7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
1/35
Economic Policy PaPEr SEriES 2013
ThE nEw alliancE for food SEcuriTy and nuTriTion
PuShing ThE fronTiEr of EnlighTEnEd caPiTaliSm
JonaThan m. whiTE
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
2/35
2013 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States. All rights reserved.
No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing
rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF). Please direct inquiries to:
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States
1744 R Street, NW
Washington, DC 20009
1 202 683 2650
F 1 202 265 1662
Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at www.gmus.org/publications.
gmf Ppe Sees
Te GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta, ellows, and partners o the German
Marshall Fund o the United States. Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the
views o GMF. Comments rom readers are welcome; reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to [email protected].
abt gmf
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) strengthens transatlantic cooperation on regional, national, andglobal challenges and opportunities in the spirit o the Marshall Plan. GMF does this by supporting individuals and institu-
tions working in the transatlantic sphere, by convening leaders and members o the policy and business communities,
by contributing research and analysis on transatlantic topics, and by providing exchange opportunities to oster renewed
commitment to the transatlantic relationship. In addition, GMF supports a number o initiatives to strengthen democra-
cies. Founded in 1972 as a non-partisan, non-prot organization through a gi rom Germany as a permanent memorial to
Marshall Plan assistance, GMF maintains a strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic. In addition to its headquarters in
Washington, DC, GMF has ofces in Berlin, Paris, Brussels, Belgrade, Ankara, Bucharest, Warsaw, and unis. GMF also has
smaller representations in Bratislava, urin, and Stockholm.
abt gmfs E P P
Te Economic Policy Program is an initiative o GMF dedicated to promoting cooperation between the United States and
Europe on domestic and international economic policies as vital instruments o global prosperity, especially or the poor
and those aected by shis in the global economy. Te United States and Europe account or more than 40 percent o world
economic activity, close to $20 trillion in goods and services on an annual basis. Given the size and importance o this
relationship, GMFs Economic Policy Program seeks to ensure that the benets o globalization are distributed equitablyand airly. Trough in-depth research, targeted grantmaking, strategic convening, and outreach to key policymakers and the
media, the program supports transatlantic leadership at the critical nexus o economic policy, trade, development assistance,
and management o domestic sectors such as agriculture.
On the cover: Market in Yaounde, Cameroon in 2011. Jose Antonio Santiso Fernndez
mailto:info%40gmfus.org?subject=http://www.gmfus.org/publicationshttp://www.gmfus.org/http://www.gmfus.org/http://www.gmfus.org/publicationsmailto:info%40gmfus.org?subject=7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
3/35
The New Alliance for Food Security andNutrition
Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened Capitalism
Economic Policy Paper Series
April 2013
B J M. W
J M. W T G M F U S W, DC.
Exv S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
A Mv B P C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
T N A C O . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
T N A Pb-Pv P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
4/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 1
Executive Summary
A M G8 S CDv, b N
A F S N.
T A k 5
v b ,
v v, G8 v
b
A. D , U.S. P
Ob 45
$ b
A . T j
b b v
b v .
A A x
, A
, b
.
T j N A.
F,
v v;
S, b bv
v
;
T, b-v
(PPP), v
v v
x v
.
B b-v k
N A b
v vz v v.
T x N A
k b b-
v v A
. T
b N A v .
S ,
b
b v k
b A
Cv A A Dv
P (CAADP). C k SABM,
N, W-M b j b A-
b x
vbA k. T
b
v v.
A v b
b k v . T
b A k b
, .
B v v
x v. Rz
v , N A v - k
v, v , b
v
.
T k N A
PPP v
v. T N A
v b v ,
v v, v
CAADP v . I k
b vv
b-v z
k
, . W v $ b
v b
- ,
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
5/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States2
N A .
T A
v b PPP, v
b z
. T
b A
-v v v
v v v v
. S v
N A
kv .Hv, N A, PPP
v
b ,
, b .
T N A
kv
b z
v.
N, PPP
N A b
k b
v . B
P M Sv, N A
v v
v b -
k b. T v
b CAADP v
N A b v .
P b x . T
v
x
N A. A
k -v v . T
b v
v . F
, v b
Bk F R S N P,
x, k b
b -v b .
S k b N
A .
PPP k v
k
v. T v vv
b z
k . T k
v v
. Ev M, E, Tz v
PPP
k , ,
b- . B v
,
b.
