8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
1/28
Tunlbj Falbnarotbch ohf Eobh-cg-Guhjtbch
^asaorj` Tclbjy; Tuttbhe Bt bhtc Trojtbja
Mchbjo Zj`cj`-Zpoho, T`FZahbcr Osscjbota
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
2/28
>
Cvarvbaw
•
Cutlbha nosbj quastbchs oncut “punlbj falbnarotbch”
fasbeh (ba, punlbj, purpcsa, prcnlam, prcjass).
•
Fbsjuss `cw tc cparotbcholbza stohforf alamahtscg punlbj falbnarotbch (ba, bhjlusbvbty, bhgcrmotbch,
volua-nosaf raoschbhe, jcmmch ercuhf cutputs).
• Moia rajcmmahfotbchs ch `cw tc (jchtbhua tc)
opply punlbj falbnarotbch wbt`bh t`a ECG^ jchtaxt
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
3/28
“Tunlbj Falbnarotbch” Fasbeh _uastbchs
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
4/28
6
Fasbeh Bssua #?; U`bj` Tunlbj(s) tc
Bhvclva bh Falbnarotbchs•
U`ot out`crbtbas typbjolly `ova bh mbhf bs t`a fbsbhtarastaf,raprasahtotbva, ohf punlbjly spbrbtaf “crfbhory parsch” (Mortbh>4?>)9 cgtah jchglotaf wbt` bfao cg hch-axpart “loy punlbj”
•
: guzzy, cvarloppbhe jotaecrbas ora mcra usagul w`ah t`bhibhe
oncut fasbeh (Faealbhe at ol >4?1);
- Tura Tunlbj ; hoãva jbtbzahs
- Oggajtaf Tunlbj ; parschs/ercups w`csa lbvas ora oltaraf crbhgluahjaf ny o pclbjy fajbsbch
- Tortbsoh Tunlbj ; raprasahtotbvas cg ercups wbt` vastaf bhtarast craxpartbsa bh t`a pclbjy mottar
•
Aoj` typa cg punlbj `os surgojaf bh ECG rapcrts, fbsjussbch,ohf jcmmahtory!
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
5/28
1
“Oggajtaf Tunlbjs” Bmplbaf bh t`a
^bsi-Nahagbt Oholysbs (^NO)• “!fatarmbha bg EcG axparbmahts jculf jraota pot`ceahs
t`ot ora mcra lbialy tc jousa loncrotcry ojqubraf
bhgajtbchs, tc jraota o lcjol cutnraoi cr tc jousa o elcnol
cutnraoi” (Nbcsogaty ^bsi Ossassmaht, ^NO, p?).
• Oggajtaf punlbjs bh t`bs sjahorbc bhjlufa;
- Bhgajtaf lon wcriars ohf t`abr jchtojts
- Lcjol rasbfahts/raspchfars furbhe cutnraoi
- Elcnol bh`onbtohts/raspchfars furbhe pohfambj
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
6/28
7
“Tura Tunlbj” ohf “Oggajtaf Tunlbj”
Hctaf bh At`bjs Oholysas• “Mohy cg t`a `orf at`bjol quastbchs robsaf ny ECG^, t`ot
bs, s`culf na rasclvaf bh o woy t`ot raglajts t`a voluas
ohf rbsi-toibhe strotaebas atj. cg t`a pacpla.”-- Zalealbf >4?1, p>7
• “Bhjcrpcrotbhe prbhjbplas cg `umoh sunkajts rasaorj`
at`bjs t`ot ora cg portbjulor ralavohja tc ECG/TTT
stufbas wbll maoh jchsbfarbhe t`a nahagbts cg t`bsrasaorj` bh t`a jchtaxt cg bts jopojbty tc nahagbt cr `orm
`umohbty !.”-- Avohs at ol >4?1, p245
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
7/28
5
Zcma “Tortbsoh Tunlbjs” Homaf bh
ECG^ Tunlbjotbchs ohf Jcmmahts• “!YV]`bs must na o fbsjussbch t`ot mcvas naychf glu
rasaorj`ars, scma cg w`cm `ova parschol bhtarasts ot
stoia, ohf naychf mbjrcnbclcebsts, tc t`a w`cla
sjbahtbgbj ohf mafbjol jcmmuhbty ohf ct`ars w`cwculf na fbrajtly oggajtaf ‚ t`a eaharol punlbj.”
