Role of NGOs in Development: Case Study from Oxfam in India
Presentation made to Semester at Sea
Nisha Agrawal, CEO, Oxfam India
October 6, 2011
Topics to be Covered
1.The Global Challenges2.Oxfam International’s Role 3.The Challenges in India 4.The Role of Oxfam India
The Challenge of Increasing Equity within
Ecological Limits
Pop: 7bn
2010 2050
Resource share of the worst off 20% of people
Ecological impact of global resource use
Pop: 9bn
Planetary boundaries
Three Global Challenges• The Earth’s population is expected to grow from 7 billion
today to 9 billion by 2050
• Even as global population significantly expands, we must deal with three challenges
1. The Sustainability Challenge--Reduce the impacts of consumption to within sustainable limits;
2. The Equity Challenge--Redistribute consumption towards the poorest; and
3. The Resilience Challenge—Reduce vulnerability to climate change.
Topics to be Covered
1.The Global Challenges2.Oxfam International’s
Role 3.The Challenges in India 4.The Role of Oxfam India
What is Oxfam?• Oxfam was formed almost 70
years ago in 1942 to respond to a food crisis in Greece during World War II; it is an example of a major global institution being created by a few active citizens coming together to provide a solution to a perceived problem
Demanding Rights for All6
Oxfam International
• Today, it is an international confederation with 15 members--Australia, Belgium, Canada, France, Germany, Great Britain, Hong Kong, India, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, Netherlands, Quebec, Spain, and the US
Demanding Rights for All7
A Growing Family
• Oxfam India is the newest member of the Confederation; two new Oxfam's are currently forming (Japan and Italy) and few more are likely to be formed by 2020 (in places like Brazil, South Africa and others) to align with the new power structure (G20, IBSA, BRICSAM) of a multi-polar world so that we can tackle global problems together
Demanding Rights for All8
Oxfam’s Identity• Oxfam is a network of rights-
based, advocacy organizations that fight poverty and injustice by linking grassroots programming done through partner NGOs to local, national, regional, and global advocacy and policymaking
Demanding Rights for All9
Topics to be Covered
1. The Global Challenges2. Oxfam International’s Role 3. The Challenges in India 4. The Role of Oxfam India
Context for Big Bang Liberalization in India in 1991
• Balance of payments crisis in 1991
• Elections in 1991 of a new Government
• Abandoning of piece meal approach to reforms and launching systemic reforms
Poverty has declined…but still high
1990 2010
Official Poverty Rate %
45.3 32.2
Demanding Rights for All12
Topics to be Covered
1. The Global Challenges2. Oxfam International’s Role 3. The Challenges in India 4. The Role of Oxfam India
Vibrant Civil Society in India• By some estimates there are about
3.3 million NGOs in India (one each for 400 people); the number of NGOs grew at an average annual rate of 10% between 2006 and 2009; on average, over the past 3 years, 700 NGOs opened every day (India Philanthropy report, Bain and Company, 2011)
Demanding Rights for All14
Changing role of NGOs • With growing resources of the Indian
government as it becomes a middle income country, as well as the emergence of a number of other players, in particular, the middle class and the corporate sector, the traditional role of NGOs is changing from direct service delivery for the poor and marginalized to a much more complex and challenging one--to evidence building and advocacy.
Demanding Rights for All15
Evidence Based Advocacy
• “In a context where many social programs have to be implemented and fine-tuned, civil society has an important role to play in gathering data about successful social policies and to point out gaps or failures. It will need to generate information at the community level and bring it into a debate at local and national levels” (Dubochet, 2011)
Demanding Rights for All16
What Can Bring About Change? s
1. Empowering the poor and marginalized to demand their rights;
2. Engaging the middle class—especially the youth--to become active citizens
3. Advocating for an effective and accountable state;
4. Working with corporations to create better opportunities for poor people
5. Working with India as a global player
Empowering the poor to demand their rights
• A lot of good laws (Right to Information, Right to Education, Right to Work), policies and programs are now in place
• The challenge is in their implementation
• There is a huge challenge to build the capacity of the poor and marginalized to demand their rights Demanding Rights for All18
Engaging the middle class to become active citizens
• The middle class in India has tended to be urban, upper caste, educated, exclusionary
• Need to work with them to change attitudes and behaviors towards a more inclusive development path
Demanding Rights for All19
Advocating for an effective and accountable state
• “The Indian state in our view is beholden to guarantee special measures and safeguards to protect the rights and universal entitlements for the most socially excluded people residing within its jurisdiction. All planning and development processes should be inclusive of all socially excluded groups”
Demanding Rights for All20
Engaging with corporations for better CSR policies and
practices• The Corporate sector is growing
and changing rapidly in India• Traditionally, civil society has
played a watchdog role to hold businesses accountable on human, social, and economic rights of communities; this role is even more vital todayDemanding Rights for All21
Influencing India as a global player
• India’s international position is one of increasing influence and assertiveness
• In recent years, in several international negotiations (trade, climate change), India has emerged as an influential actor; it is also a member of G20Demanding Rights for All22
• Thank you for your attention
Demanding Rights for All23
Roadmap
Visit us at http://www.oxfamindia.org
Demanding Rights for All