B x, PPP b
v
v . I
S A G C
Tz (SAGCOT),
vv v v, v
, - , .
Nv,
PPP b
, , v. F ,
b
SAGCOT v v
v x
b v
. T PPP
. I -b , ,
b
v b
k,
v v
b v
New Alliance countries
suffer from a variety of
onstraints in exercising
leadership that will
mpact the outcomes of
the agreement.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
6/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 3
Enlightened capita
could unleash
transformational
partnerships that h
cascading benefits
strengthening the
economy, society,and governance m
widely.
, k. I k
- -
, N A PPP v
.
S
b v
. Hv, b
b PPP ,
, x ,
. PPP b b
N A . Tk b b
v j ,
xb b . D
v b A,
v v
v v.
G8, A, v, b
v v v
PPP
v N A. R
v b
. S, N A
-v, CAADP-
J S Rv , v b
L C G8 S
v. N
A C Fk
v v. T
, v,
b b
b v k
v , v, , v
v-x
v b.
A k T Ex
G F S A, G
M F- v, v . T
k , v
k. T v
k v
v , , /
b q, v- ,
, k,
. T b v
b-v
. A
Ex G b v v
, k,
b v
.
T v b
, b v
b - .
B v
, N A
b v -
v. I b
v CAADP
x b ,
v v
x .
E
v
b , ,
v . I ,
PPP j. I x
v
G C, K R T, J M.W, Mk A, Transformational Partnerships:Innovative Approaches to Addressing Food Security in Africa(W DC: GMF) A
http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
7/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
A. I (z, , ),
,
, b v, ,
v , ,
b, bv . I
z, , vk, , , , ,
vb, v
k A b k
v k
.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
8/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 5
Enabling Country Ownership
N A v
(.. CAADP )
b
.
R v b
N A
, ,
k , k b
, ,
( PM Sv).
L v k k N
A ,
v
, q z
V G Rb
Gv T L, F,
F Cx N F
S P Rb
A Iv.
A PPP v z
vv b b
v , N A PPP
v.
N A v
,
, , , x, k
b
v
v-b
, k,
.
N P Rb A Iv- .
Enabling Transformational Partnerships
N A k
v A
, k v
.
Ev v b v
N A PPP
v b
b
v.
L v b-
N A
PPP v
v v ,
b-v, v
, k
b.
G b
-
v b v b PPP
, kb b
q x
v , k
.
A v PPP b
v ,
, , ,
(..
v)
v
(.. ,
,
k).
D v
, ,
v, , NGO, ,
Recommendations
1
Lessons from value
chain and benefit-
sharing models sho
guide New Alliance
as they show evide
of generating posit
development outcoallow for practical
problem-solving,
and create positive
synergies among
partners, stakehold
and beneficiaries.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
9/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States6
v v .
A b
, z
x ,
j vv
x.
Enabling Accountable Reforms
N A
, k
b b k v, , z -
b v
.
O N A
q b v x
, -, b
v b
v v
b b .
T N A b,
b b - ,
CAADP- J S Rv
G8 L C, k
v , v,
, v
v-x
v b.
T N A -v b-
L C , b
v NGO
v b
b b v N
A .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
10/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 7
Seven of the ten
worlds fastest-grow
economies are exp
to be in Africa betw
2011 and 2015.
S , A v b v
v b b,
b , v ,
.
T U S, E,
v v b b
W Bk I M
F kk- v.
A
j . I ,
,
, v v
.
S, A b
v
q. T
b
. S
A v . O
j q b .
A b v
- ,
. A k
A
b , v, , k
, , v.
S , v, j ,
b, v
N v W,African Economies and the Politics ofPermanent Crisis 1979-1999 (N Yk: Cb UvP)
v, k bk .4
P 98-9 v b
b : bz , k
b, v,
v . Sv
b 8-,
A b b
x. B 99 999,
b-S
A b 7 , b
9 j b 58 .5 F
v (FDI) j $6.8
b zb $7 b .6
A, v -
x b A
b 5.7
T b v
v . I b-S
A, - b
48 b 8. I
,
v b HIV
v b 74 . A
, x b
b.8 W
, b
A v
A v .9
4 X D, J T, S B, SF, Strategies and Priorities for African Agriculture (WDC: I F P R I)
5 A Dv I, W Bk,
6 UNCTAD
7 The Economist I M F. T E, Mzbq, Tz, C,G, Zb, N.
8 The Economist, M -8, .9 Sv R, Emerging Africa: How 17 Countries are Leadingthe Way(W DC: C Gb Dv)
Africa Moves Beyond Permanent Crisis
2
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
11/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States8
Africas Emerging Middle Class will be a
Market Driver
A , A . B ,
A v
7 4 ,
6 . A
$68 8
$. A
j. T
b b . SABM,
- b k,
v $.5 b v x v
b v b .
