1
Association of Legal AdministratorsAnnual Conference & Expo 2019FM32: The Performance Metrics
Dashboard A Powerful Management Tool!
Presented by:Frederick J. Esposito, Jr., MBA, CLMChief Operating OfficerRivkin Radler LLP
April 17, 2019
Objectives
• The Performance Metrics Dashboard Concept• The Dashboard Design• Dashboard Implementation• Business Value Obtained• Critical Success Factors• Common Pitfalls
2
The DashboardA simple way for law firm management to monitor
key performance metrics from across the firmWhy Do Dashboards Matter?
• Graphs and visuals encourage storytelling, a sign of active interaction with the numbers
• Effective tools for ensuring shared financial comprehension and engagement among Partners and key decision makers
• Process of developing a dashboard can help define measures of success
Why a Dashboard?
• A well-proven performance management practice – provides a law firm wide perspective of overall functional area performance
• Firm objectives/goals and management expectations are clearly defined and articulated
• Standardize data sharing and performance measurement practices – brings all performance data from various sources before the decision makers.
• Serves as a performance diagnostic tool –facilitates decision on fact rather than judgmental inference –Remove guess work!
3
Why a Dashboard?• Establishes a platform for law firm business and
operational excellence – uses functional performance metrics to drive productivity
• Directs process improvement efforts – converts business data into action-oriented information; helps coordinate actions amongst diverse stakeholders and align execution with strategic goals
• Establishes the foundation for benchmarking organizational processes – through goal alignment across the organization
Align People, Implement Strategies, and Measure Performance
The Performance Management ModelWhere we need to go. . .
1.Assess Change Readiness2.Establish Mission/Vision3.Establish Firm Objectives/Goals
How we will get there. . .
1.Projects/Services/Technology Plans/Other Plans2.Action Plans/Milestones3.Execution of Plans
How will we knowwe are getting there…
DASHBOARD
METR
CS
I
Targets
MeasuredData
Monitoring trigger / cyclePerformance Management
Track Outcome
Performance
Analysis
4
Questions to Ask Yourself• Why are you creating a dashboard?• Do you need to track certain KPIs?• Who needs to see the dashboard?• Where will the data come from?• How up to date does the dashboard need to be?• What format does the dashboard need to be in?
The Dashboard Design
5
Requirements of a DashboardIdentification of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
➢ KPIs should be firm specific➢ No law firm uses the same KPIs➢ Important to the firm and defines success➢ Implementation/tracking to guide firm strategy
Categorize information/identify data sources➢ Quantifiable➢ Practical➢ Directional➢ Actionable➢ Financial
Requirements of a Dashboard• Identification of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
➢ Provides targeted objectives/added value➢ Reflects the firm’s goals➢ Viewed as key to firm success➢ It is Quantifiable
6
Dashboard PerspectivesFinancial Performance
➢ Performance KPIs➢ Operations➢ Marketing/Business Development
Client Service➢ Client satisfaction➢ Client retention
Learning and Growth➢ Organizational effectiveness
(Functional areas)➢ Human capital➢ Training/resources
Internal➢Quality of Work➢“PI & PM”
A Balanced Scorecard Approach
Decision MakingKPIs Must Be Clearly DefinedIdentify what needs to be collected
• What Data?• Big Rocks First, Pebbles Next!
Precisely Measured –Accuracy is Crucial• Do Not Try to Collect Every Metric at Once• “Analysis Paralysis”
Accurately InterpretedAppropriately Acted Upon
“Good Metrics, Good Decisions!”
7
Balanced Score Card –Strategic Planning
What Does This Have to Do With Dashboards?
Target Setting – Firm Business Objectives
Financial Performance➢ Billable Hours per Timekeeper➢ Average Billed Rate➢ Leverage➢ Billings/Revenues per Lawyer
Client Service➢ Efficiency and Focus➢ Added Value
Learning and Growth➢ Employee Development➢ Education/CLE➢ Desired Performance
Internal➢ Processes➢ Work Managed➢ Innovation➢ Excellence➢ Results!
