav assu a c-
niin an sypahy in h pubic y. nsibiiis h Japans acss
h cuny hav as bn ais h piics h nuca via:
h cain s any nuca acs in h in hu h
bcaus is dpssd cnmy and aging ppulainsidns had
accpd h dangs in d scu vnus and jbs. nimns
aains nuca ny an h nuca inusy hav sa ( psansi n husan in Jun 20, bu anh ps sa in
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
18/24
PAIN o lI e 9
y h nhs a sixy husan), as hav isus an suspi-
cin aains h ns h nuca pans an h vnn hi
cusin ins, an hi isanan say uains,
can up, an ihhin, vn yin abu, inain ain ai-
ain xpsu.
n p- an n ps-3/ Japan, uip pcaiis , sci-
aiy, i (an ah), as h cn cisis has bh xacba an x-
psdvlap and un gh lik mud. Bu ha dsn man ha
vyn is siuad similaly acd h sam way. ain wks
a m pn blng h pcaia, xampl: hs wihu
ps-scnay ucain an h c hushs ha a sin
pan an in cass ( in p). n, vn uin h b
pi h bubb cny, n vy psnaiv in hpipha c as pa-i s (hich hy ain ay ih
70 pcn a s py in iua jbs an ih 80 p-
cn mp wks bing mal) (Gid 2009). Ta pcaiy is
iniay isibu is sn in h aah 3/ as . Ts up
nh, aay ivin in a in cnicay pss an vy ppu-
lated by elderly, have been hardest hit by both the damage o the Great East
Japan Eahquak (and sunami) and h dadly ha adiaina
ha ha has c husans vacua hi hs ih n assu-anc v bin ab un. Ts h hav s vyhinaiy
mmbs, h bas acs usd mak a living, h vy villag
n has livd in sinc bihsaddl h pcaiy li in a paicu-
a anc ih ah. n ay sy in Fuushia p
h a a h ha s his i an h as happy s ha his
cabbas, a as, ha suviv. Whn hs hn bann sa
bcaus h adiain lvl was und b dangusly high, h man
ci suici.Tuh i ay sa in n pac, pcaiy sn sips in h in-
sins li. Inscuiy a wk, xampl, spads inscuiy whn
payin bis, yin p n h ab, ainainin hn an pi
(in ns cmmuniy had hushld), nding h ngy kp
ging. I is n nly a cndiin pcaius lab bu a m gnal
existential statea state where ones human condition has become precari-
us as (Lazzaa 2004). u h ainship bn ab an i,
jb scuiy an vyay scuiy, pns n h n ivs an hn is siua in h scicnic anscap nain, pac, an
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
19/24
CHAP ter oNe 0
h. Ws in cunis ih scia pcins a ss vun-
ab ab a inscuiy han hy u b his. n Dna,
xap, s scuiy in i is n i a spcic jb; i a
ss a jb h can ih n anh n xpc supp (in ainain-
in a basicay cn i) h sa. Evn ih incas pcaiy in
h ab a, ca piics s aiv pcan puc
ps-mak scuiy: wha is calld xicuiy whn xibl hiing
an in s is cbin ih a bus scia scuiy sys
wks (Kallbg 2011, 15). w balanc xibiliy ( businss, in-
dusy, mplys) agains scuiy ( ciizns, sidns, mplys) is
a pnnia pb n, inusia sas. Din sas, a i-
n hisica is, sv i inyhuh sciais, cpa
capialism, nlibalism, sa wla, nlibalis scialism (hinasnlibalism as xcpin [Ong 2006]). nd, accding lanyi,
cunis hav swung hisically in h ninnh and wnih cn-
uis n n h spcu h h in a ub vn
bwn pivilging mak and cnmic gwh whn dsiuin
and unmplymn spik, spuing wk pss and ppulis ag
anin h ns ( scuiy) is ciizns (anyi 200).
