Where is the MoneyTree?
www.360vlaw.com 2
ABC 01/27 reporting on PwC MoneyTree report ó VC invested in Atlanta firms down 27.5% in 2009 vs 2008 ó Nationally VC down 37% year over year ó Georgia companies received $302 million in 2009 ó Average VC check (Georgia):$6.9m in 2009, $5.2 in 2008 ó Energy and Software hot sectors - $112m, $42.6m ó All companies stages down, except later stage up 50%
Where to go pick up your check?
www.360vlaw.com 3
ó Founders, Friends & Family ó Angels ó Venture Capital firms ó State programs ó Federal grants and loans ó SBA – Small Business Admin ó SBIR – Small Business Investment Companies
ó Commercial Banks ó Specialty banks (SVB, Comerica, RBC)
Business Plan
www.360vlaw.com 4
Does yours answer: óWhat you do? óWho you are like? óYour competitors are? óWho you do it to? ó Size and growth rate of market? ó How can you defend? – proprietary technology,
business model ó Management team? Have one! ó Use of Proceeds
Executive Summary
www.360vlaw.com 5
ó Obvious – grammar, spelling ó Format! ó Visually appealing ó Easy to find sections, data ó Draws attention to main points
ó PDF – send using Adobe PDF ó 1 pager?? – I am not a believer ó Well laid out, not cramped ó Images, graphs, white space
ó Content – tailor your highlights, bullet points to your audience.
Every securities offering is either:
www.360vlaw.com 6
• Registered • Exempt • Illegal
Illegal is L Bad!
Securities Act of 1933
www.360vlaw.com 7
Drafted while looking in a mirror ó Every securities offering must be registered with
the SEC except: ó Section 3 – Exempt Securities ó Section 4 – Exempt Transactions
Help is on the way
www.360vlaw.com 8
ó Regulation D, promulgated pursuant to Section 4(2) of the Securities Act of 1933 ó 3 safe harbors: J Good óRule 504 óRule 505 óRule 506
Reg D – Rule 506
www.360vlaw.com 9
ó Unlimited offering amount ó Unlimited number of “Accredited” investors ó No more than 35 (sophisticated) UN-accredited investors ó No specified disclosure format if all offerees Accredited ó If UN-accredited offerees – big disclosure ó No general advertising ó No general solicitation
No General Advertising
www.360vlaw.com 10
Issuer Cannot: (ie L Bad!) ó advertise in any media (i.e. newspapers, TV,
radio, or the Internet) ó engage in a mass mailing (snail or email) ó conduct informational meetings with potential
investors ó issue a press release that discusses the existence of
the private placement
No General Solicitation
www.360vlaw.com 11
ó SEC staff’s view is that there must be a nexus between the solicitor and his targets. ó A “substantial pre-existing” relationship. ó all offerees should be people with whom your company,
or any licensed selling agents has a substantial and pre-existing relationship. ó Sufficient to enable the Company to determine the
financial well-being and investor sophistication of the offeree.
Best Defense – keep good records
www.360vlaw.com 12
ó How do you “prove”: ó no general solicitation or advertising? óYou had sufficient knowledge of their financial
condition? Sophistication?
Best Defense – keep good records
www.360vlaw.com 13
ó Use an Investor Questionnaire, require it to be completed ó Numbered PPMs/Exec Summaries ó Lots of (self serving) disclaimers óThis is not an offering ó If it is, it is being done only to accrediteds óYou must burn after reading ó Control Sheet to track above ó Due Diligence file archived for transaction
Reg D – Rule 505
www.360vlaw.com 14
ó Up to $5,000,000 ó Unlimited number of “Accredited” investors ó No more than 35 UN-accredited investors (can be UN-
sophisticated) ó No specified disclosure format if all offerees Accredited ó If UN-accredited offerees – big disclosure ó No general advertising ó No general solicitation ó Not a “covered security” under NSMIA, so no state
preemption.
Reg D – Rule 504
www.360vlaw.com 15
ó Can issue up to $1,000,000 ó To qualify, Newco: ó must not already be registered with SEC ó Aggregate of ALL securities sold in last 12mos > $1m
ó General solicitation and advertising is permitted if offering is registered under a state reg that permits. ó Not a “covered security” under NSMIA, so no state
preemption. ó Sounds good on paper, rarely used in practice.
Summary of Regulation D
www.360vlaw.com 16
óRule 506 = J Very Good! óRule 505 = ehhh óRule 504 = not so much ó Section 4(2) = in a pinch
UN-accredited investors – are they worth the hassle?
www.360vlaw.com 17
ó Non-accredited investors trigger a larger
disclosure obligation (more time and money) ó Non-accredited investors tend to be more hostile
than accredited investors ó Non-accredited investors can hinder an
acquisition ó ANSWER: NO
Form D – E-File is Here
www.360vlaw.com 18
As of March 16, 2009, all Form D fillings with the SEC must be made on a new form that includes new disclosures. • Annual Amendment • “Date of First Sale” now defined. Must file within 15
days • New disclosures:
• List expected exemption • whether BD or finder used • issuer revenue range.
