Topic 2: Fossil Fuel Supply and Demand: Effect ofSubsidies and Taxation
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 1 / 53
Introduction
This topic follows strategy I plan in using in this course
A bit of economic theory in the context of a particular energy marketplus a case study
Here Supply + Demand for fossil fuels
But we will also use Supply+Demand ideas useful in other energymarkets
Effect of taxes and subsidies
Case study: effect of fossil fuel subsidies (general theory plus focus ona few specific countries)
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 2 / 53
Supply and Demand
Supply and demand graphs are a basic tool for many economicproblems
Involves Q = quantity bought and sold (produced and consumed)
P = price
Supply = what is produced/sold by companies/firms
Demand = what is consumed/bought by consumers
The quantity firms supply increases with price
E.g. price of coal goes up, miners produce more coal
Quantity consumed decreases with price
E.g. price of coal goes up, electricity generators buy less coal (switchto gas)
Next slide illustrates this in Supply-Demand graph
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 3 / 53
Price
Quantity
Demand Curve
Supply Curve
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 4 / 53
Supply Equals Demand in Equilibrium
Demand curve: for each price, how much will consumers buy?
Supply curve: for each price, how much will producers produce?
Equilibrium price: quantity demanded equals quantity supplied
Why?
If price too low, then producers will not produce enough to meetdemand
Excess demand means price will be driven up
If price too high, the consumers won’t buy as much as producers wantto produce
Excess supply means price will be driven down
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 5 / 53
Price
Quantity
Demand Curve
Supply Curve
Plow
Q supplied Q demanded
Pequilibrium
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 6 / 53
Example: What Influences Supply for Coal?
Supply depends on price of coal (movement along the supply curve)
Other factors will shift entire supply curve
Factor influencing costs of production (e.g. wages, etc.)
In longer run, technology and geology influence supply curve
E.g. mine cheapest seams of coal first before digging deeper for moreexpensive
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 7 / 53
Example: What Influences Demand for Coal?
Depends on price of coal (movement along the demand curve)
Other factors shift entire demand curve
Coal is heavily used for electricity generation
Anything that influences demand for electricity will also affect coal
Weather (home heating, electricity for air conditioners, etc.)
State of the economy: industry uses a fair degree of coal directly orindirectly as electricity
Price of alternative fuels
In relation to alternative fuel prices, introduce some terminology onnext slide
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 8 / 53
Electricity generating companies often own both gas and coalgenerating plants
These depend on prices of fuels and influence demand curve
Spark spread = profit margin per unit of electricity produced using gas
Dark spread = profit margin per unit of electricity produced using coal
Switch production depend on so-called spreads
Also including price of CO2 emissions leads to “clean”dark/sparkspreads
Hot issue: in US natural gas price very low, electricity generationswitching to gas, hurting coal miners
Glut of cheap US coal bought by German electricity generators
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 9 / 53
Government Actions Can Influence Supply and Demand
Example: EU-ETS requires electricity generating companies to buycarbon permits
Electricity generation from coal releases more CO2 than generationfrom other sources
Carbon price rises implies coal generation becomes more costly
How would this appear in a supply-demand graph?
Shift demand curve down
Why?
Electricity generators are demanders of coal
At any price level demand less (the effective price of coal they pay hasincreased since higher carbon price)
Result: equilibrium price and quantity of coal falls
Note: this is what is happening in US to coal industry now due to fallin natural gas price
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 10 / 53
Price
Quantity
Original Demand Curve
Supply Curve
Original P
Original Q
New P
New Q
New Demand Curve
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 11 / 53
Government Intervention: Price Supports
Price support: Set minimum price for coal.
If market price above price support, no effect
If market price below, the government must intervene buying coal toforce price up to price support
Alternatively, governments sometimes set maximum price for fossilfuels (to protect consumers)
If market price above minimum price, excess demand (black market,corruption)
Supply-demand graphs can be used to show these
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 12 / 53
Government Intervention: Subsidies
Subsidies:
E.g. for each ton of coal produced the government will pay 10 Euros
Or for each 1 Euro of coal you sell, the government will pay an extra10%
Subsidies are the opposite of energy taxes so I will defer graphs untiltaxes discussed
Price supports/subsidies common in Europe in the past (particularlyin the coal industry)
Declining slowly (but even in 2001 Germany was spending almost $5billion on coal subsidies)
Protect coal industry and jobs
Hot issue: economic consequences of energy subsidies in developingworld
Return to this issue shortly
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 13 / 53
Government Intervention: Taxation
Fossil fuels are typically heavily taxed in various ways, including:
Corporation tax (tax on profits as paid by any company)
Severance taxes (popular in US, sometimes called ad valorem taxes)
E.g. percentage of value of coal produced.