-- Lbpsbtj` bh Fuprax at ol >4?6, p1
• “YM]uj` cg t`a YECG punlbj fbolceua] `os naah staaraf
ny mamnars cg t`a mbjrcnbclcey ohf pclbjyjcmmuhbtbas. V`ara ramobhs rccm gcr offbtbchol bhput
grcm jlbhbjol ohf punlbj `aolt` projtbtbchars!.”-- Iblbohsib at ol >4?1, p?
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
8/28
0
Fasbeh Bssua #>; U`ot Turpcsa gcr
t`a Falbnarotbhe Tunlbj(s) O gaw laebtbmota, t`cue` fbstbhjt obms;
• Ihcwlafea Axj`ohea; jchvay bhgcrmotbch grcm pclbjy moiar tcpunlbj9 trohsmbt vbaws/cpbhbchs/ottbtufas grcm punlbj tc pclbjymoiar
•
Bhhcvotbch; albjbt rbj` uhprafbjtonla bhsbe`ts t`ot jcma grcm jrcwf-scurjbhe o prcnlam cr grcm axparbahtbol, ch-t`a-ercuhf ihcwlafea
• Famcjrotbj Ojjcuhtonblbty; ahsura nrcof raprasahtotbch bh ofajbsbch oncut t`a jcmmch eccf
Bg t`a ecol cg famcjrotbj ojjcuhtonblbty bs fasbraf;
•
V`ah cha bs cnlbeotaf tc ebva pacpla t`a tbma, bhgc, spoja, ohfout`crbty t`ay haaf tc pargcrm t`ot rcla.
• Maraly nrbhebhe “crfbhory pacpla” cr o jrcss-sajtbch cg scjbatytceat`ar tc falbnarota fcas hct outcmotbjolly oj`bava t`bs obm.
Mortbh >4?>, Faealbhe at ol >4?1
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
9/28
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
10/28
?4
Fasbeh Bssua #:; U`bj` Trcjass
Ahonlas Tunlbj tc Gulgbll bts Turpcsa
Nosaf ch ^cwa ohf Grawar >441
Jchtbhuum cg Tunlbj Tortbjbpotbch bh Tclbjymoibhe
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
11/28
??
Tunlbj Tortbjbpotbch bh ECG
^asaorj` Tclbjymoibhe• Jcmmuhbjotbch ‚ Trass ralaosas, afujotbchol
wansbtas, ohf summory rapcrts ch HOZ ohfHZONN ECG maatbhes9 ^NO ch-lbha
•
Jchsultotbch ‚ Tunlbj jcmmahts ch frogtHZONN rajcmmahfotbchs tc QZE ch guturaguhfbhe ohf cvarsbe`t pclbjy
•
Jclloncrotbch ‚ Falbnarotbva cptbch wbt` nrcofpunlbj `os hct yat naah axplcraf9 lbga sjbahjasohf ct`ar portbsoh punlbjs `ova `of strchebhput
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
12/28
?>
Fasbeh Bssua #6; U`ot Trcnlam
gcr Tunlbj(s) tc Falbnarota•
Jchglbjtbhe voluas oncut t`a punlbj eccf
- Vahsbch natwaah > aquolly voluaf t`bhes (sajurbty vs prbvojy)
- Loji cg oh onscluta `barorj`y omche o ercup cg voluaf btams
•
Jchtrcvarsbol ohf fbvbsbva tcpbjs w`ara- Cutjcmas ora parjabvaf tc prcfuja wbhhars ohf lcsars
- Ecol bs tc eaharota o nattar gbalf cg cptbchs
•
@ynrbf tcpbjs w`ara
- Vaj`hbjol ohf hcrmotbva ospajts ora bhtarwcvah cr
- Vaj`hbjol ohf axparbahtbol ihcwlafea joh na syharebstbj
•
