Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
1
Innovation is an uncertain process
• The development of a new and innovative product necessarily implies that at least some steps of the process are being done for the first time. Hence the spectrum of uncertainties is larger than in traditional industries.
• There are 3 types of innovation uncertainty factors:
- Market Uncertainties
- Technological Uncertainties
- Supply Uncertainties
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
4
Market Uncertainties
• According to Crockford (1986): “The launching of any new product involves risk that, however well the market has been researched, customers may reject it. The proportion of new products which survive to gain a significant market share is quite small. Even if it is well established, there is always the possibility that a change in needs, attitudes, taste and fashion may render it obsolete.”
• There are two kinds of high-technology products:
- Commercial
- Institutional
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
5
Commercial High-technology Products• Products designated for a large customer base.
• Examples: general purpose servo drives, MS Word software, PCs, biotechnology products.
• Market uncertainty can be reduced by thorough preliminary market research.
• Larger risk than institutional products. But, if successful, returns can be equally high.
• Market uncertainty can be reduced by reducing the lead time for development. Give all the necessary support and resources to the R& D team. The shorter the R&D time span, the better are the chances that the findings of the market study will still be relevant and accurate.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
6
Institutional High-technology products• Products designated for a specific single customer or a small group of
customers.
• Examples: Servomotor for injection axis of E-IMM, communication systems, information systems, traffic control systems, military high-technology systems.
• Supplier and receiver may have different interpretations of specifications. Communicate well with customers. Representative of customer may change. Maintain continuity.
• Give all the necessary support and resources to the R& D team to minimize lead time. The shorter the delivery time, the higher is the probability that the same people who represented the customer when the system was specified will be around to take delivery.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
7
Three general rules for reducing market uncertainties
• Maintain stability of market: conduct a solid needs analysis.
• Avoid depending one single large project: have no more than 10% of R&D resources to one project.
• Prepare contingency plans if any project has been given more than 10% R&D resources.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
8
Technological uncertainties
An innovative product has always new features : new concepts and ideas, novel product architecture, incorporation of new components and materials, and/or application of new technological processes.
Study the case study “Beating Concorde” here.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
9
Supply Uncertainties• An innovative product usually has many innovative
components, the presence of which implies certain supply risk.
• Traditional manufacturing often employs JIT. This may not be applicable in the case of innovative projects.
• Three simple rules for R&D projects:
- Avoid relying on a single supplier.
- If you have a choice between a novel system architecture rather than a critical component to achieve competitive advantage, choose the former.
- If a supply problem arises, immediately take contingency steps.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
10
Productmarket
pressures
Factor marketpressures
Techno-logical
pressures
Operatingand
organizational pressures
Technicalappraisal
Topmanagement
decisionProposals Innovate
How decisions leading to technological innovations may be made
Reject,delay
Develop
Furtherstudies
Level ofcommitment
Highermanagement
values andstrategic goalsExternal
Information(inventors,literature,
competitors,etc.)
InternalInformation(R&D results,
idea fromproduction and
sales depts,etc.)
Results
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
11
Risk Analysis• Institute a formal, internal Risk Analysis Group (RAG) for
each major project.
• Identify all major risk areas.
• After due discussion, estimate a probability of success (or failure) for each factor.
• Identify the consequences of failure. Estimate the cost of each failure.
• Multiply, failure probabilities with respective costs of failure.
• Decide.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
12
R&D Project AppraisalTwo methods:
1. Evaluate expected costs and benefits. Sum them up. Determine benefit-cost-ratio as a measure of return on investment.
2. Ansoff’s method: Determine Figures of Merit for (I) Profit, and (ii) Risk.
Often the method is a mirage because all the terms involved need to be estimated subjectively but consistently across all projects on hand.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
13
(profit)Merit of Figure
FORMULA sANSOFF'
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
14
Where
(Risk)Merit of Figure
)( (Profit)Merit of Figure
FORMULA sANSOFF'
p
arr
d
pabt
FM
CFM
JC
SPEPMM
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
15
(Profit)Merit of Figure
etc. staff, ,facilities extra ofcost Total
research applied ofcost Total
resources shared fromfactor Saving
costt developmen Total
fit Strategic
npenetratiomarket successful ofy Probabilit
Success ofy Probabilit
lifetimeover earnings totalEstimated
Merit Business
Merit calTechnologi
p
ar
d
p
s
b
t
M
F
C
J
C
S
P
P
E
M
M
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
16
RISK MANAGEMENT
Risk Identification
Risk Analysis
RiskAssessment
RiskClassification
Risk Treatment/Prevention
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
17
Risk AnalysisSimplified Delphi Method
[gen Schoon]
1. Form an Expert Group• Odd number, 1 Project Manger + 1-3 Team
Members + 1-3 Experts not belonging to the Project Team + 1 Lateral Thinker + 1 Moderator.
• Decision makers such as senior management, superiors to project team members, and steering committee members should not be part of the group.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
18
• The estimation of each individual risk is repeated as each milestone is reached.
• All risks are checked if they happen to be on the Critical Path of the project.
• Consecutive risks are also checked.• Consecutive risks are not to be estimated by the
expert members.• It is advisable to use an appropriate software tool.,
e.g. Monte-Carlo Analysis.• Classify the risks.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
19
200 400 600 800 Loss ($1000)
Pro
babi
lity
100
50
00
P1
P2
P3
P4
Risk AnalysisThe four areas are delineated by the General Manager
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
20
2. The Group of experts checks list of risks:• Advantages of checklists: Simple but
recognizable. Easy to update.• Disadvantages of Checklists: Grows quickly to
extensive volume. Difficult to obtain an overview.• Hence, checklists must be structured.• Classification marks such as GE = general, TE =
technical, AX = auxiliary, BU = business, ST = staff, AB = ambient, SU = supplier, CT = contracts can support structuring the risk checklists.
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
21
3. The expert group estimates and prioritizes
the risks:
• See sample on next slide.
• Estimate in terms of Consequence and Probability.
• Consequence (enterprise view):
High Medium Low
• Probability of happening:
High (>80%) Medium Low (<20%)
• Priority: 1. HH 2. HM/MH 3. MM
4. HL/LH 5. ML/LM 6. LL
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
22
Type of Risk Likely EffectConsequence Probability
Priority
1
5
3
6
4
8
7
9
2
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
abc
x
abc abc
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
H
x
LM LMH
MH
LL
HM
ML
LL
HM
MH
LH
HL
Risk Management, Manage,mment of Technological Innovation, KV Patri
23
Risk Treatment: Alternative Methods
Elimination: Changes in the business processes.Implementation of proven technologies.Extensive investments (negative).Cost-benefit ratio versus Risk Probability.
Acceptance: No costs for risk treatment.Contingency fund needed if risk probability is high (negative).
Assurance: Assumption: Risk is assurable.Of interest only if premium to pay risk is low but the risk has a high probability and high losses.
Hand-over: Risk is “handed over” to a sub-contractor.Requires specific form of contract.Is there any benefit in passing risk to the contractor?
Decrease: Preventive actions to be taken.