Sangita Kulathinal, University of Helsinki & INSEED organization and Minna Säävälä, Väestöliitto
The global spread of the two child norm:
Examples from India
Launching seminar ’Precarious family formation’,
Väestöliitto, Helsinki 19th April 2012
The two ’billionaires’
• India population 1.2 billion (2011 Census)• China population 1.3 billion
o 36 % of the world’s population lives in China and India
o India expected to pass China’s population by 2025
• Most populous state Uttar Pradesh: 200 million people, more than in Brazil
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi2
Population projections: India till 2065
Source: Population Division of the Department of Economic and Social Affairs of the United Nations Secretariat, World Population Prospects: The 2010 Revision, http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/index.htm
’000
Indian population scenario
• Total Fertility Rate 2.6 children per woman (est. 2011)
• Wide regional differences: o Northern ’Hindi belt’: still high fertility of 3-4 children o Southern and Western states: mostly replacement
level fertility or below 2.1 children
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi4
Two-child norm in India
• Long history of national population policies• Slogan ’Small family is a happy family’• The key is social development, not indoctrination
in a democratic country
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi5
• Two child norm has been adopted o in most urban areas, o in large parts of the rural areas in the country o in all socio-economic groups in South and West
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi6
Small family, happy family
We two, ours two
We two, ours two
If girl child is brutely killed then where will you get brides from?
Unintended consequence of the two child norm
• Fertility decline in starkly patriarchal societies:o A son has to be secured
• Gender imbalance in 0-6 year-olds growing• Situation not as grave as in China, a later
phenomenon• Will affect marriage market• But: will India follow the path of China?
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi11
Child sex ratio worsened continuously
1991 2001 2011
India 945 927 914
Maharashtra 946 913 883
Source: Census of India
n.b. Girls to 1000 boys aged 0 to 6
Sub-study in India
• Survey data and qualitative interviews in two slums in Nashik, Maharashtra, Western India
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi14
Mumbai
Nashik
We ask in our study
• Is the two child norm going to lead to spread of one child norm, like in China?
• What are slum youth thinking of the future and what are their family formation intentions?
• Are people aware of the emerging future problem of finding brides? Is marriage age and system of spouse selection changing?
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi15
India is moving towards“We two, ours one”
Thank you for your attention!
Esittäjä, yksikkö, pvmVÄESTÖLIITTO Etunimi Sukunimi17