A Dv Bk,Middle of the Pyramid: Dynamicsof the Middle Class in Africa, Mk B A , . Africa in 50 Years Time: The Road Toward Inclusive Growth(T, T: A Dv Bk) Sb .A A , v. F A.
Iv b N,
, x $ b
. T 9 A x b . W-M
q S A-b M H
$.4 b
k . A
v. T b FDI j
A b
k- -A FDI
N, S A, K
x .
T -k
b A .T v
v xv
, bk,
E & Y,Africa Attractiveness Survey
Figure 1. FDI as a Share of GDP for African oil exporters and oil importers1
Africa Economic Outlook 2012. S UNCTAD; WIR, IMF WEO
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
%G
DP
Oil Exporting (%)
Oil Importing (%)
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
12/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 9
- .
S , - v v FDI
GDP -x A (
F ).4 W j b
v ,
. T E A Sb
Cb S A
bb v,
v. Mb k
, , v,
v b
x b v. A
, b - , k
, v,
v .
Policy Commitments Set the Stage for
Agriculture Transformation
A
v. Gv v v
v b b
b , ,
q b.5 Sv
v z
b b b b
b - . I
v- v,
k Ebk, A v
, v . I b
b ,
,4 b A, M E,
E. A W-M b
, Ebk v A
k. W v bk v,
The Africa Competitiveness Report 2011, W EF, W Bk A Dv Bk,4 Africa Economic Outlook 2012. S UNCTAD; WIR, IMFWEO 5 Doing Business 2012, W Bk
,, v.
I , A b N
P A Dv (NEPAD),
v v
x
b . NEPAD z
v
bk . I ,
A Cv A
A Dv P (CAADP)
NEPAD. CAADP k , , A
-b . U , A
v
b 6
b . I,
A k
b b b
.6
E v A,
b v b . T k b
v k
A .7 M
b.
T v
(GDP) v
.8 T
bk A v
k v.
F , , z b
v. T
, , v vz
6
W v v b -b b NEPAD v, b .7 A Dv Bk,African Economic & FinancialBrief, Mk B, V , I 9, Fb7 M , 8 World Development Report: Agriculture for Development(W DC: W Bk) 7
With less than 20
percent of the cont
having access to
banking services, t
offers a tremendou
opportunity to
accelerate employmempowerment, and
development.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
13/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
b N A FS N.
I N A k vb
A,
. T
A . T N A k k
A b
- v (.. CAADP v ) b
b-v PPP.
T x vb
PPP x
N A.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
14/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 11
The New Alliance
and Country Ownership3
By consulting more
broadly with other p
of the government,
business, and civil
society, including th
media, developmen
policies and resourwill help reinforce l
accountability and
undermine it.
Ov , b
v b v. T
b IMF
W Bk v
v b
v j
(.. b j)
j.9 D b,
v, v
v v k
. T
b b .
I 5, P D A Ev
v v
k ,
. U ,
b
x v v
v
. Dv
, z
- , ,
b, , v, v . D
x .
I 8,
A b k
v . Dv
k
. T
b
x b xv b v.I , k xv
xv
9 High Impact Adjustment Lending (HIAL): Initial Evaluation,O Ev D, N. 9797 (W- DC: W Bk) 999
P D A Ev, 5
k . B b v,
b, v , ,
v
b .
A ,
v b
-
. G b
b. T
b .
T U.S. v b v . I
b b Rb D
. U P G W. B,
M C C (MCC)
.
T MCC b v
. A MCC,
x ,
z, v k
MCC v,
MCC- , bb k b
k v .
U P Bk Ob,
b U.S.
Q D Dv Rv
P P Dv Gb
Dv. T U.S. A I
Dv (USAID)
U.S. F F Iv
.
T v S T. L,MCC Principles into Practice: Country Owner-ship (W DC: MCC) Nvb
T U.S. F F Iv v v v v , , v .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
15/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
When global leaders
launched the New
Alliance for Food
ecurity and Nutrition at
the 2012 Camp David
G8 Summit, country
ownership remaineda key element of this
ffort and expanded the
partnership to actively
include the private
sector.
v v
v v
v z
A U N
P A Dv, ,
v CAADP, -
v b. F
F, b , U.S. v
v b -
A .