Royalties
VAT and other taxes paid by consumers, etc.
Many other taxes
To give a flavour of the types of tax regimes, faced by fossil fuelcompanies I will give a few examples
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 14 / 53
Hot Issue: UK Taxation of North Sea Oil
From budget statement on 23 March 2011:
Chancellor of the Exchequer announced increase in the‘supplementary charge’paid by companies involved in North Sea oil &gas production. North Sea companies pay corporation tax on theirprofits from oil and gas extraction in the UK and the UK ContinentalShelf. In its 2002 Budget the Labour Government introduced asupplementary charge on profits set at 10%, and this was increased to20% in January 2006. In his Budget speech Mr Osborne argued thatthe rise in oil prices since this reform had provided unexpected profitsfor the oil companies, and that it was fair to set the supplementarycharge at a new rate of 32%.
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 15 / 53
But one year later and after sharp fall in North Sea Oil exploration...
From the Financial Times (22 March 2012)
North Sea groups welcome Budget’s change of tax:
A year on from a £ 2bn raid on North Sea profits, industry operators,suppliers and advisers have expressed satisfaction with changes madein this week’s Budget to the taxing of those involved in UK oil andgas production. That raid, used in part to finance a 1p a litrereduction in fuel duty, raised the marginal tax rate facing operators offields to between 62 per cent and 81 per cent....
Note: this tax change related to relief for decommissioning(dismantling rigs and wells once oil and gas fields run dry)
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 16 / 53
Russian Taxation of Foreign Oil and Gas Companies
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 17 / 53
Angola Treatment of Foreign Oil and Gas Companies
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 18 / 53
Other Types of Taxes
But it is not just fossil fuel companies which pay taxes
Companies which use fossil fuels (e.g. electric utility companies) paytaxes
Consumers also pay taxes
Rich countries tend to tax petrol (see next slide)
But many poor countries do the opposite — subsidizing consumptionof fossil fuels
In sum, variety of taxes/subsidies which impact in various ways
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 19 / 53
Example: Petrol Taxes in OECD Countries
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 20 / 53
Taxation in a Model of Supply and Demand
Taxes on producers will shift the supply curve
Taxes on consumers will shift the demand curve
Remember: subsidy is the opposite of a tax so shifts in oppositedirection for subsidies
But, before showing effects of tax, I will show how supply-demandgraphs can be used to measure profits and welfare:
Producer surplus and consumer surplus
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 21 / 53
Consumer Surplus
Consumer surplus is the total benefit consumers get from consuminga productIt is the area above the price charged in the market and below thedemand curve (a triangle)Why?Economists think marginally (one unit at a time)Demand curve plots marginal benefit to consumers of each unitconsumedWhat are consumers willing to pay for first unit? Point on demandcurve above quantity=1What are consumers willing to pay for second unit? Point on demandcurve above quantity = 2, etc.Add up all these marginal benefits to get total benefit = consumersurplusSee next slide
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 22 / 53
Price
Quantity
Demand CurveA
B C
Consumer Surplus isTriangle ABC
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 23 / 53
Producer Surplus
Producer surplus is the total benefit producers get from producing aproduct (rent)
It is the area below the price in the market and above the supplycurve (a triangle)
Why? Similar reasoning to consumer surplus
Supply curve reflects marginal cost
What does producer get for producing 1st unit? Price (=B in graph)
What does it cost producer? Point on supply curve for Q=1
Difference between these two is profit for producer
Adding up for 1st unit, 2nd unit, etc. get producer surplus triangle
See next slide
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 24 / 53
Price
Quantity
Supply Curve
D
CB
Producers Surplus isTriangle BCD
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 25 / 53
Consumer and Producer Surplus in Equilibrium
Now let’s put it all together in a supply-demand graph
Equilibrium price and quantity determined where supply and demandintersect
Total benefit = producer plus consumer surplus
See next slide
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 26 / 53
Price
Quantity
Demand Curve
Supply Curve
Q
B
A
D
C
Total Benefit = Cons + Prod Surplus= Triangle ACD
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 27 / 53
The Effect of a Tax on Demand, Supply and Consumerand Producer Surplus
Now let us return to the effect of a tax
In previous example (EU ETS) considered a tax on consumers of coal(electricity generating plants)
Now consider a tax on suppliers
This will shift supply curve up
Why? Supply curve reflects marginal costs, if taxes go up costs will goup
Next slide illustrates this
Tax will cause price to rise from B to B*
Quantity produced will fall from Q to Q*
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 28 / 53
Price
Quantity
Demand Curve
Supply Curve
Q
B
A
D
C
Supply Curve With Tax
B*
D*
C*
Q*
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 29 / 53
The Effect of a Tax on Demand, Supply and Consumerand Producer Surplus
But what will happen to consumer and producer surplus?
