8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
1/62
Economic Policy PaPEr SEriES 09
The Farm Bill and Beyond
dan morgan
ransatlantic Fellow, German Marshall Fund o the United States
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
2/62
2009 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States. All rights reserved.
No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing
rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF). Please direct inquiries to:
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States
1744 R Street, NW
Washington, DC 20009
1 202 683 2650
F 1 202 265 1662
Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at http://www.gmus.org/publications/index.cm. Limited print
copies are also available. o request a copy, send an e-mail to [email protected].
gmF Pp Ss
Te GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta, ellows, and partners o the GermanMarshall Fund o the United States. Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the
view o GMF. Comments rom readers are welcome; reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to [email protected].
abut gmF
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) is a non-partisan American public policy and grant-making institu-
tion dedicated to promoting greater cooperation and understanding between North America and Europe.
GMF does this by supporting individuals and institutions working on transatlantic issues, by convening leaders to discuss
the most pressing transatlantic themes, and by examining ways in which transatlantic cooperation can address a variety o
global policy challenges. Working in partnership with the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, GMFs work on trade,
agriculture, and development aims to promote greater cooperation between the United States and Europe on trade and
agricultural policies as vital instruments o global prosperity.
Founded in 1972 through a gi rom Germany as a permanent memorial to Marshall Plan assistance, GMF maintains a
strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic. In addition to its headquarters in Washington, DC, GMF has seven ofces in
Europe: Berlin, Bratislava, Paris, Brussels, Belgrade, Ankara, and Bucharest.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
3/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond
Economic Policy Paper Series
November 2009
B D Mg
Fw, G M F U S1
1 K G, FP., j w G M F w. GMF P S, w , w, G M F U S. w x w GMF. C w; - @g.g.
S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
R E Bg . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
N S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
M, P, F L . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
D Eg . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D Wk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
C. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
R Ck: P Bk P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
L L . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
S Gg F. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
-C Eg . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
P. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
A: A Nw P Ag? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
4/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
5/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 3
Summary
M Cg w- ( F, C
Eg A 8), g
Wg .
P g g
w
. A ,
g g
E P Ag (EPA)
g g k
g
g- . A
W H, w g k , g
gg w
g
g .
g-g
g g.
L g j
gz g
g O Agg
q. g
g g, g
. B Nw Ag , w
w Ag S Vk,
g gz,
g,
g w w
k
w g g ;
gg w, , q; g
; g
; gg
, gw . W OAg z U.S.
g ,
Nw Ag
g, , g
, ,
.
x x 8 , w w g
g x ,
g, , , , U.S.
g g .
I Cg, g
g. M w k
,
g
. M, wg
D P g
Ag, --D w g
g
g.
8 w
w D j
Cg. I H, D
-
D w-
. w k, N P,
w w H Ag
C C C P w g
1 D w,
k g. , w wg
D .
I S, w g ex parte
-- j
. Wkg
Ag C C Hk
(D-Iw), g k
S g ( S GOP ) w
g w -
g-
D Mg, Pg L Ag W Pk,Te Washington Post, Ag. , , g E5. ://www.wg./w-////7/4/AR74.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
6/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States4
G P ( SD g).
w x k
,
g, g
gz, wg,
w j
g g
.
g w
: k g
, w, w
w ;
g x
z g ;
g
g ,
, , w g.
g
g,
g ( S
N A Pg, SNAP),
g k ( g S Ag
C C Hk),
g g
, w gg
, g ,
k. I ,
$75
g .
A g, gg g
gz g g
g , k g g.
I k w
D j
g gw
, , g. B
g j w g g
w .
g
k, g
w w . A
w: W w
g w
z w g.
kw w g.
g k .
N, Cg k
:
, g , ,
- , g
g U.S. g, g
, w g
.
w , ,
g
g w w g -1. I
. Cg w
g $1
- ,
g .
A j w g (S R
A P, SURE) w
w kg w-
. Ag C R E
(ACRE) w g g w w ,
k g.
I w g
.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
7/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 5
g w k , w
U.S. .
w U.S.
g g U.S.
g , P G, x
A B Ag
R E.
W ? I ,
kg wg
g gg. F U
S , . I ,
Cg g : g
w, M M g
, . D
($1. 8) g
$3 U.S. g, g
.4 . F g
, C P
w w wk
.
R 7
8. kw D R
k
Ag g
w g.
g U.S. w g
w z
w ,
wg k w, g
. Ex , -
g g
.
I , g
g
g gz
g w
g. w
S Mj L H R
(D-N) g w gz 7. P w k
g , :
, g k g
S. 3
M w w gz
w D j H
S
g . M w
w P k P
. I S, D
w F Bg U G P wk
g g.
F w
D j 78,
k g, g g
w Ag
. P
g, w
. S gz
. O g
w g
$5
x w
w gg
g .
R
U.S. , , ,
g gw ( , )
Mx, C, A, L
A.4 g w g
5 W Ogz g
U.S. g
xg g g w
3 S. R k, J M, q.
4 Cq, Ox I g ,N 5.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
8/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States6
. B q x w U.S.
, g, ggg
g g .
F x, 4 World Policy Journal
g
A,
() w g
.5 gg
W NGO , ,
,
A kg g g g.
USDA g g
( w U.S.
) w g
1 .
w g g w
g .
, ww U.S. w k
8 w
gg w g
higherU.S. , w g
.6
g w g, g,
g
g
. Cg
, w, gwg
g Ag.
H g w
w g w g
Cg x , D P g
5 M A B, A B Ag P, World Policy Journal, V. XXI, N. .
6 Cg w g 5 1 8 .
k D 8. (H D H
Ag C
R S. J MC [Az]
8; 13 8 g
g g
x w w .)
I S, O Ag
g g
S. B L (D-Ak)
C S Ag C.
S , , ,, kg . Hk, w
, w D
w
. I
g , L
gw g S
gw, w g
w . H R
, S. Sx C (R-Gg),
kg w
g g
, w w S g. L w
x D k
g : I wk
g g,
w g -g gg
g 1 - g. L w
w
, ,
gw k
( k Ak-
F, w g
k , k, k).
G 8
g x
g,
w . O w
7, g j 117
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
9/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 7
H 37 S. P B ( g
w w
Cg) w
gg
g w- q.
O , g
Ag
g wk NGO.
g, g w
g ,
g. gg gg
q w
g. B
g ,
.
M g
w ime gz,
, R C C
F7w w
w w Food, Inc.
B
-; w
g , , ww,
(g z
); ,
; . Dz
g
U.S. g
. , w,
x g
. Hw,
g, ,
, w
( ) w-
7 B W, T R C C F, ime gz,Ag. 31, .
. A
gwk x
.