I , USAID b v j
. K
P G,
v U.S. v
b
-v. I k
b v
z v . USAID
b
v
USAID F. I A , USAID
v q b
(.. b
PFM ). T v
USAID v
k PFM
,
v b
v U
j vb
v . I b b
USAID -v
v z, USAID ,
Feed the Future Progress Report: Boosting Harvests, FightingPoverty(W DC: USAID) Ob
v v bjv.4
Ov , b
v v,
b NGO.5
Alliance Partners Seek to Operationalize
Ownership
I 9, G8 LAq F S Iv
(AFSI) v $ b
R P.6
I b
v b
v. W b N A F S N
C Dv G8 S,
k
x v
v .
S N A
v
v , v , ,
v . T v
b N A b
v , ,
CAADP v . T
v
b v v,
v , b
4 ADS C U Rb P C S D M I A CI D: 8/6/
5 USAID F P R
6 T R P ) v -; ) , , b v; ) v v, -k k vb - b , , v ; 4) ; 5) b b v .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
16/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 13
But, country owner
also means these
countries exercisin
leadership over
their development
policies and strateg
and coordinatingdevelopment action
, , .
B , N A
E, G Tz
v v N A C
Fk, b v
v,
, b. O UN
G Ab Sb , N
A , , v
b Bk
F, C Iv, Mzbq v v N A C
Fk.
E x N A C
Fk G8 v
, CAADP :
E: T A S P
Iv Fk (PIF)
Tz: T A F S
Iv P (TAFSIP)
G: T M-T A S
Iv P (METASIP)
Bk F: T R S N
P (PNSR)
C Iv: T N A
Iv P (PNIA)
Mzbq: T P N
Iv S A (PNISA)
A , P D A
Ev,
x . D b
k N A
b
. B, x v
v
v . T N
A C Fk
b
v k
v. T N
A x
v
k A
v
.
T , ,
v b
, ,
,
. N A
v , ,
k k k v
. T k b
b v b b ,
v b v,
v k
.7 Mv, v
b
N A k MNC
kv.
New Alliance Countries Face Pitfalls
on the Path to Ownership
B, N A
? T OECD Sv M
P D
7 G C, K R T, J M.W, Mk A, Transformational Partnerships:Innovative Approaches to Addressing Food Security in Africa(W DC: GMF) A
http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
17/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States14
The role of the media
in providing critical
analysis on national
strategies and policies
has been scarce.
v k . T Sv
N A
A b x
v v
v v
.
Ov,
v v b 5
, b
. Hv,
. S, Sv v
v .
I x
v v
k -
x k
b.8 T b
v :
A v - v
(.. k)
A v
W- b (..
k b )
Gb,
9
75 . B , 5
v
A B
v v . Hv, N A
A B . M
v ( F ).
8 Aid Effectiveness 2005-10: Progress in Implementing the ParisDeclaration, OECD,
Figure 2. The Survey on Monitoring the Paris
Declaration: Do countries have operational
development strategies? 29
Country 2005 2007 2010
E C B B
Tz B B A
G C B B
Bk F C B C
C Iv N/A N/A N/A
Mzbq C C B
A v N A v E, Tz,
G, Bk F, Mzbq
M Dv G
. T v ,
v ,
v v .
Hv, Bk F
b q b
v . D k
, ,
,
k . I
v k v q
v .
T
k b b z.
I E, G, Mzbq, Tz,
. T
b x
k. T
v v
v
, b,
. T x
9 Survey on Monitoring the Paris Declaration , OECD,
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
18/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 15
In two New Alliance
countries, the
compensation to
households affecte
these land investm
has been determin
be inadequate thnot sufficient to res
their livelihoods.
.
Hv, v N A
v
b v
. E v
v b E.
W , v , v
vv
G, b
v . I Mzbq,
v , v
v . S v
bv
. T
x v
b v .
T N A
P Sv v
v v , ,
v
v . Hv, k
. P
b -v v b
b
. T v
b
. W
q,
v b
v .
Land Represents the Weakest Link
in OwnershipA P Sv v
N A v
, x. T
Survey on Monitoring the Paris Declaration , OECD,
Ib.
v N A. F ,
, A b
v
k
bk . P N A
k
.
