Technology
Dr. Joe O’Mahoney 2007
Questions: 07906133649
Agenda
1. What is Technology?
2. The Magic Bullet Theory (Determinism)
3. The Failure of the Bullet
4. Other Stories
- Social Determinism
- Marxist Approaches
- Social Construction
The Agenda
Questions: 07906133649
1. Technolgy: a way of doing something
- Achitecture, Facebook, Recipes, Printers
- Constrains and enables
2. Organisational Implementations
- No ‘neutral’ effects
- Disrupts power relations
- Unintended consequences
What is Technology?
Questions: 07906133649
The Magic Bullet
Questions: 07906133649
• Planned
• Rational
• Good
•Determinist
Questions: 07906133649
The Battle of Tours, A.D. 732
Saracens vs. Germans
Questions: 07906133649Questions: 07906133649
The Stirrup
Triumph of Technology
Questions: 07906133649
Philosophy of Determinism
• Technology strategy as rational and planned
• Clear investment decision
• Technology determines outcomes
• Doesn’t account for social ‘translation’
• Doesn’t account for structural context
• Preece, 1999; McLoughlin and Harris 1997
Questions: 07906133649
Rational, planned, strategic…..
Source: Preece, D.A. Organisations and Technical Change: Strategy, Objectives and Involvement, Routledge/ITBP (1995), p.7.
The Failure of Rational Views?
Questions: 07906133649
Failure of Magic Bullets
• Failures– 25% projects don’t meet requirements – 31% projects cancelled – 53% over-run on costs– 80% don’t meet objectives– NHS // 3G // Passport Service // Boo.com
Questions: 07906133649
Utility of the ‘Rational’
“The telephone has too many shortcomings to be seriously considered as a means of communications. The device has no value.” Western Union 1876
“I see no reason to suppose that these machines will ever force themselves into general use." Duke of Wellington (1852) Referring to steam locomotives.
“There is no reason anyone would want a computer in their home.” Ken Olsen, President of DCE, 1977
“I think there is a world market for maybe five computers.”Thomas Watson, Chairman of IBM, 1943
Questions: 07906133649
Bigger failures?
Questions: 07906133649
Different Views?
Questions: 07906133649
A. Social Determinism?
Questions: 07906133649
Social determinism?
• SRBs
• Trains
• Chariots
• The Horse’s Arse
Questions: 07906133649
Racist Architecture?
• Robert Moses
• Low bridges
• Social exclusion
Winner, L. ‘Do Artefacts Have Politics?’ Daedelus 109 (1980)
Social Shaping of Technology (SST)
• Reflecting and affecting society
• Technology as a political tool
• Historical and material contraints
Questions: 07906133649
B. Marxist
Control & Deskilling in Ford
• Skilled workers have more power, so….
• Simplification of tasks
• Automation of tasks
= Redundant, deskilled, weak workerforce
e.g. McDonaldization (Ritzer)
But… little evidence (Nelson, D.1992 ‘Scientific management
in retrospect’ in A mental revolution: Scientific management since Taylor)
Questions: 07906133649
Surveillence & Invisible Control
• The panopticon
• You never know when you’re being watched
• Self-disciplining
• Prisons, asylums, car plants, the internet
Questions: 07906133649
Technology as Capitalist Control
• Use by those managers to control & re-present workers
• Managerial rhetoric of ‘modern’, ‘flexible’, “hi-tech”
• Fit with capitalist consumerism of new things…..
Questions: 07906133649
C. Social Constructivism
Questions: 07906133649
A Matter of Interpretation?
• US hi-tech weapons
• Hi-jacked with knives
• Boeing 767 became a missile
• Technology as a social product
Questions: 07906133649
Bikes….
• To Men
• To Women
• To Manufacturers
Bijker, W. (1995): Of Bicycles, Bakelites, and Bulbs
Questions: 07906133649
• A range of options championed by different groups
• Concerns are cultural, moral and political, not just technical
• Change occurs through power struggles / consensus
Social Constructivism
Questions: 07906133649
Conclusions
Questions: 07906133649
Sociological
• Social Determinist– Technology reflecting society– Material and social constraints to new ideas
• Marxist– Sees technology as ‘deskilling’ workers (Braverman, 1974)
– Technology for surveillance & control (Sewell, 1998)
• Social Constructivist– Different groups seeing technology differently (Zuboff, 1988)
– Human aspects ignored (Walton & McKersie, 1991)
– Domination of technologists (Bailey, 1993; Preece, 1999)
Case
Questions: 07906133649
Case Questions
• What are the costs and benefits of the introduction of the snowmobile for the Lapplanders?
• Could the introduction of new technology have been better managed? How?
• What different perspectives can be applied to help understand the effects of this technology?