O kg
g 78.
x two x-z
:
g g w g
g. I 8 g g
$8 ( ), g
g
.8
I, Ag B
Dg D w g
g
gg
g g. A
g w
g
g g,
w
A -k, .
G
w (j
g g w
), w w g
g x x.
8 USDA, E R S, Ag. 6, , - , M Z, DN Mg Ag B g, Ag. 8,.
w g WO g g. F , C H, Iw S U C Ag R D F AgP R I, H AgC g ,A 6, 6, ://www...//HH..
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
10/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States8
D g 8w $1. , 5 w 37
g.1 B g
.
O g
w x 1
. F x,
-
. Ag S
Vk gg g- k w
gz. Y g g w
g. S g,
N A W Gw F. Hw, wk
k j
w g .
A j g w
x wk
w O-Vk ,
Ag
. I w w
g w
. g ,
.
E g
gg kwg
w g
g ,
. B g
g g.
I ,
w w g w
. O w
w w . j
g , notg
g .
1 USDA, E R S.
M, g z
g
g w , g, . I
w
gg g. k
g
-g . F ,
w g w w
g g-
g (w w F L
M O) g g ,-,
w.
,
. Nw
Wg wg
w Ag .
g
, x , E
P Ag.
gg g
g -w g g
k g
q g
g 1. F g
w k. Ag
g g
g g g,
w
. I w g
g , x , ,
. Y g
Cg w g g
. I , w
k .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
11/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 9
. I wk
. A F B
F, g S
g, g g
w N F U .
I , g , w, ,
g, g gw .
C gw w g
g, w gw
q.
g gw ()
(); g -k g, , (
)
w ( )
g .
E H Ag C,
g,
w O Ag Nw Ag .
8 g w
11 w D , , Og
M. w D
Nw Yk S j ,
P.
g 8 Ag
C D ,
g wg
w g g .
B 7 11 . O ,
B Mk C, O
AgNw Ag . Vg gw g, Mk . W
g C ,
w
w g .
I g w
, w w , k
,
w w x
.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
12/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
13/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 11
The Reform Effort Begins
1
G g 1. Aw- D w
g w H.
A Cg R
K w g
, g
w g g.11
I 7 - H
qk W g
g . F 1, w
K R g J Fk
(Az) M 7 w 1 H, w w
. S. R Lg (R-I)
w S.
F 1 w ,
, g
k g (RMA)
. w
g w g
$ .
F w j g $,
w g w g, w
g w
. B
g , g
g, w g ,
w gw g.1
F w K, g
g g.
11 T w $1
, g g W R C R g,g w g , g $5 w g . Ag H w, k K.
1 Aw M, Mkg W D, he New Yorkimes, J , 7, S C, g 1.
U.S. g gw Nw D . Rg
g w - U.S.
w k
g
G D. g w
w g
g . g
g g
, g
z .
g
gw g k w .
A w
Cg xg g g
g ,
g g
g k.
P 8 , I (
) g (g
z ) w
k (
) : w,
, , g g, , , g-
g , -g , .
( k, ,
w g
8.) S,
g ,
g, , w, , . Dz
g z,
. Lk
g g
g. A :
g, , ;
W w j; gzg g
; kg
, g, gg
q w k;
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
14/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States12
S 3, w g g , g, ,
.13 B g
g . A g
x x
g w w- A.
Fw
k
z . A
g, U
S w .Fg q k . W,
, , g
g (w
g w
w ),
. O ,
, g gw,
k g --
g .14 (W
k U
S , q
k .)
E , g
w g
.
13 S 3 64-- g g Nw D.I w U.S. C B P. W g, g $1.5 , ,
. S ( ) w g- , , , q -kg , g Cg R S.
14 S Ak K. M, H S. E-O, M J. M,J D. J, J W. Hk. I, W E W-Bg H, E RS, U.S. D Ag, Ag ER N. 81, g 6.
I 157, Pz Pzwg L Sw A
.15 M
gg. B 3w
- g
w
g $665,, g w
w g $6,.16
( C x
w-
g .)
M g g. Ag USDA, 5
ggg
j w ,
g U.S.
. Cgg
g gg
g g g
, 6 W H .17
B A. Bk C H Iw S
U gg 4 w
g, , z
,
k w
w k- g.18
I, g .
F x:
w, , x-z
. O w
15 L S, Farm rouble, (P, N.J.: P
U P, 157).16 M M J J, Ag EI 3, A W , U.S. D Ag, E R S, O 3.
17 E R P, F 6.
18 B A. Bk C H, Rk F Fg? IwAG Rw , W 4.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
15/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 13
g. . A 8
( 7
8 gwg)
g
w x 6
.1 M ,
g gw,
g, g
x. Y gw g
g .
B USDA :
F S Ag
g w , Rk
Mg Ag,
.
USDA $5
w
x .
k ,
w gwg.
, , w
w w 1-
P 1- A. A
g,
g ,
w w.
1 T g g k w , g S R Ag. I 7 B, g , j
g g g w USDA. Cg . Lw w w .
A w g, Lk G Mg (LGM), g . I w g g w w k k .
I g -.N .1
U S g
, ,
z ,
gw w .1
I
w g w
g w
. C
g 7,
$ ( k). I 6,
(LDP) g,
gwk $3.8
w k
w g .
(W
w g ,
,
w
g k .)3
B I w w
. Ig g-
g
w g g
g g
. W g ,
w
wk. B w
16.
1 T g z g , ( w w), k .
D Mg, C F P B S S Fw,he Washington Post, S. 8, 7, S A, g 1.
3 D Mg, S C, G G, Gw RB E G Y, he Washington Post, J 3, 6.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
16/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
17/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 15
Gw. A F , g , g
g I,
g
. Hg gz g
w Rk Swz, w x
x g.
Swz w E D.
A g N 4
E D S F g
. I $15
, - , ,, g, , , ,
g, gz
U.S. x
. w g U.S.
g
g
w , g
w
w.
. g
I g
w g-
g gz
w w g.
F w
w g g. G
g , ,
g w g
q.
Og g w
g g
kg Rk
W F Hw . I
w
g g. S
g- g
z q w
g ,g, ,
z w
. W U.S.
gz g
(z, , .) ,
Hw z
kg
g,
, g g
w. Hw F g
w g
g, g j .
Hw w G
M F U S (GMF), w,
U.S. ,
g . F
GMF,
w w k
w U.S. E g
,
.3
B gg
g NGO.
G M A (GMA),31
g g g
K F,
Hw g , g , EWkg G, E D, AF , B W, Ox A, CzAg G W, x C S, C R A, N W F, C I, I F P R I, G M F U S.