Duin h 970s an 980s, Japan achiv a aab baanc b-
n hih cnic h an a hih v jb scuiy (a)s. Un Japan, nc., h cuny as cnsi a sup sab
sciy ( s): n ih a ci a, n a iiay
nan, an an nvinn n-asin jbs, aias, an s-
cia cnncins. cuiy a inas a nc xpc an si:
wha n add dilignc and cmplianc in a scial cnac ha
is as h n. Din h ps-a scuiy xi-
cuiy, hn s a pc ss by a spcic pac jb han
by the state-sponsored social security system, Japan, Inc. operated throughh mak. O, m pcisly, i an by cllapsing h mak in h
pac, hich caps in h scia acy h aiy an h.
Japan asn a a sa an h vnn aca i in h ay
scia pvisins (hich is si u ay). Rah, i as h cpa-
in an h aiy ha u as h ac a insiuins. Givn
a aiy a hav an supp a aiy, s an ca bu
as h paca ynaic ha xac ab a
s an as hi unpai ivs in anain h hush, h chi-n, an any aach y s ha h bainn cu iv a his
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
20/24
PAIN o lIe
jb. Japans sup sab sciy pn n his n pnncis,
labors, and attachments. And, as it unraveled in post-postwar Japan, a very
paicua in pcaiy an pcaia has in is pac.
NINe moNtHS Ater h ahqua an sunai ha cash h c-
ing sysms a h Fukushima Daiichi nucla acs, causing a ml-
n a h unis, i as annunc ha h ha ha bn cnain.
T acs had bn pu in cld shudwn, im Minis da
Yshihi ca n Dcb 5, usin a chnica ha inicas
nmalcy: inac acs wih ul cs in sa cndiin. In his cas
c shun an ha h paus a h b h ps-
su vsss ac nubs , 2, an 3 ha bn sabiiz a 00 -
s, sin h as aiaciv aias. in sh pans cin sys by yas n, h vnn ha iv up is
pis s i sai. n ca cn v h aa acs;
naina say as s (Fac 20, A6).
Bu n vyn blivd his assin. uspicius ha h gvn-
mn was alsly dclaing succss appas ppls as and ang
v is incpncy, any vic ub abu h accuacy an iin
his claim. Upn haing h nws, h gvn Fukushima -
cu immdialy challngd i. T accidn has n bn bughun cn h ps, pinin u h yia ans si
hanin his cninncy, incuin cnaina a (As Sm-
bu 2/7/20). n hi s xps pais h vnn an h
ky Elcic w mpany (tePCo), h wns h Fukushima
nucla acs, civly cling h acs dwn, hs dis-
iss h iusin say ipi by h c shun. Givn
ha a as h acs n in n an hav a aiain,
h nx (vy dlica) sag mving ul m h acs will bisi, ha, an i cnsuin han usua. shun is a
ha has bn u iv h ipssin a achin s
in csu, Ki iai, a pss a h Rsach Rac nsi-
u a Ky Univsiy, an, nin h vn accin vn-
n picins i u a a as u cas uy isan h
pans: W si ac a n ba pic ppins an by h i i is
ay v s us i b n a (abuchi 20, A8).
Dahinss, as Ki sus, shu b ac ah han cnainund als illusins by a gvnmn whs pmiss, and inasuc-
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
21/24
CHAP ter oNe 2
u, say can n n b us. u h as sp a ba,
hin suviv in s ha ay qui n acics, aiancs, an
aps. piics suviva; a anc ih ah ha ans a in
inain a i. Wha his ans sins h ac aas
n ha h nuca cisis is ca b fciay v an vacuain
ds will sa lif is ha sm us un. Uncnvincd ha
hy can b sa h, any a avin ( bain up h aiy, avin
h husban bhin) a hi chancs as nuca us (gpsu
m) sh in h cunyan sh ha ans n ny -
sain ns cuniy, h, an () ivih bu as nin
in ha can b an ain an inhspiab ain. is isciina-
in aains Fuushia vacus a as iiay in h a-
ah 3/. Riniscn h sia ha as aach h aicbb suvivs (bus) ishia an aasai, hs h
living in Fukushima at the time o the disaster harbor a contamination that
can n h sciay puin (Duas 2002).
