Science, Technology and Innovation (STI),
Growth and Development
Michael LimPolicy Review Section
Science, Technology and ICT BranchUNCTAD-DTL
P166 short course on STI and development12 December 2011
Geneva
2
Outline
• Technology and economic growth• Technology and innovation• The importance of STI• Innovation and innovation systems• Conclusions
3
The Global Distribution of Knowledge
(from UNCTAD LDCR 2007)
4
The Global Distribution of Poverty (from UNCTAD LDCR 2007)
5
Economic growth and income trends: 3 big issues to explain
• There is huge variation in per capita income across countries. Why?
• There is huge variation in growth across countries. Why?
• Global growth was close to zero until about 1500, rose slightly until about 1800, and has accelerated since 1800. Growth patterns varied by region and country (and this continues). Why?
6
Technology and economic growth (1)
• Output (Y) is a function of capital (K), labour (L) and technology (T)
Y=f(K, L, T) orOutput (Y) is a function of physical capital (Kp), human capital (Kh), labour (L), and technology (T)Y=f(Kp, Kh, L, T)
In standard neoclassical growth theory Y =T*f(Kp, Kh, L) with technology (T) exogenous (external) ie T=f(?) T is unexplained
Kp=f(Kpt, It) It is new investment in physical capitalKh=f(Kht, Iht) Iht new investment in education, training and healthL=f(Lt, grL) grL is population growth (t is time)
7
Technology and economic growth (2)
• Economic growth is directly a function of Kp, Kh and improved technologies.
• Controversy over the relative importance of each.
• Additional growth determinants: Initial conditions; institutions and incentive structures; geography; national policies; perhaps culture.
8
Technology and economic growth: historical viewpoints (3)
• Neoclassical: Technology is exogenous (unexplained), but drives productivity of labour and capital.
• Adam Smith (1770s): labour specialization and innovative production processes increase productivity.
• Karl Marx (1850s): technology-driven economy and social relations.
• Friedrich List (1880s): importance of national policy frameworks, government coordination of learning, knowledge, technology to promote innovation.
• Joseph Schumpeter (1930s): creative destruction, competition and new firm entry (entrepreneurship) create innovation; types of innovation.
• Endogenous growth theory: increasing returns from knowledge accumulation through development of technology, human capital and R&D (Paul Romer).
• Evolutionary economics: learning required for technological progress, cumulative learning, path dependency etc.
• Innovations systems theory: technology and innovation are endogenous, depend on complex, dynamic systems (Chris Freeman, B.A. Lundvall, Richard Nelson 1980s/90s).
9
Innovative Capabilities and Income
(from UNCTAD LDCR 2007)Real per capita income and innovative capabilities, 2001
10
The technology frontier is dynamic
t2 t3
t1
11
Why STI is important• Building strong STI capabilities, accessing foreign technologies and
building strong national systems of innovation are important for economic growth and development, social welfare and addressing environmental challenges.
• STI applications: -improving productivity in manufacturing, agriculture and services-increasing value added locally-diversifying production into knowledge-intensive activities-mitigating/adapting to climate change-developing new energy sources (renewable energy technologies RETs)-building good infrastructure-conserving water in agriculture-improving public services (health, education)-addressing disease epidemics-organizing large and mega-cities (smart urban planning)-early warning systems for natural disasters (tsunamis, hurricanes)-adapting buildings for earthquake prone zones-slowing desertification etc.
12
STI capabilities: what are they? (1)
• Scientific, technological and innovative capabilities.
• Broad definition add capabilities in engineering, other technical capabilities, entrepreneurship, management and organizational capabilities.
• SET, S&T, STEM.
13
STI capabilities: What are they? (2)
• Scientific capabilities – the ability to learn, understand and apply scientific knowledge and skills to solve problems.
• Engineering capabilities – the ability to learn, understand and apply engineering knowledge and skills to solve problems.
• Technological capabilities – the ability to learn, understand and master the use of existing (both traditional and recent) technologies to solve problems and to produce new technologies.
• Innovative capabilities – the ability to innovate.
• Technological learning by enterprises (firms and farmers most importantly) is important for technological development of a country.
• Policy learning by STI policymakers also important.
14
What is technology?
• Technology - knowledge applied to the production of goods or services or solving practical problems.
• Different forms: machinery, processes and knowledge- physical machinery -production processes -software -codified and tacit knowledge
• Knowledge – the theoretical or practical understanding of a subject.
15
What is innovation?
• New to world: the introduction for the first time by an organization (or person) of a novel product or process that is new to the world.
• New to the firm/industry: The introduction of new or improved products, or of new or improved processes and organizational methods in the design, production and distribution of goods and services.