In preceding slide, they both shrink
Consumer surplus falls from ABC to AB*C*
Producer surplus falls from BCD to B*C*D*
Government gains tax revenue which partly balance these losses
But can show (count areas in graph) that there is still a deadweightloss from taxation
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 30 / 53
Who Bears Burden of a Tax?
Burden of taxation depends crucially on shape of supply/demandcurves
Elasticity is usual way of talking of shape of these curves
Elasticity of supply = percentage change in supply caused by onepercent change in price
Elasticity of demand = percentage change in demand caused by onepercent change in price
Inelastic if elasticities are near zero
Think of elastic as “sensitive”—so “inelastic”= “insensitive tochanges in price”
Note: obtaining estimates of this is important, useful for forecasting
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 31 / 53
Who Bears Burden of a Tax if Demand is Inelastic?
What if demand is insensitive to price?
Always need oil for cars, etc.
IMF report claims very low price elasticities of oil
“10 percent permanent increase in oil prices reduces oil demand byabout 0.7 percent after 20 years”
Suppose oil production is less inelastic (e.g. Saudi Arabia has excessproduction capacity so can adjust production easily to changes in oilprices)
Effect of tax: price rises much more than before
Output falls very little and producer’s surplus falls only a little.
In case of perfectly inelastic demand, tax is simply passed on forconsumers to pay with no effect on producers
Consumers bear burden of tax
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 32 / 53
Price
Quantity
Inelastic DemandCurve
Supply Curve
Q
B
A
D
C
Supply Curve With Tax
B*
D*
C*
Q*
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 33 / 53
Who Bears Burden of a Tax if Supply is Inelastic?
What if supply is insensitive to price?
E.g. coal producers have large fixed costs and diffi cult to adjustproduction when prices change
Suppose demand for coal by consumers is less inelastic
E.g. Electric utility companies consumers of coal and can switch togas easily
Effect of tax: price rises less than before
Output falls more than before and consumer surplus falls only a little.
In case of perfectly inelastic supply, full burden of tax borne byproducers
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 34 / 53
Price
Quantity
Demand Curve
Inelastic Supply Curve
Q
B
A
C
Supply Curve With Tax
B*
C*
Q*
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 35 / 53
Case Study: Fossil Fuel Subsidies
In their 2010 World Energy Outlook, the IEA says: “Fossil-fuelsubsidies result in an economically ineffi cient allocation of resourcesand market distortions, while often failing to meet their intendedobjectives”
In this case study, we will examine the IEA’s case
From our supply-demand graphs have shown deadweight loss oftaxes/subsidies
This leads to “ineffi cient allocation of resources and marketdistortions”, but IEA makes some additional points...
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 36 / 53
Common Types of Subsidies
There are many types of subsidies to fossil fuels.
A few examples:
Price controls
E.g. Venezuela law: petrol must be sold for equivalent of 3 cents perlitre
Tariffs of import of competing fuels
Laws which say, e.g., domestic coal must be used for electricitygeneration
Implicit subsidies to producers (e.g. favourable tax deductions for oiland gas fields, government taking on risk for accidents,decommissioning, etc.)
etc.
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 37 / 53
Why Do Governments Subsidize Fuels?
Alleviating energy poverty
Security of energy supply
Redistribute nation’s resource wealth widely
Protecting employment in energy industries
Protect the environment (more relevant for renewables, such as UK’ssubsidy of wind power, will discuss in detail later in course)
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 38 / 53
Why Does IEA Not Like Fossil Fuel Subsidies?