Ev b Bk
F R S N P (PNSR),
k b b
, , -v
b, , . Mzbq
vb
b , b P
Sv.
T N A x
b
. A , ,
NGO b
b v A
vb z z.
T v b x b
k. R
v
v v k A. A
b - v ,
S K D L
C .
z M. C
v q .8
D Rb C
.
B S I G Ix (OECD), N A k 5 Mzbq (9) Tz (47). T k C Iv (6), E (64), Bk F (7) 86 v .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
19/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States16
PPPs could potentially
serve as catalytic
vehicles for food
security but also for
improved governance
nd country ownership,
if well-structured.
A , ,
, x b
k. I N
A , v
v vv k
b v / v
.4 I
N A ,
b v
b b q
v.5 T
NA , q
b v b
v v q
b
v .6
U, k
v x
. O ,
, v
x , k
A. B , A,
,
( b ). N A
x b.
F , Tz E v -
. B
v. Sv
j , v
Tz. L k k
K G, Our Land, Our Lives Time out on the global landrush (U K: Ox GB) Ob
4 P B. M, Kj Hvvk, Ak B,Biofuels, Land Grabs, and Food Security in Africa (N Yk/L: Z Bk) 5 Lz C, Sj V, Rb L JK, Land Grabs or Development Opportunity? AgricultureInvestment and international land deals in Africa (L/R:IIED, FAO, IFAD) 9
6 Ib.
k
v
.
T v
v b
N A. U
C Fk,
k
V G Rb
Gv T L, F,
F Cx N F S P Rb A
Iv.7 T
k k
v
.
Mv, N A
v v
. O
-
.
T k b
v , b
b-
v , ,
v . T
b-v b
( b). PPP
v v b
v v ,
-.
Reporting and Accountability Must ResolveOwnership Pitfalls
A N A
? I , b
v b N A
7 S N A C Fk
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
20/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 17
b v b . T q
, , k
, k b
, , .
N A C Fk q
k
,
, v v
, ,
j v.
A x N A v
vv. C Iv
R L A b v
b J 5. I
Mzbq, v v
v
x b
b J . Bk F b
k b z
b,
( , , .), CNSS
v v
v
b Db . E
k v b b
, -
,
b Db .
R, , b b b b N A
. S N A
. F , N
G A P Sv (GAPS)
z b
v k . N A
b
,
, , ,
, x, k .
W , b b v-b ,
k, k
.
T b k b
L C C Dv
G8 S. I G8
A U . T -
CAADP- J S Rv ,
CAADP v
, x v , G8
, v b N A. R
b v
b qb ,
q, k
. Hv, b b,
b k N
A .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
21/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Over the past decade,
FDI to New Alliance
untries has risen from
$980 million to nearly
$7 billion, which has
een primarily driven by
anzania, Mozambique,and Ghana.
D G8 S M ,P Ob 45
$ b A ,
j b
v b
v. A U N G Ab
Sb , USAID A D.
Rjv S v-
, A ,
$5
A A.
T U.S. v b
v v 97. I
97, U.S. v Ov
Pv Iv C (OPIC),
k jb b
b. I v v
, , k ,
v q v
v v
. U P R 98,
v
v v . A C W
989, USAID b
C E Sv U v
-z (SME).
T E F b b
b C, ,
v
v
.8
T b-v
b v
v . I 97,
8 C L, Kk N, M Lb, TJ, Foreign Aid and Private Sector Development(W- DC: W ) 6
v . T bz v
, v x
v (ODA) v
. S 99, .
B , ODA $4 b, b
b ,
$4 b, v,
$777 b. (S F . T
v v b
.)
A , , A
b b
v v
N A A. A
v ,
FDI b-S A $6.8
b zb $7 b . I
b b-S A
v FDI v
b 5 . T
b v
z k, , jb. T ,
v FDI
v . Ov , FDI
N A $98
$7 b, b
v b Tz, Mzbq, G (
F 4).9
N A
. ODA $.6 $6.7 b
x .4 A
G, ODA x FDI N A ( F 5). E
9 U v GFDI . W A FDI v , .
4 OECD
The New Alliance and
Public-Private Partnerships4
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
22/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 19
v
v 8 C
Iv b b . D
FDI v
, N A
b ,
, ,
.4
New Alliance PPPs Offer the Promise of
Enlightened Capitalism
Pb-v v b
v x . PPP
b k W
Bk bk,
4 OECD
EU , -
j. T j
z PPP. S
PPP x . Ov ,
vv v b
b k b
PPP.