3 A GMF w w Cg he Washington Post . GMF w K G, j ,g g w w, FP..
31 GMA g w F P A J7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
18/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States16
C S, P, j . I, C M. (C) D, w
D C g,
wg j
gz g.3
(I w g , w Cg,
D g
, j C V
.) R G, ,
w , -
C Gw, q
. G F
g E D, RG kg g.
H w
g w
g .
Sgg w
B W, w
C
gg k g
, gg
w g . g
w A g , R.D Bk, gz ,
- A
w g z U.S. w
k. A , B W
g 7. U
kg
, gz
g I.
B W w
g . I w
g gz, w g wk
g . S
Ag C C Hk
3 D w x AC C.
w . L P, C g w
w H Bg
C, w .33 (Y
kw w gg , w
j g g
w . B .) I
S 6 gz
wk .
wg , Atlanta Journal-
Constitution ,
w , : A g ,
g g
. Ox g w Y B,
L, Kk
w Pzz H B
1 ,
. S, , F P
A, g
g g.34
B 5,
g g w : A
S Ag P (ASAP). I
gz, Swz; , M+R
Sg S, w
.
E 35 gz w g . I w
, g gz
I , . B
w g q g. A
-g ,
Hg F C I
GOP g
wk .
33 P w C Ig Ag.
34 Atlanta Journal-Constitution, O. 11, 6.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
19/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 17
Nw g g g
, w
, A R,
- M+R Sg S.
w , B E
N A S D
Ag.
k g .35
Wg k k gz
j . F 6 g
g 7, w-z .
A C S A H
A g , w
A w
gg A
g g g-
gw z .36
A - , ,
x
Cg C G A
V Nw D, g
-g . Cg
x $ . w
S j , R D (R-K)
A. D (D-S Dk) wg
w w , g
g
x .37
M , w
B .
35 C R, Congressional Quarterly Weekly, J. 6,7.
36 I.
37 D R D, Sg 1C: Nw Mk A Ag, M 3, 7.
A w 1, B g g g kg . I w
g w g-g ,
g GOP
w g .
P Rg g , D
Sk, g w
w g,
w
.38 Sk, g
GOP w. (S. J Ggg,
R-Nw H, w jkg wk .)
S g ,
w g
-k g
Cg.
g, g-w k
g, , g,
( w k).
N, 185
g g
k .
g ,
wg g g- k.
w
w k w g
w .
Ag g
g ,
.
USDA g
g w w
gw, 15 w R
j Cg w . F
38 D Sk, Te riumph of Politics. (Nw Yk: ABk, 186), 166.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
20/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States18
F, k 16, w k w
w w
g GOP. I
g g
. (Ag
q g, ,
.) R g
w w g
g g. B
, g w w
wk k g
w w k .
C w ,
g .
x w R. P
R (R-K), H
Ag C. k
g
g . A R
w
K w w
g . Mw, -- gg, w
gg $1 g g
S wk S. D P
(D-Ak) .3
x w
gg w
w g . ,
kw g x
,
w w.
w . A, g g -
, g w j
kg g g .
3 R w U.S. j F F w.
Gg W. B, w k 1, w g. B
g
. N g kg , Ag
S A M. V w ,
kg Sk Nw C, g
gg g. K
w U
S Ag J. B. P w w
.
Ag , P w
g g ,w, ,
g w
w g w, g
g g. I w,
185 16,
w g k g x.
16 , P ,
g w w z, ,
gw .
, x, w 13
. P k . Hw , w , g
w 5
k.4 P
g, ,
g gg USDA g
, -z-
- .
B Cg g g
g
. g w
, x w . C ,
j 16, w . Cg
g W H w
4 S S, Rk F D. 1, .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
21/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 19
.W - j w, B
g ,
GOP .
D k g,
g wk w
w g . Sg
6 g
w USDA D
S Ag C F. (Ck) C.
C S. R Lg
(R-I), B W H. Ag S Mk
J, Nk g w
wg
, V,
g .
W he Washington Post
g w
, J
g Post.
w kg
q .
J w g J 7
.
g, .41 g z
41 Te Washington Post, USDA O P C FS, F. 1, 7, S A, g 1.
gg g, 183-g USDA w
, g j
C H gz.
g $1
kg
k g,
kg w $,
j g g .
Cgg w ,
J g g
. Ag w ,
J : $7.8 g, 17 .
w
g .4
W w , USDA
g w $5 -
.
W H w GOP
. B USDA w
g w
w
g. I w w w w w
g, .
4 USDA 7 F B P.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
22/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States20
The November Surprise
2
M g D N 6 -
. w H Sk, C
Cgw P, K
1. B k w
D j, k
. I g, w w
k g [ ] w
w k, x H
Mj L S H (D-M).43
Lkg 8,
g w D w
GOP g g 14 . I ,
D w
, Cg C
H (D-M), w
D H 8.
6 1 H
R w P B
4. M D w
x j Ag C
g
w g w g .W , D g
( ) Ag
C, g k
w A.44
A , w
g w g
D g . A D
w: I
g
.
z. I w g
Ag w k w.
43 Iw w .
44 w: B Ew (I), N B(K), Zk S (O), Wz (M), KG (Nw Yk), S Kg (W), J D(I), M (F).
A , wk GOP . GOP g,
S. Lg Ggg, R L
J B O, w g
. A kg R
S Ag C, Sx C
Gg, k S
g , w
g.
D j
q -g
g. g g wk g
R, w -D g
g wk ,
A-A H wk.
Nw D-g g
gg
g
g w
g -g .
S, w .
k K, .
M M, B W
g , R. E M.
C (D-S C)
Cg Bk C
I , g,
g . g
F 1, g g,
. W F
R Bk,45 M gz g
C, Iw, , q
, k, ,
45 FRB C w g.I g gg g g U.S., g w , , gw g w.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
23/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 21
g . F , M g Wg, DC
gz.
, . I J 7
B W g g
Wg x
Cg.
B W gz wkg
g g gz
U.S. C C B, N
C C, E C,
Eg L C A. g
Cg
U.S. , g j
g, w
g g g
w.
Mw Ox w g
k g, g
gz Wg . I
, g,
Wg g
. I k L
gz, g,
Pg N B C,
z g
w w
w gg
g .
U.S.
, gz g
g W A
U S. I wk w g
Ck & Wk, w GOP, .
I - g , Ox
w U.S.
W A .
C D S
U C D, g U S w
w 6 14 .
w W A
.3 5.7 g
, g , -
w .46
G M A wg
w g
. B
, GMA D wk U.S.