Section 4(2) – Exempted Transactions
www.360vlaw.com 19
ó 4(2) “transactions by an issuer not involving a
public offering” ó Reg D is a safe harbor for 4(2). Provides clarity. ó BUT Reg D specifically provides that it is not
exclusive
Section 4(2) – Exempted Transactions
www.360vlaw.com 20
óWhy use an old school 4(2)? óClassic limited private placement - to 1 or 2
institutional investors. If compliance with Reg D is considered a bother. óAfter-the-fact justification - client comes to you
after 18 months of sporadic capital raising by “any means necessary”.
Blue Sky – Georgia Style
www.360vlaw.com 21
ó Georgia Uniform Securities Act of 2008 (effective July 1, 2009) ó Supersedes the Georgia Securities Act of 1973 ó Georgia became 15th State to adopt the Uniform
Securities Act of 2002 (promulgated by NCCUS)
GA Limited Offering Exemption
www.360vlaw.com 22
The exemption formerly known as OCGA 10-5-9(13) is now found in OCGA 10-5-11(14). • Keeps the prohibition on general
solicitation/advertising • Keeps 15 Georgia purchaser maximum • New prohibition on paying commissions • “purchase for investment” statement no longer
required but the issuer must reasonably believe all GA purchasers are purchasing for investment
Employee Benefit Plan Exemption
www.360vlaw.com 23
ó Prior GA Law OCGA 10-5-9(7) and 10-5-9(9)
limited the registration exemption to employees or the issuer or the issuers affiliates. ó NEW OCGA 10-5-11(21) allows grants to
consultants and advisors, so long as: óAdvisors are natural persons óAdvisors are providing services to issuer at time
of offering.
Recap
www.360vlaw.com 24
óA few, large, experienced investors = JGood! óLots of small, novice investors, from
multiple states = L Bad!
Practice Tip: Convertible Notes
www.360vlaw.com 25
Short Version: ó Starts as an investor loan ó Investor gets a convertible promissory note that will
convert into stock on the next (first) round of funding ó No immediate dilution to founders, no shareholder
to babysit ó Investor gets a financial spiff for being early, typically
a conversion discount or warrant coverage
Convertible Notes
www.360vlaw.com 26
Why? ó Kicks the can down the road on valuation ó Keeps the capital structure cleaner ó Can be seen as win-win ó Usually easier & less contentious to negotiate
(less time and money)
Convertible Note
www.360vlaw.com 27
But wait, maybe not so simple ó Is the note secured? By real property, other hard assets,
intellectual property? ó Is there a personal guarantor? ó What is the term? ó Is there a price cap? ó Can the Newco prepay? What happens to the conversion? ó Holder’s discretion? Company discretion? Or automatic? ó What if Newco is purchased before maturity or conversion
(“Liquidity Event”)?
Convertible Note: Qualified Financing
www.360vlaw.com 28
ó Type of Stock - An equity financing selling Series
A Preferred stock ó Amount - Aggregate receipts to the company of
at least $1,000,000 óOne or more transactions ó By certain date
Convertible Note: Conversion Discount or Warrant Coverage
www.360vlaw.com 29
Conversion? At a “discount”? ó $100K Note. 20% Conversion Discount ó Series A comes in at $1 per share. ó So, Note holder will pay $0.80/share ó $100K in Note turned in for shares at $0.80 a
piece = 125,000 Series A shares
Convertible Note: Conversion Discount or Warrant Coverage
www.360vlaw.com 30
Warrant Coverage? ó $100K Note. 25% Warrant Coverage. ó So, Note Holder received penny warrants to
purchase Series A shares equal to $125K. ó Series A comes in priced at $1 per share. ó Note Holder exercises Warrants and receives
125,000 shares.
The Holy Grail – A Venture Deal
www.360vlaw.com 31
Transaction Docs ó Securities Purchase Agreement ó Restated Certificate of Incorporation or Certificate of
Designation ó Investor Rights Agreement (reg rights, affirmative and
negative covenants, preemptive right) ó Voting Agreement (board seats, drag along rights) ó Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement (founders give
company, then investors ROFR or allows investors to sell into proposed purchase)
Series A Deal Terms
www.360vlaw.com 32
ó Dividends ó Liquidation Preference (participating, non-participating) ó Conversion: optional (at holders request), mandatory
(QIPO) ó Anti-Dilution Protection: structural (splits, recaps), price
protection: ó Weighted average = (reasonably) J Good for company ó Full Ratchet = (ridiculously) L Bad for company
ó Pay to Play provisions
Series A Deal Terms
www.360vlaw.com 33
Control terms - Under GA law (and DE), preferred stock votes with common stock on an as-converted basis unless otherwise provided. ó Protective Provisions (aka blocking rights) ó Issuance of any other securities or any authorization or increase ó Liquidation of company, sale of all or substantially all ó Exclusive license ó Declaration/payment of dividends ó Incur debt over $xyz______ ó Any amendment to shareholder agreement, charter, etc.
Series A Deal Terms
www.360vlaw.com 34
Governance ó Investors to demand right to appoint certain
number of directors, probably majority, e.g. Common nominates and elects 2, Series A investors nominate and elect 3 óObserver rights ó Information rights
Series A Deal Terms
www.360vlaw.com 35
ó Registration Rights óDemand Rights óPiggyback rights ó Redemption – rarely (ever?) exercised, used as
leverage for investor
Series A Deal Terms
www.360vlaw.com 36
Agreements with Founders/Management team ó Restricted stock – retroactive vesting óOption Plan ó Employment Agreements ó Invention Assignment óNDA óNon-solicit, non-recruit