On nws sy I had in July 2011 pd n a wman wh lf
Fuushia cu iiay in 3/ bu nv un a h
anyh s iv an as n unin Minai a, hich is
hin is h Daiichi uca an an cs , bu n
insi, h vacuain zn ips a 3/. u a ih nhs p-nan, h wman was high isk, a li wk in wn id ll h.
Y sh as unin pcisy bcaus i as isy sh, h
an pi. , a as, sh ha bh a h an a jb. Risinss
n by ha an by h?
u as in Minai a a puy pincipa a hih sch isiss
h claims mad by h gvnmn ha, wih h cld shudwn an-
nuncd n Dcmb 15, h nucla cisis was nw v. Tugh his
school had reopened in October when declared sae ollowing a ast-pacedcanup, h pincipa as n cnvinc: Tis s n in u us
a a. y Dcb, ny 350 705 suns ha un. pain
h Daiichi uca an, bu as his n an h cuny phaps,
h sai h pan is i a bac bx, an n n ha is ay hap-
pnin. n i (abuchi 20, A8).
nd hn, umbling pnially und, is h ha anh
lag-scal ahquak wih h pssibiliy anh sunami. Wih is
jury-rigged cooling system, the recent repairs on the Daiichi Nuclear Planthav n bn a ihsan a aj ahqua hih- in su-
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
22/24
PAIN o lIe 3
nai: a cincy in h iina pan as , cus. u iss
hav annunc ha anh aj qua (sh in h in
Japan, si sn) is n ny a pssibiiy bu a cainy. Ts a
acs as ys hn sanin in h uins shinai, h n
s hi by 3/, sui up in ubb an ay ba upn shvin
u in ay Juy. T a h vun pain ha jin, ac
a, s in n us, as in bs. ca a h n his spch
abu h ha, any sins, an b spcu h aa
an pp h ha su s uch. Tn, n incin s, h
us b ppa bcaus anh ahqua u c n ay sn.
inin his n h hi bhin hi, h su h shu
un i a sunai hi: Run up h hi. n un as.
Tis cndiin uncainy, umbling insabiliy, a ain mud-didby dbis, cnaminain, dahis wha Japans ac as hi
cuny vs a in his scn ca h ny- s cnuy.
s h cn cisis has shn, h cuny is n a au in. n a
sup sab sciy an n (y) n ha has cnain h aa an
ha is nuca accin. Rah, i is n acin h chan p-
caiy uip ins. an ay ca his pcaius siuain a c
shudwn?, askd Kud Kazuhik, a pss nucla ngining
a Ky Univsiy, upn hain h vnn cai ha is nucacisis as n un cn (Fac 20, A).
s cainy n. u jus asin h qusin, as s any ()
Japans a in hs ays, is a sin shin n. spas an
in an spain spicisa h vnn, is pca-
ains say an cn, an scia insiuins ha hav bn un-
nin n cain xpcains an ics (hiachy an pnncy) ha
may n lng mak sns. nd, in sm cass a las, ying u nw
acics (an sisancs) suviv pcaius is. Uncainy is uns-in. u cnnin ih i, in in h u, is a in spns
han gipping n amilia scuiis h auhiis ha pnunc
h. Tis is n h hs h b. sin in ha sns, an
wha lins, and wih wha cs and acs pcaiy is ngnding a
piics suviva: a psnain piics in a h qus-
in suviva (bs 200, 0).
PreCArIt, dItH Btler has au, ans shin hancniin an: uh n hin ha h cniin pcai-
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
23/24
n o t e s
C h a P t e r 1 . P a i n o f L i f e
1. Japans nams a in las nam s.
2. N.H.k. ni ys anslas as Wlcm h N.H.k. NHk is h nainal
badcasing sysm in Japan. Bu in h sy h main pagnis, h is su-ing m dlusins, hins his sands ippn hiimi yai h Japans
iimi ssciain.