Lcw trust bssuas bh w`bj` ecv‒t ohf/cr sjbahtbgbj jcmmuhbtyjoh aorh, ratobh, cr lcsa t`a punlbj‒s trust
Zclcmch ohf Onalsch >4?>
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
13/28
?:
(O Gaw) ECG ^asaorj` Guhfbhe ohf
Cvarsbe`t _uastbchs t`ot Gbt t`bs Trcgbla•
Faspbta pctahtbol jchtrbnutbchs tc punlbj `aolt`, s`culf stufbas
t`ot jculf prcfuja o pot`ceah cg pohfambj pctahtbol (TTT)
na pargcrmaf ot oll3 ‚ jchglbjtbhe voluas
•
Ora gbhbta fcllors nattar spaht ch TTT jraotbch axparbmahts
(w`bj` prcfuja uhbqua ihcwlafea) cr ch strahet`ahbhe t`a
rast cg t`a glu praporafhass pcrtgclbc3 ‚ jchglbjtbhe voluas9
fbvbsbva tcpbj
•
Bg ohy, w`ot offaf staps s`culf trustaa bhstbtutbchs (QZE,rasaorj` ahtbtbas) toia tc strahet`ah TTT nbcsogaty ohf
nbcsajurbty prctajtbchs ohf punlbj jchgbfahja bh t`am3 ‚
`ynrbf tcpbj9 lcw trust bssua
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
14/28
@cw tc Cparotbcholbza “Tunlbj Falbnarotbch”
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
15/28
?1
Hc Zbhela Mat`cfclcey gcr
Tunlbj Falbnarotbch•
^avbaw cg punlbj falbnarotbch bh punlbj `aolt` ohf `aolt` pclbjyrasaorj` (?227->4?:) ‚ Faealbhe at ol >4?1- 7> avahts
- ?4 fbstbhjt mat`cfs (ae, jbtbzah kurbas, falbnarotbva pcllbhe)
•
^avbaw cg stufbas bhvclvbhe “jbtbzah kurbas” bh `aolt` pclbjyfajbsbch moibhe (?221->4?4) ‚ Ztraat at ol >4?6- 77 kurbas
- >4 fbggaraht rajrubtmaht mat`cfs
- Grcm ?-> foy sassbchs tc maatbhe ?? tbmas cvar ?7 waais
•
U`y suj` fbvarsbty3- Hc sattlaf ojjcuht cg w`ot jchstbtutas TF bh t`acry cr projtbja
- Huohjaf bssuas ohf bfbcsyhjrotbj jchtaxts
- ^aol wcrlf lbmbtotbchs; lcebstbjs, nufeats, pclbtbjs
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
16/28
?7
Mbhbmum Ztohforfs gcr
Tunlbj Falbnarotbch•
Ahsura suggbjbahtly fbvarsa raprasahtotbch tc;
- Jcmpahsota gcr fbsprcpcrtbchota portbjbpotbch ny prbvblaeafjlossas cg pacpla
- Qhjcvar pcbhts cg vbaw ohf jchglbjtbhe bhtarasts t`ot mbe`t
ct`arwbsa na mbssaf
•
Zupply nolohjaf, gojtuol bhgcrmotbch t`ot strahet`ahsportbjbpohts‒ ihcwlafea cg t`a bssua
•
Trcvbfa portbjbpohts t`a cppcrtuhbty tc;
- ^aglajt ch ohf fbsjuss graaly o wbfa spajtrum cg vbawpcbhts
- Vast jcmpatbhe mcrol jlobms
- Lcjota jcmmch ercuhf (t`cue` hct olwoys raoj`af cr fasbraf)
Nlojis`ar at ol >4?>9 Onalsch at ol >4?:
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
17/28
?5
Bhjlusbvbty/Fbvarsbty
Ztohforf bh Ojtbch• Falbnarotbch raqubras smoll ercup bhtarojtbch - hct avarycha bh o
pura/oggajtaf/portbsoh punlbj joh portbjbpota.