• Invention: U.S. Patent Law: a new, useful process, machine, improvement, etc., that did not exist previously and that is recognized as the product of some unique intuition or genius, as distinguished from ordinary mechanical skill or craftsmanship.
• Innovation vs invention
16
Types of innovation• All along the production value chain: design,
production, distribution and marketing.• Technological (related to the introduction of new
technologies) or non-technological (organizational, managerial or institutional).
• Based on formal training and R&D or based on informal learning, trial and error, use and experience
• Size of impact: -Incremental/marginal (through small improvements)-radical (through major breakthroughs)-revolutionary (a fundamentally important new technology is created).
17
What drives innovation?
• Two basic conceptual approaches:• Linear approaches• The systems approach
18
Linear models of innovation
19
National systems of innovation(source: Arnold and Bell (2001))
Framework conditions▪ Financial environment
▪ Taxation and incentives▪ Propensity for innovation and entrepreneurship
▪ Trust▪ Mobility
▪ Education, Literacy
Demand▪ Consumers (final demand)
▪ Producers (intermediate demand)
Business system
▪ Companies
▪ Farms
▪ Healthcare, etc
Education and research system
▪ Professional education and
training
▪ Higher education and
research
▪ Public sector research
Intermediate Organizations
▪ Research institutes
▪ Brokers, etc
Infrastructure
▪ Banking, venture capital
▪ IPR and information
system
▪ Innovation and business
support system
▪ Standards and norms
20
National systems of innovation(source: OECD (1999))
21
Sectoral IS: an agricultural innovation system
(from Spielman and Birner (2008), adapted from Arnold and Bell (2001)).
22
Ag
ricu
ltu
ral
Inn
ova
tion
Sys
tem
sMacroeconomic &
International Regulatory
Environment
Physical Infrastructur
e
Farming & Soil
ConditionsSector Performance Growth, Jobs,
Competitiveness
Product Market
Conditions
Education System & Training
Agricultural Knowledge Generation, Diffusion and Use
Firms and Networks
Science supplier
s
Research &
standard Setting Bodies
Supporting Institutions
FARMERS
Global Innovation Global Innovation networksnetworks
National Innovation National Innovation SystemSystem
Indu
stry, o
ther
Indu
stry, o
ther
supply
led syste
ms &
su
pply
led syste
ms &
va
lue c
hain
sva
lue c
hain
s
Reg
ion
al
inn
ova
tion
s R
eg
ion
al
inn
ova
tion
s sy
stem
ssy
stem
s
Agricultural Innovation Capacity
Source: UNCTAD Technology and Innovation Report 2010, Adapted from OECD, Managing National Innovation Systems, 1999
23
Some central tenets of evolutionary economics and the IS framework
• knowledge important (not just information)• learning and decisions are made under high levels of uncertainty• focus more on production than consumption• based on dynamic comparative advantage, not static comparative
advantage• production patterns and export specialization matter a lot• government and market both have a role; activist state needed –
technology markets highly imperfect – social returns higher than private ones)
• financial markets often work poorly in financing innovation• market failures occur but also systemic failures, state intervention
is to correct systemic failures (and market failures)• markets do not find an equilibrium• firms innovate in a system (and are not atomistic and independent)• institutions (formal and informal) important for collaboration and
learning as well as contract enforcement• uneven development (not convergence) among countries probable
without activist state promoting learning and innovation
24
Problems with IS framework
• The IS framework is useful but imperfect.• It is a complex tool to use because the systems
are complex and dynamic.• There is much conceptual work on IS, but
limited empirical work on building IS.• The boundaries of an IS are not completely
clear; IS are very broad.• It is not prescriptive in nature, so inadequate
for detailed guidance with policy prescriptions.• It remains a useful but possibly inadequate
framework used on its own.
25
How to build innovation systems?
• Strong innovation systems may develop only very slowly.
• Developing countries often have emerging, incomplete, weak innovation systems.
• NSI are context specific; have historical roots; embedded in local social and institutional setting; no single, ideal system for all countries (no one-size-fits-all).
• National policies can help accelerate the process.
• Problem: How to build them is not well understood; no blueprint.
• Policy experimentation and policy learning needed.
26
Conclusions
• Strong STI capabilities, human capital, access to technologies (and absorption), and effective innovation systems are important for sustainable and inclusive growth and development, improving social welfare, solving environmental problems.
• Policymakers should think about how to build each. How can policies make a difference?
27
Discussion issues
• What is the purpose of science: conquer nature? Help mankind?
• Is technology always good? • Is innovation always good?• Do all countries innovate?• Can STI solve all our problems?• Does technology create new
problems?
28