. I J 7 H
S , k g
Cg g-
w
U.S. g
g w
k w
A ,
. I w g g g A
, g B R,
U.S. C C, NR F, N A
M, I g
I C. (Dg, g
M P A, w j
k D
k, g g .)47
W E Wkg G
q , g
w w w gwg
(w g 68,),
E D
46 D S, I R U.S. CS W A C P, OxI, J , 7.
47 D Mg, A Wg, FP.,J 3, 7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
24/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States22
H K w g k . A E
D w K
w, ,
w g w increase w
z
D .
E D x
w $1 , $15 , $
w
g g wkg . I
g O, W,
P, Nw Yk, V, F, C .
I A 7 g w k
g W P M.
Swz , Sg S, g
g
g, M+R Sg S
g.
R g .
wk
H. K w W
M C. D R. J MG
(M) w -kg R
C, R. P R (R-W)w R Bg. D R.
J B C, H
Ag C, w g
w . A
L , x g
k, g ,
.
g g gg 7
, Swz . g
w w gg w g g
, D g, g g
w x Bg .
I , g Cg k g
. Sg
g w
x ( )
j g .48
G g , Swz g,
Ag g wg
k I g
g g
.
48
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
25/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 23
S, w gg: w .
Dg w K G I
w wkg 7,
Wg x
45 . H
H Ag C
g. W
w w q, q
Bk. A
j w kg
- Cg.
I w g x kg
w g , ,
. I 6 he Washington Post
k g : I ,
g k , k,
, .
M Wg
wk g . H
z g g, A
F B F, N C
C USA R F, -
wk gg,
g w .4
R q 18 1,
z w
g, , ,
, g .
Nw g g , C
F C (g N
C Gw A -gwg
g). I
Politico, C H w, g
g .
xg , w
4 Te Washington Post, Pw I A RAg S, D. , 6, S A, g 1.
Money, Politics, and the Farm Lobby
3
, gw, . Lg g g
g g
w Gw Eg, w g g 51
, P LLC, g
Mw . Gw
Eg x, B,
N F U, wk w
P .
B 7 8, w xg
w w: g
Ag Cg; ,
U.S. S; z
gz w
Wg; ; g ;
A. M
. Sg, ,
w w w
g g
-g. B
g .
Ag w. F
x: A F B F,
g gz,
g 7 g
q 8. g
g q .
F B g
$5 6. .
I , ,
,
7 Wg. M -
w -
g .
G g g
w 48
U.S. k g z
Nw Mx g g
C H. Lkg w
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
26/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States24
-- g, , w, g . D
w, g
k
, USDA g w,
q M S.
w
-
g. W
M F M, Wg-
g . W g
w g w k, W gg k ?g
g
w. F, ,
g g
Ag g
g.5
A 1. w
$15
g 5, g Washington Post
USDA .51
w g gwg
w w . B
g 1,
w $5, $1, 5.
g g.
g ,
g , k, ,
q , g , g
, kg , g
g q.
w w 56-g
F B
7
5 E J V MG, Politico, J 18, .
51 D Mg S C, Pw I A R Ag S, he Washington Post, D., 6, S A, g 1.
q. I g w
q g g
x g
g. I w ,
F B , g
($7 )
($4.4 )
813 g .
I w k
g g
D R w g
U S w .
N F U, -
g gz,
gg , w
D, g w P
C. B F B
k g ,
w . Rg g-g
NFU w
g w (kg k
ww ),
NFU x .5
Gg 7, w, gz w
.
w , . A
, .
P w- g g
, w, , j w
g P .
A ,
W A , Ox w wkg
H S
Ag g w
w . C
5 NFU M L O 7 F B P, NFU w, M 5, 7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
27/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 25
, w ( )
w g g U.S.
w w . W g
w g g, w
w w
.
B , gw w g
. z
k
w. (C gw w w
, w
.)
O ,
W w gw, w w
g w w, k k,
gg , .
S , N A W
Gw Cg, w
gw
w k ,
g
g.53
M xg P g g
w w, g ,
g R 16.
w
w . B
USDA gg g
( )
g g
g.
N F U k
: Hwkg
53 N A W Gw, R M 7 F B.
kg g. NFU B g
16 wk. I Cg,
P Hk . I
kw w w j , Hk .54
B W w gw S
gw g
g . I
g gw w,
k . F gw,
w g
U.S. g g Bz. W
Ogz U.S.
g
.
I x ,
w g w, P . I
k g
w . Y g
g.
k
.55
O j g g
wk w N
C Gw A
gz. C w g
, N C Gw w w-
, w g $1
. gz g g
g .
Iw gw w w k
g g g
: .
g g wk w.
54 w , M 4, 7.
55 Iw w K G.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
28/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States26
w , g g Wg. w
w w g .
E
133. B w w
x .
g 1, w,
g
g gg
x
g .
, w C RCg (CRP), R A (RA),
G Rk I P (GRIP),
w , w
. wk w
GRIP, 1,
,
w CRP RA
75 . (A
w 5
.)
I - 7 ,
gw w
k g g
. C ,
x A g, g-
k , w g
w gw w g
USDA g. B g
w
USDA k.
W Iw S U B
Bk g ,
gw w g
Ag C R (ACR) w
g k
GRIP. g , w
P K MC, : F g
gz g g.56
W g ,
gw w .
k, ACR w g
, g
. B w
g . ( g w g.
F 18, g
j, w .)
ACR w
gw,
, w g
, g
. , , ACR
k w g
g
G , ACR k g
gg . B w
, w g
g w
Cg Bg O
g w g .
(S w.)
g w
gz w w
P , w. gg ,
Swz , w . P
w g B Dg,
D w k
g k.
56 N C Gw A, Fgg Nw D U.S. F P: 7 N F S A, M7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
29/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 27
g w .57
Bg . I
g w g w g,
g Bg
. P w
w w g g.
W P g x
g H g
w wg
g , kw w
w kg. Y 18 H
g w
g.
Sg g g w
wg D P
H. F ,
w
- . w
. C Bg P
P,
w- ,
w w gg
g w w
g R. A w j
w . w q
w g.
O , B
P. I cut-
g g $67 ,
g Hk w $5
g
g.
F S. B
H Ag
C, w w w
. C wk
w w g
57 P w , J , 7.
. g g w- g, q
g .
g w w GOP
w
w w, , g
g. Rkg R B G
Vg w
k
. A G
A S H (w Fg
A), g g- .(Dg H Ag C
, R. R
Ng (R-x)
g x
.
D w w g
P ,
g w R. R DL
(D-C) k .
g 7 8, DL
g g,
g w Hk -
w
Hk k .
DL, , k g,
g. I 7 k
g g. S w
P, w w
H A C. (I 3
P, , DL -
D Sg C,
g.) DL k .