•
U`csa bhtarasts ora raprasahtaf bh t`a falbnarotbch3 U`c eats tcraprasaht t`csa bhtarasts3 U`ot mbxtura, bg ohy, cg pura/oggajtaf/portbsoh punlbjs3
•
@cw ora falbnarohts salajtaf3 ^ohfcmly, purpcsbvaly, “cpah tc oll”3
- Tura punlbj; jrcss sajtbch cg punlbj ny rohfcm somplbhe groma ohfstrotbgbjotbch
- Hcta; ^ajrubtmaht mat`cf fcas hct hajassorbly ossura suggbjbahtly
fbvarsa rohea cg parspajtbvas/pcsbtbchs hcr aquol portbjbpotbch omchefalbnarohts (ae, gojblbtotbch mottars).
•
U`ot jchjrata avbfahja joh creohbzars/pclbjymoiars s`cw t`otfalbnarotbch wos hct jopturaf ny spajbol bhtarasts3
Nlojis`ar at ol >4?>, Ecclf at ol >4?>, C‒Fc`arty >4?>, Onalsch at ol >4?:, Ztraat at ol >4?6
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
18/28
?0
Bhgcrmotbch Trcvbsbch
Ztohforf bh Ojtbch• @cw wbll t`a bssua na salajtaf gcr falbnarotbch ohf t`ah
gromaf, ohf aggajtbvaly prasahtaf; bhgcrmotbch,prcnlam(s), oreumahts, pcsbtbchs3
•
Ubll creohbzars loy cut praporaf pclbjy cptbchs gcrfalbnarohts cr wbll falbnarohts `ova pcwar tc fagbhacptbchs3 U`ot axpajtotbchs fc falbnarohts `ova oncutt`abr rcla3
•
@cw wbll axpart/taj`hbjol ihcwlafea na bhjcrpcrotaf3Ubll portbsoh ohf pura punlbjs falbnarota tceat`ar cr wbllaxparts prcvbfa tastbmchy tc stohf ch bts cwh3
Zclcmch & Onalsch >4?>, C‒Fc`arty >4?>,
Onalsch at ol >4?:, Faealbhe >4?1
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
19/28
?2
Wolua-Nosaf ^aoschbhe
Ztohforf bh Ojtbch•
@cw tc ossura hch-jcarjaf, raspajtgul raglajtbch ch pragarahjas,voluas, ohf jchjapts sc os tc avcia pctahtbol jcmmch ercuhf3
- Wolua cg staarbhe jcmmbttaa cvarsbe`t, axplbjbt ercuhf rulas, ohfsuppcrtbva/bhfapahfaht/sibllaf gojblbtotbch
•
Ora rascurjas ovoblonla tc ebva portbjbpohts suggbjbaht tbma ohf spojatc fbeast bhgcrmotbch, ojjlbmota tc prcjass, ohf falbnarota3
• @cw wbll falbnaroht bhput na albjbtaf, syht`asbzaf, ohf raprasahtaftc fajbsbch moiars3 @cw wbll bt na jchsumaf ny pclbjymoiar3
- Fcas prcjass ahjcuroea jchsahsus cr jchglbjt ohf fbggarahja3
- U`c wbll jcmpbla ohf bhtarprat falbnaroht bhput3 Tortbjbpohts, gojblbtotcr,cr creohbzars3
- Bs fasbraf cutput o varfbjt, rajcmmahfotbchs, cr o sat cg mokcrbty ohfmbhcrbty cpbhbchs3
Nlojis`ar at ol >4?>, Ecclf at ol >4?>, C‒Fc`arty >4?>, Onalsch at ol >4?:, Ztraat at ol >4?6
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
20/28
>4
Maosurbhe Zujjass•
Trcjafuras ‚ _uolbty Bhgcrmotbch
- Jrbtarbo; jcmpra`ahsbva, ojjassbnla, ohf nolohjaf
- Bhstrumaht; pcst-falbnarotbva survay
• Trcjafuras ‚ _uolbty Falbnarotbchs
- Jrbtarbo; trohsgcrmaf cpbhbchs, raspajt/tclarohja gcr ct`ar vbaws,sotbsgojtbch wbt` fajbsbch, sahsa cg pclbtbjol aggbjojy, scjbol trust/jchhajtafhass, jchsbstahjy cg raspchsas ojrcss sunercups
- Bhstrumahts; quolbtotbva oholysbs cg fbolceua, pcst-falbnarotbva survay cgfalbnarohts, maosura #/lahet` cg jcmmahts ny falbnarohts
• Cutjcmas ‚ Bmpojt ch Tclbjy/Tclbjymoiar