F , USAID
Gb Dv A (GDA),
b PPP. U GDA, PPP U.S. v k
v , b
( -k) v
bjv v
Figure 3. Private sector ows (FDI and remittances) and ofcial development assistance (ODA) to the
developing world 1991-2011 (billions)1
UNCTAD, W Bk, OECD
$-
$200
$400
$600
$800
$1,000
$1,200
$1,400
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Official Development Assistance Remittances Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
23/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
b.4 T k
U.S. v
v . T vv GDA
vv : v
v USAID
j k v
b k . GDA
b v b,
, , v,
, , -
-- -v .
I USAID F P R ,
v
b-v
4 M L L, Foreign Assistance: Public-PrivatePartnerships (W DC: C R Sv)J ,
b b FY5. I
GDA, x
Dv C A (DCA)
. T DCA b S
T G W, DC,
v
v v
v. A v,
v b
F Iv O F Sv
O x bk
PPP . T b
v ,
, ,
.
Figure 4. New Alliance FDI inows 2000-2011 (billions)1
UNCTAD
$-
$1
$2
$3
$4
$5
$6
$7
$8
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Ghana
Mozambique
Tanzania
Cte d'Ivoire
Ethiopia
Burkina Faso
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
24/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 21
B GDA , D. Rjv S
k U.S.
v
b b
k v
v v b.4 O
, v
v
v v. O ,
z v
v b .
B b S R B
b k k v j b
b k v. H
4 D. Rjv S, Eb E C ,USAID Pb-Pv P F, W, DC,Ob ,
G,
S F, jb A
- -z b v.
T ;
. T x v
b. T . E
v b. W .44
T b v b
k. E
v N A F S
N. T v
b v ,
. C
44 The Economist, S R B k - , Nvb 6,
Figure 5. ODA and FDI to New Alliance Countries in 2010 (billions)1
OECD UNCTAD
$-
$0.5
$1.0
$1.5
$2.0
$2.5
$3.0
ODA
FDI
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
25/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
A v , . S v
b
xv
.45 T q
v - ,
b .46 T v
b b
x b v
v. Hv, N A k
b ,
b b.
The Anatomy of PPPs is Based on
a Clear Division of Labor
T v PPP q
b. T k
v v
. C b
x b ,
, , , x,
k, v,
z k
. FDI PPP v v
v bk k
, ,
,
b , ,
.47 A , v
x v x
, ,
, , v,
45 M L L, Foreign Assistance: Public-PrivatePartnerships (W DC: C R Sv)J ,
46 J M, E A Aq K, DoesForeign Direct Investment Crowd-Out Domestic Private Invest-ment in Sub-Saharan Africa?, A F J , v., , 7-5; J H. D,MultinationalEnterprises and the Global Economy(Wk, E:A-W) 9947 T M, Harnessing Foreign Direct Investment forDevelopment: Policies for Developed and Developing Countries,(W DC: C Gb Dv) 6
b v v. D v
b
(..
- ).
PPP b v
v b b
b. F x, M D
Dv A GDA- PPP. T
bjv b
, k ,
- k bk v b.48 T
k v
, v
,
k . USAID b
v, ,
. L OLk v
x
b. M v b
. G M
, k
v . T v M
k v ,
k b x .
A M D Dv
A, k bk
v
v. I
,4
b 4 , v
x 4, b. TA b vk
. F v
v v v b
48 M L L, Foreign Assistance: Public-PrivatePartnerships (W DC: C R Sv)J ,
FDI and PPPs can have
a positive impact on
development through
backward linkages to
local suppliers, the
transfer of technology,
and interchangeof managers and
technicians, thereby
increasing incomes,
learning, and product
standards.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
26/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 23
Under these benefi
sharing models,
smallholder farmer
in the vicinity of lar
scale farms gain ac
to inputs (e.g. fertil
extension services,value-added faciliti
and markets.
, b .49
T E C Iv b-v
k b
v v -q Ab
, b . T
v
v v . T G
F TSv
j
v . E-b NbI Bk S.C. (NIB) I
F C (IFC)
x.