S g w g,
gwg g
, , k, g
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
30/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States28
, , N . O , , w w
gg k
w .58
W , DL
R Cg W G
(M) w
g N g.
g j 3
35 A
g w g
w . W w
A F ( k
), DL-G
xg g
, g g
, gg g g g
. W
w 8, DL g gg
w, w g
.
Sg, w, DL
g k
g I. H w w I
58 Iw w K G.
w N w .
g H
S. B w g I
8, DL w .
P, w, w-gz
g (
) g
.
g ---
g g gw.
Ag w g
I , ,
,
g kg
g, S 3, x
. W
g, U F P A,
g g g
. I S C F B
A, 1
g gz. Rg w
C D R. D Cz,
Ag C. H
H A A, w 64 ,
z g
.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
31/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 29
Doubts Emerge
4
A k H g 7,
w . B w
g g
Ag w
w gg.
Swz :
I k . W
g. U w w
w , [ wk]
w I g
w w. O w, g .
x w
, w
EWG K Ck. I
w g.
S g,
N R D C, w
. Dk U, w
g ; w k g
g, F R A C
A S H.
W. K. Kgg F w
. Sg, w, j
I. I F F P
Pj, , g, ,
, g g $5.7
g.B g g
I
w g k
g.5
W g g ,
wk k. Ox, x, K. B
5 T Hw G, A A F F P Pj, O 8. Kgg g wE D, A F , C F S C, N-MwI, R C.
P B g. A gz w g -
z
w. Ox
g , w
w , U.S.
. W w w
g ,
k . Ox
g z
wk
- w-gwg
g . I w w kwg w
k. B P B x g: K w
g g
g wg
g.6 P B .
N w
w A
F .
AF g
. I . I w
g w
. P R G w
C , , g . H
U.S. g : R E. Rg,
-g C w
g
USDA; J H, I
k ; J. G w-
kg ; U.S. U S
Ag Ag S J., w
6 Ox g w P, g Ox . W , w M- g g P .T M g , q Ox. Ox w .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
32/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States30
Nw Eg g. Dg , AF w w
g, D Gk,
D, C Y, R.
B 6 G
g. H w k K, w w
Ag C, w
g -. H gz
wk w DL, w w wg
w not
g I.
A F w
gwk
w k g w
: ACR . I
6 AF
w, gwg wk C Z,
g O S U
x
k. Z, gg w
w w
: , . Mgg w
k g
w x
, Z . B
7 gw w g
g g, ACR w
g g.
AF
gw Z. Nw
-
w g
g g
, AF Cg.61 g
61 A F , Ag 7: A Nw Fwk D U.S. F P, M 8, 6.
g wk - w k-
- k . g
w k k-w ,
x
. C
w x.
F , AF w
. O , ACR
was . F g ACR w
g ,g
. w ,
w, z
g , k
g. B gg w,
gw g g k k
.
O ,
w wg
K Lg w g.
gw g w
k. I
k ,
g : I kw
w .
K Ck E Wkg G
w
g U.S. g
gw k g
w w g
w w .
K w
AF w g I. E, AF
w g Swz g. W
R [G] w , .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
33/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 31
A w D. P, g w U S g
w
Cg k I. B D
zg ,
. S g, C Cz
Ag G W, g
. E g
g , g
I
.
g, I w
w 16
. B Ox, G M F,
w wkg
D R. D
w W Ogz
w -g
w w -g
g. w
g x g w w w gw.
, g
j .
B w
g xg .
I w D ,
wkg U.S. kg
. A
g
g w Cg.I w
,
w WO
w: . k ,
g
$5.5 -
g w w g
g. g w ;
g w .
The Doha Wrinkle
5
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
34/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States32
U w H, W M,
Eg C, A, F
S, R x
qg g . W
q g ,
Ag C
k w wk gwg
g I
.
I 78, Gg , Nw Eg P
Nw. N C
C, g
g . O A A
. ( Cg Bk
C 4 H .) Eg
g
H Ag C k g
w 3 5. Sx k $1
.6
k g . N-
wk k g. F
g x . I
w, A C w
w USDA g .
k g g
z
kw g63
Ag C, g
, g kg
g .
6 E Wkg G .
63 C g g.
Ag I 15 g,64 k
I .
g g
xg j. I 181,
14 x w g
. I 8 1 15 .65
g
g , , ,
g
g g g
kg w. I 1,
Cg Bk C , g g
g w jz j
w . I 7 w
g g
g g
w w wk w
C, F, Mg.
C g
g , ,
j g . I w
Cg g ,
g w
. I ,
g w . N
w
w g j
g w .
Ag g ,
k
64 N g , , , g w- g.
65 w: , , , , , , , gg, k, , , .
The Committee
6
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
35/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 33
. S.C (Gg)
w Gg g;
S. R (K) w w
; S. L (D-Ak),
w , , , , -
k ; S. Pk L
(D-V), w . I H, P
k g N ;
L Bw (D-Iw), ; J M
(R-K), w g; D
Cz (D-C), g.
A g.
A ,
g .66 L
gw Ak
wk w .67
U 5 1.7
G A g , w
w, , g, ,
.68 S. G (R-Iw)
w g
$5, w 15
5. I g ,R G, $685,.6 Ok
R Fk L, w kg
Ag C R ,
wg 48- , w w,
88- , w
66 T g f w, g K A. G, x Wg w Sk A. Tg g wk g , g
G .
67 Bkg w w S .
68 E Wkg G .
6 he Los Angeles imes, S B F FS, D. 15, 7.
w $14,34 w15 5.7
E (w ), w w
g w R w
g, w q gw
4- D, A.
H g z
q ,
. C, w H
Ag C w
, $35, gz
gw w S . S C g
w
g. O, g w
w
M, w
C S .
H ,
g g ,
w Cg L C, W x
R w g g Ag
C 1. C w
, g
. O
, M
g ,
Ak .
kg D, C W. S
x, w
g $3, w
1 5.71 A g Cg, C
w , g, , ,
. S, - 4, w wk , g
7 E Wkg G R. L 5.
71 he Washington Post, Pw I A RAg S, D. , 6.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
36/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States34
, w, g , g ,g S .
B M, K w w
H . P kw
w . A wk
w , P q
w g I, kg w
. B w g
g g
I. K w, ,
H .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
37/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 35
I M 5, 7, w g g 8 .
P w N F U
O, F,
w A. I w j
g
w , w Congressional Quarterly.
k ,
k NFU w
g . B ,
g C D
. P w g P .
B w- w w wg g. kk
A w,
A.
P P w . S
w w S F
; w -
kg, M-kg Mw,
. (H
g g
.) W P B A
, P, w 65, w F A, g g g
gg C H k ,
S A.