- Jrbtarbo; tohebnla bhgluahja ch fajbsbch9 ah`ohjaf laval cg pclbjymoiarjchgbfahja t`ot s/`a `os mofa oh bhgcrmaf j`cbja
- Bhstrumaht; pra-/pcst bhtarvbaw wbt` pclbjy moiar
• Cutjcmas ‚ Bmpojt ch Tortbjbpohts
- Jrbtarbo; falbnaroht jchgbfahja bh laebtbmojy cg pclbjy fajbsbch
- Bhstrumaht; pcst falbnarotbva ohf/cr pcst fajbsbch survay
Ecclf at ol >4?>, Onalsch at ol >4?:, Ztraat at ol >4?6
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
21/28
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
22/28
>>
ECG^ Falbnarotbva Trcjass
bh QZ, ot Trasaht• Hotbchol Ojofambas (HOZ) ohf Hotbchol Zjbahja
Ofvbscry Ncorf gcr Nbcsajurbty (HZONN) ora t`aprbcrbty vahuas gcr punlbj bhput.
•
Maatbhes tc fota `ova aheoeaf bhfbvbfuols grcm lbgasjbahjas, sajurbty, punlbj `aolt`, nbcsogaty, rbsioholysbs, ohf t`a frue/vox bhfustry.
• V`abr vcbjas lorealy onsaht, t`a eaharol punlbj bs stbll ott`a jahtar cg ECG fbsjcursa; o fasbra tc prctajt punlbjwall-nabhe mctbvotas oll pcsbtbchs bh t`a ECG fanota.
•
Qhrasclvaf bssua; Z`culf mcra scp`bstbjotaf,rascurja-bhtahsbva falbnarotbva sassbchs na `alfcutsbfa t`a prasaht jbrjla cg vastaf portbas3
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
23/28
>:
Tortbsoh Tunlbjs
Gcrmolly avoluota t`a prasaht ECG^ falbnarotbvaprcjass ahonlaf ny HOZ/HZONN strujturas
• @cw wculf t`a (prbmorbly) portbsoh punlbjs rota t`a
quolbty cg falbnarotbchs bh tarms cg bhjlusbvbty,bhgcrmotbch prcvbsbch, ohf volua-nosaf raoschbhe
•
Nahagbts cg gcrmol avoluotbch
- Ztrahet`ahs avbfahja nosa wbt` w`bj` pacpla joh
kufea t`a laebtbmojy cg t`a ECG^ pclbjymoibheprcjass (tc fota)
- Trcvbfas usagul foto wbt` w`bj` tc ploh ohy offbtbcholfalbnarotbva ojtbvbty, bg ohy
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
24/28
>6
Oggajtaf Tunlbjs
@clf falbnarotbva axarjbsas bh jcmmuhbtbas hcw`cstbhe gojblbtbas w`ara ECG^ bs uhfartoiah
• V`acratbjol rbsi yat ercuhfaf bhput cg pctahtbolly
“oggajtaf punlbjs”- Lon wcriars/jchtojts ohf lcjol rasbfahts/raspchfars
• Famcjrotbj ojjcuhtonblbty (Faway sahsa) ohfbhgcrmaf jchsaht (Nalmcht ^apcrt sahsa)
•
Jculf pcsa t`a TTT axparbmahts “bg avar” quastbchcr t`a “`cw tc” strahet`ah nbcsogaty ohf sajurbtysystams os wall os punlbj jchgbfahja
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
25/28
>1
Tura/Oggajtaf Tunlbjs
Aheoea o jrcss-sajtbch cg Omarbjoh punlbj bh ofalbnarotbva axarjbsa oncut spajbgbj quastbch(s)
• @ynrbf cg pura ohf oggajtaf punlbjs bh Faway
ohf Nalmcht ^apcrt sahsa
• Tctahtbol quastbchs tc pcsa;
- “Bg avar” TTT axparbmahts
- ^ascurja ollcjotbch; toxpoyar suppcrt gcr TTTaxparbmahts cr ct`ar glu praporafhass aggcrts
• @alp mcfal ojtbvbtbas gcr ct`ar jcuhtrbas
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
26/28
>7
^agarahjas
• Onalsch K at ol. Tunlbj falbnarotbch bh `aolt` pclbjy ohf nbcat`bjs; Moppbheoh amarebhe, bhtarfbsjbplbhory gbalf. Kcurhol cg Tunlbj Falbnarotbch >4?:92(?);Ortbjla 1, ?-:1.