8
Financial KPI Examples
1. Unbilled Days2. Uncollected Days3. Net Income (Profit) as a Percentage of Revenue4. Average Net Overhead5. Revenue per Square Foot6. Revenue per Attorney (?)7. Revenue per Matter8. Revenue per Client
Operational KPI Examples
1. Billable hours per FTE2. Percentage of Partner hours3. Billings per FTE4. Average Billing rate5. Average Work rate6. Ratio of Billed-to-Work rate –”Realization”7. Number of Matters Opened8. Staffing Ratios9. Cost Recovery Revenue/Matter
9
Marketing & Business Development KPI Examples1. Client Growth Rate2. Dormant Client Percentage3. Average Fee per Client/Matter4. Average Fee per NEW Client/Matter5. Marketing/Business Development Budget Ratio6. Marketing/Business Development Cost per Client7. Client Retention8. Growth in Top Clients9. Practice Areas per Client10. Number of Lawyers per Client11. Number of Matters per Client
Typical Performance IndicatorsFinancial➢ Revenue per lawyer➢ Net income as %age of
revenues➢ Average net overhead per
lawyer➢ Revenue per matter➢ Revenue per client➢ Unbilled days (WIP)➢ Uncollected days (AR)
Client (Marketing)➢ Growth rate➢ Practice areas/client➢ Average fee/client➢ Dormant client %age➢ Growth in top clients➢ # lawyers/client➢ # matters/client
10
Typical Performance IndicatorsInternal
➢ Revenues/Expenses➢ Net income➢ Defects – PI & PM➢ Staffing allocation➢ Quality Control
Learning and Growth➢ Human capital investment in line
with business strategy➢ Training effectiveness
Select KPIs That Drive Firm Growth
“Higher Gross Revenues Automatically Lead to Higher Profits!”
11
Running a highly profitable Law Firm that produces amazing profits year after year has little to do with the quality of the attorneys in the Firm as it does the quality of their legal services.
Do YOU Know What Numbers to Measure to Ensure Profitability and Drive Growth in YOUR Law Firm?
Most Law Firms do NOT know! WHY NOT?
Factors:• Just don’t know what KPIs to utilize• Not Compiling Measures on a Consistent
Basis and Accurately Comparing them Month over Month, Quarter over
Quarter, Year over Year….
Do YOU Know What Numbers to Measure to Ensure Profitability and Drive Growth in YOUR Law Firm?
12
Misleading Benchmarks?Revenues per Partner
Law firms vary significantly in terms of how many staff supports each Partner –Impacts Profitability!
Benchmarks can be skewed; tend to lean towards larger firms –Small v. Large Law Firms
Lack Clear Understanding of Metrics
“Our Only Benchmark is Our Own Past Experience.”-Mid-Size Law Firm Partner
National Sources of Benchmarking Data• Lexis Firm Insight BI Companion/Peer Monitor• ALM Survey of Law Firm Economics• Hildebrandt Peer Monitor Economic Index• PwC Economic Surveys
Big 4 in the House!
Metrics and Benchmarking•Measure your Firm against a group of similar firms
•Compare specific performance measures across the members of the group
13
KPIs – Use Liberal Doses of Common Sense! • KPIs help to better assess Firm performance• Consider your Firm’s specific goals• KPIs can and will change over time as your • Firm evolves • Measure Firm performance with good and • timely information• KPIs are measurable inputs, but no• substitute for Common Sense and • Good Judgment
Dashboard Implementation
14
Dashboard Implementation
• Historical Data Analysis• Risk Management• KPI Design/Benchmarking• Reporting Design• Evaluation• Firm Performance Baselines• Control Phase
Dashboard Business Evaluation Process
15
Key Players/Implementation Process• Executive/Management Committee• COO/Executive Director/Admin Directors• Project Manager(s)• Financial Data Manager(s)
Power of the Dashboard
“Knowledge is Power”-Francis Bacon
16
Power of Dashboards
• “You Can’t Drive The Car by Solely Watching the Dashboard “
• Rather, it helps you know how well you are progressing towards your destination
Power of the DashboardBest Practices
➢ Dashboards should include 8-10 KPIs▪ Financial and non-financial metrics ▪ Get a well-rounded view!