B g. P
P 1 w
R. S H (M)
H M W, g-
3
k 6. P w
w
, B. S kg , P w
g g Ag
C. (E R. F,
D-Wg, w w k,
x R L C, w g
Cg 3.)
Reality Check: Pelosi Backs Peterson
7
A P w w wk .
D ,
g , g
, g , g
g g
USDA g, wkg
Lgw Bg O C H
, g g
w M. H
g w S ,
gg k g.
, w gg g
, gg
g, .7 H w
N, wk S
, g k g w
P B, Ak, w z g
g
g .
Lk DL, P k . H
w qk ,
kw w g D , g . P
w , kwg R.
M B (D-Ak). Q
. S wg k
.73 w P. H
w wg P
H w .
W xgg, K
E D ?
M , g B G Wg w g O Fk
7 Iw w K G.
73 Lg K, W Sg, Ak,Daily Leader, N. 1, 7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
38/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States36
W. wg k , Congressional Quarterly.
O J 1, 7, g
k. A g H
Ag C
I, D S C g
w g
g A g. w
. R. L w
wg.74 B
j B
g , K . F,
k I .
P w w .
, , g g
- , w M. K
gI R K
w g.
P w gg ,
g
k.75 O K, , H
I gg .76
g
D , kg
w g
, g g,
, . P
K w g .
k w g k
w . I --
San Francisco Chronicle,
74 Te Washington Post, J , 7, S A, g .
75 w J 1.
76 w g H Ag C k. P k . R k k g g-kg .
C L k . AL , B A
,
w w
w
75 g
, w Wg
L M P [ -g
Omnivores Dilemma] Bk
A W,
g , g w P
, .77
B , w, P
D w wkg
g 18 g
g w wg
. ,
g
I, g
, kg g w j
g $1 , g
w . B
, DL Cg J MG
(D-M) wk P g
g
D.
W Ag C k
J 17 18, P
g g
w, , j g
g I.
k k - g
Lgw H O Bg. I
, w w g w. L
: P
77 C L, P k H S F B, San Francisco Chronicle, J 1, 7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
39/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 37
w gg g w .78
Chronicle L, w
w, qk x k.
S P w g g
w g g $1
, q K Hg,
C C F
Fg, g, B kg
D
P [ kg].7
I , w . I w
w w w I w
w w w
g q. A P
zz w ,
w w w-k gg k:
XM g
. W ,
g
g g g.
- w
$54.6 w
g ($74.5 ).
C g g
. I 6 he Washington Post
C I Pg U R
P. 1
$346 , w
g $335 .8 I M 7
C H Wx H Og
C w w g w
z x ,
78 Te Washington Post, J 1, 7, S A, g .
7 L, . .
8 G M. G, D Mg, S C, CI Pg U R P, he Washington Post, O. 16,6, S A, g 1.
j g w, , .81
P wkg w
Wg , M
ML. B ML
x A
A C I j
w. Uwg g
g g
g w. I 4
g w
g g g USDA x. A
, (w
x ) w g
wg g k.
C g, w gg
, w g.
$.5 , -
, q w
w H w .
Mw, gw w
g w gg w
H. B , P g
g
g ,
Cg Bg O
g 1-
g g.
E , w . W P
wg , x g H W
M C w -
, g x
U.S. g .
F R, x w -
k D
q. W w R x
81 D Mg, Bg P F C I Cz,Te Washington Post, M 4, 7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
40/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States38
g w x, D GOP. g
D g
w P.
J 6,
j w . R.
MG, K ,
-w D R C
g $84
g w .8
MG w g ,
g . ( MG g, g g g w
8 H-
S P .)
I k , MG
k g
g q. H
g
Cg Bg O k
g z g . O
$3
x g g (
w k x
g k). A R
w , w
w g g
. S , P
g.
S g, P , P
. w g
w I w
g [ ],
. R [DL]
w g g [P] k gx [].
8 T MG-D I F E w, w , Cg MG, g g g .
W . I w gg g. W w gg .83
ML w P ,
P gg : Wg
wg w R. J C
(D-) g D
g. F, P
$3.4 , w g
w k C
w . A ,
w. A g
x w , w
g w g , g g
Cg
Bg O w.
w w w
k : $11.4
, $1.4 g,
$5.6 , g
. O D
, P
: g C
g g g .
O , g g
, g w
, , w D
g. Mg j
g , R C,
k, w
R. E B (D-Og) R
g g . k
kg g,
D w g g
.. O w C
, w w
83 Iw w K G.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
41/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 39
. w w $1, - - -
g .
A D
g , g
w g gg w
U.S. , , x
. A -z w g
kk: S , R.
C M (D-Nw Yk) g
k B R C
H. H g $,5 g gw .84
L g J 6, K
F 1 .
D , kg ,
w -
w g K. A -
, H 3 117 j .
x H , 31 11.
Sg w, P
84 D Mg, Sg I Ex If; DS B F A, Te Washington Post, N. 3, 7.
g K x
kg k q w
w .
Ag g K w
g D Ag
C D, Cg
Nk L (x), w
Cg 6 g .85 w
D E
D D
Lk Iw B S Og K.
B :
W H H
R, 1 w g
. G, g D,
w
P .
85 T D w 8w H Ag C. I ,g, w . O ,
M F, w x .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
42/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
43/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 41
g ( II g XV). q , .
Lwk w
gg--g
, x
. A g,
k k C Hg,
g k.
A H g, P k
P . [D ] w
,
w. B ,w 8
w kw . S w
g w w
I. S F
. I w I k
w , .
Iw w K G.
S , P F, g
Rw F, M, P
. I : Nw F B
Sg F R A. I
P , P
w w San Francisco
Chronicle. S j g [ F]
, w
w g k k g
-w. A
w g gg
w gg g.1
P A ,
kwg Ox . I w
w j g
g .
1Qualis Environment, D. 14, 7.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
44/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States42
O O. , 7, K Ck EWkg G
S. H
H
. S, Ox
x wg g
w
w g Mk F
B F. Ox A
$5, V g, g
Wg, DC, M, Nw
H. S
w k F B, L B, g
Ox.
P , w
w. w Dk (
: 1.4 ) 435
H, S
w F (18.3 ),
x (4.3 ), I (1. ). A
g
D g R C. B
(W Vg) Ew M. K(M), w --
D wk C
N Dk ( 641,48), w
Bg C, M D Mx
B ( 67,44), F.
S Ag C C Hk
w g- . H
q 1- g
w w , g
w
g . H g g
w G P g w-, w
. H g ,
C A, g w R wg.
The Senates Gang of Four
9
C Sw Pg (CSP),w wkg g w-
w . Hk
w CSP g
k
w .