USAID b. Sbk
P C E
. T
E M A
v v,
b, x
.5
T IFC v k-
$ NIB,
v v k
TSv. TSv b
v b
v q b . B
, 6 v 45,
v k NIB. T
v x
, v v 4
bv v -q,
. Cv v
49 L O Lk I Dv b5 G C, K R T, J M.W, Mk A, Transformational Partnerships:Innovative Approaches to Addressing Food Security in Africa(W DC: GMF) A
$.5 , NIB 8 .5
Tanzania Makes a Deep Effort
to Combine PPPs and Ownership
T S A G C
Tz (SAGCOT)
v . A
- z ,
k b v v
x . SAGCOT k
b
b - . U b- ,
v -
(.. z), x v, v-
, k. I b
v
b ,
, b,
k- v. I b
v j
, ,
bk -v
v q k b.
USAID, U.K. D I
Dv, N Eb
Tz v x
SAGCOT , v
v -
vb b. Y I v
z D S.
I Sb , USAID, U.K. D
I Dv, E
U
v
Kb , SAGCOT
v. USAID, W Bk,
5 TSv b
http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
27/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States24
S, G M, D, M, A G Rv (AGRA), N
M Bk (NMB), N, SABM,
S Bk .
T b
v b v
v SAGCOT .5
SAGCOT b b-v
v
v v
-v
v. I J, P Jk Kk
SAGCOT Iv B W
E F Dv. T v
Tz v SAGCOT
Tz A P, Y, Uv,
P, W E F. A
b
v vv SAGCOT /
A C
Tz, Tz A P,
C Tz I, Tz S G A.5
A ,
x v v
v
.54 I Tz, N A
A F S Iv P
TAFSIP. Tz
5 S SAGCOT Iv Mx ://../
/-/5 T Tz N B C(TNBC). T TNBC b v v v -v. I v -, - K Kz A F 9.
54 P D A Ev, 5
TAFSIP I-MC C (ICC). T ICC
v v
, k k,
TAFSIP bjv v.55 T Cb
M,
, v v b
TAFSIP b v. T
ICC v
-, v , . A
v SAGCOT
ICC, Cb .
O SAGCOT
SAGCOT C L.
Hv Ob , C
b xv ,
b , v
SAGCOT k. T CEO
C Dv Dv
Tz M A, F S,
Cv. T b Tz
v, , x,
b . T C b . I
v
v k b . I
b b
b v
v
.56
Benefit-Sharing Models Demonstrate
Impact and Reveal Failures
T x b-
v, b,
Tz,
55 Tanzania Agriculture and Food Security Investment Plan, Ob 8, 56 B Jk,Modernizing the Southern Agricultural GrowthCorridor of Tanzania: A Case Study(Cb, MA: HvK S Gv)
There are examples
of the benefit-sharing
model of including
government, business,
and farmers in
Tanzania, which helped
to set the stage ofSAGCOT.
http://www.sagcot.com/resources/downloads-resources/http://www.sagcot.com/resources/downloads-resources/http://www.sagcot.com/resources/downloads-resources/http://www.sagcot.com/resources/downloads-resources/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
28/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 25
Contract farming ca
bring smallholder
farmers into the for
economy and unde
the right conditions
has resulted in inco
security, higher retand a number of ot
benefits for them.
SAGCOT. W bz,
vz .
T k
b . T
v v
v
v v v
v v . T
v,
b . T
v v z
5-, k (.. bk)
. T v
v .57
T Tz R P (TARIPA)
SAGCOT vv
v Tz, b ,
W Bk, USAID, N, J
I C A, FAO v . A b
- ,
x , , -
. I v
b , v- v,
v .58
Kb P L (KPL)
b 8 b A
M C
Iv G, A A C,57 T Iv S, - PvA S S , CRDB Bk M- Sv C, v .58 G C, K R T, J M.W, Mk A, Transformational Partnerships:Innovative Approaches to Addressing Food Security in Africa(W DC: GMF) A
NORFUND. T $5 v , ,
, q,
,
. W 5,49
v,
v- b 9 , b ,844
. USAID
.59
C b
, ,
, , , b b .6
F , v v q
- Tz,
. T
z b , ,
- , .
K T, NGO b b U,
b
M D v b ,
, v b. T
M H Q F
P L. T , k
,
.6 T b
bk
US$,
US$5 . C
F A Oz (FAO),
, ,
. T b
x v b v.
59 SAGCOT Iv P P O Iv R S, Fb 8, .
6 D Sv, Abb Bx, B V, U - v v - v?I I Ev Dv/Sb F Lb,
6 ://-.b./
http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://masasi-farmers.webs.com/http://masasi-farmers.webs.com/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
29/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States26
T v b x OLAM I,
b
. T
v -
k.
