The Impact of OMB Circulars (Super or Otherwise) on Federal ProgramsMichael Brustein, Esq.
Brustein & Manasevit, PLLC
Fall Forum 2012
1. What are “circulars”?
2. Do they matter?
3. Where do they stand in the legal hierarchy?
2
Administrative Principles
A-102 – State/Locals 34 CFR Part 80A-110 Postsecondary and Nonprofits 34 CFR Part 74
3
Cost Principles
A-87 State/Locals – 2 CFR Part 225A-21 Postsecondary - 2 CFR Part 220A-122 Nonprofits
4
Audit Principles
A-133 State/Locals/Postsecondary/
Nonprofits
5
So Why a Super Circular?
6
Obama Executive Order 13563
“Regulatory Review”
7
OMB Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking – February 12
What will be the effective date of changes?
8
Council on Financial Assistance Reform (COFAR)
10 members from largest grant making agencies: HHS, AG, ED, Energy, DHS, HUD, DOL, DOT
9
Expect Revisions to:
1) Cost PrinciplesA-21A-87A-122
2) Administrative PrinciplesA-110A-102
3) Federal Agency Audit ResolutionA-50
4) Single AuditA-133
10
Super CircularIncrease consistencyDecrease complexity
But allows for disparate treatment depending on type of entity
11
Single Audit Thresholda) Under $1 million in total federal
expenditures:No single auditAugmented pass-through role
b) Between $1 million and $3 millionMore “focused” single audit
c) Over $3 millionFull single audit
12
“Focused Single Audit” ($1 to $3 Million)
Single auditors to review2 Compliance Requirements
1) Allowable/Unallowable2) Federal agency determines – but
priority on risk of improper payments, or fraud, waste, and abuse
(look to Compliance Supplement)
13
Can SEA impose additional compliance requirements??
14
“Full Single Audit” Over $3 Million
“Universal Compliance Requirements”1. Allowable Costs2. Eligibility3. Reporting4. Subrecipient Monitoring5. Period of Availability of Federal Funds6. Procurement Practices Comply with
Suspension/Debarment
15
Federal Agencies to identify “non-universal” elements, with focus on preventing fraud, waste, and abuse
16
Pass-Through Agencies
Attempt to reduce burden on pass-through (SEA)Federal Agencies to better coordinate review of subrecipient internal controls when 2 or more federal agencies funding
17
OMB wants pass-through to focus on programmatic requirements of subawards
18
Increasing threshold would increase burden on SEA for
monitoring and Limited Scope Audits
???
19
How do your programs measure up against Circulars?
20
Phil Maestri – AEFFA – 10/3/12 OIG “Perfect Lens”Program Officials “Reality”OGC ???
21
Filter out “noise” on “Success” vs. “Compliance”
22
“Costs must conform to federal laws”A-87A-21
23
OIG Final Audit Report ED-OIG/A19K0009
“The Department’s External Audit Resolution Process” July 3, 2012
24
OMB Circular A-50 “Audit Follow-Up” provides policies/procedures for use by federal agencies when considering audit reports* where follow-up is necessary
*OIG and A-133 Single Audit
25
Audit is recommendation to Program Operating Component (POC):
1. Sustain Findings
2. Not Sustain Findings
3. Sustain in Part
26
POC Issues Program Determination Letter (PDL)
1. Closes Matter
2. Recovery of Funds (Audit, Monitoring Report) 34 CFR 81.30
3. Corrective Action
27
OMB A-50 requires resolution within maximum of 6 months after issuance of final audit report
28
OIG Report on External Audit Resolution Process90% of audits between 2007-2010 not resolved within 6 months
29
Audits were overdue for resolution by an average of 1,078 days and included questioned costs totaling $568 million
30
ED lost $415 million due to the
5 year statute of limitations
31
Why
32
Lack of staffLack of knowledge among staffLack of organizational priority on audit activities
Overall lack of accountability
33
OGC PositionBurden of establishing prima facie case
Determination of harm to federal interest
(See Appendix to 34 CFR Part 81)
34
Are POCs more focused on success than compliance?
35
But even if OIG, OGC, POC on same page, findings may still lack merit
The Tydings Cases
36
Questions
37
Disclaimer
This presentation is intended solely to provide general information and does not constitute legal advice. Attendance at the presentation or later review of these printed materials
does not create an attorney-client relationship with Brustein & Manasevit, PLLC. You should not take any action based
upon any information in this presentation without first consulting legal counsel familiar with your particular
circumstances.
38