Hk w , w
w g
, ,
.3 H ACR.
W w , Hk
. W g w w g .4
A g, w, Hk w
. A g
wg S
. Hk w
. g
S F C. g w
w x
. ,
Mx B M; kg R,
G Iw; K C N
Dk, w Bg C.
B F w ,
S : w
w g w [g] , w
wg .
M S
-k kg
g wg k kHk w
w . B -wg
L J w g .
O , D
3 T EU g , 3, q w , , w, q. I , 3 .
4 w g .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
45/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
46/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
47/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 45
F C, S g, g g
g I w
.7 g
g, w
k g g
. w w k
k. W g g
, w N-gw ,
, , k,
.
D g --,-- w ,
k g wkg
g k .
S. Lg Fk R. Lg (D-Nw
J) k --
K. I , w
w g g
. F g
gw w , w g
. O
q , g
, x,
g , g
, , g
, , Lg .
G , w B L. Dg (D-N
Dk), -
w ,
g w C.
G-Dg w
$5, ,
w $36,, w
7 C g w J W. (J) M, w w Wg . A , wk f N F U w g g, j .
g g q.Sg w
w .
S. A K (D-M)
g . I w
- kg
$75, - kg
$5,. R S.
S Bw (D-O) k
.
Lg, g ,
w g . I
R :
C; S M
L M MC (R-Kk),
S -kg D, R
D (I). B D 11, S
j , 58 37,
. E Hk, wg w
, .
j , .
R k
Lg g . I
w
w, Lg .
w , g,
g k. A
w j
G-Dg .
A D g
Iw H C (D-Nw
Yk), Bk O (D-I), CD (D-C), J B
(D-Dw) C H
. F P J C
E C -
.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
48/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States46
B g --w w . g D-
L L, Mj L R
g 6
g . R
k .
g w C,
C
. S Ggg (R-Nw H),
. A gg
w k G
Ggg g
Wg g gw g g .
gg
g,
w g g.
F-g g g K . B w
. S. Bw
. x
S wg, 7 14.
R g C.
S. K C g [
G-Dg] . M
, g
g g g
zg g
, CkHk, x C
R A. D
w w,
B W M M.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
49/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 47
g w w -g g H, S,
B . w w
W H . I
H S ,
,
w x. H S x
- $1. $11.6
, .8
F g, w,
g w C H w
w x. A , H S w k,
g w
.
w . w
g g . A
g w wk
g. g g, Hk
gg g
g k,
g .
S g w
. Lwk
g
,
W H. M,
x-wg F C, Mx B
M, Ag C,
w
g .
w w
w, P .
P k,
w. O R
g H w
x . I , H
8 S , O Mg Bg.
Three-Cornered Endgame
10
GOP w k S R
g. F P R
, wkg
W H w
g . B w gg
. A w -g
(wk w x) w
w W M
C
R. C B. Rg (D-Nw Yk).
w wk g Ag
S J S. J
w g U.S. S Nk.
R w
k C x . I, B
N Dk G. E S,
--w S. C. S
w g w
Cg.
P w G, w
g -
x
H . wk
C wk 8
g w ,
g -- w C
USDA. O F 14, 8, G
wk
k ,
, w W H .
I w $6 w g
w x sine qua non W
H H GOP. w-wH $8
H J,
g w g
, w $5
- .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
50/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States48
P-G kg I.
$5
, g
13
j g $3,
w- g.
g
. N g w gw
$ j
.
Sg w 7 . S Ag C
g .
I S, w, H kg
w . Politico D Rg
, F g
k--k g W H
D R j
S k k
g x . S P
gg k. C, ,
P-G w
. A P w M
C Jk B, C,
S Dk w
P-G . S q B
g gg . G
g .
P S
w. I
w S. I g g
S g g. I
. I w zz w
k [ S ]. I w
, gk x . I
w w w g w . A I
z: w w
B gk
w w g
.
A , P gw . A
g, B g x
k q
w g w. B
g-w, B w g,
P w k. (A B x: g
g g g g
w. S k .)
A HS g g
x w , k q w w
B w g
. Hk,
W H w
gw. I B gg w
, Cg
j; g
w B w gg g,
w -- k
q g w g
. g
g 8, g g
w g
g w
. B k
gg S
, w [D
S] Ck C w k
g, . S wk w g w
Kk (M L MC)
g Ak (L),
gg g
Ak (GOP S. S),
j w x gg.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
51/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 49
I H, , R wgwg . I w . W
H w g GOP ,
w g g g
g g B . B
GOP wk g
. g 8
GOP
.
$37 , 673-g
g M 13
g . S j -w-
x P-G kg
, w g
g x g
S F H
W M .
w k. M
5 g g, g
z k, .
g gwg g
, g $33
k.
x, g
,
g , w g
. k
w w
w
g; g g w
q g g
g; w .
A S gg g
g. F x, Iw k
g
,
G w g w 6---g
x . C
k . O
, gg g.
C g g g
w gw. A g
U.S. D P & L C,
Wg , G A,
w g
k, , g
G P.
B C g
w- (SURE). G
, kg Iw
g ,
k w C k
. ACR,
G ( Hk), w
Ag C R E
(ACRE). ,
ACRE w
w .
I - -kg, C
C g
g , S
z kg
g, - g g.
G g w w
, g
gg w
g w g. w w
g
j g x
$5, ($1 ), w
g j g w
$75, ($1.5 ).
w w $3,
w x
g , w w
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
52/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States50
w g g (
) q
. ( B
w w g
g q
,
.)
I w, Hk w g
gg w, g g
g g
w w g. O
gg
w wk g
w w. A g
w
DL, w w $1. ,
- g
g k .
Hk w $1.1
C Sw Pg. w
ACRE g Hk .
I g I w . I g
, I g g,
w. g I k,
. I g
w I , w g w
g w gw w
gw, w gw .
B kg
j
Ag .
Dg H , P
k w
w g .
Iw w K G.
g ,, g-
Ag . I
g- g U.S.
g: . g
gg z ; g
g
g g; g-
g z g
w; g gwg
z
g;
g w; gg - .
Hk kwg
k . B w . W
. B g
[ ]. C. L. O
R , C, C, R,
G w g. [S.
J] S Dk. C w
B. B w k
? F B g ,g NFU. A
g .1
F , wg[]
g, g
N C C.11
w D 8
A F B F
: W , qg,
, g k
C w w 8 F B.
g $41 g , 7.5--
1 Iw w K G.
11 G M.A, , N C C, Cotton Outlook gz,J 8.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
53/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 51
- . (I
J , w g ,
O , g
C H, .)
I w , ,
W
H .