3. Manga a cmic bs, hil anim a animad vids cans. ai-
m asuhi, h auh, publishd h nvl in 2002 ih Kadaa shn.
T manga vsin, als publishd by Kadaa, as sializd in is manga maga-
zin Shnen Ace bn Jun 2004 and Jun 2007. T lvisin anim, badcas
in ny-u pisds, as lvisd by Gnz bn July and Dcmb 2006.
T a English vsins h nvl, cmic b, and animad can.
4. Tis is smha a n usag by Yuasa, hich h as m ds li ta-
mekomu ( had sav up) and tameiki ( sigh).
5. i Budiu (1998) is n h s schlas said hav usd h d.
7/29/2019 Precarious Japan by Anne Allison
24/24
Note S to CHAP ter two 208
6. amd a ny Fd, h sad h Fd aumbil plans in Dabn,
Michigan, in 1915, Fdism s a scial and cnmic sysm indusial
mass pducin. Uniqu h Unid as unil h nd h cnd Wld
Wa, Fdism spad and as xpd h cunis in Eup, Lain mica,
Japan, and Eas sia in psa ims. Basd n aylizain, pducin as b-n dn in disc sps ma i m ainal and fcin. ls, und h
mdl inducd by Fd, s paid a sufcinly dcn ag s hy
culd puchas h bjcs hy pducing hi n cnsumpin (such as
a Mdl- Fd). Du a numb acs, including h il shc in 1973 and in-
casd innainal cmpiin cnsumpin gds, Fdis pducin sad
shiing ps-Fdism in h 1970s chaacizd by m jus-in-im pducin
( lan pducin), xibl lab, and usucing (s avy 2007).
7. ccding Guy anding (2011, 910), h pcaia (s in pcai-
us mplymn) lac svn ms lab-lad scuiy: 1) lab ma scu-
iy (adqua incm-aning ppuniis), 2) mplymn scuiy (pcin
agains abiay ing), 3) jb scuiy (h abiliy advanc), 4) scuiy
(pcin agains accidns), 5) sill pducin scuiy (h ppuniy ac-
qui and advanc sills), 6) incm scuiy (adqua incm), and 7) psna-
in scuiy (accss a cllciv vic in h lab ma).
8. Embracing Defeat: Japan in the Wake of World War IIis h il Jhn Ds
(1999) xclln hisy abu Japans da in h cnd Wld Wa and is sub-
squn cnsucin und llid (mainly mican) ccupain.
9. By May 2012 h dcisin had bn mad nv pn h u nucla -
acs in Fuushima. T numb nucla acs in h cuny is hus allidn b y, n y-u, ha is, y n pnding pning.
10. T is an mgn bdy schlaship n h ac/snsing/mbdimn
/vydaynss pcaiy/suvival/a li/abandnmn. My n has bn
dply inmd and inuncd by his schlaship, and paiculaly ha by ll
anhplgiss n: dinay acs and pcaiys ms (a 2007, 2012), li in
zns scial abandnmn (Bihl 2005), aciv spac and phanmic xisnc
(ava-Yasmin 2012), a li and h hp/uglinss scial ms (Rss 2010),
xisnial cipciy and living n h magins (Luch 2012), h unvn disibu-
in ll-bing (Jacsn 2011), scial suing and pain (Das 1997), ca and dbamids unqual scial aangmns (an 2012), h chniciy pain in a pasal
clinic (Gacia 2010), hics and vlunism (Muhlbach 2012), xhausin, ndu-
anc, and a scial his (vinlli 2011), and qunss, pcaiy, and abulusiy
(Manalansan, al givn a Fminis Ty Wshp, Du, Mach 23, 2013).
11. Japans nams a in in hins idgams (kanji) ha can b ad in
din ays.
C h a P t e r 2 . f r o m L i f e L o n g t o L i q u i d J a P a n
1. Mass culu als picd up h hm h h sacd impial galia in iscmmcial slgans dsiabl cnsum gds: h h S s h la 1950s and