• Nlojis`ar at ol. U`ot bs punlbj falbnarotbch. @ostbhes Jahtar ^apcrt >4?>9Mor-Opr;?6-?5.
•
Faealbhe J at ol. U`bj` punlbj ohf w`y falbnarota3 O sjcpbhe ravbaw cgpunlbj falbnarotbch bh punlbj `aolt` ohf `aolt` pclbjy rasaorj`. ZcjbolZjbahja & Mafbjbha >4?19 ?:?;??6-?>?.
•
Fuprax UT at ol. Eobh-cg-guhjtbch axparbmahts; Vbma gcr o raol fanota.Hotura ^avbaws Mbjrcnbclcey. Ofvohja chlbha punlbjotbch Faj 0, >4?6.
• Avohs HE at ol. V`a at`bjs cg nbcsogaty jchsbfarotbchs bh eobh-cg-guhjtbchrasaorj` rasultbhe bh t`a jraotbch cg pctahtbol pohfambj pot`ceahs. Kcurhol
cg Mafbjol At`bjs >4?69 6?;24?-240.• Ecclf ZF at ol. U`ot bs eccf punlbj falbnarotbchs3 @ostbhes Jahtar ^apcrt
>4?>9 Mor-Opr;>6->7.
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
27/28
>5
^agarahjas jcht‒f
• Iblbohsib O at ol. Eobh cg guhjtbch rasaorj` ohf t`a ralavohja tc jlbhbjol projtbja. Kcurhol cgBhgajtbcus Fbsaosas. Ofvohja punlbjotbch Cjtcnar >0, >4?1.
• Mortbh ET. Jbtbzahs, punlbjs, ct`ars ohf t`abr rcla bh portbjbpotcry prcjassas; O jcmmahtorych La`cux, Foufalbh ohf Onalsch. Zcjbol Zjbahja & Mafbjbha >4?>9 56;?01?-?01:.
• C‒Fc`arty I at ol >4?>. Bmplamahtbhe o punlbj falbnarotbva gcrum. @ostbhes Jahtar ^apcrt>4?>9 Mor-Opr;>4->:.
•
^cwa E, Grawar LK. O typclcey cg punlbj aheoeamaht. Zjbahja Vaj`hclcey ohf @umohWoluas >4419 :4(>);>1?->24.
• Zalealbf MK. Eobh-cg-guhjtbch rasaorj`; At`bjol oholysbs. U`bta Topar. Faj >4?1. ̀ ttp;//csp.cf.hb`.ecv/sbtas/fagoult/gblas/Eobh-cg-Guhjtbch%>4^asaorj`%>4At`bjol%>4Oholysbs%>4U`bta%>4Topar%>4ny%>4Mbj`oal%>4ZalealbfS4.pfg
• Zclcmch Z, Onalsch K. U`y ohf w`ah s`culf wa usa punlbj falbnarotbch3 @ostbhes Jahtar^apcrt >4?>9 Mor-Opr;?5->4.
•
Ztraat K at ol. V`a usa cg jbtbzahs‒ kurbas bh `aolt` pclbjy fajbsbch-moibhe; O systamotbjravbaw. Zcjbol Zjbahja & Mafbjbha >4?69 ?42;?-2.
8/19/2019 Public Deliberation and GOF Research Policy: Putting It Into Practice (Monica Schoch-Spana)
28/28
V`ohi ycu.
msj`cj`Dupmj.afu