Swz ,
, . I g H R
k w
w x g k
g . g
Swz, H H. M,
g,
w .
w B Jk,
K R
g . S
R P
w W H, Swz
k w g
, , g g
g R . I
Swz
kg .
F, Swz . W
k , . W
g g
. I , w Swz,
W H g. w
j gg g , .
M 1 g w gw. A g
, k g
, w. I
w
g $ ,
w g g gk
. I w j
g.1
w g
15 , z
,
k. H xg g z
- ; w
g (ACRE);
g w
g .
B C H, g w
. A w w , H
, 316 18. O
R, g H -kg
GOP , M R B, j
D g .13
S qk w .
g 8 w .
1 F g, M 1, 8.
13 D Cg B, , g.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
54/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States52
F k w w -g g .
Ag - -gz
, g g
w g. k g,
g . Ogz
g w w
wk gg .
S g U.S.
g ,
z A. O
g g
. S g g I g ,
, g,
, w ,
g w. Rg
g g w I
w . S g w
k g xg
g .
W w
w.W , S
F, w wk E D 7.14 W g
g ?
q
g w
? O w I
? W g w
, w
g w .
D R
Cg w w
g . SHk
g w
, w
w . Cg, g
14 Nw w G M A.
R , g- k g
g .
B g
WO w
x. I ,
WO 5 U.S.
x g xg
g g .
A WO g,
7 U
S . g w . Bz g, g
g, U.S.
U S
j Bz . I
, w, 8
g U.S. 4---
USDA
g WO g.
I w Ag WO
Bz w $5 ,
$15 ,
U S
w Bz k
.15 A gg , g
g w g g k
U.S. g WO
q. Bw 5 , U.S.
45 , w
Bz, C, I .
I w wk
w . O
15 P F J L, U.S. L Rg CP, Te Wall Street Journal, S. 1, . T g , , Bz A w .
Postmortem
11
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
55/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
56/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States54
F . I 78, w g
g . Sg
, N P. G,
A C S A
, w:
U.S. , g ,
g
k w. O ,
Cg g
g
w g.17
G
R Cg; D
R; w g w
g
g. A w, w-
g S. C C
w-g k
w k .
I g w,
g
, g S. MC, GOP ,
g w g g
. F Ag S Mk
J j 7 8
. J
,
gg, g g, g
g . B
U.S. S Nk M
8, J w for
H-S
.18
17 N G, T 8 F B, Cotton Outlook gz,J 8.
18 J H-S wq w, : I , g M 15 G I, N., Independent.
S , g g w D
Cg g g,
g, , g ,
g .
w
q w: Cg x
g g
g k g
g g w j
. (I H, g
g w Eg
C C, AgC k .)
Ag g
. B j
w g w
w
D g.
I ,
w g Eg I
S A D 7. g
q
, ,
w ( 36 g ).
k g . B
g k w . I
w q
g E P
Ag USDA
w g
g g.
,
g g H Eg
C C M w
,
g .
g D
g. R wk g
Aftermath: A New Politicsof Agriculture?12
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
57/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 55
g w z , -g
, Mw g
g
E P Ag.
I w k k
gg ,
P w P g
jz - D.
I g w (w
j ), w
.
U H , , ,
w
. Mg
g w
USDA, g - EPA
. W w EPA w
, P .
w gg
w. Exg , w
, w
g g q 7 EgI S A. A
g g
w U.S. w g
g w
w, U.S.
w gg .
g, P
g. H H
w P g g
w qk g H, 1 1. B
w
kg P.
w g g
H .
L w g x
g g
g USDA g
6 g g.
A k w
7 g x
8
g g q. E
g . U.S.
g w gg g
g- U.S. g
g .
F wk g
g
g g. F x,
k ,
, .
7 g , w
q ,
gg w g
.
g g q
. I
g , w
g g
, , ?
w ,
- g w k
w gw .
USDA -
w 1 . O
g , g
: 3.5 7.
, .
Hw, g
k w k k
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
58/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States56
g .1
B , g
. P g
x A&M, w EPA
g , 8
, ,
w
H- .
w j w x
w g. I
W w
g ( g )
w , w E w . Mw
g xg
, w
w g g
. , w
z g g
g ,
w w k .11
g
. A F B F,
N C C, N PkP, N Sg P
g Wx-Mk
g w g
P. B w N
F U A F
; A S A,
w g w ,
g P.111
1 O C E E R
S, A P A E HR 454 U.S. Ag, J , .
11 Ag F P C, D. AgE, x A&M U, E I EPA A C P H.R. 454 U.S. R F, Ag .
111 ://gw.//6/5/-g----g-/.
Mw gw g w
g. B S g
F B g g .
Whither Farm Subsidies?
O w w
g , O w
g
. A ,
w
w 78,
. Ag g g , g w
Cg .
O k
g , ,
w wk. I
-
w $5,. P
: W g .
S. C w .
Y g
gg w .
P, wk
kwg
g w j
g g. A R
w 8 5,35 g
A F B F
5 O
g .
Ag g
g Cg
w
Cg
w g.
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
59/62
he Farm Bill And Beyond 57
A g w g-w w
A w
g. I w
g j
D R k,
Bz w g g,
, g
, g
( ) .
USDA , K C
(w N CI S, g
), k
x w
, w w g w
.
W
k z
[ g]
, . C wk
w
. C
x . I z
gw 8 g. Nw
g
. C gg
w
g k
g g
k.
g
. I
, z ,
g k
. W
kg, g
k w k
x. N w gg g , C
. R g
g g
, w g
x x.
O A,
g w
q
. I EU, g
g k
P g, , ,
. I U S,
C Sw Pg k
. A ,
EU g q
, ,
w, q.
A , gwg
U S
gw g k g
. W
U S, g,
.
z
g w , ,
; g g
g; g q; g
g w .
C
g A
g x
w-. B W H g
g g
k g wg
g -
. I - w, O
w -g w M
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
60/62
he German Marshall Fund o the United States58
P, g g g. Ag ,
O ime gz J K,
x
g ,
k , , g
g g x .
P A
g w
A g j .
C g P,
q w. A , P
k g w
g. C g ,
w w . S
g g kg
g k g
w g. w
g g Mw
k g g-g g
g w
- g g g
g g g 1 .
P g- ,
gw , w g
B, , g w
g w g, w w
! F gg, w. W g
w , Cg
g k . k
w g F Mk P
Pg ($33 ), C F Pj
g ($5 ), H F E
D C. I $75
g w .A 8 , w Iw g
gz
g 5, g x
g.
F
g g
g k,
w gg g
, , g
. F w w
g w g k w .
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
61/62
8/14/2019 The 2008 Farm Bill and Beyond
62/62