➢ Measure/track performance and success
➢ Suggested dashboard metrics:▪ Working Capital▪ Operating Cash Flow▪ Current Ratio▪ Return on Equity▪ Debt to Equity▪ AR Turnover▪ AP Turnover▪ WIP Turnover
17
Power of the Dashboard
Best Practices➢ Other Possible Dashboards
➢ Cost of Servicing a client➢ Practice Area Profitability➢ Profitability by Partner
Types of Dashboards➢ Taskflow
➢ Directed Action➢ Business Intelligence
➢ Presentation layer
Knowledge Management➢ Operational efficiency
Power of the Dashboard
18
Power of the Dashboard –Lesson Learned?
The Key to a Good Dashboard is a Well-Defined Question
Sometimes a Critical Step in Problem Solving…..Isn’t always about finding the right answers,
but in having the right answer in the correct content.
Discuss!
Power of the Dashboard The Power of Excel!
• How to bring data into Excel - ODBC• Set up an Excel dashboard file • Create table with raw data• Analyze the data• Build the dashboard • Pivot tables
19
Dashboard Examples
Dashboard Examples
20
Dashboard Examples
Dashboard Examples
21
Dashboard Examples
General Benefits• Focus on key firm business processes• Transparency of operations and visibility to
Executive/Management• Facilitates goal alignment across the
organization through coherent action plans• Induces peer pressure and healthy
competition• Facilitates a self-sustained.....
Process improvementProject Management
22
ROI from the Dashboard
• Traditional productivity gains➢ A highly productive law firm➢ Improved work product/delivery of services➢ Easy monitoring of firm expenses, cash flows,
operating profits• Second/third tier benefits
➢ Better (proactive) performance tracking with timely action
➢ Monitoring mechanisms are well-defined
Critical Success FactorsLeverage existing technology infrastructure
➢ Start simple, ensure usefulness, acquire buy-inA sound measurement foundation
➢ Identifying the right metrics (all levels of the firm) – the selected metrics should be reliable indicators of performance
➢ Interpreting metricsOwnership for (data) resultsAnalyzing results
➢ Contextual analysis through co-relations➢ Translate performance metrics into clear improvement
opportunitiesA strong improvement process
➢ Ownership for timely corrective action➢ Continuous process improvement
23
Critical Success Factors
• Employee training programs• Effectiveness of the dashboard• Metrics for the monitoring process –
Controls?• Regular re-evaluation of the dashboards for
timeliness and responsiveness of performance indicators monitored –Deliverables consistent?
Common Pitfalls
Misconceptions➢ Benchmarking
➢ Reconsider metrics rather than the tools▪ Right choice of KPIs
▪ Right data (and source)
▪ Correct dashboard representation
▪ Ownership of data
24
PI & PM – A Powerful Combination
Process ImprovementHelps us determine the best way to carry out a certain kind of work to achieve.• Efficiency• Excellent quality of work
and service• High probability of
successful outcomes• Predictability
Process ManagementA role and set of skills that ensures that for a particular engagement, we• Use our “best process”
appropriately • Actively manage
schedules, staff, and deliverables throughout this matter
Note: PM skills are used for managing PI projects
http://legalleansigma.com/
http://legalleansigma.com/
25
http://legalleansigma.com/
http://legalleansigma.com/
26
http://legalleansigma.com/
http://legalleansigma.com/
27
Frederick J. Esposito, Jr., MBA, CLMChief Operating OfficerRivkin Radler LLP926 RXR PlazaUniondale, NY 11556Email Address: [email protected] Number: 516-357-3330www.rivkinradler.com
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/fjespositoTwitter: Lawmgtguru
Contact Information
28
55©Legal Lean Sigma Institute LLC. All rights reserved. Legal Lean Sigma is a registered trademark.
Contact
FREDERICK J. ESPOSITO, JR., MBA, CLMFaculty & Consultant
Legal Lean Sigma Institute [email protected]
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/fjespositoTwitter: LawmgtguruWebsite: LegalLeanSigma.com