Encourage wasteful consumption
Hasten the decline of exports (for producer nations)
Encourage fuel adulteration, smuggling and corruption
Discourage investment in energy infrastucture
Disproportionately benefit middle class and rich
Drain state budgets
Distort markets (and, in case of fossil fuel subsidies, discouragedevelopment of clean energy)
Increase CO2 emissions and pollution
Encourage volatility in world energy prices by dampening price signals
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 39 / 53
IEA’s Justification?
Most are self-evident, but I will elaborate on a few
Note first, that economists would argue:
If you want to help the poor, more direct methods better
Type of claim in countries with cheap energy: “If we have lots of oil,costing $5 per barrel to produce, why should our consumers be payingmore for our oil?”
Economists argue: “Better to sell your oil for $50 per barrel on theinternational market. Can show your country will be better off as awhole if you do this.”
Note: students of economics will know the economic theoryunderlying this (gains from trade, comparative advantage, markets areeffi cient, etc.), but I will not explain in detail
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 40 / 53
Why Might Price Controls Lead to Corruption and RelatedProblems?
This can be shown in our initial supply-demand graph
Setting too low a price leads to excess demand
Can make money by trying to satisfy this excess demand
Black market in fuel
Smuggling of cheap fuel to neighbouring country without fuelsubsidies
Recent issue: Argentinian nationalization of YPF (previously ownedby Spanish company Repsol)
Repsol accused of lack of investment/development of resources
Repsol said Argentinian price controls made it uneconomic to invest
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 41 / 53
Why Is Volatility of Energy Prices Affected by Subsidies?
E.g. what if price of oil (on international market) very different fromprice of oil paid by consumers?
Demand for oil then becomes inelastic
Consumers of oil protected from changes in world oil price and, thus,do not change their demand with world oil price increases
But look back at our graph with the inelastic demand curve
In it, small shifts in the supply curve cause big changes in world oilprice – increased volatility
Prices can signal useful information (e.g. to resolve a shortage,conservation is useful), but dampening price signal to consumersuseful information is lost
In early 2008, petrol prices were rising, 2/3 of 131 countries did notfully pass this price rise on to consumers
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 42 / 53
How Big are Energy Subsidies and Where are They MostPrevalent?
See next three slides
Short answer: They are BIG and mostly in the poor countries whichcan least afford them.
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 43 / 53
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 44 / 53
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 45 / 53
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 46 / 53
How Much Fuel Could be Saved by Eliminating Subsidies?
IEA estimates that removing fuel subsidies would:
Lead to many benefits including:
Saving of oil (particularly in transportation)
Reduction in CO2 emissions (almost halfway to reaching the 450Scenario)
See next three slides
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 47 / 53
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 48 / 53
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 49 / 53
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 50 / 53
Fossil Fuel Subsidies Still in the News
E.g. Financial Times, September 16, 2014
Growth and fighting global climate change not incompatible
New Climate Economy Report (commissioned by UK, South Koreaand five other countries including Ethiopia and Indonesia).
Recommendations: wealthy countries immediately stop building newcoal power plants and all countries phase out fossil fuel subsidies nowvalued at about $600bn a year, compared with $100bn for cleanenergy subsidies.
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 51 / 53
Case Study Topic
In this course, you are asked to do two essays/case studies/projectsThe first one will be on a specific country, second one on a specificpolicy/issueThe IEA’s World Energy Outlook for 2010 has much more on energysubsidies, includingCountry subsidy profiles for Iran, Russia, India and IndonesiaCase study: detailed study of energy subsidies in these countriesDiscussion of themes in this lecture with detailed facts/experience ofone countryHave things changed since 2010?The IEA’s World Energy Outlook for 2014 has a section on subsidiesFocus on particular aspect (e.g. impact of energy subsidies on CO2emissions)Or broaden beyond subsidies only for general discussion of energypolicy in one country
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 52 / 53
Summary
This lecture introduced some basic economic theory: supply+demand(consumer/producer surplus and elasticities)
Focussed on supply and demand for fossil fuels
Taxation/subsidies are very important in international energy markets
Factors which determine the impact of taxes/subsidies
Possible case study topic: world energy subsidies
() Global Energy Issues, Industries and Markets 53 / 53