A k T
Ex G F S A,
G M F- v,
, v
. T k
v
k. T v
v v ,
, /b q, v-
, , k,
b . T
v b-v.
A Ex G
b v
, k, b
v
.6
A k b GMF
Ex G L A.
S
j vv
x. T
. F , NGO
Tz
6 G C, K R T, J M.W, Mk A, Transformational Partnerships:Innovative Approaches to Addressing Food Security in Africa(W DC: GMF) A
. Hv, v x,
v , q
v , -
v . T
,
k .
A ,
x z,
v
. T v
v k. Tx
j b
.
Ownership Gaps Pose a Threat to PPPs
T M , E , SAGCOT
b
k v
b v
v . T
. I ,
vb b k
N A PPP.
Hv, N
A PPP. F , v -
PPP M E
x -
v
, , . B, v
PPP k v
v v k (..
).6
6 T Ex G W, DC,B, D S -
If a country has weak
country ownership
where national
acroeconomic policies
run counter to sector-
specific agriculture
ans, then New AlliancePPPs will have difficulty
scaling up.
http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
30/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 27
Given the level of
specificity of the
policy reforms and
investments outline
in the frameworks,
these transaction-
oriented discussioncould potentially sp
a number of leadin
PPPs in New Allianc
countries.
B , SAGCOT -v b- v vz
v v . SAGCOT
PPP v ,
b b
v. I b b
. SAGCOT b v
- .64 L
b .
T
v x
b v .
O PPP v b
.
U N A,
PPP b
, v
P M Sv. I
-b , ,
b
v b
k,
v v b v
, k. I k
-
, N A PPP v
.
T q b
b v . T b
v b . Lk x
k ,
v,
64 B Jk,Modernizing the Southern Agricultural GrowthCorridor of Tanzania: A Case Study(Cb, MA: HvK S Gv)
, v q.65
Hv, x v
, v
, , ,
. F k
v
b
. I
.66 B ,
N A
b v
. G b
-v b v b PPP .
O kb b q x
v , k
. PPP b
b
, b
.
Building Trust Between Public
and Private Sectors will be Critical
A N A PPP k
b b
v . Gv v v
b v ,
, , ,
, v b
(.. ), b
x v,
. T v
CAADP v b 6
b j
65 D Sv, Abb Bx, B V, Under what condi-tions are value chains effective tools for pro-poor development?(I I Ev Dv/Sb F Lb)
66 Ib.
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
31/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
. Hv, v b
v v,
v v v
.67
B , N
A , v A
67 T Ex G W, DC,B, D S -
bv v
v b
v b vv
v v .68 T
v v
68 M Nv Dv S, Private SectorPerspectives for Strengthening Agribusiness Value Chains in
Africa: Case Studies from Ethiopia, Ghana, Kenya and Mali(W DC: P C H A) M
Figure 6. Mutual Accountability under the New Alliance
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
32/35
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
33/35
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
-b b b v . N A
b
b, Tz H
A, INTERCOTON (
C Iv), U C
Ev Rz B ( 46
v b Bk F). E
v
v v
b v
b .
7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
34/35
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition 31
Conclusion
5
T b v
. I G8,
G, U N, A U .
F b
. I v -/-
b v,
k- v
- -
.7 T
k v b
N A .
C b-v
N A
. Y
b N
A. T
A v b PPP, v
b z
. T
b A
-v v v
v v v v
.
7 G C, K R T, J M.W, Mk A, Transformational Partnerships:Innovative Approaches to Addressing Food Security in Africa(W DC: GMF) A
Africa will likely see
further gains as the
continents emergi
middle class drives
new dynamism, wh
if linked to New Alli
efforts, could magndevelopment outco
Hv PPP N A v
b ,
, b .
I, A
v
b .
A k
v ,
, k N A ,
v .
Pb-v (PPP) vv
b
z k .7 A
PPP A
v b
k v
. A N A k
v ,
v
v A.
7 D. Rjv S, Eb E C ,USAID Pb-Pv P F, W, DC,Ob ,
http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/http://www.gmfus.org/archives/transformational-partnerships-innovative-approaches-to-addressing-food-security-in-africa/7/28/2019 The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition: Pushing the Frontier of Enlightened
35/35
Off i c e s
Washington Berlin Paris BrusselsBelgrade Ankara Bucharest Warsaw